ML20237H482
| ML20237H482 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 09/18/1986 |
| From: | Stier E STIER, E.H. |
| To: | Kelley J Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| LRP-B-024, LRP-B-24, NUDOCS 8708170234 | |
| Download: ML20237H482 (13) | |
Text
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
f '*
EDWIN H. STIER PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION
- -l law OFFsCE S s ; E. CLIFF STREET TELEPHONE
.O.E mu, ~Ew aa u r o..a
'87 E 12 P1MSuaisi Septer er30,[1986 NUCLEAlt REGULATORY COMMI511od
/,
A/
Docket No.
fi Enh. No. _ ON in tte matter of Yb I b6
- M Staff
..__ 10C NTIFIED Applicant RECilVED M Judge James L. Kelley intenen.
etacito Chairman Ad WlW%
cesosn gy/2 Atomic Safety i Licensing Board c,truto, DATE 4 / /V NOSY /Md$
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission on,,
m,,,,,
Washington, D. C. 20555
Dear Judge Kelley:
/-g Reportet Mr N #W I am enclosing copies of several items of evidence that were requested by the Board during the course of my testimony.
They are as follows:
A figure prepared by MPR Associates, Inc. illustrating the slope offset and peak-to-peak methods for estimating water additions to the makeup tank.
Copies of strip chart traces showing the effects of hydrogen additions at times when we have no evidence that leak rate tests were performed.
MPR has also included copies of log entries indicating the times of those hydrogen additions.
Copies of the computer printouts for Test numbers 147, 146, and 145 performed on October 18, 1978, on which handwritten notations appear.
These copies show those notations in full.
I have not yet received MPR's estimate of the percentage of hours they spent performing services for GPU during the past ten years.
MPR is reviewing its records and should have that estimate shortly.
After I have furnished you with MPR's time estimate, I believe that I will have submitted all of the evidence that you requested from me.
8708170234 860918 PDR ADOCK 05000320 0
t I would also like to advise you of some minor errors in our report that I discovered while testifying at the hearing.
In Volume III (A), Table 1, the Notes for Test number 150 should include the word "yes" in the confirmed water addition column.
Although the Notes associated with that test make it clear that MPR confirmed the water addition, the Table erroneously contains a "No" entry in that column.
In the same Table, Test number "122" should not appear next to Shift 15-23 on 11/04.
The number "122" correctly appears for the 15-23 shift on 11/05.
Number "122" should also appear on the Table next to the 23-07 shift on 11/06.
I also discovered that in my copy of our report, in Volume IV (I), the documents related to Tests 170 through 175 are out of order.
All of the relevant documents are contained in Tabs 170 through 175, but they are not in proper sequence.
However, the strip charts are clearly marked in the upper righthand corner with the Test number to which they apply.
Very ruly your r s
/
,Q c,
Edwin H. Stier EHS:cr cc:
See attached list l
I l
l j
l Copies to:
1 Administrative Judge Glenn O. Bright Atomic Safety & Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l
Washington, D. C. 20555 Administrative Judge James B. Carpenter Atomic Safety & Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Jack R. Goldberg, Esq.
Office of the Executive Legal Director U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Docketing and Service Branch (3)
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
{
Washington, D. C. 20555 Ernest L. Blake, Jr.r Esq.
v Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1800 "M' Street, N. W.
Washington, D. C. 20036 James B. Burns, Esq.
(
Isham, Lincoln & Beale Three First National Plaza Suite 5200
)
Chicago, Illinois 60602
)
i Smith B. Gephart, Esq.
Killiam & Gephart
)
216-218 Pine Street P. O. Box 816 Harrisburg, Pa. 17108 i
I l
j 1
Michael W. Maupin, Esq.
I Hunton E' Williams 1
i P. 0. Box 1535 Richmond, Virginia 23212 I
Harry H. Voigt, Esq.
i LeBoeuft Lamba Leiby & MacRae 1333 New Hampshire Ave., N. W.
Washington, D. C. 20036 Ms. Marjorie M. Aamodt 200 North Church Street Parkesburg, Pa. 19365 Ms. Marjorie M. Aamodt P. O. Box.652 Lake Placid, N. Y. 12946 J
l l
L i
WPR ASSOCIATES F-80-lOI-l 9/22/86
- l. il 0 e
l 7 0
's
- SLOPE-0FFSET s
12 IN., 3 7 0 O AL.
g h;
Ca i _k q
- _- _g n x-
's l-i\\
N - I l
'd _
h l
'f N,"
.q i
.m N
PEAK-TO-PEAK
'x I
10 IN. 3 0 5 O AL.
A. i.
-5 0 d 0
=;
HARCH 25.197 9 0525 70 0625 RCl8 TEST 003 HAXEUP TANK LEVEL:
m-.
31J START 7 6.9 IN, E ND 71.9 IN.
5
n a
~
5 i
NOTE TH AT THE SLOPE-OFFSET HETHOD ACCOUNTS FOR THE LOSS OF WATER WHILE l
THE AD0lfl0N is IN PROGRESS (ABOUT TWO 1 p.
lNCHES IN LEVEL OR 62 OAL.1 -
,d W'
e nnr C
.N hb i
I l
]
TlHE 1 Hour l ILLUSTRATION OF DIFFERENCE BETWEEN METHODS TO EVALUATE WATER ADDITIONS TO MAKEUP TANK (SLOPE-OFFSET VS PEAK-TO-PEAK) t
. 'i t.
li!
')
l '
'l i
a l
l i
A k,,
+y-il...
..lj..
.: l d.
l r
.T.n.7_. w Pe.'.:.f.
%.4..
-l o.
.9.~...' 1 id 1 _ _ R t o__ -. c o & u m wa or wnr.in ro wr.r C _..
ll 3
i W i i
). 3./.n
__"3 " S.jiy r_
..o..yeo.__i:ou.-
l o
p' q,.
0.2).o__
Tio:.mo-. c.n_..g eiuse. P??. c.
i O
i
.j j
[
./.
r
{
k.,l,.Ug
.' 7 '/ - 7 9 f. r.v,f r. _P...._.- _. _..
_N
/
i
?...?1oc
/,.
J g
W M1_w Ws ob)
- o r A r.-/
.n/_u. ~ =
\\
y
..ui.b%.o at.. f/w d.c. r.~ '
.s.d dor !. ei.. n ": y...L.v.?
i y
f Irj
. b c c.s.v.s C._.. $.Ao.hb y - b.c.M.
bc- <:t wl g
u
} }
h.s <J._.ir.L y. s o,b a v.i :~...
j
.'i
'f.< A ~
. 6.-
b.........,...._.
i 1
\\.co G ~3 0 ydaf.---yz- $. w' !. NP..n.. c
<<.~f M o
,Cg.
i
\\
,._ cm.. N.~.
y.--. -
j
@a 1
/
1 g'
1
't
- 2. 4 - M
"{]"Sla'/~T
/fso.D t'o
. MDMW l
1 Acomoe
._ d_.7 to sf.g.ogp L7_7__ flu %A
=
Tit TD-t
~
.I 2
o Pff" f;r AC E_V_s_p j.~..s e.u.la _Th.. ~-....B...Blers 7?c..'riau s.:r.. L._._
'9.'_ orsi.
n
."A_.~D a~ P L
..W
... /.3 M.-.~-
(. T _E_. c. 7: T
.x
- e. a Recie e.
I e.,',
_.............. 'Q !. _g_,..p....
]
c l
y-i k
_ /7/C Pui. Ego 8. aq. tzgsc.cc. k ~7csr.fi)Mt ? vu....
l
...._ _wA>Yi:N.T ro!..cb'c5 To.rmit'M.gorrws.
- h 9.'.' TA M 4 o k R c ell!-c...
I w
E"'
5l]~1-. ).l.30.
.\\CSYA$b... $UA)# - bl/]:
J_ V/. ~l0 $ A. 6 2
- h
. _ _ dCD_
e-Ntee 6PJ 4 M __ 9.: 1.\\ - 5 _
I p
.____c 0/.f*a bb.M /b. 10. /Hy f u
\\
c1
- 2.. f-71
...8." J A lf. 7 o 7.o.o._. t. r. ec.
y
..o.S..3..o____fv__7-R...c E. Vjt_,.. ce.. B..ne.e r mr uu.v. n
..o..n_ o
.r e _r_.7 (cu.oi.r. 9 s).( a n. ' s.r //. t '
l
~
t13o. __..
o' D...R. C EV
.S h.G V3 C4. M B 9er. B' V'!Ce U.E.,.*T~5.-
Il.Ll D t
1 i I 3 v.
3.___
.0
.. a.rn...Y.es....m v.p. i.i.s....s..o... A... sw.r. i.a lv -..1.} '44... Of.& 4A.
A s.v.
Of.i.t,. joe s, s
o
, j d,'f M*. N.
t 4
'W
~~
,,,./.
TMI-2 PRIMARY AUXf t.!ARY OPERATORS LOG BOOK j_._. ___..
- 2. s o o.._.07.c_o........, B,
.z zi 7e.......__ _..
i I
o., 0.ci..._. a o i s u r._. > / i,/ n.. -...
\\
i
.. _.. s.t.:. J....
- u..p.. _..
j.._.....--...__..
~
e 3_a 9,,,,f,f,_,,..,_,,,f_,2.3 __y,_g _7z.
)tz(,y, _py, y,m _,,, _,
i l-l. _.
/
j'
/
l.__
K o o _. 2 3 o.o.
'd.5W 7..__
2/.4,}yq J
,, j._.J D.
5.Lt t d __%.trL _. U.11__C.$._B.uk<.1 A t.0 u_._
$$nk
...iG F..
M h A _ i. %...~i k._.' w w. a e L v....*_. 5
._.. [g g
4
.. _.ces sI.,n.1 _ r e k. sc...d..._*l 8.._Tes7 rwx
}
...Mio. _ __O.Ft.U 32 n h... 6.wu $_o d r.r.(dre, WoLs* 23 1975
<~_ Sin A._Ih. v._._cm _..c.tuw u.
_3hrw._.4 6.5(Jer 2. 8.Da,d
_3 6 3b.Tt.r-1$. A ac.k 3 9
@.ed.3awV..__
d f,
.. _.U_oQ _o2c.o - S. St1Fr 2 22 '79 l
o Lt.o comp cter.fcaw $ f94-c.Ir ~6 cp_ao. Terr rw 2
j sTagr abs-r.,..J.s i v ru_w l l
._m3 0
'=TcP_.Ft.s2.58 cE..w.bs-t-13 n - Cso.onc=.D+
n co.O_v Q?.LS._.
57M.T__fES&__ ITs495E.af RCam.5P-C-t r w_ w h t T.:!A o 235-co.39.cre fesnu TRAqs.Rg _ Co_<.q_We.Ot I't.925.-I-te _
l
_.__. 6MKFits_de..:.ssoeLwM Levet. wwT ro 8?i oELifJanie
.AEVa4_4LGIT. Ze).2 G.'.beAId %u'..M k.t-J t% bc.e +7 su.m..TD GG' uJcot6&C, f)9. y)A.T'Eg coy o F bfA_id/_,,k. naC _ _.
t 2 I Grl_e.g:.e )offas so w b_s tA Us <=, 3[.'f.-f
^r
---r o53 0. ' aratr_.gAn. net '88'- neor rAuK' To MM &_T~-0MCA A0 2.?.2-04 2-us<ac i?8'pm a %ragee -
ros.'gr_1 rar S n?P TRAAS.qq~.2_.bT 4.'4',a.lB' neoz_TA_N_C-i QMc{,Eb.Boul 70 N_'kn. ret-/hu Af aNS[42'$_.
Alore:
i;
- i_
o ~7CC _
/fC O
. bot 0
i' Cf6'L_.Sr,f.*it..!,v' muev.s _
r_ 2' m a i n!^
-r">_
i te '
w-x 1 &_t.w.vitI_d y.g...
lfCD W"7
~,s.v TES
/Ir { W.!./gj fe s.4 t.- VkiU4 p.:'_._(t.Su#
it/
fB 7d~'d
$U U 6 0 l
- t l
e
-.n..........
....u :.; s.. -
we r.cs o:.s. w.. o rs~uo u e s a sc G
O 9
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 e
(
I
(
I G
I
/
1
! 1
'l l:
l i
\\
I I
i i
l 1
I i
g i
}
g-I W
6
}
i i
3
-l 8
w a t
i i
t 1
t a
o a s,.
I
>- m o e
e-m ar.
i a-m.
o.
i s
n 8g, ~
=
2 i
.a i
g*
ml s
s.
g a=
"O.
e a ss I
s.i un
- n p
J, a
~, ~ w g
h! d I k
I w
_- n. ~
a e.
e n
m b
f kO j
Wa e m Y
l5 5 2 d 5
'h 5
W g
a y<
N g
~ ~
a O
S
-E-
- ~
o
~
~
(
t-o 8
9 7
0 y
^
E WC d a
w m
a o o o m
o m - ~
m m 5
4-E w
g a n o - o
~ m 3w 0' R."
4 8 R
9
'a E 8 A V m2 ; ;
x
= r
, o a pv m m O
.' 3 ay
=
m ~
n Q
w W
a M
g" O
2 O
a a
m m
o 9
0 6
," S O'
s b
3 3 g " 13
$ l: "g" 5 h..
w t0 5
v i $-
hN e 8
~
G 85 b.
?
5-B B;: 3' 9,
o o s
E w
"m m
a i
K S 4:
s
- i O "
- o m
$ W l
.O e
W _
e
-;8
,2
- R w
og=o
,E
'-> _ d 8f C
.,6 J
l C-c
.m m
8 S-lc.) g-G, t,, u
- ~ '
4, u
G:
w
-. = =
N l. 0 '*.' h e -
u-e a P I
E W-I
- w' w e R=
j a
u m
e j.
o' p o E
o s'
- g c i *-. _3 3..,
M!. i
- e. a Il 'h
'd C. 5 5 E o ",
W ;
s r.,9. n
=
-e W
~095 le o; R
v 't Am a,
o o e,
o
,o i
0 0
!)
9-0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 L
l M'
TMI-2 CONTROL ROOM OPERATORS LOG r-3 13 1 t?I'19!34.w.df L.
. ;. u vi k J i /e v-a. i i ' jui.af:. -- :-.y.:....
l ps
- x..
n.... ;
i.
xG
.......... :. _ _ n:....
b.
ir n
- s. b.
k 2: i;.:.'.
d..ad ~rL.ai
\\
. k l d XC-N -t.' p. g d w is..
fa.&.e., ( fu iM..
~T
/s 2s AucpMec/ f.,/<,, w J-. u in..,- e a.~~. " " .'~ ;k $ 0 R 0 6 6 9
^
~
n..
i n o.
~ -
/42'3 gy A >#u4/
4
';' 40,01T10M U. k
- Womed
!bei. a ful:.
L su i
.!I '. : % VH-1
. 'at.be-, d ylee.iac sk (%' c u,<....... ' T'. _~..:._~ {. '. ** "" '9 g
.. p. :
ic ina fasfced b z.cex Qp.,/i,.,....
t.'.
- L M n4. non afi e,<.,. u p
.s, _,d. c p.p.,?..
6 /c s-d. 2>p. v. ir.1 6(.% d Yk '..
is
/6fr 6,a.f'/Ad 1.3o 1. >< 2.o.
y x
.. c..
/7"' khed I2 "l e44,s iu
(,) Dr hN.....*..',,,,,
(.'.'
9 i f ju
... M ) Doled cok:
[*i.. -
\\
-......I
/?u~ %ewed ce,<d.,5 2>.z tzz rh.d '.ra tj&)....
/bs-d2
. ' 4 X t e -,- I. '
l :. 3..".*
t 1
/rzo ~%~a d i
See.
a. {. L...
j fg i t<c. %. a q.
u v e y. t.-.......r.......
~. -
1
. W...,,. A.
i
../ra> kIbe! Joo k( Betel s alu~ r :t..
4d L
_ s w.~r.tfa %,y,
_3+.q".
\\
/ P - g: a A et us 1. r..
l 2.::
)
..... /W rs&A-d
. cosa m eel
.t a::r.> dou~e e c
'rds,
.ecisr-W >!o ecer _.Y;.Q.l '
i i
.b ~
14.r.
d%
$ca ird%:.<,?... ': --%:[.4 a
1
- . ti u ' /& i J A k I/. q
, h *. u ~-* se' T
I
- t. c., = t.
3... c. :.i. -
L e i r 1r wK 20-v->..
3 i9adld.a>.
p.i
,,,{o a.,< &
r.i.-.:-...-.__ ?w.4 eU.]
...-.a-.-...--
r., >
+.wm.nou
........ m,
M.d i
rc...._. _..... 3..
a f..g o-j
- -. -..... -.. : a r.1r-
.{.
M'u. - t..=
.,. y A 1
.f
- f. p A.
- . w _.
99o.'10
,,r e., -
-- :. ' c..
1.:.. r.
w...
. - -.. -.-.. - ::.:c =.. -
a. -.....:.. a :. ::...
1
--- --- ~..- :. : 2.... :..... ::.. a J -:.. i.: 1. ". -
1
. ;'..'i.,. ;
. : r:..?.'.w.. ' :--.
- n. -
'. c
.,...n..-
1 c.
.,.'.. c u
(.. '
l r.s r.
p.
j - -, - ----..:...:....
1
..... ~....
l j
j.
j i
,., n
. 4.
2:!:">3 ' =:' ^.: -.
.%.c c.,
c
f
%l 't i <
0 O
o
.n 4
.k1' ym n*
6 3
d Al F
e s
s
<gy.!
T np = n 1
Y g
~g a a 9-s E
=1 n
B2 "E
g s
E ee s
5 s
va re g w 2
E e
==
B"s n 9 a
e3 a
=
5 5
5 E
a A
e
~~
g gn o
g e
m ~
== ;
n
=
s.,
?
o C E WC a.a l
'5 "d a m as-sm=-
i i
cig 4=sg s:s,
i s
w R "w..
3 Be t n i
i
~
ci i
s-
$ g ! lw g, = wl i
6 I
- =
9
= it '
- i 6
I l
n g-n I
)o.
g *siiE M
S l
e 6
l
'F O'
8 Ee a a
y
,- 8 ]is m r=
=
=
e t
!m~g5 i
a v
i 8
N 8,
w-s m-
=,
a 5
m s-o $,g 's5
~
gl #
9 9
{
g o
g' E:
A 9
=
l0 dim i
5 4
+
w m
s ge;-
~
m e
e B-
- sa i
e
=
m 1
c
$c a
a s g :s a
si E!
gEC E
E j
Ba
-E a
I 5 g' s
t R
5 '" N s
EW m;
8-a S
-1 a
s 5 sms i e
!s5=
6 cme e
c p oyo t
i i,
I v"=a ss s e-suf o, e
5, o
e e
e e
e e
e e
e e
e e
e e
e 41X: N:.E?Y.'N.b!$.l'$hl Y, 5C,'. W f h &' hikh& & hQY.l%
9 iI
.I e
k[-p.-f jf-n
-in-
- 5 i
' IE' "l 'il'
' A fnf s,,,,..,
>e n.us
\\
p swnoa
=
s f
Wiu u, w &@
s ursse a u
-~',
\\g App /T70N 1
r 6
.s'
~
/p' I i
t
/
l l
p,/ -
..y 'a..
s 4
-(,
[
Nn p<
1 I
g
.g.
.. is
.m
.+.
.. a.f.. y i.
v' sm u.
, 6 i.
g l
\\ 1850 010 le6 Aeo 600 ML j
s,l s
,k e
/ l I
/
r-C j
o
/
h.
l I
e; a
y A
' +
2 q maas w
,Y
% ' AAb /00 OL
\\
L l
k j
i l
3 7'
7 Nrosoarv
%s l
- 2235 (#0400 M
3,..
{
A '
itQ l
ir v~
D lw
{
so
)
')
g is ks]
p
- /
.j j[
^\\
W w
f i-f, l'
a g
l 7
l c'
c.
i
..3 b
l
.. f, b
i l
[
t n,;..
,j
..l',.
.j~
H--
'j 4'.
i l
\\
-s
)
n
-Q
\\
i r
f m
1
'[
.y.
g 4
o
\\
c
\\
i
~o a arrs 8'
ee O
- 1h.
dl l
- ' ~ - - - -
.j
. Ibl I
L
j EV I
TA G
EH E
S L
0 0
T V) 3 9
S LT 9
9 J
L t
TO 2
2 t
DV t
C(
t J
R 4
I T
G C
f L
G 1
A G
V 3
4 iw L) 7 8
f T
D 4
N S
M KI 4
8 L
D T(
6 5
I T.
E J4 L
IM E
f t
O' P
l l
5 2
F A
)
I P
1 V
7 2
I Y
O 0
L) 4 8
1 4
1 T
3 N
I t
T' A
O RI 6
7 R
M P
T 1
Z(
2 2
G G
I E'
A 0
t 2
2 l
4 P
3 P
0 1
A O
2 1
7 F
u 0
6 G.
3 t
6 7
4 4
T R
(
9 8
T D
R 4
)
3 2
S L
F
)
E)
I E
E E
S' 1
R VF 0
0 T
H V
L D
D G
A(
8 8
T 5
5 T
E E
3
(
)
B 1
l E
L V
t 1
)
G E
E 0
A 4
K L
R 0
1 G
2 6
K J
F 3
D
(
2 0
I A1 L
N K
2 3
4 4
t W
T N
T
(
K E)
E0 A
D 1
A F
3 3
)
L3 I
N T
C 4
0 E.
T(
9 9
4 5
5 R
T1 S
R 3
I I
1 0 C
A N
S 2
G
- 3 R
I E
D
(
E I
L2 D
A H
B 1
0 0
0 S
R T
4 3
U 8
2 1
r 0P E
T D
0 T
2 3
l
(
CS S
O R
S 8) l A
A T
T F
D G
CF 8
8 R
E L
N S
T(
6 6
E O
R 0
A S
S 4
T 5
5 T
T C
)
0 L
E E
G O
M C
E S
C 0
G G
R I
A D
R 0
N N
F Y
5 3
E U
R C
A A
R 4
8
)
KA l
O O
E A
4 3
I l
R 4
i T
R O
O G
D A)
P E
G C
O A
N HF 3
3 G
L I
I T
8 A
T D
D K
O T(
9 9
C E
C E
E A
C 5
5 0
S A
1 R
A S
S E
E 3
C
(
E U
U L
S R
R L
R A
A 7
7
(
O L
A C
C D
O 7
6 D
E E
L E
T 4
3 87 T
A I
A)
T I
72 A
V T
A R
R I
N O
O F
Y CF 8
8 A
F
/:
R R
I R
T(
6 6
R I
85 E
E N
T T
I I
F A
A T
A 5
5 T
13 P
T i
I
/:
O N
R R
N 4
K l
A E
t E
E E
E E
f 07 I
E D
P P
D R
l t
1 F
i Te O
D P
5 5
L I
0 T
1 1
I I
E S
t R
R R
R R
R R
E E
E E
E E6E 6
6 S
A EE I
I 3
O T
T 1.T T4 E
S T3T9T T
R O
N N
. T l
N 9. N 9. E N
4i T
E N
7 8
G T
E E
E - E2E DT O
D 6
0 1
N
- 1 2
2 m
4 4
y V
3 l