ML20238B270
| ML20238B270 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 09/08/1986 |
| From: | Stello V NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| To: | Cunningham G, Harold Denton, Taylor J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE), Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20238B174 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-87-92, FOIA-87-A-22 NUDOCS 8709010144 | |
| Download: ML20238B270 (3) | |
Text
' ' ' 1..
m
.c
,e rw
[yo k UNITED STATES uq y'
p, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION U.$, yp'3
% j,. g l
WASHING TON, D, C. 20$55 2
1 SEP 8 1985 G Sfp f f y'<..../
!II: I7
?ik)f}{..,
MEMORANDUM FOR: Harold R. Denton, Director, NRR James M. Taylor, Director, IE Guy Cunningham, Deputy General Counsel, 0GC FROM:
Victor Stello, Jr.
Executive Director for Operations
SUBJECT:
TRANSMITTAL MEMO DATED SEPTEMBER 5, 1986 OI REPORT N0. 4-84-047, DATED AUGUST 8, 1986
SUBJECT:
TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY:
ALLEGED FALSIFICATION OF TEST RESULTS By copy of this memorandum, the above report is provided to OGC for review in accordance with my March 24, 1986 memorandum. 0GC will notify you within one week of the date of this memorandum as to whether a written analysis is required based on an 01 finding of wrongdoing or because the report involves complex issues.
If your independent review causes you to determine that a review is necessary for your purposes, you should so advise OGC directly - by memo or verbally.
If an analysis is to be provided by OGC you should not finalize a proposal until their analysis has been received. 0GC will inform you if the analysis will not be prepared within three weeks of this memorandum.
l If OGC is not providing an analysis, the enforcement or other regulatory j
action should proceed in accordance with the normal practice including i
obtaining OGC review at the appropriate time.
3 j
..(
/
[Stel o[Jr.
Executive Director for Operations Enclosure As stated above cc: w/o enclosure J. Lieberman, 0GC R. Martin, PA, RIV h
R. Herr, 01, RIV Q)
T. Rehm, AEDO B709010144 870827 NMA
-A-22 PDR j
N c h y,fh [ /) ()
/
N
.- O C
. T r
M E
I R
C e
A T
p Y
N)
L L
AL p
I A
T@
u A
t t
0l OH o
D Rj w
l e
a 1.
G' O l
E S
l H
D C
l T
E IR o
F R
E y
N R P.
m l
I E
l e
iC l
l o.
)
a s
s TR n
OH.
e d
n e
e n
d
(
e o
f e
b i
u e
l
_ o
,E 5
4 t
i f
d 4
p o
r
'S L 5
8 t
a t
o a
8 l
s.
C i
u
/
a n
n m
/
l c
u t
GB 0
9 h
g e
s 8
i f
q c
5 2
t i
t e
e 2
w t
f e
u NA IC
/
s n
i r
/
a a
r J
TI t
8 e
e i
n e
8 e
h t
EL r
e d
o w
c t
S s
E EP a
n s
i n
n a
1 P
P o
n n
r s
s o
e d
C I
e o
e l
d n
R I
R
)
c s
d e
i s
i a
N t
0 A
F n
i r
r t
a y
v r
T 0AG C
o l
e o
e t
e e
e e
o PN i
p i
e n
r h
p E
e
.D r
t.
u t
e R
I 0
t e
v t
o n
t r
f
,D 1
c h
a A
s t
a u
n
)U u
t l[
i 1L l
r t
t i
t v
- f.. o y
S a
t d
a c
l t
a e:
a 4
C i
s e
h e
e s
l r
d d
N 8
.l
_ t n
s t
t i
e s
e a
e O
l 2
Vi r
e v
0 I
n o
i o
c t
'e E (
n r
3 T
,/
R
_ e C
v g
r e
t
(
d n
p p
l e
t e
A 8
o a
i s
a s
a e
s a
C T
S
,R p
r t
a n
n h
h I
9 ll 2
E 6O o
s a
e o
e t
t e
t d
T V
2T
. a t
y c
r c
i c
b i
S c
e i
e e
t i
d n
m
/
E
- I
_ d e
n d
d e
a l
e i
l b
E BS e
p r
n n
i r
t l
u V
R I
_ t s
o i
u l
e e
a B
i s
N u.
O
.V
- r n
t i
p h
c L
w I
.e 8
O o
I t
e e
o t
i S
l
=
"F v
d A
e l
R i
HT p
a c
D N
e t
n r
e e
n c
i
=
O i
t i
e n
w E
T E A
- r n
s e
l u
r t
T I
DT re d
a s
p h
e A
IR
._ eod
'e S
i u
o e
t d
e D
UO eii e
v d
C a
t e
i e
N sns s
e i
o s
h v
s O
w GP nee n
v n
e n
t e
n I g M
eSR e
s i
e o
l e
i e
T u
YI c
/
c i
d b
c w
h c
C C
i e
i n
d p
a i
c i
E IF l
h l
e I
e e
l l
d u
l P
LO t
r i
t i
e s
S O
e e
e s
s a
e l
e h
s i
v h
i f
h N
PG h
o il T
t T
t a
m a
a T
f o
T I
H EI L
~
ET A
SSk r
I
( I E e
C LC g
~
E A.
a
~
P S
E A P_.
Z l
nn S
l o
l S
ao l
M L
l 0D i
I l
El L.
AR 9
A A
EAA QS U
C P
N SY O
ed UA
~
I S
F
)I_
ee4 j -
ND I
EET s i. 8 US nf/
T DCI ODi R
ei9 O
UID ct2 FU!
H LPD Ol i o/
CPA L n8 T
HO S
I R
UY
!! O TR
. TOP AE 4
TV SI UGE i
SE 1
EG c
l RA kit S
P ari t
TH et n E
Y RI P P cU T
O T
O( O e
O el,
I P
i hE n l
L ES K c
o
~
I RGC nmi E
C NA aat S
A Y. I D m e. a A
op9Y-27
- 3) cP - o o t.
e
- d e*
Design / Construction Significant Deficiency Analysis Report y ~"
unit St a uc it,a t j
SYLita Comp 0N( NI
$Ah(17 (g ag g0 scription of Deficiency: gg,f h4/fgL,t,. g2h/ft,/.
- 4/-4 h D O cesisa
@w/w
&VWh WS flof ffsf/0 l [ C Y l W ' M. b / rfs b Cit f/or Construction e&fnahA a Da!% bdrm?n/
f&s s,-A w,
? h 6.
M7/
O k c' C 6 S
o ~ a y e - 0,p " ~ % d te g/98 W
/h k S / &9 l
Y
/}2 /
Ual et' a SA
\\
s Q % g g.4 y-Z-a a/
Al 1
f.c/
p, r~a ~
1
- DilFILD av' '
l
>A t t
{
T1HE l
1UGC0 CA NOTirltD Da1[
mt i
trexat l
- .:aLYSl$
1.
Preliminary engineering analysis indicates safety of plant operations ft5 O f:0 adversely af f ected nad deficiency gone undetected.
U:.KNOWN (splain briefly:
lhf det tv.Yr N*
AW i,,, m, y,d, n A A n & M - x. 4 o.
1 7
Nf ic iency considered significant O vts OnoAges Jeneric implications on other plants. _. _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ O vt5 O :o F r o p r/ a t -
l i.
s program creakdown _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ O vr5 Oe 2.
Oesign per SAR performance criteria _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _O vts Om c.
d.
Construction not as specified and extensive evaluation or repair recutred to meet design criteria _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _O vts O=
Construction Deficiency discovered af ter CC acceptance _ _ _ _ _O vr5 O@
e.
f.
Could deficiency have gone undetecteJ._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __O vts O no 9 System test meets SAR performance criteria _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _O vts O=
System test results ' require estensive evaluation and redesign _ _ O vts Om h.
- i. System test f ailure can be corrected by internal adjustment or replacement with standard component _
._ _ _. _ O vt s o no
- j. Does deficiency require testing and analysis to answer part I a cove _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _O v t s Om N1A p A'lf2 6. d C /b7 t% f / L By:
COnCLU510.1' Deficiency reported -. LMM O vis Oe gg/g f
, Time:
[k DATI I
IMf,//fY/d fi'GC0 R(Pp(SthTA11VE I
l.D.
resMarp l
3NC (0:;iAct W
"W Y.
65 9V-Ey cc:
D. N. (Noman v
J. 1. "erritt Functieaal GA/DC Manager /Supenisor T af ri ris
+*
'o UNITED STATES t
I g
[
g.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION G
E WASHINcTON, D. C. 20555 i
OCT 101984
)
MEMORANDUM FOR':
Richard K. Berr, Director j
Office of Investigations j
Region IV FROM:
Thomas A. Ippolito, Project Director Comanche Peak DiviaAon of Licensing Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation l
l l
SUBJECT:
TRANSFER OF COMANCHE PEAK ALLEGATION TO THE OFFICE OF INVESTIGATIONS FOR REVIEW I
Recent testimony of' witness "F" delivered to the ASLB on September 21, 1984, in an in, camera session:, revealed that there may frtve been falsification of certain test records'4b Comanche Peak. This matter has, been raised by the ASLB as a matter of concern to both the Board and the staff in ASLB nemorandum, of October 1, 1984.
You are requested to. assume lead responsibility for the follow-up of this allegation.
This matter i es discussed between H. Brooks Griffin of your staff and Richard Wessman on October 2, 1984. Please contact Mr. Wessman if you have any questions.
4 M
Thomas ppolito, Project Director Comanche Peak Division of Licensing n
.y.
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
,r.,.
cc:
R. Martin, RIV-L, 4.,
B. B. Hayes, 01 ; n ~ "d D. G. Eisenhut, NRR#? M('M:.
S. A. Treby, ELD ' 'fg m
4l53 2
1k-h-h1 h5 0 sa 58
- n F.
D P<PJ N
y
- u m
Ed 2 cm 55Mm M w<M
.c-W C'
V 1
_Cr
.h m 1m t,
e,
O V V' ' Y'J W L / J -
n.
L
..