ML20236Y183

Forwards 870803 Gtices Program Rept Describing Problem W/ Gtstrudl Program.Rept Sent to All Svc Bureaus Offering Gtstrudl as Well as All safety-related Licensees Who Use Program

ML20236Y183
Person / Time
Site:	Neely Research Reactor
Issue date:	11/24/1987
From:	Will K Neely Research Reactor, ATLANTA, GA
To:	Belisle G NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
References
NUDOCS 8712110161
Download: ML20236Y183 (10)

Text

y v e

j

. k '%

.o kf **_

(\M"jf' GEORGIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ,

bM! ATL ANT A, GEORGI A 3033 2

{

l GT4CES SYSTEMS LANORATORY n g ! rj g , p}e*] i4 4) 894*

CCNOO6. OF CIVIL ENGINEERING O l.o s, v -

i.o43......

November 24, 1987 i

Mr. George Belisle Quality Assurance Program  !

Nuclear Regulatory Agency 101 Marietta St. N.W.

Suite 2900 Atlanta, CA 30323

Dear Mr. Belisle:

Mr. Mel Shanon contactea me on 20 November 1987 and requested information regar. ding a reported problem with the GTSTRUDL program.

Please find enclosed the GTICES Program' Report (GPR) dated 3 August 1987 which describes this error. This GPR was sent to all service bureaus which offer GTSTRUDL as well as all safety related licensees of GTSTRUDL who use the program on their own computers.

Should you need further information, please feel f ree to contact me or Dr. Lawrence F. Kahn.

Sincerely, GTICES Systems Laboratory

/h l Kenneth M. Will, Ph.D.

Director, ASD KMW/mlo Enclosure xc: L.F. Kahn, Director, Professional Services C. Lee, Manager, Configuration Control L.Z. Emkin, Director, GTISL B712110161 871124 PDR ADOCK 05000160 p PDR A UNIT CF THE UNIVERSITY SYSTEM OF GEORGI A AN EQU AL EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY INSTITUTION y L______ _ --

GTICES PROGRAM REPORT FORM DATE: 8 /87 FROM: GTICES SYSTEMS LABORATORY GEORGIA INSTITUTE OF TECilN0 LOGY ATLANTA, GEORGIA 30332-0355 TYPE OF NOTIFICATION:

[ ] DOCUMENTATION [ [ PROGRAM EXECUTION [ ] PROGRAM USAGE TIPS DATE PROBLEM CONFIRMED 8[g/87 DATE NOTIFICATION SENT p/ T/T7 J)/l l/

M N APCM, e s COMPUTER Sudh N ,J34 GTICES PRODUCT gy ,,,4,fg OPER. SYSTEM 4// NAME 675NE VERSION 4g Mg NUMBER /"Ey.of DESCRIPION:

(_ GTICES BASIC SYSTEM VERSION A//

.5~ee a//acke/ Skeef es;fYbc/ "E/Yg ik ZX S S

' l1 Signhture

,kSD Title A/76 7 Typed Name Da t e' I

(PRF - 10/85) 1

' I

_ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ i

i, .

f A

, d ee l

. l E ,l .!

GEOR GI A INSTITUTE _OF TECHNOLOGY '

~

3

\ ATLANTA, GEORGI A 30332 1

sticEs systems Lamonarony August 3, 1987 g,,,,,,, ]

tcMoot oF CIVib ENGINEERING l404) 894-3360 R R.

ERROR IN IX, TUBES i An error was' discovered in the properties for the torsional con-stant, I X ,' for structural tubes in the "AISCTUBE" and " TUBE 80" s tee l tables. Attached are tables which tabulate the NEW (correct) and OLD (incorrect) IX properties for the structural tube profiles in'the "AISCTUBE" and " TUBE 80" tables. The error significantly influenced the IX properties for the smaller tube profiles. This error could cause a redistribution of force within structural models which require IX,such as space frames. Dynamic analysis frequencies, mode shapes and forces could also change as a result of a change in stiffness-in the structure due to an incorrect IX.

Designs using these tubes could also be affected due to the change in force distribution. Also, the IX property is used in the computation of warping stresses in the NF1'7 steel code (section 2.2.5.10.5.4'of the

, GTSTRUDL User's Manual).

We consider this error to be serious since analysis and design results may be affected. We are in the process of correcting the l STRUDAT file which contains these properties. In the meantime, users may create their own tables.to evaluate the' significance of this errrr. ,

' Should users wish. to create their own tables and use the corrected IX  !

properties, we urge them ' to contact their GTSTRUDL Technical Support representative.

l l

I l

l

\ -

A UNIT OF THE UNIVERSITY SYSTEM OF GEORGIA

', 'f l, f

• 8 3gy i

e y

n; 1 1'

F o l l o w i n 'f ,f ..#dr e 'c he cowarison values >jf ff X f o r- table AISCTUBE. 6'g ? ,

j j , AN. t l

PROFILE NEW IX OLD

$ _.__________ _ ___1 < I X. _ _ _ . - f,)

C, _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ..,

., s . , . ,

TS10101Ci ,

531.,35870 539'. % 'Q ,

TS10108 '

r' 442.43594 451330000l3 s[

!343.95105 3".5/ )OOy 0 T TSlo

'111Qio5 to.N[ 291,39o38 30q 000'io 7 ,

T9 0104 ' t

236.'79001 O OrN G; ) , /,

TSh61C3 1801.3445-1 N)923dJbou '

TSOy t 257.12408 262.00000 TS8( h *g/- 217.64448 225. Ch;OOO TF8X8X6 171.49001 '

179.00000 g[)

146.12662 154.00000 '

TSe;'O TS8'(1445 J(( 119.35719 128.00000 T9dX.Xi?: 9t.27084 101.00000 ,

TS7p q 141.30798 147.00000 ,(,  !

TS7X7X6 ,. 112.,57247 120.00000 9 i

TS7X7X5 / 96.3o356. A 104.00000 TS7X7X4 ' .

79.0295"f y$ .. R6100000 v I f.

TS7Y7X3+ s>?' 6 0. 6483 f_ / 5 .~ 6fr f, 00000 c l TS6X6X3 4

-1 /

86.02560 i, 91.00000 s ,J > j TS6X6X6 \

, ,.9.02190

75. OOorp L g*y,( w ; j TS6X6X5 a 6 59.31485 3 66.00000 , ',.

\ ,,

TS6X6X4 N, 48.84643 ,, SS MOOCO <q .

4 TS6X6X3 37.c,4870 44.00000 '

'y .

f: 1 i TS5X5X8 -

g 46.36523 51 4 00i(< ,

l TS5X5X6 '

48.39'735 43.0WOOK '>' f  ;

I '

TS5X5XS 'IC 28603 +

38.00000" p TS5X5X4 27.62397 ,

33. OOok.tk j1 9, ,

l TS5X5X3 21.43762 j ) s'2 7. OOrv th y .,, ')

TS4X4X8 21.64123 v 25.00000 1 r

> ' ,s

, ,v.

TS4X4X6 18.42190 t 22.00000 h * '

TS4X4XS TS4X4X4 16.21446 10.63396 20.00000 i

d'"4 N 1U.00000 s  ? l, TS4X4X3 10.4, ~'100 ,'tl.00000 r fi #

4 TS35354 ; &834 (%2,.%f 000 '

f' \ s {

TS35353 /

7.01:258 10,0000r.)

TS3X3X4 '

S.40148 8.g.000 r

s TS3X3X3 4.307"9 \

~'j . 00000 T?2X2X4 1. 39VM 3.00000 * '

TS2X2X3 1.16204 7.00000 ) '

"i "

TS12X3XS 409.65253 413.00000 ,e

i. '

TS12X8X6 714.71225 326.00000 ,

T'.12XPV5 ' /m' . . M-:6 9 7 278.00000 ,'k. 'b

~

TS12X8X4 21 7 '%on 20000 v T912XRX: ' A . %916 , ,

/ 'Q77

> 229 )\ 40000'.; , / h' TS12X6XR d l . e,SV t '

M' . C OOO(A, '

C

TC12X6X6 1i 1 1 f &,;: .QQ; . ifvp I s /

, j TS12X6X5 Ie < >6RO2 i 7 3 ,' C ';O O ,

i T f:.12 X 6 X 4 1:d W907 144.10[.3r? 3

'I i

lup'(.100: f4 mt2x6x3 w2.I m840 ,

i Tm y4 xe i 09. An24:- ...

1 17. N.5% F-

, 'l  !.

3~i -/

s ) I

( f, . / ' \  ; .. O.-

i t ( /

'f I ,  ?, t . ',

p

,, g

A.tSC 72/86 2 i.

. ' PROFILE ' NEW IX OLD IX 3

TS12X4X6 89.43'755 97.00000 ,

l' TS12X4X5 77.33929 86.00000 l TS12X4X4 64.04691 72.00000

, TS12X4X3 49.61189 59.00000

[ T S 12 X X 6 20.25959 27.00000

, TS12X2X5 18.39156 26.00000 h ,' )  ; TS12X2X4 15.91546 23.00000 gf , TS12X2X3 12.83036 20.00000

[ ,

T910X8X8 308.1793R 316.00000

'\, TG10XSX6 241.19540 250.00000 h' TS NX8X5 204.94252 215.00000 N TS10X8X4 166.97987 177.00000 l

TS10X8XS 127.40597 138.00000 s TS3.OX6XP 1G7.25243 195.00000 TS10X6X6 148.48473 156.00000

! .0 TR10X6XS 126.R8957 135.00000

s. TS1OX6X4 103.92571 112.00000

')

% 3 TS10x6X3 79.67365 09.00000 i 'j TS10X4X8 36.36060 92.00000 i , 'g z w , TS t r X4X A 70.66182 78.00000 i ^ TStOX4X5 61.2094'7 6R. ooh 00 TS10X4X4 50.75444 58.00000 TS10X4X3 39,34995 47 00000 TS10X2X/ 16.61984 23.00000

i. TSIOX2X5 15.00549 21.00000 I

TR10X2X4 12.93516 19.00000

( TS10X2X3 TSRX6X8 TS8X6XA 10.40190 134.53197 107.43362 17.00000 140.00000 114.00000

, T53X6X5 92 06400 99.00000

[/ s

' TR8X6X4

/

75.57934 83.00000

, 0".8X6X3 58.05495 65.00000

,3 TRAX 4XR 64.41827 69.00000 g J"j':'; X 4 X 6 52.,52715 59.00000 T?.*X4X5 45.46960 52.00000

,. TS8h4X4 37.70075 44.00000

' L' 2 TS8X4X3 29.24451 36.00000

\ TS8X3X8 35.77857 41.00000 it H8X3X6 30.12546 <:5.00000

)

g '

'":POX5 26.44269 32.00000 i

4

'W.3X3X4 22.20451 2R.00000

< ' T R8 X 'iX .i 17.42500 23.00000 Tc.8X2X6 12.65950 17.00000 T.9'::X2XS 11 47292 16.00000

. TS8X2X4 0.1537 15 00000

'- FSSX2X*  ? QRA06 1?.00000 l TG7X5XS 00. 7:270 A AS 00000 d

( T87?SX6 c. 4 .. .:607 71.00000 r97X5X5 55.6RO54 6;.00000 S

rR7X5X4 45.92452 S2.00000 fs ,', (FS7X5X3 35 4431? 42'.00000 1 42.;l2147 46.00000 i

,')RAX4YA f.s ~,

x

, 1

,% i G.

A.______.._ ___A.._

e-

.y'm- fi F, ._  !

l DG i W. 4/5U7tJBC: \

i 3 4 l

• PROFILE fEW IX OLD IX ,- 3 l TS6X4X6 34.84042 39.00000 l ff TS6X4X5 30.29664 ?S.00000 TS6X4X4 25.21537 j31.,00000 <

qu (i TS6X4X3 19.62053 ,25.00000 TS6X3X8 23.86629 27.00000 TS6X3X6 20.38235 25.00000 ,

TS6X3YS ,17.98000 22.()O000 t T36X3X4 .t5.15659 20.00000 {'

TS6X3X3 11,92875 16.00000 TS6X2X6 8.74210 12.00000

.TS6X2XS 7.97994 11.00000 i .

-TS6X2X4 ,c 6.93152 10.00000 TS6X2XS 5.60134 0 00000 TS5X3X8 18.09440 2i.00000

.TS5X3X6 15.66136 19.,00000 ,

T35X7X5 13.88164 '

i 17.000^0 TSW3X< '1.74621 15., 7d000 TS5X3X3 9.27204 13.00000 T35X2X4 5.40527 9.00000 TS5X2X3 ,4.42830 8.',IOOOO TS4X3X4 .8.47087

~

12.00000 TS4X3X3 6.69$95 10.00000 TS4X2X4 '4.06587 7.00000 TS4X2X3 3.28472 6.00000 ,

T53X2X4 2.67784 4.00000 TR9 X2 X:? 2.1R346 4.00000 1

, i

\ l

\

fi '

. ;\ l-

\

\

f

,/

i

< 1 l

t

/

4

~

/4 Followin<gn are the comParisch V4lHes of IX t' o r table TUDE80.

PROFILE NEW IX OLD IX TS161608 1896.32056 1913.00000 TS161606 1450.8123G 1469.00000 TS161605 1220.88635 1240.00000 TS141408 1255.76477 1270.00000 TS14140A 963.735'9 2 979 00000 TS141405 812.21692 828.00000 TS121208 77G.49707 ~790.00000 TS121206 600.00769 614.00000 TS121205 506.70660 521.00000 18121204 410.71381 425.00000 TS l o l O .10 531.30121 539.00007 TS101OOft 440.F.1715 450.00000 TS10J006 341.62942 352.00000 TS10t005 289,,95556 c:00.00000 TS 101 + >04 2':':.20596 247.00000 l TSOXRX10 J.'6 0 . [ 3 8 8 9 266.00000 i T *:.8 X ::: XG 217.32582 225.00000 j TARXGX6 170.60060 179.00000 I i

TSSXOX5 145.16382 153.00000 TS8XRX4 11 E:. 52003 128.00000 f 1RSXOX3 90.67577 100,00000 FS7X7X8 142.21349 149.00000 {

TR7X7X6 112.21729 119.00000 {

TS7X7XS c5.81521 103.00000 l r R 7 X 7 '4 4 7R.48530 96.00000 I C rf::7 X 7 Y 3 TS6X6X3 60.23346 96.4236R 68.00000 91.00000 I

Tf:6X6X6 60 02145 75.00000 fS6X6XE "o 13145 65.00000 TG6X6X4 40.65607 55.00000 T06X6X3 97.5004G 44.00000 TSSX5XE' 47.4568'7 51.00000 TS5X5X6  ::R. 46314 43.00000 TSSX5X5 13.23753 38.00000 TfNXSX4 27.53232 33.00000 T95X5X3 21.35134 27.00000 T' .4 X ZI XP 22.31406 25.00000 TS4X4X6 10,5925A 22.00000 TS4X4XS 16. 2' .RAC 20 00000 TR4X4X4 10.61411 17.00000 T':4X4XO 1 O. / A?54 14.00000 f 9"F?i355 10.G2645 1P.00000 rr :Krr54 . R83 4 12.00000 7 e cg ;qec 7. 01 pn 3o,00000 f r"'-: X :-4 X f-; '

. : 1 'P'M 4.00000 l T "~4 X R X il '~; 1014:2 #~

.:?0000 T::.c: X R X 3 4.':0759 7.00000 TS25254 '

96605 4.00000 T"25?53 . 4 0.'"7 5 4.00000 T'7,2X2X4 1, c:0 4 /. ' 00000

[_ .

7z)g PROFILE NEW IX OLD IX TS2X2X3 1.16204 3.00000 TS201208 1652.00305 1669.00000 TS201206 1266.02202 1285.00000 TS201205 1067.26099 1086.00000 TS20X8X8 308.38483 823.00000 TS20X8X6 626.08533 642.00000 T' 20X8X S 529.99896 546.00000 TS20X4X0 207.28195 219.00000 TS20X4X6 166.24994 180.00000 TS2OX4X5 143.111R9 157.00000 TS18X6X3 412.10031 424.00000 TS18X6X6 322.81323 337.00000 TR18X625 ?74.',760/2 2'89.00000 TS161200 1201.19946 1216.00000 Pr;161206 "22.63214 938.00000 I TS161205 777.09337 794.00000 TS16X8X:' 601.'34027 613.00000 i TS16X0X6 466.26865 480.00000 TS16XGX5 v 4. 91.'.4R 609.00000 i TS16X4XF 159.01907 169.00000 l T316X4X6 127.64232 138.00000 l T316X4XS 109.00452 121.00000 '

TS141OOP. '32.06073 744.00000 TS141006 564.09170 579.00000 l T':;14100F '77.45242 491.00000 TS14X6XP V7.97409 100.00000

( TS14X6X6 TS14X6XS TS14X6X4

_. 73975 199.05G04 162.671/;

245.00000

10.00000 174.00000 TS14X4XR 135. OE:397 143.00000 TR14Y4XA 108.50937 11G.00000 TS14X4XS 9..45426 104.00000 TS14X4x4 77.20319 ':8.00000 TS12X810 484.35004 492.00000 TR12X8XO 402.26651 412.00000 TS12XGX6 412.73776 324.00000 TS12X8X5 '65.19992 2'76.00000 TS12X8X4 21F..':2007 227.00000 TS12X6X8 242.222R9 250.00000 TS12X6X6 100.267R7 200.00000 TG12X6X5 162.13434 172.00000 TG12X6X4 432.56R11 143.00000 TS12X6X3 101.S708A 112.00000 TR12Y4X3 111.':5270 119.00000 T5:12,.4 X A '* S5200 o8.00000 TOJ2X4K5 7/ 16097 J:;5 00000

{

T912Y4X4 A'" . 7 /55 7 ".J. 0 0 0 0 0 T51;'X4X3 4'. ' '" 9 51 5.00000 rs12 X 2;; a 15.091nA T.00000 Ts 12',: 2 X:. : 12.32140 20.00000 ,

Tc;1 O Y '.m i87.OA40? 109.00000 )

T:::1 O X 6X 6 147./006'2 156.00000  !

i l

l 1

TO8C,'f3C) y

~ '

4 PROFILE NEW IX OLD IX TS10X6X5 126.15946 134.00000

() TS10X6X4 TS10X6X3 TS10;.4XG 103.25019 79.17638 G7.92424 113.00000 89.00000 94.00000 j TS10X4X6 70.G5270 78.00000 ]

TS10X4X5 61.09724 68.00000 j TS10X4X4 50.52405 58.00000 TS10X4X3 39.13033 47.00000 4 TS10X2X6 16.03183 2

'3.00000 l TS10X2X5 15.09631 21.00000 I T:::10X2X4 12.?5512 19.00000 TS10X2X3 10.3906:2 17.00000 j TS9X6XR 135.53391 142.00000 TSAX6X6 107.15128 114.00000 TS8X6XS 91.57223 99.00000 TOBX6X4 75.07497 .S2.00000 TT'3 X 6 X 3 57.66451 65.00000 ,

TSGX4Xn 64.,97399 70.00000 j TS8X4X6 52.55554 ";9.00000 j T93X4XS 45.08RSA 52.00000 {

TROX4X4 37.58377 44.00000 T' ," X 4 X 3 29.14179 36.00000 T 9 X 3 X o  ::0. 2~/73R 35.00000 <

TSGX3XS 26.46'755 32.00000 {

TS8X3Y4 22.16770 "'A.00000 I TS8X3X3 17.37414 23.00000 j T98X2XA 12.87251 17.00000 j TS3X2XS 11.'4660 1 6 ., 0 0 0 0 0 i

1Rsx2x4 0.9en69 15.00n00  !

TSGX2X3 7.97764 1:"' 00000 )

TG7X5XR 30.771";8 G5.00000  !

TS7X5X6 64.62100 71.00000 T R7 X"i'(5 F;5. 52485 62.00000 TS7X5X4 45.75300 52.00000 TS7X5X3 35.31198 42.00000 TS*X4X6 49.63482 49.00000 TS7X4XS 37.73417 43.00000 FS7X4X4 ll.20209 37.00000 rS7X4X3 24.20065 30.00000 TS7X3X6 25.37060 30.00000 TS7X3XS 22.21291 27.00000 FS7X3X4 18.623?A 24.00000 TS7X0X3 14.60R48 20.00000 T'~:6 X 4 X O 4 7. '7:4541 47.00000 l F56X4X6 P4.'/353A 19,.00000 I r$6X4X5 an 27244 35.00000 1 TcAX4X4 /5.141/.A 31.00000 T R '. x 4 X :- 1'P 9a611 25.00000 TRAXRXA 310.,55810 25.0n000 l TR6X3X5 tA.02847 92.00000 TN6XOX4 15,1 ?r/56 20.00000 T36X3X3 11.89174 1A.000nn 1

e

~ TudG90 o,

.a, 4

~ ~

PROFILE NEW IX OLD IX TS6X2X6 G.95571 12.00000 i j TS6X2X5 R.07737 11.00000 TS6X2X4 6.95954 10.00000 TS6X2X3 5.59700 9.00000 TS5X3X8 1A.76881 22.00000 TS5X3X6 15.35087 19.00000 TF.5X3XM 13.94444 17.00000 TS5X3X4 11.74150 15.00000  ;

TS5X3X3 9.24379 13.00000  !

T$5X2X5 6.36063 9.00000 '

TS5X2X4 5.49527 9.00000 TS5Y2X3 4.42330 C.00000 (84X3XS 10.01126 12.00000 TS4Y3X4 A.47037 12.00000 TS4X3X3 6.69695 10.00000 T94X2XS 4 67749: 7.00000 l TG4X2X4 4.06007 7.00000 ]

TS4X2X3 3.28472 6.00000 l T93X2X4 2.67784 4.00000 j TS3X2X3 2.18346 4.00000 I i

l

(

I a

\

l l

6 h _ _ _ _