ML20216F191
| ML20216F191 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/14/1998 |
| From: | Marlone Davis NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Essig T NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9804160466 | |
| Download: ML20216F191 (5) | |
Text
.
. UNITED STATES j
j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION t
WASHINGTON, D.C. 2006H001
- %*e***/
April 14, 1998 L
L i
MEMORANDUM TO: Thomas H. Essig, Acting Chief l'
Generic lasues and Environmental Projects Branch -
Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR FROM:
Michael J. Davis, Project Manager' _
L Generic issues and Environmental Projects Branch
/#
l Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR 4
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE MEETING HELD ON MARCH 17,1998, WITH GE NUCLEAR ENERGY On March 17,1998, the staff held a public meeting at NRC headquarters in Rockville, Maryland
- with representatives of GE Nuclear Energy and PECO Energy Company. The purpose of this meeting was to brief the staff on recent technical advances in fuel design, pressure regulator downscale failure cormctive actions, fuel performance surveillance results for extended exposure LUAs (lead use assemblies), proposed changes to information transmittels, GE's program to increase the limit on Gadolinia concentration used in GE nuclear fuel, and other outstanding issues. A list of attendees and their affiliations is provided as Attachment 1.
GE made a brief presentation on each of the agenda items and discussed it with the staff, as discussed below. A non-propietary version of the slides used by GE in its presentations are provided as Attachment 2.
FuelDesignJmprovements Jim Rash of GE discussed the history of GE nuclear fuel designs from GE8 through GE14, went over in detail the design features of GE12 fuel, reviewed worldwide experience with the GE12 fuel and the licensing process followed for this design. The design philosophy behind the GE14 fuel was covered, along with a comparison of the GE12 and GE14 designs, and the licensing process for the GE14 fuel design, which is already in progress was reviewed. A full
, GESTAR ll Amendment 22 analysis is expected to be co'npleted by mid 1998.
FuelRerformance Surveillance Programs Jerry Potts of GE Nuclear discussed GE fuel reliability performance history, fuel performance.
trends, surveillance program results for recent fuel designs, and results for GE high burnup and
- ongoing surveillance programs. The surveillance programs give an indication of how the fuel is
'P,,;
rods per million rods operating.. Debris fretting is the primary ca performing. The defect rate has been steadily decreasing and is now approximately 10 failed i
primarily to manufacturing defects. Since 1988 manufacturing defects have been cut greatly due to process improvements.
7, Q f
h
.'I
~
IEI@d7 U"Mp h'g5]
b 8 T8
%g. 7 {# u y " p 4(W ?(
9804160466 980414 b
81t
'*& N PDR TOPRP ENVGENE C
,"(Z O O 'g
{
~
a T. Essig
-2 April 14. 1998 Licensing Basis for the Pressure Regulator Downsca'e Failure (PRDF) Event Glen Watford discussed recent analyses of the postulated PRDF event which indicate that it is a very infrequent event. GE is preparing documentation of PDRF probability results and will be proposing to eliminate interim operating limita:.wpplied to BWR/6s.
Euel Licensing. Updates Glen Watford reviewed the various fuel!icensing update periodic reports, such as the fuel bundle design report for each new fuel design and Transient Analysis Statistical Adjustment I
Factors update reports. GE is proposing changes to the licensing update submittals and requested feedback from the staff concerning what is actual!y needed. The possibility of using electronic media instead of paper for these reports was discussed. The staff will discuss the reports with management and provide feedback to GE for their proposal to revise the process.
In the meantime reports will continue as in the past.
1 Outstanding issues Glen Watford discussed several reports that the staff has inhouse for review: Amendment 25 to the GESTAR ll computer simulation code and several licencing topical reports. An improved j
nuclear methods status compJter simulation Code Was also discussed. The PANAC11/
TGBLA06 code represents a significant improvement in accuracy and GE expects to be ready l
l to perform reload analyses by mid 1998. The staff has performed inspections at several sites and has reviewed the new methods. The staff expects to issue a letter within the next month l
acknowledging the new methods.
l Attachments: As stated cc w/ atts: See next page DISTRIBUTION: See next page Document Name: MEETSUM.317 PGEB4/h (A)BC:PGEB OFC e
- I /v u 11oy NAME MJDavis:sw DATE 4/7/98 4//d /98
' OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
T. E ssig 2
April 14. 1998 Licensing Basis fotthePressure Regulator.Downscale FailureJPRDE) Event Glen Watford discussed recent analyses of the postulated PRDF event which indicate that it is a very infrequent event. GE is preparing documentation of PDRF probability results and will be proposing to eliminate interim operating limits applied to BWRi6s.
l Euel Licensing. Updates Glen Watford reviewed the various fuel licensing update periodic reports, such as the fuel bundle design report for each new fuel design and Transient Analysis Statistical Adjustment Factors update reports. GE is proposing changes to the licensing update submittals and requested feedback from the staff concerning what is actually needed. The possibility of using electronic media instead of paper for these reports was discussed. The staff will discuss the i
reports with management and provide feedback to GE for their proposal to revise the process.
In the meantime reports will continue as in the past.
Outstandinglasues Glen Watford discussed several reports that the staff has inhouse for review: Amendment 25 to the GESTAR ll computer simulation code and several licencing topical reports. An improved nuclear methods status computer simulation code was also discussed. The PANAC11/
TGBLA06 code represents a significant improvement in accuracy and GE expects to be ready to perform reload analyses by mid 1998. The staff has performed inspections at several sites and has reviewed the new methods. The staff expects to issue a letter within the next month acknowledging the new methods.
Attachments: As stated i
oc w/ atts: See next page
)
j l
i w
E DISTRIBUTION: Mtg w/GE Re Technical Infomation Exchange Dated 4/14/98 rd_ Copy Docket File PUBLIC PGEB r/f OGC ACRS MDavis JWilson MMalloy EMail SCollins FMiraglia RZimmerman BBoger BSheron RFrahm Tulses HRichings EKendrick THuang GThomas MChatterton ZAbdullahi GGolub
--<._))
1
. LIST OF ATTENDEES AT TECHNICAL INFORMATION EXCHANGE MEETING WITH GE NUCLEAR ENERGY HELD IN ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND ON MARCH 17,1998 NAME AFFILIATION M. Davis NRC/NRR/PGEB G. Watford GE Nuclear R. Frahm NRC/NRR/SRXB T. Ulses NRC/NRR/SRXB H. Richings NRC/NRR/SRXB E. Kendrick NRC/NRR/SRXB J. Rash GE Nuclear J. Potts GE Nuclear J. Carmody PECO Nuclear K. Hunt
- PECO Nuclear T. Huang NRC/NRR/SRXB G. Thomas NRC/NRR/SRXB M. Chatterton NRC/NRR/SRXB
- Z. Abdullahi NRC/NRR/SRXB G. Golub NRC/NRR/SRXB
v GENuclear Energy Nuclear Fuelbgmeenns GeneralElectne Company P.CL Bas 784 Wdmmgm NC 28402 March 31,1998 GAW-98-008 MFN-013-98 Document Control Desk US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 ATTN:
M. J. Davis
Subject:
Non-proprietary Presentation Material from GE/NRC Meeting of March 17, 1998
Reference:
M. J. Davis to T. H. Essig, Notice ofMeeting with GENuclear Energy (GE),
March 10,1998.
Attached is the non-proprietary material presented by GE during the subject meeting. In '
addition to the topics on the agenda, Mr. Potts provided a brief update on the status of GE's program to increase the limit on Gadolinia concentration used in GE nuclear fuel.
If you have further questions, please phone me at (910) 675-5446 or Jim Rash of my staff at (910) 675-5612.
Sincerely,
[Y
'blen A.4Vatford, Manager Nuclear Fuel Engineering (910)675-5446/ Mail Code A13 l
L
'b Ot1C. DOCS \\TechnoksyypdmesswerAI9erNunpropvCAWepJe As YObh& ' Y
(-
l-i i
t l
l l
l l
l i
1 ATTACIIME_NT NON-PROPRIETARY PRESENTATION AIATERIAL FROAI GE/NRC MEETING OF MARCH 17,1998 l
i l
0%IC410CETectuwac_t%essMarch 199lrhonpropVGAW98006 doc L
e K~%1[y
%I,:
f 3
>I l il:
I h
A' w,
l:'
r.
s
,f,f
' ~ ^
~
3 0
<I yl'-.
< N ;,- f'.'<,
^ '<~
[
- 'J -
'^
y
.SQ : :, '
1 b, >,>
,4 v
,b,., n. c g
.h'i +
['
[y'
- l: > -
S,S3';N) in, r
,1 f'
i f
e n
','?
n
- / $dh
" ?
? k>
g s
.,?lqW g^, ;
i,hH:
. l^
E
,N r
nf,f ~' s A
@ M s"o:-
a'i,, b sy3 d['
f s
[
,,3, r
f,
J
- n, '[{
q'
.y y' ::
- : s j~
(c' g :;'2',,d ;
s',
a
[ /'
e i, ';
s t,' c eN tl
- ! 3 '\\
~
'/ +-
f y
l j
t, c
s
,i y
uN l
K a e cg i
G nn h a ch C
Tx ec E
R l
8 eu n 9
N 9
Fio 1
t ra 7
a S
m 1
e l r h
U c
co r
uf a
n NI M
f s
,F,j
[/
- f' ib jp g
I' s
.O"
[
,![
N+L Y, n dL i
[
i lp
. I
=
s e
l g
a t
n t
a ii h
m c
s x
n E
e a
r n
r u
o T
l i
i t
a n
a F
o m
i r
e t
l a
of a
m n
c I
s s
r s
o t
n l
c e
w A
f a
n n
m o
U I
i D
L o
n e
h t
c v
r e
e o
o r
s s
T r
t u
e e
p a
s g
u o
n s
E m
u p
a i
l s
G g
x hd gd i
d
/C n
e g
Ro E
Co nr r
r s
io f
f f
R et dt dt dt i
t n
i sl N
o a
e o
e a
na it e
s r
a a
Da uWdP oWaW s
mr R
s ny o
t f
n e
r pn s
n n
d l
s I
e mel e
t e
y e
t r
ol r
ul n
ui rG xe rG G
a te J
J e
F P
E P
O irpor g
P y
A na p
mo C
E G
/^ b y% : swem
,+ nd ?
,?
?; 5
[
0 d'
2 2
s e %
,. ', 's$
O <
l'
' - }"
> M l'
t, 4 s
c 1
a\\ ['
v 4
'a V~4,Cl'
( ;;
- e
- c. Jy
,1"
. Q
~
c ;.
{j
- x+
l:;' [b f_ :
M hC
]N f 4
L
,. ~ jM:3W xn;y s
ww, v)G?
J s l' 4
y s
?
3 l Z;[v,
i!
h r
- i g
- nRnw@ma
- l:
qj; u ww't.
ef ^
, e,w s
? fv c '
,'y e
T 4Pl p es,(
r t
[
- 'v o a[u't: a ?
,',,'l:( y, f ::
f f: i s
4 Y
- '/'E' y
[t n
p 'i <
?
ym;s*-
e s
,e
_ z: *lt "
l
/
m
[-
( :
e 4:, '
v o
r p
m I
n g
y i
gr s
e 8
e n
9 E
D 9
r 1
a e 7 l
h l
e s
c 1
a uh u
RNc F
mE ar
.i G M J
i;Ad ; leg %g ce
- I
,k efv i
X,,,
s 4*
~
elWk )
'i
- f 7 i
s l.
fN ey f
i f
Au i'
l[l-a U
j
- I f,f k*
i;..
.n I
3 7
d is n
a i
\\
.a 5
8,
'8 q;
g.
, ri
re irra b
,s sr d
e o
c r
a r
p P
e s
T t
a e
L s
,l d
s s
w t
u t
r) nr e
o R
eS 4
e r
s r
/
f L
aU c
2 mfe f
h P
s o
t p
h y g
r s
n n
d c
o n
e l
o a
i g
G a
n rl e
g le l
c (s l
n e
n i
c t
s g
e r
n r
o t r e
n gi n
a s
l i
e nZ a
pr r
n i
c D
y h
e e
u a i
r yd c
s c
c l
p a
r o
a a
e s Rp l
v a
r n
p n
Ws e
e y
v i
s ol r
h u
e c u l
ye td Cl a
l r
nr l
t a
F l
Lu a
t I r i
i a
c x
w r
x
,e i
a x
h 2
r e
ef i
E a
e e
c y t
,f h
i e
g e
t o
c h r h
c y
t G
t l i
t t
i a a i
ia i
t o
w t
l c
wl w
t l
t e
a a
1 0 r a
d i
l l
c 1
l 1
8 g 9
xZ 9 r e
8 En 0E 1
3E 2
i x
xZ 1 G 1
0 r s
8 8 9Gi 1G 1 9 s
1 o n
E E
E E
E E
e G-G-
G-G-
G-G-
c iL
lenoc 2
n I
c 1
r f
i o
i E
c e
l e
d aUp G
ir rTs t
r n
e! nmo 2
e r
fmcdt dI e
yl i
a 2
r "
meWca a"
0 o n l
h 1
ao c5 g
d i
r rGl n5 t
x ci Zi 9. l p
a 'E a
t r
o 02i p
/ 2 0 p 9ZO 881 26 a S0 t
1 0000O00000, 0909O09090 000OO00000 000AU90000 090 00090 000O 000 040O 090 000O000000 090S000090
'O00O000000 c
if ic l
e s
aUp rTs e
tnmon 2
r me/
l cdt dl
- l i
ya e
r a u
S nmeWca an 0
o n o
g d o l
1 ao c5 rGl ni U
t i
x ci n 9. l p
a t
t a
02i p r
/ 2 0 p ap I
t 9ZO 881 26 a SO e
1 F
n g
is h
t e
gn e
D s e r e h
dl uc c
o h
t rd c
s n i
o et oa p
2 d
h r pip pm r r s
x r e e t
y s e o
gh
/d d o
ct t
1 r
nt ss o o d fr ail g
e gd r r r o e E
pf le nrl n o e s s e ui et e r cor rP i
cfdi rl at ek G
l r ia oa apat s o a aM ab fdr at e pd t
t r
ri i
t e/
x e L# cb# p# #RWPT AD l
)3
)
9 5
/
9 8
/
(
)
8 y
4
(
B n
9
/
e, a
n 2
c e
m 8
1 n
9 g
r
(
a e
9 n
G 2
l 1
i i
2 p
m dU f
m6 o
t nT m
aM e
9 d
n 9
n o
c.
d/
c g
1 n
i m2 g
r nd e
s n
d aWd 2
e c
y e
i n
ln n
iG t
n b
d s
u e
n G
nF n
i
,3 me s
n n
i e
n4 s
o e
e>
A md c
t s
v i
i a
Ad d
a a
o t
e h
L d
Uwu e
r t
n o
r r
e i
e l
e d
LS e
p wmr p
s c
o n
us 2
n,p o
a n
e A
n a
d g
1 x
i c
oi Ep n
n a
n s
a e
e r
e i
s i
y e
d GSl a
o c
t p
s 2
,b i
i n
n e
l t
o l
1 r
gS mp c
r d
E i
e e
nUe e
i 2
c mp u
n r
1 a
i
,s G
e Es aa a o
s E
u t
n s p
p r wd C
n d
b x
Gh eia I
t o
pa e 2
n0 t
E sb oTL 1
C a
0 r
E RS 2
2 i-0 1
1 F
5 GNU E
G
e 1
e l
l l
l l
l I
l 1
ee
%~%
e i
e
<f k
04 e
\\
z M
~.o 0
L w
e N*
ed f
w N
.DO
\\
m d
).
y H
4 N
M Cl i
l l
}
l I
}
E
\\
I
e 4
1E G
i l
000O000000, eno 000S000090 c
2 n
000O000000 I
c 00 00040 1
r i
o fi 00 00000 E
c l
e 0000 000 e
d 4
G rUsp 0e00 090 a
ir T
tn n
000000O000 r
1 r
2 fme@f e
o dl 000900G090 e
yla 2
c i
E t
r a meV a d
d o
'O 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 O<
o n an 0
l h
gI c c
1 ao r5 G
i i
r r
Z 9. laGlp ni t
x ct i
t o
02i p
/2 p
ap 9ZO 881 2 a
SO t
1 dn a
c 2
if i
1 2
c l
e 1
rUsp a
E E
T tn n
mcMi G
G ya nmed a an 2
e o
l dl
- l e
/
r a t
0 o n o
V c f
S x
ct 1
oo c5 gI l
d o i
n 9. lrGl ni i
o U
a p
t r p
/2 p
ap I
02i t
1 9ZO 881 2 a
SO nos h
t i
gn e
r s e r e h
dl h
u c c
a rd c
s n it o
et o a p
o p
d h r pip s
pm r r x
o gh t} d de o ct t
s r
e e m
/s o o d fr pf r
nt s l
ai l
g e gd r r o e ro e nrl n o
e s s e
r cor r c ui et e p
i ifdirl at ek l
r C
fd r at e pdt aM ab ta oa apriat s oV e/
r a
i t
e l
c if ice h
g c
p n
c s
t i
i a
y l
f e
e H
i r
c l
a d
c e
s o
y p
L s
sK e
m c c s c if i
cRis ei c
f l
8 eK a e c
P eR l
c 9d i
i c
r n uC pP ye l
9 o e s cp mM aMsC 1
t s
p w
i r
d c e d
eM r
d K
s o
e id t
el r
l yi c
eK el v
t s c d
i mv mt a e H m yi y y g
s l
a c S e S a
i r
r
- i c m l
s e o o a u aL yi ns Wd W l
l rl y e n
yt rf L
e p gaf i
l a
mtyb ae n
t al pd o vis s
P u T i
n pa e r et r e d g e
y BB A n
a a ef e n r
s mCn ps s p h a ct u a a
l i
o e
e TS a a s
cRlaE 2
n n
u o s
l r
s 2
t a
I
- NpP s
t c pe e
s t o
r i
t e p pA i
e s
s i c n c r n
e e
e e rO s
i mAmwp pn eC r
e e l
c mr aUa e x x e vO l
l g
i d oSLSNE EG A
OL nr L
e p m
n Ai 4
l l
1 u -
F E
G
4 1
E 4
1 y
G E
r f
G a
o m
f s
o e
n g
g w
a n
t i
n s
S 4
a n
O 1
v e
4 E
d c
i 1
G_
A_
L EG
I ya rene r
)F aea D
uns R
a r (P oe t
r au s
l l i
uiga s
eF aB Rel g
ea rc n
i us s
sn n
sw e
ero c
b_
i PD L
lll i
l 2
1 2005 t
e n
r t
eu n
d e
vs e
e r
es v
e sV d
e e
r d
us r
u i
g l
vS s
p s
i n
s oT e
m mi i
r t
e r
pf sp s
e m
p r
o e t
i s
vt r
sl gd i
ml e
r oy o
t a
al t
e nn n
s a
e vi a
r a
i r
s o
n l
l ut se ul er gssn go m
pe ow pai e
r e u pb t
s r
r n
r o
r e
yu eo o
s v p
et sbt c
avl r
t r
r t
u a o n
uud uCvt l
r n
s sj n a
s o
gT c
o s
e at e
a ef s
t s a i
e r
s r
t r
u s r
o e
l n
pu ar p
psVo egh ep s
ir aeCc yin t
r l
c c
rT n
e oub r
pl n
o b
s e
i p
s oaf f
oss i
t e
nert o
u olcia t
est n
k b
e D
d nni e
c el i
r r
r h
c l
eoa a
i u
u u nn wCMl t
oS B
FI l
n I
i i
a a
e T
F F
vE 1
l l
ll lll l
e 3
1 2005 e
7 m
9 9
a
)6 r
1 f
9 yn 9
e ria m
ud 1
l it r
e la bd F
e eu m
Fl
(
c F
a nn D
s i i R
g d
o t
P n
e t
n ir d
et u s e
l t
di pn a
s e
u sa mv sb oe i
la c
v yn F
l e
ai wD ns eR 9
ae vPn i
s d
c o
e a
Dn et i
r at i
o Oe a
t r
sh i t u le Ee iv R
Mf da f
s l
a i
ev i
t f
dd b
c me lu nd arD l
A G
e e i
cf Bi inO f
r t
d rt o oE i
n n
en t CM e
a ve s
r i
i c
G Ri d
H eR t
4 12005 e
e t
t s
n a
h r
u e
t e
a v
oi d c
e b
o d
g s
m n
e lu i
t s
s o
u a
i w
m a
s i
c R
l t
a n
h A
h o
c t
eS i
n d
hl Fa esis wc6 ir s/
f oe d nR i
t t r
e wW n au if el l
sioB dui t
a gf end n
y i
r eer s
el it i
o adadn r r o
uht Bif t
it a
e e e l
od v 6
r s
aol t
e u/u u
i fb gRl sl y H
ef eWir c c af on l
6 gor in B
t g
R nee eat e
/
i rl n
Wsug a
gu n u l
l l
s B
oin n ngeq i
l ve i
ai ie r
Nf S gSrEf n
e i
r r
e O
P c
iL
5 1
2005 R
)
e 0
s P
s 0i si nC o
5 n
cl e
eMic o
eEr e
f i
ut i
t El bicsh smeet Eia ac vrI fi F) a i pl f
Pw h
sa o o yi l
s f t l g
v To e
nihl gg es t
n l
a d
et Tri nml f
t on n
a iic e
r, v
l t
r t
d e y. n b ce e
e r nt awe epr o a ou n v
c e
r oac cdi lpot u
s e ec s
n n s nhAa n l
ep n
i a aei t
a r(
f e
f gcbn er eridu t
d=
u e n r
t n
q inut aqn lahr t r g
as e
i se e oc ne c
t r
si ht u u gh n
pi f
nl t ss q
amn wabn ehe i
is o nat cr s
ml eR s
i ot e sduf l
n n
d deohinsi e
we bA nweaf r
t n
c ot oS e a
( r o
s es a
l a
t F hi e l
i f r ot rhsy n l
t t
aie ut L
/r f d
n t
r wn p i v "e.
f l
l ef ei n
eii yb e o
n o
v a D
w o f eba v
id he c
ti l
oh mte s
sbe bat e oisishrtoha s
O pi r
n utha st p r
t v
r E
dwt e
sd e
t p of ee r y oet s M
en em se ob ho n p
enf ydn,mo dwd u
t ri n
pmemlnu4ec 6
oF c
ua r
a
/
pd Do eal e oo8 o
h xat r9 o o t
D T e v s i g1 st R
xeR s
W esp B
- i i
6 1
2 005 f
lu y
G t
d i
l r
i n
b o
a f
a r
b sG s
o t
o i
mo s
d r
pet a
e t
b i
F sle l
Dyb g
p Rs a
n pa i
c) s l
P oimn s
l t
r f
p ot e
e i
n pt c
m noasi i
l l
yt oc n s c
g it eo n
e ari l
i t
us ef t
l n s un e
a n
r r
e s c e
s l
n me a
o p
nh r
t upo cl D o
o c
c l
t oE eR O ms i
e e E
6 a
dGmr A r/
i d
goat T M eR h
t n
s( Sh nW nt i
i t
r st mEi e B e
aec eGw m
pl e
tad i
t epps e6 e
s/
nt m
rp pxyiR c
i v
me AEs eW_Ea o
E f
i c
G f
l RB eR
ygrenerae icuu i
sa s
m e a c r ng ao mr rP o e frc en Pa l
l l
ei e
uv Fr u
S Q
e
- i s~et.
.s"
,kti_.
e,m n r
r
- 3
~_
ia
.a
.e"^
ej-0
-)'yR 9
=afe-90s 0
,s i i.
ef
,e/
l 2
l usMd
,. nv;b h
1 t l y, wy: y2*e~d-2 r
- a.
a n
-I y ~ :e:: b-
-C yu i=
u ro
.t" i
y 7~
-~p e n
.h ^).
o
+
2
- 0f ivE
.S^ p:,.
e
- m 4
c(
r 4~6m t
9 e(
w e rs
. l :.-
^s?
o"p~.-
,h ~.r 7m 1 -
a l -)m <-
- i ef i
ed qmv~f n
B_k o
. G*m0+
. E mo:'o,'
=-
i p-y(i aG E~iw
~tm px.
.f
'x: m ~i t e>
e-la x"
,G*~@v 7
~l 0M l
!S:
".pL o
- c, e;*-0
- p1
~6,2-h fnN
, Os=
,m c a
oj+
mg
.n*
'0sM
.~
%m
- 1 e
4gg* -
N.g 5m a
G._- (1
' J_l
^
a 3ww hm.. n*umfe
~Em.3S i
+
bS
,~
u i
ff l
y
. +M q
^
a0
~ G ;.
i s
iP y
.G* amp"
_N.c*
W-4 b
tmr+
.o" c
e*-
4 c
+
ym
. 6
- gw s
.^
- g
_4 d s'
e V
2*
-.rwj 4o r
M:.
+-
4d-,
9a, ~
k c
E&e.
e L
1
~
i
,# 9~; n n
xw:A Q
~
5 a
L 9
9.
a
.x 9v s
1-
> m. 3
^
4 rw 1_.
e s'
8~.5 wN m
l'
's
^
^ -
~
~
s
. 5 L
%e%
,m '
^<
g"-
' _ gm _
a r
8 9r i
'^ ys..).S.-
.jsd K.z~'- ga*Wa%
'., F g 1,.4, p" o
- 1 r. ;-
o
- 9" 9~
J
= ~h.
.. a -- g@r+
m r
mN?. 5*F g '~ '.
.s i
%: 7 A
f
=R
- i
..W,c..S~-
m g
e
?
~-
(
r
.i
~
t S
c Z
^
- r
_ # <c. 7 J'
,1
+* 9"-y1y y
x ' 4,= d-e
_jua Mg u'-
y_.
P ay5
.. n f^d
. 4 ympW- '
m4.(
M^m.,y l
4tj9-
.M-oe-c i
- m,&a_.
b'e x
f t
y po
' wcO a
'.S
. "y
&p a
^
s
- g' @-
nB o
o t
Qc W~
i wt G
Qw
-. %c:s l
s.
n u : c.
-.E':,+.
i y_
a:t 3g #, '.tg~
S,v
. ' h,%
x b
>,n
,.N' r_
m v_
3 t;e, s
. m, e,.. _
k a
a'
?-
ga-s mg
~
c +e.>:;s es s i
^
+
,_ro..syy p
- ea' a Pj l
em f.Q*M,
3 g-g
.y e
.lg fp m
c ;.
1#
wV R
y _:,%yO~ g:*
g
+
A*
W f
e ;.a ~
m l
2 e
0 0
0 0
0 0
1 1
u 0
0 0
0 0
1 0
0 0
0 0
F 0
0 0
1 0
0 1
0 1
E 1
G myor eo==l 6q) 3 ( og:; u xmq)J.
ij g
l i
,I
O 6
'2:
s cn CD 5%
eg.
CD Effk
- 2 CD "EO ig.
w X.
e CO t
L7 6
CO uR 6.
.M. :,
Ny w
a p
co iO CO C
cc, k
N s
e e
E o
Cm
,s 3
s u
i~
\\. \\. \\. \\. \\. \\. \\. \\. \\. 1
~
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
Q O
O O
O O
O O
O O
CD CO N
W Af)
T C9 N
T" t;$5
~
O s
za k
e e ed ed d d d d d ed t
l n
cl elc e e e e e
elc e l
c c e
yc y y g y g g g g g g y g r
r r r r r r r
m c c c
c a
a a a a a a a
d m
nt t
ct c c c c c ct c h h h h h h h h h h h h o
2 4 5 s 6 s s s s s s 7 s
C i
i i i i i i i
n n nDiDDDDDDInD n
I i
I U
gv eT r
A uM 0 6 0 0 0 8 0 0 3 0 0 0 6 5
/
e s d
o 3 7 5 5 1 6 8 1 4 2 2 8 3 3
l pW d
1 3 3 3 4 2 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4
n xG uE B
sn r
o e
i t
b c
1 3 4 2 5 3 1 2 1 0 3 3 3 6
mf e
o p
u s
N n
i r
s r
e e
b k
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9
mf a
o u
e N
L s
r d
e o
b R
6 6 2.
6 2 6 6 6 6 6 6 8 8 0
f e
mol 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 4 4 4
u e
2 2 5 2 5 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 6,
c N
F 6
u n
6 e
7 i
r s
r e
e e
b le lc f d y
mo 4 4 8 4 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 2 2 0
c p
n 6
d u
u e
z x
N B
3, lp te 2
0 E
m 1
m oc 3
o ts 1
t a
1 k
t s
l k c o
2 s d
e
/
r B
k e s
a t
r i h
1 n
2 1 at 2
2 ct d
o o
t r
f s
h h ma h h ei n 1
la e
a r
l P
A c c sP K c cP p e r L o
e dn E
aN o r
e mfoK e
8 e
t t
r z t
l K
a e o
U a a oit L HHF F KHPWCL CK R
5 G
h i
t tA
t e
e e e e le e e e
n lc lc lel el el c
el e le cl cl cl y
l cl l
c c c c y c c e
c y c y c y y y y c y y y y y c y c y c m
c c c c
c c ch c
c c d
d d d h 5 t
t t
t d
m s s s n s n s n r t
s n s s t
t t
t t
o 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 3 4 n 1 2 1 1 C
n n In n n n n n n n In n n n i
iiiiiii4 I
i i i i U
g v eT r
A uM 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 0 6 0 0
/
e s d
0 0 0 0 0 4 0 2 0 2 3 0 0 0 0 o
l pW 1
1 1 3 2 3 1
dn xG uE B
s n
r o
i e
t b
c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 3 4 0 0 0 0 mf e o p u
s N
n i
r s
r e
e b
k 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 mf a o
u e
N L
s r
d e
o b
R 4 6 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 6 0 2 4 4 f
8 3 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 3 6 3 6 8 mol 1 7 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 7 9 4 6 1 e
u 1 3 7 3 u
1 1 1 2 N
F e
r s
e e
c b
f d 2 8 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 8 0 6 2 2 le l
c n mo y
n 3 4 9 5 c
e u
u 1 1 1 2 de i
N B
te r
lp e
B m
o p
n c
2 e
s t
x 2
g la a
E n
n n
e h
i 2 m1 1
n 1
m k
1 1 1 t
f r
lo a sk t
k ak n l
h e r k k c o
m 2
n r
oh r
r i s
r d
a a
at s a 1
e et a e d
a at n
o h
c u n 1
r e
P s mu ms h it q e md a mma l
r r s n o
s sP y e
l a
E A
sik s n c n s f
r le o oi e r r z n h
r k r
it t
U ol s oh a o u o o u t
t G
A L
F OOF CHMSCF G R
F F F P
UT M
)t
/
e
)
) d l
t t
leW le le p
l leg e
k p
p a
0 k
k 6 e
p )t a) a
~
et e
e e
Ul pl p o T
l ig U
t e
U T p n
M p
T o
/ k d
Mk Min s
a a
o We
/
/
ni d e d
p et G
Wp Wt a
x n
U 4
G U G
ei T
T m
4 M
0 M 0 n
(
5 7 a a
/
x e/ d d
lp e
(
(
gaW gW e
e
,l g el r
e eG aG a g c v
r r
at a0 e0 e
r o 6
v v
eh e(
a (6 a
v r
l a o d
e s e e e
n g n g
ef l
l d
u a o a
d l
l n r n d a r
i b
et u
e u
n v a
U v b
v b
u e n
i s
T ai a
b r Mle m
U U
t Tle TU e m
r a
d x
Md MT e
/ d n n
Mr e
/
/
a Wu l
eWb Wd w sd u d / a r
l b
G e
g U c lnG U G Wd d
o 5 T o
r t
T G a u9 M 5
h r
s5 Mh b 3 P
le3 5 8
/
/
r d s,
l r d s e r 4 s e e
e d oWo c
o
~
n c oWn n
c uf nf sf o n d o n p
ud Gi n
f d Gi t
a led i
t a
)
et a b e a
u m
8 e a
m d et a m
n 6 n
E n5 n n n e n l
n e
r r
r mfo u glp mfo g5 r
f s4 mfo Gig 5 i
i i
ui i
r
(
s 4 b s ma r
r a
a u
)
e o
x B d t
e e o x e
e E
e p
ed o x e l
4 d t
B E
e p u
c e p Gl e e n 8 lyd t
f ly t
yd t
e xl e e n y e n l
h lo( ad d l
8 l
l ad d e 1
at d e 1
ni i
i l
l l
e8 n n
sl n n sl n
sl g c x
g el e Ei g el e Ei el e i
g c o c o c Gi o c Git i
i t
i8 r e o x r
x o x t
r x
o x M
OEP E L
H n 9 OE P E 4
4 ORPE o
K K
E M
K K
G-
I
)tle le p
k
~
aep UT yM l
b /
e md eW r
u s s G
o s p a9
~
x r 7 e e(
i r e
e r
g a g
a c a
r r
e e e
r v
v a u a
s le od d p o r
x n
ek u
a s r
b e e n
U wp o i
T oUt m
p a
u Ml T n
a k
n Mi c
/
r i
d m
g i
/
Wd d a o
p e
r Gt We eh x
p n
reGl n
t s
g g 3
o l
4 n5 e
o n i
t r
c e
i o e6 a
d t
l t
r o
n y
s o
d e
d d t
h h
i s
e n d d
a r
m n
i t
,s e
a e s m
ta a e
n n
c x
y p s d d d o
n e
a r
i e
o e t
a a e ni r n et a
l n
n e s
pd r
ct a
t l
r m
e o o ma r
i i r
a x n g
r ct s o e l
h e a i
)
r ei t
u oi o
mf ob l
l i
o B x n
r h
ir r
o t
r f e
s r
6 e o e
r o
n r ax t
o r
E s
e c P
i p
1 1
s c p at s
t e
i sGd a sd g g g g m i
t e( odie n
e g
n n
pi n ni r d
R ai e i
i r
t t
i ud d od e r l
i i
r s le C nd d sd n
C8 e r l
n e i
l i
i x u o c r
i a
a s al h d 8 f e o x
d ul t
o aP6 RP E aBCCF CZO r
l l
i g
u u
Q Q
n O.
lav d
ie d
r e
t e
t e
t e
r e
l lp ll p
e m
m c
o d.
o t
c o
c h
e n
n o
d o
te it n
it d
s lp n c
a c n e
u mio e
e o n
p n
pi n
t a o a s
it n r t
t o
s a a
t S
c r n
c l
e e
i i
e p
e p C
c o p
C p l
o l
y O
s O
a n
n Ci E
n Ei v
I e
ir t
g e
v r
,U A eT l
l r
le uM
+ +
+ +
+
+ +
e
/
4 0 0 70 0 2 0 6 0 0 c
s d
t n od 3 5 6 35 6 5 6 3 5 6 o
p
)
xW uB E G leh c
e y r c a y w e6 b d t
9 8 0 70 3 8
1 6 9 2 r
a 9 9 0 90 0 9 0 9 9 0 e
a 1 9 0 90 0 9 0 9 9 0 D
h l
1 2 1 2 2 1 2 1
1 2 c
C y y t
pt t
nr r r r n r r cl O e c c ap p a p a p p
( b E_S O O JAA MA J AA r
d m o
t e e c
n s a
e 4 6 0 5 8 1 6 9 4 7 0 n s e
t 9
0 9 9 0 9 9 9 9 0 a a r
a 9
s eh D
9 0 9 9 0 9 9 9 9 0 pd 9
l 1
2 1
1 2 1
1 1 2 c
1 1
n ru C
m a
ct v oy y b y r r y s
a s
O e c o
'e a a e a a a a n
e o
B' DON FMM F M MMM od a
i p n t
o r
xi a r g
E s nl e i
e mfu o
d 2
l ed a
r n
m 2
1 d
/
/
x e
P n u o
1 2
2 e
n t
/
/
/
eb 2
1 1
o to e
t t
g x1 B
k k
k d
s c
c c
i E1 h
i i
i s
a n
E c
e e
e ol r
r r
e l
i OG a
m m
m ot o
C i
iL L
P A e
i 4
P L
g E
P nO
ya w
re i.
dn s
u e
d s
n u
a ac d
~
e e
r n
u n
l a
ia l
f p
s t
l s
c l
e a
e m
f c
t n
a e
e D
r a
a g
n l
o o
l i
t i
e m
e r
r g
v p
e Z
i r
l a
e u
e r
t s
c e
t d
n y
n e
g t
la r
l a
c l
a i
n i
ib y
e T
f a
v a
i m
r t
i n
u l
r e
e o
s r
d f
r e
r i
e e
c k
o p
n t
a a
l e
d e
m e
u l
t f
r o
t o
i r
s f
e m
i r
z t
e m
n p
o o
e t
l c
d m
eu e
s e
f m
e e
t l
v t
i a
r m
t v
r n
i a
m g
s a
o s
m t
o r
r e
c p
o r
p g
m E
E g
G G
m A
u i
S
1 1
2005 we
)
n 1
.h lo ca Ve
(
)
r P
s e
o 2
ef 5
n s
i yn l
1 o
1 t l
3 c) ai t
u1 n a Edl.a m
Doocr
~
ErVio
~
r p(
~
N ef s
el nin) l
)
(
r u ae 3
~
t e
ngn
~
t of g1 a
pf of oiosis e
s e
d e
Rrfnyerdm p
m elu i
na a
U
'l imimldo g
d g
sm( mnV l
e u uu(
~
n Ds n
~
sbn o
g is e
sissi t
l n
d nanns e
namiieaad i
ut rt t c
Bnonnl of oo e iL eCiCCf n
ue o
e e
l l
u
~
e F
u
~
F
~
2 1
2005 s
e r
r u
o s
t t
u r
c o
c f
a s2d n
t f
i i
i F
d1 n
c c
d a
e ot a
e t
f n
h nl d
p w
s i
t ee v
e e
mfu o
e t
m mdt r
n p
n t
a s
snn e
l b
n p
u ee e
i j
s r
l r
d ymr h
o l
i w
A aAu w
l s
s c
r e
t nl n
l l
a a
n a
e p
s c
Re t
y l
i t
p t
t e
t e
nAh f
t s
t eTt o
n l
a i
r s
y a
t i
d a
sSo e
b l
t nEf p
p p
S y
d aGd t
r e
s U
s t
e s e
d e
r n
is Nidt p
h i
g y
Yd v a o
t n
v y
t i
o l
n a
Deol rdl ro f".
pe e
t r p i
n Onp us s
A r s sinf r
/
e 5
s n
s ot e
I emwd Nmr4 r
t tc ot e
n u
o/
apar ed I
R c
e Mc t
FedeNa c
EoaW i
.r t
i s) pe-L nF GDFB Ud aA l
rS e
T(
~
u F
3 12005 s
ro dn
?
e s
v t
g r
r n
o e
p h
d is e
t n
r o
ao e
e h
l t
e c
s i
r se w?
sh i
l sh g
et d eet n
cr eb gi l
w d
of d a n
o i
l an l
r ni iv ps ah o
e a
i s
o n v "? h vct r
a a
a e
e i
m d
y ois s sl p
t t
cQe sb l
r el a
r k
a e
o cjTu eio mu d
sf s c a bCs f
sin c n o"
o p
s b
r o
in i
U s
d C C e p plen n a o o e
errs d
ir s
c e
ekf nt t
r o
acF g
o f NN h a u
eA t
r t
p Cee m sb nl n
r r
e a
eS Raarh e e e is e
t acrd mf r
t Nt o o t
n a
aawe ocep naivu tihh e
u sc ob e
r o se c
aeiWWH mPdUR l
l i
vt L
e a o o
dS-S l
ep e
Ru uF
llll{
l1 lli 3
1 s
C e
D itn E
5 0
s N
i 5
a u
t 2
r s
ta I
3 e
e t
s I
c it S
e C
n n
u R
DU i
s s
a s
At E &
d s
t r
r o
I oN e
g S
y c
h n
p y
g n
t E
e e
i n
GR o
U m
g o
d o
n a
l o
d o
r t
o ad o
a s
t it t
c o
a u
e u
5 i
t l
O 2
ph e1 b
c t
M6 i
0 r
u o
e tn TM t
N s
R2 i
e 3
D d
g r
P mnt o CC r9 e
d i
c e 4 v
MD w6 o
s a
n nf LE o2 r
e e
R-SNP3 p
mi m
c AL I
li
e o
us N..,m 7.w
- e s %g
- . z.
A, ~;;g%g '
"tnAQ::gggl1 % YEN $
.ggte
. a
.M
.m
' 'ff.f,?..
%ca%s l%~; N.m~;.
\\
n )sa,w.,g? ;c 49 a
4 3
~
j ;.
. g" b
- 4
- gEf.
".. ~
ige;4 M.
~
$w k] $1p f M W @ g sip %.
w%swa.a ap$_ g 2-s
- g3g$lhG4%;Qm$ g, ~~.-
h e
?
Cn
~
yp..
n x
L y
9WW rg fj$
-fgjjf6A?&g j;s@' w dar g-q
%y k
4s$$s@6{M*! "4:
~
.-s h.
&e
%n L-AL M
m
%!!jjy)i., n%@" k"g@M.-
L' b
Y d[h 2
\\
5
^%b. -
b h
Q Y%9d-
.$gi
' aggs-e a~ -
e w
.I guy.
$hQu g (if,$
m$*.
i kh::
haag) g d-N
%q
( ig :eW,gy.y;gp..pS. _. _*W_
'/w:.
m m
- s.,-
p~
2TS.
~
p s
q) n
%}Q:.:..
N s w.m9 y sa y~*,
A N_. {;syaj ss q: }
w 7'na
~,,
~ _.., q.
ip
,i _
' !$b+
- &3., c
-e
- p..
g ~'
e
.r n
p..,
Ar
$ :-.p.
' _. _ as. "
- 4
.,,pa m 4 jk
$5'd f
.h$
T...,.>.
M,W40:$' d.fkh..'
w' DD O
C w
k@
%u O
32m D
O 3 Lw O-D., %
u
r n
a i
e t
y t
n d
n e
i e
m m
m i,.
e y
e v
r o
b i
u r
s q
i p
s e
m y
r i
l r
a e
tn n
a a
m a
c d
o t
i f
a s
i o
u s
n l
tnig e
c r
y a
s e
pa m
k l
t r
1 o
a 2
n f
d e
r ns e
e i
e p
e d
r c
e p
o o
dt e
t r
e a
r e
p vl 6 c
o e u0 a
t i
l h
mA p
e cisL n
c a
B i
n s
s s eG s
er u
ul T e
r c
t t
a a y/
s u
1 s
c t
t c1 ye n
S s 0Cc c
o s
27 Aa o
c d
l r
r e
r N u p8 C o
v e
cl 9 h
e vAcl9 R e
L O P a A1 N t
M e
e
d h t
st s n
e g#
e e
o d
rl n si a
c e at l
u n#
c dl e#
f ys ci oc e
d e
cl e dinl l
rl rIe P
ul y"
s gpa c
d ne l
e c#
ei r n p T N' cnfuf t
i k
a st e e, U i
t rdnau" o
c s
s e oe rl e
a r
e r phmcv*
ua r
og#
t ot t
oin#
st 0 ee cn ct a
n7 mv ae e
r e g "O s d pe#
o a
r t
e wpo r
rie N/ xmd#
l e
pv N i M o ' /m i o W i
e m f'
MC 1
2 )(
e e
e e
e o
1 1
s s
s r
Q o
e n
n e
B A
dn m
m B
N E E E E E e E E E E E E E E E e E E
B B
A, a
i A
V G G G G G G G G G G G G G S G G
i S
A E
P le B
G h
E B
u t
i F
G A
Wg e
n p D D C D D C D C D D
D ik y
6 6
5 5
5 6
6 4
4 4
4 4
4 4
4 3
3 c
T R
R R R R
B R B 4 R R
R R R R R R R R R B B R W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W A W A W W a
t r
n T
a B
B 8
B B
B B
B B B B
B B B B B B
B l
t P
n a
lP
l t
b 1
C
~
O
%b
' b eD CeD~)
e I
p.
h I
i
- "%=bD LL c)
LL1 O
u e m I
=
e e
h 4
i
%DD LL w
\\
W i
D
- c%
k, i
i n
o it c
ud or t
n I
2 1
E G
h t
i W
s e
s ir s
p t
r lu u
s S
e o
R N
gn ikcarT 2
1EG
e la s
c s
di t d
s doi r n
tn eh c
ge i
cted ntr o
u l
i p
dmo er a
rd bo i
b c
l f
c l
e srd i
dol i
a bsee t
o anit r
et i l
cd r
l ot a de pe ei ug l z sv rt oi c
t oy i
ei s
cl at rd a e at a oet 7n al r a v 9aDrMpDi e
n e
e
)ega r
e v
a 1
t n
1 a
C lp A
(
k N
/
)
s A
e P
(
k r
f o
o f
n a
.o t
i t
a u
D b
i l
r t
a s
c i
i D
ti rC d
loC
~
~
s isy lan A
y tilib t
a c
t t
a c
S a
p p
m m
i t
I y
n t
t i
e n
il i
e b
s i
n s
a t
a n
S r
a T
T r
n o
1 1
C A
N AP f
o tcap m
I
ng i
sed d
r e
a e
e l
c c
e o
u r
sun P
rd o
o e
t f
c e
n d
y e
l a
t c
b v
e i
t r
n ad r
o l
a o
i e
i r
r av r
p p
r e
p a
u a
h u
st g
c s
d o
n n
s i
o o
n k
o h
t t
o c
C e
i a
el t
r C
mb a
t r
r i
n y
R a
c gc N
l gnn a
a pt wia d
i u
s e
p p p e
r r
lc m
a n
d o
o u
f i di c
e u
t o
ot et n
c e
n c
nylc uo a
N d
y e
et yh mds e cs giisi c
s l
y v amn nbl d e
o r
o r
a a
a el r
a r ue r
r t uo oh m
pc sl e
t l TSFCCt mAsFcyu
- M m
I u
e e
e S
f
~6 4
GE Nuclear Energy cc:
Gag '
no, Manager Tex 6+4 und Moddication Services W F,har Energy ^
175 04ner Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 George B. Stramback GE Nuclear Energy 175 Curtner Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 David W. Reigle GE Nuclear Energy 175 Curtner Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 James F. Klapprotn GE Nuclear Energy 175 Curtner Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Ralph J. Reda, Manager Fuel and Facility Licensing General Electric Company P.O. Box 780 Wilmington, NC 28402 Glenn A. Watford, Manager Fuel Engineering GE Nuclear Energy P.O. Box 780 Wilmington, NC 28402 James L Rash GE Nuclear Energy P.O. Box 780 Wilmington, NC 28402
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _... _. _.. _