ML20236D248
| ML20236D248 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 09/24/1987 |
| From: | Williams C NRC OFFICE OF SPECIAL PROJECTS |
| To: | Warnick R NRC OFFICE OF SPECIAL PROJECTS |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20236D200 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8710280089 | |
| Download: ML20236D248 (4) | |
Text
J j
Attachment y
UNITED STATES o,,
/
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n
(
,N
' WASHINGTON, D C. 20655
%....*/
SEP 24196T MEMORANDUM FOR:
R. F. Warnick, Assistant Director for Inspection Programs Comanche Feuk Project Division Office of Special Projects FROM:
Cordell C. Williams, Technical Assistant Office of Special Projects
SUBJECT:
TUECO COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION - CONTROL AND RE3OLUTION OF ALL AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS COMPLIANCE ISSUES There are a number of ongoing issues and problems regarding the licensee's compliance with all of their commitments to the American Society of Mechanical Engineers Code requirements.
Significant issues in this regard are currently being addressed by the Chief (ASME) Boiler Inspector of the State of Texas.
There are a number of "open" NRC identified ASME compliance issues.
It is not clear if all of the NRC identified ASME issues have been discussed with the State of Texas Chief Engineer Inspector.
The purpose of this memorandum is to outline a proposal to seek resolution of these issues addressed by the licensee, the Chief Boiler Inspector State of Texas, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (OSP).
The proposed actions are as follows:
1.
NRC site staff with the assistance of others as appropriate is to identify all ASME compliance issues raised and documented by NRC staff as follows:
A.
Closed Issues Describe issue (short description)
How issue closed (short description)
B.
Open Issues Concerns Unresolved Violations Others (allegations, etc.)
8710280089 B71022 ADOCK05000gS PDR
'n
'q' (T).
j j
4 i
R F.-Warnick SEP 2 41987 i
. >q Each of the above(ASME issues identified by NRC will be presented to and' discussed in detail with the Chief
-]
Inspector and staff of the Texas Department of Labor and Standards and the appropriate ASME authorized nuclear n"
inspectors.
The purpose of this activity is to solicit their commentary and recommendations regarding the validity, significance, and resolution of.these NRC findings regarding the licensee's activities at thc' comanche Peak i
Steam Electric Station.
The comments and recommendations of the Chief Inspector State of Texas and staff regarding these issuei will significantly contribute to<the consideration a
- for NRC's close out of these issues.
NRC's closeout of each i
issue will be dependent on the acceptability of the licensee's responses and corrective actions, j
2.
To facilitate the control oflthese matters by all involved
)
parties the licensee (the owner) will be requested to
>h d establish and maintain a document that clearly and simply addresses all open-ASME code related concerns and(issues
- I identified by theilicensee, ASME code representatives, the C
(
,'r. Texas Department.cr Labor and standards.(ChiefiInspector),
.the Nuclear Regulatcry Commission, and! others.1 IdeaDy,.this.
a
, document could be in the form of a matrix identifying as' n
' minimum the following:
i 5"
1 i
'a.
A short description of the issue.
\\
i b.
The organization that identified theLissue.
e t 3 6
a i
c.
Date identified.
d.
Enforcement status (i.e., violation, unresolved item.,
devi'ation, open matter, allegation, conceri2).
y e.
Short description of planned coriactive action.
f.
ASME, State.of Texas, and NRC concurrence indicated.
g.
Estimated completion /closecut date.
h.
Current status (open), (in progress), or (closed).
The licensee (owner) should periodically (initially monthly)
update this document and provide copies to NRC and Texas Department of Labor and Standards.
I t'
R. F. Warnick
-!3 -
SEP 2 41987 4r
'/'
The-items and concerns-outlined above, represent a prorosed action.
'NRC (Cordell Williams)'has arranged to have. preliminary discussions with the, Chief-Inspector State of Texas regarding these matters on-September 25, 1987, at the Comanche Peak plant' site.
Discussions with the licensee's principal management will be arranged following further NRC Comanche Peakosite staff review and consideration.
C# <2. #fM-Cordell Williams, Technical Assistant Office of Special Projects l
m...c------_--
--z--
di4'l,.
,di.h0E
' < i),
o:7 f
c
%v 3.
- 1. :
?!A
' DISTRIBUTION:
',)
l
't; ik t
'[ [
jD6clieEI!Filest( 50-445f 446%39 l'
l NRC PDR
<j i
- LPDR-
' [j:
/' ra OSP Reading
/
5 y
..CPPD-LA.
-(
)-
CPPD' Reading;(HQf
- Site Reading
.q
.*CPRT Group S.Li
- SRI-OPS-
-4
.s :.
-
- SRI-CONST I
- [I)h.
AD for Projects
- MIS System, RIVE
- RSTS1 Operator, RIV RPB,#RIV
. _,! W RIV Docket File-i
- DWeiss, RM/ALF l
e er/JAxelrad'
. CIGrimer, x/-
PFMcKee
'.e
' g \\i. h...
. JLYrtis
'O' lAVietti-Cook' l
l(;
-MMalloy JMoore,-OGC-Gr
.JGilliland,.RIV b.
}.FMiraglia EJordan
-JPartlow BHayes.
j
/
- w/766 A
l 1
4