ML20236Y263
| ML20236Y263 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley |
| Issue date: | 08/07/1998 |
| From: | Baker E NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Cross J DUQUESNE LIGHT CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9808120034 | |
| Download: ML20236Y263 (9) | |
Text
.
August 7, 1998 Mr. J. E. Cross Frosident-Generation Group
. Duquesne Light Company (7)',
Post Office Box 4 Shippingport, Pa 15077
Dear Mr. Cross:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Boykan of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC concoming Beaver Valley. The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996,1997 and the first seven months of 1998. You may notice changes from statistics previously reported.
The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropriate.
If either you or Mr. Boykan have any questions conceming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, j
hMDY Edward T. Baker, til i
Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page DISTRIBUTION:
File Center /Public -
EBaker CMohrwinkel FMiraglia -
BBoger -
- DBrinkman
\\'
DVito, RI
{
WHohl, RI To recahe a copy of this document, indicate in the box I
C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E= Copy with attachment / enclosure d
N = No copy 7.
l DOCUMENT NAME: BValley T
NRR_ J EBak 8 /f/98
/ 198
/ /98
/ /98
/ /98 OFFICIAL FILE COPY r.,- - n:).,. - m C* SYN l
ff-/S ~
\\g, v A u
)
, q c) s.# "g 9808120034 990907
?
i PDR ADOCK 05000334 l
P PDR
{
pm Mro p
t UNITED STATES
.?
E NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION D
f WASHINGTON. D.C. 20086-0001
%,v..../
August 7, 1998 Mr. J. E. Cross President - Generation Group Duquesne 1.ight Company Post Office Box 4 Shippingport, Pa 15077
Dear Mr. Cross:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Boykan cf your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC conceming Beaver Valley, The attached tables provide a comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996,1997 and the first seven months of 1998. You may notice changes from statistics previously reported.
The software used to count allegations has been revised to avoid " double counting" allegations that are transferred from one NRC organization to another. Additionally, the data is audited for accuracy and corrections are made as appropriate.
If either you or Mr. Boykan have any questions concoming the data, you can reach me at (301) 415-8529.
Sincerely, f O2w Edward T. Baker,111 Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated cc w/ attachments: see next page l
O i
J. E. Cross Beaver Valley Power Station, Units 1 & 2 Duquesne Light Company cc:
Jay E. Silberg, Esquire Bureau of Radiation Protection Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Pennsylvania Department of 2300 N Street, NW.
Environmental Resources Washington, DC 20037 ATTN: Michael P. Murphy Post Office Box 2063 Ditector-Safety and Licensing Harrisburg, PA 17120 Department (BV-A)
Duquesne Light Company Mayor of the Borrough of Beaver Valley Power Station Shippingport PO Box 4 Post Office Box 3 Shippingport, PA 15077 Shippingport, PA 15077 Commissioner Roy M. Smith Regional Administrator, Region I West Virginia Department of Labor U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Building 3, Room 319 475 Allendale Road Capitol Complex King of Prussia, PA 19406 Charleston, WVA 25305 Resident inspector Director, Utilities Department U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Public Utilities Commission Post Office Dox 298 180 East Broad Street Shippingport, PA 15077 Columbus, OH 43266-0573 Director, Pennsylvania Emergency Duquesne Light Company Management Agency Beaver Valley Power Station Post Office Box 3321 PO Box 4 Harrisburg, PA 17105-3321 Shippingport, PA 15077
{
ATTN: S. C. Jain, Vice President
' Ohio EPA-DERR Nuclear Services (BV-A)
ATTN: L A. Clayton Post Office Sox 1049 Mr. J. A. Hultz, Manager Columbus, OH 43266-0149 Projects & Support Services First Energy Dr. Judith Johnsrud 76 South Main Street National Energy Come...
Akron, OH 44308 Sierra Club i
433 Oriando Avenue
' State College, PA 16803 Duquesne Light Company Beaver Valley Power Station PO Box 4 Shippingport, PA 15077 ATTN: R. L. Grand, Division Vice President, Nuclear Operations Group and Plant Manager (BV-SOSB-7)
I ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31/98 8/3/98 Site
!1993l1994l1995l199611997I1998 MILLSTONE 42!
45' 46: 72 74l 30 ST LUCIE 4'
11l 21] 46 69l 23 DIABLO CANYON 12 13l 16! 22
- 18) 18 NINE MILE POINT 10 7~
111 12 8l 14 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 13 22 20! 43 20! 12 COOK 6l 10 4!
3l 6! 12 BROWNS FERRY
- 39) 15 13! 23l 20i 11 VERMONT YANKEE 3!
2 51 9:
4! 11 BRUNSWICK 25l 11 7i 8,
26i 10 i
l WOLF CREEK 6! 12 6! 13! 20 10 INDIAN POINT 2 6!
1 6I 6'
11 10 TURKEY POINT 13!
9 12!
16' 19.
9 l
BYRON 3;
8!
4!
5l 11 9
LASALLE 5'
15 7j 9! 11 9
SAN ONOFRE 13! 16 30l 37l 33, 8
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8:
6 14! 18: 23:
8 1
DRESDEN 12! 13! 12i Ill 20:
8 QUAD CITIES 5l 9l 7j 12l 13!
8 SUSOUEHANNA 8
8!
8!
34' 24i 7
3 15! 11l 14 19!
7
_ COOPER 12l 20l:
CLINTON
! 18:
8' 33' 6
WATTS BAR 69: 64 50: 28] 14 6
SOUTH TEXAS 38 21 1 51 25! 11 6
l HARRIS 2
4 3'
2!
3 6
OCONEE 1
4!
Il 8
21 6
bYSTAL RIVER 5
3 6_
211 20; 5
INDIAN POINT 3 i 25i 14! 11l 6: 15i 5
SEQUOYAH 31l 7l 19 27; 13 5
POINT BEACH 11 4
3 4; 10 5
ARKANSAS 4!
4!
7i 2
7, 5
GRAND GULF 3:
2; 2:
9 4i 5
HATCH 4!
8 6
4' 17!
4 COMANCHE PEAK 19.
5 14' 19' 13 4
WATERFORD Si 3
16! 21i 11l 4
OYSTER CREEK 9
3' 5
4' 10 4
FORT CALHOUN 7i 4'
4:
4! 10 4
RIVER BEND 21l 12! 21} 1 71 8
4 SEABROOK 4'
5l 3
6 4'
4 PALO VERDE 40l 23: 18: 22l 19:
3 PERRY 8'
7i 2,
10 9;
3 CATAW8A 3'
7i 2:
5!
8 3
DAVIS-8 ESSE 10' 10:
2! 11i 6'
3 PEACH BOTTOM 6'
B 3
4!
E!
3 i
CALLAWAY 5:
2; 51 7,
4; 3
MCGUIRE I
8; 3
4!
3; 3
PILGRIM 19l S
8l Si 2!
3 i
bRAIDWOOD 3:
11 3i 9-16' 2
LIMERICK 1 61 12 4!
Sl 9'
2 BEAVER VALLEY 9!
7i 7j 5!
8!
2 FITZPATRICK 8
3!
7l 5
Sl 2
DUANE ARNOLD 2l 21 3'
3 2
PALISADES 5!
6:
8:
5 3'
2 VOGTLE 7j 11! til 6
11l 1
FERMI 9
19l 8;'
18' 8'
1 CALVERT CLIFFS 6;
71 8
7' 6i 1
THREE MILE ISLAND 41 2
il 1
4!
1 ROBINSON 4'
2 3:
1 2!
1 MONTICELLO 21 i
6 2i 1
FARLEY 1
2 3!
6!
2!
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 4
2i 3
7j 5!
NORTH ANNA 1 21 21 8'
4' 3'
SUMMER 2;
3' 2'
9' 2
Pe9e 1
2 -
ALLE2ATIONS RECEIVED - MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31/98 8/3/98 he l1993[1994I1995l1996l1997(1993 SURRY 5!
5?
3-3:
1 KEWAUNEE 1
3 3j j
GINNA 3
g 3
43 3
\\
l 1
I E
G Pap 2
1 DZCRIMINATION ALLE!ATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO LEAST CY98 7/31/98 8/3/98 a
m I
\\
She 19931994l1996 l1996l1997l1998 MILL 3 TONE 11 15 12 26 23; 4
-I SUSOUEHANNA-2 1
1 2j 4
-SALEM / MOPE CREEK 3<
6 7
10 Si 3
CLINTON 2
3 6}
2 OUAD CITIES 1
2 31 2
POINT BEACH 1
1 1
2 2
DIA_BLO CANYON 1
2 1
F 2
2 DsANE ARNOLD 1
1 2
BRUNSWICK 6
1 1
3 6
1 PALO VERDE 14 11 4
2 2
1 INDIAN POINT 3 3
3 6
1 2
1 COOPER _
-6 2
1 OYSTER CREEK
_1 2
1 1
1 COMANCHE PEAK 1
1 3
1 1
SEAVER VALLEY 4
1 1
1 NINE MILE POINT 2
1 4
1 1
1 TURKEY POINT 4
2 1
1 ST LUCIE 2
3 1
1 1
MCDUIRE 4
1 VERMONT YANKEE 2
1 HARRi$
1 1
INDIAN POINT 2 3,
1 1
SAN ONOFRE 6
4, 3i 6!
61 BRAIDWOOO di il 2!
4i BROWNS FERRY 4:
4!
Si d'
4; WATTS BAR 18; 18 16!
61 di WASHINGTON NUCLEAR d'
i e'
2-!
4!
DRESDEN I
3
}
1 26 3
PERRY 2;
2; 1
3 3
WOLF CREEK i
1 1
1 3
SOUTH TEXAS 16; 7i 6
7i 3
LASALLE 21 3'
2i LIMERICK 2
1 26 COOK 3
1 1
1 2l WATERFORD 21 6
7 2!
PILGRIM 2
2 2!
2!
SEQUOYAH 11 2
3' 6
21 THREE MILE ISLAND 1
DAVIS-BESSE 2!
1 1
1 CALLAWAY 11 1
1 1
1 VOGTLE 4:
1 OCONEE 1
1 1
PEACH BOTTOM 1
2i 1
1 PALISADES 1
Il 1
FERMI -
4 3i 3
4 1
FORT CALHOUN 2
l 2
1 1
FIT 7 PATRICK 2'
1 1
tuRRY 1
CatYSTAL RIVER 2
1 4
3 ARKANSAS 1
3t SUMMER 1
NORTH ANNA 1
1 HATCH 1
GRAND GULF 1
1 BYRON 1
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
SEASROOK 1
ROBINSON 3
l CALVERT CLIFFS Il 34 3
PeDe 1 u___
ALLE0AT.5DNS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED 7/31/98 8/3/98 Site 1993 '1994 l1995I1996l1997l1998 ARKANSAS 1
1 4
2 Sl 1
BEAVER VALLEY 1
3 1
3l BRAIDWOOL, 1
6' 2
3 4}
2 BROWNS FERRY 14 8
5 7
4!
1 BRUNSWICK 10, 6
5 5
ISI 1
BYRON l
1 2
3i 5
2 CALLAWAY 3!
3 3'
CALVERT CLIFFS 3'
1 1
4.
CATAWBA 1
Si 1
2, 3
CLINTON 4
SI 5
9! 15 3
COMANCHE PEAK 7
3i 4
6!
6 COOK 2
6' 21 21 6
COOPER 2
5 7
7 7
1 CRYSTAL RIVER 1
2 4
12 5
DAVIS-BESSE 2
4 1
2 DIABLO CANYON 1
8:
8 6
8 2
DRESDEN 7
5 6
5 10!
1 DUANE ARNOLD 2
1 1
2l FARLEY 1
2 21 1
FERMI 5
5 1
81 21 FITZPATRICK 2
3:
FORT CALHOUN 1
2 2!
2 4
GINNA 1!
2 1
GRAND GULF 1
2j 3l 1
HARRIS 11 1!
1!
2 HATCH i
2 3
2; 2
10 1
INDIAN POINT 2 i
2!
l 2!
3!
4!
3 INDIAN POINT 3 10!
4l 2i 1
2i KEWAUNEE il I
l 1
i LASALLE 2i 6'
5 2
di i
i LIMERICK 7'
4 1
4 21 1
MCGUIRE 1
1 1
il MILLSTONE 14 4
5 11 7;
1 MONTICELLO 2!
I I
11 NINE MILE POINT II 2i 3:
1 4
1 NORTH ANNA 21 1
2i 2!
1 OCONEE l
2) i 2i 1
2 OYSTER CREEK 2'
1!
3!
i 2
PAllSADES 1
21 2!
21 Il PALO VERDE 5
9!
8' 9
Bi PEACH BOTTOM 1
21 1
2 PERRY 2
3; 1
3 1
PILGRIM 4
11 1
Il POINT BEACH 3i 2:
2i 6
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1l l
2!
2!
OUAD CITIES 1
Si 3l 4I 7l 1
SILVER BEND 11 6'
9l 4
6' 1
ROBINSON 2
1 1
1 1
1 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3 11 71 12 5
1 SAN ONOFRE 1
8: 12 9,
11 SEABROOK 1
1 II 1
SEQUOYAH 71 1
8 11l 7I SOUTH TEXAS 16I 9
6 9
7 ST LUCIE 1
2!
13' 26! 31 5
l SUMMER 1
1 6l SURRY 4
1 1
1 SUSQUEHANNA 3,
2 1
18 11 THREE MILE ISLAND 1l 1
2 TURKEY POINT 71 4
5!
6:
9 1
1 VERMONT YANKEE 2i 1
2!
Il 21 2
VOGTLE 2
4 3!
5!
3 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4
4 7i 6'
6' Page 1 lL- - -
e 6-e ALLE7ATONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED 7/31/98 8/3/98 e
e Site ll199311994l19951996l1997I1998 WATERFORD 3!
2! 11 7
2{
1 WATTS SAR 33} 29! 16 11 4j 1
WOLF CREEK SI 7i il 6
Si 2
4 l
l I
i l
l i
t
?
?
i i
i l
1 Pa9e 2
e.. +
5 OPEN ALLE"ATIONS. MOST TO LEAST. 7/31r;5 8/3/98 9
- e 1995119961997I1998 l Total 1
Site MILLSTONE 2
12 6
12 31 l
]
DIABLO CANYON 1
1 15 17 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 1
3 1
9 14 1
WATTS BAR 2
4 3
4 13 1
BRUNSWICK 1
5 6
12 ST LUCIE 1
10 11 TURKEY POINT 1
8-9 COOK 1
2 5
8 BROWNS FERRY 1
2 5
8 DRESDEN 1
1 6
8 SAN ONOFRE 2
6 8
PkRRY 2
3 1
6 POINT BEACH -
2 4
6 QUAO CITIES 1
1 4
6 SEQUOYAH 2'
1 3
6 COOPER 1
El 6
WOLF CREEK 1
4 5
$USQUEHANNA 1
4 5
VERMONT YANKEE 5
5 1
PILGRIM 2
3:
5 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 1
4'l 5
GRAND GULF BI 5
HATCH 1
4l 5
INDIAN POINT 2 1
4!
5_
INDIAN POINT 3 1
1 2
4 8YRON 4
4 CLINTON 2
2!
4 FORT CALHOUN di 4
SEABROOK 1
3' 4
NINE MILE POINT 1
3i 4
LASALLE 4!
4 OYSTER CREEK 11 1
2i 4
SOUTH TEXAS 1
3 4
CRYSTAL RIVER 3-l 3
DAVIS-BESSE 1
21 3
CALLAWAY 3i 3
OCONEE 3'
3 DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 11 3
ARKANSAS 3'
3 HARRIS 3
3 PALISADES 1
2l 3
PALO VERDE 3:
3 MONTICELLO 1
Il 2
CALVERT CLIFFS 21 2
FITZPATRICK 2
2 RIVER BEND 2
2 PEACH BOTTOM 2
2 VOGTLE 1
1 2
COMANCHE PEAK 2
2 WATERFORD 2
2 CATAWBA 1
1 2
BEAVER VALLEY 1
1 FERMI 1
1 KEWAUNEE 1
1 MCGUIRE 1
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
1 SUMMER 1
1 LIMERICK 1
1 l
Page1 I
t'
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ - _ - - - - - - -