ML20217F301
| ML20217F301 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone  |
| Issue date: | 03/25/1998 |
| From: | Mckee P NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Woolacott E CONNECTICUT, STATE OF |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20217F307 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9803310342 | |
| Download: ML20217F301 (11) | |
Text
March 25, 1998 j
The Honorable Tcrry C:nc:nnon Mr. Evan Woollacott Co-Chairs I
Nuclear Energy Advisory Council Room 4035 Legislative Office building Capitol Avenue j
Hartford, CT 00106
Dear Ms. Concannon and Mr. Woollacott:
This letter is in followup to a request made during the February 26,1998, Nuclear Energy Advisory council meeting. At that meeting I was asked several questions regarding the number and status of allegations received by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) concerning activities at Millstone station. At the meeting I committed to provide you with additional information on Millstone allegations. You also requested information on recent changes made to improve NRC processes for handling allegations.
Enclosed is information with respect to the number of Millstone allegations received by the NRC.
The information includes statistics on total allegations received, the number of aliegations that involve discrimination, the number of allegations substantiated, and the number of allegations that remain open. The enclosed includes information for all sites with operating reactor facilities that may be useful for comparison with the Millstone data. Also enclosed is NRC's annual report on the agency's allegation process. The report describes some of the recent enhancements made to NRC's allegations process, I trust you will find the information responsive to your questions. Should you have any questions or comments, please do not hesitate to call me at (301) 415-2240.
Sincerely, Original signed by:
Phillip F. McKee Deputy Director, Licensing Special Projects Office Docket Nos. 50-245,50-336, and 50-423
Enclosures:
- 1. Allegation Statistics
- 2. Status of Allegation Program. Annual Report DISIElBMIlON:
Docket File; 3 PUBLIC 5
SPO-L Reading SPO Reading Q hl)k
\\
WTravers b
PMcKee LBeny o
's 3" ACRS DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\MCKEE\\NEACFLU.LTR vg.g..w. a...di, ioaie... u. 6..,
c. copy..enou....cw-.n.,..wio.u,.
r cary with.ft.chmentl.nclosu,.
'N" = No copy OFFICE SPO-L:DQ l
SPO-L:LA m C.
BRO:D l
l NAME PMcKei %i M%rry s]W WTraA DATE 03998' D31698 03/ /98 N
03/ /98 03/ /98 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY 9803310342 900325
{,4g [:h/g h hmv.
m e DR ADOCK 0500 5
i
[ \\-
ntngk UNITED STATES 3
g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION t
WASHINGYoN, D.C. 20666 4001 8
March 25, 1998
.....,o The Honorable Terry Concannon Mr. Evan Woollacott Co-Chairs Nuclear Energy Advisory Council Room 4035 Legislative Office building Capitol Avenue Hartford, CT 06106
Dear Ms. Concannon and Mr. Woollacott:
This letter is in followup to a request made during the February 26,1998, Nuclear Energy Advisory council meeting. At that meeting I was asked several questions regarding the number and status of allegations received by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) conceming activities at Millstone station. At the meeting I committed to provide you with additional information on Millstone allegations. You also requested information on recent changes made to improve NRC processes for handling allegations.
Enclosed is information with respect to the number of Millstone allegations received by the NRC.
The information includes statistics on total allegations received, the number of allegations that involve discrimination, the number of allegations substantiated, and the number of allegations that remain open. The enclosed includes information for all sites with operating reactor facilities that may be useful for comparison with the Millstone data. Also enclosed is NRC's annual report on the agency's allegation process. The report describes some of the recent enhancements made to NRC's allegations process.
I trust you will find the information responsive to your questions. Should you have any questions or comments, please do not hesitate to call me at (301) 415-2240.
Sincerely,
/
M Phillip F. McKee Deputy Director, Licensing Special Projects Office Docket Nos. 50-245,50-336, and 50-423
Enclosures:
- 1. Allegation Statistics
- 2. Status of Allegation Program, Annual Report
[._#
5E I
NRC Allegation Statistices i
a 1
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - AS OF 3/18/98 3/20/98 I
Site l1993h994h995h996l1997h998 ARKANSAS t
4 4i 7
2!
71 3
r8EAVER VALLEY -
I 9
7i 7
5:
8 1
BRAIDWOOD 3
11' 3
10 17 2
BROWNS FERRY 39~
15; 13!
23' 20f 5
BRUNSWICK 25' 11!
7 8
26:
5 BYRON-3 8
di 6 12i 4
CALLAWAY Si 2
5!
7-4!
CALVERT CLIFFS -
61 7
8' 7
6 CATA NBA i
3' 7,
2l 5
8
,CLINTON 12l 18' 8 20 33 2
COMANCHE PEAK 19' Si 14l 19 12' 1
COOK 6'
1 01 di 3,
6i 7
,C_OOPER 3; 1.5! 11l 14Jj 4
CRYSTAL RIVER 5 L 3_
6 21l 20:
3
, DAVIS-BESSE I 10!
10' 2: 11t 6'
1 DIABLO CANYON i 12i 13! 17 21! 18 9
DRESDEN 1 21 12i 12-12l 18 2
DUANE ARNOLD 2:
2j 3
1 3
1 FARLEY il 2t 3
6' 2
FERMI 9~
19 8
18; 8
1 FITZPATRICK 8
3!
7, S'
5' 1
[F'OlT CALHOUN 73 4I 4l 4] 10 1
GINNA li 11 1!
4' 1?
3 2;
2 9.
4-GRAND GULF t
HARRIS 2
di 3
2r 3
3 HATCH 4
'8' 6:
4' 17 2
INDIAN POINT 2 6
1; 6!
6; 12:
5 INDIAN POINT 3 25' 14 til 6
1 51 2
1!
11 ti li KEWAUNEE LASALLE SJ 15; 7l 10 13:
5
, LIMERICK 16[ 12 4'
5-9 MCGUIRE I
8 3
4:
3 1
.M_lLLSTONE i 42} 45! 46i 711 74i 12 MONTICELLO i
2!
l 6:
2' NINE MILE POINT 10 7
11! 12; 8
9 1
NORTH ANNA 12' 2
8 di 3
pCONEE 1'
4:
1!
Bi 2
1 LOYSTER CREEK i
9 3:
5l 4
10 J 5'
61 8;
5 3:
PAllSADES 5
PALO VERDE 40 23' 18 22 19 2
PEACH BOTTOM i
6 8'
3 4-5 1
PERRY 8-7i 2-10 9
3 i 19l 9
8' 5i 2i 1
$ GRIM OINT BEACH 11 4'
3 4
10' 2
PRAIRIE ISLAND i
41 2;
3' 7
5I IQUAD CITIES i
5 9
71 1 31 1 41 4
RIVER BEND i 21 12: 216 17; 8'
2 ROBINSON 4
2 3,
1 !,
2, SALEM / HOPE CREEK 13! 22 20; 43 20 9
SAN ONOFRE 8l 16 30 32 32i 2
SEA 8 ROOK i
di 5
3 6
4t 3
S_E.0,UOYAH -
31) 7 19!
28' 13-1 SOUTH TEXAS38-211 1 51 25-111 3
ST LUCIE i
4 111 21! 46:
69^
13 SUMMER 2'
3 2!
9:
' 2' SURRY I
Si 5
3 3
1!
SUSQUEHANNA 1
8 8-8 34: 20 3
U 4
2:
1l 2!
4l
_1 THREE MILE ISLAND TURKEY POINT -
' 13 9
12 16! 19 6
VERMONT YANKEE I
3 21 - 5' 9
4 5
VOGTLE -
7; 1 11 111 6'
11!
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR I B'
6' 14 18 23 3
Page 1
e 1
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED - AS OF 3/18/98 3/20/98 f
I Site I1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998
$ATERFORD 51 3 16 2 11 11l 3
l WATTS BAR 69' 64' 50 27 13-'
2 WOLF CREEK i
6:
12 6
13 21!
3 3
- ZION I
7i 17' B
14' 51!
6 i
l
[
Page 2
.t.
DISCRIMINATION ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED AS OF 3/18/98 3/20/98 e
v She l1993l1994l1996l1996l1997l1998 ARKANSAS i
i 1!
3' i
4 it il BEAVER VALLEY
-BRAIDWOOD 1
4.
-1 2
4;
'p iBROWNS FERRY 41 4
3 4:
4'
. MUNSWICK I
11 1
6:
14 1
3; 4
) BYRON 1
CALLAWAY 1!
1l 1
1 1
CALVERT CLIFFS i
1!
-}
3 3
,QLINTON i
2).
3~
6:
COMANCHE PEAK i _J 1l 1!
3, 14 COOK 3'
1!
1 1) 2
[ COOPER 5!
I i
2 1
2 11 4!
3'
[ CRYSTAL RIVER DAVIS BESSE
-2 i
1 it li DIABLO CANYON 1) 2 1
4 2!
1 DRESDEN i
3!
i 1
2 2
3 IDUANE ARNOLD i
i il 1
1 IFERMI i
4 3
3 4
i FjTZPATRICK i
i 2!
1!
i 11 FORT CALHOUN i
2' 2
1 li
{
Ii i
1 i
GRAND GULF f
ti HARRIS 1
HATCH 1!
t I
j INDIAN POINT 2 i
l 3'
1!
1 INDIAN POINT 3 I
3l 3
5 11 2
LASALLE i
i 2'
3 2
LIMERICK I
2 1
Il l'
MCGUIRE 4:
MILLS TC!<E
! 11 15 12' 27; 23:
3 NINE VlLE POINT 2!
1l 4'
if 1!
1 h5tW ANNA II i
1!
j 1
OCONEE i
i 1i il 11 OYSTER CREEK II 2
11 11 PALISADES 6
li 1l l
il PALO VERDE i 14! 11!
4 3l 2
1 PEACH BOTTOM 1!
2:
I 1f 1!
PERRY I
2' 2
it 3
3 PILGRIM
{
2 2'
2:
2-POINT BEACH i
li i
1!
1 1) 1 PRAIRIE ISLAND I
il 1
~
II I
2, 3'
QUAD CITIES i
' RIVER BEND i
6i 1! 10:
6 11 ROBINSON 3
l SALEM / HOPE CREEK i
3!
5' 7
1D 3
2 SAN ONOFRE I
4' 4'
3 6
6 SEABROOK 11 i
SEQUOYAH 11!
21 3'
6!
2; SOUTH TEXAS 16 7:
5' - 7!
3' ST LUCIE 2-3 2
1 1
SUMMER i
t l'
[SURRY 1
1 SUSO'JEHANNA 2
1 11 2:
2 THREE MILE ISLAND I
1!
TURKEY POINT 4
2:
1!
VERMONT YANKEE 2-VOGTLE 8
4:
i ti WASHINGTON NUCLEAR t 4
4 2!
4' WATERFORD 2_
5 7
2' WATTS BAR
- 18. - 18:
16' 6
3 WOLF CREEK I
l-i 1;
I 3
ZION 6
6 4!
ti i 1 D' 2
Page 1 '
SUBSTANTIATED BY YEAR RECEIVED - NO LICENSEE OR NRC IDENTIFIED 3/20/98 I
f Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998 ARKANSAS I
1 li 3
11 1-
- BEAVER VALLEY I
1 3
1 2
[BRAIDWOOD 1
1 5
2 2
2
' BROWNS FERRY 14 8
5 6
3 IBRUNSWICK 1
10 6
5 3
11-IBYRON I li 1
1) 2 I
~
ICALI AWAY i
3 3
3 IdAL' VERT CLIFFS I
3 1'
L4 CATAWBA i
11 3
1.
2' 3
CLINTON I
1i 8
3 71 B
UOMANCHE PEAK I
71 3
3 3-4
_ COOK l
2 5
2j 2!
i COOPER 1
5:
4' 1:
2:
CRYSTAL RIVER 1'
2 1!
11' 4
[ DAVIS-BESSE 2
4 1
2 1'
8 6
5 5:
DIABLO CANYON 6
2-6:
3 5:
DRESDEN DUANE ARNOLD 2;d 11 1l 4ARLEY i
2_
l 4
.FERMl_
l 5'
5; il 6
1
.FITZPATRICK 21 _ 3_
FORT CALHOUN l
il 2'
2~
I 1
2 l'
GINNA GRAND..GMLF 1'
2 3
t 1;
i 1'
HARRIS 1
i HATCH 2,_ 3 2;
2n. 7 2
2 1'
INDIAN POINT 2 2-(NDIAN POINT 3 10 4'
2 li 2
KEWAUNEE it LASALL_E i
11 2_
3 11.
1; UMERICK 4
3 3
1 1!
1!
j MCGUl_RE i
, MILLSTONE 18 1B_ 10l 14; 10 MONTICELLO 2
1'
.NINE MILE POINT 1'
2 3:
3
. NORTH ANNA 2
2j 2
1 OCONEE 2 J_2; 1
4 OYSTER CREEK i
2:
1 3
1' P,A_LISADES 1!
2 2
2 1
PALO VERDE i
5 8.
6 5'
4-P.EACH BOTTOM I
2 1!
2' 4
PERRY i
2~
3 11 2:
PILGRIM 4
1 1l 1
l POINT BEACH I
3 2'
1 5
UR IRIE'ISi.AND l
l' 1
i i
QUAD CITIES 1
3 2
1 3
.R[VER BEND 9
6 8
4 ROBINSON 2
1:
1 i
SALEM / HOPE CREEK 2
9 7 -- 12 5'
SAN ONOIRE 1'
8 12 5
7 SEABROOK 1.
1i I'
SEUUOYAH
_j__ 7 1l 8
10 5
SOUTH TEXAS 16 7.
5 5
4 ST LUCIE 11 2'
12; 24 30 1
SUMMER 1
1 1
1:
5 d
43 1'
il MURRY 1f 1
SUSO.UEHANNA 3;
2 1J 15f 8
THREE MILE ISLAND i
1!
1.
i 2-TURKEY POINT 71 4
4 6
6 VERMONT YANKEE 2-li 2
1' 2:
VOGTLE 2'
4 3
5 3'
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 4'
2:
2:
4 Si Page 1
SUBSTANTIATED BY YEAR RECEIVED - NO LICENSEE OR NRC IDENTIFIED 3/20/98 e
o Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998 WATERFORD 2'
21 10 4
1; WATTS BAR 33 29j 16 10 4
g/OLF CREEK 4:
6:
11 3'
3 tZION I
3 3
4 21 Page 2
o OPEN ALLEGATIONS - AS OF 3/18/98 3/20/98 l
Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998l Total
[ ARKANSAS
{
4!
11 5
11 1!
2 BEAVER VALLEY I
i j
i ti 2:
3 j
BRAIDWOO_D i
BROWNS FERRY I
I 2
5' 5
12 BRUNSWICK i
1, i
3; 11' 5
20, BYRON l
3-3 6
CALLAWAY i
i i
i j
ij 1
CATAWBA f
I i
4l 4
CLINTON 1
i 7,
2 9
COMANCHE PEAK i
l l
I 11 1
COOK l
11 2
6 9
i COUPER l
11 3
4 8
+
_QRYSTAL RIVER i
i 3
li 4I 2 10 DAVIS-BESSE j
1J 1l 2
i DIABLO CANYON 1:
1 5!
8 15 DRESDEN i
1' 5'
11 7
DUANE ARNOLD 1l 1!
1:
3 i
FARLEY 1!
1 EERMI i
I 11 1I 11 3
hTZPATRICK I
I 1'
li 2
I gFO_RT_QALHOUN l
t 1-2; 3
t 3
3
- HARRIS HATCH i'
3 2,
6 INDIAN POINT 2 1:
3:
5 9
i 1'
2!
1!
4 INDIAN POINT 3 KEWAUNEE i
1 1
i LASALLE 1
i 3
4 7
LIMERICK i
3 3
s MCGUIRE l
i 11 1'
2 ELLSTONE I
1:
3 21i 24 9-58 MONTICELLO I
i It 1
g JNE MILE POINT i
i 1:
1' 7;
9 N
NORTH ANNA l
i 1:
1 1
IOCONEE i
i 1
1!
2 I
1:
3 1:
5 IOYSTER CREEK I
i fALISADES 1
1 fAL_O VERDE II 2
2, 5
1!
2
' PEACH BOTTOM i
l'
, PERRY I
2 4
2 8
PILG RIM.
I i
2 li 3
l POINT BEACH i
l i
2 2'
4
[ PRAIRIE ISLAND 2:
2
[OUA_O CITIES Il 5'
4 10 iRIVER BEND 2:
2 4
kO]INSON 2
l' 3
SALEM! HOPE CREEK i
1 4-4 8
17 SAN ONOFRE I
2' 5-2 9
SEABRO.OK I
1i 2
3 6
i 4
2 1:
7 SEQUOYAH S_OUTH TEXAS l
4!
4 4
12 ST L_UCIE i
1 2
12' 15 i
1' SUMMER 1
SURRY j
t 1;
i 1
i SUpOUEHANNA l
1 1!
5-.
3 9
THREE MILE ISLAND 1
l 1:
1 TURKEY POINT I
i i
1:
4' 5'
10 VER.MONT YANKEE t
i l
5:
5 VOGTLE i
2.
2 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR i
2 1i 3
6 i
WATERFORD I
i i
i 3
3 WATTS BAR I
3 5
3 2'
13 p
! WOLF CREEK i
i 11 8
4-13 Page 1
OPEN ALLEGATIONS. AS OF 3/18/98 3/20/98 Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998l Total ZION t
i 12:
4-16 Page 2
O O
o w
a en o
I Mar-96 Apr-96 May-96 Jun-96 Jul-96 Aug-96 Sep-96 Oct-96 Nov-96 g
m Dec.96 O
Jan-97 E
- E h
Feb-97 E
8 Mar-97 o
Apr 97 May-97 Jun-97 g
Jul-97 AuD-97 Sep-97 j
Oct-97 M
i Nov-97 Dec-97 Jan-98 Feb-98
.