ML20235N294
| ML20235N294 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Seabrook  |
| Issue date: | 02/20/1989 |
| From: | Backus R BACKUS, MEYER & SOLOMON, SEACOAST ANTI-POLLUTION LEAGUE |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#189-8081 OL, NUDOCS 8903010144 | |
| Download: ML20235N294 (5) | |
Text
___-_ - _ -
.I g [,,
q
,ses, & UTIL FAC.y._
f.
e$I-9 I
+
UNITED STATES OF-AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g@
4
' ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING. BOARD j
E I
-fg Be fore Admin is t ra t ive J udges:
s Ivan'W. Smith, Chairman-Dr. Richard F. Cole Dr. Kenneth A. McCollom In the Matter of
)
Docket No. 50.-433-OL
)
i
)
PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY
)
(Offsite Emergency
)
Planning) of NEW HAMPSHIRE, et al
)
)
(Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
)
February 20, 1989 SEACOAST ANTI-POLLUTION LEAGUE'S TRIAL BRIEF ON THE SEABROOK PLAN FOR MASSACHUSETTS COMMUNITIES-("SPMC")
The Seacoast Anti-Pollution League (SAPL) intends to litigate Contentions Ji 46, JI 55 and Ji 57 during the first phase of the SPMC l i t i ga t i on.
SAPL will be bringing no direct tes timony and will litigate by cross examination of witnesses.
4 CONTENTION 46 Contention 46 states:
The SPMC fails to provide reasonable assurance that adequate protective measures can and will be implemented for all those persons who are patients in the two hospi tals l
within the Massachuset ts EPZ and for those who become inj ured during the emergency, from radiation j
contamination / exposure. The SPMC theref ore f ails to comply wi t h 10 CFR 50. 47 (a )(1), 50.47 (b)(12 ) and NUREG 0654, Rev.
1, Supp.
1, II.J.10.d, 10.e, 10.g; and II.L.
SAPL's position on this contention is that the SPMC has failed to provide adequate means of public protection for those persons in EPZ hospitals because there is no realistic plan for sheltering or 3
$0 8903010144 890220 p
PDR ADOCK 05000443 O
t l
l evacua t ion o f pat lents f rom Amesbury Hospital or Anna Jacques Hospi tal and there are no adequate host f acili ties to receive and treat those patients.
Fur ther, SAPL plans to show that the hospitals identified in the SPMC for medical treatment of evacuees are not adeq ua t e ly prepared to treat the numbers of emergency workers or general public evacuces who might be referred to those hosgitals under various accident scenarios.
Finally, SAPL intends to show that the means of transport of general public evacuees to medical facilities are i
highly insufficient.
CONTENTION Jl 55 Contention JI 55 states:
The SPMC fails to provide reasonable assurance that an adeq ua t e number of buses, ambulances, wheelchair vans, vans, tow trucks, drivers and road crews can and will respond in a timely f ashion. Therefore, t he S PMC v i o l a t e s 10 CFR 50.47(a)(1),
50.47(b)(1).
50.47(b)(3),
50.47(b)(10), 50.47(c)(1) and NUREG 0654, Rev.
1, Supp.
1, II.A.3.,
II.C.4.,
II.C.5. and II.J. 10.
SAPL intends to establish that there is no solid, basis for expecting that the number s of emergency vehicles and drivers relied upon under the SPMC can in reality be relied upon to provide services. - _ - _ _
/
. _w m,
c CONTENTION JI 57 Contention JI 57 states:
The SPMC falls to provide adequate means for the handling and disposal of contamina ted was te wa ter and contamina ted materials, contrary to the requirements of 10 CFR
- 50. 47 (a)(1),
50.47(b)(9),
50.47(b)(11) and NUREG 0654 11.1.8 and R.5.b.
SAPL intends to show that the means for handling waste water and contaminated materials are so unwieldy, cumbersome and ill-conceived that they will encumber the emergency response
- effort, cause h
inappropriate hazards to evacuees and delay the process of decontaminating evacuees in a manner that is a detriment to public safety.
Respectfully submitted, Seacoast Anti-Pollution League By its attorney, BACKUS, MEYER & SOLOMON fy R6bert A.
Backus, Esquire P. O.
Box 516 116 Lowell S,treet Manchester, N.H.
03105 Tel: (603) 668-7272 DATE:
February 20, 1989 I hereby cer t i fy tha t a copy o f the wi t hin Seacoas t An t i-Pollut ion League's Tr ial Br ief On The Seabrook Plan For Massachuset ts Communi t ies ("SPMC") has been sent this date by telefax to those indicated by an asterisk on the attached Service List and by first class mail, postage prepaid to the remainder of the parties on said list.
q Robert ~ A.
Usekus, Esq. I
m-7
$ 'Ums.pignan, Espiire g Ivan W. Smith, M an Suzanne Breiseth Atanic Safety and Licensing Board of Selectren M' Ra;es'&, Gray Board
'Itwn Hall gn i 4' M Franklin Street One Drinkwater Pcad. 'Q,7
' m, FR 021 4 ton U.S. tac Washington, CC 20555 Ha.pton Falls, la 03S44 k?
oac? V '
0 *\\o%O.V
4
- Dd
,fD:cketing & Service"Sec.g
~-
Office of the Secretary,.g$Nnogggg;Yughty Kenneth A. McCollom "0 tug g -lk. et Street r
Atanic Safety and Licensing U. S. 13C Board U. S. 13C Washington, DC 20555N d7 s, orts cuth,13 03301 Washington, DC 20555 q
N Of fice of Selectmn Richard P. Cole George Dam Sisbee Esgair hm of Hrpton Falls Atomic Safety and Licensing Attorney General's Office H.Lgen Falls,13 03344 Soard State of t'eo-hwh U.S E Conccrd, IG 0332)1 Was, ingtcn, DC 20555 n
Ashod N. Amirian, EsTaire
-X Joseph Flynn, Asst. Gen. Cnsl.
Sandra Gavutis 145 South b'ain Street Fed. Daarg. It;=t. Agcy.
g.n of Ke. sing'm-500 C Street SN Box 1154 P.O. Box 38 Bradford LA 01333 Washington, EC 20472 East Kensington, la 03827
-;4-Sherwin E. Turk, E. squire Charles P. Gralum, Esquire Carol Sneider, Esqaire Office of E<ec. Legal Dr.
ttKay, Fur-inv and Graham Assistant Attorney General U S IGC One Ashburton Place 100 bhin S'treet Washington, CC 20555 A esbury, Fn 01913 19th Flecr 3 sten, MA 02108 Judith H. Mizner, Essaire William S. Iord, Selectran R. Scott Hill 4hilton, EsqJire 79 State Street g y g311 79 State Street Ueaturyport, In 01950 Friend Street Ne.stq;crt, F",
01950 A esbury, FA 01913 Paul FtEachern, Esquire Se.utor GordOn J. H @ e, Diane Cirran, Esquire l'atthew Brock, Esquire U.S. Se.mte H ar:on, Curran & Trusley 25 1bpleaood Avenue Washington, IE 20510 20001 S Street tu P.O. Box 360 Attn: Janet Coit Suite 430 Ports cuth,13 03801 Washington, EC 20009
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - " - - - + - - - - - - ~ -. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
G' J. P. ludeau h n of Rye 155 Washington Road
- Rya, m 03870 Adjudicatory File Atanic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. NPC Warhington, DC 20555 Richard R. Conovan FEG Federal Registry Center 130 228th Street, SW Sothell,la 98021-9796 Robert R. Pierce, Esquire Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. 5. 14RC Washington, DC 20555 James H. Carpenter, Alt.
Tech. Member Atcmic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. NRC Washington, DC 20555 1
_