ML20215H093
| ML20215H093 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/10/1987 |
| From: | Naidu K NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
| To: | Merschoff E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
| References | |
| REF-QA-99900839 IEIN-86-093, IEIN-86-93, NUDOCS 8704200040 | |
| Download: ML20215H093 (18) | |
Text
'o,,
UNITED STATES l
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o
y WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 k
,/
April 10, 1987 l
Docket No. 99900839 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Ellis W. Merschoff, Acting Chief Vendor Program Branch DQAVT/01E g
/P THRU:
Edward T. Baker, Acting Chie Reactive Inspection Section Vendor Program Branch DQAVT/0lE FROM:
K. R. Naidu Reactive Inspection Section Vendor Program Branch DQAVT/01E
SUBJECT:
TRIP TO CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA. MARCH 6, 1987 TO ATTEND A PRESENTATION BY DUKE POWER COMPANY (DUKE)
RELATIVE TO THE R0TORK VALVE MOTOR OPERATOR (RVMO)
TEST RESULTS
Background
NRC issued IN 86-93 informing licensees that Duke Power Company discovered problems with valves operated by RVM0s at McGuire Nuclear Station.
Specifically, the problem involved RVM0s for which the factory-set torque settings had been changed at the plant site using a generic correlation between the octuator torque output and torque switch setting.
Rotork stated that whenever the factory torque switch setting is changed in the field, an individual calibration curve or a bench test is required to accurately determine torque output.
f' uke Power Company represent 1tives stated that during the construction phase cf a nuclear power plant, it is common practice to turn the torque selector switch (TSS) of a valve motor operator to minimum. After installation, prior to l
startup, the TSS is returned to the manufacturer's recommended setting.
Rotork I
stated that manipulating the TSS in the field may yield different torque values when returned to the f.actory preset position.
1 Minutes of the Meeting l
R. J.,Kiessel, IE (author of IN 06-93), W. T. Orders, SRI McGuire, and I attended the presentation.
Several members of Duke and Rotork participated in the presentation.
Luke stated that they performed tests on several RVM0s installed at McGuire 1 dnd 2, and determined that the torque value measured with the TSS set at position 5 (Max) was the same as the value indicated on the Rotork test certificate.
- However, the values measured with the TSS in positions 3 and 1 bN !u NO Nh l
99900839 PDR l
EilisW.Merschoff April 10, 1987 I
varied due to the variables in the actuator and test bench. Variables in the actuator included attributes such as the spring pack pre-load, torque selector setting, actuator speed and motor temperature. Test bench variables included attributes such as number of brake pads used, loading rate, and equipment cali-I bration.
Duke outlined the program direction consisting of the short term evaluations, a five year M0V upgrade program, preventative maintenance program, and continu-ing MOV research program. A handout, titled " Valve and Valve Operator Improvenent Program," outlining Duke's program is enclosed O
k-K. R. Naidu Reactive Inspection Section Vendor Program Branch DOAVT/01E b
Enclosure:
As stated y
Ellis W. Merschoff April 10, 1987 varied due to the variables in the actuator and test bench. Variables in the actuator included attributes such as the spring pack pre-load, torque selector setting, actuator speed and motor temperature. Test bench variables" included attributes such as number of brake pads used, loading rate, and equipment cali-bration.
Duke outlined the program direction consisting of the short term evaluations, a five year MOV upgrade program, preventative maintenance program, and continu-ing MOV research program. A handout, titled " Valve and Valve Operator Irrprovement Program," outlining Duke's program is enclosed
\\sI K. R. Naidu Reactiwe Inspection Section Vendor Program Branch 00AVT/01E DISTRIBUTION:
RIDS Code IE:09 i t VPB Reading 00AVT Reading JTaylor BGrimes HMiller EBaker KNaidu RJKiessell, IE WT0rders, SRI, McGuire, RII GASchnebli, RII i
\\
- See previous page for concurrences.
VPB:00AVT ASC/VPB:00AVT ABC/VPB:DOAVT l
KNaidu:tt*
EBaker*
EMerschoff*
l 4/8/87 4/8/87 4/9/87
Ellis U. Merschoff April 10,1987 varied due to the variables in the actuator and test bench. Variables in the actuator included attributes such as the sprinn pack pre-load, torque selector setting, actuator speed and motor temperature. Test bench variables included attributes such as number of brake pads used, loading rate, and equipment cali-bration.
Duke outlined the program direction consisting of the short term evaluations, a five year MOV upgrade program, preventative maintenance program, and continu-ing M0V research program. A handout, titled " Valve and Valve Operator Improvement Program " outlinino Duke's program is enclosed
\\sI K. R. Naidu Reactive Inspection Section Vendor Progran Branch DOAVT/01E DISTRIBUTION:
RIDS Code IE:09 VPB Reading D0AVT Reading JTaylor BGrimes j
HMiller EBaker KNaidu RJKiessell, IE WT0rders, SRI, McGuire, RII GASchnebli, RII l
l l
l
- See previous page for concurrences.
l VPB:D0AVT ASC/VPB:00AVT ABC/VPB:DOAVT l
KNaidu:tt*
EBaker*
EMerschoff*
l 4/8/87 4/8/87 4/9/87 i
l l
1 1
s DUKE POWER COMPANY s
A p
W I
l
'[m$M).
- T y
gy I
/
.C i
VALVE AND VALVE OPERATOR IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM
..e e i., w PRESENTATION ON ROTORK ACTUATORS AGENDA INTRODUCTION - DON GABRIEL I. BACKGROUND INFORMATION - DON GABRIEL II. OPERABILITY VERIFICATION - TERRY EDWARDS III. ACTUATOR TEST BENCHES - TIM CLINE IV PROGRAM DIRECTION - NEAL ESTEP V. TECHNICAL QUESTIONS - ALL i
6
U
, r4 e
e 1.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION A.
METHODS FOR INITIAL SETTING OF TORQUE SWITCHES B.
METHODS FOR POST-MAINTENANCE CERTIFICATION C.
DATA VARIATIONS IN TORQUE VALUES
/e : ecic.
/S u /E7!
- % l+f6 S'" / #
A
i.
,,. l
, f.;,,
c'a +i i > <. 7, a,
.t r
- ,,e
/
.s.~,
[e /kl.*y*
/ f(v
- ,, k Ccs -n L ll im G.
^
j }(y - pe u..L
"~"
- l. 2.ui.1%p t' U'
's-
/ <- % '. *y
- g.,,, 7 I"
~ ~'
- Q,;.
pea.J
~
i n. r. f t.
~ a r.
e i
l
^
l i
DHG!n3:05:R7tA3
E o>
11NA1 29 RPt; e
=.
2Wm_
O NT==
Q T
z
-~
_=.-
pA" r_
.nFG--.. -
rmW-W>-
--Vm aw
-A'
.-M----2 'J' fa- _M...--
f W
1-
-.W
-a--a'-
-,V
-.-Aw.
kW M
--A 5
-A,r-V-.
M A
qA
-.------>, -- =
r--
r-J--
-4---
4&w-- -,-
1
--/-
Mf sanc--_c
-^
Torque V-far/- - B, s,'.
s 1
- e
-""Mzf-M' ":-
- -~
n.
g;
"/
-f i"
', {
r-
\\
,.5 l )*
A
-- r m
-1.
a
+ - -
1
- 2. s,
, 1 l
+-
1> -
e 1
- _ *U:
+,,1,-
r
- e
,--J p_.
g,'
p p
- i r
. V.,.,,.
w,
-s l ;;a
\\ v
- r. -.
~.-
\\
s
-K.-
1 4,
i
[
2 s
v u-_-__,_
. __u-
____ _ _.t.._ _ __
..-.___.__....a_.__
.w.._._
Torque Switch Settings i=1 n_=
.. ___. p._.._. :
..L__..__....
I__.......
^M.*gm e.1
............e....-e..
.4.-...
.__...e...
. i
^ -
O
__ ^
^
-N 4
- --4.-*+_---
e....ie...
....A.
e.e...
I..
_._.4_.....
_4 i h --.e, f
......l_.......J
_-4......_..
+----
r
.a t
p m
E a
c i
f y
i b
d d
e e
t s
c i
lo f
h e
t C
C
/
P p
b sn l
i t
sc T
z k
p H
c m
lco a
itn te a
/
y a
k b
D n
c e
o d
p O
lc le t
V ip f
t
/
n m
b e
o I
r C
r uc n
s u
r no th is t
ig s
u n
l r
p e
o x
m o
e la t
r t
ls a
u i
b n
t
_f o
d g
r r
s n
e ia i
o f
y a
i e
a p
o a
e n
t t
d t
e n
w g
o e
s t
t o
y d
y it s
p n
ls e
d e
e it r
t u
c e
e o
s y
g e
n b
e i
e e
/
ia e
a e
b b
e v
v e
t c
e t
g a
c k
a r
d p
t e
e b
p la n
f t
n n
u e
a d
s e
d r
e s
n ls ls s
a le e
e u
a a
a n
q s
l t
d id a
t t
i e
e e
e b
s ia ic c
t e
r h
l l
l o
m i
u r
n o
n e
t r
t r
o e
o c
l l
c n
l e
u p
a b
v v
v r
a e
c t
u v
e r
o id t
f q
t e
o e
a s
e o
ig a
fa r
s c
p n
o c
i a
i i
o tu g
e e
s u
f n
h x
p r
t r
s e
y i
s n
r r
a p
p i
o le P
C L
M S
T T
I S
T F
B A
I F
C D
D C
S T
S S
M o
e n
n t
is lc o
d m
n E
M r,
h o
t P
oR kcolc itn a
z
/
H
)
k o
c it r
e lo a
d c
o e
k G
i t
s p
c t
/
e a
a r
h W
r r
o r
d o
t c
(
a e
t a
r d
s e
h a
u e
to e
e g
s u
p e
t t
/
a c
y o
p lo l
c A
T M
S P
W F
A V
m d
a e
r r
n o
ia ia is g
v t
d b
r o
e t.
o p
t e
u u
s d
la a
n t
e t
k a
v d
it e
o c
d r
t r
e e
e e
o c
h h
te ra ta pe
- f.,
c s
e e
k t
la m
g c
u s
y p
P n
n s
ip s
e t
o i
o a
s h
o a
i n
e c
iu it i
o lo ts n
k f
c t
t t
r a
c it a
y y
d e
it c
t u
e y
v a
o lc la r
w a
a d
e f
r b
b o
h a
t o
r a
a i
t t
c n
ic p
r e
e ta t
n ic s
a c
l c
lo 1
2 m
D o
i m
la h
iw d
n e
n p
a ts r
o le r
t n
o s
o h
e te o
g c
a o.
e e
c r
a c
rc n
m o
ic o
i n
c t
e t
f a
t s
it t
N s
c d
e r
r r
o ro e
ic r
o n
t iu P.
P.
ts to
/
a p
h n
S k
e e
t u
c s
a r
t c
c n o O.
O.
u
/
e u
i a
s le s
e r
u s
b le i C A
A C
M W
M S
T I
M L
L T,
D H
i C
O r
n u
o E
C C
J
k"ga9 [
o p
0 m
ht 2
c f
y G
b N
I t
d D b_ p g_
S e
5 e
4 s
O.
t
\\
ce 2
t p
4 C
s e
W Mb gg i
/
3 n
g t
f/
/0 lb s
4 g
d
\\
f I
b 6
k g@
p m
\\
Ngg g
a 1
G N
g y
I t
3 b_ f g
N e
ic b
g it d
E s
\\
a l Q g
a P
n e
t g 4 a
O
/
i Q [
D ft 6 g g
lc e
C k
p g
/
c m
I G_bkN p gg O
o tn o
s b
r g
ru c
n E
s u
2 n
l o
3 E
is t
n s
u N
r e
ls I
to tp O
a u
im r
o d
e la T
r ia I
9 n
t s S4 te N
o e
y ia D
p o
a n
e f
s D
n w
g o
te d
g s
e t
ls s
t O
e t
r US g
a lo y
d it u
s A
y n
c e
e e
p i
b e
n e
o e
g ic a
e ir e
C s
B e
g v
v e
/
c a
k t
p t
e e
b f
a t
e a
d ts e
d r
n n
P a
p l
n
.a S
r s
n e
e u
a u
lt d
n o
n e
ls ls t
h l
l la e
i a
ta i
e r
m R
O u
V c
n la y
e o
t d
s ic ia l
a a
e r
l e
e e
b c
c r
e o
e e
u la b
v v
v e
e 4
o t
l q
u h
p c
p t
2 r
s n
n p
p is f
r t
s r
la s
e y
i o
c i
a i
i o
tu G
o le e
ig t
T T
I S
T F
D A
F C
D D
C S
S S
M r
r o
e n
4 P
L S
d 1
lc o
n i
Y M
E N
l l
tI h
c P
h
(
b co
_ n h
O y,
d V
3
/ 4 R
M g
D 9
T' g g y g/
Q
- k. M 9g / /
g g C
g g
{
ag g,
k z
\\
)
H o
o it
- N c
g a
d g
lo R
r e
k G
io e
c c
p j
g o
h W
ta a
/
t r
e s
r r
M d
o c
r
(
u a
r d
a e
ta s
e h
t r
o e
u A
T o
p le g
s tc c
y t
e
/
a o
l M
S P
W F
A V
,g d
m 9
{f, e
a n
r o
r ia g
i lb
)
s R
ia t
q3 e
g g, /
v b
r d
o e
a g
g g g
p c
o e
u h
t u
k t
s p
d la a
g g n,
p e
t v
k a
d a
e te r
c g
h f
3 d
te r
ta p
oi e
c i
e r
a
(
h o
e n
h M
ity l
io o
a c
m e
e k
sa p
g c
tc io in u
s t
p s
e c
f k
t s
lt ir a
c ita c
u n
s h
e 9
e n
it o
a ta y
y p
E t
u e
y o
lia a
r s
a v
n t
l f
r o
b b
s c.
h it c
to le s
te ta s
o ic m3 l
c 1
2 o
p io t
c la w
a a
d e
n o
r t
c n
ic e
n c
i r
n r
r r
t e
e a
e h
t e
tc a
is o
n e
r t
m D
o ic o
ita n
e it d
e r
c c
g d
.o ic lo P.
o r
a s
m u
P N
ic r
lu c
w d
n e
n p
a f
h it s
r i
r c
to n
t c
n o
e t
t to
/
a p
h
/
e
'u i
a s
l O
t s
S k
e e
a r
e u
c O.
O.
u s
e s
su
.b le i
o r
r n
C C
J E
C C
A A
C M
W M
S T
in M
L L
T D
H i
(
o
- g
Rotork Contrds Inc.
'Otorit n'estT*#L24 Nucioar Tost Cortificato f@uttomer P.O.
Actuator Enclosure Date hoo No.
Type Model l
Performance Test l
Mit:r Details Motor. Check Condition Open Closed Light run LblFt Amp LblFt Amp h!!iS No.
Poles Torque setting 1 min E.ta%3 W/ gear ratio Torous setting 2 l@oecification Flashed at Torque setting 3 f?nermostat Trip RPM Torque setting 4 (Insulation class Torcue setting 5 max Stalled l
Toroue set at Test voltage V
Hz Ph
@lectrical Check 100 (Continuity checked to diag.
(Control circuit flashed at f A.O.P.1 pot. value obtained 80 l Cust. voltage V
Hz Pn k
a3 l
51 m E B Mechanical Check 4
of 40
$=$
USwitch Ratio 20 Leadscrew Turn Set At D ection of Act.
0 1
2 3
4 5
Torque Switch Setting leseected by Tested by Rig No.
Seccnd Stage Operators Final Inspnction Tyoe F a D:rection cf output Caole Entries D/S Retainer 5:'e aad Keyway Dimensions Cover Tube Drive Sleeve
- :tuator & Gearbox Stub snaf t! ped.
Tags
. ;. Fun Carrent Special Paint Special Labels Miscelaneous C e: Red cy Checked by Final inspected by Outside Inspection Approved by s
CC1 Rev I
II.
OPERABILITY VERIFICATION A.
TORQUE SWITCH LINEARITY f
B.
EVALUATE SIGNIFICANCE OF FINDINGS C.
SHORT TERM CORRECTIVE ACTION EVALUATION
)
i
. DHG:03:05:87. :.A3-.-.-
.I WORST CASE TOROUE CURVE im
/
,b
?O -
f
/
e-th 7o -
o O
h3 60 -
a 2
3_
8 3
/
x ao -
gn -
10 i
i i
=
I 2
3 4
TCF.QUE SfilTCM SE1TtlGS
+
WCft3T o
LtJEAtt
't > " 1 (c. f (t
Sheet 1 McGuire Nuclear Station r
Unit 1
/s. # / 3 Rotork EMD Evaluation 1
I. Valves Which are Acceptable "As Is" - These valves will require no action with the exception of torque switch setting verification.
A.
Valves set on Max. Torque - No change required based on the operators being set to provide maximum output at the "5" setting which due to gg sample testing, are considered, with a high level of confidence, to be operable.
B.
Operability Statement - Valve is expected to perform it's safety 25 ;
function based on analysis of system and valve conditions during a postulated accident.
C.
Valves Set on Less Than Max. Toraue - The revised expected torque output including the worst case Rotork torque curve value deviation 4s j) 1 areater than the required torque under maximum aP system conditions.
-d f
D.
Non-Safety - Valves which were deleted because they do not receive 1E power and have no safety function.
/3 E.
Power Removed - Valves which will be placed in their safety position and power removed until the next outage, i
II. Valves Which Require Torque Switch Channes - The revised expected torque l
output including the worst case Rotork torque curve value deviation is less J4 l
than the required torque under maximum aP system conditions.
III. Valves Which Reauire Testine - These valves have limitations on maximum applied torque ana require testing to verify they meet the required torque for operation.
iC #*I A.
Bench Test - The operator is set to a specific torque value on the test bench.
B.
AP Test - Valve / operator combination tested in the system under j;
maximum system aP conditions which the valve will experience in the accident condition.
1 C.
Strain Gace Test - Valve operator performance is verified in place by the use of strain gauges.
IV. Total Unit i Valve Population Evaluation -
A.
This item is the total valve population evaluated by Design Engineer-in.q which is the total for parts I, II and III above.
, ;f f,.
7' e
y
III. ACTUATOR TEST BENCHES A.
GENERAL THEORY OF OPERATION B.
TEST BENCH TOLERANCES C.
TEST BENCH TOLERANCE INVESTIGATION lciLl;,IG"'k'
).' t Io ?
g,,
,,, j,, a & a V
I.. b b f 8 H '[
//
,.4 iei
%... u..cdaR ##"1
,.7, s..rr. :ja>J i. - [ t * *
- b_"-
,.;, 7 ;
- j..?., i lic
,. < r p.. e j-
.s,. y,.i.<,,ar1
\\
.i < ;j :1 < R 2 s,4.
D h..
- i...
- m.., n w J.~..
{, / i. ^$ f '
(
t.... j.m. v.
.n,/
s DHG:03:05:87:A3
000 0 TEST NO./.[q3.7 TORQUE SCALE: 8.3 cv/ft-lb tv 1070 ft-lb/of.7 THD SCALE: 10 v/ inch v / /s inches 01/1 CURRENT SCALE: 100 m:v/ amp cv 2 39.0 ccpn 2.3T 14NAl-43 B4058F1 (TS. TO. TMD, CUR)
V/0 1.000e1 Vy -3.4400000e1 T/0 2.500e0 TL.-l.8000e1 7
V/0 5.000e-1 Vy -4.920000e-1 Aa.
T/0 2.500e0
',r.,f.
,~.e TL -1.8000e1 e-Vy
'* ~ ~,...
V/D 2.500e-1 Vy 7.805000e-1,
T/0 2.500e0 TL -1.8000e1 i,
_. M V/0 1.000e0 i
- - -- ; = m.z : : =. :
w >.'* * ' " '
i Vy 3.000000e-1
^
- m. ;;a..;;.,== -;;
" ~
T/0 2.500e0 TL -1.8000e1 i
b i
f f
I I
t TL
' ' " ' " " ~ ' " " ' ' " ^ ~ " ' " ' -?L-3 "F
VX TORQUE SWITCli SETTING q"
tilHi t i!UN Ol'E N CLOSED PEAK HOLD IlEADING
- 2 O FT-LBS I
No. OF liRAKES t/
DISK NO./ LOCATION P //y l
l
IV.
PROGRAM DIRE *; TION A.
M0V UPGRADE PROGRAM - 5 YEAR PLAN i
B.
PREVENTATIVE MAINTENANCE PROGRAM C.
M0V RESEARCH 3
1 l
l l
4 1
a SYYEW5hb&fDbAB
V.
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS l
l DHG:03:05:87:A3