ML20236D977
| ML20236D977 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/28/1987 |
| From: | Merschoff E Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Rodgers M U.S. TOOL & DIE, INC. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20236D980 | List: |
| References | |
| REF-QA-99901082 NUDOCS 8707310165 | |
| Download: ML20236D977 (4) | |
Text
,
e ff o
UNITED STATES g
g g
g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
/
r, y
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 f
July 28, 1987 Docket No. 99901082/87-01 U.S. Tool and Die, Incorporated ATTN: Mr. Michael J. Rodgers President 4030 Route 8 j
Allison Park, Pennsylvania 15101 Gentlemen:
~-
Thank you for your letter dated June 9, 1987, wnich described tbo corrective action U.S. Tool and Die, Incorporated (UST&D) has and will implement in response to the Notice of Violation and Items of Nonconformance identified in Inspection Report No. 99901082/87-01, dated May 12, 1987. Your respcose and corrective action for Notice of Violation 87-01-02, and Items of Nonconformance 87-01-04, 87-01-05, 87-01-07, 87-01-08, 87-01-09, 87-01-10, and 87-01-12 appear to be adequate and no additional information is requested. The following items, however, require additional information to determine the adequacy of the UST&D response and corrective action.
Part a) of the response to Notice of Violation 87-01-01 states that after receipt of commercial grade material at UST&D and dedication to the specific basic component by UST&D, the reporting requirements of 10 CFR 21 are in effect. This is in accordance with 10 CFR 21.3(c-1). Please provide a description of UST&D's dedication process that is used to upgrade comercial grade products for use as basic cou1ponents and a sample of the documentation implementing the dedica-
)
tion process for P0s 86-60802, -81208, -61112, -70103, -61218, -60921, 87-70132,
-70115, -70118, -70130, and -70208. For part b) of that response, please provide pertinent sections of the project specifications which address the applicability of 10 CFR 21 to P0s 82-1051, -1032, and 86-6020. Part c) states that 10 CFR 21-
)
is imposed on page 2 of P0 83-1387 to Sandvik. Please provide a copy of P0 85-1387.
)
It should be noted that the NRC has not taken a position on the Atomic Industrial Forum's Committee Position Paper, " Recommended Practices for Procurement of f
Replacement / Spare Parts for Nuclear Power Plants." Also, in addition to imposing 10 CFR 21 on UST&D, customers impose ASME Code Section III, Subsection NF and
(
10 CFR 50, Aopendix B in their P0s and specifications. UST&D must comply with 10 CFR 21 whenever a specification unique to the nuclear industry (e.g., ASME Section III; 10 CFR 50, Ippendix B; 10 CFR 21; etc.) is invoked in the customer's P0.
The response to Item of Nonconformance 87-01-03 states that in-process examinations not performed at the South Shop were performed at the North Shop prior to installa-tion of the cells into the final rack assembly.
Please provide assurance that the types of in-process exams performed at the North Shop met the requirements of " Production Work Routing and Inspection Plan," Drawing 8601-D, and Procedure 14.1.
8707310165 870728
'n j
PDR GA999 ENVUSTD (FI 99901082 PDR
4, U.S. Tool and Die, Incorporated July 28, 1987 The response to Item of Nonconformance 87-01-06 is incomplete in that P0 82-1068 to Capitol Pipe and Steel and P0 86-81208 to West Penn Laco were not addressed in the response.
It was stated in part a) of the response' that Cromie Machine follows UST&D's QA/QC program. Please provide assurance of this and what controls are implewnted to ensure the UST&D QA/QC program is being followed at Cromie Machine. Part e) of the response states that "Q" on P0s to Alloy Oxygen implies imposition of their QA/QC program on that P0. Please provide assurance that the individual issuing the P0 acknowledges what special notations are required on certain P0s which impose QA/QC programs. C of Cs and CMTRs document the final products acceptability, however, this type of q
documentation does not ensure the implementation of a QA/QC program.
For part f), please provide assurance that QA/QC programs were implemented at Columbia Electric Manufacturing and Do All Pittsburgh and these types of manufacturers have QA/QC programs in place.
The response to Item of Nonconformance 87-01-11 stated that Historic Data Records are available for Columbia Electric Manufacturing and Do All Pittsburgh; please provide these reports. A copy of the NRC position regarding audits of suppliers who offer calibration services for measuring and test equipment that they manufacture is enclosed for your information.
One final note on the response to Item of Nonconformance 87-01-13, the training given to procurement personnel should include measures to ensure that the "no shippi.ng until audit is performed" clause is added to the P0 as needed.
1 If you have any questions concerning these requests for additional information, j
)
please contact Ms. Claudia Abbate at (301) 492-4776 or Mr. James Stone at (301) 492-9661.
i i
Sincerely, Ellis W. Mersch6f, Acting Chief Vendor Inspecti Branch Division of Reactor Inspection and Safeguards Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Enclosure:
As stat <>d q
i
lI;..
'L U.S. Tool and Die, Incorporated July 28, 1987 DISTRIBUTION:
RIDS Code IE:09 VIB Reading DRIS Reading JPartlow BGrimes EMerschoff
(
JStone CAbbate JConway l
'1 i
1 i
l
.. :...... O (L.. :............ :. _ _ _....... :............
- SC/VIB:DR S :ABC/VIB:DRIS:
0FC :VIB:DRIS NAtE :CAbbat
- JStone
- Etterschoff :
DATE :1/1N87 fl /11/87
- 7/2f/87 l
I d
l
U.S. Tool and Die, Int:orporated
-3 July 28, 1987 DISTRIBUTION:
W DS Code IE:09 \\ \\
VIB Reading DRIS Reading i
i JPartlow BGrimes EMerschoff JStone CAbbate JConway l
OFC :VIB:DRIS
- SC/VIB:DR4S :ABC/VIB:DRIS:
_____: _____________:____...p t__:____________: _______ ___:____________.____________.________
NAME : C Ab ba teh_ _ _h_ _ _ _ : J S to ne ' '_.._ : Elle rs c ho f f DATE :1/W87 d /11/87
- 7/2ff87