ML20217Q482
| ML20217Q482 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 03/03/1998 |
| From: | Skinner P NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II) |
| To: | Mccoy C SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9803120257 | |
| Download: ML20217Q482 (47) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:;. ,[p I March 3, 1998 l l Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. ATTN: Mr. C. K. McCoy Vice President l P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham, AL. 35201-1295
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- DIESEL GENERATOR ISSUES - V0GTLE ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANT - DOCKEi NOS. 50-424 AND 50-425
Dear Mr. McCoy:
i This refers to the February 25. 1998, meeting held to discuss diesel generator issues at your Vogtle facility. I have enclosed a list of attendees and a copy of the slides that were used at the presentation. In accordance with Section 2.790(a) of the NRC's " Rules of Practice." Part 2. Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room. No reply to this letter is rewired; however, if you have any questions concerning this mutter, pleas 9 contact me at 404-562-4520. Sincerely, (Original signed by Pierce H. Skinr.or) l Pierce H. Skinner. Chief Reactor Projects Branch 2 Division of Reactor Projects Docket Nos. 50-424. 50-425 i License Nos. NPF-68 NPF-81 (f
Enclosures:
1. Lict of Attendees l 2. Presentation Slides I cc w/encls: J. D. Woodard Executive Vice~ President Southern Nuclear 0perating Company, Inc. i P. O. Box 1295 I-Birmingham, AL 35201-1295 cc w/encls cont'd: (See Page 2) 9903120257 990303 h h$hh!hhhh PDR ADOCK 05000424 P PDR l TfVb i
SNC 2 cc w/encls: Continued J. B. Beasley General Manager. Plant Vogtle Southern Nuclear Operating Company. Inc. P. O. Box 1600 Waynesboro. GA 30830 J. A. Bailey Manager-Licensing Southern Nuclear Operating Company. Inc. P. O. Box 1295 Birmingham. AL 35201-1295 Director. Consumers' Utility Counsel Division Governor's Office of Consumer Affairs 2 M. L. King. Jr. Drive Plaza Level East: Suite 356 Atlanta, GA 30334-4600 Office of Planning and Budget Room 615B 270 Washington Street. SW Atlanta. GA 30334 Office of the County Commissioner Burke County Commission Waynesboro. GA 30830 Director. Department of Natur al Resources ) 205 Butler Street. SE. Suite 1252 Atlanta, GA 30334 Manager. Radioactive Materials Program Department of Natural Resources 4244 Intertiational Parkway Suite 114 Atlanta GA 30354 Attorney General i Law Departri,ent 132 Judicial Building Atlanta. GA 30334 Program Manager Fossil & Nuclear Operations Oglethorpe Power Corporation 2100 E. Exchange Place Tucker. GA 30085-1349 I cc w/encls cont'd: (See Page 3) i j
SNC 3 cc w/encls: Continued Charles A. Patrizia. Esq. Paul Hastings, Janofsky & Walker 10th Floor 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue Washington, D. C. 20004-9500 Senior Engineer - Power Supply Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia 1470 Riveredge Parkway NW Atlanta. GA 30328-4684 Distribution w/encls: P. Skinner. RII R. Carrion RII C. Casto. RII B. Mallett, RII M. Ernstes. RII R. Chou, RII L. Reyes RII J. Johnson. RII D. Jaffe, NRR PUBLIC NRC Senior Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 8805 River Road Waynesboro, GA 30830 l ) 0FFIE RII:DAP j SIERIATLRE [fC i IIAIE hPCarrion:&a DATE 3 V _3 /98 2/, /98 2/ /98 2/ /98 2/ /98 2/ /98 2/ /98 (NY? (YES ) MD fES IID YES NO YES IID YES NO YES NO YES IID OFFICTk RECORD COPY DOCLSENT IIAfE: G:\\WOGTLE\\DIESCEN.SLBI
i i List of Attendees NRC Attendees: R. P. Carrion. Project Engineer. Reactor Projects Branch 2. Division of Reactor Projects C. A. Casto. Deputy Director. Division of Reactor Projects l R. C. Chou. Reactor Inspector. Division of Reactor Safety D. H. Jaffe, Project Manager. Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation l J. R. Johnson. Deputy Regional Administrator B. S. Mallett. Deputy Director. Division of Reactor Safety L. A. Reyes, Regional Administrator P. H. Skinner Chief. Reactor Projects Branch 2. Division of Reactor Projects J. Zeiler. Senier Resident Inspector. Vogtle Electric Generating Plant i Licensee Attendees: Southern Nuclear Ooeratina Comoany. Inc. J. B. Beasley General Manager. Vogtle Electric Generating Plant W. Burmeister. Manager. Engineering Su) port. Vogtle Electric Generating Plant D. Lloyd. Engineering Manager. Vogtle Electric Generating Plant C. K. McCoy. Project Vice President L. A. Ward. Engineering and Licensing Manager. Vogtle Electric Generating Plant I l l 1 )
c SNC/NRC Meeting to Discuss DG Exhaust Issues February 25,199810:45 a.m. Agenda
- 1. Overview / history - J.B. Beasley Overview of problem How was problem discovered Initial actions and subsequent actions to date
- 2. Engineering evaluation - L.A. Ward Operability e
Reportability j e Reasonable assurance of safety e Inspection results e Root cause
- 3. Corrective actions planned - D.M. Lloyd Planned design change e
Safety evaluation summary for design change
- 4. Implementation of design change - J.B.Beasley e Planned schedule Installation constraints e
- 5. Summary - C.K. McCoy i
Safety significance e e Schedule for corrective actions j J
4 o'2 3 ',-1^ t. s,p ,p 9 4 '#*% ' 6 41 t. s, h~ t)..'t a i ( ,y 4% o; f# 8 . i' H. .I' Q i %,. i.. ql. 4 i,
- .&4* oj f. Dj l i l
-N' Q~ ^ec g E: O l ' f' ! ',., ( A Qc key. g Q > u! ^j (y V 3 e (f;,,- 5j }. is f, lJ;-:' .. +; ;, ... q: ;.., i i f-i, gr p,' -
- f f
f} \\' .O i - { - l,- . ;r [ y n i g /,f. n. et,, { I r%.1. ,.r,tf., g ;. 1 ' if; s i- -D, / y V; O4 1 Q j k E} p ' h) .t i s. - i ( m , / '_. a )[ .-h .I ,} t, 0 ): t' , g LQ,. L ' .s , 2.,,3, f,., p ; t,. I J l ' gs '. ';'0. g 4 hg.[ T l ' r w+ ..'g; : t >,. y 2 3 - s ,n Ef H '
- l.lrr '
[ Mh p- ..] [ 'S e l p. J >, f. f. 4 l, S 4.- m c. t{, k, f 6s s 4{ li"6 g L f,t:g>*g,. e,,.fY,j y.I ~ i &y , f 9 .D:: t
- t.,,,
, w* , m,h-y . sw: a ,, + mlfl, 5 I' _f,y i.,. 4. &~s 4 .. y. c,,..d V: ); g' h
- t L
- y
,4 epg;"3, . q. [4. -~, c; j,- ,%p +.. i 7 g4, 6 u %, r. t A y.. y j-2 . m.g m).,'.' c* ~ f f% y fc) gidf.sfr.. 0 .~ H. p 4.: y r;<:n,., . i.. ;y -
- m..
,As
- t m,
v: - 4 . -' i vae sg g r t- ,,f., ,[ .N j ' %{. v j[ e. m e w& w# 4 t, c@m. %.m./ Q v . :. ( 17 g kje ,d, % ;; q; w' x;.;,.,gf :.s g -. e.g~. ' = , 9,_# A , y } p <\\ .t%;. -. x: m ., 3,.. } t '? p s z_ . a:gTw Jl,.wd. i, pf., te"n. FMr%..a.m " e TA dn'Vi$. r-np m[ n ! l 'f' 7+'*' Q' X { L';, ,n,.~ ?.%- ( e h J< r 4 as. a[n, J., e y...: + s 3 '< 3 l -$p:, N ),,a i ~ v a M _: i ..b.f f k n.,d/ g h.- ,9g. I
- }.
- p; ; t.
,p y' N m [ v' i
- r 1
- a b
.; y g 4 4.b .,,i t i-1.e g -.rg t s 5,- ,-+ t e 5 O - i_ f.sI6.' H'A L t r!~ % 4m. (.t )' nr> ,-[ mr s. .yp e f c g. ? 4.k i .. W i r 7 yfp
- i. p 7'
. JE 3 g , ' V;f1:,;e. t r p y 3-2 ~b <'6 y,2 M.4;ph.y 4 W t -a lk v f^ ~~ i s.j +
- h. l..f
^ n L p L 1 J _ b g j H,. %.. t (P Q F i, o, i y \\g .e f.,
- 1. - ai.
g '.( {p:i ~ y ? -. . Ly 1 ' " 8-3.. c t O-L-
- 5
....e' a p.a. 5 a t.
- u 4.,.
m <w.
- t.."4 E w
c i i _7. y _., , M_,I $ h: n i
- 1.,.
). i. .,_A !. A h, ' 9' r j t' I, -\\( .su 1 ks ~ ~~ d [4.._ df* $ b.h5Wi:N. _. 4 r
4 C w We a u [d b. (;V d, m Co p. Q y 1 1 pM ' h o "3 C k;& i I;\\ L)$.' * ;j YIh1 d *phG 4 g 3, .i
- l r/)
y$ ea -
- h 1Mh(
m y;, yQ '* j m_ - 3 { e #@fh ' j@ u a i 4g W 4: igN hi 5 ' # a.. +/c, :. l,p D? d [ fu b' L,#;auga< i p8 4 W, h Qih k k h [. 6[ t. . s.,A_, i " r xyph3 c L v. 7 h .... ; ' }M4 a s eA a a pnn;j gyg,gq 3 5g me. w a-2 7 4 mg u.ea ~T fi {igjyp) 4 I[f
- 'ii (g.
E"w< w, q m~k rq b_ p i ~A;j w. e hs /t%' 3, \\ ,f:N., e-[. ,.- a. .O.. (n.,_ j v L )pif ,m e'. -~ v ;r s t x r i o..: i e. %- S,g: , r,;. -:-- ,s t k f . 5 -a n gl y(? e,h5[ 7 ha. yw..W;7,.o: q g '~,y . m:. - :c Gf
- 1 4
W q hl jn} 4 3,. E }, o y. f, " m p;/.fp: m c h n y cC w+pyh"cWb n -%;} o$mE 0 ta C C@: #d 1 a %p i 'o @ $fl Lq: e 3: ij e cd p e2 6 Nv D gn:w~d A j a W W
.. RQ'*.?' @ ' as.. <, s $,3M't'M s[ ~.h j ,t ';;.$re.; ;m.. { i; g_. l, ? I k N;4 1 FNQ(f -s gj?iyM dl m j i
- 2.6, p
' l' f 'bhkG -{ ^ y;r e ll w. p C; - r. I +:p L> k dkf b n.,N' f[I e Y] a?wb$ k 4 o .,y y % 47.$2
- i T
d tll0 / C i en g.l v. 6 hfb: og . k & %$$? ;. d [
- ,76 [ $$hdd@yI' BEE**@g h
.9 \\ w t A W g G s-g C6 \\ W 0-y y," jgM iQ M JQ / c o 6 .3 p% @ fv .5 .M. t e 3 e M M { l{:jp,,gg, w'd y ..,di. ? I / sy 0..' .w .- g qs:y,
- c
. p n-d -Q Ujp 1x Ag [k. I'I .q', ,[ # j' p'Ad )gg;:g[ ' is [cg, 91 4y wp% 4 NYh N +. <a ! ~ %. ,fg '. - TA. 9 _ y, t
- f v@e&, pQc
- =". a.
O" ~ 'f. y + :t%;. s e, e 4
- s}l
~ ~ ~ 3.$f)!
- a%w
')~ r9RMS,y%f%.. Ef'%#go c'm+g~*% %.m r - n. 'gs'f$mg$ t c 1 , !"};ndkW.d' f _. #;; KQ[g) 1 If, p,f' f l f" t% y :c _
- 5 g
f
r 1-% h 1 y;l ( 9 s 7 c g>h 3 ,ag 4 ,\\ \\ \\ ) t ~ E t B ~:E. I 2 s 3' y 4 j e ,t l /* I 4 / 3 . cl > ' ~~ g s- \\ . $l:. t. I gn + + i 4:yfu ' ", aA c' J. Q 4 d? n If%,Q{s[; Vj + s;' $;"ux, &$9{3 L t s s w::.idlS P" ngr~4 ' {l.s Oq j. .g Mc e c+ 4; 4, J /,) ; ? i %hy p s ,e s, r d ' '..4 / r A y q' I f 2 . j mSC[ h bAagg g~Py n M g y p ,i. '] g. / 6.Q i
- k,.
e 'Q s f; \\ .i " g;.m, w s ..mr %
- 'Q A,
g[(qp?;aw %dg;glA. j 9 vp fS. V' Y % w x ( %Yvi%$ il/ ? sy - lJ. P j%g i
9
gn t les i t a su re ea n ihs e Dxe r G yE u t c n crt a irl no c tP et u c ar e grt m l E r eS e e n me l tgo EG V s
k A ,A af 1 e o 2 o G l t r D B s s e ut E 1 l r ai e e y x e n r eh e ht h e wx nt nt ee o e o v p s o l t ut edi r o n ep ee qe pg eg c nt t o c s s a s s eu gab i r pa nmum.s D esh dasa i e pu x dr d d l i ,s e u endu m 8 t bt aec 9 aA e e l 9d1 er eaur l 1 n h cr et b ,fG nuvs t i f ot et o 7oD o c uc r s r yt E f r s u P g odt na ra e oes oh n uih r ret ix t t np e v ust e ce a e e ch pB mr h o a e J t nt h ns s2 t x Oaw Odei& i n =
ts t u 4 s t s a u l un h l x a a ao e f h o x hi f e t o r xa o o e Ed i r t d e n ra s x n i i t r n e e o t g i l er n s a l ae a h oe f rD t b r e du d e n r nt a ne o g u c h er gn o u r e u ni f Gt t t s s s e i l o kt r l c ap cs c leu px au n sr se r a o ch c et e e iS e ex d t ru ce e g. D ct r a c fG n l l n u r ai or uD pp t i Cs SE Sp =
e d l i e s n s t g i m s is u e e a d d t i hn en v g. r a o n xg et r i s Ei wi pp i s s op r se t e er t o r ss tD u a iu t a ce na t re uh oh i r r t x e t h c e u st nt ie n wt uG t ec s e f D udr n Gu ae gE cn r ht r i t x co s l o eS e uc ef rt d d s n e Gs e Dn c aio l i or pt D Eco icce f edn nt io h ni r r e Tar Pp =
r o f l t i t s v idn n e c no d mt e u iod Sat i e qt r e a u dea e nt CBd e q eRi t yl S1 a t nt d i p r e a n i iebm A&g l i .i r s s e ge) dao EAd era ar c R1 b duE e e u s mps t esr S n d c (R t u r ou hGt nu e t / j oDc sio ut e eG A r u osc t Er nt f n nD1 t o c ssa gE eds i t iA nut nt G s et s nt s t oai eaD oc u t h s mhE pe a c i cx s t s ph A eeA ene es x o c t p r n ng sinn e l s i on yt iu n a n Sasr sd i I r e e n .r e i I t .t idy 8e 8ee 8meh 9em i l n r n t r /ci 9r ct / ni 9 / e n 4if I 7ng e gn / o n 7t f o 1 ef / no / dam cE 1 ec 1 1 = = =
n i .e e n r t t ot u e n or t nt i c e c ae t u dn nvr u eo iet t c m s q c r et e af eis l o t s u t s nt es b oc dia ca mh us p m x s ide Sn am r e et e /o wi at t si l a r a nl r ut i nt oit o c dn et e s iA neg do n ape t eton c v pi mr p p ay A Gep Sl i l ub Dh Cci t l t a E s Sis t s eu r na .a o it 8i 8p p 9mh i x 9 n ad /r e / 5e 6t I l 1 e 1 a u t / e h / h o 1 dt 1 t c = =
n t y s o t i t u t i l i n b a a yd i l t h n e a m i l xriabo r r u e oB e c a l p f i q o Bmer 2 n. 1 e d 2i t & s pi o s G e& oni t u b D sA d Ua l E s1 Ana u t u s 2ai l iaa i t d gG Sn dnh v e nD GeI t e /sio n iE Dt .d r nt m e d c 1 i e1 e Eede t 2pnt t o c nt c i r a n e s u c i iA gne in oiU i t t t e f nUf n i f d 'y c d n et a Ueeib A C at r r S o eeend h N d Ct n h wwioe la Se Sny T t d ssa n t t .c .oi .en n i 8e 8t 8r oiu t l i i in 9f 9ab 9uimo f t rb / a / u a t i / cde r 7 9l 1 I ae unt s t / o / vp 2r 1 1 oe a / tscdw 1 n 1 eo 1 = l l
n d o e i t t y n adt t t s u nl s i u i e ub u l u ao a ad ad vbr h e h e q e e x v x v sp e o e o e aGo m l m r s mDo ee c e r e b rE N cr r o n n s es u sf 2 ei i Sn l r ir gt l nin ib sb s /oino e e si eUt Ad B r i d a 2 nt e eu 2 d d o c nhl n &n a &a iAigt v Ba nge A t d 1 d c en 1 e e A Sa Gc Gt iG t t c CcD De De l iE a Sd Ep Ep n1 s s s i n .n .n t i i 8 t r 8i 8i n 9 dine 9g 9g /e / / 2uUc 2n 3n I n i i 2syo 2p 2p / / / i s i ibc 1 p 1 p 1 = = =
..-,,-.myimum -,mmmmmmm,. l l c L?aa, 4 I
6 s - 5 l ~ i s 44. w o. O m O s' k 4 N 4 .h M 3 6 ~ e f t c g g A m. c.m .n. Y e ~.,,.. 4 _ 5 j.' : 7 /.._ l 3 e a . ee. "... - a s. , e *. [ ' ',, '/' ", + ^~ t
- aef,
$/ i.,,.
- ** ism
'f/ a *,1 *, & n,,, * *
- ha*% r 4.
- )...,, a, ;
9,,ec( ~& .a ! ..e. . e c *+ v y m[.g,.. ! c ..74p49p.f 3,;g4+g.' 4. g.;;,. tf;e f. L ~,.gqp gy c r./
- .e*
s' s., 'a.* 4 .g .g6 g .m,m :f y. w m3 6: + w ~ ,,x.c4MF 4.sfdgMM: nQ$o, %.su$m.a*$1GR4/$.yV:M, .- - m4 se-.w,a,,-:;w w<,j s,me, wog N, p g g,gg;m n, ~... &. . 3-t n e- . q ep.., ,*te ?%. ,rA?P,+,. p;9 w" W u.s t 4 m %. q n y d. y ,y 4v % & $ $[ $h[j $ $ 5D C l [ & &; O m a':..e,b? w %. y$ h 5$ Q ,k -h "4 / d W5 M d
- 4. ~. w w & ;. m?
^ t%wW% s&y.c +4 +h *f., eWTy,..)r#.: w n4;oe 9'y.%gy&w r1 uw ,. n .2 j)W ? A'f + . c.pt . y f lYbl> j [, u n h, v 3 t* F . : rl 1 .,:u. ?:.-f .,.5[yw*v,, :;h y.*5l;y . %y: YhjQ' ..w q.; 4, n, N %G 4:k f T:~&hI _N: Y p'&-} g_ p y
- h f
kh ? m,,irvKV,y+A.,e kcw~e::yn m m%L.m:m,wwnan n=a~c$g**gES- -n n nw: e.g&& qm a4r w i se s . x .n, c y. vPppf E 2,'j f.;, j ; ? W h ff - 3.c w 3g Agip. - hf @lfiK@$6EENR[$g: lOMN5@$$$$2&M$$llh;b5,Q@%%j 8 5,gWW 2$$ h? E n s!S M Sd8!ff M.
i e.s a w b g s e e m = g 1 ~ l 1 ,I = 8 l l l l b e e 4 f e Y o 3 g wb i . \\. D a e 4 ) en g a o 1 4 J y 4 '4% s, e e e, p ,4 a c m.- = e 4 G
- 'M es*e **0.._ -
D.. i
3'9' 4 4 8 e w 4 a0 e t e I = 4 e h 4 w t I
- W q
e \\ i 4 ,,\\ 6 ' O J e ) g i V W
s + ,- f e 4 ) h' I e D 0 N 'e \\# \\ t O y i a M s. p O
- h..
-~ t s v . i. - ' <' '+. _ ; ;,. ,1...... O ' xy% - '1' I.. . g..,,. ?.; h R, .,ill - ~ ;; k: f I , h Y,, ? ,m.. '-( i \\l,[r$ *.. 8 s. f' ', fc .h, I .) .c ~ -l h '7 ( /'-,-,
- O
'.d..'., s... ., 4{.l.;;.. ,../.y 3.,,:;. . : m..g., t h b /5 s, / s i,ipg.'. 4 + Q ",
- .. ;s.,,;,i.,
<t.- I ' ' ' . ec. a' f,. I. f j , i. ?" 4 .c +
- .f._'**
{.. I ~ y._ s, - y :-. g,: Y J..'. '6 ' l'j_ g .r e, l 4' ,,', + ' 1 s. M
I I* ':.g 2s -m. w,, g_yn*1 . as,r,:, :y~~>,q.u - z.. ; &wf. ;,,' l~?$&.s., i. ?Qg 'jf .Q, s ) f a~\\p,.}y&g7'g:g
- p. c.i y'... au;. w
..n y. w;s.. y, kf',,n;b k,.. ' j; I' cW;Wl0 . ~.. h n '.,. ee, f .e y2 w.+,u . g,y. f' -h Q& qq] .,& [:@]. .E f,.( ; .-nni f r ay, .;p s ?h l k,h,D_ql'g$,&, k,ml;.,.._: ',..f %., g -., yf. $l.,,,l l .s n. .n, a J. ~,, lh. 9 ;f y ,1,,Q ,;y 4 y-3
- u. 1
&l;.&3 r 7,
- i,
,,yz..a Q af k w f. r? [ _ _ j. :u ^
- 8g-
- i f.
. k~. x~n:c,p;~f. N Q 1 ;' w,t} $ %,y,. ... e. 4.. f~ w i n gg f c ,i ty a. g.ym, a C 4p;m';h,,;&@W
- j,
p 2n f' ' iY pp 3 ~ r. a. ' ff l .? ~ 3 .,',,C t gr p T. gig 4 p 3 @,,S.:.sy, u; n..w. >. %. M. '}.- p c .,f'? - 'ml t ..e a .y 'l ~. ng ,4 P. ~ . p',{. d /f
- . : y d
. y: - h,$., / g n I. , w. r ' v..- n p 1, ~,y,,R. iY. s v (*', '. - ^ 'a m \\,7
- .R
}b e b ~ c ,.. fse .e
- n., y+.
s . $ ?< j Mb J w, w o t ^&- . ' ',Vf'& ? %b
- w. 3 r l g~ -
.,f,5 l k..,.[v, _,,', s. '. s 4y n,, 2 g- - y- :; % 3;'p,"fi.'. b .~ p
- ;mm A%
7.'..', l ;,.; 9,, !,f: m.].,y 'y .g.3.,:, .,e b 6, 1
- '[:
y.f <g .c,, .n p l;&,-, }%:. Y. < y'!,,,wi - "} ...s, ,.y ',y __ g ,iu 8 ,a~ ' ' ly S;i' e. p' . b:. 7:,.. _n 3, m,h'h;:,r w.#l-Itf fi$, y;; ; y! .l' l4 9 s, , 41; 7;a,. ! n'4 p, +p;g., g . O,; \\ &tfw, m, 6.v
- % j s
\\ ny y, g;:,w-qyn-w .s l O m u.c; e Y g! Q,d,,A s .., ;,., s, ; u r
- '}
p,j: e 4.,.. lam>,c yJ,. -4 n'?p&, +- lN.fln,l, n,'4 .P, :, m,fj 4-Q,; _. .a t w a .f,.,..'
- n., 4 ' ll.;T, '
5 i o, ;.r.;,9 Q, ~Q, 9. 4, /.f W 4
- .yw w 4. s....r y.
j L y, . ' :}M s i' '.,'sf. 3 # i = -j.s . - W,,_ .y
- 3 mpu w:>pf. % _fg$fh my.,!h fa,l: ls..n.}}
,1..,p,,s. e, f g,:; < %;. f % mp% ..n h 4:u d + ,*,gd'-r 'b - ',,ldffikl.; h >' fy fc' ' '
- f 4,&pOM ff h, kW,*hN,*
f,.chf,. (p -. g'. "f [, .h .,.w . ;m. j f ^ v '8 f ~: - w;n'7Y /.,':,n ' y
- y k
.YY 'r 'vve - f' o .T'Y A ,,, m_2**y Gsm,t,Qw n. M .
- A,, 9.9[ffydpy(sc )* g ;,..'3 p
I ' e. +g 4 r
I l 8 a l l 1 i e 1 l \\ 1 4 a 9 e/ \\ e t 9 . p. Q 4 <T t b ' M ] r. it 1 - Y Il t e 4g9 a t7 \\ Q 3 ^ e g 9 \\. 0 4 o b, 1 m e3 9 b
i b3 v, t ~. ' ',.' 9 W 1' ;j4,t...,, -mj r :: 'e !, } ':; _ g4 -s< r t ) p.,.' n.:!. Cg:.i./ ;,o;gr'. t, y.g m ! 'p " *, i .. 'r ; ) A;.N .JQy%; . e 3. '. ;,sw i ,3 d ' ',$'{p, g f:}l.\\J,g i
- ~y s_
-e,;i;; fk, } .ffwlj7., ( . *f':f y' i+jh $o%,..,& j,,a, y T
- ?
- g,;
- M r
.a p.n .~o., ~ w,; - .s. .m
- i.. -y.
i =90 i. '.k%[.,':'((,h[,)[,;:jldi'si$ T[MkIS$$!$$1M[g[' b$ $did I h..,,., 'l j g4 -
de s g t d g c u n e J f i f e r n u e re e d e w vs ee d g r e a s ,u t e et a c l b c r i o s y a u t s r s b t r i t n m es f i p o l o i t b os m o n d u e a d o a r e1 d d a i gt n r e e ex r yn a r u e o t p d e e t t e i i s 'a r i d b u n a i O sd e v i s gi n e s at e od n p sis ca o a e ge su r ea r C c c n pdl eg n i r p e s d a r e<2 n a r a ec r d o o e nat i i s t u e l c vib Git r g b 3 a Dw u u nn r o F s E o A m a m llL
g wo e l b s a i r e e r p u) o s t s n e t c a i o ut s n r n G i t o D s s d o m i t m e a r y t d x e gi d t n a e r n s n g t g i i s ed n e l i t i t r i b e n u l i ej 7 t a d o pe eE n r e r e i s el s3 d e lb ewb s p 3 u i a s i i m1 o s s r O u st e ad w pe mup i a y l t s o t f e n 2 a e en ot e ri a uh t ,G y v f me t oa eJ i vf r i i ur b x c s e o et e a o t i m c e r c b p s er n ud f e or n o p i f r e E w"t e a s r P S ( m m L
e saw s rey nb g p isu e t d d s e u i a v c i 1 ca y x b es d t t e i n s "o i l f i eir b t r ma e s a u u n oe qmo r ng eit e ad y ga p eu b d u j O c n u c a oj di a i t t a ni cic n t ai eign nd pi n oe s i r r n i mi oe tc f e r ei asn f pn ui i sg s o s an n i c Vb e I n
l to
- s. b s
e a gn w ao e t t i s a c u n l al a r a d ev i ve u e g sd y n 1 t a t a .v i y l e d r ib ee R a wv r e o 8 c i n 1 e v s eie p rdt 1 t 9 O smr i r a w wle e t b d i yo n e t r a L i l p i b y c id l agl r a e r n e z eib ni r r pu e el it Od v Gu f k
3 7 0 5 A ro 2 t s 7 o h 0 m y 5 t e R 7 i l F t i b C t s n i a 0 e t ) n i t 1 i r m e () m r o e 1 e r ( e ) p p b r iu e e a u ( i R b e 2 q l a R 7 e .r tr g 0 e o n 5l b p it R a e r F c R o Ci t p p o e 0 p N R 1 a k =
n i s t t n a l h u ot n i t s t a i e dl n yr n f o t n p er a yo e ii,t rf o aaa nt ch S r I es; n t a Ne d) a f E pc a e o y ou p d (A c n i I f s t a ni a: i g n )B i g cr i i s v e l g n ngni( a i 1 b ni r eis
- b i
r t a ou pd e f bt y t t d osy at n i eg a t t l r n ni snt as l f i c o o ogua i n s e f i p t t niol i t i pot d i i od d d e i r e r t n i e n n n u s ed a i R o ol wn pt ,h r c u c c ngoo e or s ein pc h o eid i h e t rd ss 1 t t nb a e t i n mu n a ,e z sei ev pslcyo o l r s r r r l et e u s u ein api i r n q yu wr amt n s e Ae h n o a "r e oa h R" r pbt u ct o
sen i le d g i n u i3 G tr7 o m p0 a e5 r y R g d o t t n r i n a P l e i b v2 s a E 7 es s t r 0 a e 1 o 5 B n i p e l .vR n e e c eF gd n i RC s u i R a e G d 2,0 D iu 21 ne G 0 s 4 l l g e0 1 i r n n Gl 7 W i it E e9 r Rd C i o U u E N i p NG N S e R_ a
d d e e t s ce i a m l f f p o a r e ic p s to e n m u n i l a r b p of o c s a c e a e t a e b wu r r yl o t y o t b n t t p naos mc n u e apiis er i t l R s cac at t i b cnb ss i i f t e u y i a o r n ef n s s t r N u gb t ygGu i tc s t i a o g u t to esDh f e p n r o t d ad f x i n s oe e n s e t R i t sgi nl d r m s ad e a e ao wu1 p g r u r d e ae jt a t hi yege r e xr t r r ag e nd n e D ea ei i f s b awmt od r G s i r u t o Dy s ce t t oo n1 f e s ef nGf t ut r h a aDe oF y is l T s P pN* b a B m E E
d s e i t s a f a sd d o r b ae l u e n ewitr y on o nl u o i t we gsgqn i t i id g sisne i l n e prt n i i emisb o b o f d u i d d e e pi i a t a d e g dt t 8 o h c t n c n s n r 2 a r u o n t x i u 1 r n o f t e 0 e er ad p Ga v 5t eoh e1 D e o nt xd 9 e ea h R n i ge rL t t c F R awiC s nd eg i m a eihvt eG l w "c r t n s 0 o d r r t ei poe e n v e 1 s i ,i f f p ee s b e s co n n i m,or r a et o o og e e ob f psi t n i gu e e sitcd at t n i nl r di e g e h ee u r i ut s ct g o i n s h s l od ap i J m *T e T 1 oi r v e d wpujer c
l l l n R om F 5 i ge C y l eb r 0 a R o 1 u ,r r R p y r b R g t e e p F Nn i l i i r b d n o u t e o d a t s t y r d es r r o e t r o a p l ao l p m e d t i c r m p e m e b u ep R u b u r s 3 s a n S o t 7 l I y R u gt d 0 E_ t n i e5 e e l i r r b d n r y i di o a u o r si t q a e et r e2 t d a n8iR u o r 7 v p t u9 od a l e o0 o9 r n v R N5 V1 P ae = = = t
o d fo ant c t r y n oe t e t ff e m a a d f e a s o d s t S e t y ee s nl f s e e n o a k s ml e i n e st pn n u o e i c e u n s n qy n s o e ee l a e r p r s ms e r t e d m n u d w a r ee o r r u s a dt u s c d s n xt a 1 e A S r u ec e u vT e d er m e en d eb t r s y i l R o s b f dt r ,n n o s o o u t a 8 e u n c yo a a 1 t l wh s b o s i n l 1 a r x i r b e e s 9 o ai p e a e l t sh l .p c e L ast m i .o a vio o R Gi f Amb C n k a mu
e r u w tc o x& t y s ud r e yle o s )s t n t r r el i i e a sf e s i i ps a it f g d n vis ppf a a ea m aao S d d u n s ( l l f t ol e aq o o nc a r f t it a o c gt o c y) eG t c e e n ni si rD f u t d uih l e o t i f bt nt t r u c p b y an gcn n t b oiuas e om trd s s a t ennf r k s n o a l i r ni p6is u u e s gi s ed rt r s 7 s viac g n n e n or s emmt nE o e i e d od 3 r n gt i A ndd r a n a e n p e3 u sih t e ct mt t a e n a e n1 u uu y l re mmf et s si r t b o ot i s esi t n so a c b a r a i et s y ,a n me F 8b nugavsi t 7 o i f or eb xt D i o E s yd ed a ogC r a t a si r p n 3 vb pia e n n 31 e f r o o o p l S l a r r R Sto C p P (a ih P1 0 u e u m
y te f t a aot h S h t dt i f d ew o et c n n e i e e mpv c r x e ee e n t r r a e e u db et r wc u syou l r s nb pt oa s s ny it A ao ct s n u s u e a a l e avegrh l r b e e xe a y yld m r t n ued i a o e l i o m b wded s a a m e 's v r r i a og u pGr e e S R O D pd gsu
e raep p t a o t n on d d i s e s d t d e s a o e lu r d n g i s l e t e d g s n u R si k a i c 1 n e a x o c r e a c i s f mt t r e c u c o s e s r u a f a p ef r 1 t d s e u e x r s v e n c s o e I no m7 a l d e t c r e r e r od sg oiaia r i r r r e et gb m t xe ea nEd Dd
e er r r e u u c t t a a n r r e e h ei p t ps i m w mG e eD s t-t- t r h n h o g a gf l i i l h e p h n e t f o n h s r oit s i c r e a u e n a h d o b B t a n i o t u C e y a o r b y cf f n t i o s a p l o a e ww y pe o f at s e is g R n u ni r t g g v n n o e e egleV i i s t e a sR dist t e i e oa i D r d s od pe s t ee t ot a e e r nt n r e ao e e pr n n r l bi l cigd aml n yc p ic ni a a r ni n i o o f n cO o U soc e r I D B
n e o ec gi t n a n n r a eig n ads e h ie t s n C nd i od a de n c e m d s e g es s o d d e d mp n e r v i isiro ad d o e pr d r i p n v D a oo a p o ir y y t st cp t c d in e r a i yi g g u e td p n si e q i nie ne n e l t br n ao ib d i att my a l cc a rt r c l ua el u i P rf i i t m t b t sg ga c nn np u s i r oie oa e t Cb Lc S S =
sno dn i t a ng a a is r ir e e e t a d d irir l c e a is t n yi i r r n o c g i o t r a n o C g l ui o gs t n e e t rd n o e eg i l n a t lbi v a ar i u c e u e q i l l a pn e pig n v a n g E t e i e s y eg e n d t mi e ts w l f l x e i i a We N S
ts e u n i a g g h e s t x n e ed b s u a be e o t a wt r h ou e h t t el d C c np e ex d u m u l er r t o o d w n lus f c e e g d t e h nd es ge c f e is h u nb s ot e ca a o n nl e sh D x ht o op s cd m e t t i i l f a ne a a o iw gu o l l l r c l l ee sd as a i e t t t t e n ee ss s a b lu M. r Dh nu n o c a o I I f d .s .h .t 8.d 8 s 8x 8d e 9e 9e 9e 9e h 9s 9r 9w 9l u a 1 u c 1 1 1 h t e d c ec t t e S l r r nu pn p i h pu ut en e c r Ap J s So Ss = =
l e e l i w b ru n e l t l r yc yn i g w t u u t o i i r ei l d e bt f t i s e r s e c u a a a l t sl l D o t is a r c a rt u u v es p f n r e a a h n t h t o no sm n i x o e e oit u i t t e ia s nh ng t a Gw ot al u l on a at De k l g lat t s h a n it a En r sn x or i eG ef wu ah ni o tC ie D z d n eh wE in d rt e mo e 's e u nt nC t g n1 i i m cn f n ia nS ui o o ml l t u a aS r e r l nd ot pt l sd s o p n e n ie t t sd z as t t t m i u e ae p ics a s ap mg mfie l l l I n i u m ei in c h t r n o t u igo xe s t Mirsp Eb n c Ad I = = = =
lI )eg s a e e t r b u u ot n c a 2 u r c x t ts i i n rf n o o t m U s f i ( t u i a er s a c e nh l b t if s an u x ei d n t r e i y b o o pn d t e a a4 i r a m r c c ol a l et A c .s a l m p n a v d f o e e e o s m in n v d d a t eis n o: n i u e n eio m c t l r e e r e u u S ot t c d e r d oi x c r e t e e n p sc i a s o l e e r p c ni C cr l e s ot s pl n if n t si c r i n i u e i /a n o d n c g ek f e i r d n a s e e amred s iS o o i pmioi l r r s a u r ef y wt d or e e t G etnB P e o s e r f D Linh P pI a c S mm S ' a}}