|
---|
Category:MEETING MINUTES & NOTES--CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20210P1611999-08-0404 August 1999 Summary of 990415 Meeting with Utils in Knoxville,Tn Re Status of Mark 3 Program Designed to Determine & Validate Submerged Structure Drag Loads of Newley Installed ECCS Strainers at Perry,Grand Gulf & Clinton Facilities ML20198G5501998-12-18018 December 1998 Summary of 981201-02 Workshop with Entergy Operations,Inc in Taft,La Re Licensing Processes,Licensing Submittals & Other Topics That May Affect Licensing Processes & Submittals. Copy of Slides Presented During Workshop Encl ML20155H3931998-11-0202 November 1998 Summary of 981007 Meeting with Util Re Review Status of Standard Quality Assurance Manual for All Util Sites.List of Meeting Attendees Encl ML20154C4771998-10-0202 October 1998 Summary of 980908 Meeting with Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co,Entergy Operations,Inc & Illinois Power Co Re Joint Effort to Propose TSs to Reduce Requirements on Secondary Containment Integrity During Refueling ML20151X0011998-09-10010 September 1998 Summary of 980827 Meeting W/Util to Discuss Status of Review of Std QA Manual.List of Attendees Encl ML20237E0271998-08-25025 August 1998 Summary of 980625 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc to Discuss Bulletin 96-003 Re Installation of ECCS Suction Strainer in Ninth Refueling Outage for Plant.List of Attendees & Licensee Handout ML20236M0501998-07-0808 July 1998 Summary of 980702 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc to Discuss Review Status of Std QA Manual for All Entergy Sites.List of Attendees Encl ML20236F8171998-06-24024 June 1998 Summary of 980331 Meeting W/Util to Brief NRC on Licensee Risk Mgt of Upcoming Ninth Refueling Outage.List of Attendees & Handouts Encl ML20217K5141998-04-24024 April 1998 Summary of 980416 Meeting W/Entergy Corp Re Standardization of site-specific Security Plans.List of Meeting Attendees & Agenda for Meeting Encl ML20217K3461998-04-24024 April 1998 Summary of 980401 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc Re Licensing Issues & Regulatory Performance Efficiencies.List of Attendees & Agenda for Meeting Encl ML20217F4811998-03-26026 March 1998 Summary of 980319 Meeting W/Licensee to Discuss Status of Development of Std QA Manual for All Entergy Sites.List of Attendees Encl ML20216C6471998-03-0505 March 1998 Summary of 980123 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc Re EP Changes Being Considered by Licensee.List of Meeting Attendees,Meeting Agenda & Info Provided by Licensee at Meeting in Handout Encl ML20203B5741998-02-11011 February 1998 Summary of 980122 Meeting W/Entergy in Rockville,Maryland Re Licensing Issues & Standardization of Licensing Documents. List of Meeting Attendees & Meeting Agenda Encl ML20212G8521997-10-29029 October 1997 Summary of 971022 Meeting W/Entergy Svcs,Inc Re Development & Implementation of Common or Std QAP for All Sites.List of Meeting Attendees & Viewgraphs Encl ML20217E0131997-09-29029 September 1997 Trip Rept of 970825-26 Visit to Plant,Unit 1 for Interviews in Preparation of Salp.Agenda for Interviews Encl ML20198R3481997-09-0404 September 1997 Trip Rept of 961121 Visit to GGNS to Discuss Implementation Methodologies Employed for Graded Aq in Procurement Area ML20141H3661997-07-17017 July 1997 Summary of 970710 Meeting W/Util to Discuss Licensee Emergency Plan Change 28.001-95 & to Determine If Change Reduces Effectiveness of Emergency Plan for Plant,Unit 1. List of Attendees,Agenda & Info Provided by Licensee Encl ML20137U1331997-04-10010 April 1997 Summary of 970325 Meeting W/Util in Clariborne County,Ms to Discuss Entergy Operations,Inc MOV Thrust Methodology Used for GL 95-07 for Plant.List of Attendees & Info Provided by NRC Staff Encl ML20137F2351997-03-24024 March 1997 Summary of 970207 Meeting W/Listed Attendees in Rockville,Md to Discuss Nuclear Energy Inst Concerns Re Graded Quality Assurance Activities W/Volunteer Plants ML20132D1421996-12-17017 December 1996 Summary of 960827 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Graded Quality Assurance Initiative at Facility.W/Attendees List, Summary of Licensee Presentation & Licensee Expert Panel Guidance Document ML20149M3611996-12-11011 December 1996 Summary of 96111 Meeting W/Licensee in Rockville,Md to Discuss Comments Developed in Response to NRC Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Financial Assurance Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Reactors.List of Attendees Encl ML20134N5661996-11-21021 November 1996 Summary of 961003 Meeting W/Licensee in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensee Upcoming Eighth Refueling Outage for Ggns,Unit 1 ML20134M6611996-11-21021 November 1996 Summary of 961114 Meeting W/Listed Licensees in Rockville,Md to Discuss Results of Self Assessment of Accuracy of Info in FSARs for Four Nuclear Reactor Sites.List of Attendees & Licensee Handout Encl ML20129G5261996-07-31031 July 1996 Summary of ACRS Plant Operations Subcommittee Meeting on 960521 to Review Proposed Rule on Shutdown Operations & Associated Reg Guide as Well as Studies on Shutdown Risk at Surry & Grand Gulf Nuclear Plants ML20059C4041993-12-27027 December 1993 Summary of 931206 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensee Proposed Changes to Security Plans for Plant,Units 1 & 2.List of Attendees Encl ML20058P4491993-12-15015 December 1993 Summary of 931206 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc in Rockville,Md Re 931021 Submittal of Proposed Alternative to 10CFR50.55a(f) & (g),10-Year Inservice Insp & Inservice Testing Update. List of Attendees Encl ML20058G3081993-11-19019 November 1993 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 93-43 on 931117 ML20056H5721993-08-0505 August 1993 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 93-28 on 930728 ML20217C5121991-07-0303 July 1991 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 91-12 on 910626 ML20062H4811990-11-28028 November 1990 Summary of 901023 Meeting W/Util Re Control Room Emergency Filtration Sys.Proposed Change to TS 3/4.7.2 & Handout Encl ML20056B4161990-08-17017 August 1990 Summary of 900615 Meeting W/Licensee at Site to Discuss Licensing Activities.List of Attendees,Meeting Agenda, Handout & Licensee Comments on Draft Safety Evaluation of Fire Protection Program Encl ML20247E3641989-09-0606 September 1989 Summary of 890717 Meeting W/Numarc,B&W Owners Group & Representatives of Lead Plants Re Status of STS Amends & Outstanding Issues Associated W/Lead Plant STS Submittals ML20244D8961989-06-12012 June 1989 Summary of 890518 Meeting W/Util Re Performance of Licensing Activities.Meetings Should Be Scheduled to Seek Means for Eliminating Weaknesses Identified by NRC ML20244C6441989-06-0909 June 1989 Summary of 890517 Meeting W/Seri in Rockville,Md Re Licensee Plans for Fuel Cycle 5,which Include Use of New Type of Fuel Assembly Developed by Advanced Nuclear Fuels Corp ML20247K0901989-05-23023 May 1989 Summary of 890517 Meeting W/Inpo Re Similarities & Differences Between Performance Indicator Programs.Detailed Discussion Encl ML20247K1011989-05-16016 May 1989 Summary of 890517 Meeting W/Inpo in Bethesda,Md Re Similarities & Differences Between INPO & NRC Performance Indicators ML20246L4791989-05-11011 May 1989 Summary of 890214 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Pipe Support Calculations.List of Attendees & Handouts Encl ML20247F8481989-05-11011 May 1989 Summary of 890214 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Proposed Alternate DHR Sys & Proposed Exceptions to Tech Spec 3.0.4. Agenda & Related Info Encl ML20196B5971988-12-0505 December 1988 Summary of 881116 Meeting W/Util to Brief Reviewers Re Request for Tech Spec Changes Per Generic Ltr 87-09 ML20195G0741988-11-15015 November 1988 Summarizes Discussions W/Licensee During CRGR 881102-03 Visit to Plant.Util Mgt Described Licensing History,Past SALP Records & Key Issues Which Resulted in Delays & Addl Costs.Util Rept of Visit to Foreign Reactors Encl.W/O Encl ML20206E3031988-11-15015 November 1988 Summary of 881110 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Design Criteria & Safety Aspects of Alternate DHR Sys.Attendance List & Viewgraphs Encl ML20206E6711988-11-15015 November 1988 Summary of 881101 Meeting W/Licensee at Site Re Potential Changes to Tech Specs Concerning Review of Fire Protection Program & New Auxiliary Hoist for Fuel Handling Platform Over Spent Fuel Pool ML20155H9771988-10-18018 October 1988 Summary of 880831 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Status of Leasing Activities & Schedule for Completion of Activities.Related Info,Including Meeting Agenda & List of Attendees Encl ML20245D8411988-09-28028 September 1988 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 88-38 on 880927 Re Events Which Occurred Since Last Meeting on 880920 ML20154E6161988-09-14014 September 1988 Summary of 880815 Meeting W/Util Re Plans for Third Refueling Outage.Major Activities During Outage Include: Chemical Cleaning of Standby Svc Water Sys,Low Pressure Turbine Insp & Inservice Insp of RCS ML20154E6511988-09-14014 September 1988 Summary of 880815 Meeting W/Util Re Potential Changes to Tech Specs.Other Actions Discussed Includes,Status of Completion of Conditions in Operating License & Actions Taken Re Problems Identified in Info Notices ML20153E4321988-09-0101 September 1988 Summary of 880728 Meeting W/Util on Licensing Actions Re Third Fuel Reload.List of Attendees & Viewgraphs Encl ML20151R5391988-08-0808 August 1988 Summary of 880623 Meeting W/Mark III Containment Hydrogen Control Owners Group Re Emergency Procedure Guidelines. Resolution of Issues Listed ML20151R7011988-08-0808 August 1988 Summary of 880614 & 15 Meetings W/Util Re Potential Changes to Tech Specs,Allowing Change in Operational Modes When Limiting Conditions for Operation Not Met.List of Participants & Potential Tech Spec Changes Encl ML20150E0241988-06-21021 June 1988 Summary of 880615 Meeting W/Utils Re Proposed Establishment & Licensing of Sys Energy Resource,Inc as Operators & Licensing Agent for Plants 1999-08-04
[Table view] Category:MEETING SUMMARIES-INTERNAL (NON-TRANSCRIPT)
MONTHYEARML20210P1611999-08-0404 August 1999 Summary of 990415 Meeting with Utils in Knoxville,Tn Re Status of Mark 3 Program Designed to Determine & Validate Submerged Structure Drag Loads of Newley Installed ECCS Strainers at Perry,Grand Gulf & Clinton Facilities ML20198G5501998-12-18018 December 1998 Summary of 981201-02 Workshop with Entergy Operations,Inc in Taft,La Re Licensing Processes,Licensing Submittals & Other Topics That May Affect Licensing Processes & Submittals. Copy of Slides Presented During Workshop Encl ML20155H3931998-11-0202 November 1998 Summary of 981007 Meeting with Util Re Review Status of Standard Quality Assurance Manual for All Util Sites.List of Meeting Attendees Encl ML20154C4771998-10-0202 October 1998 Summary of 980908 Meeting with Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co,Entergy Operations,Inc & Illinois Power Co Re Joint Effort to Propose TSs to Reduce Requirements on Secondary Containment Integrity During Refueling ML20151X0011998-09-10010 September 1998 Summary of 980827 Meeting W/Util to Discuss Status of Review of Std QA Manual.List of Attendees Encl ML20237E0271998-08-25025 August 1998 Summary of 980625 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc to Discuss Bulletin 96-003 Re Installation of ECCS Suction Strainer in Ninth Refueling Outage for Plant.List of Attendees & Licensee Handout ML20236M0501998-07-0808 July 1998 Summary of 980702 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc to Discuss Review Status of Std QA Manual for All Entergy Sites.List of Attendees Encl ML20236F8171998-06-24024 June 1998 Summary of 980331 Meeting W/Util to Brief NRC on Licensee Risk Mgt of Upcoming Ninth Refueling Outage.List of Attendees & Handouts Encl ML20217K3461998-04-24024 April 1998 Summary of 980401 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc Re Licensing Issues & Regulatory Performance Efficiencies.List of Attendees & Agenda for Meeting Encl ML20217K5141998-04-24024 April 1998 Summary of 980416 Meeting W/Entergy Corp Re Standardization of site-specific Security Plans.List of Meeting Attendees & Agenda for Meeting Encl ML20217F4811998-03-26026 March 1998 Summary of 980319 Meeting W/Licensee to Discuss Status of Development of Std QA Manual for All Entergy Sites.List of Attendees Encl ML20216C6471998-03-0505 March 1998 Summary of 980123 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc Re EP Changes Being Considered by Licensee.List of Meeting Attendees,Meeting Agenda & Info Provided by Licensee at Meeting in Handout Encl ML20203B5741998-02-11011 February 1998 Summary of 980122 Meeting W/Entergy in Rockville,Maryland Re Licensing Issues & Standardization of Licensing Documents. List of Meeting Attendees & Meeting Agenda Encl ML20212G8521997-10-29029 October 1997 Summary of 971022 Meeting W/Entergy Svcs,Inc Re Development & Implementation of Common or Std QAP for All Sites.List of Meeting Attendees & Viewgraphs Encl ML20141H3661997-07-17017 July 1997 Summary of 970710 Meeting W/Util to Discuss Licensee Emergency Plan Change 28.001-95 & to Determine If Change Reduces Effectiveness of Emergency Plan for Plant,Unit 1. List of Attendees,Agenda & Info Provided by Licensee Encl ML20137U1331997-04-10010 April 1997 Summary of 970325 Meeting W/Util in Clariborne County,Ms to Discuss Entergy Operations,Inc MOV Thrust Methodology Used for GL 95-07 for Plant.List of Attendees & Info Provided by NRC Staff Encl ML20137F2351997-03-24024 March 1997 Summary of 970207 Meeting W/Listed Attendees in Rockville,Md to Discuss Nuclear Energy Inst Concerns Re Graded Quality Assurance Activities W/Volunteer Plants ML20132D1421996-12-17017 December 1996 Summary of 960827 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Graded Quality Assurance Initiative at Facility.W/Attendees List, Summary of Licensee Presentation & Licensee Expert Panel Guidance Document ML20149M3611996-12-11011 December 1996 Summary of 96111 Meeting W/Licensee in Rockville,Md to Discuss Comments Developed in Response to NRC Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Financial Assurance Requirements for Decommissioning Nuclear Reactors.List of Attendees Encl ML20134N5661996-11-21021 November 1996 Summary of 961003 Meeting W/Licensee in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensee Upcoming Eighth Refueling Outage for Ggns,Unit 1 ML20134M6611996-11-21021 November 1996 Summary of 961114 Meeting W/Listed Licensees in Rockville,Md to Discuss Results of Self Assessment of Accuracy of Info in FSARs for Four Nuclear Reactor Sites.List of Attendees & Licensee Handout Encl ML20129G5261996-07-31031 July 1996 Summary of ACRS Plant Operations Subcommittee Meeting on 960521 to Review Proposed Rule on Shutdown Operations & Associated Reg Guide as Well as Studies on Shutdown Risk at Surry & Grand Gulf Nuclear Plants ML20059C4041993-12-27027 December 1993 Summary of 931206 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc in Rockville,Md to Discuss Licensee Proposed Changes to Security Plans for Plant,Units 1 & 2.List of Attendees Encl ML20058P4491993-12-15015 December 1993 Summary of 931206 Meeting W/Entergy Operations,Inc in Rockville,Md Re 931021 Submittal of Proposed Alternative to 10CFR50.55a(f) & (g),10-Year Inservice Insp & Inservice Testing Update. List of Attendees Encl ML20058G3081993-11-19019 November 1993 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 93-43 on 931117 ML20056H5721993-08-0505 August 1993 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 93-28 on 930728 ML20217C5121991-07-0303 July 1991 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 91-12 on 910626 ML20062H4811990-11-28028 November 1990 Summary of 901023 Meeting W/Util Re Control Room Emergency Filtration Sys.Proposed Change to TS 3/4.7.2 & Handout Encl ML20056B4161990-08-17017 August 1990 Summary of 900615 Meeting W/Licensee at Site to Discuss Licensing Activities.List of Attendees,Meeting Agenda, Handout & Licensee Comments on Draft Safety Evaluation of Fire Protection Program Encl ML20247E3641989-09-0606 September 1989 Summary of 890717 Meeting W/Numarc,B&W Owners Group & Representatives of Lead Plants Re Status of STS Amends & Outstanding Issues Associated W/Lead Plant STS Submittals ML20244D8961989-06-12012 June 1989 Summary of 890518 Meeting W/Util Re Performance of Licensing Activities.Meetings Should Be Scheduled to Seek Means for Eliminating Weaknesses Identified by NRC ML20244C6441989-06-0909 June 1989 Summary of 890517 Meeting W/Seri in Rockville,Md Re Licensee Plans for Fuel Cycle 5,which Include Use of New Type of Fuel Assembly Developed by Advanced Nuclear Fuels Corp ML20247K0901989-05-23023 May 1989 Summary of 890517 Meeting W/Inpo Re Similarities & Differences Between Performance Indicator Programs.Detailed Discussion Encl ML20247K1011989-05-16016 May 1989 Summary of 890517 Meeting W/Inpo in Bethesda,Md Re Similarities & Differences Between INPO & NRC Performance Indicators ML20247F8481989-05-11011 May 1989 Summary of 890214 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Proposed Alternate DHR Sys & Proposed Exceptions to Tech Spec 3.0.4. Agenda & Related Info Encl ML20246L4791989-05-11011 May 1989 Summary of 890214 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Pipe Support Calculations.List of Attendees & Handouts Encl ML20196B5971988-12-0505 December 1988 Summary of 881116 Meeting W/Util to Brief Reviewers Re Request for Tech Spec Changes Per Generic Ltr 87-09 ML20206E3031988-11-15015 November 1988 Summary of 881110 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Design Criteria & Safety Aspects of Alternate DHR Sys.Attendance List & Viewgraphs Encl ML20206E6711988-11-15015 November 1988 Summary of 881101 Meeting W/Licensee at Site Re Potential Changes to Tech Specs Concerning Review of Fire Protection Program & New Auxiliary Hoist for Fuel Handling Platform Over Spent Fuel Pool ML20155H9771988-10-18018 October 1988 Summary of 880831 Meeting W/Util in Rockville,Md Re Status of Leasing Activities & Schedule for Completion of Activities.Related Info,Including Meeting Agenda & List of Attendees Encl ML20245D8411988-09-28028 September 1988 Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 88-38 on 880927 Re Events Which Occurred Since Last Meeting on 880920 ML20154E6161988-09-14014 September 1988 Summary of 880815 Meeting W/Util Re Plans for Third Refueling Outage.Major Activities During Outage Include: Chemical Cleaning of Standby Svc Water Sys,Low Pressure Turbine Insp & Inservice Insp of RCS ML20154E6511988-09-14014 September 1988 Summary of 880815 Meeting W/Util Re Potential Changes to Tech Specs.Other Actions Discussed Includes,Status of Completion of Conditions in Operating License & Actions Taken Re Problems Identified in Info Notices ML20153E4321988-09-0101 September 1988 Summary of 880728 Meeting W/Util on Licensing Actions Re Third Fuel Reload.List of Attendees & Viewgraphs Encl ML20151R5391988-08-0808 August 1988 Summary of 880623 Meeting W/Mark III Containment Hydrogen Control Owners Group Re Emergency Procedure Guidelines. Resolution of Issues Listed ML20151R7011988-08-0808 August 1988 Summary of 880614 & 15 Meetings W/Util Re Potential Changes to Tech Specs,Allowing Change in Operational Modes When Limiting Conditions for Operation Not Met.List of Participants & Potential Tech Spec Changes Encl ML20150E0241988-06-21021 June 1988 Summary of 880615 Meeting W/Utils Re Proposed Establishment & Licensing of Sys Energy Resource,Inc as Operators & Licensing Agent for Plants ML20154S0341988-05-27027 May 1988 Summary of 880519 Meeting W/Middle South Utils Representatives Re Proposed Establishment & Licensing of Middle South Utils Nuclear Operating Co.Agenda Encl ML20154G8161988-05-17017 May 1988 Summary of 880510 Meeting W/Util Re Licensing Matters.Util Will Submit Commitment to Install GE Wide Range Monitor by Fourth Refueling Outage.List of Attendees Encl ML20149J9181988-02-19019 February 1988 Summary of 871202 Meeting to Brief Director & Assistant Director for Region II Reactors in NRR on Util Operations. Meeting Attendee & Handout Encl 1999-08-04
[Table view] |
Text
,,
if ,3--__N ~,
4d o &
Mp 'kg T October 15,:1987: ,
9 f,$ h; f.J ." t' 'T,y, W6 deket No. 50-416 DISTRIBUTION o6d9 h6m- L .
(
WNo ACUS (10)-
NRC & Local-PDRs:- 1
. System.Eneray Res'ources, Inc.-
i, PD22: Reading ~
p gd yh4 p M CENSEE: . 'E . J .
H.-Berkow c ,
FACILITY: Grand Gulf Nuclear Stationj,; Unit 1 L. Kintner ff ,
> :0GC-Bethesda M%K)7' '+ ,:e:.. .
SUMMARY
SUBJECT:
. OF SEPTEMBER 24,g987 MEETING E. ilordan -
REGARDING-REACTOR THERMAL lAND HYDRAULIC LIMITS NRC Participants-
! v % .8. Troskoski
- ', The. purpose: of the meeting was f o ~ discuss possible thermal hydraul.ic. stability f// L k MM tesis for the' end ~of the second fuel cycle and possible' reduced. minimum control:
,l .povsv ratio (MCPR)'marginsJfor the third fuel cycle. The licensee'was repre- t' w sented by.Y. Balas.<and.I. NJr. Participants for NRC were'L. Phillips and .
r; :L. Kintner. Enc 1 & re 1 1sla handout prepared by the licensee: Sheets 1~-13 h
3p
- concern potectini nydraulicisidbility tests and.use of the results' to enlarge
, , it% opefating region isthe' power-flow map; and Sheets 14-26 concern potential
% q~ " improvements in operating flexibility by refined analyses of MPCR and other R: thennal limits. Resulty of GGNS Unit 1 stability tests at the beginning of fueP cycle;(800) So. S are compared with RETRAN analysis results in Sheet 5 of' i u
'! I, Enclosure 1 showing tha,t !
for the range of decay ratios tested, RETRAN conser-O' vatively, predicts decay ratio.) The licensee estimates that the maximum achie-vable decay ratio. during 'cyclej was at mid-cycle (0.70) and. that the.~end of e
4 g 'dyc b (E00),dw ay ratio will be 0.65. The licensee expects the highest decay y i ratilfor anrehilibrium cwe. The staff commented that while the comparison.
of the GGNS UnitL 1 RETRAN eMpulation with 80C test. data 2 indicates the calcu-lation method 'is. reasonably accurate for low decay ratios, a calculation bench mark fodecay ratios ~ equal to oCgreater than'0.8. should.be obtained because previous calculation methnds have'shown large inaccuracies for high decay ratios. ; A' submittal.requestYng expansion of the operating region in the low coolant ficw reghte should iricluda analysis for flows close to those of test point No. 6 and for an. equilibrium ~ core. In addition, calculation of the worst case core. decay ratios at' the intersection of the natural circulation flow and rod block line would be required.. Any extension of the allowable power-flow
- operating region without stability monitoring would need to be .iustified based on calculation results. Approval of the claimed RETRAN uncertainty for predic- -l tion of Grand Gulf core stah111ty will require a description of the model and 1 appropriate benchmarking to plant measurements.
A tape of plant data.obtained during mid-cycle operation at low flow-high power
-conditions has been provided to ORNL for use in LAPVR benchmarking and for Jossible use in support of future applications for changes to the allowable
. HQrating conditions.in Technical Specifications. It is anticipated that addi- j E- '
th4t1 p pes will be obtained for high decay ratio operating conditions near 16e:end of cycle. Such tapes icill also be provided to ORNL.
j
, j q q
~ ,- l
-ih '
1 t
{
)
l r, G710220451
,PDR 871025 t t ADOCK 05000416 1
[r,.P pg t
g .
, / /,
't
d
^'
-?.
The calculated MCPR and MAPFAC factors based on new analyses are shown on- I Sheets 25 and 26, respectively. Operating limits with the recirculation pumps. d in automatic control (auto flux) and manual control show a large margin is available when using the manual control mode. ,
The licensee said it planned to submit requests for improved thermal. hydraulic l stability and MCPR operating limits with appropriate . justification and bases in the first quarter of 1988.
Lester L. Kintner, Project Manager Project Directorate II-2 Division of Reactor Proiects-1/II
Enclosure:
As stated ,
cc w/ enclosures:
See next page P: DII-? 0;Nff22
) LA:PDII-2 DMiller LKintner:bg H8erifow 10/1j/87 10// /87 10/pf/87 l
.] ... .R
! o- *
( ,
Mr. Oliver D. Kingsley,.Jr.
System Energy Resources, Inc. Grand Gulf Nuclear Station (GGNS) l- 'CC '
L -Mr. Ted H. Cloninger Mr. C. R. Hutchinson Vice President, Nuclear Engineering GGNS General Manager.
and Support. System Energy Resources, Inc.
System Energy Resources, Inc. Post Office Box 756 Post Office Rox 23054 Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150 Jackson, Mississippi 39005 Robert R. McGehee- Esquire
, The Honorable William J. Guste Jr. !
Wise, Carter, Child, Steen and Caraway Attorney General P.O. Box 651 Department of Justice Jackson, Mississippi 3UO5 State of Louisiana Raton Rouge, Louisiana 7080a' Nicholas S. Reynolds, Esquire
. Bishop. Liberman, Cook, Purcell Office of the Governor and Reynolds State of Mississippi I?00 17th Street, N.W. Jackson, Mississippi 39201 Washington, D. C. 20036 Attorney General Mr. Ralph T. Lally Gartin Building Manager of Quality. Assurance Jackson, Mississippi 39?05 Middle South Utilities System Services,'Inc.
P.O. Box 61000 Mr. Jack McMillan, Director New Orleans, Louisiana 70161 Division of Solid Waste Management ,
Mississippi Department of Natural !
Mr. John G. Cesare Resources Director, Nuclear Licensing and Safety Bureau of Pollution Control System Energy Resources, Inc. Post Office Box 10385 P.O. Box 23054 Jackson, Mississippi 39?09 Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Alton B. Cobb, M.D.
Mr. R. W. Jackson, Pro.iect Engineer State Health Officer Bechtel Power Corporation State Board of Health )
15740 Shady Grove Road P.O. Box 1700 1 Gaithersburg, Maryland 20877-1454 Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Mr. Ross C. Butcher President Senior Resident Inspector Claiborne County Board of Supervisors U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150 Route 2, Box 399 Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150 Regional Administrator, Region II U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 101 Marietta Street, N.W., Suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia 303?3 l j
Mr. James E. Cross l GGNS Site Director !
System Energy Resources, Inc. i P.O. Box 756 Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150 1
g .
ENCL 9SURE!
. ..,4 EOC2 STABILITY TEST.
Supportina Information Estimated maximum ~~ achievable DR during' Cycle 2:
Cycle Exposure- Max DR BOC 0.60 MOC 0.70 EOC* 0.65 ,
100% rod line 39% core flow line LHGR 5 LHGR limit Rated equilibrium Xe J14 MISC 87092104 - 5 /
j r __.a..____...__:.__.
/ .;
-l I
GRAND GULF CORE STABILITY
.\
ANALYTICAL-CONSIDERATIONS j
.i
'o' 'B002 Test Results k l
Methodology Deficiencies / Uncertainties-4
-*' RETRAN Methodology
' - GGNS Unit 1 Cycle 2 Results
- GGNS Unit 1 Equilibrium Cycle Approach ;
i i
- : Methodology Uncertainties ;
1 i
i
-l 3
i J14 MISC 87092104 - 1
]- --
l GG B o c .L 4sc4 fe , a (+ .,
- /3'/ 8, s kbi l.1 3 4rsk rs cu I k s nF Coe np/pr
'& 4/e L l1 ii Il Test Information I' Decay Ratioi l l l l ORNL Noise ll l l Core ll Analysis lll ll Test i Power l Flow ll Best l ll Point I (4) l (%) l Estimate i Rantre lll ll l 1 ll l ll l l 11 I ll I ,
ll 0 l 100 1 103 ll 0.18 1 0.11-0.22 ll 11 I I li I I :
1I I I II I Il l1 1 l 52 1 39 ll 0.31 l 0.25-0.37 l !
II l l 11 1 I II I i 11 I il ll 2 l 62 l 45 ll 0.32 l 0.27-0.37 'l 11 1 I il I i ll l l ll l lll ll 4 l 59 l 39 ll 0.32 l 0.31-0.33ll 11 1 I il l I II I I II I !!
ll 6 1 44 l 27 ll 0.35 l 0.26-0.40gl 11 l I ll l I 11 1 I 11 1 II ooo h. - s.h u m: h r.k.s oi, f ow e v-F tua A S .\ fue < D,W.L u A<.k 4
3
I i .
l * '
, Core fle MI6
. I 11 22 33 45 56 67 ?l M 101 112
{
I P uer
- 33 93 . . .
344) 0 P
, 80 - -
30H e c 70 -
2H3 8
}H ,7 4/
1m l 54 -
i i -
[ 1r' -
1916e' P
e 48 ' -
1533'
'r 34 f ,- - !!49 y j 7g 20 .
.i A- llotural Circulation I L a $ ted i Mcx Volve Posn it /-
C*HiftltedLMinVolvePosn 0 Il odLine 3g3 8 18 28 36 40 50 H 70 et 90 101 Percent Core flu Figure VI-l Stability Test Points Power / Flow Conditions 1
4 TP0 TP1 p
w ~
l' , .
- 8. TP2 i
t A
e
. .. .. . , . . ... . r. . .r. .
Fraction of Distance from Inlet to Exit Figure VI-2 Stability Test Axial Power Shapes 9__-__________.
._ g . - . . _ . .
]
- m. i' Co npaia t ot. 4- eoc .2. O nil $ascIbt
%//e A i1 l l II Test Information . Decay Ratio l l l ORNL Noise l l l ,l. l Core .
Analysis l RETRAN l l Test l Power l Flow 1 Best l l ll Point I (%) (%) Estimate Range i . , , ,
ll 1 I .
ll I I 11 ll 0 l 100 l 103 ll 0.18. l 0.11-0.22 l 0.19 ll ll l l ll l 1 11 Il i I 11 I I 11 ll 1 1 52. l 39 ll 0.31 l 0.26-0.37 l 0.35 ll ll l l ll l .I II II I I II I I II i l 2 1 62 l 45 ll 0.32 l 0.27-0.35 1 0.36 Il !
1 I I II I I II i li l i II I I II ll 4- l 59 l 39 ll 0.32 l 0.32-0.33 l' O.35 ll I l- 1 I ll l l 11 ll -
1 I ll l l 11 l 6 I 44 l 27 ll 0.35 1 0.26-0.40 1 0.46- Il l I I II I I ll 1 I I il l I 11 dyc l e 1 G V e h c.A ,o u E wwvy
(} t k I
$ FSVY t- h*4 40C C.bo
- dc o,~/o 6 oc C 6[
3-
- EVALUATION OF ANF's .
, METHODOLOGY / ANALYSIS RESULTS' l
- - Core Power / Flow Sensitivity - Test Results
- *; ~ Analysis Region Attainability i
1 f
I J14 MISC 87092104 - 2 P
4.
)
l-0 Tigurs IV-1 GGNS RETRAN Model Schematic o ve , um. .
I8 f Junction.
en Q, i
- e. ,...@,,. ,,e ,
- E sa6 e#19 pit ##5 ^
i
e WM '
l
' / / A3 > 1 V
> e
,u ef,g'p; , >. y y 3 %
p v
j ED's/V/ / t <
c ens ' / I KD) i V '"
^
E3 (#9' / T m%! / l'/EI 4 A tat.: n. der QWQ6/ / E
'//KD> Y / *L%
\
mtpV /L
//,/ //'/GY f
, gin / / >
)
A Y W
[f(( j b .n b'
_ g 9
(~'
7
i~., ' -
i 1.2
-f l /
/
-/
1.0 -
j 7
Decay Ratio / ;
' (Core region i only) 7 0.8 -
I
't
/
/
0.6 -
/
/
/ !
0.4 -
/
/
/
0.2 -
V
/
0.0 > ' -
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 .
Decay Ratio (Recirculation loop included)
Figure 1 F.ffect of ANT stability methodology assumptions on decay ratio calculations 4
e _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ . \
RETRAN METHODOLOGY Le .' Based on EPRI Developed Approach
- :- ' Core, Vessel and Recirculation Loop Modeling RETRAN'Model Benchmarked Against Cycle 1 Startup Tests
- . Time and Frequency Domain Solut. ion.
- - Model Qualific'ations Sensitivity' Evaluations Benchmarks to B0C2 Test Results P M e p in 1. f rad: c.4 s'a ns
- Equilibrium Cycle Analysis Approach i
J14 MISC 87092104 - 3
i e' =* .. .. .. .
",.'s-a . . N *.
. Le 1 7 i . .' I
i i fI
~
6 5 e .
I q. .
.7 I
Q.} .
.
'r !
M n .
u.J E g k o_ - A_
l U.J
) ~ ~
1 x
v u.J 0
b i i i 1 ,
b 4 6 12 16 20 TIME (SEC) i GGNS-1 STABILITY STUDY - TEST POINT 4 i i i i i s_ i I
cr R_
&m.e z
u_ o . .
=
H e
u,.J _
oR a.
1 I i i
% 4 8 12 16 20 TIME (SEC)
F / & g( -
/b n_- _-
7sh/e )
. Sensitivity Analyses Paramet'er-Conclusion
- 1. Core Power Sensitive
- 2. Core Flow Sensitive
- 3. Axial Power: Shape Sensitive
- 4. Fuel-Clad Cap Conductivity Sensitive
- 5. Moderator Density (Void) Sensitive Reactivity Coefficient
- 6. Delayed Neutron Fraction Sensitive
- 7. Direct Moderator Heating Sensitive O. Prompt Neutron Lifetime Insensitive
- 9. GE vs ANF Fuel Geomett y Insensitive i
4 l
l I\
,-y ,,
. METHOD UNCERTAINTY
- .RETRAN results agree well with ORNL test results.
- All RETRAN results are consistently more conservative than ORNL results.
- To allow for additional conservatism establish surveillance procedures for 1,0 i: DRRETRAN > 0.9 and restrict operations for DRRETRAN > 1. 0 J14 MISC 87092104 - 4
/ 2-
l --
D.SO90$cp 4
s V hh55 B [S Of6AAT/W6 AE$ LOW i.
i l.
i.
CoreflesElb I 11 22 33 45 56 67 M 98 til 112 Poetr-flevnop 168 . . . . . .
, 3:33 to . . . .
j*d . . .
g49
' u p#.
r mlr e c 78 s@S p 2683
2299 P
- t. e 54 - .
1916 '
P i 8 o 48 .
1533 '
W g ,
e 34 . .
gg49 gg I T N .
.t . .
?g It - .
/ .
f.- ,. - . .
383 4,/ ..
g 4 IN 18 26 34 44 54 64 70 et 90 Percent Care fiev I
0 1
j l3
-, GGNS-1 T/S OPERATING LIMITS IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM
- t. , ,
l,
- MCPR~
MAPLHGR
-~ MAPLHGR-
l
)
J14 MISC 87092104 - 6 Iy
g _, ... ~ . . _ _ _ . . , . . . . _ - . _
._ ., y
[j .,7 : .- +..
- CURRENT LIMITS l
L oi Established.in Support of Cycle 1.
o ~- . Changes made.as needed,in. Support of Cycle 2/3 MAPFAC f
.- ~MAPLHGR I
o Margins Available to. Improve Limits a
i i
i e
i e
+
J14 MISC 87092104 - 7
/f
,, .. T ;: 7 2 . _; u .r:;;.r--- x :;-- , ;1
. . I
. o )
- . 1
-: TARGET NEW LIMITS l
'e' . Cycle 2/3 Analyses identifying Available Margins .j MCPR P-
.MCPR f
MAPFAC P ,
e- Operational Modes (Flux Auto / Loop. Manual) ) '1 1
MCPR j f
i MAPFAC j f i i
i l
l l
i J14 MISC 87092104 - 8
/G
r7~ -.
- -- - ;u _ - _ _ . . _ _ _._ . ... ..e
- ( - .
l'* .
l- -
'. . SCOPE OF ANALYSIS i
Scope of Analysis In Progress.
-~ Generic RWE
-Limiting Transients (GLR, FWCF)
Two pump flow increase event One, pump flow increase event )
Other events as necessary Both rated and'off-rated events will be considered.
SCHEDULE
-i
- Complete margin improvement package - first quarter of 1988 i
i J14 MISC 87092104 - 9
/ 37
0 i2 1
0 1
1
'3 e
l cy N 0 C
( -0 W L 1 1 O F L t F M l
i n
MM L I 0 9
U M
l X
f u M l u
m15 G 2 0D 8 d 7
0 0 2 E n a
1 1 T r A G R
- 0 7
r o
/ f O
f s
t 0 7 i
,6 i m
L H R O P 0 L C
,5 F M t
E n e
R d
,0 O n 4 C e p
e D
,0 w 3 l o
F 0 1
,2 5
e r
u
,0 g 1 i F
- - - - - -0
- - s 7 5 4 3 2 i.
6 .
1 1 1 1 1 1 l
b mn_or
\ , . 1
. 3
. . ~
f_-
- n mm E s$.a N<^E o" ,
52 0
I 51 0
t 3
l e 7_
c y
C ;
0 5
0 1
1 -
t i
n U
0 -
5 9 f l
u G
d D
5 0 8E n
a r
T G A .
R r o .
I 0 F 7 F ..
O t s
i 1 1 0 0 7 m 5 5 0 i
> 2 I
6 , L .
w w o
R R l
o l E P C
F F H M e e 3 00 r r 5 P t n .
o o e C C E d R n
- e 3 0O 4
p e
C D r
e 0 w ._
g 3 o 7 P
2 g 0 2 5 e
r u
g 3 0 1
i F
0
- - I 4 2 2 8 8 4 2 1 1 1 1 -
2 2 n_v na_or 1ll1 1
0 2
1 3
0 e 1 l 1
c y
C s 1 w 0 l
o 0 t 1
F i n
e U r
o 0 f C l 9 u l
l G
A d D n
% 0 a 0 8E r 4 T G
> A r r R F o
e 0 w 7 F o % r P 0 O o 5 t c
>1 w0 7 a 0 F o4 l
$ 6 , C F R A r
ee E F P
rw W A oo 0O M CP 5 P t
n E e d
R n
,0 O e 4 p C e D
r 0 e
,3 w o
P 1
0 5
,0 4 5 % 2 w0 5 o4 l e F $ r r ,0 u ee g rw 1 i
oo F CP
- - - - - - - - 0 1 I 9 8 7 6 5 4 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 t.
Em o(t0:C
. 5
10 ANT-87 66 :
Revision 1 !
1 R_
X 8
i a
m*
A .a &
ErJ ,
.C -C -
.. 3
$$$ -8 uo ?.
m mm E 6 l
$--1E m u 1 -R L 2 o 8, v
- 3 .s
[$ ' )
-S L> E 4 w w 1
% 8 4 1 E2=
~8 o A
[
s BB .g 8
% dd c
' =-
W EE .
-R g t
B, !
~* - !
w ,
, , , -=
- - . . s . m l a a a a a i I
(J)OWJdWW L- ------_--- -
/ ANF-87-66 8
Revision 1
. . i a [
MCPRp limit Ref 1 .
2.2 -
AN.F C_R_WE_ _
Ref 3 e MALMsts AkSULTS 2.0 -
I
~
j 1.8 -
l l
Ir E
~
( $ 1.6 -
~ ~
1.4 -
g l i i
I 1.2 -
L ~
3
-I s
1.0 . . i '
0 20 40 60 80 100 Core Power (%)
, Figure 2.4 Grand Gulf Unit 1 Cycle 3 MCPRp Limits 7.- vs. CRWE Based MCPRp Limit e
s.
w %4. 9s' r4 '.b ~ ?' " '
,s wm___ , , - - .,,,g.-,,
,.w _
y w,<m yM
N1iE-
_ s 0
i2
_ 1 t
l u
_ . s
_ . e 0 R 1 3 1
s l e
_ . i s c y
y l 0 C a 0 n 1 1 s A t w = i l
o n
%F 0 U 0 9 f 4 e l
> r o u rC G e D d wl 0 n ol 8E a PA T r R G R r 0 o F
7F O r o
% t 0 7 c 5
0 a
>% 6 , F w0 o4 R C l
F 5 E AF
. r W P A
ee 0O rw 5 P M oo CP t E n e
R d n
0O 4 e
. C p e
D r
0 e 3 w o
% P 0
% 0 3 w0 2 o4 2 l
F 5 e r r ee u rw 0 g oo 1 i CP F 0
8 5 4 1 1 9 8 7 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 g oatng i
C s e
h1W"Eo ~
~ ~
0
- - _ - 2 i- 1 w
o I 0
wl _
1 3 of _
l + 1 e
f .
x l
, a x m x c y
, a ,X I 0 C m% 0 1 1 5
7 2 t 0 0 i n
1 1
+* I 0 9D O s s e e E f l
s s y y T G u
l l
+X C A a a BR 3
d n n n a a a r
e s s e F G a
e a
e + x I 0O 7
r o
r r f c
n c
n - % s i i t
, i
, o o w w +x I 0W i m
6 L l
F F l
O R L P
+ x 0
F C M
+ 8 5
E t n
R d e
0 O e n
+ 8 4 C e p
D w w o o w l 3 0 l l
o F 3 F f m u
m m 5 u i m x i 0 2
, i a 2 x 4 1 e a r M % u 5 g
% i 7 2 ' 0 F 0 0 1 1 1
_ - - - - - I O 7 5 4 3 a 1 0 L 1 1 1 t 1 1 migLOM z
(
4 l
0
- - - _ - 2 1
w o '
0 wl -
1 3 of +
1 l
f .
- e l
x c
, a x m a
, *x ' 0 C y
0 m% 1 1 5
% t
._'- 7 2 i 0 0 n 1 1
+x 0 9D d E
s s f l
e e T u l
s s y y l
"d +x 0 A G
8R a a d n n A n a a e e s s x F G a
r a a 0 O r
\+ x e e 7 o r r F c
n c
n % s t
i i s , i w w .
m
\+x Nt0 0
o ol A 6W i L
l F F O R L
1
+ x N A A
' 0 F
P C
M A 5 E t n
P R d e
o O n o 0 e
+ N L 4 C p e
D w l w\
o
' 0 l w
o o F 3 F l
F m u
m m 5 u i 2
m x ' 0
, i a 2 x M e
_ M a
5 i
r u
g 7 2 ' 0 F i 0 0 1 1 1
- - - C 7 6 5 3 2 J 0 1 I 1 1 1 L 1 n 4OM Y
h g
m j -
-wE
- y'* ,
"y 0
4 s s 2
1
- ~~ n
(
0 s
0 1 1
l u, , -
f
< O 0 T 0 s C 1
A %
m ? /
- 5. %
2!
0 9
m 00 11
~
L WW
~
~
E OO 0D 8 E U LL
,% u /, F FF T l
XX 7' .
/F AN -MM AA 0
f R
s' - - .
i
.j/ _/ -
7 F
O v, L
- x -._
. 0 7 l\
s y ,6
,- A s W o O L
g ,5 0 F
A p
/ E R
t ~
,0 O o
o L
5.M_/
2 0A' 11' 4 C
v WW 0 L OO ,3 E LL U FF
~- '... F E AA XX w . , .~- G MH ,20
^ '
~
. V, s '
k ,0 1
~
-* kI s
- -O
~
~
1 g 9 8 7 6 s.
- 1 C D 0 0 o s
o
~ y*0[ -
'- I 5 [