ML20237E816

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Non-proprietary Version of W AP600 Design Assurance Review of AP600 Safety Analysis Documentation Pertaining to Chapter 15 & Containment Analysis Portion of Ssar
ML20237E816
Person / Time
Site: 05200003
Issue date: 03/30/1998
From:
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML20237E801 List:
References
REF-QA-99900404 NUDOCS 9809010197
Download: ML20237E816 (28)
v • d • e


Text

.. . .. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Attachment 1 A Westinghouse AP600 Design Assurance Review of AP600 Safety Analysis Documentation Pertaining to Chapter 15 and the Containment Analysis Portion of the SSAR l

l l' Performed by Westinghouse Electric Company i

Nuclear Service Division W. S. LaPay Team Leader March 30,1998 i

\

G ST

!- 99900404 PDR l . . .

~

Westinghouse Nonproprietary Attachments to Westinghouse Letter DCP/NRCl324, Rev. 2 ,

I August 21,1998 Attachment 1-A AP600 Design Assurance Review Attachment 1-B Design Assurance Review Corrective Action Plan 1

1 l

l l

i i

i 3687aR2. doc

\.

Westinghouse AP600 Design Assurance Review l

of i l AP600 Safety Analysis Documentation Pertaining to Chapter 15 and the Containment Analysis Portion of the SSAR Table of Contents i

1.

r OBJECTIVE..............................................................................................................

! 2.

S C O P E O F R E VI E W . . . . . . . ... . . . .. . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . .. . . ..... . . .. .....l 3.

REVIEWTEAM........................................................................................................2 l 4.

PROCEDURE.............................................................................................................

5.

SAMPLEFOCUS......................................................................................................3

6. .

S AMPLE SIZE AND STATISTICAL B ASIS.................................. ............................... 4

[

I 7.

R EVIEW P ROCEDU R E AN D PR OC ESS ............................................................

8.

REVIEW....................................................................................................................6 9.

SUMMARY

................................................................................................................6 10.

R E F E R E NC E S . .......... 3. . .... . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. ... . . . . .. ..... ...... . .... . .. ...

l t

l i

I

l .

7 l

' Westinghouse AP600 Design Assurance Review ~

Objective As part of the Westinghouse oversight of the safety analysis documentation for the AP600 program, a design assurance review was performed. The objective was to assess (via samp the adequacy of the AP600 safety analysis documents supporting Chapter 15 and the containment analysis portion of Chapter 6 of the SSAR to satisfy the provisions of Appendix B l in 10 CFR 50. This review was conducted in accordance with the AP600 Design Assurance Review Plan defined in the February 10,1998 letter DCP/DCP0343 from R.M. Viluk to the AP600 Project, and the procedure plan given in the February 12,1998 letter DCP/WMS 1134 r

from W.S. LaPay to the established AP600 design assurance review team.  ;

Scope of Review i As noted in the objective, the review focused on the safety related calculations that form the l basis for Chapter 15 and the containment analysis portion of Chapter 6 of the SSAR.

Therefore, the scope of the review included six items:

1) Large LOCA
2) SmallBreakLOCA
3) Non-LOCA Analysis
4) Containment Analysis
5) Long Term Cooling
6) RadiologicalEffects Associated with each are three distinct areas that were evaluated: ..
1) Pla$Configurationinput
2) Analysis
3) Computer Code Validation & Verification (V&V)

Four computer LOFTRAN; programs were included in the scope. They are: WCOBRA/ TRAC; NOTRUMP; and WGOTHIC l

l L Review Team 1

I The review team was established as an independent group drawing on technical experts from within and outside of Westinghouse. It was assembled to represent all major %chnical i disciplines. The team members were asked to review documents within their areas of expertise. ~: . .

t . .

2

l*

Area of Expertise i Team leader ~

LOCA (Large and Small Breaks)

LOCA (Laroe and Small Breaks) [

l Non-LOCA Analysis

~

Non-LOCA Analysis Containment Analysis Containment Analysis  !

Lono Term Cooling Long Term Coolino Radiological Radioloolcal Software, Validation & Verification (V&V)

AP600 Interface Statistics Consultant Support from QA Procedure l

The review process consisted of the following steps:

1. . Establish the scope of rev es (see Section 2]
2. Establish committee membership (see Section 3]
3. Establish sample population areas of focus
4. Determine sample size l 5. Selection of review calculations
6. Establish review criteria >
7. Perform safety calculation reviews
8. Characterize and document reviews Sample Focus The process / procedure used to select the sample population was based on recognizing:

o similarities in the analysis areas o that small break input is similar to input for large break and non-LOCA analyses o the importance of analysis in all categories o that the radiological analysis does not have a unique input or computer mde, and that industry standards are used it was important to assure that the sample population selected safety analysis calculations that were unique to the AP600 plant design. Further, the calculation packages available for review should allow the reviewer to identify and evaluate any errors that could propagate through the cnalysis. Therefore, past revisions were also reviewed in some areas.

Based on the above rationale, the sample selection was based on the matrix shown in Table 1.

3 l

r .

Table 1 - Review Focus Matrix Analysis Area Input Analysis Code V&V Large Break LOCA X (WCOBRA/ TRAC)

C,wil Break LOCA X X X fNOTRUMP) l Non LOCA X i X (LOFTRAN)

Containment X X X (WGOTHIC) i Radiological X l

l Long Term Cooling X X (WCOBRA/ TRAC)

As seen from Table 1, all four computer programs that are used for the Chapter 6 (containment systems) and Chapter 15 SSAR results were included in the review. The programs are:

WCOBRATTRAC; LOFTRAN; NOTRUMP; and WGOTHIC. In the review of the computer

programs (Validation & Verification, V&V), two types of reviews were performed. One review was performed of sample calculations that were associated with the computer program V&V, the other was a " global" review to determine if the proper V&V review process and procedures were employed.

Sample Size and Statistical Basis ,

A sample size was developed based on the areas identified in bection 5 and the population of available supporting documentation.

Using the review focus matrix as given in Table 1, safety related calculations were initially identified. The sample size was increased to a total number of 55 safety related calculations, eighteen software documentation packages, and 22 LOCA related Design Change Proposals )

I (DCPs). The increased population of samples was needed so that the reviewers could adequately perform vertical slices, review to assure completeness, and assess potential i propagation of errors. This population does not include calculation revisions that were also included. The safety calculations selected for review, with the reviewer identified, are listed in Table 2.

l The adequacy of the sample size is assessed based on the confidence interval for the estimate

( of the probability of occurrence of a significant observation or finding in the independent review.

l l

  • l l )

( -

. Critical norm:I deviat:s bas:d on ons sid$d tests are used to define methodology and formulations are discussed in References 1 and 2.

An estima,te of the minimum sample size is based on the formula given in Reference 2 (

268): ,

(Z.)* p(1- p) n= e ,.

n = sample size n = target confidence level Z,= normal deviate for et - number of standard deviations from the mean (median) l p = estimate of probability of significant observation or finding

- e = orror band around probability p The hypothesis is that the percent of significant issues will be very low. To define a sample size,it is assumed that 2 to 3% of the documents may have significant potentialissues. An error band of similar magnitude is assumed around the probability p. A sample size from 50 to 75 was then established using the formula above with a confidence level of 90%. A sample size of 73 was used excluding DCPs and calculation revisions.

- Review Procedure and Process 4

j

- Each of the participating team members that were reviewing the safety related calculatka l focused on the following areas:

i l

i 1) Applicability of the analysis and modeling methods and engineering assumptions Gudgments)

2) Reference to current analysis or design input
3) Competency of the engineer and verifier in understanding methodology and procedures
4) Verification techniques used by the verifier, and resolutkm of verifier comments
5) Verification of computer codes, macros, and error reports i

' 6) Adequacy and clarity of documentation .,

7) Accuracy of portions of the analysis calculation selected for review i

' Reviewers were required to document conclusions or observations related to any of the above items, or that it was not possible to make any statement due to content of the calculation i

selected for review. Reviewers contacted the responsible engineer and/or verifier when necessary for clarifmation or to address questions.

A review was performed from a general perspective to determine if the overall software i

i documentation necessary for a V&V code was on file. The purpose of this review was to determine whether the documentation for WCOBRA/ TRAC, NOTRUMP (Versions 32,33),

LOFTRAN AP (Version 1.8), and WGOTHlO (Version 4.2) conforms to the applicable Quality Assurance Procedures for computer software development. There was no attempt to evaluate correctness of technical information such as equations, source coding or numerical results.

The technical reviews were performed as part of a technical V&V review of the documents identified in Table 2. Emphasis of the software documentation review was on being able to track the connectivity from functional specifications to validation documentation to the program

\,

l 1

I which is configured end r:lrased for use on AP600. wo check lists w:re used. One was a L- ,

validation document checklist, the other the software change specification checidist.

F Review '. i l

Upon completion of a review, each reviewer provided documentation in the form of worksheets and report.

l l Summary in the design assurance review, potentially significant technical and documentation quality issues were identified and summarized in Table 3 for the documents reviewed. Other comments made by the reviewers are considered to be suggestions for improvements and good practices. The individual review team reports should be studied by the AP600 responsible design groups since they contain additional recommendations to improve the documents, identification of conservatism in the design, and improvements for future consideration .

1 I

l l

1 l

l l

l l

l

)

~

i 6

V OT

& Q ('001 0 7 0O

- i x V C6CCCC 0 - - - 8 CC - - 1 1 R IO- 0 3

_ r e 1 8 7 00381 - 1 23423361 - - 7 R1 0 01 O0 4 4 8904 6 43 - -

t d 7791 9 81 6699 56010 7 3 9 CCCC

_ a o 4S4445

- - - - - 4599 AA9 5 0A

- 2267-M C SP PA SSSSS P SSAAT 7 RD

- 551 1 1 1 99 ACPPPP AAAA A PPTT AA NN NNRN S - T A9C T

5544 n

SSSS CCC A N o CECCCC S ES EEEE ACCC C

NC RC C PPPP AAAA S SSSS N EE i SS C-N CCCC t EEEE

- a C SSSS l

u

. l c

a

. )

C 2 8 s 4 w i s . e 01 001 01 0 3 7 2 3

i e l y 01 2?CCCCCCCC CCCC99500001 - - - - - - - - 55 27 70 1- -0 00 07 2 3 66 C. 70 07 9 23 09500 v - - - -

a 9999 n 2222 88344444 222 0000 44455555 7781 67 77 9 59 3AR

- 1 7A 9 R 0 6CC - -

e A 5555SSSSSSSS 1

99- - -

AC 91

- 83 785 R - - - - AA AABTA97C -

RI 2 SSSS PPPPPPPP TT- - TT - - O RN C AC COA 55- -

s PPPPAAAAAAAA - - - - - - - - NNN NCR NM CRSS i AAAACCCCCCCC

- - - - CC CC N NC R PP s

y CCCCEEEEEEEE EEEESSSSSSSS C C-N C

CN T EC CC AA- -

- l SSSS EE SS a

n .

A y

t f

e a t u

S p - 4 - 1 0-5 1

0 0 000 0 0 n 0 0-0 0C CCCCC

- - C -

0 i

C C 3M 1

3 6 99 6 7 667 8

- - 0 5 0 776 6 6 3 M

O SS

- 4- 5 444 4 P -

0C l SI - l-l - I S A PAAA A A X P

0P 1

1 SASSS C CCCC C

- - - S

- EEEEE E SS SSS S 2

l e aA s s A is s b eC r C is y t c

g n

a AL O O L la y

la n fe i

lo T sk e k e A n A f

E C

o sro i t o A n yB r

C e m d r WT l

O m e age N a L n nra m n o

ia t

n g

n AL S N o L o

C

{

j{

t h

e

. i t

lp ee eh t

s hT n h e

i g s -

n d . d e Y 5 C

- ' i l

l eam r

are e t

n . 0 E S

s c a s pb l e d n e r v

.' e o dso m u o o u oap r e o b f

s t h

l p f a e .

s d t o e s d n e

I

-y et hm m a n a io t

mdt o gie o le i

t l a e w it m t la i

l e b u n c s u

. a r npl t o q o a t n

u n ipler leabp u r

i t f r

e lc a

Q o h a c n

i t

a d

o s,c aeh c l

e id o

m e

o c Mwl i e r r v m h c

i f lo ptpo t t n o r o c

t t

a t

t o c o y t a .

dng a e f

i x f y f n lc undlb t

u u n b ir a

e r . i n a l o

l f o d l c

s e m u

f o f ot euef p la a c s t f

i it a t e

c d u

s a

c o i de W. r elcbp aaa l

h t

e d h

r l r

r e f f

e n a

w o ercnod

_ l D f

i d  : w e c a e v

y d o! b lo Y e o i

t l n muo dos af aa n l a e h e a r

p r

a a e e h Y .

u bed me rl o t e s stice b l

a t .f g d lt im Q u c be ncb oa an ndo n a o n i n R oteed s es is m s e t _

wo At r oo e ic u r auu u e i t eit h So t a ptsa s r r s d _

c Snn r a lut e s o e n

_ i v e lugr e e s ea cie nar lcntshi f w i o m d

ret l

r a e n hc c ct oo 05 t

t o a ept h e s a _

e n t k c epo i n l u

r a

c a it a

t aa enab ee hrdf x

v o c a o c v he i r it s nc i r t r ht gd e t r n ogn o

r a l

a n _

ao r

f i

n e d bt n nob p vr c o _

uD ig b s ei l ieh t o isodeo ri t e e e s

it c

o dp sdet s a ssdn S ns eramrsa l

iat ohc a b b e Aa y t

n e icd t erswf t

ir d o h d nl l

l a mA ri e ahp s

nie d e yid l

u o

t n

t t

a d e

3gc a a ic mt a n

_ i i

t f oi cp l ts t isTp a hg nudco rv h s c ht e esin n in sg u ea if l

be e g es n n ee oe p s i n d e

m aDch i

t o is iC rL s oiuu ceqq nb ae r v s

a g t o o m

T0e P r nb ii e oco b is n c 8 0T o t E r s in i

i t t s r .

e 6t s i

D ot ib A o sO Pn g t oa rc lh neda iC R Aac n n e a s sdtee e een t a g

t i-ot enn t

i d

r rhlbio n ;4

,, 1 t.

r ef i n mks r aoo asit e s. e r.r si r e dsa m  ;; 48- r.

un ma i

uiit t r asl oig f

o o er el o aluu l e r pn eoe m i

f

c. S i r .

hS N Cb Ness voo hp o o o cP

-i c

g nly TsAc C N MA C il

_ tsia s et t n

Wne t e

o m A A O1 23 A P u C A

_ C C CCCC A 0 A 'O 1 0 O 1 0 1 0 f c O - - - - C 4 C C- C CCCCCCCC

_ o D

o L O Ls 0000 9999 O L O 0 O 1 O - - - - - - - -

99500001

_ y k ks i 2222 L 0- LV 4 Ls 88344444 k &

r k kt a & a ay 5555- - - - a au C 8 i 7781 1222 m a e r rela SSSS e ep 3 aV 4- ks ay 44455555 e B Bn PPPP r r n M ee rd S ela SSSSSSSS

_ m r A AAAA B Bi -

Bo P r BnA PPPPPPPP u A e e S A-S s g g CCCC

- - - l l

a a N

X 8C a n a AAAAAAAA l

e r r a a EEEE m m P m C CCCCCCCC SSSS E m EEEEEEEE y L L S S S S S l

a SSSSSSSS n

A

ue n too es r s an i

) t kp o d n

P gd + u cs ee u Onter O w c ph a e dr o t s

f n

Lo eepo o r n

. e t

u ars pt ea a (ll roxrf e u n otuhw i

t a

ef ehn e s

a i

d wseio t b

ehoy t nc od pnode bwi p t d

l y hian ba a t

i t

n s w yt e c ecu it l

eoqu um h e

rbs e s ss wn us l

a i i

e g u sods h f a n Q or r r r

r efio en t y

f 3 f otsOba Ped h a

n eer ic f n oaOoo e c o h e 'm a sl e st LtL f

i t

a ot rhnn vt lc oaadfeo h t

_ t n eieet r d n

l e rrgs t a

e bwe n n bp a a hffoods h m r t p e t

rl eejL uo t s u uo a nio s s e c t n v o f o aitb mith e e al as n t

u o a r ntsynt d .

a s

s D u d c h r, a p n o aer e ic i

iel e

. r hel pbe ef vot n e d y d f at e i nR d s n

. t n it ne ci e,h . d a o i i a t t t= iweasr di m t a

ew r

l a ehl bu Fi n e =

= d go a u h l

r u a dt d inLbc i gt a e o t c v a = r Q i n t e np .re r e m y glofohed m r

n h otie npc )e s w e aea st be o r.

wo

_ l c i eh ,st f ec sh s r a d t t a s ne ei e nca no h d oc sat n t t t iavt T cn o s n

eaeLt ed g i

r n e io t i n e

Re en t n

iaisi t

a r shs r i it a o mhvehe e t

m ag r

a un l

uoi v it it d dtd h em cfs ant ee t

s c eeadnt m cu i c l r

e s a htaonef o ige f e -

Lamo i

f nc i n aibr cs m b d t

ss t c nl ao g aeo o e e

f s e t n oib cbhha stsoRm m r

uD t

r d si a cs e le uapa s uoi on i t t S ja t

n n a sd sn y b a e cuI.oeey ssct ic f np Aa l u ei(k hr ic m is r pL r r it i n ose _

d e c l l f

nl a siWiev i

n m i

dt is nt gsibi g

sr 3gc ia i

e o f g o a i s a t

por. et i du whe n hr r is c 2ehi n ti t I t o

les n i

t e t f

ooh vp r e

R 8irm.s n b ol nm n ety beh aDc o r t t u nin t o ou rF ieio u 2 e, 3ub r

P s i t r pm t

3l b 4t 9 T0e ieda e e g t c a p. o min - ad 0T f i

e rdent d h in E- . e im r

ua 6a 9t p _

6t eeh ef d - S gt n e esr 9gt p Pn vet po n -.

ds t

Aec

- i Asoce Aac e ocme R m ni a e od ne i

v c 6ne@

f Aoiv h TNa c efi si hr T pf r ion N o

C o Sl Sf l boist r

ourhf TA N N un t pt o C- D-oig hS g

ni o ))]1 J1 i"

t t

n 5569 0538 ]

6 ]7 96 -

t s _

e 3333 33 22 09 22 e '^ -

- m A A u C C 0 0010 8C

- 7A 0 CCCC CC CC W ^- c O C6CCCC

- - - C SSSS GGGG SS SS o L O - -

GG 8 0 00 04 381O 6L V 1

2 - - - -

7 D k LV 7 89 3 AA RRRR AV <> G- _

t e k & 4 4 - 77 91 & CCiss SSSS AAAA C&

RR AA AV RR

& e aV 4S444 5 SeV 5OOy SSSS9k 1 C& AA i e o r ee

- - OV SS OV SS crA e B l

rd Bo tC SP PAPP A A PP A Bo C AAA SS SS Prd oe S LLl a Pnnn AooA

(([I 5507 7027 Le nd oo SS

((

23 34 Le nd oo S [

[S 11 C NN s a e l

1000 NC m m CECC C C AaRC -

6777

- - h-E 6 NC 36 S

t i s

S S ESEE S E E Sm E 9999 I 9~ 56 l

y SS S S N S S - - - -

AAAA AA

- - 99 a TT - AA n T T T T- T T-A NNNN NN NN CCCC CD C C.

1

e f!j ip z i ,i

~

.1 f l

. 5i!Ibj'!!l;l'!!1!

ill!!!!p, i

i iip!!! yil f i ! b ili ht I! 4JJ idill.ff,l!ldhllie 1ll i

i l I I!  !!

I! lei ,! ~ll ili!!!11]la;nlaiijl1 ii ildlild))illi Ill Iill>l 1

lil

's I

y bt r t

i l

h eeeeo r ped de edor a t u u d s s s ube r mdo nh Q n en ee v

r o et nu n lear pehs eaw f r r a em e o b poh i

t a

bn t

aeel vua st se sct aey t

n e it nm o

inhele ase r w s b s r r eid e m u

sa et st l neea nI e t

u s c u qo s en O.t n s o c esahi f n.tye i

D is elede r

e m u y t h r ah ipo

- t i

l d

n et ye ef f t

e

. t a

c or oc a a hogrpi lb ipd Q

u l a dnss e s r e n a n

f ign r

ene c ao nSUim o vkie n in eiet r s r b wo h r

pladT n e a

e a oe ia eit vt c

e su c aO L d t

e r wwv o sa Sl k en R e T Uca se s o o hih st pld t

n T s ah t lo em c u a Oimh s t

des d t

od u n co n c c Lamg n ah a

i d.

a r o f d ebr eo u s d iKs nt h de i

ie n ie h d e e d Wtp uD f f t r

e lb lb 2 ,g gt d ig it it t t

par c i sd n n n a a sn A a S

y e e isn n a neoe e t p t p

i r

ces id d i odleEv bt e .m e e sh K nl ll ir u c c t 3 g ca de e c ia s s s 3m ios . Oc c KtaW ese nh i

i t n 3e 6e t m

edh O luh do vf e Ras a s

wha Atde l

b e 2i t 6i ret R os l 1 i 1i

.0 hdl n s aD c t o 2n t 0t n u sa e 7n 5n e nh s rew t

T0 e P 9a 5a I A6 0o 0o huf 0T 6t Tic 9c t eC3 r

0 mpe 5t a i

7t a i

Too f i

sr a 9l 9l P n Bi f Dgn Rn Af i naO-e eL 7e Ac u

Ac u 'ts n naio msk 9 id t

A a c 0 s l Ra Ra wta l

Ci s Cis -

eilet efi si No No ma aA si u ole eR er s f

Cc Cc di r ic t

un oig CN CN CrbC er ht ev eR Nh e Nh e adi f

r CT CT Cav ne

_ hS g

nly il tsia s t

et n n W e e t

m O o u 3 7 R1 P ct 3 66 3 5 f

o onn t 2 0 t

n es 7 nV 1

t e

1 7 0 Deesni s 2 5 07

&mt ny 0n9 V m&

y 9 mis r

a nny 9 59 -

eiiaaa l

T-A B iaa l

Aaied 9A m et n n AR AonnA DC-C R

t t m r o nA o

Rtno RC u C C CoC S l sC C NN N C-N NC e CC C l

v C a

n A

ll j l

a i

n g

n

. . r o s d e .s e

u su e i I

s l s de y '

t y

ao nc i

l a l e .a, u b s0 ;.

a e0 e Q t p s6

_ n e aP n o c eA (

i c l

_ t a a re h;et t

n s t t0 e

i ne i6 n0 d

s m e d nd P e e u p e eA d

. u c o ps o e o le e u no c e D v l

y e dl ee e d d eds h mou

. t t i

n e .n it mr l

a a s o ei u l a l e ef n ds Q a c i ueit n

c y dmdo i

]

e i o aiet a idGl i

wo n t e msfic usb i

h f a

o edi 'e at eit c ia vt e s hoi f

t Gss s r

dr ms t

en T e t u rUi n Re t h eoej e em n t sf by snfy cu a d n u n U nnt i i nc i f

c a dMlda o mut See ao r

i ne n h ou c, h o

. Nivd uD i

gb l

o t e c sht le Ag o Aa sd s n ia Sn yo it a

ic n

r Mei e pdon w b

t p

a 1

1

[1 odi st ne nl a l s f n hoco t

e 8a u t i 3gc l

aa e t

rnt c c 3t G o as i

e i 2m i

i esi n t

n s r v, f nher a 3l

- s ni ot v

_ l beh e r 2s 7i s 9r ios 'e r aDc o a t

4 e o atet coon 2n -

2 Pp e 0s y A i

T0e

_ t 0o sU 1

_ 0T p 7l a afini icn t i

7t a Rn Coi n 6t Pn a 9- n fie s ar 9l u i Aa s vfg Oug I t t

Aec -

RR uefie f. Ac ai n ef i e Ca jdi". ,, Rla Mch si un n o Nv e r

ooe-NCVs r

, Cc

- Roo t oig N CO Neh TNN hS g

- - CT E- -

nly s

i!

il tsia t

n et n e

_ We t m u

O R-8 3

27 2-]e o

P ct on 7 M!

1

:e s es 423d 009i d

f o D eV 0 - - - G p & nV m& - f 3- oes Ds y 77As 7- : el a 91 99

- R 're u aiae AACs f 4 in et d t RRIU Aonco

c. r 9 SA CCOSN T.

E C A:Wf R

C- P f O NN MA 2g N CCRTTT C T- [

E c.

S.

- u o in s l f d

e o a e .

_ a on R l t r

_ y di e

v A t

_ i l

e ota o S

- a l mu c S

_ u b a ma o

l is dk e

c ev Q t h p s c t ae

- n e in o c c n wd

. it c a

a r

a r t

u d t

a eo f op t e

n is t r r n c s

e d t

en bio ei le e n la f e

u c m

u p o

oa t t t

ai n f

e r

n s o le d n 0 a

i s

D v fie e Ceh h y e i m 9 t t

_ .. t i

d n

d d u o o c 7ot e r

_ l a a e 6 u

_ u

]

e s a md 4- h g t a

_ Q l

a c

g a c eo b n lao u r e

n k y Sr p wo ei in h

c a f t

e dd lun Ct

- h m

e ia t

c P a s oa Ed t vt e s n hse, Sie e en T t s.

o e nrr v Re n e on t

_ t e n it h ia it em n w a t

d d tp c a a o v cu m r d

_ a u n ct o e s r

- nc ic m n a c a e ao rD f

i n o c

r o

ig f

n n, h en xw e,h s

n

_ u g c o t s . o o

ad c awn c t

sd i n t n C t

lei

_ sn S a a it a h u b h e Aa y f c c N A

ic t so i f aw r o

l f f lt h t ps 3gcnla n l

_ a ing i

n T e f et ,a s en m

_ es n i i i

t n is is g I T v r r ew cio a l

beh e o

[

s ie v n ct ala d

_ aDc o 0 f ie o e e u t

_ o N N 3 e r s

T0 e P 0- s y

ewi t r c u 0T -

Voa ala e 3 la Hd n sc s

_ 6t Pn le b lb 9- n a

t n s.e t

nc is y

- Aac t a a D e em er i t la mpm l

me t

_ eif p p T la n e e S-coum si r mto a u n ooco c c e o

_ oig c c N v e e hS, g

A A C O Cirse Dg h

T n i-i-

t s s e' t n

_ W ]. ,

e

]

Wl e

m g g 0 0O 0O0 g

_ N u s 2 5 in n 00

_ f cl oala o

D 4 0a l 6 0- J 0

3 oo i

l CCC CCCn

- - - li CC

_ o c Di icsm - Jv 4 oo 1 37 899 oo s 83 y ggs i 7ics i 7ka 3 - CCt 6 71 667 85 5 09 776Ci 9 gs 1 2 v

r &ooy o o 9 9- s

_ a - oy -

mmp u 4 54 444 55 mly l -

a l l Al oa l e D - - - - - -

m widooaR I SSI l l a SS m

u din Aa aAlo CaA t

r Rin d

A R

C-Ad o

C T"

S-eeI n r r TT A

S- AA PP S AAAen SSTA r

PP AA

_ sR R -

S t

n NR NR N C~ gg CCCCCg C

i s o C C CN nn E EE EEEn CC y C A T

oo L L S SS SSSo L EE SS l

a I T

n (

A

e u

s ia ncl t

nie ct nr o a

s n

o lashnm l

vAs eh

- oerice i e .nbc s t sie hen r r r c h e o i

cboea t

_ e .

y t e t t .

it ntocmo e r euh s

da

.t h ac a at by ic deilit e

uqu l

a methnw e t t f sinsb u i ufin d

u ssde o steepheea c

ih r es Q cr lc dhp spt c e n o eat e h n ia n ecae adaer ei s t

o dvte e er ho at i t

t n e gtotar t o

i

. t a h h dt y t n e7 e rn t t

,yas nob b3 moa dcfo i

n rb s t 0 gf hi e o e e d e o5 udcf s2 s

e vnmdees o n-aenre ds3 i

oan u

m u

c ewa r t e su d

O sS aP eiamoio s

s o woglei ona C hA bm r wr t

s i

y D hki,s d dmr 3 AC e

n ef ot o odn e t r leitc ebo t

. t d 6 1 v E a iesdaV t

e i

n t 0 eS u ad l

a a ba e ah rr ld e d 5-Rt n q t nshegsa et

,f eo u t pt o ut ll e eat Q

l a ee cn ohp l

e A Ae d a mwn r an n ic cdi sr r

S- 7m du us iseckci a o

wo pca n c o is t e nte cl t a C oc oui eb e mh on ei h 2 ia t

c E Mo d 3 dsid t eil l ni i

f vt e bT/ e ai t it is S erbuoc en T Cn n hf o apimi oCe mm a pe Re t t t t n Aot o t t

em cu n

a sWle n df oo r t enRi mioT a is r

e aya sds t

h c cnli e nc i c o he oin ne ua/c t Aifi V t aoivgo a eo r if it la t t t r cd oiRc P d ut t eqeta2a n

uD ig n

le uie nde c a r daBe pl M dndaen esn c3h ssdn S b a

l cdsi rd aev e vOS U Aa ly t

p cse e ur i cnn.

ote n sit eo k gfoC e a sWg T R acmioe

<wtsus ar r 3 ic nl g a l

a e c h spbeh e ea cir n t O

s. hto e coVf ew es n i i

t n

c a

t r l amfo ha Pi N cehD t

o u a .he s dadT pu l f edc nde rC l

b eh e e n gl u ).

c o r 4 aDc t o a r

u eo osl na ont e t n islc etyt ic 1 a ae a r

To e ohhm o if r f s a ih c it oT P f

~ inma oi c et t s

wf t

r ai t

t dylew i c it a

It srolcrtape P n n e ot n gluw sf t

t n

t t f r Aac e la a ao eegops nn v i cr Vu qleS e eif m

u imea eamd r r u pci laia eeee m u mmidah nf se p

eg c a em l

c mup c ae si hdrh t un o c oig D haio Tdd(gh a TaAT o o o d nt Cdmdui sh hS g

  • t f - - - D ar w ni i" -

t -

o- t s

o".

W..

n e n n

mg g io no io uinn 1 0O 0 g O t i N cl CCC Ciln C at t aC 0Ot CCtan O0O00 CCCCC f

o D o ooooVli - - -

226 551 0o 2

nnA eeR t

37 eP2 7901 4 y CC& 8 o 5 mmT 63 33444 r

a 1 1 9 6C V 554

- - 1 5- uu/ 00 mM3 88888

&mm a r r V e SSSl m& ccA 55 - -uUn c 44444 m e eed PPPAeV r S P ooR l Sori o l

SSSSS m r A TTo AAA DDB APDTs P P P P P_

- - - ST r

u gg C - A- eeO SAe Oe AAAAA S a nn CCCCg C r r CCa rNV - - - - -

EEE En a aC CCCCC leo vL1

o. SSS SoL E S wtwW EEw EEEEE t f SSf t SSSSS la f o o*

A n SoS S

s e

u

~ s i

s y

t i

l

. a u

Q n

i o

. t a

s t

n e

m t e

e u a

. u c u q

s o .

e e e Dt e d t a

l y a a u

_ t d u q i

l nq is e a ae 8 d u l aa d a Q c 1

s n is n i wo ni3 o 2 ei t h

c3 is r 4 iavt en e n en To s V o Re t s P s i

em nr A- r cu a e o nc i cV N w ao iP f

A i c

r uD nM g R T

h t

o sd iU F

- sn SR G

_ Aa yT O Wr L

a O

_ l nl l 3gci a iN f

o f o

les n beh i t nfo e n n

o n io 5 aDc t oo it a t a

1 T0e Pi t t

n t n

0T 6t t a e e Pn n m m e u Aac m c c u

efi u c

o o si d d un oig D o R l l

A A hS g

nly il tsia t

s -

et n n Wne e o n n t

m6 o o2 o t O0 i i P ua c n t CC6

- - 0 t

t a 78a 9

t 4 9tn no 46 12 15 f

490 7n 1 03 o oeP3 78 8 e 6- 1 1

- ei 0100 - -

DmM3 70mN 6 s

968mr 67 66 i 11

&cuUn 5594 uA 9- S 9 ue 99 -

- c

- sori o SSA P cR

- l oF S A pod.C TR cV -

DA AA TP AA eH SC RR eDTs m r Oe r

PP AA S AD C eLO I C C-

_ AerNV sa CCAWa E r NA A rT -

9_ i st w EES w CS SaO NN EE N Ntw G CC SS AA yf o SS t f f o

SoW l

aS n S A

s

l-

. References

1. 'Ang, Alfredo H S., and Wilson H. Tang. Probability Concepts in Enaineerina Plannina and Desion. Volume 1 - Basic Princioles. John Wiley & Sons, New York,1975, pp. 252 255,
2. Lapin, Lawrence, L, Statistics for Modern Business Decisions,3dEdition, Harcourt Brace i

Jovanovich, Inc., New York,1982, pp. 265-266,301-303,834 '

l l

l l

l

{

l I

I l

t i

4 Attachment 1-B i

I r

1 l

l Design Assurance Review l

Corrective Action Plan 1

[

l l

April 3,1998 l l

l l

I l

l t

h

t i

l a

u Q

n i

o t

t a

n

. e s m le e u b u c a e o t

p I

s D e y d c

. t c i

l n a a a s u l a a Q c w n i n d wo ei h e w

t c vta s i

e Re en T t e w

r em n s cu a nc i c P' ao if C r

uD n g D sd i e Aa sn S y

h t

f nl l

o 3gci a l

i a n t

n o lesin e it beh aDc t t a

o n T0e P e 0T m 6t Pn le p

Aac efi im si un e oig h T

hSg il nly s t

tsia nl a -

et n es We t mo up o co d 4 071 36 4 8044 62721 1 39028 P or e 024 778 9901 2704 0681 1 222 D P t

f a 1- 1- 1 1 1 1 2222334

- - - - 4 -55555 o sl e - - - - - - - -

y & e)Pg P EEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE r e nC C R EEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE a e aD DA r h(

GGGGGG

- - - - - - GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG C

m m

u AC sn O L

WWWWWW WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW GGGGGG GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG S ig s

yl o l

ao nD A

t ~ lae e gl ie u l n sar t u u i

l r inp q u o t a c s a

n R p st . ef la e u lea n ee it r ht r la nid c t

Q o r d h r e e it a

o os c nh e oov d e h n Wc Mwo e os r

r t e h t o ic t

n o cr t o t s

i t

a f

i r A .l f o t d ce a c eo n f y a a r e

dng it e x u

f f

f s

i r l t

n lc ui n u f f r l en i O la l

e e r . h t ot lo ep f oio it

,C c w od o s t

m r f la s f Nt a r - d u

f e u eu e Nno i

r e1 n s d d f r c d l e v4 a a c ie ne el a h r e8 n o f o w c t

s h e r w4 e r D id le N w i Y o o- v e er lo l

a c H.P S o c d d ob .

do t e r n e n

a mu o d

e af la e h h e eA p

o i r

bed t

e mec o d e8 f t

Y d - im c u l

a e l

p st i

t n d h 99 o . g aC o s c e

c Rb .m n c o ar o ec t ed s e n mE t e

i h R erS i t n n At do it p it w1 u s i

s d t

n a h So e la g la ru o9, u u r a g c Snn rC u u t c s hl e hi s r efo m n W o

l P e i lcin w e i fo8 T s ea u2 n si r t e

t o c n n hc q2 e a et la c o c op o0 5 9 sd na r n A t

n o t ce A t d 9 a o a it a

t aa k r f e v

em h e er t ny dfr o e1 ,

i om s D r e

i t c v h e I hg t r ob a d 3 t as n S ht c i r

t r d b 2R t n in do i

gn i v1 vt r n o N A

f i

n e s ei t 2 R ien t a no eio ol r i ee it c o r

u p rp l r t bsm f g b d lp vA sd ls o ui c a t e iS o ns eS er ia ia o t ca t ht a eA omo d r o v e RS t e s l

a ir e e celuc N t

cd l wfd n

ean r

i t

c l

y n a mA Rn d e yi lby b t

nc ay d

6 t

t e .

l a ic mt .

Ai ts t h dn a co l i

l J e i f oli cp Sd n s gu hc nv wte icb a P ir t

n i

n e Ls Sed sg n

e u o e t

e e a p a se f

idn 6i o

t e

o t e

o ig s

r nu omu ce n b sis ee r v i

sp l

gt e n o

r e

l p

C P r o

isC E

i x cn l

inbq n eo ivv ee co isb bo am is c rf e c

e p

o m it i r sh t t o t of a R r o w s :D FI oac n e RR da AC s P C e g n t s na sde e e

h  : len  : : ger t i

v e N:S r ot en t

r a N:S bio NS na i.

NisS ds i

e d n mks OU T r ui ao ea OU it sa OU ids . OsU I r T sl r.

R i f

ma TA el t r e er I

TA o e I TA T int lu r.

I TlaA yT e o o er CT o vo alu h p CT pr r o CT f

ose c i

CnT c N Cb AS Nes T s AS Ac AS Nr C AaS n

a r s u

s t

n s e A mA A O1 23A A A 0 A 01 000 uC c C CCCCC C 4 C C C CCCCC n

g oOL O 9999O O 0 O 1 O

99501 D k Ls 0000L L 0- LV &

4 Ls 88344 i

s ks i

2222 k kt C k 8 7781 2 e &a ay 5555

- - - - e a epu 3 aV 4- k is ay 44455 D e re ela r SSSSo r r n M ee r S ela SSSSS eB r BnA PPPP AAAA B BI S

Bod P r Bn PPPPP Ae e l l A- l A AAAAA la C l

sg g CCCCa l l a X C la - - - - -

r P CCCCC ir sa a EEEEm m m E m EEEEE l

yL 1

L SSSSS 2 S

3 S S S SSSSS a 4 n m m m m A t e t e t e t e

I I I I

t sn v s c r eosqus s e s i

o r

en e ee e e it ss3 wnu sa e g e mr l

a ne e r

h f r n r Q

u ehe t b n

on

. an r

o h

t t f

ot P ed n a n f

t o a y s f sOba o h c o

_ n oht t o ci t pt c f i

r a oaOoo e t t o ri n ea a sl Lt L c e c ew l

ke l e e i

t s f f c cf lc e st oaadf f h

r r eo t

a bna eif efe w l f e

f f

t n moh or i d o.

d n s eoo gs t a e uit Nev a hf f uo No ds h o t

e nai t a t m

l , uN p t e n t

rl eejL s N u aucl e t n n v r obms ai i e e e g

f c dl b e i

o e t t a r ie a ntsyntt dh c ta e

o r p c d o ic u D it e p f d n

h t n e it el vot aer e d t

a e

. m o r pbe ef n n n nh e i et ce f

d p o + d i

o c u d s e i g

_ n dg c e e a a t s a mtirdim uweas t a

i s

a iebn a d n o f m e i h R e s goa u n h e

l a opis n i d t sdnLbc o o t

t n e e a n ai h y glof oh ed i r

_ c n eis e s r g i m t

_ i n c s .

i e m n o t c r o e nc a )e d 8

d n

i v w e i i

t laea st e e .

d n h c ioa bsa i

v9 u e98 s r t

o c eht t sta b ,

l f r ne e a e t r o9 o r

9 n a n A d t noh d e8 o lu8 l

T lao e c r p1 f d1 o s -r e aeLt ed g r i

s9 c9 uf h D mh vehee e9 it in n9 P s n n e ag lcis is t , it t n

t n o3 a a3 a o S h it ddt dh m1 r u n i1 o

a c as ih lehn v a t t 1 w n1 h c N t r eeadnt i

t 9 ige t 9 o c b nil y oil r

e s o u t h aonef o f l f e ni l or ce a Wi s f i i t oi r t f t r ip c ir t

ap t sst L am e nl or c i n .o t aA n b o

d e r o f ep ob s i e lu A e esolsm m cs t

A g je rh N

t t sA aA on b d ot l d si

_ i u uy t is lcy t

n n t

t e st s uoi ssct ey a l uy S swo h u u .oeey

_ I

_ e cb s a b a e d bb np cb

_ v y er ar u (a t l a n cet ic m l

a e c s pL r r it ose l ae nt e t

l ci o l hp iidtr is gsiib t

i t

i e e c e f

i n m o e ee sr ct c l t

o ei e n wl g o r t eht ntI a t a e ep o

. i e t n

f ot t hi re f

e 7- i c e 2.bolunm n t w.s mlp wh el r e rd l

vE t

n imv is e psm 8ir um e t im s r

o t o ee mv fi d ot ee e eo r o R oso r

PlyC i

nr ou F eiu o c oo 3ub r y v eo ne n RC r a RC t pm DC RC

_ C P ee f

r e  : : p  : :

s g t s

n  :

a n:

ht capom mn .

r i

4t 6ne ad vc ed p n e  :

w NS a NS NaS i

r uo N:S 9gt NS ero ne sn e Sgt n e esm ip a

e OU T n OU d m Oe U OU Ase OU i

v hp op T d pe I

TA A I

TA T in f

m TsT I

uA Rmndsae i v i I TA T Toc c I TA T

e n sd 1 . a en ri CT AS 2

. CT AS N o

C o cat AcS Aoboi Sl r l Sfourphfo st h

CT N Na CT d t t AS C- AS e

c s ))))

5569 n

a t

n .

0538 3333

))

67 33 r e - - - - 22 u mA A 0 001 - 7 A 0 CCCC CC

- s uc SSSS

_ s cO C C6CCC8

- - - C C- G4OG SS GG A o t O 1 0 00 3 1 O 2 A RRRR

_ D LV & 8 4 7 77 4 89 99 06 -

LV k &

3 C

A Ce s AAAA AV C&

RR

_ n g &. k aV 4S444 -

aV 1

5- O Os SSSS OV AA SS S y SSSS i

s s. t e e r SPSS S P ee S L Ll a ((((

Le SS

((

e e r s~B do PAPP P A A- C-AA rd Bo P A-n o

nn oA 5507 702 nd oo 23 D AR C e A-A nC N N 1003 NC 34

_ CECC C S a C - - - -

6777 66

^

e.S gs-5 m ESEE S SSSEN S m E S

9999 AAAA 99 AA TT ne 6 TTTT-

- - 7 NN A m NNNN m o e CCCC e CC n

t t I s

l1il )!llI ;i g

f o e n e

  • e d h n e

s t it a ic s h a

. ~

n n r f w

t n s e

i e ioDo r

s s l t

n i t u

d u s d d t

_ e e ,S n e e p s

. a t n g t n

t n e m e r

s e

e v

e r e s ee N s

Wi e h s n n a xu a a m i m d g o u g e oC f on e a i s t s l p h I f

e e c a f f

H ehi ogs lp r e l

a m wT cne m p d f t

y t s

i e s rO st it a6

. e s n o

f e

i g u s ee0 sr4 e f l

a n iq eG e u o t c o u i r n nnd f o W p1 e eto-8 J q

e s e N Q e h ignt i e r y n e c n oc t

laha9 fr i

u n n e eie e r i n

o ig t t e ap ut h) cntR t e e o i

t a n n hmx i n s p h i e a lahCA o t o t t

u nor e t l t

n f H u ciPC t it u r p d l o a w a (td u n o efnts e t e s s y lo ei l t ho roec st lo e r a e m

u it s wtasu t s r o s r i

l e ) nf ue e n f m

s t

c b ehe Cedqp o t n

o a h t b t r reex ht e e e D e w mn gn AsfRe F yi r w t

c e 8 r

ud lt P m d

n h

T lo eio st Keens o f de er C u c

a .

la l

buc Whvol ETn iu t t

lla f

e 99 c /u D o l d o tod o refe r cs odo .

1 oc f d

a c o nt e pa e f N se .eAe t eN 9

, r e pR o

d i

g o cu e o es dmbevn t

nt o c e n n n y i

ch n it u l

i et cr r

u a a h t lat r a wre a etotio t

c r r p r o s c r e s f Rsn et lat o P cu o n

l r s oi Wo Ay P e v esv Osyer ce8 n t lc C n T e lac t r ned 9 8 r v of 9 f

n Ac s D98 o

t n b cer ieA nn 9

1 BgaCe Snh f 9 1 Mcnbeo i

e r r a d 9 i a o e r aig o ,

S i

pd n o , er tri n e w n1 t

c i c t s ho t enN 9 (i pn i N7 l h olai o t oht e a7 f

be nil s r ade t t s r r A i n

g r

a e

i ndo so oeh i t

or p eo df ms,sRp i

r ndua iol cl u eu nf h e nl oir ip e i S

p . l t t

st aA o ot seeAA ilso ac i o

t f

t aA v ps isar l c

t arscl a l i ri sdrCy deN r uy l i y aeit t ee ad eeec t

n .uy t

c l si d d en pa l cb t e ta yd o b t

d dh i .

e scb as ae l

d n n ud r el a u r s at e hg nt e i

e r i t e r o N. hug p

a "l e C at -vtalosdt ueh Get pyct e r n u c net uB n inle t

e e obe i it a p e r o plawl o e u eb s r eop u el se upl a nep C

t q lus no r a c dc o s upm obv o

on s s o i

s e c et v ei smo o aim 1 t P 0l n et hy e no Rve v R wa nie et t Nde 0ai Tar R C= eRCo I

osRC t

w e e n Cfcce t

o ne e tm t ,i t

o e:R  : C t 1

2 lb o h n  :

est a 8h: : n he1  : 2:

i v a i t

Oo n ss e u N:S r r aerTNS ssNS NS ta:S nl ereN Sye

w. mO UT e q e. O U dO U t i e p c ead e t u T

i OT U myIO U 0lid t

R e A i r I eaI T T e er I

r. "s TA I

r c o 0af u n e mfi n dTA r

e ETA TA mteTA e c N

1 1Qc o hp Oe CT haio oCT hpCT r CT ofaCT Ch c A Ts t AS TdcmAS TsAS AS CsAS n

a r ))

u s 98 t

n 09 s e 22 s -

A m CC u SS -

n g

c o

t n GG- -

t n

1 0 t 5 e Av RR e n 1 i

s D Ca AA 0- e 0-m mtu C mt e & n Ov SS n n u C3 O

D e e

i t

a Le nd SS

[I ip tan S- ip an M oo n i t A n r -

11 0 n i S o NC 36 o 0 o s C 56 C 1 C C i

s 99 1 P y AA _

l S 9 _

a T T- m ._

n NN e m A CC e l t e _

I

!j1 l i;'

.I  !)

I l_gl)!I!)1 r

.a l a n r

a yaN

- .ht o e r.

i t w e r t w e ie w s

e goCWi e ey d n sb e i

c Nr v

e r ev i

e

.ue enden so epe t

e ethe r ht e s pd u m w tyhah e l

y as r r e ne sr snc u t e

e bt t

r i

l t

eee hr ped eo h s de edor a t u dss sube 1

u

~

ere d

a mdo nh Q n aren e aw v e r f r

o mu et a

n e pehs p r em t o l t b so s poh e i p

i t bn s g r a aeel t sct c _

vue n aey t

n e

nmass o

hmheie tsts i

wrs b a

s eidt sW eta s ^r r t i m ux nI et uK t

c u une:a qo a s:_ in l

oe w to O.tnsA yeef D

o s c e' - f e

t ne

.t n re mr od d

iel t

ethre' =

h ow i op cool unnr e n ef y- rf i t

t ca e

. t a or o iu _

a hog r pe er l

b ic pd tc ta o _

s ses ign ec a l

a n f

  • e a f _

dn n enef iR r f o enSi f _

  • e _

i c a eb Ur m o r o s vkieein f

r n

n oboeo r

h r

pl ad Te n N de a e a eNvi a c su aOte u89 r wwv dc t

e Slca s Ld os a l

P T l

k hih dA n ^

TUc seo eht i n1 o c9 o st pd ar oe i

o -

Oirhesnt d s o9 l

d t

or n co i

l u th t t -

Lamgs t n nr d sh l

c - d ebr us ni r a op iKs ou F A  ;-

e hnteoe i d e d

i t

ao

<. hrd a A e t

.g t l e

v t

n e

2igtsnnda l y t

n b a W AW1 4," uN l

i y d.

n eoe odl ve ub c

e m

t p

e ue% ad l c .

t c l l

s s

s reEbt e

. l a^

u t c sh K t ce e

r i

t a n r

ios vf e .de c e 7- do c m c a KtW wha a de t

i n 6e edh Oluh ReTRos eu s At eo o

l o e 6a 0rn h d is T- l n 1i deh m n suA6.0sa l

C t

o v + e l 5n e nt v o e o ReC P 5a I

3s e w n 0o huf RC w 9- c. :eC 0mp r e 7i t Too 9 a t r n f 2 e A <n naO es NS ra o d t: s n NS 2

i v Rg e msk 9id eL 7t OU cc A naio e C ei e I T s t R ewt a OU No ma eRer ol e aAsif TA l u a C+e mdi mti fc T T I

R CN CerrbChev CT se o Nh i

CT A

e t AS R n CT Cav o ne r AS c

n a

r t s

u n e

s n s e O A u S 3 7 R1 ct 3 6 3 n on t n 260 t n 1 t n 1 5 g Den es 2 9 5 es 7- eV 7

)

0-i s &n s mis ny 9- mis 9 0- m&

nV H97 e ei a

.l aan TA B

iny aa l

A ie ad 2

9A D st i OR tn n R t AR Aon nA no s

C o C-C oA C- oC RC sC NN C N C C-N

_ l e o CC C NC l

v i 1

C 1

a n m i n

A o o n e l

la - lb s0e u -

a e0v Q t p s6e n e aPw o o l eAo h it a a e r e h;

n tn 0 t t is s n ei6 0

s e d l t

m e p

d ndeAP u el.t u o e s d u c psu n e os o le e o r cer D

v e dl ee n e d eds o h no t

d n

a es mou it r nr t

c e

.nt eic a o .f d se e ef nf l

i l

a c e uef c y dmdoe et i

]

id i f Gl e it n

i n f t

e oaia nsficNo r u sb i o a h a e di f G et raN l c e s to h oi t 8 s 8 P T e dr t

msu 9 s s re Ui n 9

9 n t h eoej 9 y e1 n

t sf by n1 Us infit o d n o d ,

a ud ,

nn i0u i

t c n a del da i8 t

S ee g 1 c i f , omut ou lal upr i

N vd sr l

i A hr i

n n A ig i le ef oho T st o r p t

g b o sh lc A e e i S a it a meei r t a

cy I

n e sA e pd w v n T od uy i y o ic ht on e b [ i eb t l s f oco 8 ta iu c l a a d ir e

t h et 3 G he e i t e e r v r nta is o r t

el e 2- it n r s t t ele d n e

r s

i u ,

f nhev ni tot sp 3 irl t p a

o t r

a q 2s 4 e oate n imv 9- r ose dm C o e e 0s y i t

icoo eo A sU po P p R af RC Rn UC 7l cini t w 9na p

e s ra C- oin r

a n i f  : :  : :

e o -

Aa it s v ru NS  ! it g u n NS i

v - i t

Rlla uef ieg OU O ai OU c jdi if M ch e e A Cr e r n TI T T T I

R n o o Nv ooeo NCVc CA R oo t

A N AS T T- NN CT e N CO - - - E - - AS c

n a s 6

t r n u

s e

8 s m O 3 u R- 27 2 ]e A cl oan t s 423k s

n DieV c 1

7 l

a c s e 009

- - G u

g 0- s

& nm&

ig oi 77 99 As i

s e

o nVi 7

9- oDs y - R eloae lo it el a AACW D md it d Aao cn o A

R ids a A n RRI -

CCOS N sRC C- Rf f -

NN MA O RM CCT(

i s N l

y C21 a E n m A t e

I

II e

  • s r

h t

de f o

ew ve e s

i l i e n

? e gev h o u nr t n d s lof e i

t s e o a d t c

h e .

d a n i -

y

- t a

t r e e p R e N

t d h n v x A i r

p e e o= o o e S u

l b mh i

t c s .t s S o a ma a r e w Q o i

t cev t dkt n

p e

t s s cu ht n o c c n n a eor n o U

e c

a aa o wde t i

d d

c t

s rf eo m e run opo e s n t nn t

c r e

i d

t en bio ts e d

eit c le h e

m e l nae l

f e t c

u p o oa t t t

uh s t ainf f r b

r e e n rde f

o le dnee O a f

D v Cet o d d e iim f

du nl u ocn 9 hn t

a ht N n e oco 7oc e de a t 6 t if r u

l

]

e s a md ci eo 4 gn hi t a f e

a c

g a c bn eo f t f

l Aoi ue r e d i

n k y ed Sr s p o n c t e dd ot e m a h a f lun Nad Ctho e m

d .o l

P c

e s P a s h oa ,

p Ed N t eC T s n e sen 8 Sie e r n t n t n o u 9 n na 8 v i2 o

t n e e it a

ht e d d o e 01 9 i t c 9

9 it a u2 q

i e m m r d o b 0 p n1 v e v.

u e as t

c c n ct o l 68 o r e

r e

M m o m o ig a en l

iPl cxw i9 NR A

e n

g t c

t c

f n

o n o

ht s ad

. war nr p i

e,h t

l i al ur s

n o 2R n c cp hawn v

i S n C i t ooA lei c vA a a t

a u i f y h l a A e eS i

t c

i i f

c d

ic N A

c t i so f t

adb bwa cy r o RS e

i n e f

i n d e T t

n e

lt h et r,sa t i nla _

t ps eb m Rn d

^

g h g k

I v

f e v^ e n he a Ai ie ew is u i

s T r _

cio t t Sd o u [ ,

v n m ure" ct e Sed o p o q 0 s .

ala el d e

ewi o n e f

s op C

A N e N e 3 e s caa e r u l

vm s nu w

T - R - n 0 - y voa t os D n C- ala c

eo u i xcn l

le n le n 3 l a Hdn sc RC: s l e :i:o o a 9- n - i FI 4 b s b n s e nc 2 t t i

v a de a uc D a .

Nt S en

y  :

e t

p t p T i l

a e em mpm OlaU me t NS l a N:S e A e A S-I uT O TU n OU R c o c o r

e mto o TcA um I TA a I T e Ac N A c N N C

v o Cirse ooc ClaT AcS co o e CT h e TA CT c Dg AS T AS n

a r

u t e

s n s e ]

8 A m u s e 0 e g g 0 0 g O0 n o 2 5 0 d n n g c la o

l a D 4

0- a l 8 l 3eP i l

o i

lo CC -

n h CC i

D ic c cs 0 a e a v 0 .

o o 1 3 o o m 83 s g gsmm i 7 ie gs 7- 3 6 7 85 e & o oyoo 9- oy 9-ogv 9":. C Ct 5 0 Cs 55 1 2 D e e

l o loaR l

A oa l l R in A

R l

oe u m n npu 4 5-I S mly - -

r a SS r

i d mnaAlro d C- aA C-id do r

e eI n AP en PP A

R a R N R RaC m"L- T T g

SA TA AA e t n N NC g n C-C g - -

CC l

e o C C CN n o EE n

_ y C 3 A o SS o EE l

a 1 T I

L 4L 1

5L 1

SS T

n m (

m A e e m t

I t t e

i i

a mieh e e t st T nsil dei s u -

ufin t

d u u eebt n Q s st o n

cr o ea dvt i

lc n is dho e Wptph cs al t u i s

o e i n ecae adae r e

i e er t o e t negtoter r V t

a h h d n e e r n ar n t

t

,ya t

n b t t

n e rb g s t os moadcfoo hioe i

h a

e vnm t e gf udcis2c f t

I_

y o nl t ds3e t

m u ewa wog s d s u aenre oanf f m c

r e 0 a s r hki a on bmeiwr a mto ist oe o r C- h e r i

f n

n r n e an D ,s d o 3 An e n eft od r o

d leitc 6 1v o t

a ot o it e sdaVc C n bae t t c 0 et u ad e i Refc

,f a ah rr e 5- q t et f .

t pt o f e nsh eat egs a eoi n n o

l ani o l

f a e l

A d Af mwn l

c ee cdi n c 7 e a r i t

o S- us i ck os a co e i

n n a N do is clt se ci a ebat o c a C e mh h i l c e

t E Mo N. . e 2

3 oui dsid t pcN i f

i r

P bT/ e 8 9 S C t 8 n ei l

er buoc l nif e n , T 1 t

e 9 t n A o9 o hf oaph oie v eel n9 t t

en t a p l o n a

e n1 o 9 R n1 is r

t aya sd s a n

oe c i

t c

r i mio t T

/ o 9 ,

e hc cnlo ia e i c i f it t tho t ai lr ua A i

t V t aoivg f r

A i la nd l cd R ai l P dut t n o n

g uie up da oli B

l up M r eqeta2a f e le cA desn 3h v

i S b lcds l ay e v O l cA U ndaen c d e

a aevi gf C ay R eac mioe i

y t cse cb a o cb s t

c l p d e ur e ht e k s Wr e T mwtsus a r u

e l

a e c e r hse ci am t

o ht e O moec oht ew r

3 cehD oVfo r i c i pb t e N t r

t n a u d' ad el sp Pi l f t e elp e 3

n o q r edc a . h ics f

e e e y gl ou ). im nd e s im o r u etyt o

_ C t P

o r a R rhhm e v eo ia t

on t t

le v

eo n

o ic sl if f i

s f

RC a inma r oic wf s a s t r w t n r dy e RC it a

t i

ol t e e e n 0 ie otn g'  :  : i c l

a a a s t tt sr f cr ap Vt vmea e 6 NS  :

n r a i

v e m A

c eamd i

OU Vuq e NS OU e eegops nn nf se Nu u r r T ee le m mmidah Oe eg cupa

- I c TA T p R

I o hd r u o h io a CT Ta A TA c mupdsh e t Td I

ce D N Tdd(g AS - -

CT AS D o oo c a Cdmdarui nt w Ca AiS s n s ar t

n .

u e n n s

s msg '

1 00 0 g 0 s

t o o it n

o uinc n e 00 A cl i o olo CCC

- - - C- il o

C -

t n taC nA CC it t

a 00000 CCCCC 226 08 - -

n g- D CC& o oV n 2 e - - - - -

551 o 5 eR 37 63 eP2 7901 4 V 1 1 9 6 554 C 1 m mT 00 mM3 33444

- - - 4 V u i

s e &mm s e SSSl -

m&

5-S c u/

cA 55- - cuUn 88888 44444 oRi o r r - - - - -

eeed PPPA r eV o oR l S l

SSSSS D r A TTo AAAS T P A- D DB AP SA Dtrs PPPPP s

g gC - - -

CCCC g . eO - - eOe AAAAA son on r

EEE E n C r a aC CC rNV a

i SSS S 8L o E wW EE CCCCC yL L S w 7f t SS 8f t w EEEEE SSSSS l t 1

a f o 1 o 1 o n

A m e s mS mS t

i t I

t l

o f

e.

t a e u

l q b

. a e

e e t p

t d t a e a a u c u q c q is e a e 8 d s d a a 1 a is n is w n o d a 3 3 is 2 e r 4 l

n e n w

P o V o e

i v

n s i

P s

s e o r e A- r e

r s

i t V N v P'

c P A c A M R ih C

  • U T t

o D e R F G e v T O h i

t L W t c O d f d r d

f o

e N e o e f o e n r f k n k n k o r o u o u o u o n q e it q it q it a

C io R t a

n e

R a e t n

R t

t a n e w t m

e n e n m e n m o m o e i e k u d u lp v m t

c c c c dc e u A o A o m R c d d A i

^

o E o o e e D h A N R

A N h T

c n

a r ~

u s n n n l

a s e io o2 s A

t a 00 t a 78 a 4 i t o t

n CC6

- - 8 t 9 9t nno 46 1 2 p n eP 3 490 - 78 ne 1 03 1 00r 5 o d d 4 g 78 6 1 ei 01 e 721 1 39028 M0681

- - i2 mM 3 66 9 9 6mrs 1 1 70 mN 87 68 P

- t a 22 1 222 9- u e 4 4 55555 i

s uU n c 55 94 uA 99 99

- - e) sl e e oRi o A A gP P EE EEEEEEEEEE APSScV l cR -

R D DTO ser SS A PoF Po DA nC C EE EEEEEEEEEE e PPS AA AD C sLO TA A DIC

- TR RRaD SC C Ch( DA GG

- - GGGGGGGGG r NV - - E eH C WW - - - - - - - -

a w

CCA War EES w NA-art CS Sa N NwO NN EE C CC AAn O

L GG WWWWWWWWW GGGGGGGGG t

f SS t f t G SSg o o f i s

S S SoW e D ,

_

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20237E816&oldid=3221769"