ML20238A447
| ML20238A447 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 04/30/1987 |
| From: | Dossett D, Latham G, Pursell E NEBRASKA, UNIV. OF, WASHINGTON, UNIV. OF, SEATTLE, WA, WEYERHAEUSER CO. |
| To: | |
| References | |
| OL-5-I-SC-054, OL-5-I-SC-54, NUDOCS 8708310082 | |
| Download: ML20238A447 (6) | |
Text
j
-]*
p]T*gg ag-w, -
- ', kgi9...i,v.p.%.e_
.g 'eg ym.e w..
&&% f&. :. p4 yY'.pQ. hin ~, _. --
e ~.5
}
y m
r---
r em. 3.Mqe..
4.y.;p._
cwi.w w-p.~
y-rq w.-.- -
w n.
-. ~..
t
@ E.Y h
1.Ok.
at.
,n-co rj, i
?
N f' ' ',,
PrRsoNNEL PsicHolocy 19 A0. D S
F OBTAINING VALID PREDICTORS BY MINIMlZING 93 h::
RATING ERRORS IN THE CRITEBION' C
ELLIOTT D. PURSELL h
J[j.'
Weverhaeuser Co New Bern, North Carolina p-f22 38 N
- b...
DENNIS L. DOSSETF University of Nebraska
\\S & '5 r'
GARY P. LATHAM
{
University of Washington 9 ',.
o The correlations between each oi five predictors and supervisory ratings of job effectiveness were not significantly different from zero.
On the basis of the job analysis that preceded the validation study, 7 ',
U the author concluded that the low correlations between each of the five predictors and the criterion were not due to problems inherent
~
in either the tests or the performance appraisalinstrument. Rather, p.
it was hypothesized that the low correlations were a result of rating errors made by supervisors. The results of an eight hour training
,^
program (Latham, Wexley, and Pursell.1975) designed to minimize j
rating errors supported this hypothesis. Four of the five predictors correlated signific.intly with the performance ratings that were con-ducted after the supervisors had received the training.
h..
A performance criterion is a measure against which the efIective-
.t(
ness of a predictor of performance is evaluated. To the extent that problems in a criterion measure exist, the effectiveness or validity of the predictor is attenuated. If the problems are sufficiently severe, a Type 11 error may be made. That is, a conclusion is erroneously s nached that there is no significant relationship between the predictor
?,
7 Y ~ and the criterion.
The " criterion problem" is due in part to rating errors in observing t
i,
... and recording what is seen (Ronan & Prien,1971). Careful observa-p
((-tion is a necessity for making valid recordings of behavioral measures 3
+
' The authors are indebted to W. W. Ronan and Patncia Cain Smith for their helpful l
- siments m prepanns this article and to Michael Campion for his assistance in ana-
'g
>{~. hang toc data. Requests for reprints shauld be addressed to Gar
. Met JL Organuation. DJ-10. University of Washington. Seattle,98195.
s f
- ' CamwM C 4980 by Personnel Psychology. Inc.
)
a 4
91 k
D DO OO
6 MEulAINVh see,i me. 504t1-06-05 '
g4.m M :
h>W s a a; U v'b l
la the matset et 0N Y0 Mn h>bD
_lgtNTFlfD 7 Staff
MCEMD __
Appiloat
/~
. MJECES
. latemeser Contg Off'r
~
DAR.
Centeesent _._ _
_Witaeus '
j-Other 9\\Arv Kmns 9
.e,e,,e,
(
1 i
'1 s
t a
e L..
.___.___.____..__.________________J
fe ai s i
e e2 y eb s
U e nc o i wd pa iuh b
wt n i e r di l
s t
i oh r n y nbi e r f i t n
c ol n a r r e
ef r
o
,c o
r r
t e
o n a
r s e c a o e w c e d
e pe e a
l a ms ih le ei lei t
s t s
a o v r r ei p
r r qt p pi e
i r
c e c sS a f
o yuh v i
r e,
s we e
v s rd mmni e u yy T
. r o
t sf s f
t s
t r
t r
ct oh t
.d b pir l t t n o yfeh i a r e e
wb n i
h t n
e oet ht t
d e op c
w c
c os s n o pP ef g i ms u s e x.
ph s
e t
l e
s e
e e a e e ynt a,j a. h ei a
r g
td s t d s
me e e rl b ed e e a s r noe y
t s
ne a s
t a
r r
h e e e 's v
i e (e 9 a s e e e r t
ud s r r a v e
ehh e t e
wh d r
'e t
t ts t
ot d
e e e pt e
t r a e nich u
e s e
al e c i l r
y c
v o nf ah yd a ed n s
wy i !e ool ri t i :
g f a s uli r l
t s n b oa a v
a r
t f
t aiqk e d
o f e ud o o h e r s on ct ei l
,mnl e
l e v t i l
a i
t e
h ed nk d p f i a
e wd s e p e or s t
r r a s
i s
d vl t t
md n c pr i
i r
r e a a m d iu
/ r a w e a a r s o e s t
e e s e i s w me f
r et is t
t s t mo t
r t
e ge e t
na a u nie n oe mr l
e
,n ish c el jh
. ini ys t
hh o e
e sdi a s
l oo a
c r
a sh o ye q pjpnc h
s at t t
t t
k r k ma e
l L
n e n nb e ei c ai et s
n wrl mr ooe e i
f f e oa e ai rd t
L a s el o
h os i
Ey mt vc i
l r
a c eTnb9
. o ei yf s a e
g p l 6 cl e s
osl 2 r inm 2
e ehdi d
d E
e mc pa e) t i o u
s s v h
o2 el d c r
t b n ei n T n. I c r t l 9 s c s i c t
S t
e e
r
.jf l R
jTr i f eid or o Y
nue e o
e a
ei t
e oe n o me e =
b g k
e s uc U
.uc t
nNe iad D
c t
e e nd h
l m s. i y o n s n D
e s
d e ehi s e r s
t s s e F
b hi h r al r
t s
e e
e v a u U
puina ms c e l d nh rh t
t oe e u o ao ognwa(hl ot f t
M r
s a i
s e
a w
n ut e
e T
niw D
yt md rh ml e
j nopmb t
r a o
,a ei c i
t c
r a o
f t s c r c pi s
bi n
nn omoia gt y oEr n s
s mi nuf S
h s ati t
T dd a iaf ef r r n ne e
t s r d os od u
t r
T d e n,
l s
k l
eni e
n c
i ai t
l o
e ei a s al i nd s et mr v e a u
wF q e, O i r t
.h vt e yu a r e r r
rd s
a IL i p l
e a
u r f
t s
r i a s al h r u o e e e s
a r a e
t ys och a o h ed o l
ri ud t
c eh R i ot nti yt h d n n u gins
, ww gaf.
t L
na d u a os e o ot j r
ps novf i
t t
t r
yc a
w,dt E
e ud e s e
i s
r d
r r pvl a e
7
- d di e t
s pa al r n noi ei s o i s yi n nc ei e o u
i r
si 4
n al ed i et c nps l
t e a z
l h rr d o t
ui a et e t
t po ah s
r ot ah v v r c rd ul i a a e a e ri e
r e a ai r oh s c o
s r cTe e i l
a r t le r e
e ei l
e t
r ppt Tr p
cb b oat s
c v t
r f or oi s
i we c p h
l i le a/
n ot r nt g o
k msict. t
,e s s c s ej yoadi ynr p owd h e x p t
t h nn r
s a
et r
h e a c ei P p t
e e
e et gnio u r ir h oe s mr ebhlic e e e
c r r oa os c rd od t e
t s
ne ma d s
/ mig rhh pi nons n d t t
a a a plop v e ef oi gah h
r t d n
t d
ot r
s ou n
a oki eh m9 eh i gpva n e at l
t l
t n un fr h mua obl d
r e a
n t
r t i t
s t
s v c oe pf v ns e nt b a a we i
l z
o nh et ooh r s
e d d ge) wf wt ejsf ych u o e i r pe n i
e
, c. pi r s
is ed h ws un m p h t
s r
i um mlud y pe r e pe d
i e
t t
t h ge e or os nt nn m
e n ge t
nh e i
h oh f s
ni t
t nt n Nrpc u
t i pi l
c r l i nt jTf r
i a
I e ooi Blod aiTl e
e o n nr m, - S et l
a a
i a o n
a ysiN uoh lpwa ai ak t
ub h om sb
_ hyh MkbhfM/bh1]h t
ud s t t s
c a e e r vr t s t c at h
dyA@hUhbbDMl ]L@;%- bhDW$[r
!?1
?
M d
r l
N
_h5]^ k ( 3 9
UQWi-j ;
e -
s nl.d n s - r e
- nd i na e 7
, nh, oi
)
- - e e - n md
- g ndl s
mh h b e ni n
e e oh ci o
s f
e n
v ah wie ial i p t
a ri r
t 7 e ei le b r t
t o e a a t
r t
1 int me t d e p g mmf of r a r ef le n e vfi i 9
a r
b t
r out n
s n n e y
o oh a s c e r o a5 pe
,d eS o c o
l r gn s
fi s t
u el 4 us s qc
( f t
nl yr l
e oa n pn at yi rd n
oa e ad r s p x m 's s ai a i
l s p a e u e
o sbl r l e
r i
t e 'e mnsi r r n gnt el y t
ihf pypc o h
gok r
t l
x s e
e g
a e io ni n at c
of Tp 0 nt r
s e ad s e oy i s eh i a e ci e ad e 3
t al ui Wh r
widgnw u ebd l gri nr pbeid f
e u pr
. a t
f s
a r i t
pm j
t o
s c
r oe nl cd ia a
i l e c s e f
e r
loa r
e n v e n
d u nc r s al
,a et e pa ad o.
ivos e y
t h oh mv h a sf t
r n s a npa iwc t ih d nf s i
r e
t et ami bb a
o f e. a d
,e mirf e
i a n
ehih la t
t c
a r
t l
e a c
t ya e s
v) di tnyuT s n r
o e rf o mi u r r r t
s a pgi r
j r t d e v ei t
1 t
e oy o e yb a cl a c is d. r a teh at a e ni 7 e v v nc r rh i c o l
pnt y
af
. Y t
e u n
pl n
h ehh s
hi".
l 9 pi n t
irb t
t r
a e
. G s
e a
t e1 o e o o r. m t a u n p s
a i c bl as f eTd e
t s r s
a ct s a
c w
c e
n d e i ici a
l O
e c
,l e e L"
c o owc o ns.li e
ut n n v rl e
d r t
a at ei i L
pI c
mi n v e
ine le ri ad r a
e r c O
,df h ic r s
ii l
S r yt et pa e e o s
t t
g s
s mird o
.d, a e s ef yw mk n c u c e s
t nt n e l
Oa h e i
r I
a yr a ud e pt s e a I ivid c iDorP) wp r n C
h ge g d omod d
e or e d nh s
Y B"
.i u s l
5 n
t el f
.f d i
i t
r c s t
Y o
n wyc ni
)
r or u et t
t a
r 7 s r
S
- f 6 c ua os s gnfet onfy oh e n9 n
D h
r e n P
3 o7 u s n i e pa1 e ini a
et r
s gt a n s
n e
nt ul e
t 6
9 s
ea a gn edi e
ah i c ai
.a at i r s
L 9 g! d i io n
winid n i U
o e r cf n(
c cTr t
e nvi of T M r
e 1
n o
E s yn ji. e r s r poo al nu l
o e
N
,ikpi ta g pr r
r p
ab e e l
al ei h a t
fe S
7 t s
niRuMvt wid. r ioe e o 4 c e x w
d w c
l n
h r e pnn N
a s
ahh g c r a
- t l
r n
s et e di ed oo
.mt p f
O a
c a
s a( P. e a et o c
f let s i at n nos o d
n nmS oe o o oot S
c ne o
r s
e
,n z
e e ie f nf
,t i v s nv yi s
h y S
y r s n
tc r t
R d
a
,b a
e e(
s r
n e mlehTi d ed e l
s t
e n
d o e n a imsii F
ei I
oici Xh a
t s n s
. a e r
ri s c d
el e y nnji cj e e s nrh c at t
l no si l
s ig meb a 'e we pf n
i.i t i in1 bh c lp t
r eh d a i k t
0 a e e r
r d
l s
i e n e t
r ge r s
r n
t p
o o moeh v
miwe v n
eai e
l y gs s s nd e f
n n
Uf b
e mt l t
t aii t
r o e o r o os ef or ri o
t d
o ci i cl h e n o ctcd ot oa n c
n ne h
t c r t
hhl i r n e
o j u a
nc e
t o
r e et ef t
c xt c
c e
t u a I
mr e e
ed vf t
f es b a.
e r t
g ivi n h imlad r )
sd c s e
ns y
.d e e o oyea edhf o s
s r ne oi r lpf pW r i
t e noo i d a n c mr e e n
o f
o os a aTl t
r s
S v n e7 i b n e e y gd ga ssd
,e r
b s
pi u
i t a
r e s
.b s
i S, ea v5 ir i t
z n t
oc oi r
a va gi e
v e e na e nt b miio e7 ji f ts u r e wid a ph a r
r a s
T a
mtahwg, wpe i o e
e s tu t
d c s
s u xd s
Ea e o r
ct pt o u el a in t
s v ed h c ia r
s pl s
r l
e n ei Bll nN, /
c n d qi e
c s a i e n r.inige r
t u a r rh p p h aS c
e t
e n o s
. e i et r
i r nh v poc a
e n al r ms t
6 s
gwe s7 e mnoL n mTi ed o As cbk aiTge vb wei t i e s
t e ch v a
a r
c r e e 9
(
a al 1
it r s el ig 3 e g ah f
t t
2 e sb e9 uf e r
1 f at Ts d wi S
irh e
nhhi ohl oa t
t h P
s t et it t
f 5
- e r r s e i g
- s e - el -
- e ge -
l s nd 5
i I r gh e oe pf n na v uh a c b
nh c a 9
mit e n
o h
i h
e ogt ici o i s
s ica i i J e a
t r
d t
T s.
w n s ah r s
int le o t
, t r r s nh ga c pat ne s
t o
l.
g o)ie e e si e
f a r
i a
n t f a t
is I
247472937 n
5 nn u s r ol m)h c p n or d ei oiw n 0. h w qi c
pi7 t d i e n
t h d C
1 1 3344 t
e e
et d v
r t
ta o a2 ge et me s
s 4
r ys e
r d
a o o9 d o
i a c g sf a p
nrd r,
o ne w=uk n a o n e o f n a
)
r g y let t 1 f
r 2
s e
o pt s( at g s a s g
S ci s
f e ob s r a
e s s
e h
h oe en g
m net 2 Dt o 'n emef oad ori ivf t
s f
r ei n
wg n 2.S l r o c pe pu t
t i ps h gt i
iT a
,At n
oci l g
v ia o ni 1
c ad t
t y
yei ya r t
ikb sl e e nl el gn a s l
r e ishn
= 4. puyni god n oab ih t
e Tl ch a
- 6. 10 er un ini inh e a
t ml i c r
e r d
et s
h ci t
c pJ ph m i yr ft 1
s
'f h D5 r c I
223735744 ei teS t
d y t
s l
hhi e s sl i e l
S= <h os ab s n
f c aa e e pnt a ws v
eicTi i
a A n t
e c r o
r h
o c
a d eh. e L
t i t d 'o d n g 7
pi ef r
oit t
t t i c
e y u
1 M9, whi e f oopn s c n
L nl e
nbwr r
l t lieh E
e v
a t
n ol 6(
y of d ph igb ai t
R o a e my
= 24 osigh i n
e1 ys el s
e0 r
1 f
t t
c a pa rf a
)
uc ot f
pmh a o r
il s
U 2 fn al m
d o
i x e t i i
e t
u7 e ot t
t t
e e al o
P BO cd s
M m )=
e r t y
eh n
la9h dl c 7 e r
e s r E
e c
o e et v s
v1 upy n ige s
h a s
t s s t
n
(
h m L gr f
n n c 000340 24 j
7 c
5 nt w u
(
i s
e s e4 v D
B i n 1 3 4
f 1
44 b ai T4 r
c e n as mspd e
o nt t
nt s i
b e ad At u ni e
(
nv s s
oo ne e i h e T
TaE og.
ri pl epi e ah i t
c k
s n
t r
n af ll o e i
h s i
hi a
i o n e c h nt i mh O
n-i e
c c i ) imat T
L teR i
e ie d 0. T t
, nn opt D
R g
1 t
t s
s s
t a m a
1 a u lyi t tL iot a e r s t
e et s
a os2 mu r
t t
ad t
r oe e h y r
r t h ot b d n r ni pnd 1
a T
e el at e nS irl r
t d n a E
i e hdla<
n a -
t r
i u u o n a ngt r
a c s v c vt u o s
gme Ci c
z n
f s
ei od e e fm ihh v pi o gi oior n n eh e
is t
i o
s ni ih e
o r
s t
t t s
e
,t r oir d wt oi f
0003l 1
h r0 af r no i
mntahTn pc ed ei a oM i 16223 wt n in o
o h
8 nn e is e i c e o
. i yr n sd rh 5
e gget r r
int t udl c t
t os ns t
t oi dRona a p oo itu t
s,d od pc aa i ua mh b y a eh s b
s d - e r lo u e h d ni l
me ye e yi c
s t
t a
i h
s n
e s e e u=
mf s
c n oiaf
.h b nn s s
t t
t wKaTe.
a aic v l
t h
r t
f r
a e
ai a is s
t e
s e s ei t
e s)l e
hd w
D k t z
d wn h
r e d "t i e. i nc r t
t h
r e) n s a8 a ed e n e n(
oat. c o s6 t
t eh y
g 9 v t
t b
)
r e
y si c
a r e nel et
,d s
l n r r
t 4
t n a n
n.
r u s ng r
ei o
d d e iol t
c ui e C. i e
9 a t
s1 ioh i
h (sht io n (p juf j u
ta l : 34s6? g 9 e
i n nb s e
ed e qo t
t i < lyg a
r t h a ai o c q
R e
i t
r la 's T n s epcWir h e c
n r
e c
r t
n c
ci c
nel a e a F
y n
e t
rd ni Tn ul ei r
e t h o i a mi osr f
s g
t r
bi ai u npa a i me mc ct t
r c
r is pt d invdki r
a woii
(
c r k
s t
t P IJ : '
1I ITiy77 ? k y f v
~
3 r' ?
' = Lfj 3[9 I
.F ) 3 0
?i
]3FJ i^
>;{
1 4
3
. a e' d g s, '
r e 4"
,d l
t.
- 2 ~ -
it eh n r n n n
.f nh o n u e
r t
ce e ef e - -
- r oh li o x a e r n im a, ai o ot r o s lab e e f p
gi mt p pt t
e o B
t r e s n e ei ud mp tai gdh a e a
,r s n d u n e r
. r o y
n n
r e u g si et n
hd on gr pd i d e o h or s e c gbi i i -
s
)
n i r i
2 s
e T s_ d e
nt t
M n ptyvi w aFa c e nz n
t o
e c nf gt yi d a r i e ri a
u e o w
(i o
m t
l t
ri aih nin n t
e wmo om nl
. r t e
01 3 66 a
c ai r
t i
40653 e
- d i unn eTc I
t 5 inli r oo el
.t r
a e
s g
T s pe,r oie pl o v eh a
e r e a
- 2. i r
e f,
h el e
b i el r
oh h a
e at fi a r in e pet h los t
n wiTt t
r e c om b
g a -
t mv e e eh s r r
s o
er i
h h t
r s e a
. s a
rTnp r
r u
T b et t
f i d i p las io nr o t i e
wonhbi e e n e
t r
t s
if f
e h
t r
d e
ycdh o
nb e v r n r ooh e
t f
Int wo h, a sh e oiei r r
r s e a af et yx e
e t
t e
t r s s f c o t
t s
t r r u oah mo
. a a gy m,at s on c Y
A
) h u i a z ywf ei nie e n c e r
t s s e e a el v wci m
air es gpeii t
G d
5 wl oc o.
c go e v c c g r
r at ri O
a 9
a unt ng y
ne o n
7 n mngnW e c n r r
L e
t 1 d v dd a ph h if me i ei r r
e n n n e nl r
e e ci adi ot mus t h a) n u ed a c r e a a
u et p
oal r
24 3 3 2 i
f m
0 0 0 0.!.
l,d
,ec lO e
. r nh ai i ei o x e
r t
l n nt s
r s e
r 5 e0 ieshi r en r v h
t t
r i
a oot mmt e
f r
at s f is v
h e ei C
I R o T
e i
l t
t ci r o aih t
o t
r ywm<
i h d ~e n T. 2 wi u
r z
e r
e et d h os n
r t
wi i t
t n a i s Y En e
t pet a
o
, e s
o s
oot S
oE s
t s
p pet l
, r P
Li r
lul os s tnhi ei s
m e,i i
r r
el pl r
r v h
gimr r s B te g y n (p cd a n e n u
oiome c ut yt t
e e n
l t
L Ai i a ps c a e ct wp s
t t
c e r
et ns a
e nl imt hb ei c nirii6ie E
r t
h to d
e yh ye in r f
c o e aid el TCa a e t
s s tuTf a n n
t wf a
t N
R di a r
n f
a e c t
d t
aeb, ts p c
h i
a o
N n
.f n c eb t
eh gh i i t
i d
oe t
r oel hi a ei h O
a l
i d o nl ut nd oTnf e
t r
t f y f
At S
s
(
r s r r iel Tn e
t s ct s
ij i gf t
r ou o a o
e s
r gn nid tymo. nia u u R
o e v ai E
tc e af tpe gt nt
. i h p
).
y i
i n e e n d igid ui t
t l
a cdidhdd s
l 7
eb ed g4 n
P d
h ooi r ne e y si r e s e e
t r
s b gyt e v e e
r e o l r
s r r
s e we s cf h c ee nb l i = ed ial s
c t
s ot v
r n
l gil a
d t
t r
a oie a e e
ts t'dl d l
oed eh t, i woi lai a et t
ui r i pntchi r ot 5'
e r~
n e
el r d s pne s c a ol pb a e c
aNl t
n y ue u t
s s
s r r
e x
e a gci r t
r gopd s
r ini v
gai eh pr i e p e
ir o
t c a r e e ht e o
e n
( r le i r s inl e e9 s
ew epmb gi e t
u l
w e
e c ot iat r
r f
et c s o ni e
d wrl niyn h e c i g tei v n pe n r bd r - e u p T
t r
t e s e
oe n
e r
e t
x v r ot o e e r4 h d u e
b ePKp mjlwd t
r it it Dl l A e e s
e s io y s c ci e a woci Ty s
r o mr ot e
h t
t lo a a r d v a
e od s
r n
n l q
o r
t u e s t
s ne e a ot wl n is
.lt r
t el s s a
pur r m emni n e e on ml n pi a o
c c e pet et sdh a r
r aii a
e a
v el l
e rc t b n
i b e e l
s r
s s r t
r k
h u rd wr g a e n_
t c
o es el leh e v i
v a m e r e et h e e
t
- v e pa owit r
u a d oh ivd s si l MEEN e
i le le u e,
c o
h pnI r
t s ai n
f e s d e t
r b r t t
e n r t
h u v wt ei h i s eh e s
i et pt f
, p,
o mimia n
pa
,t C
v s
i s el ivi oi Tsl t
ot a s
Tome n
r n nTu s n t
r a r t
a 4
ci e e r r o s
a e mio e
f e oi s v mr cb e p lat msah e
t o pi cb c g a T pi p a
ai ir r
s t
t
- ll
s
)
t dl h
y a ei g wr c
a a
o B
l me s c n aF r
r a
s i S
t ef iL u
t n
r f
oi O
hd h ohl bt ny cesdrd ivoe eht B e e o
. oy d
op r
t a
o e n nl Cx e Kt t
r t
n egs i u o
o i n o it jniouvie J
i l
s y pa
. t s i
wapuawd tcisd s h
h n r o
hd or ol s
d ut c n g t t ivt a v s
n yb h nf r r u c p gl n na s
e r
s v D
ot u ni iwas e pc n
,r a ed ot di s n i d
i el mind i i
n a ion iomjamt o
l ed i p n e n a,b U e
tc N
nb sid
, t u g. nc t o), si s a c
ma nn n ei c
e pl f
e e n s s. oie a f
e ao R Ofe lsd r
A F i to( en n tait o loegl s e
i la0. r l l a
a s
s o
s ob ne gr n
o( n u
s
- t e
ur uioe et oi ai O
we st wgn t
t ol s c noe. sl s a e nt a8 li S. h y
t icpjns Af u a taa ebi ch t
s r
v r
S s yt oegf tn ot s
e 4
si
,hi t
s s
r B
r sh s ri e cb b let N
a C
eot peh
)
tnC 0 s as v ga et e m )t u
N ag ns s ivl o l
a S, i f 7 s t
I
( nh ii u palpn e
r s t
e e et aj s a e o1 c r pa TO h
r ec ndi o e l
o r cno e x n
el o! nh sbu mr mt eot iphl R e le S
c y te dl a
SI E
cb e
r t
icNn w
e r
ai t a eiagt o omai he t
e I T M
s r t h pi s h
a f
t a. a T
shf h
s r
C e
t uol j r s e s S
t s c n s b r f
c a
at o
yLf,
RA A
e e E
s r n a i T. e r d c o
t co ui nf a e pw e o n o e Oed r
v h
E N n
O rc eb si v o s, mo v
J Ri N
h t
r r o esi s no nnk e e pi i o.j d a. s j e
,i r o uN E.
t c
t a
e s
dl or yi ord dv i e a gn dPt eE ue d p it s r TI e
. s e r r
e a CM
. oU J
j a ifl p nd o ot n R i n e
wf uyn e
en c
l
. o n
nh. e s
v s
abi sit t e ioe wrib n ur e e h
qs N
t P R c o e
e a
nr abae e
r( c u
t a
s oc i
r s
AA E
hi a
nwms rd p r c eR R sl e
t ts f
t r
n yon o O C t
s e mt et o nu n sd d a or e
Bi N
t io n al f opr ls e
s RX I N
l e e e a
.l h
t r
f o
i e c
t r r i
ego c ioc ab ia ic.c i ivRtoe ei io t
a a
d s b n me t o c c gi if a r
f h A
la pi oe ncdf u or s
,t r
AET E oC v
e c
r s
t s
L I
m p pi t fl ddf a e pncj ipe e pa or a
s ri e o
mDv s
L H
A R te v
.d vri ik r c r
l t
eidl I
s a n si s
u c
u i u yiivi e
mi mn t
a CNS W ituax A
l s c a G. d h
ndt y i
r v n a
e v
s r ed s t l d r us ol mtc s a e p
e A
eadl o
ul s et AU L
sT a
a e r t
e r si a nfoimp nB a
a era s got e a e wNraD n
p
,s vri t
n a nh B
A I
N r
t a
r v f
usbi e),poma c
d nhh i a a f
k s o s
r h
ud an od n eac t d hh c
nht hi t
f i cojne( temf o d e n n e
t o O:C onr i )i g
u s2 e
a oe u) c d l a
n oic f
u s
n c e a N
ad ot c) db s4 aitaed ivd b o r
f r o t
ts t
ot c j
y J
g s
r d
ee s
s o( ye nia6 o
t OL e
o DT A iwe a id a at e d ut nt o L oi pf o t
t g i o
nt el r
r r at ;b t
- nqo e e
- ah em Ajc i O h.
o s
t I
n s
r t
n g n9 c
s. we uI 2 h
ed rd 5 s f
C of t
2 wl s s
ECC lov er f a h3 a mi
,1 s
e c al ee nnl Tn aepmf n
6 r
pm/t VAO lo n
uiui io ad s a
.(
sl c
ao I
s 1 h r e e u e7 T
i r -
s f ns e a s
y u
fk s
s t
r o e s r s ol a E n a pms a
s ati t t
n oCt o ol a
s s
nt f
P I
FR eart o pncs pid ci u
,ca r a
R
- f d h e x
E ht oieo O.o s t 7 t
,pc tuel cye ue et 7 o nt h e
J L
a SP
/
cc crt d i b r
N CI Tb ptpr E
- e. i e tuibjn u o - e e u r
. T r
t t
uitor n po E po p4 s
o oe e s f air I
i Nn me ee eoerm l
ej p1 o
RTC c pb (dps tast st t wh n
jt i
h i
0 h h e s.
EAE Tcrd u
t e n 0 e eTrt c a
0 Is S
r o eW n o E9 P1 PSR Pa Na iv f
r
^
jd' oe ;tf E(U. i Ljj a ;j[O - i1(; n:
&?YY{J. Jj{ 4{
y_
T
>i
[
g'-
.'e
' ~.i;. y y
e - - - f s s a, eh
. p r r
a v
. a t
h tai e io' it n p a e nh i o ot l
eh 9 e ta5 a
f c cl P
i s -
- e r s s
u n r o 0
c i l p
c r u n
.m 5 o
t t
t et r o o a v a o
r a s gi e r ot s t
a ui hi r
8 n
ch o g s
b f
r b v of 6 r c.i a
oet nal o4 s
a e wv g a.m c
r y
bn e0, m
oy e o I
Oeh o mo".hmeh ty9 u ob z
s s
hh a
f i b
z6 o
a paip s r
mP t
y N
g ei c
E n
r sh h a s
e 9 a
.im5, fr lb n tos n
c 1
o gi et e y
oh
, r c
m el b cl c
a P
N ni l
r us c nt rib sb a r
t 1
f
.am, a
pa ol E
i
.a nd ys yi 0
e e
7 P
h o
a o
.m 91 n
r it a ie R
t w
n n
b r
b e ci e ci f s ioh
, e oo cd s
ni s
al opgi ei ga b mdi r
ci md c
6 n pgyo v i 4 p y
m ei f
r b r ted o ni e
eisk v gi n
s r p P
ua e n
u ah 9
o a n oe ch e e i n r e i cj t
oa 1
o t
g o
u h n p p nTr v n t
nit h
r c
t tcib i i e a s it nl gt n c s w,
y d mi sl l
T a pA s
e b
, f J
n r o f
g a
w e
r s )
a e u(
e i o c a u i ie".
b h o gs 8 eh f
- O Al ie f
r t
c nf inmt c ol 5.si r e r
t a
s eij o le6 g s
o r
e eh sh a "y fe rf a a
r qt c
o c
t l
2 a y ef a7 s
ei a a r t
e v
o y, t o a l
- n s e
t pwa peic9 r r c
n nd
- a e
O e
r l.l s or e )n bi rh a lyef cb t
o r
gv c
h s5 aP e
e n s n r
mi n
t Y
x ptc( d r a r t
1 h
ol o yf yn2 md m i l i J r
e e a
l t
e r c
5 v a n r o u A
i ns i0 inl u
ei t
o m,h in o c c o G
e e
e a
e t
s o
.gi e
tc a e
b a s
.c p
P t
r t
a s
t L
b opa wb os a
t j
o o F e o is e ), e ad n r a
fe t
t io p
t e s oh s e tn n v g ta3 s
f r y
ri n p
c gt c s v
a n np e u r
e7 r f M
l d
pl a
s t
O e e n ge. oe o p7 e r
5 nn n e e i r 7,iA e
u I
t s
h qe Sd a
)
t p
a9 n ;r ooga a
o h
x a h
n 'e s r c e m E nb 9 mk nk s
a n I
T. l e
t c
o e
nI e c e
7 n pi g a r t
C
,i 6l i s r
s oe g s
b v
d 1,iivS n
i go ef e C n o1 o
f yd ad e
a c e lul eic r
o
,Da h
Y d
.if t
o og f
teh e oh 7 P
ulpa a op pu na oahh e a e r ini ei N Cl v. r n1 i( r t
t o
n o
t t
t
. c
. t n
S l
r a a. i et b
a ni a
mh u E
r G E u o7 in t
t l zk ot rs foo r
t e c r y a ta a
e q
R o
i r e
L o
r t
o t
a oi o
s9 N f e nys i lo6 e n ic wt c mt L nmd
,ci e gb it l lpe a e )e oe e E mh i r o cnon. a b
gl F a a tO l,J e1 a e
opr g El v L le i
,gd la v
s
.. r y r E
b r
r v
n m,n c a s o e
s r s
r t
nf s
a mi ina i mh N
l n ob a r 7 r eh c
(
tah R uB e C ui e o h oh 9 ov c r
e r
t e r a6 n
a et pr pr dl 7 tr s md) t o
YP v t
r o
s f
r e pr e sh a
O e
ga
,mn e
c a J. s a
1 s
l 9 t
NPdh rCn 1
e o f
n e
t n r gu m taKE a, f
. ut El Ma m
S i n e8 P
g e1 teih a c i r
t a g ot oh c r
,Rh o
s e nd me e t
a
),
n e e -
R yid p7 no ad n c
?
. L b
P y, d ly
. nc r
s pal a n uhi gmn i a o r s E
b s o9 t
t e yh Lf h a n e
u n n
f N
t h
P t
lu( a a
al n ai r c
d qi r ai No
. n ma n g( o e
s s s, a e e o
a gr w, N. n E e e t
c o
o s
r nh v( oe a o i r e nl v
s r e t i p ol sKo
,Cr, eMll, u r
t r e O teNLu g
r y
s c
n t
r uf r r n e na yel c r S o t
t iehdd o p( nt n iah s
n ol f x e R,i n -
n a g od r p
pe u gr gnet ed E y t e ns p
r e a
c u i n s n e n e parh o e ityWP le v ir tei e e t
mpn e "a l
r o
nd di g1 o
r y ei r
t o
b s
ei i f b t
c y i d s e s lp a P
u n n c a r
Da e m5 in pl aS at s b n e
s ct u
oh,
d
. x e r
t nib v
n a
r c o ai mf o i o.j t ye o l
n 5 n,
b d
.RKa xb t
r s ei e a a v n
r t
b eWo rl a
a n ph n1 ia e a n g
r r
r s r
p V. o, e s
oAudi b e
e a
eD;d u r
t e pe o s
- a. A on 9
e yo a n
. P p.
Wk: B. ga f 4 r oy f a t
r ic s r
. d n c r il d sh T
mim n
oe e ps e a pd e r
ic pe oh a
t r Ph
. Ma n
ls e G. u.
t r
et e
e
. o1 yrh wt e ml
. G p G, i WYPInh. o 4, M r r r
ys y g icCn7, D t
C e ppgo c e
at p
al d e
J
. o.. cpi e a b
e ei tet c a w t
o v s ui c pe n r b
, m, l mr
, w, i g ims 1
o vl s
,i vt k h ir r ni i r u e
a s
i ah h d ei ws adf s
t s
s tc3 r
e e s
n c
n e pot e t
a ia a o5.n a., u6 l r n n f
e r
ir icl b n c
oq e
h yh t
e a yTi i e e
). Tt e a oc eh e e I
r n n i h r h r 5 r
a e t
r t
t 9
k r
r n a g gtaf h 'n d8 oh le nNie o n e r y o e n
t pt e5 6
t et wa9 nt rk nthTspr i it s
J L L
R S
S S
o mt p
a a
.t t
e e
9 pa iiv
>l
,I i'
I
/u, u.,'o
' UNITED STATES.
I 8
g NUCLE AR ' REGULATORY COMMISSION -
')
o
<p WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 a,, s **
n fiay. 26,.1987 1
i MEMORANDUM FOR:-
John Milligan i
Technassociates-FROM:
'Emile L. Julian ting Chief Docketing and Service' Branch'
SUBJECT:
sHoAEHt<w EXHIBITS-l Any documents filed on the open record in the Braidwood pro-ceeding and made a.part of the official hearing record as an exhibit is considered exempt from the provisions of the United States Copyright Act, unless it was. originally filed under' seal with the court expressly because of copyright concerns.
All of the documents sent.to TI for processing: fall'within the exempt classification.
l l
l N
1.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _