ML20217H082

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Discusses Five Sites in State of Az That Do Not Have Clear Documentation on Site Decommissioning.Commission Directed NRC Staff to Discontinue Work on Sites in Agreement States Since Any Matl Identified Falls Under State Jurisdiction
ML20217H082
Person / Time
Issue date: 10/01/1999
From: Lohaus P
NRC OFFICE OF STATE PROGRAMS (OSP)
To: Godwin A
ARIZONA, STATE OF
Shared Package
ML20217H088 List:
References
NUDOCS 9910220049
Download: ML20217H082 (6)
v • d • e


Text

i 1

l DCT I1999 1

Mr. Aubrey V. Godwin, Director Arizona Radiation Regulatory Agency 4814 South 40"' Street Phoenix, AZ 85040-2940

Dear Mr. Godwin:

As you stated in your May 28,1999 letter, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) informed you that there are five sites in Arizona that do not have clear documentation on site decommissioning. The December 16,1997 letter that you referenced stated that NRC was prepared to send you the existing documentation for these sites for your use in making a decision on the radiological status of the sites. You informed the NRC that you did not want the files and that if you acted on these sites that you might expose the State to potentialliability.

i The Commission directed the NRC staff to discontinue work on sites located in the Agreement States since any materialidentified falls under the Agreement State's jurisdiction. Therefore, the NRC staff has not taken any additional action on these five sites. During a discussion, i

subsequent to the receipt of your letter, I indicated that the Commission, in the Staff Requirements Memorandum for SECY-98-273, asked the staff to conduct further work to resolve NRC/ Agreement State jurisdiction issues and evaluate possible approaches for retuming identified sites to NRC jurisdiction., You suggested some approaches for consideration, including joint NRC/ Agreement State determinations regarding these sites and whether any additional action was necessary. We willinclude this suggestion and others in our

' response to the Commission.

We appreciate your assistance and will continue to work cooperatively with you on this issue.

Sincerely, OlginalSigned By:

PAU1.H.1.OHAUS Paul H. Lohaus, Director Office of State Programs I

Distribution:

lf DlR RF (9-110)

DCD (SP08):

SDroggitis PDR(YESJ_ NO

)

Arizona File DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\DMS\\AZGODWIN.DMS ee previous concurrence.

T2 receive a cop r of this document. Indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment /enctoiMEp= Copy wRh attachmen "N" = No copy OFFICE OSP

-l OSP:DD l

OHM:M l

NAME-DSollenberger kk FCombs PHLohalis #

DATE 9/27/99*

9/30/99*

0l

/99 OSP FILE CODE: SP-AG-2 :

l 9910220049 991001 PDR STPRO ESCAZ h hjIllIQ k

[

pa ary - '

[

.. UNITED STATES '-

l.

F

]

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 30egM001 gf

(

October 1, 1999 I

l LMr. Aubrey V. Godwin, Director.

Arizona Radiation Regulatory Agency l

4814 South 40* Street Phoenix, AZ 85040-2940 g

Dear Mr. Godwin:

1 As you stated in your May 28,1999 letter, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) informed you that there are five sites in Arizona that do not have clear documentation on site.

decommissioning. The December 16,1997 letter that you referenced stated that NRC was prepared to send you the existing documentation for these sites for your use in making a

. decision on the radiological status of the sites. You informed the NRC that you did not want the files and that if you acted on these sites that you might expose the State to potential liability.

The Commission directed the NRC staff to discontinue work on sites located in the Agreement States since any materialidentified falls under the Agreement State's jurisdiction. Therefore,

. the NRC staff has not taken any additional action on these five sites. During a discussion, subsequent to the receipt of your letter, I indicated that the Commission, in the Staff Requirements Memorandum for SECY-98-273, asked the staff to conduct further work to resolve NRC/ Agreement State jurisdiction issues and evaluate possible approaches for retuming identified sites to NRC jurisdiction. You suggested some approaches for.

~

consideration, including joint NRC/ Agreement State determinations regarding these sites and whether any additional action was necessary. We will include this suggestion and others in our response to the Commission.-

We appreciate your assistance and will continue to work cooperatively with you on this issue.

S rely,,

j l

aul H. Lo AJs, i or Office of State Programs i

(,

Mr. Aubrey V. Godwin, Director Arizona Radiation Regulatory Agency

-4814 South 40'" Street Phoenix, AZ 85040-2940

Dear Mr. Godwin:

l As you stated in your May 28,1999 letter, the Nuclear R gulatory Commission (NRC) informed you that there are five sites in Arizona that do not have lear documentation that the sites have been adequately decommissioned. ' The December 16, 997_ letter that you referenced stated that NRC was prepared to send you the existing docurrpntation for these sites for your use in making a decision on the radiological status of the siteg and whether there was any residual radioactivity that may need remediation. You informe and that if you acted on these sites that you might ex (the NRC that you did not w se the State to potentialliability.

I The Commission directed the NRC staff to discontinu work on sites located in the Agreement States since any materialidentified falls under the A ' ement State's jurisdiction. Therefore, the NRC staff has not taken any additional action on these five sites. During a discussion, subsequent to the receipt of yourletter, Iindicated t at the Commission,in the Staff Requirements Memorandum for SECY-98-273, ask d the staff to conduct further work to resolve NRC/ Agreement State jurisdiction issues a d evaluate possible approaches for retuming identified sites to NRC Jurisdiction. You s ggested some approaches for-consideration, including joint NRC/ Agreement Stat determinations regarding these sites and whether any additional action was necessary. W will include this suggestion and others in our response to the Commission.

We appreciate your assistance and will continue o work cooperatively with you on this issue.

Sincerely, Paul H. Lohaus, Director Office of State Programs Distribution:

DIR RF (9-110)

DCD (SP08)

SDroggitis PDR (YES_f_ NO

)

Arizona File DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\DMS\\AZGODWIN.DMS

  • See previous concurrence.

Te receive a cop r of thee document, Indicate in the box: "C' = Copy without att hment/ enclosure *E' = Copy with attachmenUenclosure *N' = No copy l

OFFICE OSP l

@ DD l/

OSP:D l

l l

l NAME DSollenberger.kk FQoSs'l-

/

PHLohaus DATE 9/27/99*

4\\h7)98

_/

/99 OSP FILE CODE: SP-AG-2 l'

N r

e e

Mr. Aubrey V. Godwin, Director Arizona Radiation Regulatory Agency 4814 South 40'" Street i

Phoenix, AZ 85040-2940

Dear Mr. Godwin:

i

. As you stated in your May 28,- 1999 letter, NRC informed yo that there are five sites in Arizona that do not have clear documentation that the sites have be n adequately decommissioned.

The December 16,1997 letter that you referenced stated ttpt NRC was prepared to send you the existing documentation for these sites for your use in king a decision on the radiological status of the sites and whether there was any residual radi activity that may need remediation.

You informed the NRC that you did not want the files and hat if you acted on these sites that you might expose the State to potential liability.

The Commission directed the NRC staff to discontinue w rk on sites located in the Agreement States since any material identified falls under the Agre ment State's jurisdiction. Therefore, the NRC staff has not taken any additional action on th se five sites. During a discussion, subsequent to the receipt of your letter, I indicated that he Commission in the Staff Requirements Memorandum for SECY-98-273 asked t e staff to conduct further work to resolve NRC/ Agreement State jurisdiction issues and valuated possible approaches for retuming identified sites to NRC jurisdiction. You sug ested some approaches for consideration, including joint NRC/ Agreement State terminations regarding these sites and whether any additional action was necessary. We w'I include this suggestion and others in our response to the Commission.

We appreciate your aasistance and will continue to c;k cooperatively with you on this issue.

Sincerely, Paul H. Lohaus, Director Office of State Programs Distribution:

DIR RF (9-110)

DCD (SP08)

SDroggitis PDR (YES_f_ NO

)

Arizona File DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\DMS\\AZGODWIN.DMS Tm receive a cop r of this document. Indicate in the bor: 'C' = Copy without attac ment / enclosure E' = copy with attachment / enclosure *ff" = No copy OFFICE OSPM(6/l OSP:DD l/

OSP:D l

l NAME DSollenberW.kk FCombs

/

PHLohaus DATE 09/7//99

/99

/

/99 OSP FILE CODE: SP AG-2 1

I

%[$[s g@WWTW'Mycm.Wn WGM.pFT*W7/P.WP'"M**WQ?

k

~ T W:t ^ " W9 4 MPJ@

N'~~

V c M y X g ~'

W W 11.hdMR AfEICE TRACKWGiSYSTEMt 41

  • w arp; m.@,9 4m s:,M;

);

w MWW..

~

,1, jfkm v o m W '-

ww n

MMQ A th ' M.

% M'

rd Y

f f

' h @Y l w s:Wg%

. k$ --

,m s

h

'h e %e.a*.

m t eno w'e

%..Vl;( @.R, mO, wy; o u.q n. -

- +.#m w ; w s

- ~

w( w qlp+[M iM gg.%

M/ :fl d%

.G n

w.,2

' %,%o#e, y m

,.s r

3 a

w n.b.--< w as n~+

.. ww -

<a

-o,.n

.,w 8 ~. %y 9 9 y:g. n -

- - %'9

,W c

,ha s.

q u

e

' Sh, cd,, #4, r@g Ny'.

J o

.r m.

tj,'b

!] z w/9/99j -:q q, r w;. vn p ?.,.,, ;f.gaWS. w r ~,, p -

6

., : ;g.,, N,s h' m, M- ~g$p;

<.tp y.

g

...a

. q m.

qq,

&w..,

cp m

4, ', q &y@WW apn,, b.

W H Q

m. C p:.4,a,s ; g
E 4

q a~

u. > ey a ;u y.- v e gny.w# 4pr ;g gs ypg pp? gfj9-110 y

t 9 m.

p Q 9MSy,, Mg;&ghj K Ts..,K MA$' M*d k W W :*

W,; M,; * %%

i e4 aWA%

'c 4

e<

g,4$%Qf j$ h

( Lir from Aubrey Godwin to Paul Lohaus regarding 5 sites in YhN hhM

.? ; Arizona which were not property closed out by the U.S.

kffg W4 OWj#yg ' g[

@," :. Atomic Enerav Commhslort_.__

_ ___. _ _ MtjM y?

4 0.J G#?b m

.J "MMmwVwg-~w~wmmmmmyw" d - 6/9/99 h 1 _ 7/2/99 M [' M k

_[yi

[my,

h

  1. WW] ~ ^h^ 4% >, 2:

..N y gyk i - %

Q Mp~~ ' g.b.p' :' W** Mp;p$$yy bll

- M0

-JnhA Miset,sdenl m,f JW

.W h

7/2/99 pf w, e,, p+?v x

s,by?qy]pd s a:.....,. a;J

'n wd w

s l1 bf${

Q

ji 3

usW~

'y m;y...

m

'o,

~,>/g m,.m,g,y.nn 'n.. w'N.

u,4 A S: ;;

..n,,

.t ;

.p,...~A v

n

. v%'

f.Q {.,

4 s _.. s 2

Ay,&;W,

WY;%mw~ ~'~' ~~~~~~~_. _ _. _ _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _gg3.qq'hg@;ki:@W

\\

' f

.g h; q p q q yyggy,%,,.,.n%. g( g,*. ~ 4>g g %,Q, QF %y>.g.Up '6.~pg4 9

,lGODWIN/ ARIZONA l

jv M

g &.,, % 1 mw.,,.y

,,s

.N.vu y

p y :,&y--

9
m e ~

,4 jf: % N - >

w m

...n g,c. c 9 z ' g/ sm,g-g>g :n],1 (z%g

, m% y y.(.J ' g.j,

y-p ' ", * ", _,_w, M y

3 y>y

&y gg s

f s

y p

n

,, %Q fNi hll"gh -

y a

f i

' s.

W e w@Her n:"ts,,*?,,,

~...

-.', d E.

Ymka 5

. b _"*_ _ __ _ j j.Nhp6

j. _,.

.g..

a

+ ww.,,h.l _ __ _jh.

, p.

s m.n.,w w m,, m n;c.w n_

m,m e

~ nw a

1 a ~. ~ ' m.i y.

x

  1. e,m m-

- g.

s a

..,., e. 4, -'

)

+

n ' Q v b@r; T.;

si sK-q i

.u. ' " W :, A.

w.

a.s c

4as n-

,.. /.M.q N

,. t. ;, ',

/

4

  • /",

v y-f, ~s 4.

q x y

y v.y y

, pm f t,,

gf g

i

.J3 :s m,.,.x.gs.m,', c v, t r em t.

t n

.,3 y

q w;

c He y--+ M.mS + r.-

u w

t g

.g, 1_- 'vp-ar..

et.

' y ).

T ::.-

t k

n,

1

,s

[7 f '-

4'-

y%,.x.,'.....-

{

sf3

  1. l-

,.,i

'#s,w.

4 ' t' (;,

m'; u..~ - n

'e l

4?

Q ' a.g>

c sn.

j.., - 7

.r s

y, r
t ?

g,

- f y

Edhieddh".~AwdkadidA& 25DhdkisiN '=d.Lhash.n3.,$$M+g i);a M-M.iuM.,, -

1 gg,..g 6.-g x.W rJJ,..

'e of t

P.1 i

j -

e.,,,

if

,4;

,.p q

- 4x v

)

i g

.4

. ~..

- - i,

n z..w d

dN

- 1 1

l I

I l

I i

1 i

h o

t'

~

\\

J' 2-5rio g._.'_i L {seei g

-=

==

i

i ex n

f

, k dMht[

k[bC.k

$ MN

~

\\

g

, - e<J==

  • s l {1 S 'I'f % y y $I M y% -

s,.

. a h?,

T90fM{ohf' niu n

-3,

  • 1 <

l V

\\

w^ s,, M J.e. &_hMge,

@m mam: as g~

h y

m Q;4h,4&e g M _T__9'h L}y.4

~ % c~ q ein,;sh g :

1 e.d{e%.0,'n.uE h i ' M Y; i

=:gstg 4 f_

mfd'E, a i,,,,.

, %,g h. _S N ; $f d

~ ' ' ' * '

. n..

n nw n-

f,11J ll i W M,. 7? +hW$&~e " .

g F

...u

[g9

. 3$,",jiij( r

M W % d,Y.

S,~%

y - g (l9,,,,% v:t d.

L U"'

a ll.~,: [~ %.$h 3 E"MP.p't e

i l ",, p!s%u.}h>ff-f 'ik9ir4 % y'*, w'

  • 7 ". y i

($.(' - m}.+

v.

- % p ', ;.ce g h,,, s l e

~ i

~ ',

j r

y m"}~~y'"- 3 s

s 2,.. m u/ s. s. y e t

~

2 jijj%R f ?,.8%gf s,

e,, u/,,/

s,,f? R e Q s,

S f u-

/

r b~s $'d

_',, = ~ '

~ :!

~

SMb

(

b

- hI

@}N O6 d

  1. o b%2k?..,'f'W),M zu, %t?W % t ;;%t;//AW,!$

-h gM : e/

f, g p,

- y-V.i _ '*-. M _== >.

t

>=

x

.r.$

go w

9

/, n e-w.f/ - - f'.,vi/H/6, o..R m

N \\s

-; b [

i

//r g

Wdx 'w

{I Y, 'sy, 1[

] i~.

i'8 E'M-::w'<

,, d '

$ 5 h] esk N h, A k $ k S ' h "' ? 6 } t ? h, 8 N

? - N$'h$

$n$ $L a. ? f B e

i li i$%!}f))[;QQ@fN!j,N?9. y y#? $rg?%g8%

eTsis a W 6 RA.z,M-, i E A' k 4

k kn.2,'N' G'mqrd ed 8

'eff k a

-?EL%

! AtY?

%=

'E :

&pu. p2l' g/,

~~%

s A? Wl

  • h!!kIf. % yflUN$

d,h=+ hf'?r/$Nhh7M "k,$'

I j

,esmewmem aggyd egsq I h N3l$< Nhd !wy,$ii#y bLJ

~,o, 2,_

i

-

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20217H082&oldid=3962857"