ML20217Q444
| ML20217Q444 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone  |
| Issue date: | 04/30/1998 |
| From: | Pastis H NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9805080122 | |
| Download: ML20217Q444 (120) | |
Text
LICENSEE: North:rst Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO) April 30, 1998 i FACILITY: Millstone Nucl;ir Pow:r Station, Units,1,2, and 3
/
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF APRIL 7,1998, MEETING WITH NNECO AND LITTLE HARBOR CONSULTANTS, INC. (LHC) TO DISCUSS ONGOING ACTIVITIES AND FINDINGS On April 7,1998, the Director of the Special Projects Office and his staff participated in a publicly observed meeting with LHC and NNECO representatives. The purpose of the meeting was for LHC to present the findings from its ongoing oversight activities of NNECO's programs for handling employee safety concerns at the three Millstone units. Also, during this meeting, LHC provided an update of the 12 attributes of a safety-conscious work environment, the results of its review of case files containing allegations of harassment, intimidation, retaliation, and discrimination in potential violation of 10 CFR 50.7, and the results of its continuing programmatic review of NNECO's Employee Concerns Program. LHC also distributed a copy of its matrix listing LHC's recommendations and responses.
NNECO discussed its March 31,1998, letter for readiness to restart. i Enclosure 1 is a list of the principal participants at the meeting. Enclosure 2 is a copy of the slides distributed at the meeting. 1 Original signed by':.
Helen N. Pastis, Senior Project Manager Special Projects Office - Licensing Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-245,50-336, and 50-423
Enclosures:
As stated (2) l ec w/ enclosures: See next page l l
E-Mail (w/onel 1 only) Hard Coov SCollins/FMiraglia T4feelset Flies WTravers PUBLIC PMcKee SPO-L Reading HPastis SPO Reading JAndersen HPastis SDembek OGC BBoger DMcDonald
-~
LBerry 1 BM a (BC ) T hhE JDurr, RI g DOCUMENT NAME: G:\PASTIS\MTGSUM.407 9 T's receive e capo of this document,Indicata in the box: 'C' = Copy without attachment /gpplosure *d" = Copy with attachment / enclosure *N" = No copy OFFICE SPO-L:PM ( SPO-L:L4 / D. ,P SPM[l)D NAME HPastis {lff l' LBerry Alf ' PM$ed DATE 04h/98 ' 04/ /98 04/ /98 04fl/98 04Q98 '
' l/
1 o
pa nico
!. t UNITED STATES j
l
.-- ! UC NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION p .c WASHINGTON. D.C. 20555-0001 8
\.....o April 30, 1998 LICENSEE: Northeast Nuclear Energy Company (NNECO)
FACILITY: Millstone Nuclear Power Station, Units,1,2, and 3 l l
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF APRIL 7,1998, MEETING WITH NNECO AND LITTLE I HARBOR CONSULTANTS, INC. (LHC) TO DISCUSS ONGOING ACTIVITIES !
AND FINDINGS 1
)
On April 7,1998, the Director of the Special Projects Office and his staff participated in a publicly obse'rved meeting with LHC and NNECO representatives. Tne purpose of the meeting was for LHC to present the findings from its ongoing oversight activities of NNECO's programs for handling employee safety concerns at the three Millstone units. Also, during this meeting, LHC provided an update of the 12 attributes of a safety-conscious work environment, the results of its review of case files containing allegations of harassment, intimidation, retaliation, and discrimination in potential violation of 10 CFR 50.7, and the results of its continuing programmatic review of NNECO's Employee Concerns Program. LHC also distributed a copy of its matrix listing LHC's recommendations and responses.
NNECO discussed its March 31,1998, letter for readiness to restart.
Enclosure 1 is a list of the principal participants at the meeting. Enclosure 2 is a copy of the i slides distributed at the meeting.
n , j l Helen N. Pastis, Senior Project Manager Special Projects Office - Licensing Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-245,50-336, and 50-423
Enclosures:
As stated (2) cc w/ enclosures: See next page i-l
[- '%
e 1 l
Northrst Nucle r En:rgy Company Millstona Nucliar Pow:r Station, Units 1,2, and 3 cc:
Charles Brinkman, Manager Lillian M. Cuoco, Esquire Washington Nuclear Operations Senior Nuclear Counsel ABB Combustion Engineering Northeast Utilities Service Company 12300 Twinbrook Pkwy, Suite 330 P. O. Box 270 Rockville, MD 20852 Hartford, CT 06141-0270 Mr. D. M. Goebel Mr. Kevin T. A. McCarthy, Director Vice President - Nuclear Oversight l Monitoring and Radiation Division Northeast Utilities Service Company Department of Environmental P. O. Box 128 Protection Waterford, CT 06385 79 Elm Street Hartford, CT 06106-5127 Senior Resident !nspector Millstone Nuclear Power Station Mr. Allan Johanson, Assistant Direct ^r clo U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of Policy and Management P. O. Box 513 Policy Development and Planning Niantic, CT 06357 1 Division 450 Capitol Avenue - MS 52ERN Mr. David Amerine, Vice President P. O. Box 341441 Nuclear Engineering and Support t Hartford, CT 06134-1441 Northeast Utilities Service Company l P. O. Box 128 l Regional Administrator, Region I Waterford, CT 06385 l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l' 475 Allendale Road Mr. M. H. Brothers King of Prussia, PA 19406 Vice President - Operations i Northeast Nuclear Energy Company I First Selectmen P. O. Box 128 Town of Waterford Waterford, CT 06385 l Hall of Records !
200 Boston Post Road Mr. M. R. Scully, Executive Director l Waterford, CT 06385 Connecticut Municipal Electric l
Energy Cooperative j Mr. J. P. McElwain 30 Stott Avenue Recovery Officer- Millstone Unit 1 Norwich, CT 06360 '
Vice President (Acting)- Millstone Unit 3
{
Northet
- Nuclear Energy Company Mr. William D. Meinert j P. O. Box (28 Nuclear Engineer j Waterford, CT 06385 Massachusetts Municipal Wholesale l
Electric Company Mr. Wayne D. Lanning P. O. Box 426 l j
Deputy Director of Inspections Ludlow, MA 01056 -
Special Projects Office l 475 Allendale Road Ernest C. Hadley, Esq. l King of Prussia, PA 19406-1415 1040 B Main Street P. O. Box 549 .
Mr. F. C. Rothen West Wareham, MA 02576 Vice President - Work Services l Northeast Nuclear Energy Company i P.O. Box 128 I Waterford, CT 06385 !
l
- l Millstona Nucl:ar Power Station, Units 1,2, and 3 Mr. B. D. Kenyon l cc: Chief Nuclear Officer - Millstone Northeast Nuclear Energy Company Citizens Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 128 ATTN: Ms. Susan Perry Luxton Waterford, CT 06385 l 180 Great Neck Road '
Waterford, CT 06385 Debcrah Katz, President Citizens Awareness Network The Honorable Terry Concannon P.O. Boy 83 Nuclear Energy Advisory Council Shelburne Falls, MA 03170 Room 4035 Legislative Office Building Joseph R. Egan, Esq. )
Capitol Avenue Egan & Associates, P.C. l Hartford, CT 06106 2300 N Street, NW l Washington, D.C. 20037 Mr. G. D. Hicks Unit Director- Millstone Unit 3 Mr. J. A. Price Northeast Nuclear Energy Company Unit Director- Millstone Unit 2 P. O. Box 128 Northeast Nuclear Energy Company l Waterford, CT 06385 P. O. Box 128 i Waterford, CT 06385 John W. Beck, President Little Harbor Consultants, Inc. Attorney Nicholas J. Scobbo, Jr.
Millstone - ITPOP Project Office Ferriter, Scobbo, Caruso, Rodophele, PC
, P. O. Box 0630 1 Beacon Street,11th Floor Niantic, CT 06375-0630 Boston, MA 02108 Mr. Evan W. Woollacott Mr. Martin L. Bowling, Jr.
Co-Chair Recovery Officer- Millsonte Unit 2 Nuclear Energy Advisory Council Northeast Nuclear Energy Company 128 Terry's Plain Road clo Ms. Patricia A. Loftus Simsbury, CT 06070 Director - Regulatory Affairs P.O. Box 128 Mr. Daniel L. Curry Waterford, CT 06385 Project Director Parsons Power Group Inc.
2675 Morgantown Road Reading, PA 19607 Mr. Don Schor fer Verification Team Manager Sargent & Lundy 55 E. Monroe Street Chicago, IL 60603
, Mr. P. D. Hinnenkamp Director - Unit Operations.
Northeast Nuclear Energy Company P. O. Box 128 i Waterford, CT 06385 l
l
l l- .
s o
! - LIST OF MEETING PARTICIPANTS April 7,1998 MBC W. Travers L
P.McKee i H. Pastis I e!al.
- NNECO M. Brothers D. Amerine et al. i i LdC J. Beck J. Griffin l B. Garde l
- et al.
l l
l l
l l
I' i l,
Enclosure 1 l'
p ..
!*'.s:
l p
id l
- l. -
l i
Northeast Utilities Briefing for the NRC Open'ng Remarks;
! Restart Assessment Panel.
l i
sruce Kenyon {
l . Millstone Station Presittent & Chief Executive OMicer NU Nuclear
) April 8, f998 3
- e.n ..e a ., e, -
I Northeast Utilities Agenda. The Eight Restart Affirmation Criteria Confirm the Unit is Tracking for Restart
- Restart Readinese Overview aruce Kenyon
- Safety Conscious Work ,
Dave Amrfne has been identened and corrected Environment (SCWE) SAnSFACTORY
' Unit 3 Readiness ANhe arothers 2.Compilance with licensing and design besee has Afstfy aewfing been restored Deve Smith TRACKING TO SADSFACTORY e Design Change Reviewe Pauf Groseman 3. Safety Conscious Work Environment has been
-* estabelshed t
SARSFACTORY -
I
[- 4.Self Assessment and Corrective Action
- Oversight Assessment ' John Seseler processes identify and resolve problems in a of Readiness . ach Handey timely manner Wayne Krepp SADSFACTORY lan.a,r, -
- ..,,..,,,, - )
1 l; The Eight Restart Affirmat'>n Criteria Success Objective Progress
- Confirm the Unit is Tracking for Restart g' g=. n ., j i-
- s. unit and support organimamone are ready to e ,,, g,,% ,,,
YA$NG SATISFACTORY
- '****'** ********'Y C******** '" (U*)
- 8. Entire stMion le propered to property support
- strong Nuclear =0vereJphs yes operations Sakty wsAs ye, TRACKNG TO SATISFACTORY pneneseeny .amorpency PJennene see T. Management controle and oversight sv4asures . med. ProtocWen Yes are in piece to prevent etOntAcant future - = Proc. Quealy & Adhere. Yes (U3)
SMPsfrA Y *Sedf A- Yes
- 8. Restart readinese le alRrmed poing a rigorous pgggwg o,,,,g,, .Coneesve Aasen Yes (us)
Page 1 s 4 libelosure 2
... : I
' Success Objective Progress
- . .. ';;!r=
.... .c.,,.s.,,,,,,, v <un t ,,1 *3 ~~e- <
Safety Conscious Work
..,,,, -.s!.,,c . v. Environment c ,. e,,,e., ,,
. . . . . . , , . . , , , . ,. c.~, en
- '"*'*~ osv. Am.rin.
.CL ,,, .
3 cy,Wy
';;jun
', v.,
Vice President. Human Services
. , , . , , , v..
c u o.u. .
We Have Met The 5 Internal We Have Completed Our
' Success Criteria for SCWE ReCoverv Requirements
- 1. Employee willingness to raise concerns
' 2. Line management handles issues
- Submitted SCWE Restart Readiness Letter ehetiveh
- 3. Employee Concerns Program effective
- Met Success Criteria
- 4. We recognize and address " focus areas" - Nuclear Oversight Concurs 5.ECOP concurs - - ECOP Concurs
- NSAB Concurs
- Responded to all LHC
- LHC concurrence pending recommendations i , ,,, . . , -
i I
We Are Committed to Sustaining and improving Our Employees Willing SCWE Performance To Raise Concerns
- NovemberLeadership Assessment
- Stable Human Services functions - 97,9% leaders rated effective
- 1998 2000 Work Environment
- November Culture Survey Performance Plan developed
- 82% of areas had a SCWE
- *SCWE Oversight Transition Plan to be
- February ECOP survey developed
- 95% would use theirleadersh>
' 'SCWE processes refined by lessons .
- February LHC interviews tearned
- 99% wouldreine issues to their leadorah>
- , .. 2.","If - '
Page 2
Line Management Handles - Employee Concerns Program is issues Effectively Effective
' Average age of CR evaluations is %ge of c neerns underinvestigation 8 ~ seas improved "I"
' Overdue AITTS items <3% People who would use program again have significantly increased
' Quality of evaluations >3 -
+ ECOP Judged program as effective
' Corrective action program is *LHC judged program as effective satisfactory for restart
< eNRC 40001 evaluated program as effective
- , .. , u.,,, -
We Recognize and Address Focus Areas !
" Focus Areas" Support Restart
- rocus areas are not increasing
~** N "" N
.m w,3 , u %,, m . ,
d of the remaining "rocus Areas" support restart.
- enore than 80 teedback heens froen me sh on " Success Stories"
- Desire and capability to improve
- the " people team"is being used as a '
resource for the organisanon are evident in all areas. l
. leadere know what to do '
. they are nehing Glor assentence on how to do N l
- , .. .. u.,,, -
- , .. ...., u.,,, -
We Have Met The 5 Internal Success Criteria for SCWE
- 1. Employee willingness to raise concerns
- 2. Line management handles luun effectively Unit 3 Readiness
- 3. Employee Concerns Program eNective
- 4. We recognize and address " focus areas" Mike srothers g,gcop concurs VicePrealdent Nuclearoperanons
- LNC concurrence pending
- n , a u.,,, -
l n ., .a , u.,n -
.- Page 3
/
F l .
i l*
- l l
1 i
l MP3 is Ready for OSTI Mode 2 Physical Readiness
- The following performance indicators are
' Entered Mode 4 on 417/98 required to be at goal prior to Mode 2:
Current Goal
' Scheduled to enter Mode 3 on
- Temporary Modincations 19/15 l
' 4/10/98 . Control Room & Ann. Def. 14/10
. Power Block AWOs 899/500 :
. Walntenance Rule AWOs 395/350 OperatorWork Arounds 20/10 Millstone 3 Completed Millstone 3 Completed Corrective Actions Corrective Actions
' Restart Assignments 1f,050 to be completed
- Runconn uramn e f.m m 6e comammd by (W2H6) by Mode 2(90% complete) g "gy; *"**'"*" "*** # I" * **** *I
' Deferrable 5,950 of 9,550 completed
- Deferrable configuration 428 of f,350 compared Assignments Manageant noms gnggy (MME)
- RestartICAVp OR 202 to be compared by
- Maintenance Work 36,0L,. :o be Assignmenta (ytMs) afode 2 (80% compiere)
Orders completed by Mode 2 (Wf1/98) (99% complete) e ceterresle IcAvp OR 204 of ssa compkted Assignments (3/tM8) l..n..........,e,,, _
- ..n........,,,,, _
Millstone Unit 3 Age Breakdown of Millstone Unit 3 Age Breakdown of Deferrable Engineering Backlog Deferrable Level 1 and 2 Condition um. ion. s.u.,cn im Reports ullistone 4.Marta19s4
. I---l -
g I --- I j- .. :
l_._.i -
I :,.
i i
( lp==== e == I ene i
Page 4 l
l
l 1
1-Millstone Unit 3 Age Breakdown of Deferrable Temporary Modification Backlog M4Hetone 3. March iest Millstone 3 3,
I---I Regulatory Readiness 1
I l . -...
gggl. . .
l Marty Bowling Recovery Officer
~~ Millstone Unit 2 5-?
" ~"
l..,,..........., -
NU is On Track to Fully Restore Compilance With NRC Requirements
- 50.54 (f) response has been submitted -
programs and processes are in comphance with 10 CFR 50 Appendix B Regulatory Readiness
(
- SCWE Readiness Letter has been submitted
- Deferred items Management Plan submitted
- Two remaining licensing actions to be David A. Smith j _ submittedin April Manager, Unit 3 Regulatory Compilance
- Restart corrective actions are on track to support scheduled NRC inspections l m.,,s.-u n-.e s , -
l ** nan * "n*** *"ws =
l NRC (MC0350) Significant items List The Remaining NUREG 0737 Closure is On Track To Support SIL Zone 38 Items Will be Restart Completed By April 20 ' l
'86 SIL Zones required to be e NU review of remaining 36 of 50 items is addressed ongoing
, *216 SIL Packsges identified in
- These reviews have Identified l these zones weaknesses that are being addressed i
prior to resubmittal
- '215 SIL Packages submitted for
- Compilance with NUREG 0737 will be NRC Review confirmed prior to Mode 2; Mode 4 and 3 l
leaues resolved i
l n .. u ,, -
- n.ns.~, n~=- u , -
Page5 i i l
.= .
c .
i l
- i. 1 1 1
,' Remaining 10CFR50.54(f) Technical Specification !
! Significantitems Are On Track For Restart Change Requests
- SFp notaflex UnderNRC review
- 179 items remain that have actions
- Shutdown Margin Monitor UnderNRCreview
. for restart - !'
e instrument Survelltence underNRCreview
- 4333 items have had their restart Chenge assignments closed
- pressuriserLevelChange UnderNRCreview
- Inadvertent Safety April 9 injection l
l
" " 2
- , ... ,,, - I I
l 4 l i License Amendment' Requests Licensing Bases'and l
! .. Inspection Status j t
- ARCOR Coating . UnderNRC review
- aosoo - correcu,e scuons on evneroes ror no na idennned at NRC puhuc esN
!
- RSS Direct injection Under NRC review
- ICAvp Tier 1 and Tiers 2/3 - responses due l
- RWST sackloakage April 30 * **Y ~* * * " '
\
progress
- Motor operated valves - response due Apr# as '
- 36 open NRC home required for entry into Mode 2 l
l I
l l'
l The FSAR is Being Maintained l
- March submittal has brought the FSAR l current through November 15,1997
- Noat sub ntaiis ech.duied for June and will g g I= -baisne. of itn7 chang.s Results t'
i - Mode 4 requ! red items
~1998 changes that are ready for subental
- The Quartetty update schedule willthen Paul Grossman begin and continue to maintain pending Director, Enginsierlag.NPJ changes atlow levels l n . , , ,,, -
l n ., , , ,, -
Page 6 l
l i
The ERT Determined Causal The Current RSS Modifications i Factors Were: Addressed All the Causal Factors
- Physical Cause -
- vibration 4nduced fatigue of the expansion
- Pipe spool addresses expansion joint joint sleeve liners design issues l'
- Root Cause: The design change package d6d i not address the correct use of expansion joints ePipe spool addresses the localized
- eMects of locallaed how condations in the expansion joint not fully understood
- Increased flow with direct injection
- nund loads on the sleeve liners were not modification addressed with pipe fully evaluated < spool
} ., - determination of design limits on the expansion joint was incomplete a., .,an un ,, -
- a.m..,== -u~,1 -
1 I
l A Design Review Of Modifications implemented This Outage is Being Conducted
- As a result of issues with both the R$$ and RHS 1
Configuration Management "* w
- yi.,,4*
, ',,o",d'7,,c ti , s,,, ,iia.n. no
. Activities - wem of design engin. ors is sere.ning for safety signancance and reviewing modtecations made this outage
- input from current self assessments and -!
Raymond P. Nocci '"' ***** '**8'"' "'e being used as !
I Direct? AfP W
- scope includes DCRs, MMoOs and PDCRs
- ., an r -
- a.~ ~,=~a-*~m' -
The Results of This Design Review Conclude: Scope Expansions Revealed:
I
'
- For Mode 4 required design changes, ' System interactions that were not there are no open design or post. previously identified modification testing issues
- FSAR and OE reviews will be
- Reviews of Mode 2-required design complete prior to Mode 2 - no
- changes are on-going significant issues identified to date L
- Two CRs have been issued to address L documentation discrepancies t.
4
- a., . ,
,, - ; a., .., == - e . -
Page 7
E ....
l
.:. : .r,
(
Nuclear Oversight is Conducting a Comprehensive Review of the
' esign Change Process Des 5gn Control and
.Procesa implementation + Desien Process Review Assessment
- RSS ERT and BATP Root Cause Phil DiBenedetto ActingDirector, Analysis 4
Programs NuclearOversleht l 49 og o ,. . . - . . . . . . . . . - ; .. ........ . , _
l L Review Criteria Focused on " Smart
! Sample" of Recent Modifications Documents Reviewed
! . o ienproni se st
. noeuresproerna n.acc,n emme est
. sr n- me.e st e 11 DCRs
. Leesuems sApproermaet e 9 MMODs
. a e onc e n.n.ve ,
. caicuisuonssuspenthen eent . * "7 MSEEs
,- . Proc.eue.an secamensmenen st l- . 88.88. Cornpiece, Con.ct, and Acceptamist
. P.st Memncation Teoting Adequate?
- Acceptancemoviewatcone.cto. wort?
45 f es
,- l a n .-s , -
- ..,, ., . .., e ,,,
l-Results corrective Action for RSS Vibration Reviewed for Compliance with
. Acceptable 7 10CFR50, Appendix B
. Acceptable . Process issues is ' Review included:
I . Technical issues 4
-a are es e OWons (Mesolunon Prior to neede t) -DCR Developm nt
. Not Acceptable for Mode 4 0
- Sa EvaluaHe Development
- Pump Loading Calculation Reviews
- Retrieval of the Liner Parts
( - -EAT Pump Air sindins Root Cause Accepts 6de 47 as Page 8
)
s . .
I I
, J Corrective Actions Were Developed and -
Implemented in Accordance With the Design Control Program and 10CFR50, Appendix B
' Final DCR Package - Acceptable
- Safety Evaluations \cceptable Nuclear Oversight Restart
- Testing (Pump V;bration) . Acceptable * *** *"
' Calculation Reviews (Pump Norale Millstone Unit 3 Loads) Acceptable
,
- Parts Retrieval (AllMajorPloces John Streeter l Recovered) Accepta6fe Recovery Officer, Nuclear Oversight \
' Overall RSS Expansion Joint Failure Resolution . Acceptable 1 l
I Presentation Topics _ Formal Process Implemented '
ForReadiness Assessment
+ R.. dine.. A.m.m.nt proc . son H.ne.y *Sei cted eoordinstor and team
- Mode 4 Readiness Aeoessment sob Handey
- selected attributes
+ startup & Power Ascension see HanJey
- Weekly meetings to status issues Assessment
- Incorporated NORVP results
- m sm Wem W . , Added emergent issues i.
' Continuous monitoring ofline activities t
Assessment Results Startup and Power Support Mode 4 Readiness Ascension Oversight
- All Mode 4 assessments completed
- Assess power ascension progress
' Full shift coverage of modo changes
' Oversight concurred with Unit 3
- Oversight : overage based upon unit Mode 4 OSTI Readiness schedule and performance
- ,, ... ...a.=..,,,e, -
Page 9 1
t y n
. r e t
. t o m ns a s d -
c e e a vd ice n s o
rde s
f f ik e is pe na t s t
a e ge os S ImN iW S NA -
G R B 8
9
- k; T'in ggg y g g[
gh} QQ $o g
- h~ p, sx
.2 . [ 4v
!h
/
4 h. Y Y g Y B h. p $ 5 gfi $g g g, C# pW (( %rw 1 'c Mn g Q g T
-g } .
4 p }2 {'a {T3 T y' . ,
j g [
g y 8
9 1
0%.6{4 g. h g'. g}j. .
y; f j g W- f;. .
y d, d =-
{ g g j__, y 0 d, y Y 5 Y g Y Y g iM Y Y g @R 2 ,
/
3 Mn-a ff
{
h'*
[ {
g i y r ,
!. _n 8
C
]3 @j p g j U %
rg Q g3 jg s
}; g Q Y y &
Y 1
( Y Y Y 6 6 y
%[ ]{i Q{ y 6
/ -
i i :
Y Y P y- yh', h 3 [ ;
[s b } 1, 8 s ]f 7; j.
~d g 4 9 K",a.
gi V
j
%}@'(g g. K g $
P
/
Y { Y y Y Y ]j/
0 2
/
2 'jI;
% ; fij G,
j;
's Q
E Y
d KM Y
j y ,
Fa.
I-J
- g. Y
'g, Y
R % p f { 'h g jy y.
l f ?
h 8
9 h % (i Q @
Q' R Q p @h
/
Y Y Y Y E $#
6 1
2 y { J Q
? s {
3 %
Mp; Q' Y Y Y j
y Y Y O
i T
8 M f N %s. Y [ M 3
9
/
% Y l
f f Y Y Y h Y Y
@, Y % $g W., Y Y 8 8
[ %$ Q N
2
/
1
[
M g QM 9 4
2
/
4 2
9
/
g $
i 8 % f, % $i h M d d 9
1 9 Y M[
Y Y Y Y _ { Y Y E Y g ]$
d Y Y e
c n
e c
n M( M
{[ f 1
f f 3 1 7
I [
i j
(
h [J
[
f' Q p p
}{
i e m
m e
m m
9
/
9 Y Y Y Y d Y
'}.
P 5 Y Y Y Y M'. Y Y { d l,l j $ c o
c o
t i
1
/
2 1 % y T5 2 M E2 @
Y i
t n
o i t
n o
n a a u
7 f u
@ h %, M h
l l
9
/ a a 5
/
Y Y Y Y Y R Y Y Y Y Y Y 5 Y Y E v
E v
2
@ k % N $ V;5 U *f v 1
7 " ?
9
/
1 2 Y Y Y @ Y Y Y Y "3'd Y Y Y Y d I1 Y Y Y 0 Y Y
'4 1 i E
1 1 S 4. E $
e c
t n n y
r n e r g o e e v m h e e n )
i s
o g d e g c s i
r 4 n c n n n o e e e a /A n c t
i n a o o i n
d s
R n y n i i t o o A l
i t n t a t i a C p p c t a M r n o h M a l l
P & m e e r
e M (
e e i u o n s c g n Q r p t t l m i I
I A P o a o e w s A s r to g o r
e C r O t n t i g o p i l n c y y P f n P i s e e a a t n n r c n o y e c e v v r ru n o g t tr y m te ha i
h r s to s s O u d e o a &
C n i
c e
n u s tr n o t l r
e s c / g e e a a E g t i
o r C p n
i i d A e B i e k t i
r l u r a i n d m r P e u a f r A f r n c i
g r n te g W e d i u
n e c v e d i t r
o S o o i
e e l
n o a a e C m a a i
o h o a W M M R S E R Tr C C Se En F M r r t L S C N C P E i
S
)ll l 1lll 1
y g
r e
n E
g r a
i n le c
u t N e t s
a e 8 9
h t
e r
M 9 N o
1 U ,
N
/
7 C l i
r R p N
/ A C
H L
- N y
g s e s r e
a r e i n
r r
e E n
d h e h r a
n t o m t
o l e
e g B r
A B r
N c
u e e e t s
A k v k a e
i a i ht s M D M r o
i e k r
N t
i o) -
l i
t s WEW _
s U k r uC k s
t a i(
oS r a
s m e
ct sn m a R ne e e g om R h n Cn yo g
t i n
r n t r i s
o e p f ei v o
an N
l O SE C
+ + +
s /
~
llll llll \
y g
r e
n E
r a
e t s l sn u e i e
c v
N t
c u
s r a i
om c e nS e e h
t r
s o n n ia o
N nr rmu e
oi v mH A-t Cn e n ve yE ad t Dies f
ek r r ao P e
SW i V
c x '
3
e
~
S x
y s g r
n e n
l r e e E aE c v r rWno a
n i
t c e m l e
c s el u t
eC c e e u f
f b e ro N
t nSr i s s ais mp g n h s
a e
I 5of r s
a" r s i
d t
r o
o e g s n N e a t l sd n r o re e p
hi s P d Tr e e a s da t
n nh n e tt gt r n n d ei r e e n m i
c a s MC l
l m n s s weg Ci e i
o r u e es z s s n c sa vs e ay e nl e ee g n o
ae y a vy o c c C Hc c l o mit o p e clp e r "s P H L
e u nf e aO mif meeC r WS ELeE WaE 1 2 3 4 5 4
s /
i
- s y
g r
e s n E
r s r e
ut s a
e n l c
One u i
d N a '
s r t e
dmR s
u a -
t e e t c
n h
t e
r r o l
eri t
a C N o
pu s t C mq e R e i ah r
eiss g
s H
L s C oR E W
t i
r r
r u
r ul e c c ao l
n y C v n n ot i er C sO oot a ve S s r CCd d av d e a e n e c ePB de Hoc t t c u
l COA uCS nm i
r o pm ee meSNEN bt t s o WR SL ue e t
M
- - - e c Rr e
+ + +
s e
~
y g
r e r e
u b s E n
O o n r s t o a e
og n n s l c
o a s u t n e i l
e N c nd P t
dic e vn t
n ee n l
y t
s a
e t oa u mp oi o b h t
r r d ipmfr t
s nl oe t
i s e n
N o
m mo erv ciev n i a f mif r i v
r nd En T r e r
ode e s CnP Skl at h e _
a n rP o g s _
e i s -
rg E aWces r e c
AnW m u0n0a mop e
v de o r enci H 0 EoEe n p
d WiSt a l e2r-a9r oWvWr b8f l
e _
s t 9eCeCa e u ++
S1PSdSl
+ +
S s '
6
, i llIi!iIl,l1 il\11j I il)l
- N y
. P Is
.n e.
g r
. =
. O .
C.
lt A
s u.
n
- ~
- a
- e t.
n
~
. EC f s - ?
= ..+ t.
o ;
^ . .
P E
W.
t 4 l.
n
+
. :. ~
- 5
, c,
- e.
u e
E s ' C.
P p :E ;
r e r a
.t t - . .. :S --
n '
't .
l.. .:S:E t
e v
. . P . e7 e*
'e
- l e
E . .C.
htE-0 A '
c o
t u
= = .-
n -
e m N T m :
n --
o a t y s r ,
i
',,
- a es E v
n
'; Y e '*
- e ON- ht se k '
r ';
o ~ r o
nu W o --
=
s g N _
os ps i
c s
n o
u o
o'
"- 0 3
g in t.
i t
0 e
L.
e n
e s
e.
e.
e
- t. k .. : te C .. i: : g s
g
. t y ." : , u t .':: g
. n a
eE e .
f
= o e,
n P a
S o =
RW t e
s n
y-dC o p ,-
Aw s
i e pS i,
R P ?
d l O , l i - e .. 8 a
p u N e M
n e t,.
a a nr .
, e E ?
et R M e i
s.
- , i e c i. , ! wer R
r . P n e f,. ? (n et o CGo . e .
- !D eIn?
.X:.
I f E .!Rt teyt t w e.s: H.t E. J- C.
e!I r
f ste ep s .
s 7.. i. :
- n. ,
e . l e .e:0 : 7. enteaim c "5.C u e. .e "l, 5.ea o ns ae 1 e.
6., ., ll oehh nsrP r gR r e l" n.e nlt tpgg i
P
= eMc
. i l
., il hh
,. E o C s .. se
.WPRP ,s
.i .elle l .c tiiae t
. .l gt nn e e MCRAU SHMN ,i te ll etnee r tt 9
. i e l gi o og m rlESPP 2 9 n1 9
. o .
l2 e
l.li.
r .
ep-l I
RA-s /
7 i\ll
\ili;i! l 1! l l
- N y
g r
e n
E y
ifC " ,g g d
e r t
R 1 7 it nt c c a
GEe0it 0 p e
t f NoN m
i 5 f m
Po C l
c e
v s u in t
c e
o r ti r c e
v s it n c o n N
f C oA ei t r
r c oA ia' t
o t s
Osn n
a t
C c ig iod e f e d e
t e
t t f s l
a r e ol # E ilat o e e v
P p gdp n itn e0 7
E 7 m 0C o
n i om ll Po i C I
h t
nr t 5 .
I b e 5
O
- r o
t a s e
b m
Y oe n
d e
d d
l m
e e
4, s
w.
s e,
d de t
a e.
n d.
in l
l ih g
N a i n-c / C 6 t s
i a e
6 o ""
- v. S t s i an l
D il .
h C N*
s i
co m e
c n
o rff ioE t
t c
e
?
t n ? s Ye 7 n 0 de 5i c
v e
eP fC n g t C e c e ns P Mt on i t
i s
e r
p [" e e rdo n
s a s e
i C O n em n y ~ r ieps r
r E io
- rw t e e w sP de " ec t
a Pa g vde r r n Ci atsi eb i
y et s e Es te faun n'Ad A *- io n
w ec '- we s f is ne oK pE v
n r
p r were Mdr s e e is ns s l r
a t aC s s I id s r
- i. d e r g
u a Rn e g L A. -Pc - ,e iv g 3el e l
C miil l
r 5 h n v
rO re g i
r e I fo l
E s s
tno I t e
N
=
C * #oc e
c l
o a t o
r t Ret o s o A c t sd P e nnY "7,<I
t e Kl a e eI ng pE Ei t gne
@RsW e C
n o .d l an e nG e eF e n into m S e
g d -
a8 f d' e am n ll iP I a s r wee efs ioae O
i T
r 8"*
ed o
r s 8' -
,s dt e
r e n
ni s s7 t
a te igig
""Ae8 i
8' h 1 l t s .
? L8 1 p3 r ve o nC n r I
re re g
n e d l
Don t e
it r N De # e Ri t a rf e
ef es e en g I c Rg a g I ig I
Enee N*
" gv g I e - t D sd el iE Ill ir T nse Reiv T
r IA l ov Nn Ug ve Ihc ed I
s /
8 l
1 y
g r
e n
E r
)o a le s )e r g
a c
u _
wd e re n u a s e N
t s
i ewc en isy V1 > s h
t a
e viov n r
o ee r c Ol Ml r
e N
Rs e0 7 ( (a de cn d e _
5 det a odett a _
l eiR l
F t et aiCte t
ann ai t iannt F
i e iaciiat F sC a0 t
nmtrsf enmt da a rs PC1 agstl et ebf e suEtst eb e u Cd et i Iebu dn nnu gb dsn Eoe snI asiul i l
siun l t 4374i653 h Co6 5 1 4 8 P - - - C - - -
20 1 21 2
++ +
s 9
y g
t r n e p n e i i r E _
me h e r a
sv s r
h t le c
sit e o u gsec d t N n nse r sf f yE e
a e s u s
e t
s a
e i
l l eAep d vW r C l
yirw s h
t r
o i
cieuSeees Wnh orsr t
aS artuvhii rv e e ees N
eCesrdsst s
d r et u
ee adlusOl Cldp a
hP d
uni i
a r
ysL eae C a C u H uhi oi e o s r rEo l
a y wL y wr pRar%ee l
b 9 b % r % r %d e
m o m7 m2 a 5 a 9a e9 e8 u9 u r9l e E T 'ov v r
N N
obebe-F F
+ + + +
s '
0 1
y g
r e
n E
s s r l
e i l
a e
c s
d n N u
ny i o i s t s
al e t a % 3 m a
e Hv t i l
u a
3 a
r gt r h
.t N
r o
t nc v s n s o a e
eef R mo ei t rt ps mf Csi t a n er eE f oaS y u o r gs o l
i T a t cf a e d T v ay n e u g0 a3 I
e A f e ro a s e e oivt Ms g <-
- u y t ca c
l a dr t ef s e
i rd l r
eo e a ri i
n vo v u ota AgOQCs L + + + +
s '
1 1
- N y
i s g r
e n
n E
o m e r a
v e s i
a t
le r a g
d i v a c g i metci a s et N u
o t
s r af c m t gref ef e a s
r e r a e
P v o c f e
g h n r s t a s ro n r i pi o se r e ey ma p N nv ri d slt un a md t n r e e c u dac og r a g at c e s l
uf i r u nf f n oi n p ol a r
C oE r ede wgd c v os ed i p v e
n oh g e1 e o r wa sd g 0 e
y f cp eh j ud 0e 0v o ml pnPj u4i t l
o i e s oaOCCc e i
p ga egCHRf f Ah PaEL Ne m + + +++
E s /
il ll 1
{llql
~
y g
d r e
e r n E
n n s r o o r a
i a e f n l e
c r d m o8 u a N T eg ra t
n/9 t s
n i4 l
g a n di d2/ e e en or e4 ht r
e p n o i
hasr iy N b i t t r bb a
l s bE a t ms oe a tWs sCk cl u h eS c ed t f i u bo n oot qsl l
m e %n r a e wtn i
m 5e ed ga 9e va nd g
e l yb aeinn l
reh a av e ewiu e ad n Nha W~ nTr e r
a + + +
M s '
3 1
t\ lll ,l
/ '
y g
r e
n E
e e r s r
a e
t n e rdm r a u c l
c u
e no oso N vhas ei t
f ef t s
r e st eo du a a s es ps e
h a
e oeit par ra n a l oim nro t
r o
N r u e ef -
o edot t r o v e hs Ar glvgn p dwt u s a vl oim l
ssp pn u sni i
ws i
nui c i a
i en e r. p aoe oe r su se u l rh gt F a orsd nra sthoilo e o oi v u el e vh i t
ct sd crbl oke ane .
oe a sa es a fhn et n vie ar AwursAera
+ +
n 4
1 lli
i l!il '
~
y g
r e
e t n n E
)
h e n r a
d e
t y s mo e si t l
e c
u b
u s a s t
e a c N i
n d e i ed s n t
s a
r e s n a t t e p
n o a e a u a e ht o l u pd shd r o
(c vr ee s ed s wnd N eaib sl n e nd aet a e sded n s s v ede i
a sh a n nit stel p eit o cl onm r a nfoea pio e c e o Al pn t r a
st e
r cf f a eiet smc s s s s npn l
s n e ome uieiiiinl t
n e e e a n n pi m e
m c cg e de de de nsis s f f f f oaad e n in o e F h a - - - - tcla ss Tm Apa
+ +
s '
5 1
y gr e e n
t w s i s o E r
s y e h a e
e r h e h t
a s
n o
l c
u t
m a e N d e o d c t gr o r e n s d nf f
s a a e
e s u noos t A "s a ht i
s b m gi t di s r e o daere s e t i i nazt os a
N n r c s n s u k c
ei bnt a r a o aAi e t o n i
gsdi a "s beighf r
s r
o wg n
z s nimeos et "m wi e ok iu e sl efS ah et n s ncr go asdpdr eb 0st ro6s eo r k srt a
e nelp f r ai oFaa ehc a c o e e o cd e r a e yd c" eemt u a oc er S "p uol r r e a ehott R e e o "n es s e e -
u wb mother _
e c o - - - _
W F
+
s ' .
6 1
y g
r e
n E
r s a e
u e l c
t" a s v N u
t t s e a o r t r p s a
e sadr nA m h t
at s a s i r o
e re ru e c t o
s
. N ya ARbomF u" t
ir l
ia e
str ng b l uo cphna eir nt
. al pa an op tit e as ci t
Fu vmredn eet n e S i l rr e e o rei v ad b hpie p s et u e re WfosDa
+ +
s 7
1
y g
r s e n E n
l r e aE e c v r a
rWo n e i
n c m t l c
s el e u eC c N -
e b f -
f e o t
t e nSr u s -
r g a s s mp e -
I i s n h 5or ai s
a" r s i
d t
r o
f o e g s n N -
e a t l sd n oe r r e
p hi s Pd Tr e e a s da t
n nh n e -
tt gt r d ei r n n e n m -
e c a s MCim i
l l
n s s e
we es s gay Ci nz cu o e r s
s vs e nl ae ey a evy e o oc e g n a -
C Hc cl o mit o ce "s P H L
p e clp r aO e u mif nf e meeC WS ELeEWraE 1 2 3 4 5 y '
8 1
l
\
i s - j 1
l OVERSIGHT OF MILLSTONE !
EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM Little Harbor Consultants Presentation to NRC and NNECo l April 7,1998 l / N April 7,1998 Presentsuon to NRC and NNECe en I Entployee Concerns Program
\ 1 ACTIVITIES COMPLETED I
REVIEWED.
27 Non HIRD 29 HIRD (Non 50.7 Files); 55 Alleged 50.7 Files Implementation of LHC Recommendations
! ECP Self Assessments ECP Manual, Rev 3
- ECP Administration Control Documents
/ \
Apru 7,1999 Presertauen to NRC and NNECe en 2 Employw Concerns Program I
l 1
)
,l N /
ACTIVITIES COMPLETED REVIEWED (Continued):
Investigative Process for Allegations of Retallation Joint investigations Guidelines, Rev 2 ECOP Reports Related to ECP ECP Monthly Reports Completed Feedback Forms Sent to ECP From CI's e s AprE 7,1998 Presentauon to NRC and NNECe em 3 Employee Concerns Program i
\ /
ACTIVITIES COMPLETED I INTERVIEWED:
25 Employees Who Used ECP l
l 10 Employees involved with " Joint investigations Guidelines" 9 ECP Staff Members ,
l l
- s April 7,1998 Presentasea to NRC and NhTCe en 4 E*ployee Concerns Program l
, 2 l
e ',
~
P I
, Y ACTIVITIES COMPLETED i
OBSERVATIONS:
ECP Staff Meetings Training of ECP Investigators Triage Reviews Closure Panels l
10 CFR 50.7 Review Process ECP/ Peer Representative Meeting
/ x Apru 7,1998 Presentauon to NRC and NNECe en 5 Employee Concerns Program i
1 s !
\ / l 1
REMAINING ACTIVITIES TO BE l COMPLETED l t
L Complete Reviewing Alleged 50.7 Files (10 l Files)
Complete Contacting Allegers (HIRD/50.7 Files)
Complete Analysis of NNECo 50.7 i Classification l -
Random Review of Open Alleged 50.7 Allegations
/ \
Apru 7,1993 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe en 6 Employee Concerns Program 3
N /
CONCLUSIONS:
EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM Employee Satisfaction Continues to improve
- 88% of Those Contacted Would Use the ECP Again
- Communication With Employees Has increased and improved
- Contact With Employees
- Chronological Log Reviews
- Review of Closure Letters All Organizations Have Committed to Using the Joint investigation Guidelines (JIG's)
/ \
April 7,1998 Presentation to Mtc and NNECe en 1 Employee Concerns Program N /
CONCLUSIONS:
EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM ECP Processing Manual Rev 3:' 4
- More User Friendly
- Forms Have Been Greatly improved
- Development of a Rapid Resolution Process Provides a Good Mechanism for Handling and Documenting issues Conducive to Fast Resolution
- ECP Investigations Are Well Performed and Documented
- Manual Compliance is Good
/ s April 7,1998 Presentation to Mtc and NNECe en B Employee Concerns Program 4
~
]
N /
j CONCLUSIONS: 1 EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM Chronological Log Entries Are Consistent and Complete A Consistent Closure Process is Being Used Additional Training in Sensitivity in Dealing
.With Employees Has Been Conducted Qualification Records Have Been Reviewed and Documented Additional Training in How to investigate HIRDIAlleged 50.7 issues Has Been Conducted
^""'"' *
"C";".'OJ,:."O#.**" ,
\ /
CONCLUSIONS:
EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM Multi-faceted Concerns Are Now Classified, Counted and Tracked As individual Concerns ECP Management's " Big Picture" Understanding of Collective ECP issues lias improved Self Assessments Were Performed and Corrective Actions Are in Process ECP Contribution to " Lessons Learned" Process Has Been Significant
/ \
AYU 7* 5 * * *** $8 5
i s -
CONCLUSIONS:
EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM
- ECP Processing Manual Rev 3 Does Not -
Adequately Address ECP's Commitment to Control Potential Operability and Reportability issue Through the Use of a CR The Reason That Employees Are Not Using i Line Management is Determined
- This Information is Provided to Executive Management 3
- it is Not Apparent That Management is Acting on l This Information -
/ \
Apr0 7.1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECs on 11 Employee Centerns Prograrn s /
CONCLUSIONS:
EMPLOYEE CONCERNS PROGRAM The Site Exit Process for Both NNECo Employees and Contractors is Still Not Being implemented Consistently or Effectively Implementation of the JIG's is Adequate; but There Are Some inconsistencies and Need for Additional Program Guidance and Training
/ s Aprl! 7.1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNTCs em 12 Employee Concerns Fregreen O
6
1 i
t i
l
\ /
! LHC RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ECP t
PROGRAM Require Concerns With Operability and Reportability Potential to Be Documented on CR's Management and SCWE Should incorporate the information About Why Employees Chose ECP instead of Line Management and Take Appropriate Corrective Actions i
/ s April 7.1998 Presentauen to NRC and NMCo en 13 Employee Cencerns Program i
s /
LHC RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ECP PROGRAM i
Implement the Exit Process Effectively to Assure All Terminating Employees and Contractors Are Processed in Accordance With Procedural Requirements Assure Consistency in Use of JIG's Through Further Guideline Definition and Training
/ s j April 7,1998 PresentaUen to NRC .nd NNECe en 14 Emrleyn Concerns Program I
/.
7
? 8
' ~
l . ..
I i
x /
l CONCLUSIONS l A:
l ECP Has Adopted Exceptional 50.7 Allegation i Review, investigation, and Analysis l Procedures l
ECP Training on Investigating Alleged 50.7 l Issues is State-of-the-Art Implementation of New Analysis and Investigation Procedures Not Yet -
Demonstrated I
/ \
April 1,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe on 1$
Employee Concerns Program 1
I i x /
l-RECOMMENDATIONS Continue Training of ECP Investigators Through Use of Critical Case Analysis Reexamine 11 Closed Files identified by LHC l -
Conduct Vigorous Self-Assessments on New W-Investigations into Retallation Allegations Utilizing Revised 50.7 Analysis
/ x April 7,1998 i Presentatka to NRC and NNECe en 16 Empl yee Concerns Program 8
. j 1
1
/
4 l
UPDATE ON LHC REVIEW OF CORRECTIVE ACTION l PROGRAM !
Little Harbor Consultants i 1
Presentation to i NRC & NNECo April 7,1998 ,
' s April 7.1998 Presentauen to Mtc and NNECe en Site I CarrecUve Acuon Program
/
UPDATE ON LHC REVIEW OF CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM.
Previous Review of Corrective Action Program (CAP) Concluded That:
- CAP Was Acceptable Through Specification of Corrective Actions (CAs), But Could Be improved
- Insufficient Progress Had Been Made in implementing Corrective Actions to Reach Conclusions LHC Made Recommendations for improvement This Update Focused on Reviewing Effectiveness of Programmatic improvements and Status ofimplementation of Unit 3 CAs
' s
! April 7.1998 Presentauen to NEC and NNECe em $4te 2 CorrecWye action Prograan 1
l l
ACTIVITIES COMPLETED BY LHC TO UPDATE ASSESSMENT OF CAP Reviewed Program Procedures and Instructions Newly issued or Revised Since Last Evaluation
~
Attended Four Unit 3 Mgmt. Review Team (MRT) Meetings Interviewed Key Personnel involved in CAP Reviewed Various Summary Reports Prepared By or About Program
- s A Pril 7,1998 Presen . e h1C and TCe .n Sete 3
\ /
ACTIVITIES COMPLETED BY LHC TO UPDATE ASSESSMENT OF CAP
- Reviewed Status ofimplementation of CAs for 10 Unit 3 Level 1 CRs initially Reviewed in Previous Evaluation
. Reviewed a Number of Recently issued Unit 3 Level 1 and Level 2 CRs to Assess Effectiveness of Recent Program
. Enhancements
/ \
4,,, ,. i ,,
g,..g,c, .gc. .. .
2
\
/
CONCLUSIONS FROM 3/98 UPDATE ASSESSMENT OF CAP Implementation of Corrective Actions for
" Older" Unit 3 Level 1 CRs is improved 1
Acceptance of " Ownership" by CR Owners is Varied. At the Same Time, implementation of CR Ownership Concept Has Yielded Other Benefits
- Improved Coordination Between CRs
- Interim Review of Progress in implementing Corrective Actions
' x April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECe en Site 5 Corrective Action Program e
1 l
\ /
CONCLUSIONS FROM 3/98 UPDATE ASSESSMENT OF CAP NU Has implemented Acceptable Program improvements And Has improved Unit 3 Performance to Address the Recommendations Previously Made by LHC
- Procedure Revisions and Newly-issued Unit instructions Have incorporated Most Recommendations
- Training, increased Experience and improved Review During implementation Have Addressed Remaining Recommendations
/ x Apr8 7,1999 Presentatlen to NRC and NNECe so site 6 Corrective Action Program 3
N /
CONCLUSIONS FROM 3/98 UPDATE ASSESSMENT OF CAP Several Level 1 CRs Have Been Written Based on Management Recognition of Trends, but it is Not Evident That the Formal Review of Level ~
~ 2 CRs Has Been Effective in Identifying Trends It is Evident That the Role of the MRT is Critical to the Successful Performance of the Corrective Action Program. Itis Essential That the MRT Maintain a High Degree of Vigilance in Executing its Responsibility
/ \
April 7,1998 Present* den to NRC and NNECe on Sue 7 1
CONCLUSIONS FROM 3/98 UPDATE
- ASSESSMENT OF CAP l
The MRT Has a Crucial Role in Preventing inappropriate " Paper-to-paper" Closure of Corrective Actions it is Still Too Soon to Determine the Effectiveness of Many CAs, but Program
- Requirements Have Been Added to increase Focus on Effectiveness
- CR Owner Assigned Explicit Responsibility for an Effectiveness Review
- CR Owner Required to Report to MRT on Effectivensss
- N AN
- M bN 08 8 OE I 4
/
LHC RECOMMENDATIONS:
CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM Senior Management Should Participate in and Maintain Oversight of the Activities of the MRT to Assure it Meets Management Expectations Management Should Take increased Action to Assure That the Acceptance of the CR Ownership Responsibilities by CR Owners is Uniformly High s
4,,, ,. i . . ,
n....g,...g,$c.;.7g..
, ,, sus s -
LHC OVERALL ASSESSMENT:
CORRECTIVE ACTION PROGRAM ;
Overall Assessment The CAP is Currently Performing Acceptably Well Through implementation of Corrective Actions for Unit 3 i It is Still Too Early to Confirm the Long-term )
Effectiveness of Many of the Corrective Actions Being implemented I
, s j
Apen ?,lt98 a N en She 10 heng,Uon
,, h NR ,
5
\ /
LHC REVIEW OF MILLSTONE INDEPENDENT & SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAMS Little Harbor Consultants Presentation to NRC & NNECo April 7,1998
- s d.""""."*"L'Es?.;"'.".W.*; ms
\ /
MILLSTONE'S OVERSIGHT & SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAMS Operate in Conjunction With Corrective Action Program to identify and Correct Problems Represent Another Comerstone of a Safety Conscious Work Environment Oversight Plan: "The (LHC) Team Will Evaluate
} the Licensee's Self-Assessment and Performance Effectiveness Capability...to Assure That a Safety-Conscious Work Environment Will Be Maintained..."
- s Ov r and Sel a sme re as l
1
i s-1 i.
f.
/
LHC ASSESSMENT OF SITE'S OVERSIGHT PROGRAMS 1
l Site's Governing Oversight Procedure, NGP 2.38, Rev. 5, " Nuclear Assessment Program" ,
identifies Three Assessment Activities l - Self-Assessment i - independent Internal Oversight (Nuclear l Oversight)
- j. - Nuclear Safety Assessment Board (NSAB)
LHC Assessment Covers All of These
! / s April 7,1998 Presentauem to NRC and NNECe on 3 Oversight end 5et0 Assessment Fregrams
\ /
I LHC EXPECTATIONS:
SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAM l
The Program is Adequately Defined in Program Manuals and/or Procedures Management Provides Support for and is i
Involved in implementation of Program The Program Has Been Implemented at the Unit / Group Level
/ %
AprH,1998 Prentauen to NRC and NNECe en d Oversight and Set 0 Assessment Programs j.
- 2
[
.l
. l I
\ /
LHC EXPECTATIONS FOR SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAM Self-Assessments Are Being Conducted Effectively
- Where Appropriate, Strengths and/or Weaknesses / Problems Are Being Identified
- CRs Are Being Written to Document Adverse Conditions Personnel From Unit / Group Express Confidence That Self-Assessment Activities Produce Useful Results
' s April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECe en 8 Osersight and klf-Assessnient Progesnes N /
LHC REVIEW OF SELF-ASSESSMENT:
ACTMTIES COMPLETED Reviewed Applicable Program Definition Documents Interviewed Key Self-Assessment Personnel -
Acro.. une Site Attended Unit 3 Self-Assessment Advisory Board Meetings Observed Self-Assessment Training
/ ,
April 7.1998 Presentstien to NRC and NNECe en 6 Oversight and Self-Assessaient Progreans 3
s.
'\ ,
LHC REVIEW OF SELF-ASSESSMENT: :
ACTIVITIES COMPLETED Reviewed 73 Self-Assessment Reports from
.Various Groups and Units 2 and 3 Reviewed Self Assessment Follow Up and.
Closure Reviewed Unit / Group 1998 Self-Assessment Annual Plans Reviewed implementation of Work Observation l Program I ofe'rshU[nd seir a e menhresr ms s ,
j LHC CONCLUSIONS: SELF- l ASSESSMENT PROGRAM The Program Definition Documents for the Self-Assessment Program Are Adequate Management is Actively Supporting the Program Unit 3 Self-Assessment Advisory Board Provides Management Focus on Program Self-Assessment Coordinators Are in Place , And )
People Are Being Trained in Program j l
- s April 7,1998 Presenteuen to NRC and NNECe en a '
Oversight and Selfassessawat Programs l 4
i 1
1 N /
LHC CONCLUSIONS: SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAM Annual Plans Have Been Prepared for All ;
Groups / Units
- Most Self-Assessment Reports Evidence a '
Thorough and Systematic Evaluation
- Weaknesses in'the Area of Acceptance Criteria for the Assessments Were Noted in Some Reports
- Some Follow-Up Reviews Did Not Test the Effectiveness of Corrective Actions
- x
- "'"' of!;;'"fa"l"2?.t."'.".TL'.","n
\ /
LHC CONCLUSIONS: SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAM Most Reports Cited Both Strengths and
- t. Weaknesses CRs Are Now Being Wr;tten for identified p Adverse Conditions Coordination of Health Ph,tsics Self-Assessments Between the lhme Units is a Strength
- x Or and I : me r nas 5
3
)
I
/
l LHC CONCLUSIONS: SELF-l ASSESSMENT PROGRAM l
Recent LHC Structured interviews indicated a ,
(94%) Level of Awareness of Self-Assessment
, . Program Among Interviewees, With (86%) of the j People Reporting Positive Results from Program l
/ x Aprd 7,1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECe en ii Oversight and Self Assessment Programs i
l
\ /
l LHC RECOMMENDATIONS: SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAM e Strengthen Guidance for Identification of Acceptance Criteria for Assessments Strengthen the Conduct of Follow Up Reviews to
- Focus on Effectiveness of Corrective Actions l
't / \
April 7,1998 Presenaties to NRC and NSTCe en 12 Oversight and Self Assessment Programs
?
6
N /
b LHC OVERALL ASSESSMENT:
SELF-ASSESSMENT PROGRAM 1
Overall Assessment:
The Millstone Self-Assessment Program Has Been Aggressively ~lmplemented aiid is Providing Positive Results
' N April ?,1998 Presentauen to NRC and hWECs en 13 Oversight and Self-Assessment Programs
\ /
LHC EXPECTATIONS FOR NUCLEAR OVERSIGHT PROGRAMS
+ Nuclear Oversight is Effective in identifying and Evaluating issues in the Areas of '
Corrective Action and Self-Assessment Programs i
1 i
' s April 7,1998 Presentaden to NRC and !OTECe en 14 Oversight and Self-Assessaient Progresns 7
e l
L LHC REVIEW OF NUCLEAR OVERSIGHT: ACTIVITIES COMPLETED Reviewed Nuclear Oversight Documents
- Audits and Assessments of CAP and Self-Assessment
! Activities ~
- Nuclear oversight Restart Verification Program l (NORVP) Procedures and implementation Documents
- Independent Review Team (IRT) Report on Unit 3 Self-assessment Program Interviewed Nuclear Oversight Directom and NORVP Coordinators for Selected Areas Observed a NORVP Meeting
/ s i April 7,1994 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe en 15 Oversight and Self-Assessment Programs l
\ /
l LHC CONCLUSIONS:
NUCLEAR OVERSIGHT Nuclear Oversight Activities Are Adequately identifying lasues Associated With the Corrective Action Program and the Self-Assessment l Program I The NORVP is an Effective Means of integrating Nuclear Oversight Results and Communicating )
Them to the Line Organizations l
' s April 7,1998 Presentaden to NRC sad N5ECs en 16 Oversight i ad Stor-Assessment Progranis l ..
i
, 8
i N ,
LHC CONCLUSIONS:
NUCLEAR OVERSIGHT
- In the NORVP Process, Individual Observation Scores Are Not Time and Significance Weighted in Generating Quantitative Results NORVP Observations in the SCWE Area Are Limited for a Number of the Key Success Criteria
' s April 7,1998 Presentaden is NRC sad NNECe en 17 Oiersight and TetrAssessment Prograrns
\ /
LHC RECOMMENDATIONS:
NUCLEAR OVERSIGHT Enhance Quantitative Results Produced by NORVP by Irnplementing a Scheme for Time-and Significance Weighting of Observation Scores
" Eliminate NORVP Observations and Reporting in the SCWE Area j I
/ \
Apru 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe en 18 Oversight and Self-Assessaient Programa 9
/
LHC EXPECTATIONS FOR NSAB (OFF-SITE REVIEW COMM.)
The Defined Roles and Responsibilities and I:
Membership Requirements for NSAB Are !
Consistent With Industry Best Practices There is a High Level of Participation in NSAB Activities by Personnel From the Units -l 1
Material Provided to NSAB Members is Timely and Covers Adequately the Areas / Activities Subject to NSAB Review s
Overs sh a d Sei s en regrams s i LHC EXPECTATIONS FOR l NSAB j i
NSAB Meeting Agendas Reflect an Appropriate ;
Balance Regarding Breadth V5 Depth of issues ,
Covered and Assign Sufficient Urgency to issues l
NSAB Meetir.gs Are Conducted in an Efficient and Disciplined Manner While Maintaining an Open, ,
Professional Environment I Information Provided to the NSAB Is Effectively Processed to Develop Key issues and Recommendations
, s
- """' J:,;";".*::::L"%'.';;.: "
10
4
/
LHC EXPECTATIONS FOR NSAB NSAB Members Leverage off Each Otherin Discussions ofissues and Bring Diverse
. Perspectives to important issues Results of Board Deliberations Are Effectively Conveyed to Senior Management; Senior Management Responses Are Timely and ,
Thorough Board Results Are Captured in the CR Process and Are Tracked to Resolution
/ \
April 7.1996 Presentadon to NRC sad NNECe en 21 Oversight and Self-Assessment Progranis
\ /
LHC REVIEW OF NSAB:
ACTIVITIES COMPLETED j
Attended Portions of Three NSAB Meetings l -
Reviewed NSAB Minutes for Meetings Since l Summer 1997 Interviewed Two Outside NSAB Members Interviewed Most Internal NSAB Members e x April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC sad NNECe en 22 Oversnght and Self-Assessaient Programs 11
l l
. x -
l LHC CONCLUSIONS- 1 REGARDING NSAB l
i NSAB Roles and Responsibilities are ,
Adequately Delineated in the Procedure - '
NGP2.02 -
NSAB Membership is Consistent with industry Practices; internal Members are Drawn from Sufficiently High Management Positions Participation of Members from Units is an Ongoing Problem at Meetings Because of Work Load
- s
^""""'
of, "7a".*a"sE.5/.."'I77.*,*.".
\ -
LHC CONCLUSIONS REGARDING NSAB Administrative Support for NSAB is Adequate; Distribution of Materials is Reasonable and Appropriate.
Meeting Agendas May Not Be Sufficiently Flexible to Accommodate Changing Circumstances Monthly 1-1/2 Day Meetings Meet Current Station Needs
- N and if-As regrams 12
.l J
. i 4
/
LHC CONCLUSIONS REGARDING NSAB Agenda items Were Focused Mostly on Plant Restart, Which is Appropriate for Current Times Presentations to NSAB Were Mixed in Quality, With Most Being Above Average; Presenters Were Knowledgeable and Had Good Visual Aids Energy Level of Meeting Was Not Always High; Relatively Few Members Probed and Challenged to the Level Expected
- s
^'""* "
ODE.".* TOE?.2",,7E.*,*."
/
LHC CONCLUSIONS REGARDING NSAB NSAB Chairman Briefs the President /CEO After Each Meeting, and Outside Members Meet With Him Periodically President /CEO Considers Output From NSAB to Be Valuable and Regularly Probes the Board on Keyissues President /CEO Relies on NSAB As His Primary input on Nuclear Oversight Effectiveness.
- s o%?.":::::2",lT;;;'
13
i l.
l
\ /
LHC RECOMMENDATIONS REGARDING NSAB l
Consider Reducing No. of Senior Managers on
- NSAB to Reduce Cumulative Burden on Senior Management Team L -
Consider Means to introduce Flexibiilty in Meeting Agendas to Permit More NSAB Focus on Critical and Emergentissues
/ \
April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECo on 27 Oversight and Self Assessrient Programs I \ /
l LHC OVERALL ASSESSMENT REGARDING NSAB l Overall Assessment The NSAB is Providing Adequate and Effective Oversight of Activities at the Millstone Station I
/ \
April 7,1998 PresentaGen to NRC and NNECs en 28
, Oversight and Self-Assessment Programs 14
9 s ,
LHC REVIEW OF SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT FOCUS AREAS Little Harbor Consultants Presentation to NRC and NNECo April 7,1998.
- s April 7.1998 Presentaden to NRC a 'NECe en SCWE 1 i
s j i LHC ACTIVITIES FOCUS AREAS 8 Focus Area Files 7 SCWE " Cases" 8 Interviews SCWE Focus Area Meetings Reviewed ECOP Survey Data 1 -
LHC Structured Interview Results
- s 4,,n im r,e. 2
... g .g mEC. .. sCw E 1
/
CURRENT STATUS 20 Focus Areas Closed 3
5 Focus Areas Need Evaluation 8 Focus Areas Open/ Active 7 SCWE " Cases"
- s Apru 7,1998 Presentaden to bl(C ad "ECe en SCWE 3 s -
EXPECTATIONS / CONCLUSIONS EXPECTATIONS CONCLUSIONS j Established Criteria -
Criteria is Defined for Designation As a However, No New Focus Area Focus Areas Added Since November 1997
\
Apru 7,1998 Presentauen to b1tC ad NNECe en SCWE 4 i
2
0 ,
l 0
N EXPECTATIONS / CONCLUSIONS EXPECTATIONS CONCLUSIONS Reason for - 5/8 Focus Areas Do Designation as a Not Clearly Define Focus Area Clearly - Existing Problem Defined
/ \
AprH 7.1998 ' Presentaden to NRC and NNECe en SCWE 5 Focus Areas x /
EXPECTATIONSICONCLUSIONS EXPECTATIONS CONCLUSIONS l
The Action Plan . 5/8 Do Not Appear to Adequately Address All Aspects Addressed the of the Identified
! Identified Problem Problem Ie
/ N Apru 7.1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe en SCWE 6 Focus Areas 3
1
L*
?
l f
\ /
1 EXPECTATIONS / CONCLUSIONS l 1 1 EXPECTATIONS CONCLUSIONS -
Action Plan -
Actions Completed Completed in a in a Timely Manner, Timely Manner 1/4 Files Have Documentation of Completed Activities I
l
- \
j April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECo en SCWE 7 l Focus Areas
\ >
EXPECTATIONS / CONCLUSIONS EXPECTATIONS CONCLUSIONS Effectiveness -
2 Closed Focus Evaluation Areas Appropriately Performed to Closed Determine if e 1 Evaluation Problem was indicated On-going Corrected Problem l-
/ \
April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC n=d NNECe en SCWE 8 Focus areas 4
~
e l
\ /
EXPECTATIONS / CONCLUSIONS EXPECTATIONS CONCLUSIONS Focus Area Files -
1/8 Focus Area Files Are Properly -
- Reviewed Was -
Documented, Properly Complete and Up to Documented, Date Compiete and Up to Date
, s April 7,1998 Presentataen to NRC and NNECe en SCWE 9 Focus Areas
\ >
RECOMMENDATlONS Reevaluate SCWE " Cases" as Focus Areas Review 33 Focus Area Files:
- Problem Definition
- Adequacy of Action Plan
- Effectiveness Evaluation
(' / x Aprl! 7,1998 Presentation la NRC and NNECe en SCWE 10 Focus Areet l .
5
1
\
s -
RECOMMENDATIONS {
I Review Effectiveness Evaluations of
]
the 20 Closed Focus Areas j Determine Effectiveness of 5 Focus Areas with Complete Action Plans 1
/ s f
April 7,199g Presentation to NRC and NNECe on SCWE II j Focus Areas '
l
, 4 6
I {
I f e _._ - -
STATUS OF A SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT AT MILLSTONE Little Harbor Consultants Presentation to NRC and NNECo l April 7,1998 April 7,1998 Presentaden le fGC and NNEco 1 t.
N /
STATUS INDICATORS FOR NNECo's SCWE IMPLEMENTATION EFFORT lo l World Class J,/ Acceptable for a Restart M bed Not Acceptable I2"'~I v For Restart f Significant j-ln (Weaknesses i
Trends: " improving + Steady u Declining
/ N Aprl! 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe 2 1
i
\g S 1
/
i STATUS OF NNECo SUCCESS
-CRITERIA FROM LHC ATTRIBUTES- .
NNECo Success Criteria Status -
- 1. Demonstrate the willingness to raise concerns.
e '
hAN Yellow l
I N
April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe 3 I l
q/ I
\ /
STATUS OF NNECo SUCCESS ,
CRITERIA FROM LHC ATTRIBUTES
_N_NECo Success Criteria Status l 2. Demonstrate that issues are being effectively resolved by line management. (Corrective Y now, Action Program)
I
, , i.
41 '
April 7,1998 ~ Presentseon to NRC and NNECe 4 2
l-l
n7, . , ,
l' 4
I
, (
STATUS OF NNECo SUCCESS CRITERIA FROM LHC ATTRIBUTES I J
NNECo Success Criteria Status
- 3. Demonstrate that the ECP is
/ effective. -
Yellow
' s April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC and hhTCo 5
\ /
STATUS OF NNECo SUCCESS CRITERIA FROM LHC ATTRIBUTES NNECo Success Criteria Status
- 4. Demonstrate that management can recognize and effectively deal with allegod instances of Yenow
+
HlR&D, or other circumstances which have created a chilling effect, which collectively are referred to as problem areas.
s April 7.1998 Presentation to NRC and NhTCe 6 3
1__m.1
c
.- o e '
/
FACTORS CONSIDERED IN GRADING ATTRIBUTE
!- 4. Demonstrate that management can I recognize and effectively dealwith .
y,if alleged instances of HlR&D . I ]
Positive Factors Continued Effectiveness of the ERB Establishment of SCWE/ECP/HR Protocol Establishment ofInterim 50.7 Training for New Management Personnel !
. Olminishing Severity of H!R&D lssues )
Lessons Learned Analysis of SCWE/HIR&D Events l l
Real-time Attention to Emergent issues by Officers '
Use of Full-time Cultural Change Experts
/ s April 7,1998 Presentsuon to NRC end N5TCe 7
/
FACTORS CONSIDERED IN GRADING ATTRIBUTE
- 4. Demonstrate that management can recognize and effectively deal with y,ig' alleged instances of HIR&D .
Neoative Factors Continued need for extraordinary involvement of officers a Change in Millstone culture is not finished
. March HIR&D Concerns Lack of Timeliness and Coordination by SCWE in Some Cases Occasional Lapses of Management Understanding of Their l Role in a Safety Conscious Work Environment
' s April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC end NhTCe 3 4
~.
N /
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status
- 1. Senior management endorses a policy that places priority on nuclear safety, supports the er n workers' rights to raise safety -
issues and ensures that workers will not be subjected to harassment, discrimination or intimidation if they do so.
/ x April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECe 9 x f SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE. STATUS LHC Expectation . Status
- 2. Employee perceptions of the policy and its implementation are favorable.
3 y,33,
' s April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and Nhh 10 5
l l
ll
/
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS i
)
LHC Expectation Status
- 3. Senior management provides I training to all managers and supervisors to ensure that they Yeuow
+
understand and employ good management practices when ;
dealing with employees who l have safety concerns and do so j with understanding.
' N Apru 7,1998 Presentauen to Mtc and NNECe 11 4 l
/
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status
- 4. Members of the workforce have a' sense ofidentity and are committed to the publicly stated goals and objectives of the 4
Yellow organization, have respect for each other, communicate effectively both horizontally and vertically, and feel responsible for their own behavior.
s Apr0 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe 12 6
1 N /
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK
-ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation ~ Status
- 5. People at alllevels of the organization treat each other with mutual respect. y,n,
+
/ \
AprH 7,1998 Pruentauon to NRC and NNECe 13
~\ /
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status
- 6. Employees exhibit a " ques-tioning attitude" toward work and the work environment with fg,+
respect to nuclear safety.
C , s AprH 7.1995 Presentaden to NRC and NNECe 14
}
7
L .. i
?
- l
/
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK l
- ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status l 7. Positive recognition is given to employees who identify safety '
issues, y,,,, , )
i s
April 7.1998 Presentaden to NRC and NNECs 15 i
1
~
SAFETY.CONSClOUS WORK H
ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATU!.
1 LHC Expectation Status
- 8. Incidents leading to allegations of harassment, intimidation, retaliation or discrimination y,ig,
+
rarely occur, and management -
l is timely and effective in taking )
l action for resolution and )
prevention.
' O l s Apr0 7,1998 Presentauon to NRC and NNECe "
16 l
r L 8
~
1 .,
N /
FACTORS CONSIDERED IN GRA' DING ATTRIBUTE
- 8. Incidents leading to allegations of harassment, intimidation, retaliation or 1
' discrimination rarely occur, and h>
management is timely and effective .
Positive Factors
. ' Continued effectiveness of the ERB
. Establishment of SCWE/ECP/HR Protocol
. Establishment ofinterim 50.7 Training for New Management Personnel
. Diminishing Severity of HIR&D issues
. .. Lessons Learned Analysis of SCWE/HIR&D Events
' Real-time Attention to Emergent issues by Officers
. Use of Full-time Cultural Change Experts
/ \
A=ril 7.1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECe 17
\ /
FACTORS CONSIDERED IN GRADING ATTRIBUTE
- 8. Incidents leading to allegations of harassment, intimidation, retaliation or discrimination rarely occur, and g'
managementis timely and effective Neoative Factors
. Continued need for extraordinary involvement of officers
. Change in Millstone culture is not finished
. March HIR&D Concerns
. Lack of Timeliness and Coordination by SCWE in Some Cases Occasional Lapses of Management Understanding of Their Role in a Safety Conscious Work Environment
/ \
April 7.1998 Tresentation to NRC and NNECe 15 9
l.-
1 1
i.
i-l s
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK l ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status
- 9. There is no evidence that an atmosphere exists that has a E ,
" chilling effect" on the A y,ii,,
willingness of employees to report safety issues.
1 I
l N April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECe 19 l
l l- r i
< s ,
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status
- 10. An effective and efficient l corrective action program is functioning and all employees y,ii,, ,
f recognize the normal (and L preferred method) for j addressing safety issues is through the line organization.
s April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC sad NNECe 20 10 1
1 4
P . .i t
.,1 l
s /
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK l ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS l l
LHC Expectation Status
- 11. Senior management ,
recognizes that some concerns j may not be addressed through
^
venow j the normalline organization and has established an
-[ effective) Employee Concerns Program (ECP) for handling such concerns.
/ N April 7,1998 Presentauen to NRC and NNECs 21 P
% /
SAFETY CONSClOUS WORK ENVIRONMENT ATTRIBUTE STATUS LHC Expectation Status
- 12. Independent and self-assessments are performed periodically to monitor ^
venow performance and correct identified deficiencies.
/ s April 7,1998 Presentation to NRC and NNECe 22 11
9- .
~
.:7 LHC ATTRIBUTES CONTRIBUTING TO NNECo SUCCESS CRITERIA 1 o
Demonstrate the willinaness to raise concerns.
- 2. Employee perception of SCWE... ly.noJ l l
- 6. Employees exhibit a questioning attitude... lyto3 l
- 7. Positive recognition is given to employees... lvisf l
- 9. No evidence of" chilling effect"... iv noJ l
- 12. Independent and self assessments are fy.nawfl performed...
/
April 7,1995 Presentsden to NRC and NSTCo 23
/
LHC ATTRIBUTES CONTRIBUTING TO NNECo SUCCESS CRITERIA 4 Demonstrate that manaaement can recoanize and ... deal with ... HIR&D.
- 3. Senior management provides training to all ;, ;
managers .
- 4. Members of the workforce have a sense of Y'"""
identity and are committed to the ... goals .
- 5. People ... treat each other with mutual respect. Iv.n# l
- 8. Incidents leading to allegations of HlR&D... rarely occur.
9, ;
- 9. There is no evidence that an atmosphere exists that has a "chillino effect." *"""
' s AprH 7.1998 Presentauen to NRC sad NhTCe 24 12 l
- g. 4
)
t-4 -< 9 4 L 4r 7i g g, j i 7
it ,,
i.:-
{th{ j{nii[
L ,
i l d m r i
[:ig !J.!
5- 3 i .1 bd 3
= -
sw s i: lal$
- ss ! e h ( .-.
!I
)
}I jlhl} ] !
lil t [ lh[, l ! j I
= .
ar i .in r[ -
i t*.h-i 1 -
1 1 '
. s grg a g- llg f q! d *f' 1 I i lo!..jIig'l.
e 1::
5 s i;,!g }
}jlLt ji j' i x
! x; i t, a
1 j;
g ;.;,j jI 2,r i
= l i ,
i 9 -
a .
1,J{ {alg L i U hk ! I' !!rijl
[!
i 9
gi a
[I i.
[
i i
s 11 in
.j I
ilj L li llii l~ l il 10.,i31 8 i ,a a
1] II 1,.s,J1!
l r
i j p. ,ij g ili 1 ...-
I, ]
8 jq f -{' g lL]{ , , a
.l ' .
h j k
; e t. b ji yc flj?Q. lj j j s:'! I.; . I
! l112E!k, Ms:r .i lllIiilt 3
}lUii!!!lll l~
;. ,f
?
s ., . . . f!! fl 5 f ! II 'll f Ii'fgjljII((I s
!j l m;,ll
- , li ,1 6 a i
,,I!lIlfW.iio, lil li ~I i @s i
i- 11i,jii1
}
igg
} i diii lbl$I 1 .10 1
.a il nt Ji i
!g$
f I lf 11 j 9
l, ts e
} I ,e !-. ,
l 1
,1.$]31sill _jj l
j .$ f}a h!s l h! i j ~' i' h' L I : i illfh ! , 11 ! L i !i,lifras]i p b j i a hi$ nJgfl!.j liDi u(r8 : 31 it r g eg i h h N15 h lll f ls ik!e !l2 l ! !
... . . . .s . e
, $ f j i j I. I i i i l ! ! !
~ . . .
4 i 4t: 2 % aa in J. i 3 1 l a :l ! i i !! ajv Ilia
,ill=l]i ml!!
h]fy!I'fllig - fi = ar ; lilj lijjj I*il i liji j ylin dgjifi j i !@t;[j l l!di i
!!!!i((j"dpIIllj!!*
i $i 1 s 1 ll $ j n [ Liu
!$x IILI l{
j ls, a lf1 1
!!sni i
I[t}- l . fI j If I I I fe l4 i pi
~
f g I i i ! l N ij an dSIl lili -l l i .
,gl I
e ip t ; 4
..I , ,
l l li
~
t
*j
{
}
~
-g i P ti1!ili1 iltIfl i
i i ] 5 i
?
1 i ' ! int
!!lI;2iP3M4"rli s In]
! e j - t u i HII $< i s
1
! i ?!l:iU jilliE!,Il?=
5 1 {s [.; p15.? l 5 5 fig I; !!!!!N$Nid[1ij!!I!!; .t
.4 .e .... .. .. =
i N- N }[g '? i i i e i 5 i lf }}li s ,I .
= , ,,
iiit i=}s = J Je n 1:!! : il$iNv q!!j
*g! ti pl>-
i IlkY - i>>4 w ]. .iI i. kb il .I I aba P
' I y j tiin a;p I
r 7 }} it 3IHst J l,Ii]X - .
.3 i
e l l 04)1 j[,3g:j I l t)) 1jA 1: E I*] '
, lt .
L - kJ ] lh kk ang
' l i 5 isi a3 Ja8l-i i E}{ b}r& .
ji 4 ll I L
.o p , l'l n'I'l i
1J li i dP
.u .
a , , , j l- . j
{ ,. -- _. 1 ne;19 !
! ]:i}I ij((;
i< j glji,1i- 3 L g If n luii}mlk. h ;
=
! iMHi!jA
= juli thililit ; ,
:'i , , ,, , .
5 -f ! ! ..f . Igi I lylpl;a!!Ild,p!k I n j u,g1
! , I j ![1 1
r y
! J1 l
e ni;i i
!n s- 1 1 lh jM ,
o j;jlc!w..pnljip. aj i ! !! !!l D,11 0
L: g s.. . ar wn mm Il
!:;;0,llhalll#i t
9 h Ii l l} u i s :
- 5 F
s f i 1 - 31th b lf5 . E
- j. j p*. 5 i *8 l$ .
i,1I!,p1y. 1 2 -
,I.
i s w li 3 1 [ ti p]} a- { Ii j
>; l aii 11 1 n1 i.I 6 :#p 1
5 SJa$! i!aA!! r !! !! i lj. E lt - i ] I m ial h' I &(8 i a yl }i.
l6 Ei g .! t l 3 2'
- f; ffk!!!=! k ji ynoi 2 I I
- v3sE i:I.E l4 -
e 4 M a i i i w li t w a,1.1{m);u
. i, E 5 vE it E sllitiai!al Ea [}- $
. . . . =a m f=3E e I
, RE J
.s -I'j i8 i .i 7 .i
_E !d III:j{pll.! Il } g .f 1)1 i
! ! ii g
4'aill 13 1 Off!)!Ill i I:li i I i
. . . 3 @.f .i 3 ) dis g 5 41 $$E'f"3844 E N B8 fl 4
- lia.la ik IP .t agljl A[gf= pig
, 40if']ljI
.n id .;
s 1
.!l: $
14{i[!1 e 5 id.=it'}gg 1 -Qi rt ug # ; g ! i .
!n$pp,1 t 4 1! in u i e.u4,,131 _y l_#{
. i i i !?!p! ,li ie 1Ji 1t',l j ,a 1 ie I
fr ag e u l, p,h, et i llt m I 1,1ly,ii 1, 1 ni i g ig l >, l l i 11 illh!li flil;all .l i UEh ii g . 'I
- s. ,i }}li n e
ni il.1l
.q g *'
.{i 3
s .j l .
] ))3Mi r iIi 8
JI igg ))4 )a.
!x
- l l
e o n o D el n nr p r e v e it F n i-
*Aem n s n a
_ a n A 1 aa rmi c e t A li[ ( u ee J( e i
*t a t s
_ m ncs a. r n e s s l w siA t t c y
) nl I
s re nl a be s IyAa' e t h tp n s e e em.e tnac v it Mm s c Pei . f f e trmt aI cd m E e le n e e v it. C Ns 8 bat e roh st y s 9 9 pu a ps -i1 t I tr 1 s. 9 I, e c 2- eqmh 2 - t e 1 I c c eit e - _ 1 cd en1 3 A 0 Aab e0 M # g e s s t m a or pade led e i P _ e nt r v mte C n o Re ly erts a re heraec E y i t h icsist ssiy nF. h n oc r b d a u tnY oN enme e e mog t r e l a M (r r ehgn e a p gt ta e ei k c ar E v hl eis ne tguha c gct tg nNTMt tmd e e r e a t C f iwe sPpol u s l e s b e - i ehiCoc nh t s n a e .
. IsS b aEt . ce r L e .T et o P lb8 l b 8 el 8 s e!y7id e:u tp8 r f
)h9 / s we gv r a9
- ta p
9
- taA u
9 iPP tm3 0 lo s1 o e2 c - e c 1 2-qg e n 1 2-CMx/les E( n9f rC i el - c1
.A0 A c 1 0
di s Au 1 e l ht a e
- u f
o ny n n : . w a -. e ts io b.n n n d a _ _ r g . _ e n v M-o e i t v c
-. i t u l a 2
_ c - d i 4 _ -. a , n i t o n f l c i o r e 0 la4 d e u l g fo d e ht t a 1 e g r cn t n h a fo ini l d e t d P to a n m te t rh u c a e o s o ts pn s n o p lme n e r so lyta hti z d b l e d n a
- s.
s n e n e n . R fa i g mre e liw'. tn7 a e9 . o e m9 _ t n hll _ C e m t a dy er 1, E e nb a aI ptd M lp a pd x le muh s e N h Ed Aui gs
)
3-
) a 2 e )Ab a l
4 77 1 9 7hg I 7bs
- yt E
n 1 M9 11 RMi b e MC9P) 35 Bs RE23. ( ( n Be (h71 / o9 7t 7 r 7t 9f 9/ 9 p e
/ e 9c 7 4S 4 o n / oFy 2
/y
/
2 c7. 4 2 tnCb
/
7b 7 e9 /eE 7n(" ess e e9 r=7-es e y1 t c te o te = 9' sor el 5 mp t
=1 / ,
I p I mer e=3 l =/ ea e ebe el7 _ Cr Ec e Cd ee s Cnar ee eb Mn Et Nl e a tp Ge t s eH Nco NrS e xsi f MeI w t e n ly y h e ht b n nf tP C c o r n o d e i a oC gse ep R Lo'n d l m d n sh i a e e e r n r e8 a n c n- iii n m c = n t n t i ne 'v =h nd u=i dt ec ed i r e n adan gn na a
-r s
n fe m ea en=to) c o=dL a r re t ca eI e ne c m ih e a c
= ne ms tsd n da o
noaio rl n-f nnl geW t r a af e s an t o a ne' ed r u ema n e ae e mwe e ts s r e a le4 dao nt xe om cei S, ec un d t en imui mis n o% na o i l ye r v ro e eR uv rop e h o suuPi u qm t n ho Pr eae B tei s u emCc Mr a E (a p rc ul s
- c. d nn- L S 5 Ec o 6 s
6 i i 1 i
}
s i
, . .-
- i y' l
_q e j- j. i v i lj.(( # 1 i o
! Il ! !g a s! j_i i li ! ){ Ill ii l
f i iLi,li i !!lilil i
. i hh li
[ ! hN l l H *[IIfj}f-j l !! i Illinf i ; fifi j I h 'l !Ih! ,
!!jh['jf!!! !i!;!il hji i
,Iik a
$O!
jl [ . O lil!! - 11!
.o its ..s 2-r ! e 2,5 1 e i: 1
.i - ljE iiE l$9 i l;4 l! i8 r o i*
n sin in s ui: a 1 t i UR r4 i ng y xi r s a w s ie 1 1 n i is. 9 I!i !ij i sf1a!s,el5 !*-
- a. ip "
sa p 13 7 d r
- - 1p; }.i b a ,.ap? Id tc : ii q e .
3 ]! h fML is n lp; i
. js- JJ l ia % !
W-I w!!!! LPi 19e NE 43
'y ap e
I; ;1; a lld 3 s a an
.s a
is l;
- si
- lf l' . gif
.t I]
f L P ji
=r jd l' #
hs
.a< 4, i p ti/jblpa;{ tl1iw I
. il 8
4 l i t. i i ! !q 3 . ' t 11 t g}i{ }$ 1 2 j !! Il j i .b, e i fj
,t
- i. ,],!w!!
i
!q 1ljlits li,g !!! j!
.i illas 3 .! i d,
]l] 1 i~n g
}o! ii E E.
IE g, . Il LEI I lE'g }" i l ! fi is il I 11 1! 1 18 i 11 il if f iln la i odf}pl i lI g 11 11
!i Ilhi> g I,i ,tji l ,
i ,
.I g
U Il fd g,l.l!!)fill Ib .. l1 1 O 5
m t ' j - jj]ili di [c I n jy ,p t ! L 1 fijlij lfid!!}, I i I r,
!;p2 ie utnPM[d khlldI '
i , 5 Ii liilllil15 Illi!NN!!i i 3
, ! 9rt
'5 '
g_ Alf] g , 3
}));
di I i il01 i l- ,!$ ; IiI~Igla "Wiii a4 iin{ith o)>]I il e; r i nll k i l ; l I li a ly{}g11,g11k{i
! ,I m h,h,,,
i ,1 j,i e n .l n, in i, k fj! kl - l$ }I
- g. pi v 1 y P, w}
is l !l Ib!fhn I k lu ! pi ilI ilil i a .i i J
!!Il !1s 11,I
- g i t 11}I 9.
1
4 n D D f a D D t c ht D e o v s Q Oe s i
.ts F F d tm -
s % h wdeS Q' h s w Q' a it s F se u e d ra p _ a n n w et R ndi i J- O d r,vi.ieln O. e e v h R F n a s m =tns w F R w - n 4 nwp po GN Q e t pic s e e i tne i t c gc d C t b t G t. wenina m i c m ns N e h :s. ae m e ai 4 e N = - r ta ef h RI ae s t w I S .
- r e 9 r 9 np I e r t
- t. Pv aI w IDws me R p^ .
. a 8 R %
t fgN n n O Cle dettedla a e O m
-. .,.hs h s
O m D e own e T fIopw ns s ic IT u .,i t re 5l e a.ha I s ih i t i-im s v d , tnt neemtn N e ns N s
. qr
. er ni e
Wlimto1 e dA. Ni - 0 nIe :s. ce e e O O n e e s me n S ne f sn &s
.- ne el bb a l .
n n n im em a meg in) s M i ma.l f u nt n e s a M e e a igmel psfeD ta w a s a 2 .
.c h a s t
D
/
Pis anm leo Ct s n aM 3. W v r h s. n F o i fte -
- 2. F t
ie gt mh ni aei tt)S e wIwd m nAsp tr e a e S
)
F a 4 vMt 7
-;6S 2) c pn c dfeI doc s. aet P" hc sb A 2 aP 2 m r5i .l T
c am?ef m e Fmb t ti e (' e I ICn ;.. ,eI vrVI leh a I C dd' wwge eI Cr m ieafbc d o sI I E aminh I er . . rm nol ep ni n i mre r e . w.d h.C i ia e omclfivd i e nr7 m9 o C tne ud os9 e nt 8 ns1 oee --,8 'e si r cer o8 tatiab s z 8 vs e 7 tell ih e id ee m s8 t IC u p 1 9 e9-mqvde a# r - - nim ne2 9 R nweRo m me# I 19oJleJ e CcCt yr l I i el dnkf - I, I e s nv os ep e2 - e r g nd - 2 t eJ uI) nP2 ta - a at g g p1 C9 wI teIone3 nl e s - honta p3 hnn# DI gI1 f r r e2 T ciI a# I pa i sI0 OeS8 3f 1 onI sl ceS8 t n e m - u c o n d o 7 9 it / s s 5 1 t / R la d te e v e a te a t a te E v u u u a C i e e c d q e q e q e A u q e l r a d a d a i ;. d a i t n s s s s s L ne-.i s ta 8 i i, i e i 8 8 8 au 9 - 9 . 9 s n 9 8 9 hl a - Cv e I J I to'- I 8 2 1-8 R 1 2-1 R m 1 2-1 0 R s e o p 7 2-1 R m 1 2-1 8 d
, _, e ta e m t s
1.,e P ht
. d
- c. s y L, s aC F, c
. a e wee ev lla yl cef s e fo a r r t r
athit it at e on hi tan hf r a ph a r U - c i ht usi N n c ot s - d - 7. e e a2i n mt si s v 2 d e9 ir e erol ar o n is91 Db d nu non 4 a v ee t cl p r ewno i er o h v aids e a rf a t a hh) die vea la i ri r ota 4 dl ea u s btoO z li R.t a n MDt I e at n 1 e sGo g yH ins e m ehi ne a n is bp f : e - h t d m P e r l. Pr m n( V n lp . t tor o u e5 Ce it o e e ps doc eCod ErT u tn mee Mirt e tag h b s M1 t pi si se n nus I a e e is c r a - em u r mh n ms ec h p o r g a, u hN itr e v ains sf aaot f f a s gA of t C 7, P pO a o r wn i gl lh 2tshe a wtr eth e r 9 r ta oi R p [o 9 E da nelc zr a p e n oP sTc n sl 1, dn n eP Psm is C l. a e mro t
- a. . uN gC Ca iEu a ur C a.
ee sansa v r t r tan o ts n .f eEEy E n e c uo -.te Pehhee Rht nd Md ue gi u ss r M si v
.ne CtT..ep r e
he nPs m Ai Eg N ha et nM ed eni 7.h aCu Tt rs OP hi s hd9 Tr9 ets wdEr c
)i )C Tet
) ) n . ewhi en 5 n 0i 5E 0
5P 8e , 5 0 e e1 se 5) ot e 6 m 6 e od 6 c - 6 R. 6 8& 0llot 6 6d 8 a 1h 6 t 6i0 1 V 1
.tsd ue 6f 1 es er o eiv 3e 3 n, Be 3f f. go (h
7t (o 7i s (h .-. (taut Bb ip ( oB o 9 n 9i 7t 9d7 7 s A e, 7t at
/i 7 V # n9 9Pnt
/ a 9 al
# sdd 4de 2
4 2P 4 a9 4Cei r 4 wuted.
/ / 2/ r1 p 2 o c e 9z i 9C 9u s2 /
9 e
/
9 tiwdu s fis rl e eE r rh r len t n e e sh t e y2 t ey t rl 2EWo te t t t s o p p a rnd ni teanoa e uac s t I sfa at ePu J Ad as Imcedee en t eW l s enrhe I ew a d o r a r Cee C Cet Cbetul m e Chetser -. au o a. l Eb Ec e Eio% r n Ns a Nh G" I N - Nnc NCi on s Ntis e n Ndb eo c Gttd' I a Nh un .M t
.n
.a .
e d ht b e n t nd o a i w C b .ht tina n nuo n o e H e ioin u t ph i c n Lo n eh esh a tny wsL biit c iig e - t v t n allu h - - i e te n d r w r r nf p dt b l ae a na adn n i a* e m u at ol e h ce e n dO pv gd r n o a m o c se nf e e r g lp shgese s a o n o t o n cr ms r s ie uop r e r o n us pUi t r s t tuh hh s irh c oa aMnd otd e r a
- s. e
,ec trda and t ae z i
r p n t, a nn n p e P e Wt D i r d p e ip ds c s i e R ntla s o u s em e ta u r seu D nci u r nr etni h Tcfea 9 a P 0 1 p o6 t o r iceptar ue dd aca rVy ei c i f hop I I a i i emW mg u e i r Fp 2 1 a kp 3 1 ep p n r o
e I
~
g s i is. # ge -
* ! yea ifl, g e
! i i[d i !! i ;
i is is i 11 il s i titil* , 3r 14 I EI$5$!< l"i $ 5-s p tlysi d H IIsl 3 $$Ein5DB
- I i l3 k i
i .e
] ." E k k oc d h r
a al a ,a 5.4l krl(i=i:.ii*]Igi i ilngri il b i s) , gu.1 ct _f{i, L,glyi,
,- i,, !
y If3 b I f j i ,1,3i ! I a n 3 vAi- ! ui T ]I a a-L
.Ij}]$f..
d
,kh, E4! j!
.!n}],
- 5
.i f ill hbIll U 'a a $
m ip pII!ill I I hil O 8
9 4 u a, t i p ,j 4 i - i ini i rginiki ! i 9l 1@d 1 li! 4 a s v
}ll jl{
i 1 11 iint Jh i i h ig{fl!![a I!![j h !!!p, il { lh !
- ! h hhi l I}
!q s, Pljl u! i in,j!jjll1 a a
,1j,,i
! 11l;lgjgi r iialij' t
!!I ilI h
!OlillI!il!!!IIl011IlillI o na l !a h NllI f h! ,
ililll e ;
o
.I 1 i} 5J~$ $! !*
.} ' }$}IN-pl.?slij[,iii!!i l}Eh 5.ill I s uyPi I dlP i
z g ellbi m'p -s a
.E i jjdUii$I j E
*f.
i
.i h play!HIDj.ig o ng,3_ el li.t e -
b' }}k iE1 Jg -L- f I- ; E
' Ilj i dt! !r Ehd.!!Ol$~{l.r W{i=; dg" 12 iI i i i W d i U
}
e r
=
N iI e e a a n
^
38 1jii t2 2 -
!]erji j
jlI
,lh-i (ablj 2
vp aii e ,a . u
=
, b.4 4i a lg-} , .}l,f, d
[y , , 1, [ 2
]3}
a l c. e ,i
$
- 8 h
s Ijr{ s 3]l
?vIjd!
11e! II il,t hit
, t 3 l
i 1 . 411 1]1 . i} Llm i
d j i
'i. 31 ji !
I (j ab ja ld {I -
! 4U i gj i It i il i i e
~
i p ~ l l illi i1 63 A j' y , j'i-g jedr aq
^ rit n j 11 iij@oih.l[.jlsig?
!!&] ljil ib 9
=
i i ,!! U!iduijf b!i illi
>l 1ipo pHi lul .
s 10 yh }}n!k} jd{>l r fP v41 i~ tri j. l ILt' g {til{lil
- i s i l'a j ll i l'a g ,
iilllili} lhs i!1 u ;{1 $1 i
.s} {f.
jj !a;ulit ip iI f Ih
4 g Ol ' i: es
.g C j-
- .a -
4 ,i , ,
!! ! ! 3 ! 3 I .pt i JfI 4 f2
}J!! d!a Iiil l ]r:141 Lgj
! '}i-lJ[: ,44jp i 11..i ri iii W I#r
- i5f{ill1$hij' li] di 0 415 1illiu i F (( ,
i 1 11.,1. iii 111:13 3 a . .]i ;
,j ]j 1 $ I;? I
-i i g i1 i-I yh l
ig 1 t j- . jer i]l {8 b;rf
. i! 1 ,
h i 4 J ti ,j!leuniin l' e 4 n
! si]ui lI y>i
- d ol}ani
> eA I
el d
.n ll ' lh l i ' n i f li wll 11l1 l'l i , !{] l'Il!
- i. ilni !a!
$1 (
0'!!I'd l!I!!!!! !!!b..
s a t n d D D s . i o h c u Q' h Q' v s s o - t a n n e w wl e nG F R
*i w
F R n 4 i i
's hs ie G s.
G J n n N n r e r tl r n 2I
.N m
. I -e e a 9' s, 9 R .
R y . t c 1 h ev r O d O _ ie t e &. TI e m T i l s 1 a . I a r w r te N Mwr m s i e 5. MO N e e p a O s v i u e sno n I, 2M e P q M n e se tn 6 ./ e r C le r e m e D h
! e D v a i m.3S e F tewf l
e . 2. F
. l d
2 d r a S it v I c e n n me7 u n2 ok p a 1. DI w a h a s s e I E ef I x C T f iW tnr o m p .C tm et vl au t F. l
=
a eewe r7h cl s h s e c a r teffiepa v g i mmm9 p C e r e y, a d d v 8
- a se rev
- t n
8 9 I l i G - I L l e u y uweteumee qCeI tcCtnv es m 14 a. oi st e r 2 J t'r y g de I AIJlestI.chS# oa e1 e - '+ wTpoC r u 8 4 s r i e ht te n ri ed tna b A. e . i t o v ese o J w (td o nt o /_ liAt F ICiq e a u a h, de s : ( e l u eid ea. J I d a a da n e :. A. , d s meene h te a n te a E n b . u q J. *a u q e n _ C e v _ e c, -...inn e l i L b ha h s ase ePtg s i., d s s e1, r . d a1 s
- i. n .:
d a s 8
..iL
_.swde 8 i_ s s 8 s en& e#dfa g 9 9 . 9-n 7-r gk en 1 1 a s o o1 - 2- y w ev'-(e "- vi r 1 o eeb r Pweja0 r o m2 RR 1
# R 7
8 s o ' l a u sw n e ns t n e r e z - ad Man nl s e toPtioiv 8Cgr ae d f es t ioe Ps r 9Ei rts a tor t ec oht tudl n foyep Ce 9 c c s l o 1 eet r v a oth n od e ue Ed n ou s w es y n eid nm sa.u n ped tgf r r er
. rodtoB rR " inaf r
t s o h o tgC eh o o 2 4 L nv.e aan f u e s e Ig e ts, p Fwn o lee s d . hl d a au d n nr r e ti iolaLl c 0 2 3 ni id f n a Pf c b r ao earg oa f eO e i o .b em el Ced b e g a lap v e . . st e c e nh r e p s. E h ei l trt oh t P a o s u t lwon
^ t gt r- tat r g c
u L. yer e ing- h s o n d bc ipr i n e am- n L. s pi s tai n e ' nw no o dt csi e n utu lab r g
- l lc P. ta e alep ri o o
.ro
- J lo i " pf m o
_ p vi e t. r pt f lwE rt a it enr c _ s e s r e eg rou do P t o es inhel ieTci R t c ine" nne $ /tde tae mi v b . r o nwl o ur n a t d tga l e cd n l l n itwed C e go s? r i s sie am eie c et mtec ae E a s : - h : h ec Ce s icdec N ni evr
- ~- c
-- h i
N P s e c n v tc orle na ost N e - w Ci rai aCf s
- m. u p
" s e- wr e s i Ed Dag n fOh e p r e ;e bu s
)deny 5
4 61 3ge e n sy r l kr e e w 4
)
5 s 8 6 nly 6l u d n p
)ty 5b 8
4d e 4 Ac
)5f 4
0 OL. f i 4e h .e
- r
.b o
8 a eh r 1 s m u 3r eo 1 n e Btf tci B s' s ( a (d c u w 7 n e) s n $ a.n, 5na 4 e 2
/
mloBn r eeHac vDo t i $ 7 nr o 8uf 4f r 2
/
"9 4
/ p"s5 2
/ r./ .l Md H
( 8 9
- o. n e_
L. yL. o c 9 r h s (t s 9 s 9 . tn .. ewd rd rd e2ei / sn a .rs u _ ee nrarhjh oe amM te o r
@M n
e t t ass w t ys e-t oT . mte gfd oi f l Aeis t de Ik net e Ib he m le e cios Cpsneea r c n %g s s e es tsI n L h Ca R td hre r ap ? Ehar y CwseB* Eer n o L,.. n oc h. Mid Nwatopl a % Nd e t nh NvdH i s r e _ra . iat NsedM a paf i P
" i C C to W hEto Hn t -
e B ht e, Lo d e o _ dt a i ke # t sda d w i t e n a e n "d t es e e e s r s e ao _ ef n _ ee em f~ m S oc N as P* 5 e s e n eP scal a R i s n _ eEm aW t C m fo rd e a D e n4 l a& P r e 5 2
%, 6:
2 7 2 l Illt !lll1 lllIl!, lllI1Illt
w t ;d o r
- ek : D D 7 D
. F y 0 n i
t mx 1 - t
)
r 5 Q' o s at ) I F R F n vf R R in o o v e t u t f C t c a n t M i G d i r 'mi) t nc m, 9 9' 5 2 w N I t r o N I e
.c e ,k1 sl 7 1
h e i R t R a c t e v v i. 2 t A. v e O d e 0 el T D s i o mwm4 nM . f J t ti r I N l ta e f i N mh a, 2, r Me O s t. w e rr is92 m 2 t s O n i f 74 s: C u e
.M n
e e u 2,1 e 6 I q / e v s s is 2 J w D s is6l r e 2 e i f 5, t 8 d e a -F I S s F it i 7 1 s iw S c Gil 2, f- 2
. 2 O f
.. D e f f 2 f J
&n ieR tp r o ml e4i o .
1 c e I 7i o C
. i f
E wo x
. w e; h, 2t e tc a e c
x w s, F l. ig v 7, r C e d Re ee w 8 9 m p 8 e 8 t r u (w w
. e e tn 9
a tuu 9
#h Ct mn rr 2 e C -. vIeC 2 t
- i. i 1 s r 8 qr 4 I ! I e e r u e rc 2 LrIe o c e I. J 3 4 i I ! c t. 8 S ~m C 8 lacr - 2 av fb .
o 7 w ". e
~
9 u-n v it o e e r iCsi't R e de a m I lef - . u ts JGr e i - e
.eveu
. r l
a ne s f s v e eh si o m /. . t a tafl S c t e el E u i n6 e q uof q) Pd C s s1 d e e s wCre d leeEia H Ani f-a ain f r e _ L lde is s i32 4 - v s o S ;e P ky 9 8 9 2(dn s #
'n 1
1
- - e.
f F
. 8- 7
- 1. P.a"2-J 2-3 - J
# P 2-R
. .C C f
# F. - E f t
et n r . c s7. e t u o h t te inno
- Pr a C
Fn h e to2 ,i 3 t n L. h g 7 9 a a99 l d1 l i e ht deec o e2U ih 9 wi, 4 _ i wf d vrife ta ht rt e c a- l. f s 7, 1 t u fisI ._ n l gef o s r.ihseo.e bmpam bi a
" le d s *a dcfr if e
.t t iea n e a1 d r b. l a 7. _
e c n so . e i ra oa r e e f c 9 _ n ua ..et c o h iA. /
/
s s
- c. i ad ey T' v s fod t
i t s Gba o e 1 iM. y c en 2
.Dn l
ea sd st 2 i.aut a ieq ee ie c s o c . s c .f 4 "ci r c u 5
! ut h b 9l e ns ea r
aev t t ni l aO cy P1t o f o e f.N_ bd qc eep rad a 1 df
/ e o D ;o .ed '
y o le e s' ipa g
- sb Cyt 1
d" a 5 h nh et s s c s ly E. .sbedtae 2 ef l owh e toct s==-8 g ne d ve l e ee su- 99 .M.e ita ii - l sl n v ta iwt d nf eb en Pi lG C .e_ g t lo e a a s o h Mto tai . r P p m s a e ev 3 1 te e e dtaDse 1, c Pn d :, p E , r t 3lah c n - e Co u _o - o "sag i el t e Tn a .hi es41yed E d a dra=8 . u to2t2 r u e te i,.akc L. L i.- s s
.e ,i.tnnvuet e
s i n r ie2 6 ta1 4 ra we d h i" n d ts e s e 9 9 s 2 9 s lpdh h c ew. s n b . man urf leu t o rv n s i i de p e n 7 2, 1 a d v ets dr e fof e bha . ol7 7, dse o re c o9 R s e si s a he lct 2 6r2 eye a h c2 e1 4 sP e eiaw nCc s eEero J e s o p e h n v e i rc b s len sd t s s inrhhCrI e ud tnsEd
- e. at oe41 t
s/
/
ey 2, d ar rc t e o r s er tni eS a. mnieNanI oa C e lbbyc 2 dun 4s eot red 1 bi e dl eG s t fa edp it s fe c dt a c6 e d isN v 6 he s oL ge ir e l lof iec h '~ o9dd o9t E iwar le nFi v at hly . nl
.eneh al - T r e tne tctec~ C9i E 1, o r v at 9 e d 1, dg N leu c c Gnbyyor Cn .h ar- .
er c u a r n NI pa r t e e N io a f Pa" lp ) oPcc I sCed i - ly e ess pa" r Ne- e m w. e isI n a d e - e u h Nn Cv- l 2 8i eEs es len
- v ha h ass n, a 4. ) rI v
.El Th - h a) 2t sh )B c i
) a a) o w l
pe e ) c 5 ed e" 7 s 8 9 phth md. 5i ) ei i 5 - 1 nS e Asdsna a n 8 8h 4 raes 2 a 0iud m 8h 8 6 c m 6 - sS o n Sl eon ee)e3 6 w 6 4 el na 6 6I 6 1 ih0 s 6 B- -a uBye s n 1 t o D B phb18, 1d e Be g ve 1 e 1 3t 3c n .B u ceB ( 7" sHal rbt e (Pe sT s3 9 (a m Rl n ( i ( _7 oi7 mn( 9 .sMsid e sl n 8Co ^ .ha dna71, 9 7 Mir lwte 7 s I 9 C "s /9 t 4 - h( ewe c es n 9
/Et 7 r y l 9
/ er (
87 ne 9" p dd e gl sede/4
/ .
6 2
/
9fl 5 sTo r&8a/niu o 9 hm 2
/f 2 es s oa r .m91 d7 a
e2 r y . 4 a 2s
/
9 we 92c
/
5 = s i t sinf ovted osl 1 rdi2 s e w e l / a r c e rge e n c v
- n (s maa s ri e v
/
.2 j. hu 9.
- s. "r e e c le n n r I lc ir "r te ew e" e aha auiliJ sd nemar ga o e re s t e.
sa- neg err t Ii e t f t o l cs i sdf e e e. l" "oem v emWd m M'e RNt m I m : oI Ds e s ePdr em m=say eavifs e l hI" o w9 s mim1 NNeiNeWoN Eig 3 O 2 6 nCnp s at Ci e Circ eo vc 2 eE 7 e r Ei d t Bt l edGhEPct En eEt f c oE r H=h Nn f le n o9s s Nde - m nt e Mbe nI aM 1 e MAaMPq m r "sCNn* N i s , l - e n t r a io Gi s al e ld C ir u ds u ea c n sq neu Hn Lo d aed et um r e ei hmed e ee is ue d sv md s , i seas m. ealo= eL. a~ dt bomL e mdan ish st - s i s e ot sE s ei s lac w i m e n e 6, y =f e cn e ede c s9t s9 r e GoP r r b s o ;, f eo = le1 ed pt am ea e d l lo uc int e ty~ sl
=
a i- on f e-a rpr a e oer amao to elif s= es sge o S, ec h sdf y o s pqc h= e p teR a leev - cra Bl o i eh bl we q au twN,t e w n D as e Ns L.. cuc
. a houyW mi e v t s
Esfeod r e a v s =e it ea= Rli c e e ur r 8 9. 0 2 2 3
t a e
.g j
,i ,
'- r' f! :
1 ! ! s : 1111lll. Pp ai Ult i 1 . si 1 . y jlplfjlajf lllf I. ~" }lhf
*s t o ej g 01 =
f,,jjijj
., ,9 ihi 1 f,i'l, i
I ;
} g a!a n i 1 i 1
a!
.i,11 n#% j Lv j i ilIbN{fi l1 jiil!Ipl
$hkf l I
! Ilo} M!j[i }'jh } ~li -
SIn !- 4 i li lclii i in i nI !ill
1 r
.E :
{ t { ' p g 1 5
%fjfi i
x lu}}ilil nn } f,k I!h - ! f !
~
I1,g!. 1 r!j
,1 a aj"
=
L 1 i t il P i}}lj;,.j
~
a i is: a; LlIl[}jg-l.])jjNl]
- a. .
11}I!j
,ii L
lii. Il dj 0 ,!!lol}ifP; } 4 ilya p ligl
$ !llil!I!!hil!!!!11 I
lllih! i]!!!d i i.
!ji it it at
)).j ji.
1 1 ill p: e
E z fr I i L i i ! !
, , n.
L i ! AI !!! !!d!ll ilfl ! !bi! !Huil i I! l :
%u lfd!?'j alllml iL}l3}, .
4 l 8 ij I li? 4}! 2!!a:]I.I
~
1-l11gi t i i e j' [ j ij
~
! 3 1!'3 .
i !!! ij i ! l0>}h l
!I!i !!
II!la!lyIihiIlilid
!1 ii
!n i1111111 l I
a_-_______-__------
_a _ . ~ n ) I t y y nn *
. o F m a
r o sny r ty ai g i t t a e ero e n ee n o d rt s a m t_ tnt e men s a r y a 1 mt n r se ma p a v. e n ma vi t pmslp=4 m n u s nre e i n s e p -
- s s.. het f e
qice e a t te, rmmmoi di a ,t o sm ns w e n ,mn h mtr m t n= wentac spe_d a f. r e r=e a e d r _ s o ecy emt c etis mvf d e p mppNuadaI tct tsen r c eei e t h& sf w a e aCwtc e D s e et udi t hk n p e. t e o c e sl nI s t f e d s a r ewt sd e a u nms e e v imt es reme s n _ r et wnmI l t, c t lcRlea s adlp e _ n n c I al eaiMr niam c n tn1t ha nde b e e ht i s v s ein o s rt e u t ye nifoted xmdle d nei eemie twtr t r a l i f la :. s r u .e t c v ementeR ti f teeI yh has r r anl
-. teucai f
e o w . a pl t n i aCnl sif aa sOh to _ c p nd ew gdI e roievem s tnt 6g . der f o s _ ym ga esn l . e E et oleepe kit t - m l o r ci - e ngud ahi h i tati i yvea s s r s.r m. e o runaalL tc) gl C v vd r s ne lpr vl is mc 9 i g I 7- Rins pi r e. _ I, 4 Ti s enmot 3 wv i ud .
.d -
I #. 2 PRvte i ir eo pn n r sdul a mc nl e t- ts f c in s n 0 RMreca tc a sc asUaate f e nt c n rRee r ". to t .n I'( ug tnn as to n we d e r d&ni nmot v e i m t.e a gti ec i n ly mar tn o ne recru b e v o i t c t a t o u f< h e I e, a t ft en cl e .h lu g m I k 's v t s a v k e LaCz 1 - t I t n e E n u, . r el a Ilw.v e o e C I I k e n n - iot s n sneer .f af . r
.o av ew.^
et c L n b n 8 de vIeeo l id wi l hr s 8 t a e 9 e t 9 ld mv 7 n r 2 1 s tcetio' e e n ufe vt at - u c 2 Fs e 2 - Tel teh a! c =- a 1f c 1 0 0 5, 2 e n or af s n D t e c laer n o is
; te Aviou = -
tjimc"- s a - te e9. at a7 r er q h T - v pe a c
. nd--,a n ep9 em ipr W. 8 r"_i"- tca s .
s I, i . 9 et n o = wo7% tn ot r d r n a e ). Mo e Ctwns . sowt mht s x u e e mpeR el sT 4 t r 2 _ eee . o ng uee C.egod 6 n M tonn 4 hh t tod; tLnd i, A w ati ( m.4p f ff oon od ice d adt e v naa" ei c a8 P e 4d 5 o r si ed ea t v R, nI f l e9Rn 2 ed g r ret aonud c hs d,h a 4 oe -
- T/r 7 otr a i
e g t nci mdoe r . Ps s s w2f a nc of2 o2 r e sd a e y R, vlei";i - e1 2 P mr r8t u a ehT r c re-c ee v eat tel e s ng7 a s s _ ell - d a lre A :e - Re6nq t u e s htf t o o 7, f n wt a aCte ee ao a9 i n r n in 9 ,h
.sa r - vo e
- e *s d n 9 ige s - = a
-- ao t
o a p 9 1, NrhnmRcb c c n rh o a I.hs da onc s R *= e 4 = _P= r a s .&et rth ntent etEti r e teWwd 5 e 2 7, lee c aaia o R e= ;- aye9t t h h t t e c t al e pl ue ee t rlp . o R. r b haNit r 9 sf 1 off d i p L "e f C mt Uutc h 7,1 a
's a M te nt e s,m o ht ei e dd htmm a
E d" e g;e Ne st e U 6. h m8 9 c t e N t m9 m nds t a
~ a ft ht c d*d h e N S e ..t
. o m1 rl a ggt e eh n ,tt a c ee R R13 r e tnt N r a ,tei r onn O ~h oint a a re
))
d n ahd S ) nger uchhu ccs e t_L..hhOet re D t t o ci n r a e 8 5 1 a nci )) n 8A r, h s 5J 8yl oaD67 e l I6C .i . s .t i 6 v h pg90t 1 8 o (
- e .dh 1 tit ni77 n Bt
( nt oAwt 7, sat ;_ te o t cen a 3d ( tewivt eoBBa 1 r y 7 9 9
/ r e
tman9 t s o 1, i i s9 n . s s g k 9 79 d mioto 9 n sb r e n p(( s s p8c8 ee a99 2 r apA ta5 2 e n oate a. ta n t 2le tc sn e77
/ pa ah22i
/ / n 1
D a=rb me i r mOliVe . '- 2 mei t 1 / s r n e o ee o eM9 e t r 7 a. 9d n Q 1iet r e ivdy12 c e b r r gen.o eb e ydete teain t taibt t masleOl c tehe 1, a e Ason~ o r Il o et mah c a n Isiu ts abad rl r nrao bt7 e 1 I s;I c tu n Cnd ii v ea e ts rwtno i C s eCCu eeleem s d mEEed l Emiev7 saeric s E .e d e Nddd MAiu1 n n9 ul9f nt toll teOM i N MnI s v eMMh g r aNMsa c n h e
. e r
d Rf _ C e s s Co ye Hs ht er I n su c ttmh eM.a e o l e Le dt n i a h t a s i adls ne t esssl e c e o d "e. e s 'e f
@ n v
e rse Lad r o en o en . s n adn tka rea atha r c er ua d fs h a_i t e e t sgs ct c c t nr s c m d io eeire t tyof o r s n r a rar #e ilsf ie c t e t .a ut t nu t im one hluci o a,e gst nag su sl e iudd "_r cn _ i s v s n i rt pa a - a r te - S, ce s e e - o ; ant s a'^ v hh st gel teR c- _ d eh _ r a en u c tdaid sn a n a E .lu m t ai=g m N "- te"_.~^Eas= t c na - D N- ;- itneh ? y ts s e c vA d 9 0 3 i 4 - v
e O s ty n
- e e n n s, l m e s s o m ent ta R o u y ch e a o cgw r
e r , f te rsC a. tenmtmu ,m emp ti % l f r r it a s y da a o e e n ih tsehe eu pR n . d c_ i e r a t c m rmo e mCeh v e s e . n po c at een eo h a n et m scy r e r t i s. d t h o et o taun . r e n t.e n -l t e a s. Irmt e ee tnw n s oca d.s ..t te tnR e ivi i s e imr N enheiviamer o r s t ed cNoht fept sh f. hf s u a er e s e esccovi st i i ata cwth w e mnI t wsR atch emet e s h. r nwmvr s g 'e d a ,nf s ni p w magdr t e Rd h ind s c itme3 e ict gti taapeaew eMt wfew4 f c ta re tternt ro 'si ny we a na mw lCnot emnIseemtoan e-s mvd ne nmT ps wmr e awt r i t n er pa dmmw/ . qS s te h s
'r rcd rats aed e
e < D l a pI se t se e or e e l u la rewe s
. mpe ippns ic wtic a i r ho ouh ah ol o oa t
wei yne d sr . fnet e6t i mh d ;. i tst n t m1 rgept n t
~ m mti mmtt ma e n kf enne n .
s f. h v d e g mt r e ut r w 1 ty e ivr os h ee n de tm,im r
. o atc >nd evh < e ov wt en w m. m1 e not pniwnt dh e sl e n msmct o .e*tu c nt aevc. d;,wset a ti a b epei e 4mi r a a. tmhe t
- n ig3 f p a,n l si iumt e n 4 c s rd ea iutas tr aCf uRet ch apea .
s es n o teR n r ec vre as n1s o s tyu p3i g r it c at tmev t f = e a h h, J . nni , v s i P iwh t r t t y M a- nist s rt la v%ti c v s. e s e yh rdtfe oe i.mke f n4, i t a s s t nRaf e e
. i t a o o ad n opa thvh T
r el d setaswe tas ;o. ta c ws e hs 41 l i s o )mfusrc sR r ugAsTe en a c. ni . m 'a,c t ic h, o 1 pdR trs R ~ vi - n I . s e s ta rda sh e
.hd ph e e E -
a.wti eexsefto mq n st se iAns v(f sdi i roe nf ve C _ e .. as l r uet nsd e e g C mqi mdehs r vee ve ehhl r aeeu wt u e m.rl r) .y q I ; t . eo ;. h mt
,ts a ns e s mR a A "x h ei
*r dei tc) ;
p toat e cei ph pti*d rt vcl s p e c s tcC , wadv ;_ rgh irhluiev s I ct e pt t s l t i t I. c Te e t rt menme tahmu v e eIli es . n u i e o I i Capn eedf r uf tat eiwoidi n empocmft wo e o( ug I effRf eCe(fI thi v mp .
.ot
. pi wi tat mv re l ea poie'( up r
o m a_ . sf r e n g ht .o
;n o
n ; n o ..i
.e t
c a
- iv .
i t a l u a
?s . Md tcd le'C f s rr b I s e e e ;e ao v aJ ar c E
t pI wc ga e c nin' i C c a ono t e H. . etis-N l. tg 's e I l b 8 by a. _
,tnC oR 6 a 9 e ~ 9 tp n .
tooI i l e 2- i .. 2-c 1- is2, deev tne 2-c 1 h . et m 1 A 0 1' rnai t 0 es n eo
. ht tad r tat J h ep o tsd uer
' t
.?
, cd s
.t i r ner e
2
. n d an sw 4
- 5. nee no f o o vpo g ele mn 5.i vt R 6 2
a R, v ia R, ae c C. e 4 e 4 s a g P d tr PIpi c P a R, nladn R;n' : pa e io st e s
- noc e i
nc os p n s R n-o p
%t 2 of r d a
r seCap 3Il s e n o lee ne ovi o l n hb h i etc R d e at n d tal a e n e ut tni nt e on o C mcouo n sp e E mc o a.del u gU nn . N c sl ea chc sn N ReRe e R o
) r Cs p ei t v
) c 1 or e 1 oa 5f sa 5 rpe 6 s g pu 1 re n l e al n 3no
( eti a Bd ( nv e 7 stc 7 a, ofT. 9Re f 9f v e oR 9Cp x 2 f sE 9 2 r odM e pse 2 e I 1 h s 2 1 piht r p e a, e ap t rl i r o e a d Ast taui t ems e ns I e l laTs i e 7, evRv i C4 l f f9ebM E00 hc l CeMi 4Ree l f I T M'f hf t e tc "re a R s; n e C w (c o Tr a fC R Hs Le Rn o e f e s
=
= aI
= l f s o se d n \
dt i Thipmn o g v e ne av n e adan
=
ks ai n t
==
lf st i c h= ewh e otrafe e e a==a== m m Mp = Iz e de
= h gT f nl e cm r os a tt m sie=
nr an s c m *= e c a io% ia ea e al ;- n pR e e* r oae c cn ti e r
=
S, ce e m C' int nv em e e v ei "s. e e eR t a d e ihvl o el I s r e n di iot vd s d. o w ' ec r p t i e t D %e 1II r n w o Pa r t i' m r e c 1 4 2 4 llrI I
,L
v
. a u t y e e y w e n
at t g af b II d 7
. e evs sdl a nAt re r uknnunti fdhs A ei ntet 9 t d s a a m e i
r c, t e- eC v 9 tus eeeCmgni4rt d e ad s r n r r ee s nr w e i h e ne we led e as1 r e r e w-e Cshdat n at i ai e a2c s t r scR t t h a ht
- t. e ks s vi he t ni cr gs oa oew1 t.h t tt 4
i i de nec dn mg owt in cr a+oiI ymt rr =- r a f o R r e g = e 1 o nivi sha tshd m i le e o d e wed enl m - d t we e srCnrRm tmwr mynvnsr awwh ecs f s wmt dIe n.4cve h - r a e it Mlies ti ta4" cwmreCn a e mi wwh st ei tpmOad t t ee t n t e re r wdh alaetm! n imas - I ah i efihte mh tah I e iedhhgt ahd gt e R D lmrsi vyr na t met hmrlae rst ert mih . Nt e 1 i( re n tor ted mrs mveu ess e n v1 t - t e -g n h s I e tmlm ot ut r yart C u s"a R he ge hv y gt a re2r i greCos h s nnie nit a nh c desvwao ns mnRlye utr v h. s s n s h4i ei v tnha ge sfa f.w i e t i nRmkh r t me . e k oR 4 n ta i iao .dAe esCveor n sl t. e e h C,stRtmr ste u s s A. ewe memeen . i eC ~.ta gR e tmhh wdi hi t t ee i mtn r ~ re u a w wR e Oe a z mA . - iddt a y s r ws ne wu wta n . v n tmt o g i en c ni nf aCs r l . ot t i sll ea m A_tfaf i at _.2tC sda a ns r et e t e tcfd* r c e n wimt e ed r i c c a g i wmvi e terseiAt 5 na 4 daveenh el n v a a t ymt is v e ss wged meps r m e at c a e r uf aoJ p o riN v c -tnie
- i o f whsoc ahs l
tc Ari vic n et omleef a f as e tni r n uh le- evf s cad et eopn a. .tteNti f~- ssR se t.nse mel l F f. a aeti t t n t nys e w ora a. i s r am wS mRet ae ght veI hF- si gC-- l s f pe C lAs r i g el s te na ar os 3 nf wt es e e3 . ev r I Cu CpuCa mrosucCot nI
- c) p
- y. r ea f eis v pd n r deye . a.
,d g iemns ta t g
p I, et teor n t s h sl atmel edlh epl s v e s o v! c s g aS s ic R dnsns ppoia- -.tvr r r vi o n ;eirUhApm_i r t nv es tc) s y. ci gtehetsuru elt e! im 1 g t f r Uf T t tinel r act oh chl aa u gg. Caaiamp p pM m cc aI r i s etnhh eal e ed yoE nf e i 4 t t S ab c( me s n to e R s dna "K e d geC h t J rue sh nh g I. 4 sa p n h. t w i s d p o nge rR relum ~ s
.toa ei n it eCeno v s w e, rf .d e .
e t tn .dea r d- ar man a Oas u gns n n s l le ts. ge . lesgmpo iv ei a . d uti J ot a . g mt n adndindd b . a v i i pior teLtxialu-E p h C cn c e e v tofinf ehtfte a e c o nc bei ps de nio t aopind le - ti. s r l t uat i eta s n e b a - a hdn vlhpa e oi r c L tyt n mr tp t s ad s nroe a e o t s 8 e s e ;a smop w 8 mmt ct yh i 9-2 c c sot a ri p a-is4h to a 4t r isf icnu - cur n 2 hgi Ti nb ai tn 2-1 0 t I Spapoat le oc r ctteth t aa M. 2-1 w 0 d h i e ge e d ir e os s uu - c n t eh hr i ne or de te i vtst n ir tc cu r al u s a, f uAno
- a. h s.cs s er i c s mro e v s e
- ta v dneg ch't 1 4
mmie d c 1 1,i ta pi s f r r o or ew hRe g 7 olT l icv rlO s 2 CiR w eat e g d M v mu Cn e o a P r T - i
- te O,roh ni t
.,.n -_S ew e
s e h e _hd ys t eg n mtra t, wn o p 4 i n-e ~.e a loa a 5l h s agt n r s nft oc e u o o R e iO t d a n 7, u. wo n~ c a i.^ nic eno
,md l_.. agtnRasr C e9 n/ .mfe i E m30Aoi r / ct n N o9 led e t
_.lus;. ; c N e n Rol e vi e Rs e iC. I)d 5 t e n eio t nh o t I)dn 8 eht t ta e 5 a 9sC 6 m gS s I e Bl nr no t6Re h ( pi 3 ( gs Ct 7itmfFs 3s iyop n t. e r 7i n e n 9 s1e ne 2 c e6 at a 6uisk 9 d
/ 2d a 2
1 r oro tc ai n
/e o
pf rd r 2tro t 1 r te gls fooo r pd e t ino o :.. co ee e s p o ledt t nl erel t a se oreac ytre Ctiet es e E hlyd. ag Cngd s Ein Ntnnanre m n a Nnl d e Niat n N re P e v a r C h t a f o to
-f Hn Lo h et tsi dlin y l d
e s i R vi n dt na Cos) n papse t a adn et c s h mlae a d- nri ag g n r- as ctyhc e
- m. i (i
el c a
- i es r vd
.t n - s uns au aOn mff i L, e ce eaag s c d n e a a o nnei y e o eR t
h e sF n upnt noi mti au a D o o m Ccii 3 omd e annh tl c s ne I r a o 4 4 4 fl tll1 , 1I
e e a n 4he m. w
- e a o ,
e mh t ev i r n ie e et ef e s3, n s r ,1hA t s n erede f-i tsdi c c h g r c eat satobm f t a hr veS er e it nn mmta w ;. 2 :dttne e O r e v et i( 6 . n e n. 4 sn(eh e nh eh v
-es t
wn s1 a t m v e(a nwu rl w .l e t. i m uer c t, r n en s mc o e t r r c r at e of Au4 d. De iIsw ee .. le .l h SdmR . v
.. r
. of i w
w r e e u:d rtui ndo curefs hretRn mo e g c.s d cr n uCee t . e e eve s. P . AeR w3 F i n eniua g n n mac tic ;R
, y mMsmi
.C gt
-e miGih .s c a h -
in .
. wc f r tadeb nt en .. se e
i ms etslu d fa e ...- e a s . wv i e t l ciwn eu r r y btsirtat su s s Dumv Al Cgs ei n emv eis r mnl utnu h evh es eia c rn lgC' e n <w ,.la . pvt e3 eis r) g!ul at u e mnw u e h rr ho e c n r e a nRg nit e 3i tm mt e oi ssr ;Rais, Tcmd r evni a e f r od mrio1 le&cusb h c s e v s tnb tuk esL,M s et e
. nee nt a ian6 c f ixDr (tee af s g e a n n n it c Uao e hliRe p mtwc d r a3 iatinc a
. .l a nn s A e ;c t
.- heet t
f toeir gSgtf ne e AhemAtpsrl e e ct c ns e me a .
. ah n
T nyCend f o nImieS nI T cmotnma a :s a.C . ins w as vo ..t .is s I E tua f gF) - dts r . hRRr e e n modi n aa in nh n n t i iCCpa n T.1Ts( a s . etT ytws
. otam)
. i s t sr ee C
r e w . r wfes e es i e v. i g ueeaueOdg s s st u wgla t v i f ngA5Aup aDis n a.u ( i v p g. e ei tih s I it s e g p0 w ce )s y. I L u isr c i n. aRfi mi e n nnvinnieTCriodhf e s. eov i v r v n t e c i g A.,, Fn t t t i h tdth e r Cd e te t c t e t f eh 4 e aa wtoAht tog hnc ee ,n 1iRR: .oRiap
.l e ed o d nr .
.,f.
( ugg rd ser ee vt ye ah e J, y n o lbh a1 a tp n-so e a. J.l -.
.I w ;. l o .tc e
r - i e nat - tu m. . i
.ebe ds e.
t a c oh1 a cit ; mi. - l r u atser = a d. b oiu l to! u! frot s inpsi tat t d e a v r s o nn nt o edieo c E a e p ted e iyi nc t de cc n san ehe
- t. e p
r C p onaa ng n I I ta o
- si s
wsain s e el v g iat n i. o .
..toai ._ nt h
L c .i n e &. ei . rm.d
.ul e sh s J.
et .ac r e 8 ec .o a e 8 o s d se . h 9
- n . fh -m 9-ihs _d
,vi ont 2 2- d a
~. smc u 2
- hi na e ..hi s rm 2-h&
T a .-u rt ch
.i at 1
0 G . ti t ne
~ 1 0
n s e aigo n di l tci v dAk e c o r nea r pt gv r istiT ie h 7, en s rceR a te8 5h t erC r e e s1d 2 aCh s e,1t/en- r 4 r .tn .
- 4 ,d t
f et xr n e me fo r 4;a 8 Oons tn 2 R c o R 97 w e g CRti
;Cm a C. D'
~A m P a
ef r s n oo f , 4 e, s e oen ,3 P u s s pdi n s e r e tng n .Misc o p 6dt gt r 1 7sfnc .i i s nl e g e nae p e o iwn ol tips R t a oi dn nr a ny d of e e ean k e g ni ti e c tne C nr ua a n a,id u E md m-on n M a o cah e c ,t N RsRe ac R' e s n
)Ct )
o 1 ri s 1 /. a mi t 5 os 9f s 5 tg s s a 8 ni 4i s i Bat no 1 s e (l 9ev ( cri n 7 pl e nb 7 u sR 8oi 9ila 2 tca 6aC 9 e 242
/ av a 2 /elue 2
1 te e re r el a p 1la e v e e v mn mmosr sfl em or o i at a df Ie s e e Col n i Cs mt mm felve Me NdC pmh o n Ge r du u Njg gi m 2 l yr e e C r a s v ner Hn t o I Lo dt na i xh tew nl ee c no eP nn tctef rofo e e c e at s ad e n Roi e Cstr c t m a.- epe a ne uhW diuu gs n u veio d a r en o v inhiv e e pt ni c Se c 6=irore
. t at t a) ytm ecr (s me e mr aRu rpi, s e eo o t 1 cCe n t
aeR d n c i v ue nn y f di . D rof ni v os6 Pig M4 5 6 4 4
1 . O e 6 fyJ e e n P a, R e s f
, r s .
ff oc a
. o R - e crr om i m o t e i g
at r ty i s a i e fapa r ut a ro nah hn mts t _ t a re he si n sJ t m n uer y e i n r e a _ at ewlc e t e wvl i h s dhd e ed eu s n n n f n.rmu' se pne ta a wvi u e we s et et qmI h to 4 =_ im mdmie ch il nmdi e fcl iWend h r a v mol eh a e r c e e y r
~
fo m r et h d.e r e pot 3 e eiwat r rb i s Id sfte d i hgs s luwc e c s t s d su0 d e t e mdt ed awnnc e wh c eo ws m a e n ges r tu j A. t ie erg mnicaa ov h s e 3 e e m e ec r ==fn tsdt s de ih s a g D tnanI me a c eteh wle e _
, c w.at d nt I u s i eh m sur n s s
s 4c h eemmtop, e cthe . aI s nh a c a s e cc v. ch kd rs e , nt vs n Ts hi e vi a.u a i n' n e e em nse vin 4 r r e a a v tc e a ewi s a - un i c n r 1P e8ei4 b e e Re et ef tuhh w Mat a t t r r tpi b e e e upth A.3 i a n a 3 d i t c v 6vhIi ai af s et c to oautcr tast r c e nf ef dI sl ee e r vJ c tuf R t o n s i t uc senic in dpt a nlaca w - sa' st e a y to n e e R eleid r a hf ) tecc . iplet t e c a I npc eml s edh naadni ari cosn htyoe r ( r a n n v e aco ssi f h. f E 4 nal c es at rd%mwtm s e 6vdei ea m. drngei a ncf l l e s s _ Pt Rnf a a n ee a r scdu-dc m oih r os r n C u ofohtJ nci v rg v ef g -c ' p y i tswifRt eb teev ev e e aoCs2ct g t _ r gr e e e e p . c ws ia a. he .itc) v vdh c el r i g t i e hIh b ri r rh y R -
- y. r ne r ic);
p L t eervo it niew m eTtog pR r 4 w fes
. ta A. Etni.g ei wTb l t s ges n
neMfo ox p. Pe i. t f hst al oRmee t NRsueh' r s Rht .hL( uy . t OhlaMnleni: b(iRi t u v v - e uI gn u v e R e htuo' T nti n _ 4 eet
. sa' P c -
n R c o e idp . i o f tct a u x t a o.. p b, e- du l e u i.. ns on - e l a g o -c _ v g inmn _s _he E h n J. xt fo
. e r C n e
e b e _ H p 4, wh s e ty . e L le b l oth ea a 8 9 ba - 8 9 blellaziu a ss 0 gg e 2- tp e 2- tps a tq 9-2 c - 2- 2- e eh u c 1 c c c c pp c a 2-1 A6 0 A 0 Apet m o 1 0 vl d eu R, h o 4 s rPs r 7, s iRo e t 9 n hinc a
/ o s ted s el f
a _ 0it 3
/ a w
o 9, u
. l l
- u. d s - l a e iu v 5 v s 2 o ctao v e s
e 4 prh r we Rl bthig et s e e R, au 4 c s p c e e 9 2 CilOr w s- v e Pt o e . e g
.,e r o R, or D, TR a P
oe ,M
.nci ct d a av f o
--.Iel o
_ e rd iluap s
, ev
,t n o
rGuT al .it 2 .aR 3. of a c 7scM nandted 7 s ner 4 i 7f nt i ol s pan ov o s
%e t e
d or s r ne a l iia dta w nro d iu ta jy r nid e ct nt o no C e nf et mac E moer u m o a c si e unn n mfs N c e ,a uD ai c ta oit c a N R" c s . e c Ri f es R h
- 1) .tn R s.
i
. oCe r 1)tss )it w
5 8n / nt seo 5} 8s 1 5 8 e, 14i ss eat ra s 4 1 r e 6m 1 3znpon ( t ri o 3i ( gu 3t i 7 ut ei st ( n 9 o cga c 7 e 7i o a n 9 s 9t Wseeie 26 vi v Wt 2h a / a 9 g 2i
/ eirt /t / s 2lav 1
t r v rb uce w yt J. 2 1 ce rn 2 1 v rn te e a ef e o cle e- td i ei t f emt i na cs s s st iemu g t e a eesldoreny Cm Cd e se e C G e g t,oda rp lh t Ei v E f u . ep Mor N Nj6ba Np Nc I l e s e u to C Ime vt a c t n e t n Rn I o fofoc a r s u t a se-ys a uyie u reftio s e
\
i rs t di enn s f dt a o n a bmitfoic ad sr 0 qi ts 3 t r ela ev t n u ci e . ino a n qi un e et e n aeu e eg i v is an ri et et in r a e vs . wia paGa em ee Gi t tct inr e os r s ae ys f u t t ot ef ig ti c e s rRc il t s a n se miyn ovn ng S. ec i, I eCE e s uv J e D i"a i s t aeR 'b. . . c D 6 4 6 4 d - 6 4 a
= !)$!fl!
nl:lisill j 1 5
$$hJInfl1 51 { ii
! 8* y 3 ; ;-
2 53]-]3 Qi! y $1"613 j j ; g g, 5 ; - l
!. Ile!1.j;II;{Ell t IF!jleIj 11 eq j t
1l in{sgli*l"1 1.* 1 i
!~!ild3IFagii*11 i
E'!liti **s i
.?
0 it))is!1LLa iP]Y'3i181kts i1]!tililli i.t si sitili]Ei!!il aikilil!!!!ii a
., 3*.= l e 6 5 j ..I=! 10 i
6
}
{ L idilil
- i 61111.1i ill I.ij i k i E l .El 2 3 3 8 .! ?ll i is it i a i
!! 4
!:)!
((]l} yh*g ji
- p. il =
5
$s bh b E4a{si bs N
~ E iii (I Ig JEi r l' s
s ijl}]l
,po P
- 5 11 5j i* jiri !i
!!.gEEl il' !
11 il*l C Co 1 lt 6 E II I U .
.l D N ll 1lilt}if e
I J l
g _ _ e n s D _ , in h a ao a m 7_ f D. F dk d p y D
)
s f F s ne f o i.- im es a w y ae F f e - R e n; b s w s m F n n w um m b d r i R t C R s mGN i I i n t C ll C e ul :a. 4 m r fntuo f o N i c 'e
~
11 G e r va c n 4 I R W h tm aDt e h t 4
/
I
. I h tnI N =
c t gll Y' O vk g d R " r k R n D e tmWi 9 T le.r eini n a OT -i. 2 w"O
- c 3MaI l
t a I a eI r ; *T e c h N m b u R I s r s p% ! 4e d M N e rN s t O n t 0 i t A. 3 sa mO _ e n s e1 r R h
=.
t n b e e wn t i g x. gh c t 9 4 V f b l d n a 1. u iqsM e Wo s i s mtad u n
/
D t n er mD / pt ner n s F n - if s irn% tc , S tuM ih a o o E S u n
- 2. lahF J esS e
r r5 r a e O. sm s tr s e c J a e e a ee k O. J ras eO. T mmarc tnm o I C r gts f I"b E mde1sl iI c re Co C efC f a e r et 1 E o is n r h a u g tsfih Ct I k pd n o_ g E g t t l h. a2 n7 m - C udt c e r J u I o 8 9 te u . mm de=
.. e ge8 toa7 s e e c o8 v hf
_ I tnot v o hc w - ad ue 9 s n m t e mlew9 _ g e r I. epmo c rP f i qk e c J d- ;tce emtah r rc rmna a v q# 9 uu1 - nbaue9 I aC ni2v _ em m MI 1 d a f o ea rae d - al a - Ri f mhMhTaH hdEMRW
?
8 At r H : eJ _ 1 t Ce _ r ie t u s _ e ht s c _ e c o a._s _ thteh o _i n mt ss tn gh _ o I, foo e e t... mc nar . i d rt r c v e . t a a a iM a u mps ari ed p
. l r
lt f o l n -- un e aa nnk a e s ar - v ;c. b e - s a te o iooi ee te E .
,. s -
to ap-*s t hdt w i s s a &d* h "t r - p C L; s u s hci' at c aA1 e c e I I. i s emon-s gnp r a6 r s u .h lptetr d a s . eufa o I oapot i
- # e 8 _
9 r a a t r n s q 8 8
- pel e o 9 ned 9 9 rm J 2 d o :, m r t adi 7- od e pa nn 8 2 R 1 8
o G ;. o
. r oh n in& a J.
2 s eea Rapr l 2 2- - 2-I 8 # R S . r e _ e e e ht e _ h v s s tnEh e s a r h lade kaWto T -. t, l , f e h e o sg d e I gt e3 na r n e s si-s f Ct iSt r te y7. e a n _ C r sAa ygen o cl 9 um ul e A. e. h - a s wses sa- ntc9 s a i t n nt a .
.e- s i hahst un s r - fih p ise1ia u l
s at n% a ist e r iss n aa e e ;-tnsf r tyw t - st Dt a iw7.h t n bm"4 aue er c y tum d et ea c id r n- &in eM c
'91 wnoFb 9i s c op s : R s n b a yrh o
rh e
- a. t-.diof2 a
e e
. ts in oi r r ipo Rn l
o . mP pC 2
- t. L..romt l l
gr n sr atooi e f e3 s r2 s I ist 4
==
= L inie eh a c s yenrpd v 4 "-: .lbit rn n t
e hly1 igt1 nsn o e e eE n f o
.dh e a a edfnf Sm ni n nt wd n amt - s c _
h ige 0c o wic el e fi.f ; . n cet
. Uno a, d r
n haiaaEc r h loe 1 3 J.,IL f m n on 3. ri r oee sf f a o .
.ncea e o psa g d r tsWt a cw e sLnui t
e g o vh s e eh er s s nh cbPC t As - a g4 f lopvh bT
- inties i
r lyac nioCS - P ys trt or i o g e o. hr r e iht n. g e b y o o s. bl r n nu awcEei -- re r foar m.r ;. o ed af nni l ineti eh a c tna sti eh - tne e o s t r se O,het hh t J _
- b e
s d g
. t d a5Is as now8 9 itshdmcL.
ol
. m rh br oe Dsr st tr df n o P l .
n e r .un1Ccad9 eo .
.i e yenr e n 1, h Wig in ea r a o
. &u R o gf e uo eH Ci8 Fw9 9 l
o p 4 n tpyr r pbet erh ee r s7 a d a s. fnade ftept n o ntdh f o od n ECu7 9uitsno I h e 1, . s e ena sl et nt Cy roe"- h nnCiw1 t e iinIl syco v o chi 2 a f 'e tao ie r g n n o a de)A9ic a97 ne1 we t ft i7 R
.M erie h gf n oa r u
t r ca
- o leeot P i 9 u 7, ffS o ; 2, y
vfhtCt ainI a e r tnt nO i m1 J tani c s. sl i y,1rs$ a e oet r r c a e pI fiaNb r i r m - leniai v r nC ni
' .pphth tint m.lpI cF e Ded .e s lpci e E, e C =2 n gn w oc, ecn3erea ex ny s
PlodenumerP rl cet c h r a PApM bd= m et a s ehL t t ns a E i Cr ns c s od nclyC o aeF _ N P
- ewgn e ene ni rl cinicd t ob Epai eddpgogeE C (l, e cie Emicl r e e ef yr c g b N 6W Canit eis o ndeat v tiwc o e
n gfs n havrn er onc mm urnit a el i yi s u hrgA nd e nd hie e a pD sh I" gee r oiaaie T pge _ 8)b e snfh e tetwiagsm n tal uta tyi epnndeS ea Tone na Tl tun t cnn )ivt e eisntac 9is ) p rid 8 d eF
)
8em s e 4W E 5d 9 61 ne igoOo ab ec .nrprl s e osl alap ream 9t a 6 1 art, c ehnunaa aoohd s si n s
.n 9 96inuiER gelcC ntc s 9 r 9
4t p sl e toieipe u a pfn n a n o t 3 )s n yedioae s r ei 1 3id a nono df o 1 n 3e m a.2 0( (Cart i s tct as tnr e tce gb wps ass opell avPemshi oe r e n e 3=hrl 0 ( 9 = tsn nPgt .ml e s elanTeu i t p a e ov t o ( 8t c tr ar c o e st sn t ( smi e 0ebc 9lae
/ s 1
2
/u nd eCger r ete w J t
2 gsi e
= aed nCr uEorl eb s e m e 3 erne 1
2 r r ew a ceo np 3nn 1 ai 2hw te es !yE gar sesh / e d nur por u c w gD esa NM q 1 idih! evti chi mI m i ed ihta sd i aer t, s eCmc ei1n a c eeirh w 1 inn r ro=etnhas eeg= ael sm s es =pf o s
/
1 eeiie eh cn pnhe
/n 1 eh rai c e sh me s utehe=
t n o i t sht tsh p" t a y ,er e n = s e e es e s sn y& st sf aost en t a r t, th emoce ,w t kW M Id On ev s s e a e ph eolft - xtl s t i= u o Id 0aumd na l e sA=si i s= n tnr
= t Oisnt osb gh a il md mi nae I r3 O
P
.no Cetri a hl' ai isw 0td si e egss e iP Cnsini r C e" PePeM Ec r i niPC" P 2a pdivl birnMees c s Einet t gd r dec s
5W i E WoiCi t n Cl C P C e E =e E 19foipn-4 nrot a a ecptr= ni eV enddu r s E f L. . e vi fi aAFd e ICiEd".Pte f E f .R l2 y f o J P r tn P e C RM __l a lcu e e me n C En r u Hn Lo r
,,irpp alc t y s e nl eb oy gvt ti i
l a m h& a c i mo e r ,
\
dt npr e ni t e. na adn s ,n s a i. s dYs eit su f inis in a .
. s a, =n e
cn e " PM wroitau he t ic t ptWl o ni c suna r e n gd ei y r t s ld' an n e ., m= c t ni e e e es m ih;re tnoen l o a e= e mo nt ot at n iesi t e tid r eRh t rl mol a cus a S, eR t a ec "MM fs e e shlou* ngo= e r eee us t ht rnta e ec n v ni o r o s pca dUi eE w e ng d en ivfli s r aof es iuer s qc D my he G e ua tr r-Iml aa l e r of a e ia Psd t aor t p I e Mn I 8 4 9. 0 1 4 4 5 $
O e d o e a s O n c D ly I! t n m e D e D_ n s o 1 u t s e e n c n n F
- Q' h rs r iW Q' e e a i . h s F t
n s pt t d ei n $ r. t o s di m F i ) o a no e R o. e in ei ec e to R t A e M h. qt cn ne n a c G g f otsm4 iyt( s rern n agma tnt e i n G m a 1 0 ta as w. i l N P h sh c n ur et
- p N k m
r st h w I ICs- lu a csh ta eme s p r toei c us I h v a n m. t tgra wn w R u' h ol R t e oe ie 1 O ht e^ ah eedh A am c E i n p m .eunesi ue i ht r ss'n e ev e 5T . c s epd e ta es i 2 ad n a. s T D N in 5 9 s aV - i I N h t henRct c r ss ei .d R o lev r - s G82 nad &. 4 O: de ed ei h 6 'l t deR O s e 2, M m toh nr ad m tnA ty t 1 a1 rmn e Ad9l n a M tr 3t tn yn me 7 w 2 S "I e . n ' 6W a _m tnh o en gM e / D n a v r i a abA f A ee . e c 2I tn e
. u s o9 n wPa 5. SF o st a c e e ad osnme .
m t e4f f r p9 n e em u ?. S . F t r n l at h eed v i R. eh l t t ai eCp 1. D taime i bk p e c a v m .ar f e icvFe t a e
.m a JI J. C d of d -pmo ne r or e c r at ta r ure cnt nye m
oo svwA vatr ec a .
% t O.
s&C ly R E f uCr ;.h 6 nwe 4 gg e3 et ct d1 hl nao5 h l aI vJ c
.la le=8 ss 7 a o te8 l s inrl.dt es r ev e ghei ens9 ru 4. tedta v e s i ewi l
tn C t r o nn9 a s8 o 2 eI
. a. nlpi d e imc "p iefc rm98 i
9 wir eeaR. h or r M -29 t l rh . nie - tar t p - lf t - a ic eprp o p1 o22 Cv sh l e c . rf e f u i L dn agn r we2 re 8 med- dnRa# t ean ekRe s n eec p i
- g
- . Ammm uhi J one8 e - P 2-UMi" teS# e e e nr f ri i 7 r
I LRt tr h aCI e t t RmL mtoGeS8 F 8 s d nn m u teo re - in "s l n n -Pe o n o CnI' a p f P it inCt a . . a Fh . . e l u lahnt tg . mm
. t a ioiwia n q te te.
t te v h t s t a lad e a a a E u u u C &odnina ai crs q e q e q e st aindr sei d a d a d a H lpeu r s
- a. "i e sa s s s s L , v n
- tcc
. 8 i
8 i.' . 8 i 8 iem 8 9 9
. ~
9 - 9
. o c ._ dud e - - - a 9 r2
. nt J - 2 2- n 2-
.er oce 2- 2- ,
2- v 2- s p 2-a cl I , 7 7 , f e Rf r toes f R # R 0 R o R f s e s ly 7, r m a . ec -ech ot i h le yr 2 e w- dn o f so~ f .
- r rwah
.pi t ^- tno -
i ) n a3 be nu f e r a s p o e gn dinoslat .i o3 p m r e n g
.hr e nr et n iino pn o r E o he nF c e h e .e i k s ci C
lu n u v
^
pi ly i d b c o t. asi h E tcio y t n e r e ninnv s Aecb i' r te R 2 o t e ae tn i ellP Of a m c&mdR' e d enl o eh milnt g v i Ce iwEs d u nUs ioNem c ni ed 4 f o hAgaa tc iees s ne t a nd nua Pei n ehh ae t ele a u t mc 2 t A a fs tce Fu r t ightd onee 3 sr te s1 o e i a 7 tn C .inlp tfi s ou c g tod.cf PitgM o e P 9 9 n e ",ladm v r g tor e P a CsC In so eu ei ioi r6
.FvE e 1rdi tv, d n
a 4 itnce' Pt e leb t tnope nd sb s en9 8. r t n _ yn n e ci pe b ls n Rofproet ioSenm ew19 e ,d1s.bini ed uCa r J r pe s si r s e ee s e yM e ye3 ( e m s v ts i2 c 7, n so ae os cb erf c os tc c ehP pt diHiu hb m et ie mn o iyay t c o r e DwC tebi a awisv t p r u ps phane eof hee m0 f i par s dnsn r u ecea= lem o im9 r it e gaqv h tst t in t pbt ro re eR mE9 L e ui b R i n m ed siebne eta ht idn at e i beRu e s ese ge h1 1, ms mhe lTF e ter a va pc phi w wdl e a / nn 1 3 e s c il wdb
.y C hhina i e d ms e8 t u .
guvi inlc u R iwlyRM' t e yn r Pv e E minq i a m c tgwh m etic htc 9 us e, a i C Ci e N N i u n r tywt b emra 1, gad e we Rb e CrahC e tE P h e Wae J m e e h s T e EcW A pd e y B=l DWdiris p7 l ae 5) o n ) m
)
m aO eet e2 ) ) 5 ws a s c ey r 5i 3 d 8 y 5 9 eiihm mf 5s m 9 = er 5 mPm 5 s e r p 5 e 6s 1 e 3m ( maem 0i ivairTe r enu s as aemwF e sa a ey
.h r
6 =r ac8 . 1 3tned9 ( 5i, dm 7t, e9 9 6 gCi d 1 3i ( av re 8hel ed nEn e s e T@b 9 6 8 3 ( isnsen 0 m a a m m ms e 9h e 6tb 9 3sn ( s 0 e mewi 9i mh 4 n ur tg- imkb 9 8 e 9 mh e 9Uas i 9 ah s 199 ay
/
m2 / e nl r / Nnm m c 1i 2e
/ s e n ysd eibc - ee nu 41 mr ia 1
2
/ n ee~
etbl 1 2 yt s
/
1be sn a au fih t 2l
/ew i .
m 1 s re e mmruemb m 1 rrb yem 1 r u yl m r eey 1 s e ped a e a r h ecbwi rel e m sa m m t u t ml s r te a mb enis v s r ec s he p e mipl u e e emo ei A n m. a wy mdn u IJ Ifl a n Obi eb lO"m, t c l I
- i. M I@min O i e Cd m m e n u a 0 dew OeP mhPic iW r m C b ei Cni p . 0v Eoy cec -
E hmsi Rede Sg a8 r s EmB . M e l l E amis f mu a E e i9 8 pe E e Nmis e i w NiOp m Et IP b9 T1 9pu 1 aO ' Gd f u r s e s a e y e= r a= la m ua C n u to e h i d t e = d r i e R m gt h m= m ivem Wl im e e inn e r e hr dnc a s L i m m . mti u eb p e p d m rd mu dim ikc d ae emm too uu m n f tomm e t gn ar e e a otsuam r u ag dl i wia a . i t a t m s c . e e eeae n n uu ad sa e n smC ts t i i n m iiam u i r r m me u ma me u t e dg md a m mt r epaom g tnIm m e e id wuim v e ain iymp eo r m mty t s e enuo mm m c S, hius oh ci oil e, e aal tm yum m w l. y ytu e es ty t ml s s eb rn d t D a a m,m Mg7u mt ua d m
$ g i
s oh u aKm RI d u s itehh ur qe ep Rs u m ada em nm o Eac lisi l mev m mi e Ciim n ad 4. 2 1 $ 6. 5 $ $ $ $
i i i !!! e t r i a i! i;!. a "l 3 i i i! li i E ! II -!.$ ! j >i i 11 a il ,!!, 3, M E ] ,g 3 jj ,g g r 3 g 3J g 12a 3 si 5- 3 kl 3 51 3 l l
.i ,
I. . 1
=
1 J 2 3 1 J 3 B 1 J i B a
's 3 1* .i .E 3 1 x I Il h!!!
1
,. i,i,.<I'n,i..;n;
! B
!s,'ilil:1 !l e -
1 3 !,, e
.i a.
{,! s-!i,
.i g
e
,n
!n e
![h},.
la ill.ildj$]l'3 ji i lj,.
' ]lji!'l!fi l h 1111111Lhjh lill.h!g.l j I j{ d fini 1111 g 11 ! -
d i j p[ fj r 11 p i (l
,i il L
lil
O 4 I j f
=
w! 9 ina] 1 j . k kl3 4i w!}i l- $ l- ! $lill 5 l]y! iN ! ! bI.l!.!!!jjf!il '
}!Iil!
.1 . J .1 g g i j g g s ..
, r .
} $ ! -
e i i ifn -
- ((o.i.11>,
3
- i Dil!bishi r e i l4:li 1 .
l f' 3 f a r p.h[}ii ilt , fn-hj h ,c a m lll!ll r. %y 1 5
, I 5I ii !}, h l. l ' ,' lh is r .
a if f,f# ld f3Ililjgll+h i r 9' ld[t l1 lI 111 d ili .. . . lf I li ! W ds il E*ll ji - il - ti or .lj 1 1 {e 1 lil all l! i II: 18
0-h 3 }_ ' g- h-
, I , f-t bn: n 3
! Ii N!!!pdI i fi[p,Si
, n i
i !!h 1 ii j!!! i l i 1 iII II [1 hidl1 1! ! hI i 1t r{l !!!!ill pg i , i
!lfl I h ff
]ll!h!!!!Ilib i
1 1][n!! iI. !! : li Ih p
0 s c *? *
- y, P G y 3 a
gi d,,F3
}
- 11 i O!i liO E ali%!}t n w3 f ila e i =
?
= kg2R j I g! ! _g{e .
0 igi 1tl r 5 i!H]j}1 ; 3 3lt is 9 !111 p i .! E,; 3 Esj 3 2' - $ II5'! 4 $ $ $ $ $5l3 ISI 3
,- f El 3 b g I-[ o E
a If,E} fli
}
h. 5 Illi eut :e
.= 5 l $' !e l; !
atd - [ e a e E} 5 .F l
, 1, 5
;lIl! -llIL !jg n l { ja
(*),2] jlf i M .. i 35 2a , fj i .! $8 [- J. l N I i.a .? *al {1
=
g e rl ?? s g [ )),I
]
35 N il s ig. pa djits j,],'s t g j:.in 3]39 I*
= ei M ljadd i !! gt gi =
a i c il fe iIj]n e n ti !l. j {J { ah}
!,g e!I Il e
ill'l &qe,egt}. lg, sl l, a aa 1,il, ibl. r p! $ jIlllll 1 lllI il, l 5 . 5.1 E j' IN l!
]lfj l' Is 1 lill a 11
. I
*I Ili 0 4.'!sg 11!! mdl
O [d 4 .h j 1 E i
^
i l i 3 E 3
$ f f I a
1 ,, v
-! E 5
5 lli 91 , di tyl
~
lli ! hdII i d IIlfi li '[ lsp '! i! ' pit.ijllamibasf} ! 'ad Yuj"h abi lijlh 4 d 11fu
- hlf !L :"I d33 ! 5 i
I'l
! isiM F =
1 flillfhg1p!!
, a isil 4 '
I d.jhhjj]
>ol.!!"ifj!'hd [ }ji}'
e e !q tt. i i i til i !jI
$dilllj'dlb
;ljiflpl.i{yTiml ell, s an. i N
ilhllE!Il!1!ili IIlhi p.I }i vi a,I
- s .,y :
I]I } Il {l3 pk,,g g} e n
0 t.. 8: # t i li i 1 i j- .j ] ib lf llil i
,i j jlml3y!!
i !!!!!li,p,i i op Il ' t $IIIr
.I 1
! j! -
i l, O g o j. f $ i D I i i i 8 1 5 ! ! i" a i ; ix a ,- id j." 1! [a , p ainsjl jl i 1
- s. q,gpj jie;d _
ihr,flli8 IM i s
- U}j. %,[}'jL1:y' ol al g I5 "s h.i 3
I Wlii}g;jjjj!!B}iHegn;hl!IIlII lill
! ga i s' u tE w(fjj, 5-
-d kI i hifjhNlh l t, iliinilinlitim!I d sa lfhli
$ N -
iu, ' i t l J]gs it b" j{,[ht ,h l$ h._..
D e. O s v + e n b D n o t o t F s e. it n m m a e w J w c IA e i n w I d C m ar n a i t i n e m c. o m r t lnrl a I an atI r v r Ti e t e m a RNe T I Nr y e s s db n wtnd e t tis i D a n n md ereo s s lpsi ee r umm r u e nt e rs cyr y ar k watr em n w b =*r em r e s m n e i f Nl a i v Ne v empr t n n n ig we b tc mtm g e nno ae dl cd e T I tme n y r enam ps sI e im w E ml s lat e p-e C l tn e mneh i g l i w na uwht ms g d g 8 g
- m. ,
c en I , 9 a g ms g I. I IC I pm.C pl I r tnr e owr I et
- g 1
0-4 u e rf T fe g g n i o t a l u a ;e. e v . ta E . u q C I 4s d a e I s s L i i i 8 m.
. 8 9
8 9 9-6 1 R w 8-d R 1 d R 8 4-8 o d s t s.one h p o Re st l e s E n fi o ht e n eWi tI ut s s hs g8, n u W ho rcaarl s r a e e e t x;v e n taIeisl s l iwek ss ,C e
. o y a Mi w, le G. e e
fnwn l1F ri ot ;s.vsk r n1 a e u omrynyth n o r n i 2S ? bDy f w
..iei
.t tatlur r a wop op t
s u e n G. G edl l o ; el m . .icwtaaib u n ntes t, s s, br o eiuun s WaA es m ny ioli t a d . a8 e9 d n
.c A. rpeon2t s r d aier khMeaikiw.s dad
;w -c.. rbs r e kansiIe s oI r9
-, neh .
nsu n e a 1,CP En a, l r ca o n . c n o v:y ~ t ct - eF et gr eic
. o ga
.di c nny rew
- l iges up s s ieki
- f l
o wld es as anie esdt c, y' ,nVr sPl a o l. e eh mtg W hha5f tao s 2 4 Aato .anuNe aft nh mRel rd enl g lag ef emib e rde l,o p s si a sl rh r aeoi t nnt e n v ul a c v o mi of n ta rco. ii _la f o Li h s ipx f_ ik vi wg ,y cm h a 0 gmns aihien t e - wrii e e tg M .tre een d G.h aa l nFneAt t e c el i 4 d nCa n he
.e
,d em e r e ngas aet sd e fa c Rt ny 4 n, e n .. a t
pbf a nid
)at tan esr e _.gmnw r e l, Ss r s iaMleg a ri t
- ec med rh ewts r
e Id ,ienio i t i.k i tt r s, A e m b s toe n e ibn i o P g a RS aig .ah a G.d t bI a . nl ,an a . ri e e ar a nGirjntrotr g B. tot iC:d t
.dd r a e.tsi J R gH b wDh t
I g e 1( - e d tr a pg p t n oo a.#t . cfeMa el i r d
. ga n 1,W . E .f- .f
.od to d.Iidi I n
r n
. g
,v e a
3
& .dni i
m
^
nus su s . d sy ,a asd r e
. C* oifh s y gK e . r a nt eh s a r e at n 9
e e P e m_ M rmMt p m p M, P8 .c e n s,d e or imea vhh aGer Er RI ng S. 2 wnf a tontete nrb ; r . M ra r at s h M R ; y i, Rebi t p tsic9 c e9 o .r t. a ,w f - oo r t t a nol enot
.iv tf ntetsdior ned g n e ene n m I I hi el mn l r e t
s e RmV 1, 4Vd -. a :- ww yn h h M,imMtes a et s oiPnt aSoeimni i dr t t o wfom R ns r6 ,i n .l - mo0i t sr ii a/rEDr eCa ml t luue a n i,de b e a t nnm i i n ;. e s ; adig"
,t e e o2 .
et 0. vf s p aua C o noi ny imt s e a r _. ai.h c o ;tn a _wpr oa c e rcalleTmpnt a .na gh8i e pRRnei n a a c aoh aeet,h t s chs toIIi mlud
&fotno t st s
u cD s e E n o ishh t e m ee r E ll a S,n u s e n ui t r i..g no hr ,.l r t h i l o dRi is td d danng s ce e N ent Dii os s r aidf n J e n eh aRso ;..d e
. aLI r E. h ry nr ainayml e&htn s el t
a c u s. e p i es roj okif AwAet nHenoh oo ri tsirosvm s n ol c e sI Ad n @ nmal e hl N o n r 'e
) n did l e
Iien a eGcs sI . ea r o . e . fs ret v ) a ) 2f 2
- uWisl e n
. egstoJi asu n e e tw.r rMsB6N2t o
torITynt u e .t5ioa
,9f rt e aagt ecRe r d ooBn EDiieaf t snfd t r a t a, re yel ngoe onp e ne l b er 2l 2 a 0 g . h
?
2 r eg 2 8 et t oi r v n 8 8Av fe C.it l mlei s-n e ,. o re ay91n oeStni n ei c 8 - el en 4 8tisl h o e eicPt h 8 lmei o ;laEafo 9 pt e sl s mvf 9 a vn Sl e s uaiM1a dnonli v
'lih Aei 9 o f
l GmD,h m a nmtrCn9 i s tj s e h Bt a h ts An ni D r-M, f tae ir - nmra ot l s u eh ga n B a, i ms tsfls paEi91, nnr cir oe yat h hdt n s e e e Dmh Dl a nr ( 0 n9t iI i ot eRl eadh t "s a g
,d
, ef irMdei eusl ld te a na6 echi enfi r a oint n
( o n 8 fr o ( e n=e 9 e1 7/ s, fonn eges r t s
.ts wer
. aacn osM os t o LPiard g a,i e
p c y ss atd spae n cuAu r s 9
/
7 ev ev st o
@ 8
/ sion 9 o ngc n
si r.Aoi 2l
/ea ed i
e o aisn y h E. . .. e sli cio 7rinc 2 e 2 rerenul r vseb el poi a e cn mt c to I. ssh esddt e r td atUnt s Gt r paEn C pbeede s a ur a s aclinhTe t sd rp r ene 2i
/
2 tar retn o p
@ / pao 2
Pt tn r a anen n r a i a, or esi m rCsi tee t sdt h ae s i, e. IRun f rhd lMt G. 'n hn N i nr i e r t oe nale a us 4slI, ppte R n,IRFl ns igat i e m! Inil fcat t er enh w e t seo M s e t Eh no no t i s e a n ne wdnd ednb r - I e c e a f c e gm, s I pt s I t fi ed Ca;ei dt o h, e r n ngtt o tsIa. s es h tr yt r lee p unllngt s on e a smot s a ne 4i yA l ovHsieRpnm e aal a, t ic/ er ne e s er g Cr a
$ ede e e' Cd si ot s Ee Mv .c
.mp r
e l et id u s as d s nmgsd8 i lhs tePs o e v t e r Eot Ei v ot s ped W l e ns oan iludaefI n oA wn1a e9 feet aad e e9 fCepmer ie iht Mne Mor
.Oem l
f a v fh MTShiiCaMf r h e rES Nss e n Nppini u d 3 p lsa o l o C H n Adin l a ge ed c o g t e t t eer n M e ve Lo imr dt i I ape v e o i r e ingw skr
't i o n
ydr a e o=r snn= ii e 3 i do t o t tye eiy o ui ll e ei a u xtivme pl mt n st e c r umes usd m nh s ieoe t s r s e eo u r c se
$ tnbp ia ns'tei t mon nu o u a ms ee e
t tI o s n ec s n a oie eoi tc ans scy tms e ei nr s s r ve
$ dcitel laa sei esl vi et e e
ot o m a _tef e nt et gol M ntr is rf F, ce mf aps npe o snyo ol s e s s Pmes a int _ at au r eR Hnep ge ms y Cei vnr t D a Ds 6 7 e y u
~
, mah nh ut mr uo sf e s e n e s ihi s I t t 7
el $ d 8 t 8 l Edt ec c ed ef n Daec 8 nf o 7 l 7 L
,4 i 11 i 1
$ i li E
~
i i II i
! 2 $i !
5 i !s l
$ 1 sE W
- 3
=
i ll'I a i 5 1 -! 3 - y o
= ,
nti tJi. J i
; .I 'i
))4 d' i jiEig'fjls o i ha g
;i :
1 y .
; inn 1
.g wn.n: pl j
e pi a all op l.1' ' a i di} d 4 11 l! Ii I .1 1 1 1 ,p t aj t c[l el pA a 5 $= i h lll liidlOll !! m >>- t E a i
!I ' ff~ .I M }# jl j] n!!ig f iJ l l iB 1
n s 1
,lILjillut u
e
l . g ,. i
- e . 'd
,! i a
f 5 i 0 I 2 a i I L l l
,] .. L.
1 ills.3311! ildh,1
.}}