ML20217H858
| ML20217H858 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/01/1998 |
| From: | Rubin M NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | NRC |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9804060097 | |
| Download: ML20217H858 (2) | |
Text
_-
'i k
l i.
April 1,1998 MEMORANDUM TO: Public Document Room FROM:
Mark P. Rubin, Acting Chief Probabilistic Safety Assessment Branch Division of System Safety and Analysis Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
PRESENTATION MATERIALS FROM WORLD ASSOCIATION OF NUCLEAR OPERATIONS WORKSHOP ON THE OPERATIONAL APPLICATIONS OF PROBABILISTIC SAFETY ASSESSMENT On March 11,1998, Mark Rubin, of the Probabilistic Safety Assessment Branch of the Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, delivered a presentation on the status of the Nuclear Regulatory c I
Commission's Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) Implementation Plan at the World l
- Association of Nuclear Operators workshop on " Operational Applications of Probabilistic Safety
(
L T Assessment". The presentation included a brief background on the NRC PRA policy statement, J,
major activities in the PRA Implementation Plan, and the status of ongoing risk-informed -
~ regulatory initiates. The presentation materials are attached.
Contact:
Mark Rubin, SPSB/NRR 415-3183 l
Attachments: As stated pf DISTRIBUTION:
MRubin PDR sFWe Center.
.SPSB R/F SBerg
{
DOCUMENT NAME: N:/WANO_MT l '.
To receive e erey of this document, indicate in the box C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure
(
)
l:
E= Copy with sGt 'nont/ enclosure N = No cop" OFFICE '
ABC:SPSB:DSSA Ob l r NAME MPRubin ' -
V OFFICIAL RECORD COPY Q
9804060097 990401 f.
l plk 4 < fQ Y b PDR
,0.t G 8
.h,w q w e as
. k( ~
e p reau y-
-+ 4.
UNITED STATES s
j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20556-4001 Q,
o
- g April 1,1998 MEMORANDUM TO: Public Document Room FROM:
Mark P. Rubin, Acting Chief /
Probabilistic Safety Assessment Branch Division of System Safety and Analysis Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
PRESENTATION MATERIALS FROM WORLD ASSOCIATION OF NUCLEAR OPERATIONS WORKSHOP ON THE OPERATIONAL APPLICATIONS OF PROBABILISTIC SAFETY ASSESSMENT On March 11,1998, Mark Rubin, of the Probabilistic Safety Assessment Branch of the Office of Nudear Reactor Regulation, delivered a presentation on the status of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) Implementation Plan at the World Association of Nuclear Operators workshop on " Operational Applications of Probabilistic Safety Assessment". The presentation included a brief background on the NRC PRA policy statement, major activities in the PRA Implementation Plan, and the status of ongoing risk-informed regulatory initiates. The presentation materials are attached.
Contact:
Mark Rubin, SPSB/NRR 415-3183 Attachments: As sta 'ed i
P r
o ba b
i l
is W
t or i
k c
sho A
R p
c ti i
g s
o n
n C
k t
Oh h
iei A
e ffc
,f M
As O
e P or p
f o N b a
Ss e
a e
rU u
r t
ciM b
a l
l c
a iS eia t s t
h o
s at rik us nN r
c 1
s R
aU Um SR e a 1
l af u AC ceb e
pL t t 1
p oy i
Rs 9
dn pE An r
li es 9
at cA g e aR us 8
t i t
em oR l
s i
ai m t
n oe nn p
oE t
fG B
l a
e r
PrU n
m oL ch bA e
abT n
iO li t
sR a
ti t
cY RiC io sO n
kAM P
sM s
l eI a
sS n
sS mI eO nN t
.( (
k To07330o
upT CupT srh o srh e e eoi e.
m ip s
li r
me mnop ir sr ng i
u siee al ssds ra ik e
yt ot n nio a o n
t i f t a r
ny soht d
re o
i g
cmCn r u u
ei re oi qd n
rdmc ua e
in npml P
r t l u
ec l
l ai se ynsd e
U Cd rt s e a
S i
el is s
N os vionm U
e c
mc ee a
N C
i u
L nbt o
E ms wisye t
A sis r
e nint e
i R
s g
ha id gel R
oi thd E
t nn ieTh G
ea at s c U
ph gict L
shh A
i ps uina iois T
rop dnc O
v r a sab R
e a
n.
l s
e Y
l c
Se C
pe eTt n O
n ha r
itoa ef M
f M
t ri f
I t o o
S on r
S I
is ON
O G
BA r f ir ar icsT C
eonepetsmP n ouh K
gl cq qaeR p
t l
u aA dmpe uol ur u e awdrioi s
e p
G l
p u
r a
pl o i
r n t er R
t eiepe ou s
o.d ngmrimtf-ed hmt e
n et ehs a pedo O
a e
sI Pn s i R t,e n e )
hnbP U
f t
s t - s i
s s
l t h,s A i P,s a h o osyR N
r o c st thA D
o i n R r,t ui oh a
et l
n a Ag o d t pe et a
l f
l e
bct c su e
h s
h Nt c e o e chl r a e bd y Rah cu o ot d a
Ce e
t n orprduouu n o
sr m e o a dy cs a s' o l
l r
o N
cn eel f
p,u e c b g dy dg ense eu u s
ethy R
l i
inie t
dds wudn s
ees C
n ef r
h wr ois ee r(
a i s r h d,s c g.e mr o P
t e e
it u t
t e ug nil R
hoc 1 l
s nd t i is A
l uoh 0ocsa,s iPb ndanCs nr oe cRe P
eat t
lethg F u sy rn y
aAn O
i a n Rp e c s
i s
p c
p s tg 5 o c omi pmr L
t i
2 hhr0r on av r ee t t I
st ot a C
t met i
eee.
t 1 t ey ahs si g0hmr v r coe Y
e n u 9 e i a,s s hdd t
t t
l u
a si S
r a (B rpmt e
u swd na n T
t i
n o aoe let r e
dna A
soycpnmhi e s sdl l
kot i s,s a r,
T af r f
e udr nt et s
u pa e E
hq a aspn ptg di suRl nor c au M
iuodc a o
r f
ic e l
epr r a a E
l go ee r
t a sat t
s nt ulim) dae ca do N
i t t l
t r
a ce df dai hiy T
n tynAif l
e n t
t o i tp ip w w y am i
sspor ia N
a i
n nat t
sh hoachhn Rmt t sr t
a cnl Cae i
t aa opl i
r t r r cu y
s' n r t
s uie er hs n
e el a
x d tg s ee r ro r
e t et rei eu.
n b,s a
v sb l
t t d
epaWt oa ihh t
i r t i
s r
tiae ndoohe un egec egnd ot e r
d y
. r ve r udi n
x ued el sm a
te eo u a
l l l t op d
n r
spe ofo e
t r t r f
a es y ht e
nd a
f e
n dao n
s n r c
e d
e
G O
BA p jaT aP C
u ode h pR K
r wgt e pA G
r eeoC o e r mbo pv R
p eem ria O
lan al nt um t u t ssi ea U
e s t
N si o ds o
l i
cn u
w o pn D
i e
t s
nhin p
t s e h s' oi n N
e r
en a s t
s i
sepa nu R
epe gp C
f dr dp t
foy ao P
op g t r o
at R
r ri o
pa a s
A r t f
l oes h
r pcf oe P
ooo ug sn r du O
l i
l niu ba L
sn t
I gd c
eo C
a el pry Y
re n a a u
dt ir b de S
bop l
3 ic c T
an o i
l ow y s A
c i
kfe ao T
fiur vn t
np as E
t i
i ncl s
M l
ge a a
h r n b
E o
nt t l
as eu N
ei l
wna od T
f t n i
r b
(
ged es re C
s e
niu va is O
en r
b e
ims wr N
c e
i T'
r ad a
eki l
ia
)
i qnr s
t ugy i
i r n c
re eu a
mgm s
eu e
p nlar r
t i
t a
s o c c
a t
or l
i y
c n
o a
n b
b j
u e
e l
c c
l t
a e
i a
v n
r e
d s
9 BA oeaI C
n nnr K
ig e s G
i siug R
s n sh u e O
et e ds U
e r
N si nia D
nn cg o
cd R
ma or I
n e
mams S
ey bu K
l i
l nsnt I
sea s N
ustid at oe F
r oni O
r tefwe R
v o
wct d
M i
it uh f
E hs dr 4
o ie D
t l
hct m e
R iee r n rp ismr E
meio G
nb p eia U
s oat b L
r nii adcl A
t is nr st T
cey i
I c
egs O
t r t uei N
s olamk st a oaa fr ns ey ds ty a e
t s
te s
n m
t e
io n
n ts
BA C
G O
G K
G i
r E
cE R
nR i
fe sf on O
f od ki nh O
U c
t i i r
a b
N r
u mc ne on e
j D
ee f n c
c l
dd ot e
t r
a i
mu cs v
I i
Sn s
ca e
Td e e if s
) u d
de o
et o
f s
i y
t nf n
r r
sN t d y
R pR me i
b eC c
s u
c ai r
t r n s k
i i
5 d
o e ao n
I s
g n
f e
n n
s o e
o m (s
(
) u r
c e
.e m
e r
.g e
ng e
s t
d
),.
c R
g
(
.e r
o e
a g
n g
d f
u e
i l
g a
I d
P u
t Q
E r
io a
,A t
n in i
s o
r n
i i
s g
k h
t,s
PRA IM n
n NE P
I q
I L
t uf Mn E
e ao c
M rsmi So O
E e a m
g r
r dfop tem
,S m V
N r
uer r t e c y-o a
r s
ap E
T e
ev t
l dsfe e
y A
if ig c d d
C na R
i T
n nir I
die e uo ds A
s O
ufng P
pm Re i
L N
sct u d
L t a ul R
r n A
am es P
yt s a t
e o ga O
L t
bi i
so r s fy P
es A
u i
ss oc B
N rduad l
t ni J
eege a
i n,s ec ao sv E
ni n
s n n t
C i
ia n
ci nyo B
d i
r o
e T
ed n
6 r
s e-e bf s
I p
sm n
r V
o oa is i
n uk e
et n
E d
ri f
fa S
n i
c i
n eg t
if N
g s
s nf gp R
A t
i o
n in sr
,R N
l f
e o
c o
D s
c s
u g
R l
s s
u r
S a
n d
e E
C i
f g
e s
,S O
e t
s y
e f
s o
v A
P f
i E
E g
r i
t n
s a
f o
O i
ic n
,D a
t n
h t
e is m
su o
e s
t s
OP fR f
i cA e
I oM f
G S
9 S
G 9
S e
S 9
N P uL cE E
A A
R E
E O
n P
D eM l
i v
c d
e v
v p
s e
i aE l
a c
v g
a e
o v
e p
r l
i l
u d
a u
u n
r e
e t
c a
R N a
e n
a a
a l
t lo t
t p
eT te n
c t
t a
o p
t e
o e
s i
r o
p aA d
r s
l I
R cT P
m y
u n
i l
e r
s s
c s
c i
G t
E a
e e
e s
e a
oI n
a f
t
/S rO i
f o
m n
i n
a c
e o
s R
RN s
g t
f n
g e
o c
e i
t P
n n
s P
i e
t g
s gP r
i h
m v
R f
r s
e e
e A
o f
n v
n r
o uL t
aA l
r i
t t
e n
i r
o e
s s
i r
iN t
i w
s r
k s
d e
k onA e
s e
s i
t v
o n
i f
n C
e a
lu o
f r
l o
T m
u t
r i
r 7
a o
m m
V I
in t
n e
i e
I e
o d
n n
o d
T f
r e
e r
I e
E c
g g
g e
e u
S u
s n
l s
e a
l t
a a
r o
t i
r i
y c
r o
y n
i f
s i
o s
n l
u i
l t
o e
i w
s a
t i
-u v
p e
s a
c t
iv i
t ies
OP fR f
icA T
e I
h oM e
fN P
+
+
+
+
N uL R
cE n
R R
C eM l
P I
R c
e a
s S
rE i
A o
v R N k
t i
r e
a eT T
p i
w n
ff aA r
o a
f cT r
o o
h in a
t t
a oI f
r n
n P
m rO i
i s
e RN i
g g
l o
d b
e R
t e
gP R
e uL S
is e
n aA l
k u
g N
t b
u c
i i
o n
m o
nA l
s a
i i
t t
n C
g t
o c
a r
T 8
h y
e I
l t
s n
V s
G t
I u
r T
in a
I i
E d
t i
i n
a n
S s
n g
p c
e e
e c
f t
D f
~
o e
o i
n v
r t
e s
A o
l i
c p
n t
v m
i t
e h
i t
n e
ie t
s a
reas o
f
R iT R
r IS sh IS ke K-(
K-(
g R g R g R g R R
Tu Gu iS IN )SiG QiG uG u
I iG e
d -
d -
d-d-
Gg nt N
i F
a.
A a.1 a.1 a.1 eu fa F
1 n1 n1 n1 n1 nl of
)
O c7 c7 c7 c7 et r f O
a mi R
R e7 e6 e8 e5 r o a
s r
M o-o-
o-o-
y l
nA nA nA nA g
e M
uG di E
f E
tp g p ip ip D
ep rp np np iu di n
D cl al sl sl ad c a i
i i
i hc dc ec ec ne R
na ea r a r a hl R
it t
vt vt c1 i
E ci di e.
az E
i i i i G
a o o
co co 1
n e n e n o7 ni G
n q
t l
gn U
u i
t 4
U s s as n s e s eg L
l L
p p i
p sp sp c
l i
e e t e pe t e e
sr A
A c c y c e c i
c ni n
e i
i i
f f aif cf gif s
t T
T i
og O
i si t
i
( c e
c c c
O a
s o c i
e I
R u
n S
s u
t t
R io r
T l
ha Y
a
(
Y n
n S
et
)
I s
c G
e o
G I)
U c r U
9 I
uy I
D gS uG sS sS S
r D
A uR nQ pR pR R
r d eA cP cP GP eo A
e e
idP d
N aS iS f S nC nc N
e i
r I
f n
C e
dn c
u C
cie ie eh t
c c s
c c
r a E
et e
E vp gt g t l
ap m
i i
i i
oo e e uo uo t
l c
c ot dn dn ge i
i nn l
ur e e i
a a
T1 po n.3 n.3 d
n n i1 S6 mn 9
c.9 a,9 st c.
eG e8 e7 s
1 n
nR i
c t u o-o-
e e nt A
id nA nA v
gh p
t i p
p os a
a I
I p
n Sp Sp i
Tl so bt l
I i
c l
c t n i
i a
e c
c a
sw a
a a
f P t
i t
t f
i i
i o
i o
o l
n sl n
n s
(
s pe Cu c
Lp i
f c
Bp i
o
)
rt
9 D
"f e
i u..
v
" d c ;.:
c
- hs n e ;.
An is
- b e -
i N" (R. A Mu.p,C U d:e r
.hc n..
o r
0 d q w; n
lp a e ee-ie.o n n
$CSe;
.gs u
d7 g.
L Rv Ft s =.
G e.e e a
R $t; y,m. J.
o b,.d C.,. e l
[.
.Sl f s..
- S+
g f
. S o m. R 5
z u
0 P C'~
mtm
.uS.h. e n.
. iR.
sq 6 h.
a i
- fo c
iu 9 sa~.
f 0ti n.
uf-P.f so
- n. [R p ;. f B P.e.e i g v.
.t:;t.
9 de.
P f
s T o n _. s n
r o
o 6s i=
-s Dn; p
r
,gP. s t 3 i
i.
m R
o,
.i
,h%.o w t.ie e
1
- '7 jc.e-,
h s.
i
- C"
- .E' C
t.y q
p s
). n h. _.
u 1
i
<Uf
(
r Rj e
f e na a
- s_ R.C
-i m
- %. R C.
- .f g,cs e
c,:. E ;A.
u.r n
- dn e
.wNp it
.'j.
laa g
s p;T,?
E.
G t<.soe e
pg Uyl.
y,.d s
- z.
,N r
e.
R yC.G
- cR N" s
- q E p' Ae t
i F
ok e
9'p N ;::
a nq, o
.r s-
- ';c S i' a u mi I,:
l n
8 U'.
- . N $.-
yi t
r 1
0 af se<
h y e.n g G )1 sm e
sc o
i l
.,.i '
Ge r
Sm o nw c
a... B'.'
t n s,.
n.
aa d e..
y A[,!
ut C
"h RA' ea
- S,f f t io C
- f i d-e.-
o
.e I A u
- c.. S ;;.g
,hn,
C'(e s e~juu
^p e p.
l rq gLj;-
r hou s+~s m l
t n
r
)s s#
e 0 se 5
ts m
n S
3;0 =
FRt C
- 1e.
t 5' i h 4v0-L f a 0f n
!Pg
- s. l9.
i
. KD 1 9oe m
c m,. Bw e
U o 0s. e
- a i
- gg Wt i
nm r'
e mcw n
_c i
s o.w
.k
..s -
,5w s'
.; R Pv
,o n%n f
.n g n s
s w
c i r;
s s e c
g i
eR.
k s
'_ u :"
>mu &
n N
N".
t p
u.
e v
- lm g
o.tg
^ *'.
n.
n me r. R-x
'.y
- e B
i t
'r
- x-m.s i
s t
e+kw
.. h a
di
,5 s
-nw,
.. 0
.g 5 s
i
=f y / ow-
- r 9
Sm
(
4 a '
.~w-C
,K t
~io L
n B
)
=
~
R IS K-INF ue x es i
O Qm
- p, r'g T c.
w (r;r e r.QT'
>1 T
3 c*S lq p g h%
R o n h hc:r e
e r.i c.u i u.
p ;..:
M Q
71 f' m e e :s,.:
l cl
..nd@p,-
a oi hsi e,
r :-
r t m
tt-o g;.
g 4 r" n ;gp w:
P E
n.ely o.-
a i
= n Mh c.
i
=.
a sa o ;;.:
D r.-
"r.
N%r e ee s=gsi m
j
,?
e d@M r
l e:
. ~c.uo ty r x a u gL.
^+m s lu o r-e
?
R
'stn i
mslde.
. i f
c!
a-*d e d t,.
i6s:
nqJ n
E s
h!
?
W:p h
"o a m t+, a :
t t eq i.gj c
G s..
u g.-
- L i=se'.
U o
6 ss j :g i
m
' p,..
e Dp L
f
~
n m. ~ o.
e sg
~
eg A
t,-
"dc el c
e T
y.
_ D l-c O
i
'e s
- i. s
.e t Ng.c d c' s
{
R xc.n,g~.
._: s eo f n-
- g o
w, nQ-- i. o Y
s i
N,Mh' e
4.-
of G
.. sm r-
- i a.
,. o u U
c
- .nntn 1
nR e
w 1
I m
i D
. m ad, t
m w.
y.; mi A
m t
.a.
s 7l N
.ua
?:.
ak z
C unn k.
I E
(~
Q:
..g L
l
- e
"?
- P C E"m rf ".-
n rq
- g' g-i
.ood c e -
nn lmse i
u "-
cymiae3.
f s
g s g
ts n " g.e Ss oe c *-,
e i
i o
a i s s y '-
m T" t
s t o t-i+
a sr m 'w s a *~
e n ni r
Pwyc-tp "
m h
h u $o *--
io st r.a r e
io I
nS s
nnp tahdr"O l
t-a s d=-
0 eebr*hf f
l g u s-ss" e
i*a$
ym.es'@g;.s.-;
t s
f~>:M d =
G e-s k *tmtd j-
-c s" s d
on a h a-
.ih=
e a
- ~ emu at l
'T f a y a 0:c.-.S
'n ol l
t n l;;
'tn~=-
" e + dig-- 5:..
h rg-
- ]e ~
WI a
r, e
k' f)
9 O
9 O
9 E
R x
I p
S e
K-csI Sr bT uooaA mP c
n i
omc t sah nppnl r
t n
a kse dp e e o a
I l
ar t
os t
sl e eie eor N
p t
u ava il mms di a i
s it t ef o
sr o
F en s r e s
epfe r u o at e
n i
o a n r c e er s na r o bi nl y d
s O
c dei t.
l R
t a tpf i
l m
c
(
r ei mn a o l
r C e
o s as h
P i
i M
n ee nbr nk a
r p
f a
n o
E t ns dae odmc g
c ht t i
cb r e as e
e D
e,s m oiD t
r n n s
s l
daa n
ia egaf o s
di a
s R
e nt stim e
cd ungt r
)
i st t
g ce eh e
E d
sca i
ieme e
G r
ohC eie i
nr n eD ns giep v
ckF nnr a
U cF r
l mu y ae ig t o u
L r
a amn wsq sdap a
A k
isu
,k epo t
iud t e e cps e
hs air e d
T nlaL n
O t s c nsod gtiE i
hmy doia n
c c pvR nn h h a
R e
eF e (C os a
n ro i
n Y
e n
cf r t
in t t D jbn i
ef e s es egF g
n G
r u
t n u) owe e
s cu t
st aha g
U i
1 t
l oda 2
t di r r
I oi fe n t
c n
d oyh e a
l D
f l
t i t
sg hnL ebt e e
A yhv d
uf ee a l
r i
N a
c o C ig sr miel f
hm ose n dl u a
i eia s
C c
c hp maE t
h a n e e E
t t i
ar mna aind o
n o g p ial ryfs n
r i
s cy eie n t
e o s
qne h
ic s s oeR ugia a
e e
sn t
sd npl a
ir h
s' t e enui e
a n
n oC a
uL Slbs mdst ie s
d B aee et n g
u n agr l
r f
k e aF t
bc tpr sir a e
nit s
eh y pe tg s e a
rq h
kd h
t r n Gou ea t
ag o ae d am a
n t
l ce a cn iv c
a a a
ks hc al n l
l e
P y
e ny n l
a t
nt s p
dr o o (L saie a e l
r nl c aE eg sr i
i y d eet a n
i dm d R os c
so i
r F ef ip p
i te e
ma e) le d
sa s
pt s
r ss r
a oo a
t i
o n
s g
vf re e
O e
O e
E R
x I
p S
e K-cD qT siinA mnaT c
lea uh gcp at ae a
I anh t
at ae nl p ul i
r,a iur n ry s N
l t
tp i
fdo t
l i
ym yl a esc o
F i
a c ip r
n a eo n
de cn a n i
n )s p s
O ot ot ngi e
a ch n s-ut d d e
R t
c
(
uo tp us e a
A pso M
r md oe nic cn n n
n l
e,s ego aod d c
c l
a E
si n
npuq t
si r as
,t ec u y
D n a f
l c
t e n u
apd i
a s
t nioel d d cP i
a a hR t or c fdi s
R i
nr e t
t ig a uhty E
)
l n s aA e
r t o
ds st s ai de o
G e
o j f as ah mn n cut i
vs n a ghsh U
t am oo atie L
i i
i n s f f r nf l
e a e bn e u mu fg ye A
d et n l
t n
e hg T
ps o c ca ei l
e c e e n e tin n
O fr nd i
r e dt ot n dp e r
i t
ot r e R
a gaor pr e o r
i ua ns n n orpi Y
i i
t e
n u
gy p
og t
bu pp ebs G
l i
fs r aea s
i ep e
a sdn U
c e eo eg t
1 3
r d r r ie a
I v o el be g
Ly D
et rt v
nd Cl di s
i oBe A
i vc a
e s n
e n
eie c
wu n
ki x
c s N
n pth h (i p
w p
a e ea n C
s a
o oe n
r nc iagl E
n re d
e r
a cp cl n s e u t
y r
er o s cbsi d
e r o e
r e uhn t
g ip r
o es ai og u
f l
t t i
c s c a ut l
a t
t al r a a t
n hnda i
o vd ed d
t l
is e
bi o
r y
.n h an paet i
i l
d a
ct a s a o e
s t e npn o
i r
a c
b op
- t. pp l
is e
nr er a e
o e
t i
r n
ot apn o
a t r d n-s at ei i
m u
do dapt r a
b dn a e o j
r k
e eo nfb n
c sf do a i
r t
sf b
g e
t i in hl a
d i
d es r
t i
t e
o n
i g
c
,s
R IS K-
% OQ1 wN IN 1
1 0
0 FO 6
5 C
R j
x.
cf g
o g
M x
j'a
'h re
- g%j E
4 j
D 3' %@g ;vj$
D l
.f4L 1[g.
- ' %, E(f ER a
^
Ig y-
$h, y@sm==j sQ m
g i?'g E
i G
1 a
- s e
0
~p U
g k*
A L
5 e
9 g
c A
F 4
g c
T r
e e
p O
R q
t a
u 1
n Y
e 0
c G
n e
c U
1 4
G I
y D
- - R R
- R Tt MVe Tse Ne og u
(
a o egi cao r o ramgi Coi i
i A
r cbryo C
sFs e
n kin hn d
ka N
Cel ml CCi a1 i
e ul e l
uh l n
D C
i x a g
mni l ma e
l u eb l n
i F
l iC ug s
aCl l
A n
E ih ae
)
t t
i Dya i s l
e t
vF n
v lo
(
e wg e
w s
/
i e i
e i
t m
hs m
d R
p r
p a
e a
)
Y c
s c
t p
t s
e s
)
c t
( r e m Le x El iS e si Rat Fssm i
ef
)
l f oa r r r el q aG ur u eg d i
n e a cen y acr e ly
~
R R
R G
R i
i i
r I
s s
s a
S k
k k
d K-I I
I e
n n
n d
f f
f I
o o
o Q
N r
r r
emPm nAePm ndPm np P F
u r
i e
eeo e oer a x
r t
Sq e
eur r
q p e o e e
O Muo d dt g d nr ol i
iohg d t
u r
f ig
- ogry R
t r
v p r r
s r so aI aEmaI eo aT a
r eudms a
n l
n m mA M
mr s sc ems
.d ame f
f f
nie i
c ea s
e o
be e.
t t
s t ni l ed mr emh y nas E
l n
h r
odt cl e
r Pa v
l u
v dan r
D t
r el i i
e eo p
l r
eg e c ey c am wa r
ec o
owf l
ie wq r
e q r sn P
u e a g
uam t
r i t l
eo l
sI s
is dng c I
ideT aimnin p uS L
areane mtp eo a (e ir ns f
s l
t c
t n
ieG O
cp e mtia eie q
d r
r meue t
ot t l
y e nii n
c u n ang f
p g dQ T
on giadc sn i
t ai h set i g
wni maQ)A A
it eio n.s n c
tnhm n i
d m (I ho a enA ivt nd P
i t negiS f
l I
c c e p (I eei
- t. f o P
ci i
a d x h )T r o e
r ol o ma n
t t kvS n u ei l
n e.
L r
p t
al t s n n oee)I i n (s dr I
o l
t r i d cr s cl bl C
n ahi oy e
as i
t o u at T c o A
te on mbnd n i )S i
r k
os p u e
n o
e odf nk ms T
c dp r o is i
I o
n eI m g
ea O
1 mf c 5
d p doi e n Sp he cf t
r e
N n
To i c h
t m
g ay oe n
.s p v he nr S
t r
nt a
e el r e c o y od ea ie sl nt c bg q s n
oi e a e u e mta tsnia r
t se t
i g
s p b mti my wd r
of n e
t l
dt n ie a s uog em thq cw e ni u
,s l
ccm u
n p
t eac dmd em opi e
eo r
i r
r sm t
i nni bp h liz s
yl do y o o ai ie t
,n d
bn bn l
in ig r
e l
e
.t ce n
s u
c ti u od i
nc y
nE t
l r
n vui et a f
eci a
p o n cl s
e z
r eia sna r e r t em ot iob c
dn i nt l
me a e o
s g
e n
bin c
os et y n auo ds ss Awf l
r f e a i i o
l r
r o ed sy nn Soi wne w m Qcl n
r Mks etl e h
Au t
Eep dy c e o d
r e d
ce oati e oni n
t ct cr c s vg i e o
t c
n ddo t
i t
eain ie sh r
nr a
ol ti g e mn s
o d
og n
b s e o
y t s n
~
R IS T
G K-e r
I c
a N
h d
eaaarenS n
N e
F i
xndml ja R
d O
i t t eimetaef c
nicinetce C
iy Q
R a
t spniddo A
l u
M otiasmSnE S
p t
ner v
p a
E ss a e R (L a p
l r
s c
v y
D t n i
bivt MPu e
o t
i l
y s e T (i Sa a
I t
f l
A P
i Au chs) o i
i c
o s
I i
pnoesuSn a
s L
f rgn s eysR t
S u
O i
t
,l t
aroadt e o
T i
r 1nl f e
fo p
P a
T 99afoanmo ns G
n A
8mr n5ft c
r ead/of
(
Q e
P 2r o n cC8wr C
A P
mn aS E
P (S
L doe
/
e f O )9 r r
7da O
o o
I ng G, ef g
u C
i e
dt w
fr hhty n
a h
A r
t t u t
oa aeoi e
m T
r iv n
T I
t So eCCj r
g e
O 1
e 6
n oo c s'
r a
a x
a n
a N
n ig m m i r
t sr o
G s
S Okemmn r
e t
n eiss o
d P
i omdssT p)u o
r a
i i fat oon n
o reno nnk j
a 1
e Lg a h n (s c
i 1
/
Pet a S m.e dS S 6
)t
/
c I
9 ehnET I
7 a n n o C )s nt i
d coy a
pab9n Sr l
j o se7d ITg pc-r 0L s aeto9o i
c smin5w y
f s.
c t (4 P i
eta o/r t
i3e t
mhis0s e o s/s n
As u9u a7r Ot n ). e a
Tf c
f S
eI na ot fe f
h t
they e
2
~
R I
S K-I I
n n
s s
I e
e N
O O
O S
rv S
rv F
t t
a a
O i
i f
c f
c f
f e
e R
A S
V e
A r
n T
M I
r u
e v
n i
e k
i t
r r
e s
c s
E a
r n
y m
w p
p t
i D
s o
i a
n n
e a
in t
t g
c e
s f
t s
g P
Y N
a ol o
F i
I (C
L u
n l
o o
cl e
w k
n e
i w
o O
r a
e n
a m
T r
g rd a
A s
i n
u n
b g
P c
C h
P AE AW AE m
o e
L tt m
C I
t I
s E
Ei E
M n
M e
e a
A Ce Cg Ce t
e ot oh ot
)k T
d h do d h d
I 1
7 e o e u e o S
O d
s d
Co Ce Co E
al aO al R
N o
o S
sg s
sg t
ey ew ey o
n N
Ne N
C o
r 5
5s 5
7 7
6 m
8 7G 0
m r
i
(
o s
u C
s l
p a
oi s
n M
s e
b t
1 y
h p
M o
i d
p a
i ol gn y
o 1
g o
y 9
n 9
l)y 8
1 R
IS N
K-E I
N l
fA hiN P
F d
irs s e eE O
i a
tp nl l
tl t h i s' o
R qa
+
+
+
ur f
t aiO M
y t
a r o n nb P
E te dg j r
f e
T" smt o
D r
S S
A c
T a
N o a a oi g
s f
v f
P P
n r
e e e r
O 1 k a
I t
O 9
y L
i n
9 0 os m
o 8
bt jo O
t e
fr h
e e
ci T
im t
s vp A
t er a
o P
f a v P
f deP eP 3P e
r n e elir r
0r x
s d
L smo qo o
ip up mp p
ea I
i C
g e
f f i
no r o io f
c ie nl/as es n s t
ct A
t a u a s
iy ciel ma t
enf T
l l
t et e
t eLo no s o c
O o
I t
o 1
t nOr 8
s se oe e
wu t
t r
iOe x
c as N
l n
ai l
g Pa sm 9t e
y o
S x
0e s
i f
bc si n
v n
t t aod o a md e
oh sni ct e
i t
t e
aie nh h
m ic s s
ue e
a c u e t
r l
eH t
iu r
d2 et f
o nr i
es c
sm t r io e
l ae l
nt w
a o
in t
r t n w
nt wt ht t
t r
o ar i
i t
ho n
de i
hm y
n g
g i
l e
Le dr qu i
i t
r e n
Or oq a
d ual i
e t
at Cq gu u
o i
t ei o
s er Au r
ne n
t y
i r
p fr m
o y
rp r e re f
o e
s or m
c o
m n
H u
t ec e
ot 2
b ce t n ms ht s
m tis es b (e a
os i
t i
Fa n.
m a
nb t
Sn eg p
oy l
s f
d r
l A
s in d
p
)
R g
u u
r b
f i
r n
l i
o g
c m
R IS 9
O K-b I
N j
e In c
F t
t O
e i
g v
R r
e U
S PE E
P a
s S
M u
r v v
la t
o a a
i p
n o
E E
bl l
p a u u
n D
i o
ba a
n O
r t
t s
o i
t e
e f
l I
p F
i t
t e
R N
E s
t n
h h
c P
S i
i f
c e e
t s
k R
P o
i RA S
o r
n A
E c
I i
i s d g
n e
ke n
A o
N f
I C
m q
i e
E f
c r
m S
T u
i t
l n
ea c
I i
mc a
v a
G O
I t
i y
n t
t A
e c
e o
H N
i i
c no e
s n
t t f s
T iv o
L w
S f
i i
i t
nc i
i I
t e
I s
Te n
h n
s N
1 9
hs p
o e
e t
I ie h
N r e c
S t
e BP i
r o
ar n
P s' o n
o E
ep so O
n C
s b
P T
a se R
I l
A O
s rv N
o a
f r
t a
i c
A P
o t
r n
o C
o s
r g
s T
r a
a n
h IV m
d e
l I
s p
T F
s i
w n
E t
h d
o S
i i
c n
h gs have I
~
R IS S
G G
G O
9 M
K-a I
n N
U cI Q
P nC U
u F
i n
ris u
R t
s o s
a ep a
A p n e
O i
t l
i l
z r e n
es o
C R
e i
i a c t
R c s f
i R
o a
s o e P
h M
t t
e t t P
i i
u n n R
a E
t n
i A
v c
A p
l t
D a
e s
Py t
in c
r t
f t
t d
oi o
e h
n I
i o
g r
o v
re r t C
N r
i n
ah o
2 S
t m
s ie h
o me m
5 a
P s
t t
o U
p 1
io s
p l
r e
5 E
d s
l n
h s
o e
m C
o v
a t
u a
e A
i o
d o
n T
d n
l l
e d
p I
c n
t C
T p
O h
f a
o e
th r
c d
e o
r e
N a
n a
u o
m d
c s
s d
t n
o m
it e
o o
e u
o x
l i
i r
n t
iz n
n t
d b
i a
C e
2 h
e a
c l
0 t
e t
s a
i t
E h
e e
d r
o n
E s
i f
n g
x o
m s
i o
n p
m i
i n
r o
e e
g i
i f
n n
e e
c a
m R
r i
f a
t i
n c
p n
a i
i c
t s
a c
o k
g t
n a
e s
i c
c p
n R
A o
i e
c t
g e
n n
a i
a l
d a
s o
b R
l e
i t
y f
e e
s l
n i
i t
g d
t i
n y
u s
s s
I l
p e
a n
e q
t f
c u
o o
r r
t e
y m
io n
n c
R a
t e
e i
s s
q o
i a
u n
su i
w n
r e
d e
i s
m th su e
i c
n n
t c
s h
t es e
s
IMP LEMEN T
IN G
O O
O o
R I
I S
C CP T
D m
K-r o
hR e
p ev I
m aA a
e N
l n
t e
p g S m
o F
l l
e p
m O
e ec t
so n
m e
R io p
t n
e e
n M
o n
t E
o f
t a
D f
U o
t F
Q n
f i
1 r
c N
o R
u 2
i s
a e
E u
n l
G t
i r
t t
o y
a me C
U f
i L
R n
r h
a A
e t
ic a
i K
q e
a T
u s
l i
l I
l n
A e
O i
d re c
n N
P d
c t
e g
i lo o
p e
t t
S a
s R
u n
e p
c v
p e
ie o
C w
r t
r s
i t
C e
L r
i B
a