ML20215D939
| ML20215D939 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 06/15/1987 |
| From: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| References | |
| CON-#287-3845 OLA, NUDOCS 8706190194 | |
| Download: ML20215D939 (250) | |
Text
.
9 OYG NA_
r UN11ED STATES
"'l NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF: DOCKET NO: ~ '50-275-OLA-
- 5 0-3 2 3 -OLA PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power
' Plant, Units 1 and 2) t j
(h. .
LOCATION: AVILA BEACH, CALIFORNIA PAGES: 1 - 113 DATE: MONDAY, JUNE 15, 1987
/ ,b
/
ACE-FEDERAL REPORTERS, INC. '
Official Reporters 444 North Capitol Street Washington, D.C. 20001 8706190194 PDR e70615 (202) 347-3700 ADOCK 05000275 NATIONWIDE COVERACE
t
._ )( . .
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA '
'2 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION' 3
Iri the ' Ma tter of )
4
)
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY ) DOCKET NOS. 50-275-OLA 5 ) 50-323-OLA (Diablo Canyon, Nuclear Power )-
6 Plant, Units 1 and 2)~ ) -(Volume I) 7 -San Luis. Bay Inn, Avila Beach , California 8
Monday,
'9 June 15, 1987.
10 The a b o ve - e n title d matter came- on for; 11 ' hearing, pursuant to notice, at 3:00 o' clock p.m.
12 BEFORE:
C hie f Adm nistrative Law Judge 14 GLENN O. BRIGHT, Administrative Judge JERRY HARBOUR, Ph. D., Administrative Judge 15 APPEARANCES:
16 On behalf of the NRC Staff:
17 L AWRENCE J. CHANDLER, Esq. l 18 BENJAMIN VOGLER, Esq. ]
19 On behalf of the Applicant:
Pacific Gas and Electric Company:
20 BRUCE NORTON, Esq., and i 21 RICHARD F. LOCKE, Esq.
22 23 ACE-FEDERAL REPORTERS, INC.
24 '444. North Capitol Street, Suite 402 Washington, D. C. 20001
~25 (202) 347-3700
[ 2 1
APPEARANCES (Continued) f'~)'$
'x 2 On behalf of the Petitioner: Sierra Club 3 EDWIN F. LOWRY, Esq. .
Grueneich & Lowry ;
4 380 Hayes Street, Suite Four ;
San Francisco, California 94102 5
6 7
8 l
10 11 12 13 i
V) - 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 l
25
(~h v
3A c,
y
- i. )
2 1E"*3 STATEMENT OF: PAGE Kenneth IIaggart 5 I 4
Marian Wolfe 7 5
Polly Cooper 9 Elpidio Rocha lo 7
Willard Jones 11 Lisa Bunkowski 13 9
Nancy Culver 14 Lois Barber 17 Steve Berg 18 Craig Meagher 19 13
- f. S *
(,) George Leone . 21 Jane Wiley 22 Wendy Brown 23 John Beccia 24 ay n 28 18 Lars llansson 29 9
Arlene Chandler 34 20 g Willow Moon 35 Rochelle Becker 3G y, June Von Ruden 37 l' Sylvia Reichman 39 24 25 Sheila Wynne 41 t'%
()
< 3B I
STATEMENT OF: -PAGE 2
Elaine Holder '42 I
' Ann Morgan. 44 4-Mercelle Martin- 46 5 George Eastham 47 6
Ray Renick 48 Carol Scott 49 l
8 Sue:Sunderland 50-
.Gail Jacobson 52.
10 June'Swanson 54 i II
' Sandra Miller' 55 12 Ralph Vrana 50 II Gudrun Grell 57
(' ..
14 Michael Yoshimura 58 15 Mary-Joyce Yoshimura 58 16 Theo Coleman 59 i II Eve Eden 61.
I8 Maria Stanley 02A I'
Laurie McDermott 64 0
Jim McDermott 65 i
' Tresa Des Hotel 68 Docug Rosener 69 Josephine Crawford' 70 24 Carla Sanders 71 25 Roberta Foster 71
<O
3e ,
)' ' STATEMENT OF: PAGE Jane Pearce 72 Mary Duenow 73 4
Madeleine Steele 74 5
Doris-Murray 75 6
. Nelson Sullivan 77 7=
Shirley Bianchi 78
' Betty Schetzer 81 ,
' Anna Alexander 83 10 Christine Collie 84 I
II Jacquie Earp-Thomas 80 12 Sherry Ilayden 86 '
II Steve Paige 87 ,
~
14 Marcia'McGee 92 15 Thomas Schumann 92 I0 Frank Bush- 94
' Jeanne Girolo 98 18 Lynne Landwehr 99 ;
Franklin Wakefield 100 Melanie !!arpe 102 Pat' Renshaw 104 22 Amy Shore 105 Dianne Randazzo 108 24 Evelyn Delaney 109 25 Kathleen Hil. ton 110 0
3D cs y
~/
i STATEMENf OF: PAGE l 2
Colin Moulton 111 3 - l 4
5 6
7 8
9 10 11 12 ,
13 p-V 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 r~~N N ,) -
a 4
1 P_ R_ O C_ E_ E D_ I,N_ G S_
(T -2 3:16 p.m.
%)
3 JUDGE COTTER: Will the proceeding come to 4 order, please.
5 This is a session'to take limited appearance
~6 statements under Part II of th'e Rules of Procedure of the 7 Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
i 8 I suppose I should begin by apologizing for 9 holding you all up. But, unfortunately, we had plane delays ,
10- and, as you can see, just arrived.
11 My name is B. Paul Cotter, Jr. I mm the 12 Chairman of the Board. To my right is Judge Glenn Bright 13 and to my left is Judge Jerry Harbour.
q{ )
14 I note, with introducing them all, that the 15 counsel for the Applicant, Pacific Gas and Electric, is here.
- 16. The counsel for the Sierra Club is here. And counsel for 17 the NRC staff is here.
18 We only have three hours assigned at th'is point 19 to take limited appearance statements. So in the interest i
20 of time and in the interest of hearing as many people as 21 possible, we are going to limit the statements to five 22 minutes each. I would appreciate your holding to those so 23 that as many of your fellow citizens have an opportunity to i l
24 speak as possible.
(~)
s-t 25 With that introduction -- I guess I should also j j
5 1 mention that a representative from Region V, Graham Cook
(} 2 (phonetic) is here. And we have brought with us our law 3 clerk, John Agee.
4' With that brief introduction, let us begin.
5 promptly. I have a list of names here and they were taken in 6 the order in which they signed up. So we will begin with Mr. l
{
7 Kenneth Haggart. I I
8_ Mr. Haggart? j 9 STATEMENT OF KENNETH HAGGART f j
1 10 MR. HAGGART: Thank you.
l 11 I am Kenneth Haggart. I am president of CODES, 12 a local environmental safety organization of about 400
- 13. members. I am here to speak in opposition to the proposed !
14 method of radioactive waste storage.
15 The proposal being discussed, as we see it, is 16 the result of a series of policies of putting the cart before 17 the horse to produce a fait accompli on the unwilling public.
18 This general level of policy started with the 19 development of nuclear power before developing federal waste j i
a 20 storage facilities. Therefore, when waste storage becomes 21 politically difficult, it forces storage at the plants.
22 Secondly, more specifically, Diablo Canyon was 23 constructed before a thorough seismic study was done in the 24 area, therefore forcing a policy that we can't stop because (Q
v 25 we've got too much money in it, in spite of the dangers
6 1 involved.
{} 2 And, third, even more specifically, Diablo's 3 growing waste is produced and storage occurs on site, as a 4 result of Policy No. 1 and No. 2.
5 And then most significantly, it is proposed to 6 store the waste in a close packing as in existing storage 7 ponds to make the stcrage easy and the least expensive to g PGandE. That's in spite of the fact that the ponds were 9 designed for one-fifth as much storage and in spite of the 10 fact that studies that have come out in the past week show 11 that a potential accident from close stacking storage in 12 . ponds could'be twice as bad as the core melt which occurred 13 at the outset at Chernobyl.
[}
14 In spite of the fact that no containment 15 exists in the fuel ponds, in spite of the fact that the 16 Iranians announced last week that if we hit their missiles 17 in the Persian Gulf, then they would attack our nuclear power 18 plants which are easier to get to than their missiles. And 19 those of us who live here locally realize that because of 20 the different demonstrations we've been over there.
21 Well, my proposal is, it is time for this cart 22 before the horse policy to stop. And the Federal Waste Policy 23 Act says local concerns have to be addressed in this g- 24 particular issue. I think many people from this area are
()
25 here to say that this is it. i l
a.
7 1 1
1 .This particular plan for-waste storage is not
~
/~T 2 . acceptable and we are no longer willing to accept the cart (4 1 3 before the horse policy of forcing the local public to take 4 greater and greater risks.
5 Thank you.
I 6 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you, Mr. Haggart.
7 The second speaker is Marian Wolfe.
8- STATEMENT OF MARIAN WOLFE 9' MS. WOLFE: I'm Marian Wolfe. My family of j
-10 five was unanimous in emphatically opposing' the proposed 11' expansion plan.
l
~
12 Way back in 1981, the nuclear industry itself.
.( y 13 jokingly admitted that it suffered from nuclear constipation.
14 Now six years later, this community is expected to bear the 15 consequences of that industry's lack of vision, its 16 incompetence.and its failure to heed the warnings of its own i
17 staff reports.
18 You as members of the Nuclear Regulatory 19 Commission have a mandate to listen to us and above all, to i
20 protect us . 1 21 PGand E is sure that its racks are safe and 22 that there will be no accidents. The Russian Airflot planes
]
23 used to not have emergency instructions on board because --
24 quotes -- they never had accidents.
I')
s_-
4 25 The people around Chernobyl must have felt )
8 l' assured that they were safe. The U.S.S. STARK crew must have
)
2- thought that they were safe. The West German sailors injured 3 during the Warsaw Paci Naval exercises this very morning must !
4 also have thought that they were safe' .
5 Mechanical and human errors around us abound 6 all around us. .And yet we are supposed to trust PG and E 7 when they tell us that increasing nuclear waste storage, 500 g percent is not a threat to us.
9 I respectfully, but most fervently, ask that 10 ' you fulfill your mandate, that you listen to us, be objective 11 and base your decision as to whether'or not to allow PG and E' s-12 - proposed expansion upon the criterion of how this could and 13 surely would pose a threat to the health and lives of the 14 people on the central coast.
15 Thank you.
16 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you, Mrs. Wolfe.
17 (Applause.)
d '
18 JUDGE COTTER: Let me ask if you would please 19- not to respond in that fashion because it simply takes time 20 and might slow down allowing more people to speak.
1 21 VOICE: It's important, it's part of our j 22 ' freedom of speech. THat is very important.
23 JUDGE COTTER: No, it just means that more f- 24 aren't going to get an opportunity to speak.
' 1 25- When you come up to make a statement, would
9 1 .you spell your name for the record, please. Next, I have
~N 2 Polly Cooper.
\_)
3 STATEMENT OF POLLY COOPER 1 4 MS. COOPER: My name is Polly Cooper, P-O-L-L-Y,
]
r 5 C-O-O-P-E-R. I'm a local resident, local architect and a 6 local professor.
7 As you are well aware, the Federal Waste Policy 8 Act requires that waste storage proposals be consistent with 9 the views of the surrounding residents.
10' I am a resident of this county and I'm very 11 interested in the safety of the people of this county. I want 12 concrete and documented assurance that all alternatives for r^3 13 temporary or even longer term storage of spent fuel is s_/
14 thoroughly studied, and that the safest alternative has been 15 chosen for use.
16 Up to now, it certainly appears that PG and E 17 has left this critical question up to partisan attention by 18 the rack manufacturers. I don't trust the judgment of these 19 sales people to protect the public's best interest.
20 Ignorance of the importance of the Brookhaven 21 study alone is grounds for questioning the r;afety of their 22 dense packing scheme. It is imperative that a thorough study 23 of all the possible alternatives for waste storage be made.
24 These alternatives must be evaluated with the )
25 special earthquake hazard as a strong deterrent. The choice L -
l
)
10 1 of the alternative which is the safest possible is the only I. ~ 2' acceptable one.
3- For this process to be believable to the public, 4 I strongly urge that the utility seek the cooperation of 5 informed citizens of this county in their future study of 6 this issue.
7 Thank you.
8 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you.
9 (Applause.)
10 JUDGE COTTER: Elpidio Rocha.
11 STATEMENT OF ELPIDIO ROCHA 12 MR. ROCHA: My name is Elpidio, E-L-P-I-D-I-0, p 13 Rocha, R-O-C-H-A. I'm here as a father of a four year old 4
14 daughter and my wife. I just moved to Morro Bay.
15 I happened to be here about 15 years ago when 16 I was a professor of architecture at Cal-Poly. I also happen 17 to be a structural engineer. But I resigned after nine 18 months. In part, I wanted to join the United Farm Workers 19 in the valley because of what was happening to them. And I 20' wanted in some way.to contribute through my information, my 21 knowledge,.my education, and to resist the destruction of the 22 lives of these farm workers, as well as the environment.
23 Here I am 15 years later, not with farm workers i
24 who are not educated, but a roomful of white middle-class t O .
25 -Americans who I must assume are very well educated. I am not !
I
l
! 'll I concerned about this too much. I think we are going to
-Q .2 survive okay if we stop certain neurotic' kinds of things that AJ. .
3 we are doing.
4 But what I' wanted to say is, to make this point, 5 that I don't think we are. dealing with legal issues. We are -
6- not dealing with things within that map. :I think we have I
7 gone beyond that -- beyond the map into the territory. We g' are dealing with moral issues.
9 I believe and encourage that all options be 10- examined.- I believe what PG and E is advancing is not an !
11 . option. So I encourage the Board to make a decision-in favor 12- of studying options as proposed - advanced by Professor 13 Ferguson, and ou'r local Sierra Club group.
14 Thank you. ;
15 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you.
16 (Applause.)
17 JUDGE COTTER: Willard Jones. .
18 STATEMENT OF WILLARD JONES 19 MR. JONES: I don't know if these microphones
]
I'd get down on my l 20 are made for someone six-foot or not.
21 knees but you might think I was praying. !
22- (Laughter.) 3 23 JUDGE COTTER: You don't have to adjust the j I
24 mike. )
O. MR. JONES: Thank you very much. I am Willard 1
25
12-1; Jones. I am. representing myself, my wife Elizabeth,.and'my 2 family, although_I know there-are several thousands ~that are 3 most' interested in what happens on this occasion in Santa 4 Barbara.
5 We're from the downwind count'ry and we'have-6 problems with winds coming in to. Santa Barbara. And we. stress
-7 today that there is still no adequate evacuation plan: for the -
i' s' entire south coast.
9 Because we are downwind, just as the Scandi-10- navian countries were downwind from Chernobyl, we are the 11 normal recipients of air-blowing matter generating at Diablo.
12 our city.of Santa Barbara is' located in a basin similar to' 13 Los' Angeles, the ocean on one side and the encircling y (( m -
14- ' mountains on - the other, i 15 Any fallout, therefore, settles in over our 16 city. There are only two exits in and out of the city 17 other than by water -- the_ ocean. . So any blockage.of roads -q 18 for any reason would be catastrophic.
19 After this, the potential disastrous effects 1 l
20 of polluted water supplies are obviously cause 'for deep 21 concern. Today, we urge you to reject PG and E's plan to 22 store radioactive waste in an inadequate and overcapacity 23 manner which-courts disaster.
24 When the original planned capacity for storage j k)-
25 is reached at Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant, it should be
13 1
l~ shut'down. j i
(j 2 (Applause.)
3 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you.
4 A VOICE: Excuse me, why are these hearings ~
5 .always held in facilities inadequate to accommodate the people 6 who want to come and participate?
7 (Applause.)
8 JUDGE COTTER: Is it Lisa Berkowski? i 9 STATEMENT OF LISA BUNKOWSKI 10 MS. BUNKOWSKI: Bunkowski, B-U-N-K-O-W-S-K-I.
11 I am a public school teacher, and my school was recently 12 chosen for the honor of Distinguished Middle School. There's r3 13 less than 150 in the United States, 11 in California. We are V
14 very resourceful. We have excellent. scores in academics, 15 student programs, community service.
16 And yet, I speak for myself, we have not 17 figured out a way, a workable way, to evacuate our children
.18 if there was an accident. At the same time, we spend much {
19 time in educating our children and community members on 20 earthquake safety.
21 As you know, the Hosgri fault is three miles 22 offshore here. I cannot rationalize under any circumstances 23 storing nuclear waste in an earthquake zone. I don't know if 1 j
24 you have ever heard them call the Columbia River in Washington O.
25 the.most radioactive river in the world due to the waste
14 ;
I 1 facility site there which isn't even in an earthquake zone.
,Au 2 And yet in Morro Bay here, which houses vast 3 amounts of wildlife and fish, is back-to-back with the j 1
I 4 . proposed area.
5 I am just going to end this by telling you a 6 little story. I just finished giving my eighth graders their 7 final project, which was to design a community. And prior 8 to this we had studied the pros and cons of all the energy 9 sources.
10 The only stipulation was that they did not 11 pollute the environment in which they lived. And not one of 12 them chose nuclear power or coal.
A 13 Thank you.
U
_14 (Applause.)
l 15 JUDGE COTTER: Nancy Culver?
16 STATEMENT OF NANCY CULVER 17- MS. CULVER: My name is Nancy Culver, C-U-L-V-E-F .
18 I am here today to represent myself, my husband and my 10 year
.19 old daughter.
20 I am here to tell you that PG and E's quick-21 fiX Plan for Diablo Canyon's nuclear waste is unacceptable to 22 me and to my family. We want to be counted among the voices 23 that will tell you today that enough is enough.
p 24 For 20 years, the Atomic Energy Ccmmission and
, V 25 then the Nuclear Regulatory Commission have treated the public
15 1 of. central California with complete' contempt, grudgingly 9 . ~
- {} 2 going through the motions of public hearings and then leaving 3 town'and doing just exactly what they had intended to do 4 before the hearing took place.
5 But today, the law requires that you listen to 6 the public and to act as we would have you act. You didn't i
7 care that we didn't want two reestors next to an active 8 earthquake fault. It was okay with you that the plant was j I
9 built and rebuilt to less stringent standards than would be 10 required by the NRC in any other set of circumstances.
, 11 You didn't object when the Advisory Committee i 12 on Reactor Safeguards justified these lower standards by 13 explaining that the, area has a low population. You know that l {~)
14 the NRC Commissioners have admitted that no nuclear reactors 15 would have been allowed at Diablo Canyon if it had known of 16 the existence of the Hosgri fault before construction.
17 And yet, despite that position , the NRC has l 18 already approved almost a year ago the plan to add to this 19 same unacceptably dangerous site.a nuclear waste storage 20 facility.
21 The makeshift plans for waste storage include 1
22 free-standing racks subject to slamming into each'other and 23 -into the pool walls. It includes fuel assemblies clad in a
,e s 24 zirconium alloy that can ignite at fairly low temperatures,
(>
25 setting fire to an entire fuel pool and if combined with a ut . . .
, .o 16 T 1 loss of coolant from an earthquake, can cause a catastrophic f 2 meltdown of. fuel.
3 .It includes protective layers of boraflex to n 4 absorb. stray neutrons but which'we now learn is subject to 5 pinholes.
6 The disclosures continue to surface,: making it 7 painfully clear.that this plan is poorly thought out and g~ poorly examined.
9 But once the waste facility is in place,.it 10 would take an act of. God to undo what.is already.there, if 11 past NRC practice is any guide.
12 We are being asked to pay a stiff price-in:
$- 13 personal and environmental safety for the failure of the 14 Federal Government to develop a suitable permanent nuclear 15 waste storage facility. I am not entirely convinced that that.
16 is even possible after the 30-year search.
17 And that failure is likely to become permanent
-18 if the NRC can simply turn nuclear plants into nuclear waste 19 dumps. Making plant sites the-final resting place for large 20 ' quantities of high-level radioactive waste is no solution, 21 most especially nuclear plants as-unsuitable as Diablo Canyon.
22 Storing vast quantities of this material at 23 Diablo Canyon is an ill-conceived short-sighted plan that, ,
p 24 - once again, asks the people of California's central coast to i
+0 bear an' unreasonable burden in the name of keeping PG and E's 1
25
l-( 17 1 profits flowing.
We have'had quite enough nuclear facilities I(J ~5 2 3 rammed down our throats. How dare you ask us to learn to 1 )
4 live with a radioactive waste dump.
5 Thank you. -
4 6 (Applause.)
i '
7 JUDGE COTTER: Lois Barber?
( g STATEMENT OF LOIS BARBER l l
9 MS. BARBER: My name is Lois Barber, B-A-R-B-E-R .
-10 The first name is L-O-I-S. It-is an honor to follow you, )
L 11 thank you.
12 I am the president and owner of L & D Henrehan l l
(3 '13 (phonetic) incorporated in San Luis Obispo and I live in
\) l 14 Shell Beach, which is a few miles downwind of Diablo Canyon 15 nuclear power plant. !
l 16 When I purchased my property five years ago, 1
17 I did not believe that Diablo Canyon would ever open. I
'18 believed and I still believe that any five year old would see 19 the absurdity of building a nuclear power plant near an 20 earthquake f ault.
21 I strongly believe that Diablo Canyon is an 22- accident waiting to happen, even in its present state.
23 Apparently, the insurance industry feels the same way, as I L
24 cannot get insurance to cover my business or my house in case 25 of a nuclear accident.
l
18 i
- 3 'I believe that the issue of storage of five O
-Q 2 -times as much waste as the initial design accommodates should 3 not have been dignified by any consideration. The fact that {
l 4 this is seriously being considered is not surprising to me i
5 in view of the disregard that many of the NRC have had for 6 safety issues in the past.
l 7 I therefore strongly oppose storing additional 8 nuclear waste in the present pools. Doing so, in my view,.is 9 an additional invitation to disaster.
10 Thank you.
11 (Applause.)
.12 JUDGE COTTER: Steve Berg.
13 STATEMENT OF STEVE BERG 14 MR. BERG: I am a representative from another i
15 planet. We have been watching PG and E's Diablo Canyon i 16 fi'asco for a long while'now. 'It would be somewhere between 17 humorous and absurd, if not for the dangerous mentality that 18 seems inherent, that regardless of all opposition and logic 19 the badness of nuclear energy is pushed ever forward.
20 Your planet has no answers for the safe disposal 21 of nuclear waste products. And this particular plant is 22 neighbor to an earthquake faultline. You originally did not j 1
23 know the dangers of an earthquake here.-
(. 24 25 If the proposal to build Diablo were put forth today, there is no way' it would ever be considered. Because i
t l
19 1 of the astronomical' investment,lyou persist.in' pursuing'this ;
N 2- ' error. Please reconsider.
(V .
3 Say no to any PG and E waste storage expansion 4 '.at Diablo Canyon. .Perhaps start a trend that leads your
'S planet down a reversal'of its ssif-destructive road.
6 We seek no> interference in your internal'
- 7. affairs. We offer only a' suggestic::, It may result in the 8 temporary reversal of some ' corporate ar,d economic . concerns, 1 9 but it will contribute to.the longevity of your planet.
10 NoJto any new PG.and E w0ste' disposal plans at 11 Diablo Canyon.
12 We wish you. good luck.
13 (Applause.)
14 JUDGE COTTER: Craig --- Meagher?
15 STATEMENT OF CRAIG MEAGHER '
16 MR. MEAGHER: My name is Craig Meagher,
'17 C-R-A-I-G, M-E-A-G-H-E-R. I'm a representative of rural 18 Arroyo Grande. And I was formerly a plant employee at Diablo, 19 working for:a subcontractor.
20 And I can tell you first-hand that if it were up 21 to me, not only would your fuel pond licensing procedure not go 22 forward, but neither would the plant.
23 ' Based upon the current knowledge that we have 24 and the earthquake potential in this area, sighting this new l
25 project at Diablo Canyon is sheer folly.
20 1 . Another aspect to look at is the character and
(
[ 2 . competence of.many, if not all, the workers out there. .Some 3 had good intentions, some.were good workers. Many were not.
4 Many were there strictly for the money.- Subcontractors worked 5 under cost-plus contracts. What motivated them?.
6 PG and E feels that they.are on cost-plus with 7 the public. No matter what they put forward, they want to get l
8 paid for. What motivation does the.NRC have? Who knows.
.5L Recently, I built a housing project in Lompoc, i
10 California, and while there I employed a worker who was at 11 Vandenberg. The day that the shuttle blew up, I teased him 12 a little bit, saying, well, it looks like your company might~
r /~T 13 have been responsible for the terrible disaster with.the space V
14 shuttle.
15 He said, "Oh, no, that was Morton Thiakol."
16 At that point, he drew me a picture of the fault 0-rings.
17 Everybody on site knew what the problem was, they knew that 18 some day it was going to happen.
19 The same problems exist here. I have a five 20 year old that's in school, and I worry about what would happer 21 if there were to be an evacuation of the Diablo Canyon plant.
22- I did a little checking, and I found that the school district 23 here will send their children down to Allen Hancock, about f- 24 20 miles to the south, directly in line of the existing winds,
+v 25 At that point, the Red Cross takes over. So I l
]
'21 f 1 called the Red Cross and I said, can I have a copy of'your. ;
((};
x
~2 written plan should there be a disaster ' at' Diablo Canyon.
3 There is no written plan.
'l i 4 The lack of evacuation plan, combined with the 1 5 above factors, makes me feel that this expansion of the fuel f
6 ponds, should not be considered at all.
7 Thank you very much. :
i (Applause.)
8
- 9. JUDGE COTTER: George Leone? j 10 STATEMENT OF GEORGE LEONE 11 MR. LEONE: Hello, my name is George Leone, !
12 L-E-O-N-E. I'm opposed to an expansion also.
t{)
13 Many people before me have talked about the 14 problem of having an earthquake f ault, et cetera. But even 15 if we totally ignore that, the problem of human error is 16 something that will never go away. As long as we_have human .;
17 beings dealing with this, the potential for problem is 18 obviously there.
Everyone makes mistakes.
19 In the Soviet Union, a very large mistake was :
20 :recently made, as everyone is referring to here, Chernobyl.
21 But there have also been other mistakes here in the United !
22 States. Three Mile Island, we had a very serious reactor 23- problem there. j 24 The loss of core coolant water at the North 25 American Rockwell ractor at Santa Suzanna, California, in
22 1 1959. That also resulted in the loss of a plant, and about
'T 2 20 years to chop it up and get it away.
'LJ 3 Wherever that has been disposed of, perhaps 4 the NRC would consider disposing of materials produced at 5 Diablo Canyon.
6 It is not good for our environment. As a small 7 businessman I can tell you it is not good for business.
8 People are not going to be interested in investing in this 9 county. It isn't doing anything to help out the economy.
10 And is also uninsurable.
11 Thank you.
12 (Applause.)
s 13 JUDGE COTTER: Jane Wiley?
O 14 STATEMENT OF JANE WILEY 15 MS. WILEY: My name is Jane Wiley, W-I-L-E-Y.
16 Jane. I'm a farmer. And for your information, I want you 17 to know that this area grows a great deal of food for the 18 rest of -- not only the state, but many parts of the country.
19 I represent myself, my family and my newest 1
20 grandchild. That's why I'm here. I happen to be a native-21 born Californian. We're kind of rare. And I have been ,
l 22 through a number of earthquakes, I want to tell you. And also j i
23 I have seen the results of many of those earthquakes.
24 And I want to tell you, believe me, earthquakes t7-) .
25 have devastating effects, unknown effects, unknowable effects, l 1
1
_.- 23 g,.; 1_ .that even the smartest rocket engineers; don't know-how to i* figure completely.
m a ,~s 3~ To add this waste. storage racking component I
g
,s 4 with it's unknown dire possibilities is too much to askthis.
, f ';(O o, se l !.f. 5 community.to bear, as to the safety of its children, its
. .6 adults,and even our property. We simply cannot afford f?h 1 % 7 Diablo.
8 We'cannot afford its newest problem. The luck
'9 _ is running out. Let's quit -- let's call it quits before 10 it is too late.
11 Thank you,-gentlemen.
3 ;12 (Applause.);
r 13 JUDGE COTTER: Wendy 3rown? l 14 STATEMENT OF WENDY BROWN
,w x15 MS. BROWN: My name is Wendy Brown, W-E-N-D-Y, 3
1 16 B-R-0-W-N. I'm a certified public accountant. I am a member I s
)
h ' 17 of the Sierra Club. And I have been a resident of this 18 county for 27 years.
19 I feel that the only reason that PG and E has 20 had -to make the application to store .rme spent fuel rods ]
21 at the facility is that there is no federal waste disposal 22 facility. There is no federal facility because the safe site
.m
' 23 can't be found, and nobody wants it.
4 24 So why should we get a federal facility here by
,0, 25 default? If the federal government were to establish a site y
24 1 somwhere, it certainly wouldn't be here next to an earthquake f /3 '2 fault.
%)
3 Therefore, I am asking you to not allow the 4 storage plan as proposed by PG and E.
5 Thank you very much.
6 (Applause.)
7 JUDGE COTTER: John Beccia.
8 STATEMENT OF JOHN BECCIA 9 MR. BECCIA: Hi. J -O-H-N , B-E-C-C-I-A . I'm a 10 12-year resident of San Luis Obispo County. I'm a school 11 teacher, so I'm not being paid to be here. But I'm here 12 because of my convictions about Diablo Canyon.
, (~') 13 I've been an outspoken active opponent of'
(-
14 nuclear power since the late seventies. After much research 15 and reading about the subject. I've been arrested at the 16 plant five times, to make the strongest statement I can make 17 against the plant.
18 Although there are many disagreements about 19 the nuclear power issue, the one thing that both opponents 20 and proponents agree upon is that the storage of waste is 21 a major problem that must be dealt with, i L I personally feel it has been irresponsible 22 23 to produce this waste before a storage solution has been 24 found. We can't go backwards, we can't make Diablo Canyon 25 disappear -- although that is what I would do if I had the l
I
25 1 power to do so.
2 So now I am here to give input about a storage f) 3 method that will increase the fuel pond capacity to store 4 waste by five times more than it was originally designed for 5 on racks that are not bolted down and thus susceptible to 6 sliding if an earthquake should occur. I 7 In an area that has active earthquake faults, 8 some which may run right below the reactor itself. Such an 9 absurd proposition deserves an equally absurd answer. So my 10 absurd answer would be the following.
11 Divide the waste equally and place them on 12 barges. Yes, similar to those that carried all the garbage 13 up and down the east coast lately, that nobody wanted. Take
(' )
14 one of these barges and float one to the NRC headquarters in 15 Walnut Creek and Washington, D. C.
16 Since there interest for public safety is 17 subordinate to those for the profit interest of the utilities, j l
18 In fact, the only reason the NRC hearing is taking place is 19 because they broke the law and now the court has forced you 20 to be here to listen to us.
21 Float another barge to PG and E's legal offices 22 for their efforts at defending the nuclear insanity while 23 fattening their wallets simultaneously.
g-) 24 Float a third barge to Congressman Thomas and
\/
25 all his cohorts on Capitol Hill that vote for huge subsidies
i 26 1 that keep the industry alive.
f2 I will decline to tell these people where to
{
1 3 stick their waste because I'm afraid it would not be.in_a j i
4 geologically stable area either. l i
-5 Anyway, so much for absurdities. I would like l l
6 to close by reading'a brief article that I wrote recently for l
7 a local environmental publication.
8 " September 30, 1986, marked a sad and 9 tragic day in the history of San Luis obispo ,
i 10 county. With Diablo Canyon's Unit 1 having ;
11 its first spend fuel rods unloaded and stored 12 on site, it is indeed the beginning of'the end
(~ 13 of the so-called nuclear fuel cycle.
\-)1 14 "Now that Diablo Canyon is basically a 15 radioactive' waste dump, high level radioactive 16 waste is being stored there. Temporarily, they 17 say. It is time that we realize the threat it 18 poses to our community.
19 " Irradiating nuclear fule, often referred 20 to as spend fuel, is high-level nuclear waste in 21 the form of 12- to 14-foot long uranium-filled 22 rods encrusted with fission products, strontium, 23 cesium and crypton, and transuranic elements, 24 plutonium, americium, neptunium.
-O-25 " Fission products are inherently radioactive
27 1 and have hazardous lives for hundreds of years.
L
(~T 2 Transuranic elements, while less radioactive, V
3 pose serious biological threats for hundreds 4L and thousands of years.
5 "An average nuclear power plant will pro-6 duce 30 metric tons of spent fuel each year. In 7- ' addition, low-level waste will also be produced 8 in enormous quantities.
9 " Fact: waste generated at Diablo Canyon 10 must be isolated from humanity for hundreds of 11- thousands of years.
12 " Fact: the track record of the nuclear 13 industry in the government is extremely poor in t (~)
14 their attempts to store nuclear waste. Recent 15 history shows that leaks are the norm at the few 16' disposal sites that now exist.
'17 " Fact: the Union of Concerned Scientists 18 have recently discovered that the waste that 3 1
19 was being stored at Chernobyl was involved in 20 the fire at the plant and is directly responsible 21 for a portion of the released radioactivity that t 22 escaped into the environment.
1 1
23 " Fact: there is currently no proven j i
1 24 technology to isolate nuclear waste from our I
(
25 environment. )
i 1
1
28
- 1. - I hope and pray an accident never occurs 2- at Diablo Canyon, but even if it doesn't we are
.(
3 still being asked and being forced to coexist
~4 with this lethal waste product that not only threatens our own well-being, but also that of I 5
6 the generations that follow us."
7 Amen.
g (Applause.)
l 9 JUDGE COTTER: Ann Clayton.
10 STATEMENT OF ANN CLAYTON 11 - MS. CLAYTON: My name is Ann Clayton, A-N-N, 12 C-L-A-Y-T-O-N. I live in Grover City, downwind from this
^
13 monstrosity.
V, -
14 For a dozen years, PG and E representatives' l
15 answer to our concerns about disposal of radioactive waste
[
16 was, "Not to worry,there are several options."
17 If their chosen option is to cram five times 18 more than prepared-for dangerous material into unsecured 19 racks within a stone's throw of earthquake faults, I would 20 like to suggest that whoever schemed up that solution would 21 be better informed if they spent their time reading news-i 22 papers or watching TV news.
I 23 Both are helpful tools for getting acquainted 24 with reality. In the absence of a disaster, it is reasonable 1.
I 25 to expect the proponents back to request storage of 10 times l
l 29 l i
i 1 as much radioactivity. Expensive cleanup alone should prevent 1
2 this madness called " option."
3 Hanford Nuclear Power Plant 'has closed for 4 six months because their option is leaking into.the Columbia 5 River. Who knows how much radiation has contaminated the 6 vast Yakima Valley fruit orchards.
7 Love Canal, Osage Beach, Casmalia (Phonetic) 8 Dump, proponents of all were able to convince their local 9 officials, their chosen options were safe. Thiakol convined 10 NASA the O-rings were safe. Met en r 11 But how much damage, how much suffering must 12 be endured before the arguments even start about who will 13 pay for cleaning up the mess?
, N_
// .
i 14 Ideas are abundant on how to saturate the 15 environment with every toxin discovered by man, but none for 16 removal. Until the results of these dangerous assaults are 17 dealt with realistically, the answer appears to be to stop 18 generating them.
19 And thank you for listening.
20 (Applause.)
21 JUDGE COTTER: Lars Hansson?
22 STATEMENT OF LARS HANSSON 23 MR. HANSSON: Good afternoon, my name is Lars 24 Hansson. That's -- everybody has trouble with this so I am 25 used to spelling it. L- A- R-S , H-A-N-S-S-O-N . And my tax
30 i
L 1 returns have been filed this year, I just want to say that in x
' advance. Everything is in order.
) 2 3 I am here representing not only myself -- I ]
4' don't have a wife or children so I fortunately don't have 5 those concerns, but I like to think that I represent the 6 thousands of other people who had to work today who couldn't 7 be here. And, frankly, it is probably just as well because j g there wasn't enough advance planning to accommodate them 9 anyway had they been able to come.
i 10 But I work as a free-lance journalist and 11 filmmaker. And I am not an expert in nuclear issues or T
12 nuclear waste disposal issues, although I have studied it for about 10 years now. I do know, for example, that as has
./} 13 14 been brought out Diablo Power plant is situated on an active 15 faultline, the Hosgri fault. I am sure you are aware of L 16 that now.
1- I do know in fact that there is no safe way to 18 store nuclear waste anywhere on this planet. And even after 19 the 10 years that I have been studying it -- I wrote a term 20 paper about it in college 10 years ago -- they have made no 21 strides forward in that respect.
L 22 I know that the situation currently exists at ,
23 Diablo is not safe. So increasing the extent of that 24 liability five times can only make it five times more unsafe.
25 I frankly am a little bit more of an expert
31 1 .on South American issues. I work.with an organizat' ion that p
.J 2 'I assume that probably all'of you.are quite familiar with.
3 It'is called the Christic Institute. And most of. my energy 4 has been1 going towards publicizing their activities and 5 pressing a law suit against the individuals who are responsi-6 ble.for hundreds of thousands of death in Central America, as 7 well as Southeast Asia -- the people you have been reading g about every day in the paper.
9 But I might add that the Institute, which is 10 an' inter-faith interdenominational public interest law firm, 11 was very successfu2 in getting a judgment against Kerr-McGen 12 in Karen Silkwood's death. I think it is a little bit too .
.({]y 13 bad that-the organization couldn't be more actively involved 14 in this situation, but one only has so much time and energy.
15 Since the other issues have already been 16 addressed, I would just like to bring.up one situation of 17 which I have very close personal experience. The Institute's 18 current law suit against the individuals who are involved in 19 setting up the bombing in La Penca (phonetic), the CIA of 20 course is strongly implicated in that, in which eight 21 journalists were kA11ed and an effort was made to kill Eden i 22 Postora who was going to blow the whistle on the CIA, the
. 23 scenario is outlined very well in a lot of our literature.
24 But I will run it by you very quickly. An 25 individual was recruited by the secret team from the Chilean 1
.J
i 32 1 secret police and was brought in to Costa Rica where he was !
N '
2 given C-4 explosives which were smuggled there by the CIA in !
([O 3 order to attempt to assasinate not only Eden Pastora, ;
4 Commodante Zero, if you will, but also in an attempt to ;
i 3 assasinate Louis Tams who was the then-Ambassador to Costa 6 Rica, as a justification for1the United States blaming this 7 on Sandinistas and invading Nicaragua.
8 Well, now you might ask, what does all this 9 have to do with the current situation here today? Only this, 10 that I know from first-hand experience last fall while I was 11 assisting a local group in putting together a weeklong 12 presentation on Central American issues and attempting to e' 13 counter the Administration's similarly-ludicrous policy nj 4 14 there, that I worked -- I work part-time as a carpenter when i 15 I have to -- and I had occasion to work at Diablo.
16- As a matter of fact, as fate would have it, I 17 was doing finish work in the command center, the new computer 18 control room, on the sixth floor of the administration 19 building right directly across from the power plant.
20 Now, I want to stress ahead of time, I am not 21 a terrorist and I have not been involved in bombings and I 22 am not threatening anything of that sort. However, if I were, 23 it would have been ridiculously easy for me to smuggle in an 24 unlimited quantity of C-4 exposives as well as triggering 25 devices, because I brought my lunch box in which was never
L 33 1 -inspected. I could have had pounds of these explosives in
~ ~
'2 the bottom of the lunch box. And also brought my radio in
}
3 .every day which I could house a dozen electronic triggering i
4 devices. !
5 And I might add that the U. S. Government did 6 teach me, in my previous capacity as an agent with the 7 Treasur" Department how to use those particular items very 8 effectively.
9 And what really concerns me and as I mentioned, 10 I have no intention of doing this but considering the threats 11 that have been already made by Iran in terms of what they 12 would do to retaliate against any attempted retaliation by the United States, it leaves the situation very well open
.(~v}
13 ;
14 to that sort of penetration because of the faulty physical 15 security at the plant.
16 And just by way of proof of this, I would like 17 to submit my former badge which was never actually taken away 18 from me. And I have a permit in my car with which I could 19 drive right into the plant today, if I were going to do that.
20 I have no further use for this (indicating).
21 I would -- I prided myself that I actually never worked at 22 the plant. But I felt it was worthwhile considering what I 23 was doing at the time. However, I won't have any further use 24 of it and I hope in the very near future the other people ]
}
who are currently' drawing salaries from there have no further 25 l
34 1 need of.it also.
L 2 Thank you, gentlemen.
3 (Applause.)
4 JUDGE COTTER: Arlene Chandler?
5 STATEMENT OF ARLENE CHANDLER 6 MS. CHANDLER: My name is Arlene Chandler. ;
7 That's A-R-L-E-N-E, C-H-A-N-D-L-E-R. I'm a retired community 3 college teacher -- that is, retired from the local community 9 college, which is Questa College.
10 But I am here today representing myself. :
11 consider myself a concerned citizen of this community. I 12 have lived in San Luis Obispo for 27 years. And during that f., 13 Period of time I have felt numerous earthquakes.
~ Q/
14 I know from personal experience that' earth-15 quakes do occur here. I am here today because I am afraid.
16 I'm afraid for those 18,000 bright, talented young college 17 and university students who study in this community every 1
18 year.
19 I'm afraid for my community, my neighbors, my 20 friends, my family. I'm afraid that the high density 21 unsecured fuel rack storage which PG and E intends to install i
22 for its spent fuel will result in a tragic accident which 23 will injur many, perhaps kill some of us who are in this room 24 today, or others in this community, and make that beautiful
'im i 25 area that we are looking at out there uninhabitable for no
35 1 one.knows how long.
..e
'. rT 2 I have no special technical expertise to bring
-Q '
3 to this' hearing. But I feel that in fairness to the citizens 4 of this area all. reasonable alternatives should be' considered. ;
i 5 Again, I strongly object to high density 6- racking in this earthquake-prone area because I fear for the 7 lives and safety of those of us who live here.
8 Thank you.
9 JUDGE COTTER: Willow Moon?
10 STATEMENT OF WILLOW MOON i 11 MS. 800N: Thank you. It is an honor to speak before you.
12 There are many people who cannot be here, not
/^ 13 only working people, but there are other people who cannot'be
,. ' \-)% - ]
1 14 here.
f l
15 They are the. children of the Navaho, the Hopi, 16 the Duckbill Shoshone and the Paiute, who live on lands )
I 17 where there are thousands of ponds leaking radon gas. These 18 children are sick, they are dying of disease because of
'l 19 nuclear power.
]
20 We may not realize how many people our acts 21 affect. We affect those children daily because these ponds 22 for the uranium mining that the nuclear power is usually 23 using exists, 24 Also, I think many people are under the f~ i
,1 I 25 illusion that nuclear power exists for us, for cheap I
36 1 electricity, when in reality we know it isn't -- this isn't
'r~T, 2 :a fact. Because~ here in California nuclear power only e
.V 3 provides about 15 percent of our energy needs. Nuclear power 4 exists for the war machine.
5 And before anything else should be looked at, 6 this issue needs'to be addressed.
It is the war machine that 7 keeps nuclear power going. And we have to stop it.
8 The racking is a big issue in the storage waste.
9 And one other issue that has been proposed, that the storage j 10- waste would' be stored in the desert where the Shoshone i
11 Duckbill people live by the thousands. It isn't just an 12 empty desert out there. There are people who live on that fg 13 desert and they do not want that desert destroyed. It is V
14 their home.
15 (Applause.) l 16 JUDGE COTTER: Rochelle Becker?
17 STATEMENT OF ROCHELLE BECKER j 18 MS. BECKER: I am glad you have a court 19 reporter here today. I was sitting in the back of the room 20 wondering how you were going to remember all this.
21 My family has lived in San Luis Obispo County 22 for 16 years and it would be difficult for me to state the 23 feelings of my husband, my 19 year old daughter or myself 24 better than Nancy Culver.
25 It is inconceivable to me that the NRC would
37 -1 1 allow PGLand E to store five times more radioactive waste l l ,...s .
k q
2 than the pools were originally designed to hold.
3/^)v
'Q J 3- This is California, and Diablo Canyon's proximity ,
4 to an active' earthquake fault is well-documented and widely .
5 know.
6 If you cannot. assure the residents of San Luis .
I 7' Obispo that radioactive waste storage at Diablo Canyon will.
g be 100 percent safe, I-feel your only choice is to suspend 9 the premature operating license that you granted PG and E 10 until the question of safe storage at Diablo Canyon and all 11 other huclear power plants is resolved.
12 (Applause.)
( 13 JUDGE COTTER: June Von Ruden?
)
14 STATEMENT OF JUNE VON RUDEN 15 MS. VON RUDEN: I'm June Von Ruden. I live in 16 Pismo Beach.
17 I was standing out there in the mob and ;
18 everyone that comes says, "The Board looks board." And I hope 19 you are not because it is very scary for us to come and speak.
20 We are not accustomed to it and it is at great cost to us that 21 we come here and stand and tell our feelings.
22 JUDGE COTTER: We are anything but bored.
23 MS. VON RUDEN: Thank you. I'm glad. I will 7 24 let them know.
G' 25 First, I want to present a letter, if I could,
38 e
-1 ~that was sent to me by a Mr. and Mrs. Ed Fisher in Los Osos I _2 .and.20 of.their neighbors that could not be here. And they
-3 wanted- it in the record, if that is possible.
4 (The document was proffered to the' Board.)
-5 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you.
6- MS. VON RUDEN: And I do want to thank.you for 7 the privilege of letting us give our views here today. I g don't have a lot to add and I want to keep'it short because 9 of'all the people waiting. And I understand there is 95 10 signed up now.
11 But I am a member of the Sierra Club. And I've i 12 been well aware of Richard's work for the last year'and a 13 half. He has given his life, he's given his money to his
-(
14 research. I'm' aware of the conclusions of Dr. Ferguson. I 15 am impressed by them. I am also aware of the Brookhaven 16 findings.
17 I have been out to the plant. I've seen the jg massive racks that hold the fuel. I've watched my swimming 19 pool in a very mild earthquake and the slopping and movement i 20 of it. They do move, gentlemen.
21 I think the site is wrong. I think the plant 22 is wrong. I think we should start over.
23 Thank you.
24 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you very much.
>I 25 (Applause.)
39 3 . JUDGE COTTER: Sylvia Reichman.
/k STATEMENT OF SYLVIA REICHMAN Q. 2 3- MS. REICHMAN: My name is Sylvia Reichman, 4 S-Y-L-V-I-A, R-E-I-C-H-M-A-N.
5 I am, and have been, a homeowner in Avlia Beach 6 for 16 years where I have raised'my family. I am here to 7 address the legality of the increase of spent fuel storage
.g proposed for Diablo Canyon.
9 In order to increase storage capacity of the 10 waste storage pools at Diablo, it is necessary for the NRC 11 to have their original license amended. The amendment would 12 increase storage five-fold.
- - 13 The original license allowed for 540 spent rods t.
14- to.be stored in stationary racks secured-to the bottom of two 15 pools. The amendment PG and E is requesting would permit ;
16 2648 rods to be stored in the originally-designated area.
p 17 These rods would not be anchored to the base of the pools.
18 So anxious was the NRC to have such a plan 19 approved that they determined no health nor safety hazards i 20 would be posed despite the fact that this on-site waste 21 storage was to be increased in an active seismic zone. j 22 Such a determination was made -- and I quote f
23 from Leon Pinetta - "without considering whether the 24 reconfiguration of the pools could create the possibility of O 25 a new kind of accident."
l
)
40 1 The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has found 2 that this-action was impermissible under the NRC's own V'
3 regulations promulgated pursuant to section 2239 (a) (2) (c) ,
4' 1982, of the Atomic Energy Act, 42 USC.
5 In addition, the court found that the commission 6 acted in. direct contravention of congressional intent, "that' 7 doubts be resolved in favor of holding hearings before g amendments are made ef fective when there is possibility of 9 a new or different kind of accident."
10 This public hearing is important in that for 11 the first time the NRC is required by law to conform to local 12 public opinion. However,this must not be a token meeting to 13 pacify the public.
14 Our whole government is made up of a system of 15 checks and balances. We cannot leave an agency to policy 16 itself. We are aware of the report from Brookhaven National 17 Laboratory. We realize that high density nuclear waste l
18 storage could cause a nuclear plant accident twice as serious l I
19 as a core meltdown if an earthquate hits. l 20 The NRC rules intend that they respond to any 21 questions raised concerning safe operation of nuclear power 22 plants. Yet they downplay the Brookhaven report which very 23 specifically addresses the safety of storing spend fuel.
24 To ascertain that decisions are being made i
25 according to the legal mandate, a Congressional inquiry is l
41 1 needed. I.ask that public hearings on the issue of spent a
f~} 2 fuel storage be conducted by the committee on energy and v
3 commerce to insure an unbiased investigation of this serious 4 issue. - '
~5' Thank you.
6 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you. ,
7 (Applause.)
i 8 JUDGE COTTER: Sheila Wynne.
9 STATEMENT OF SHEILA WYNNE 10 MS. WYNNE: I am Sheila Wynne, S-H-E-I-L-A, 11 W-Y-N-N-E.
12 Here we are again venting our anger and our rm 13 frustration at the people who do not even make the decisions-
%s] ,
14 about the issue that we are airing today.
15 Where are the Commissioners and what do they 16 think it is their job to do? I ..would like to specifically 17 exclude Commissioner Hasselstein from my negative remarks.
18 You are here today because the Commissioners 19 seem to believe that the NRC is above the law and that the 20 health of the nuclear industry is more important than the 21 health of the people .
22 I am here today because I wholeheartedly 23 disagree. PG and E's reracking proposal is incredible. The 24 pools were designed to hold only one-fifth of the waste that l
-O-25 PG and E intends to store there. The whole plant sits on an l
42 l
1 active earthquake fault. The racks are unsecured and liable to crash.into one a'nother during an earthquake.
2-3 Common sense tells me that this is dangerous. l 4 And no one will tell me that it is not a risk. But PG and E j
-)
and the Commissioners appear ready to take that risk. I am 5
);
i L 6- not. 1
[- 7 I don't pretend to be. impartial. I have been :
~
L f g opposing the licensing and the operation of Diablo for almost 4,
9- 10 years. A major reason for my opposition has always been i
10 the production of highly radioactive nuclear waste.
11 While I can see no justification for producing 12 this waste, it is now with us. The responsible agency needs j 13 to deal with it safely.
It can 't be stored safely on site 14 in unsecured racks above an earthquake fault and at five times I
15 the intended volume.
16 Please tell the Commissioners to reread their 17 job descriptions. Please tell them safety first. Please.
18 tell them Chernobyl can happen here. Please tell them that 19 we won't let it.
20 (Applause.) j J
! 21 JUDGE COTTER: Jackie Wheeler? l l
22 (No response.) )
l 23 JUDGE COTTER: Elaine Holder.
24 STATEMENT OF ELAINE HOLDER l ("s ~
'%s) 25_ MS. HOLDER: That 's Elaine Holder , E-L-A-I-N-E ,
l
i 43 J 1 but I really would like to speak for more than a thousand s
i 2 people who signed petitions that were circulated by Mothers
'~
3 For Peace. l 4 The petition reads:
5 "PG and E is planning a five-fold increase 6 in tne amount of highly radioactive waste to be 7 stored at Diablo canyon. It is outrageous that g any nuclear waste be stored near an active j
9 earthquake fault.
{ 10 "We, citizens of San Luis obispo county, 11 say no to the short-sighted and dangerous scheme."
12 While people were signing the petition, they
- j. 13 also were making various kinds of comments. And I noticed 14 that there were three types of comments that seemed to be 15 especially frequent. '
16 Many people were concerned about current 17 safety issues, the possibility of an accident. There was a 18 lot of outrage expressed about the idea of storing radioactive '
5 l 19 toxic waste where our children and their children and their '
20 grandchildren and their grandchildren will have possibly 21 their environments destroyed.
22 But I think the commment that I heard the most l 23 frequently expressed was, if the officials at Diablo Canyon a{
24 cannot find a safe way to store that waste that is being 1 /3 kJ 25 generated by that plant, that plant has no business producing l
l
- _ _ _ - - _ _ - - - _ . _ - - - _ _ - _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- I
-44 1 that waste.
-(Y p '.
2 (Applause.)
3 -(Document proffered'to the Board.)
i
~
~4 JUDGE. COTTER: Ann Morgan.
5 STATEMENT OF ANN MORGAN 6 MS. MORGAN: My name is Ann Morgan, A-N-N, 7 M-O-R-G-A-N. I am a local resident and I am a professor at 8- Cal-Poly.
9 And I am beginning to feel like a broken record.
10 But then I realize that the remarks I make are addressing the l 11 issue. And the issue is the same. The nuclear industry'is 12 'still dealing with the same problem, nuclear waste.
13 It is' no wonder that the contents of' my comments 14 have changed very little. In view of the fact that problem 15 of disposing of nuclear waste has not been solved, it seems 16 reasonable to request that further storage at an unacceptable 17 site be halted until the problem is solved, i 18 We have the classic cart before the horse 19 _ scenario. We can no longer hold to a 19th Century belief that 1
20 science will come to our rescue and will solve our problems l 21 before.a disaster occurs.
22 We have every right to insist that problems of 23 the magnitude of storage of nuclear waste be solved. And if 24 the very best scientific minds cannot provide us with this 25 solution, then we should cease further the health hazard
45 1 'until such a' time as we can actually.get.that horse before 2- the cart.
3 Please. place the health:and the safety of the ;
i 4- People of this~ community before the health of the industry. f 5 Thank you.
i
6 (Applause.)
i a
1 //
8 //
1 j
9 10 j I
'11 12 Ib i 1 14
- j. -15 j
l -' 16 1
17 ,
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
- m. h i
25
46 l
l l JUDGE COTTER: Marcelle Martin.
- x. _/
STATEMENT OF M ARCELLE M ARTIN 3
MS. MARTIN: M a r c elle M a r tin , M- a- r- c-e 1-e M-a-r-t-i-n.
5 I am a newcomer in t his co mm u nit y. I went 9
to the City H all of San L uis Obispo to find o ut what I 7
sho uld do in c a se of disaster. I was handed this little l 8
pa m phle t (indicating) and read it, and f ollo we d it re ally 9
w ell . I was given that be a utif ul brochure in case of 10 disaster at Diablo Canyon. I i
11 However, when I received that be a utif ul ;
12 brochure, I was told that it was not sufficient; that it 13 was not c o m ple te . I was asked to give my P.O. Box Number,
~ 14 or my addre ss, to receive more. It is bea utif ul.
15 Why so much money spent when so me c hildr e n k 16 cannot even be cured, when so much money is needed in 17 education?
18 Please, I do no know to whom I sh o uld I9 address the que stion. Please address it to the proper 20 person.
21 Than k you for your attention.
22 VOICE: Exc use me. But the microphones have 23 been turned down, so that the pe o ple outdoors can no 24 longer here what is being said.
25 Would it be possible to turn those up ag ain?
f';
u .
47-( ' '
W. .
?
. JUDGE COTTER: W e ' will g o o f f t he r e'c'o rd . f or a ' min ute.
(Discussion, off. the record.)
-4 JUDGE COTTER: On .the: record.
-5 Joyce Howerton. Is Joyce. Howerton; here?
6
( No re spon se'. )
7 JUDGE COTTER: George Ea sth am.
8 STATEMENT OF GEORGE EASTH AM 9
MR. EASTHAM: My name is George. Eastham, E-
' a- s- t- h-a-m . .
II I 'ha ve - lived in San Luis Obispo . f or. 21 '-
.12 l years.- Teach economics at C al P oly. I am m a r rie d. I 13 have f our children : -one married and out of the household, 14
. . L three in c olle g e .
.15 Let me- confess so me thing initially : In the
'16 very early days of Diablo Canyon, it seemed like, to me, a 17 reasonable idea to have a project of that sort p ro viding 18 cost e f f ec tiv e , cheap electricity with minim al damage to 19 the e n vir o n men t. Sufficed to say, the NRC, PG and E, and 20 various assorted other people have changed my thinking 180 21 degrees on that pa r tic ular issue . j
'22 Most of the points I was going to make have 23 already been made: The cart-before-the-horse syndrome, 24 the quic k-fix synd ro me. ;
25 b It has occ urred to me that several speakers )
iOL ;
i l
48 vN 1 Q- have sort of sc ra tc hed t heir' he ads, fig u r a tiv ely spe a king ,
2 wondering where on earth the NRC is coming from, as they 3
purport to reason their way through so me of these iss ue s.
4 It occurred to me that, in sele c ting jurors for a fir st 5
deg ree murder case, pe r s pe c tiv e jurors are asked if they 6
have any r e se r v a tio n s about imposing the death penalty 7
where the law wo uld re q uir e that. And it seemed to me 8
that there is kind of an analog y here that really oug ht to I
9 be thought through in selecting p eo ple to serve on the l 1
10 N u cle a r Re gulatory Commission. l 11 Co uld we perhaps have avoided a lot of the 12 present dif fic ulty we are in if we had screened them o ut, i
I 13 p in pd r t, by asking : If it becomes n e c e ssa r y in serving j
'd 14 i
the public intereet, as you are re q uir ed to do, to shut j 15 down permanently a nuclear power plant, could you do that?
.Yes or no?
I wo uld like to sug g e st for the record that I
18 that be given more thought.
l Thank you for your time.
20 JUDGE COTTER: Ray Renic k.
El STATEMENT OF RAY RENICK l
22 MR. RENICK: Ray Re nic k, R-a-y R- e - n -i- c - k.
1 23 Recent events with the USS STARK in the 24 P e r sian G ulf have re s ulte d in increased world h o stilitie s, j 25 Last week the Iranian Government announced that the U. S.
1
.+g 4 1
o 49-in volv e men t in their a f f airs would ' bring' on an attack on
~
2 U. S. Nuclea'r Power Plants. . .
3 '
The Iranian s have U.. S. TOW Missile s, Frenc h a .
'vocet Mis sil e s . Chin e se Silkwo rm Missiles, and others.
5-An idiot. with an . IQ of 20 could fire one of these missile s -
6 off shore'from Diablo. Canyon N ucle ar' Power Plant. A-7 -
l c o n v e n tio n al warhead, hea t see king g uided missile wo uld j 8
have little t ro u ble locking on to a reactor. T he - re sult '
'9 - -
l would be in st a n t C he r n o b yl. It is the ultima te st upidit y -
to compound this ' insanity by. adding a : precarious f uel rad-wa ste . d ump.
12 (Applause)
+~
I JUDGE COTTER: Carol Scott. i STAT ~EMENT O F- CAROL S C O T. T : j 15 Carol Scott, C- A- R L S- C- O-T-MS. SCOTT:
l0 T. I've been a . resident of San L uis Co'unty with my - f amily 17' for the past. ele ven years. We moved here wit ho ut any 18 kno wle dg e of Diablo Canyon or even -nuclear power. Over-19 the years as we became more informed, we also became ,
0 concerned and scared abo ut what's happening here.
21 To c o mmis sio n Diablo was the fi r st big 22 mista ke un til now the storing of waste on site is ' to t ally ;
23 outrageous.
.24 Thank you.
25 Sue Sunde rland, JUDGE COTTER:
i I
50-
~
~
- \ .
V . 1 Njg STATEMENT OF SUE SUNDERL AND 2
c M S.- SUNDERLAND: I've received se v e r al
-letters in 'the: m ail. And two I would like to present to 4
you, .and .- two. I ' wo uld like to read to you.
1
. 5 .
"To the NRC: As.We all kno w, ' t here 's 6 ' '
oftentimes a price to pay for modern c o n v enie n c e s.
7 ~
As ' is' also w ell- k n o wn , we are not immune. to O
po te n tial hazards from Mother Nature, for e x a mple ,
9 earthquakes. Modern science enables us to p re dic t 10 the = likelihood of some disasters. There is 11' credible . information: f rom many reliable sources that 12
. th'e . W e st e r n c o a stlin e' o f the United ' States 'is an.
-l3 ' area.of concern for future earthquakes.
.f ' 34 "Never bef ore in history has so much 16 waste from hu'm an consumption been amassed. Adequate 16 storage- of r a dio a c ti v e . waste is still in 7
' e x pe rimen t al st a g e s. . We are re spon sible for our
' 18 '
actions upon this ear th. l 19
., " As a responsible citizen having lived j 20 5 almost twenty years in the San Luis Obispo area and 21 r aising a f amily of third generation locals, I feel 22
.; a n'e e d to express concern over a c o mmitm e n t to
'23 something which may not be the best decision for the
'E 24 future. In a d e q u a t e storage f a cilitie s of I
25 r a d i,o a c ti v e waste from Diablo Canyon in an ,
i h .j 51 ry.
07 %
f l G
1 -
\g earthquake f a ult area does not sound c o nd u civ e to 2
human growth. An alternative solution must be found 3
- be fore we commit ourselves.
4
" Living 3.4 mile s from Diablo Canyon is a 5
mere hop, skip and a jump from po ten tial disa st e r .
1 It may be am accident waiting to happen. Put 7
yourself in my shoes. Make your d ecisions wisely.
8 Sig n e d : " Cha rlo tte Co y. "
9 Another letter I r e c eiv e d that the person 10 1 asked to be read is just a brief note from Margaret Paine. '
11
" Count me in as being a hundred per cent 12 opposed to the . sto rin g of nuclear waste at the
,- Diablo Canyon Nuclear Plant. Especially next to an b 14 a c tiv e earthquake f a ult. I bet that none of you 15 members of the NRC lived anywhere to this dangerous 16 area. It mig ht alter your Attitude. You are safe, 17 b ut we are not.
18 Sig ne d : " Mar g ar e t Paine."
19 As a representative of my f amily, my husband 20 and three c hild r e n , we feel it is time for the NRC to stop 21 protecting the in d u str y, and stop protecting the 22 in d ust r y 's poc ke tboo k, and protect the health and safety 23 of t he puolic. Stop Diablo Canyon and no nuclear waste.
24 (Applause.)
25 JUDGE COTTER: Gail Ja c o b so n .
~, .
4 1
i
_- D
52 h 1 STATEMENT OF GAIL JACOBSON 2
I am Doctor Gail Jacob so n , G- a-i-1 J- a - c- o-3 b-s-o-n.
4 Today Telegram Trib une , the local paper, 5
says that PG and E is see king to store 30 years of spent ;
O fuel rods at Diablo Canyon. I think that is the sa me 7
thing as the estimated life of the plant. So, in fact, PG 8
and E is asking to store the whole batch of spent fuel at 9
the plant, forever presumably.
10 One thing I don't understand is why PG and E 11 just doesn't dig more storage pools, four more storage 12 pools, and have the problem solv ed. I am sure the c a pit al 13 f r e q uir e d to do such an o utla y wo uld not be beyond PG and 14 E's needs.
15 Science M a g a zin e , which I read oc c a sio rn ally, 16 May 8, 1987, hat an a r ticle " Nuclear Power After I
C h e r n o b yl. " I am sure you all recog nize Scie n c e as being 18 the be st, most r elia ble , ar ticle in the g e n e r al science 19 field. And the article is by John Ahern.
20 It did not occur to me un til I had finished 21 the a r ticle that this guy was on the NRC. He was Nuclear 22 Re g ula to r y Co mmissio n for a w hile , anyway. And he was 23 certainly on a team o p p o sit e from the one that I 24 represent. And I wo uld just like to quote the la st two 25 parag raphs f rom this ar ticle :
O U
3 53' I '
"There has been s t e a dily in c r e a sin g 2
disavowal of nuclear power in the United States. A 3 '
few years ago, I c o m ple te d [and t h a t is 19 8 3 ) -- To 4
recover in the United States, the n ucle a r ind ustr y 5
needs the f ollo wing :
6
"(a) Energy demand: That is a g r o win g 7
economy that, in spite of c o n se r v a tio n and new 8
tec hnolog y, still needs more electrical energy; 9
"(b) A solution to the waste management 10 problem: Tha t is, an actual location and repository II under construction ;
12
"(c) No major accidents; and
"(d) Competent management.
14 This is from John Ahern, a former NRC 15 Commissioner.
16 Today, the demand for energy grows.
'7 However, at present, there is no solu tion for the wa ste 18 management problem, in terms of location of a r e po sito r y.
19 A major a c cid en t has occurred at C h e r n o b yl. In addition, 20 swee ping moves to improve the compete nc e of management are 21 l' not e vid e n c e d .
22 !
Thank you. l 23 (Applause.)
2#
JUDGE COTTER: Jane Swanson. l 25 jf r
L)
__J
54
.P s 3
() STATEMENT OF JANE SW ANSON 2
I address the Nuclear Re g ula to r y Co mmissio n a n'd the members of this Lic e n sin g Board, as p u blic a
servants, who are supposed to be r e g ula ting this mess for 5
the past two decades. In st e ad , they have ignored, you 6 I have ' ignored, one safety problem after another. You have 7
lost your c r e dibilit y. i 8
You ignore the peo ple of this area when, in 9
1971, we told you that there was a po t en tial earthquake 10 hazard at Diablo Canyon. When, by 1973, you co uld no
'l longer ignore the Hosg ri Fa ult, you merely ordered PG ar;d 12 E to put a very e x pe n si v e Band Aid on the problem --
13 r chargeable to the rate payers.
14 You ignore the f act that a n ucle a r plan t on 15 an earthquake f a ult is not fix able . And lately you have 16 tried r e ally hard to ignore ad ditio n al major hazards of I
cramming together spent fuel a sse mblie s.
Yo u s h o uld be ashamed that it took a court l
)
I9 order to get you to come here and face the public on this 20 important safety issue.
21 (Applause.)
22 And now we have the alm o st c o m ple te d st udy 23 by Brookhaven N a tio n al L a b o r a t o rie s. A study of hig h-24 d e n sit y fuel st o r a g e e x a c tly as that pro pose d for Diablo 25 Canyon.
55 S'
' 'Are you going to try to ig nore this-too?
2 Are yo u- going - to tr y to file it away.and forget it?
Are-3 you going' to' tell us that this is another a cc e pt a ble ris k, ,
-i 4' I because we 'are a low population area?
l 5
Don't d o ' it . For once, why don't you 6-r e g ula te ;' say the simple tr uth : this is an unsafe 7
p r o po s al. Just say no.
8 (Applause.)
9 JUDGE COTTER: Sandra Mille r . ;
i STATEMENT ' OF S ANDRA MILLER
' ll
-I am Sandra Mille r . - S-a-n-d-r-a M-i-1-1-e-
.12
- r. I! am an architect and a professor at C al P oly.
13 Ge n tle me n ,. I w o uld lik e to express grave concern with the storage policy proposed _by PG and E. In
- 15 lig ht o'f the Brookhaven Study, and the seismic f a ults in 16 this area, it- is clear that this p ro po sal 'is not the 17 sa f e st alte r n a tiv e .
18 One of the reasons we are here is to state, 19 e ye b all to e y e b all, that the entire w o rld will hold the ,
20 NRC r e spo n sible if there is a n uclear accident at Diablo.
2I If this happens, ple a se r e ali z e their names and the
' 22 history of their polic y decisions will be the ones in Time 23 i2 a g a zin e , not those of the Soviets this time. ;
24 This is a grim legacy to c o n sid e r . I urge i 25 you to reject this unsafe and ill-con sid ered proposal.
O
56'
}
' 'l'
- Thank you.
JUDGE COTTER: Ralph Vrana.
3 STATEMENT OFl RALPH.VRANA' 4
MR. VRANA: My name .is Ralph Vrana. Spelled 5
-V- R- A- N - A. The storage of nuclear waste in large
.6 quan titie s at the' Diablo Can yon .. n uclear plant is. a serio us 7
mis t a ke . An earthquake co uld easily ' ca use a . merging of 8
-such wastes'and a' .r a dia tio n ? spill g r e a te r than a c o r e..
9 meltdown.. ,
10-What is, *de. risk of h a vin g such .a n 11
' earthquake? New evidence shows faulting exists 'between a.
12
.the power plan t and the Hosgri f ault . a f e w mile s . a wa y. A 13 branch of the Hosgri f a ult now - called the San L uis' Bay
(
34
.f a ult apparently connects up with the .Hosgri; and comes in 15' closer to ' the plant. It is 'possible that this f a ult.
16 ~
. connects up' with a' --
quote --
sig nific a n t f a ult 17 discovered by'PG'and E g e ologist s in the sea clif f at 18 Diablo Canyon.
There is also f a ultin g under the turbine 20 b uilding and under the reactor b uilding at the plant.. Do-21 these f aults connect up to the Hosgri? From the north a .
22 spur lof the Hosgri fa ult ~ comes wit hin a few mile s of the 23 plan t. From the so ut h, a long sig nific a n t f ault ex tending 24 into Santa Barbara County also aims in toward the plant.
25 Do these f a ults connect up? Does either or both of them 301 1 I
i 57 y
h,
\
3 connect up with the sig nific an t f a ult in the sea w all at g :
the plant?
3 A thorough study of the in flue n c e of these 4
f a ults on the seismic risk at Diablo has not been made. 1 5
Now a hearing is being held and perhaps a decision made to 6
store even more waste fuel at Diablo Canyon. L o c al 7
r e side n ts have every rig ht to worry and to pro te st this !
l in ade qua te a sse ssm e n t of seismic . risk.
9 I As .a f ormer geolog y instr uctor and residen t, ;
I add my voice to this prote st.
JUDGE COTTER: Gretchen Grell?
STATEMENT OF GUDRUN GRELL I 13
,c x MS. GRELL: It is not Gretchen. It's N
14 G udr un, G-U-D-R-U-N. G r ell, G- R- E- L- L. I live in H alc y on i 15 and I have lived there for 38 years.
16 How is it possible that anyone, even PG and 17 '
E, and even for most of us as money, can put a plan 18 together to stac k e x plo sive wacte rig ht one on top of the 19 other, just like the skeletons in the Catacombs. Only the O
skeletons were dead. But this waste is not dead. It's
]
I o nly d e adly . It may strike back any moment. And if it 22 does, it may destroy this whole area and all us peo ple 23 who live here. l 24 How is it po ssible that peo ple can ta ke such 25 d e cision s and still sle e p at nig h t?
(~h
'% l
58 i H
() 1-Thank you.
(Applause.)
3 JUDGE COTTER: Mic h a el Y o s him u r a . '
l l
) 4 STATEMENT OF MICHAEL YOSHIMURA 5
MR. YOSHIMURA: Mic h a el Yo s him u r a , M-i- c - h- l l
6 a-e-1 Y-o- s- h-i- m- u- r - a .
l 7
I am a Cal Poly pro f e sso r in the biologic al 8
( sciences department.
9 I am opposed to the pro posed increased l 10 l storage capacity of nuclear waste at Diablo Canyon. I ll Nuclear wa st e is dangerous to like almost 12 forever. The United States does not c u r.r e n tly have an !
'3
, a pp r o p ria te procedure for elimin a tio n of these wastes.
k- 14 Storage,of n u cle ar waste at Diablo Canyon is not in any 15 way an appropriate means of handling such life-threatening 10 m a t e ri als. The risks we c iti z e n s of San L uis Obispo 17 County are asked to live with are just not acceptable.
18 Thank you.
19 l (Applause.)
]
JUDGE COTTER: Joyce Yoshimura.
STATEMENT OF MARY JOYCE YOS HIMURA 22 MS. YOSHIMURA: I am Mary Joyce Y o s him u r a . .i 23 Y-o-s-h-i-m-u-r-a.
1 24 I w o uld j ust like to ask the que stio n : How 25 can the in tegrity of storage d e sig n be m ain t ain e d if the
(~'\
- w) .
59 h'b ma t e rial to be stored is increased by five time s? We NJ are not c o n side ring adding fif ty shoes to clo se t de sig n e d 3
-for ten.
4 Please refuse the proposed storage plan.
5 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you.
6 (Applause.)
7 JUDGE COTTER: Is it Theo Cole man ?
STATEMENT OF THEO COLEMAN MS. COLEMAN: T ha t is T- h- e -o C-o-1-e-m- a-n.
i 10 G e n tle m e n , currently I am going through an 11 in spec tio n in my driveway to make sure that I have the 12 re q uir ed six inches of sand and cement. You can imagine i 13 what part of a "Far Side " car toon I thin k we all in volved 14 in here after we hear the c on tin uo us te stimon y of the 15 problems that are involved in adding to the sto r a g e 16 f acilitie s that were origin ally proposed, and what is now 17 is being p r o po se d , five times as much.
18 O bvio u sly , the City of San L uis Obispo wo uld 19 not c o n sid e r these thing s sa fe. And I fin d it f ascina ting 20 that somehow the board of supervisors for the county has 21 ac tually allowed an yt hing like this to go so far.
22 I am here to say "no" f or my f amily and many 23 No; we do not of my f rie nd s who c o uld not come today.
24 want this. Most of the peo ple that I know did not want 25 Diablo Canyon to get this far; and, unf ortunately I feel O i V
)
60
'. that the. fact that you have allo we d it, under all of the cir c umst a n c e s that have been pre vio usly stated, re ally 3
contribute s ' to a to tally criminal act on you part.
4 (Applause.)
The United States does not seem = to have any 5
6 p'roblems de aling . with mor al -issues w hen they are poin ting 7 fingers and ' discussing. the crimes against nature when they 8 are pointing at other . countries.
However, what it manages 9 to be able. to sto mac h wha t' it does'to its own citiz e n s, 10 based.on the low' number of density population in an area 11 such as this, absolutely I find in c r e dible .
12 With me today, I did bring some sig n a t u re s 13 of 13 people that I literally just ran in to before I came
~ W3 '
14 I said, "Do you r e aliz e that public o pinion is, to today.
- 15 a great extent, going to be based on a three-hour time 16 slo t that we have been allo tt e d. Three ho urs . in the face 17
~
of how many years for the ramifications of what you are 18 c on te mpla ting. I t hin k that 'is ludicrous. On this piece 19 of paper (in dic a tin g ) they have all said that these 20 hearings sho uld be c o n sid e r e d in v alid if they are not 21 ex pa n d ed to allo w all of the peo ple who ' would o t he r wise 22 have to be working in order to support t heir f amilie s and 23 liv e in this c o mm unit y s u c c e ss f ull y and who c o uld not 24 attend to day. Thir te en is just the people that I ran
- 25 into while I was wo r king . And I really think that this is TO :
k 61 !
I f/b another major issue on your part that should be-- j V 2 It is so easy for you to ignore what we do 3 and what and what we say. And, to me, three hours for a public o pinio n he a ring is ludic ro us. One more aspect of 5 farsight.
6 (The document was proffered to the Board.)
7 (Applause.)
8 JUDGE COTTER: As many of you are aware, 9 there are p r o visio n s for you to s u b mit your vie ws in 10 writin g , and peo ple have done ex actly that over the last 11 Yo u may write to the NRC, and they are kept in few years.
12 the docket that deals with the Diablo Canyon issues.
13 Eve Eden.
C\
V 14 STATEMENT OF EVE EDEN 15 MS. EDEN: I am Eve Eden, E-d-e-n. I am a 16 r e tir e d ele men tar y school teacher, and very concerned 17 grandmother of five.
10 I am ple a se d to find that the NRC is, ha ving j a hearing in the area concerned with the P a cific Gas and 20 Elec tric Power Plan t at Diablo Can yon.
21 I am here to express my complete o ppo sitio n 22 to PG and E's plan to st o r e fiv e more times more n ucle a r 23 wa ste than the spent fuel pools were d e sig n e d to hold.
24 Even storing them at the pl a;' t at all is outrageous. I 25 have totally opposed the plan t's existe nce since attending
/-
62 I
h) n a meeting sponsored by the PG and E over 15 years ago. A 2
'PG and E official stated that he and PG and E were aware 3
that there wo uld be p u blic o p po sitio n to the p ro po sed 4
power plant, as there certainly has been. But that plan t 5
-would be plant reg ardle ss of pu blic o ppo sition .
.6 PG and E irresponsibly ignored the report of 7
a g e ologic al survey that had reported that the proposed 8
site was next to an ac tive ear thqua ke f a ult. PG and E has 9
had a cav alier a t tit ud e about safety factors at the plant, 10 comparing the dangers of a nuclear accident to the dangers 11 of a severe snow storm. And now, after ac k no wle dging the 12 risks of the spent fuel sto r a g e e x pa n sio n , they are 13 W ell, I am not.
g willing to accept the risks. I have o nly 14 one life to live and give, and I resent having this 15 n u cle a r clo ud hanging over my very existence, and the 16 health and future of my children and grandchildren.
I7 After seeing on the TV the d e v a s t a tio n 19 caused by the Chernobyl disa ste r , I shudder when I
'O vis u aliz e our b e a u tif ul C en t r al C alif o r nia Coa st to t ally 20 devastated by a nuclear accident. We can 't let it happen 21 here.
22 Thank you.
23 (Applause.)
24 JUDGE COTTER: We will ta ke a te n -min ute 25
/s
. v) j
i 62A-n fj.
Q'- .
I break.
2 -(Whereupon, a ten-minute recess was~taken.)
3 ' JUDGE COTTER: If'everyone would be seated, we 4 can proceed.
- 5. Several. people : asked me, during the break, 6 about those who would not have. an opportunity to speak 7 today, where they could write. For those of you with a. pen,
.g let me give you.an address. You can write to the Diablo 9 Canyon Board, care of the Nuclear . Regulatory Commission, go. Wash'ington, D.C. '20555, the Diablo Canyon Board, in care'of 33 the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington D.C. 20555.
12 We started a little late and I don't want to 33 deny anyone any time; and we will run over 15 or 20-minutes 14 past'.G.00 o' clock.
15 I believe the next. speaker is Marie Stanley.
16 STATEMENT OF MARIA STANLEY 17 MS. STANLEY: Well, I do need to spell my name 13 because my name is Maria-Stanley, with an 'a'.
19 JUDGE COTTER: I am sorry.
20 MS. STANLEY: M-a-r-i-a, S-t-a-n-1-e-y.
21 I had a prepared speech and I was talking to a i
12 lady with children, in the back, and we discussed the fact 25 th'at people keep calling this potential an accident. It's 24 not an accident; it is a crime. I am sorry.
..25 They have a loaded gun pointed at our heads; g
63 jk. 1 and they are playing Russian roulette. I can't see any 2 other way of putting it. Okay; so now I am going to. read 3 what I'had to read.
4 Let's just suppose for a minute that the 5 President of PG and E, as a private citizen, decided to 6 landscape his back yard using a few nuclear warheads for a 7 futuristic look; okay? So I am sure the NRC, acting in the 8 best interest of the public, would tell this private i
9 ' citizen, in no uncertain terms, that he would not be 10 permitted to do his landscaping using such material.
i 11 So next we suppose this same private citizen 12 goes to his place of business and decides to landscape.his 13 power plant with five times as much nuclear fuel as he
. f')
V 14_ originally planned. Now this same NRC smiles and says it's 15 still acting in the public's best interest.
16 Do not let PG and E play Russian roulette'with 17 our lives and future. I vote no on the proposed storage of 18 five times as much spent fuel as was originally planned. A 19 meltdown worse than a plant meltdown -- give me a break. i 20 Good-bye planet, or at least as we know it.
i 21 NRC, don't let yourselves be responsible for i l
22 such unthinkable devastation. Tell PG and E that they 23 cannot do this in view of the risks, just as I tell my 24 children they cannot put metal objects in the outlets, in 25 view of the risks.
A M,./ !
l I
l 1
)
64 i
- [.)- - 1 Better no electricity- at all than no s -
1 2 community, no planet at a,11. Who needs electricity without
, . 3 a planet or a community. PG and E certainly can't make a 4 profit with no customers; can it? j 5 A concerned family, Maria Stanley, Arthur 6 . Stanley, Cameron and Shawn and Morgan, my three young sons.
7 (Applause.)
8 JUDGE COTTER: Laurie.McDermott.
9 STATEMENT OF LAURIE MC DERMOTT 30 MS. MC DERMOTT: Judges Cotter, Harbour, 33 and Bright, I am Laurie McDermott, L-a-u-r-i-e, M-c-D-e-r-m-12
-t-t.
33 I was born and raised in this area; and I,have
;d,m 34 a long-standing concern about Diablo Canyon, what it has 15 done to this area, and what it can do to this area.
16 I speak in opposition to the storage and
~17 reracking of spent nuclear fuel at Diablo Canyon. As a 18 member of a local group, OPPOSE (phonetic), that opposes 19 construction and operating practices at Diablo Canyon,' I 20 have had access to NRC and utility information and paperwork 21 throughout the years; and I have noted that construction was 22 begun on the Diablo Canyon Power Plant with the engineering f 23 20 percent complete. Eighty percent of the engineering for 24 building the plant had not been done.
25 Most of us are aware that the power plant had j w O
' I
L i
65 ;
-s -
<c A 1 to be redesigned and built three different times at a cost -
r 2 that is still very much_in dispute because of the mistakes
'3 that were made.
'4' With high-level radioactive waste, we cannot 5- afford any mistakes, not one. yet, during the time leading 6 up to this hearing, we have had history repeat itself.
7- We have had incomplete engineering and 8 engineering assumptions found during the discovery process.-
9 And, as recently has been brought to light, the NRC and the 10 utility have been overlooking a draft report done;for the 11 NRC by_the Brookhaven National Laboratory.
12 This report has been available for six months.
13 It states that contaminated land area from an accident with yy D 14 this type of. reracking would be two orders of magnitude 15 greater than for a core-melt accident.
16 We cannot afford this type of problem here.
17 By law, you must listen to the people who live around the Is plant. We do not want nuclear waste.
19 Thank you, gentlemen.
20 (Applause.)
21 JUDGE COTTER: Jim McDermott.
22 STATEMENT OF JIM MC DERMOTT 23 MR. MC DERMOTT: My last name is Mc Dermott, 24 M-c-D-e-r-m-o-t-t. And I thank you for being here today, 25 everybody.
I
E i 6G
.g 'I' was a Diablo Canyon plant' worker for about L'
2 five years, as' both a Quality Control Inspector and _ as a 3 craft worker, specifically a welder. I believe, from_my 4 . qualification and experience while employed at Diablo_ Canyon 5 Nuclear Power Plant, this allows me . to talk about some-6' technical issues at the plant.
7 I think it is _ premature to want more spent-8 fuel storage when there are so many' generic nuclear industry 9 problems, I am personally aware that there are still go unanswered nuclear safety issues. In fact, some of the 33 branches-of your_own NRC, specifically the OIA,-believe that 12 the Diablo Canyon allegation management program DCAMP, as 33 everybody has shortened it to, was a breakdown in the 14 government's own procedures. The NRC OIA often found that '
15 there was no basis for their answers to the allegations and 16 concerns of plant workers.
17- I want the public and the NRC to be aware of 13 generic welding problems which well may jeopardize plant and j 19 Pub 1dc safety, possibly at the spent fuel pools as well as 1
20 the rest of the plant. I I
21 Before you and the public, I making a new 22 allegation for you and the PG and E lawyers to manage.
23 While working at the plant as a qualified 24 welder, I also directed --
excuse me --
I was directed to )
)
25 make an unqualified weld on Class 1 material. Because of my O
N .f
67.
l
. .y -
$ 1 past experience as a qualified Quality Control Inspector., I 2 noticed that- there was a weld joint called out on the 3 approved drawing which_was not a qualified welding joint, 4 which is required by federal law.
5 I notified the Quality Contro1~ Inspector and I 6 advised him of-the non-conformance. I also advised him of 7 his_ responsibility; but he told me, to weld it out anyway.
8 Because I was directed to do so, I made the weld joint as 9 directed.
10 I know that there are other unqualified weld 11 joints within the plant. .I feel that the failure of an 12_ unqualified weld joint could lead to a catastrophic nuclear ;
l 13 accident at the plant, including the spent fuel pools.
{
. . f t's !
-V- 14 Therefore, I question the larger spent fuel 15 pool, let alone the rest of the plant. l 16 I suppose, if you don't consider this matter, 17 hopefully the courts or Congress will. I speak in j 18 opposition to the spent' fuel pool expansion as well as the 19 rest of the plant because of the above allegation and other i i
20 disregard of the public law. i
- 21. Thank you.
22- (Applause.) l 28 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you, Mr. McDermott.
24 Tresa Des Hotel? I 25 //.
3
- 2 1
l
68 k '
STATEMENT OF TRESA DES I!OTEL
[U 1
_2 MS. DES IIOTEL : You _ said it right; very few '
3 people do. -My name is.Tresa Des Hotel: that's D-e-s li-o-4 -t-e -and just put down 'T'. And I represent myself, 5 my-flance, my six children,.and the future generations, if 6 we are lucky enough to have future generations.
7 I pray that all of you who are here to make 8 . decisions and who are in positions of making decisions for 9 all of us, that affect our lives, know and understand that 10 responsibility because it is our lives that we are talking -l jj about here today. And I don't want to.get emotional, but 12 this is life and death.
13 And I feel like our blood, of the people who
<A D 14 live here, is going to be on your hands if there is an
-15 ccident here. And we will shed blood. And you people are l
16- responsible for making these decisions. We voted you in; 17 and you have a responsibility to serve us; okay?
13 We're scared. I'm scared. I live 20 miles 19 downwind from here. And I would live here for the rest of l
20 my life. It's a beautiful place. But I'm afraid. I'm 21 afraid-that, at any time, an accident could happen at Diablo ,
22 Canyon: and me and my children and everybody here could be 1
23 blown to hell because corporate profit comes over- human '
'24 lives in most cases that I've seen.
25 I want to know when that's going to stop. I h 1 I
l q
3-
- - 69
, .1 f eel J11ke, if you . people vote for more waste storage . at 2 Diablo Canyon,- you are_ going to be signing our death 3 certificates. And, if you can live with that, then go ahead 4 and vote in favor of PG and E: but we think they're crazy.
5 Thank you.
6 (Applause.)
7 JUDGE COTTER: Doug Rosener.
l .
8 STATEMENT OF DOUG ROSENER 9 MR. ROSENER: My name is Doug Rosener, R-o-s-10 -e-n-e-r. I am a Professor at Cal Poly in Electrical 11 Engineering.
12 I've worked with --
or around radioactive 13 material' and I'm not afraid of it; but I oppose the
- i?"'
d 14 increased storage at Diablo.
- 15 I believe, when the decision gets made as to 16 whether~ they will increase the storage --
well, let's 17 suppose that they will make technical reason, not monetary 18 or political or human. And, if we suppose that, let's'take 19 a look at what they will do.
20- For example, if they are trying .to decide 21 whether they are going to put a new water pump in, they 22 could test that water pump. They could make a thousand of 25 them and test each one and see how it will do. And maybe we 24 would be willing to risk our lives based on the results of 25 those tests.
[
w
l J
70 l
9
- k. g But what they are proposing to do is . make i U
~
2 mathematical calculations based on seismic studies,
~3. .. earthquake predictions; and they're going to risk 'our lives 4 based'on mathematical. analysis.
5 There's only one way to test whether the 6- storage will work at Diablo, that's when an earthquake 7 .comes. That will be the proof whether the theory works, s' I wonder why we have to. risk our lives for 9 that; and I can only think of one reason. If there are more j 1
10 lives'at stake, maybe we would be willing to do that. But ,
g; 'why is this energy produced by Diablo so sacred that we all 12 have to.' risk our lives on the chance that those mathematical 13 theories are right?
34 Thanks. i 35 (Applause.)
16 JUDGE COTTER: Josephine Crawford.
17 STATEMENT OF JOSEPHINE CRAWFORD l l
18 MS. CRAWFORD: My name.As Josephine Crawford; I 19 that's J-o-s-e-p-h-i-n-e, C-r-a-w-f-o-r-d. I am {
20 representing myself and my husband and my son. )
i 21 I have . no speech prepared; and I am very 22 nervous. And I just want to say I've heard an awful lot of 23 insults; and you must feel bad. And I'm sorry about it; but 24 we are really frustrated.
25 But I have a feeling -- I was talking to a l LO. .
g
'71 hk i friend outside and she said, "Well, nothing will happen and
.U'
.'2 ft.will'all be the~same." But I may be Pollyanna and all 3 those things, but-I feel like, af ter. all I've heard, and 4 after going over the things, I am sure that this new plan 5 wont go through. I am sure'you will see that it's up to 6 any plant.
7 Thank you very much.
8 (Applause.)
9 JUDGE COTTER: Carla Sanders.
10 STATEMENT OF CARLA SANDERS.
11 MS..' SANDERS: My'name is Carla Sanders, S-a-n-12 -d-e-r-s. I am a teacher and I have been a Planning 13 Commissioner in San Luis Obispo County.
14 By law, the NRC has a specific mandate to make 15 . safety the paramount consideration in their decision. To 16 store radioactive waste on an earthquake fault, next to a 17 large population area which cannot be evacuated quickly, is 18 not safe; it's insanity.
19 Law and common sense dictate that you deny 20 PG and E's request.
21 Thank you. !
22 (Applause.)
23 JUDGE COTTER: Roberta Foster.
24 STATEMENT OF ROBERTA FOSTER j 25 MS. FOSTER. Roberta Foster, R-o-b-e-r-t-a, !
72
[ 1 F-o-s-t-e-r. .
Q) 2 We've lived in San Luis for 17 years.- My 3 family of four and I are absolutely opposed to the proposed 4 method of storage of nuclear waste at Diablo. Canyon for many
'5 'of the reasons.that have already been enumerated.
6 Safety must be-the prime consideration of the 7 NRC.
8 (Applause.)
9 JUDGE COTTER: Jane --
10 MS. PEARCE: Jane Pearce.
33 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you.
12 STATEMENT 0F JANE PEARCE 33 MS. PEARCE: My handwriting is rather 14 careless; it's Pearce, P-e-a-r-c-e. Got it?
15 JUDGE' COTTER: Thank you, Ms. Pearce.
16 MS. PEARCE: I am new at this. I am-nervous; 17 and I was hoping that I wouldn't be called. Unfortunately, 13 I am faced with it.
19 For 25 years I've been in this area; and I 20 have four children. Two are now grown and have moved from 21 the area; and I am going to suggest that my other two also 22 move'from this area. I don't think it's safe.
23 And I agree with everything that has been said 24 for years and years and years. I have been at this a long 25 time too, although from the letter-writing angle. And it I. . -
l 73
'I 1 seems to boil down to people versus money; and money seems f l
- 2. -.to' win, always. )
3 One suggestion that I think was. hit on lightly 4 by someone was that perhaps the waste-should be stored in l
5 the area.that benefits most. And I think that would not be 6 our area.
l f 7 Thank you, j i
8 (Applause.)
l l
9 JUDGE COTTER: Mr. Vince Leonard? ;
h l l to I am not sure of the spelling of the last l f- .name. It's Vince.
11 I
12 VOICE: Is it Ferraro? j 1
'13 JUDGE COTTER: I am sorry;.it is. 'l l.
VOICE:
14 Ile had to leave.
( '15 JUDGE COTTER: Mary Duenow. ;
16 STATEMENT OF MARY DUENOW 17 MS. DUENOW: .I am Mary Duenow, D-u-e-n-o-w.
! 18 I have lived and worked in San Luis Obispo 19 .since 1950; and I am opposed to the plan. j 20 But, before I say that, just briefly, I 21 understand these hearings are going to continue tomorrow.
22 And, if a larger room can't be found, perhaps.this one could 23 be rearranged because almost half the space is taken up with 24 this arrangement of tables. And we want to see your faces, 25 see if you are listening, see if you are awake, you know,
74 f(
v g- all of that.
2 I think I represent an ordinary, prudent 3 ' resident' of San Luis Obispo. And there clearly are 4 reasonable doubts. And it seems like, in America, we are 5 supposed to prove things beyond a reasonable doubt if people 6 : matter. And there are reasonable doubts about the safety of 7 the plant, itself, the evacuation plan, and this new waste g proposal.
9 And I ask you to reject this plan because no go amount.of money or electricity is worth this risk, 33 Thank~you.
12 (Applause.)
. . , gg JUDGE COTTER: Madeleine Steele.
34 STATEMENT OF MADELEINE STEELE 15 MS. STEELE: I am Madeleine Steele, M-a-d-e 16 -e-i-n-e, S-t-e-e-1-e. I am a retired educator. I am 17 against any further storage, any more than they have. Like 1
13- many other people, I've been against the establishment of 39 Diablo Canyon under the circumstances that have been in 20 force.
I 21 Ilowever, I am net going to talk any more. l 1
22 Everything that I could say has been said very ably. I 23- would simply like to call your attention to the fact that I 24 think I was number 54 on the list; and there hasn't been one i
25 person who was in favor of expanding the storage.
A m.
l
75 l' .(Applause.)
I would also call your attention to the fact
~
2 3 that you :have a very fine cross-section of the people of 4 this. community. You have people from as far away as Santa 5 Darbara who' are concerned. You have had farmers 6- represented; you have had the educational community from Cal 7 Poly. You have had professors of science, architectural 8 professors. You have had mothers; you have had business I 9 people. It's been a true cross-section-of our community.
10 You have had young families represented; you 11 have had , elderly people. You have had people . who came $
12 recently, as recently as five years; you have had people'who q 13 were born here. I, myself, am a second-generation b) 14 Californian. You have had all sorts of people. And nobody 15- is in favor. And, if you are going to represent what the 1
16 people of this area want, you simply cannot go ahead with l
17 this cockamamy plan.
13 (Applause.)
f 19 JUDGE COTTER: Doris Murray.
20 STATEMENT OF DORIS MURRAY I l
21 MS. MURRAY: I am Doris Murray, D-o-r-i-s, 22 M-u-r-r-a-y. I just want to relate a couple of personal 23 experiences with PG and E.
24 I came here about three years ago and bought a 25 little house in Morro Bay, about three or four blocks from O
l
76 1 the PG and E plant there. And, after I'd been there a month 2 or so, lying out on my deck, I realized that there was some 3 sert of brownish kind of stuff that came down out of the air 4 every now and then.
5 Go I called the plant and I told them my 6 -problem; and I said, "What is this stuff?" And they said, 7 "Well, we'll have somebody call you back."
8 And, oh, within a couple of hours, a gentleman 9 called me and said that, you know, welcome to the 1 10 neighborhood; and please be assured that there was nothing jj coming out of those stacks except steam and it evaporated 12 and there was no problems, whatever that ~ reddish stuff was 13 was not coming from their stacks. j I 14 Oh, a month or six weeks ago, there was an 15 article in the paper about the stacks at Morro Bay belching .
16 out these dark red clouds. And the article said it was 17 nitrous oxide, which -- I don't know if it's good or bad; I 18 know that's what the dentist gives you to relax you so you 19 don't get too upset when he injects the novocaine.
20 Then another experience was reading the 21 emergency evacuation plan, which I was very concerned about.
22 And I got to about page 5 or G and it said you should always 23 keep your automobiles full of gas, you shouldn't get on the 24 evacuation route without a full tank of gas, and you also 25 should not get on that evacuation route if your car was old
F.
r 9 77 L['Y . I and-broken down.
(
2: And'I walk around Morro Bay and I see more old 3 broken-down cars than' I, see new cars. And I've about 4 decided-the only thing that I can do is join them. I mean, 5 there ' are' going - to be quite a few of us left behind, I'm 6- afraid.
7 So I really do question their credibility when ,
t 1 3 'it comes .to answers to problems that we have. And I can
- 9. 'only hope- that you might question that credibility too.
10, ~Just don't approve-this expansion of the obvious thing that 11 has us all so worried, the extra storage space.
12 'Thank you.
13 (Applause.)
14 JUDGE COTTER: Nelson Sullivan.
- 15 STATEMENT OF NELSON SULLIVAN 16 MR. SULLIVAN: N-e-1-s-o-n, S-u-1-1-1-v-a-n.
17 I live in Morro Bay, in the shadow of the la sirens, which were an expedient afterthought, also.
19 The nuclear energy and the Diablo Canyon have 20 been a calculated risk from the start, low population of low 21 risk.
1 22 It's been a series of mistakes. Reading the 23 local' papers, it's like the' Perils of Pauline.
24 As the investment increased, the pencil that 25 calculated the risk got sharper and sharper. Now that we've c0 -
78
- got a billion watt potential in the' plant .of - profitable
" [d:
2 electricity, the. pencil is getting very' sharp.
3 This quick-fix patch on the storage. dilemma is 4 perhaps the irresponsible calculation yet.
5 I appreciated Mr. Hantron's mention of the 6 terrorism factor, that it's- not only in a' geologically 7 unstable area but the country is in a - very. politically j g unstable'world. Jod I hope you. realize that each of us here p represents hundreds, perhaps thousands, of' people who have go been disillusioned and disappointed by the proces's that we
- y are still going through.,
12 Thank you. I 33 (Applause.)
14 JUDGE COTTER: Shirley Bianchi.
15- STATEMENT OF SHIRLEY BIANCHI 16 MS. BIANCHI: My name is Shirley Bianchi, 17 S-h-i-r-1-e-y, B , as in boy, a-n-c-h-i.
18 Last year I.was a candidate for San Francisco 39 ' County Supervisor and I lost. One of my main platforms was l
20 anti-Diablo Canyon. And I believe that I still represent !
21 the 3,000 people who did vote for me.
22 For whatever reason, I very much appreciate 25 this opportunity-for the people in this area to express our i 24 opinions to you regarding the Diablo Canyon Power Plant.
25 The majority of us simply cannot afford to jet i 1
i J
10
i 79 j.- around the country to various hearings.
1 And because of I 2 this, we believe that, perhaps, your Commission does not ;
3 realize the intenr;e antipathy- toward this plant by the 4 people that have to co-exist with it, i
5- In the interest of time, I am not going to j i
6 repeat .the concerns expressed so well by the people .that 7 have spoken before me regarding their reracking plans for f- 3 spent fuel at the plant, although they are certainly my 9 concerns, also.
10 This hearing is to listen to the people who 11 must co-exist with nuclear power plants, as is required.
12 But for me, personally, to stand up here and say I just 13 don't like it without giving you a reason, I don't believe,. !
! . 14 would be a good thing to do.
15 The first reason I have for closing this 16 plant, of course, is Chernobyl. And I am not going to take j 17 more time discussing that.
la Locally, however, we have an added 19 complication which is, in my opinion, a total and complete i 20 inability to evacuate this particular coastal basin. We 21 have only five escape routes out of San Luis Obispo. North 22 and south on Highway 1, we have Highway 1 to the north and 25 two highways going east off of Highway 1.
24 Highway 101 is directly in the way of the 25 prevailing breezes from Diablo Canyon approximately 40 1D
80 I fi
%,) ~
i percent.of the time. Highway.1 to the north.is notorious 2 .for being closed periodically in the winter and, during the 3 winter of '82-83, was closed all winter, thereby reducing 4 the escape' routes.by one-fifth.
5 In fact,.during that same winter, all of the 6 . highways . going north and east were closed for a 12-hour 7 period due to mudslides; and that was only from rain. Our 3 soll structure, here on the central coast, is predominantly 1
9 Franciscan melange and is- subject to what is known as go. liquifaction. When it rains. the soil liquefies; it just 33 turns to mud.
12 If we had had even.a miid earthquake during
.yy 'that time, the roads would have been closed for a much 34 longer period.
15 Since I am a third-generation Californian, I 16 find it very frustrating that earthquakes were dismissed as 17 being no problem for safety considerations. We have been 13 told that -the plant has been engineered to withstand the 39 most severe earthquake. Unfortunately,. God did not have 20' access to the same engineers when he designed California.
23 Although the plant may -withstand the most 22 severe earthquake, the surrounding rock and soil structures 23 may not.
I 24 And finally, the people living in this area do 25 not know what to do if there is an emergency. An article in
\
i
,1 81 4
- [-%; 1 our local Telegram-Tribune paper, June lfth, indicated that
. \-)
2 very.few' local residents would know what to do.
3 We are a tourist area also. During the summer-4 . time, on any given day, we have thousands of visitors on the 5 central coast. If the local residents don't know what to do 6 or where to go, what makes anyone think that the tourist j 7 would know what to do or where to go?
g The whole predicament. is unbelievably 9 nightmarish.
10 Once again, thank you for this opportunity.
11 JUDGE. COTTER: Betty Schetzer.
l
- 12. STATEMENT OF BETTY SCHETZER {
13 MS. SCHETZER: I'was-going to refer to this:
14 and so I will just. leave it with you.
15 (The document was proffered to the Board.)
16 My name is Betty Schetzer, S-c-h-e-t-z-e-r.
17 I wish to add a non-technical statement, one la that addresses attitudes.
19 It is pertinent because your attitude towards 20 safety influences your interpretation of the technical ;
21 information.
22 And advertisement in Saturday's Telegrara-23 Tribune, which I just handed to you, contains about 600 24 names of local residents who are opposed to the current plan 25 for storage of radioactive waste.
D-.
s e- 82 Q'V 3 When I' looked at it, it struck me that a large 2
number, of those names were- identified as being either 3 students or . teachers so I ran ~ a rough count. And sure 4 enough, over' a third of them are either students or
-5 . teachers.- '
6- To me, that indicates.a serious' concern about i
7 .the future that' reminds me of an event that occurred in'this 3 very room ten years.ago. In 1977, a hearing was held here; 9 'it was a- packed audience representing many different go viewpoints, unlike today. There were both pro-nuclear and j 3j anti-nuclear speakers.
12 A dozen young people, to dramatize their fears gg about safety at Diablo, came dressed in rather strange-14 looking costumes. And -they presented a. lively skit on 15 nuclear hazards, their version of street theater.
16 Then, when_they were finished, an older woman, j 17 ' representing a local agricultural organization, rose in 13 _ defense of Diablo, telling the young people, "I don't know 19 - what you're worried about, we all have to' die sometime."
20 The moans and groans would have been funny if the situation 23 weren't tragic. Now, ten years later, we are all ten years l
22 older; but are we any wiser?
23- In light of all the mistakes mado since 1977, 24 perhaps this is a good time for decision-makers to change 25 their priorities and really consider our safety as their i 1
i
83
'$N Il number one' responsibility.-
~'qf' 2 Thank you.
3 (Applause.)
'4 JUDGE COTTER: Anna Alexander.
5 STATEMENT OF ANNA ALEXANDER ;
6 MS. ALEXANDER: Good afternoon. My name is 7 spelled A-n-n-a, A-1-e-x-a-n-d-e-r.
8 Thank you for the opportunity to' speak to you f
9 today. I have lived in San Luis Obispo County for 29 years.-
10 It 's . been a long time. I've followed the hearings; I've 11 attended some of the hearings. I've attended some-of the 12 walks to Diablo. I have been very' concerned of the lack of 13 importance that.seems to have been given.the testimony from 14' -. people of this county.
15 You can add another couple of names to that 1
16 list that were in the paper Saturday. My husband and.I have i
)
8 17- just returned from being o'ut . o f the county for about four ]
i is and a half months; and . we weren't around. when they were 19 collecting the signatures.
i 20 I think everything really has been said this 21 afternoon that needs to be said; so I don't want to take a 22 long time. j 23 Recently, when people have asked me whether or 24 not I support Diablo Canyon, I say, "How can you support a 25 place where we don't know how we are going to take care of
.h
i
'84
, h.. 3 :the' spent' fuel?"' you know,' what do you do about it?
it y 2 Okay.; you. know, I have been asking this 3 _ question; I asked the engineers, .I asked the people that 4 support Diablo. We haven't gotten an answer from you. I 5 have asked one who is rather prominent in the engineering 6 field. Ile says , "Well, I think that's being taken' care of:
7 I think that the answers are thera." I said, "Well why 8 don't you send me some information that tells me that it's 9 been taken care of." -- because we don't know.
10 I think one of the best statements that was gg made today -- and there have been many -- is that, unless 12 there is a safe way to store nuclear waste produced at 33 Diablo, we should not be producing this waste.
14 S there isn't a safe way to store it, it 15 shouldn't be being produced; and it isn't safe to increase 16 the amount of storage that's already being permitted at 17 Diablo. That was to be temporary storage to go to the j is permanent facility that we haven't been able to agree on 19 where it's going to be and how it's going to be done safely.
20 Thank you.
21 (Applause.)
22 JUDGE COTTER: Christine Collie, j l
23 STATEMENT OF CIIRISTINE COLLIE 1
24 MS. COLLIE: Good afternoon. My name is j 25 Christine Collie, that's Christine with a 'C'; and the last h
1 l
l
l
.l
- 85 -1 i
f .
't i name i s. C-o-1-1-1--e ' . . l V l 2 My husband and I have been residents of. the- l l
3: -city.of-San-Luis Obispo for the past la years. And I would -j
, '4 like to add our names and the names of our three~ children to 4
5 .-the list of those people who are opposed to any increase in 1 6 waste storage pools- at. the Diablo Canyon. Nuclear Power
]
1 7 Plant.
,I '
s At the time that the hearings were held for 9 licensing of the plant, it was.not the intent to store such 10 a large quantity of fuel here over an indefinite period o'f 13 time. And I think' if the people ' of the . county had been 12 aware that this was to happen, I do not think the power jg plant.would be here today.
34 I urge you commissioned members to listen to 7
o 15 we citizens-who do not have.a vested interest in the power t
16 plant, but rather have a vested interest in the quality of 17 life here in the county. And I urge you to' deny the extra 13 storage of the spent fuel.
19 Thank you.
l
< 20 (Applause.) ;
1 21 JUDGE COTTER: Jacquie Earp-Thomas.
l~ i t 1 22 I hope I didn't butcher that. l 23 MS. EARP-THOMAS: That's all right; everyone l
24 does.
25 //
iO
BG I
h.
]
3 .- ' STATEMENT OF JACQUIE EARP-THOMAS u ]
2 MS. EARP-THOMAS: My ' name is Jacquie Earp- 4 3 Thomas. .That's J-a-c-q-u-i-e: and- it's E-a-r-p hyphen j 4 Thomas, .T-h-o-m-a-s. And I am very used to explaining that. l i
5' .I am here today representing myself and my 6 family; and we've been residents'here in central coast for !
7 many. years. I have watched, in utter amazement, the g seemingly unstoppable advancements of all to do with Diablo j 9 Canyon, 10 It is incomprehensible to me that any of it gg has.been allowed, given the serious reasons for opposition.
12 Once again another serious problem is before gg- .u s ; and we are called upon to let you know our feelings.
(
34 Many have done so with great' eloquence today. Why. is it, 15
'then, that I' feel so strongly that you are going to 16 disregard us?
17 I beg you, please, prove me wrong.
gg (Applause.)
19 JUDGE COTTER: Sherry Hayden.
20 STATEMENT OF SHERRY HAYDEN-23 MS. HAYDEN: I am Sherry Hayden, S-h-e-r-r-y, 22 H-a-y-d-e-n. My family and I have been county residents-for 23 19 years. .I am a mother, a grandmother, and a pediatric 24 nurse; so I have quite an investment in the future.
25 It's late, so I will just keep this short. I J
- 10. !
/
l
f 87 I
.l ~1 just.-wanted.'to add:my. voice to the opposition and say that ]
2 it was madness - to build the plant close ~ to' an earthquake 1
3 " fault;- it's madness to - store the waste fuel there. We i
'.4 didn't want the plant; and we don't want the waste. ;
-5 (Applause.~)i 6 JUDGE COTTER: ' Steve.Paige, 7 STATEMENT-OF STEVE PAIGE-I 8 MR. PAIGE: Good afternoon; and thank you for 1 9 coming'to San Luis Obispo. And I thank the system of laws to and. checks.and balances that allowed this forum to be open 11- and:be as such as it is; and-I also thank the Sierra Club 12 and Rich Ferguson for coming here and. Rich, especially, for 13 making his. dedication to'the science of physics so that it
'14- will be -- so that physics won't become a sutijective science -
15 ratherlthan an empirical science, 16 Lawyers and engineers have a-tendency to cloud 17 facts with the artifice of their respective professions; but 18 I think that.we all need to know -- have some perception of 19~ what the risks are implied here, And to do that, I would
-20 .like to quote a draft study of a report, the Brookhaven 21 Report, which other people have mentioned. It's called The ;
22 Beyond Basis Design -- The Beyond Design Basis Accidents for 25 Spent Fuel Pools, Generic Issue 82, whatever that means.
24 I'was just trying to get a handle on what the >
' 25 risks are; and so I had a tendency to look at this document
88 IN- 3 and want to go over it and understand myself.
G 2 Now paragraph S-2 of this document states that 3 the accident-initiating. events and probability estimates 4 were made. The accident-initiating events that have been 5 considered include (1)' pool heat-up due to loss of cooling 6' water circulation capability, (2) structural failure of pool 7 due to-seismic events or missiles, (3) partial drain-down of' 8 pool due to pneumatic seal failure, and (4) structural 9 failure of pool due to heavy load drop.
10 Now estimates of the likelihood of each of 11 - these initiators are provided in Section 2'. It is concluded
. . i 12 that- the dominant initiators are structural failures g3 resulting from seismic events and heavy load- . drops. !
k,o) Uncertainties in the probability estimates are quite large, 34 15 being at least one order of magnitude either direction, 16 which -- I don't know; I'm just a lay-person, but I guess 17 that would mean that it's the' power of ten either' direction.
33 So there could be as much as a hundred percent change in 19 what they consider their values either way.
20 The second thing that I read that was kind of 21 interesting was that, in a fuel-storage accident, the land 22 contamination is two orders of magnitude greater than in a 23 core meltdown. And, again, I assume that a magnitude of 24 order is of the power of ten. So I would assume that a land 25 area a hundred times larger would be contaminated than a j
{
3.
1 - . . . . . . . . - '
89 73 1 land area in a core meltdown.
'O . 2 Ag ain , in a further memorand um from some of 3 the o rigin al authors of this document, there is so m e 4 in f or ma tion that was quit e pe r tin e n t . One of them was i
5 that the uncertainty involved in the c alc ula tion s for the !
l 6 c ritic al decay power, which is the point at whic h the 7 zirconium allo y melts off of the fuel rods, that that 8 uncertainty was 25 per cent, plus or min us, which is a 50 9 per cent u n c e r t ain t y, as f ar as I c an tell. That is q uite 10 a large uncertainty, and quite a large rang e.
11 In the c o n cl usio n s of this report, they 12 state that the power level, or se n stivit y studies, 13 in dic a te that the c r itic al power level varies from 50 sq kilo w a t t s
-Q 14 per MTU for c ylin d ric al r a c ks with large 15 o penings, to 6 kilowatts per MTU for new hig h-d en sity PW R 16 f uel storage rac ks.
17 Now, as far as I can con st r ue , is that the 18 temperature, that the power flux in the pool itself can be 19 like six ti m e s less, and you c o uld reach a c ritic alit y 20 factor, than it wo uld be if you were to store the f uel in 21 its present c o n fig ur a tio n . i l
22 The recommendations of this report were that 23 -- it was recommended that new spent f uel no t be stored in 1 24 hig h-d e n sit y r ac ks. It was also recommended that te st i
25 programs be initiated to confirm the ca pability of n a t u r al l O l K) l
90 ls 1 air circ ulation to cool these fuel storages a s se mblie s N.]
2 in the case 'of water being drawn from the pool in so m e 3 respect, in so me way. q 4 Okay. B e si d e s that, my own personal 5 experiences -- w hic h are so me w h a t s u bj e c tiv e -- with 6 earthquakes, is that I was in the Selma earthqua ke. And, 7
I remember it q uite vividly. It was about 6:00 o ' cloc k in 8
the morning. I tried to get o ut of my bed, and I 9
co uld n ' t. So I crawled on all fours o utside the door, and 10 I looked out onto about a half acre of land. And coming 11 at me, at abo ut 15 miles per hour, were abo ut two and a 12 half foot hig h waves of earth. The y co n tin ue d to r oll 13 And there was past me w hile I was tr ying to stand ' up.
'\, ) 14 also so me utilit y pole s that were four and a half feet 15 in to the ground that were swaying back and forth, going 16 through about 40 degrees of arc. That is just one 17 subjective experience that I have- had with earthquakes.
18 Another sub j ec tiv e e x pe rie n c e that I had 19 with 'e a rthquakes is: I was in an earthquake in Santa 20 Barbara. It was based offshore on a f ault belie v e d to be 21 lin ke d to the Hosgri Fa ult. T his was se v e r al years ago, 22 and it was 1 4.5 Ric h te r earthquake. I was sitting on a 23 bench right next to my car, and my car got up and leaped 24 two feet to the left.
25 Given these, given my personal e x perie nc e s,
91
,m.
() 3-2 and reading this draf t st ud y, the draft study e ssentially says to me that nobod y really knows what is going on yet.
3 I thin k it wo uld be a bit premature to approve the fuel storage at Diablo Canyon in a hig h-d e n sit y co n fig ur a tio n .
5 I think that given the 50 per cent uncertainty involved in l 6 and the fact that the ig nitio n poin t of the e qu a tio n s, ;
7 spent fuel is one-third that of nuclear fuel, of the 8 zir c o nium co a ting is o n e - t hir d that of n ucle a r fuel, and 9 the c o n clu sion s of the Broo khaven Report that the spent 10 f uel should not be closely packed and that further st udie s l 1
11 are necessary; given those conditions, I wo uld like to 12 feel that it is my, as a landowner in San L uis Obispo 13 f~s County, who feels -- and the fact that I have my f amily :
14 here -- I do not t hin k that any fuel st o r a g e sho uld be !
15 - allo we d at Diablo Canyon un til so r.e of these things are 16 better known, and better qu alifie d , and peo ple are be tte r 17 qu alifie d to make r a tio n al e v alua tion s about what wo uld 18 happen in a loss, in the fuel ponds at Diablo Canyon from 19 a loss of water.
20 Thank you.
21 (Applause.)
22 JUDGE COTTER: Marcia Mc Gee.
23 //
24 //
25 //
.(*)
v '
92' STATEME.NT OF MARCIA MC GEE MS. MC GEE:That is .' Marcia, M-a-r-c-i-a, Mc 3
' G e e , .' M - c G - e'- e . .I am . employed by a local labor union. I am here spea king on behalf of my husband, my mother and 5
my,,1f, 6
A couple of pe o ple have me n tio n e d the
~7 problems of . evacuation o ut of. this area. The group that I 8
was with studied the entire evacuation plan, which runs to -
9
'fou'r very heavy, very long, very boring volumes. The plan 10 has major . flaws. The geography, the road system 'in this 11 area pretty much negates an e v ac ua tio n. To add another 12
-ha zard . to . those we alread y f ace -- than ks to Diablo. Canyon I
-- is a bit much.
) .- 14 PG' and E n'eeds to come up with some 15 sol u tio n s for a change, rather than c r e a tin g - more 10 problems.
I7 Deny their request. It wo uld only increase 18 their opportunity to make a critic al mistake.
19 Thank you.
20 (Applause.) . ,
21 JUDGE COTTER: Thomas Schumann.
STATEMENT OF THOMAS SCHUMANN 23 ME. SCHUMANN: I am Doctor Thomas Schumann, 24 a physics professor at Cal Poly. S-c-h-u-m-a-n-n.
25 It is clearly ver y dang ero us to store hig h-
!}
93 d en sity ' .2 ucle ar . wa ste near an earthquake f a ult. And, by 2
the way, EI understand it is 15 time s, 'no t fiv e times, the
- 3 origin ally planned d ensity. T he. .re por t' by t he Brookhaven N a'tio n al Laboratory - which was kept from the public b y.
5 '
the Nuclear Regulatory Commission '-- confirms 'what common 6-
< sense indic ated anyway. Tec hnical- precautions can e a sily -
-.g'o. w r o ng : C he r nob yl, Three Mile Island, - Bho pal and the 8
Challe ng er are so me e xample s. Even the elaborate defenses
'9 of the Soviet Union were -circumvented by A teenag er in a
~10 - -
l private plane. l 11' .How can we have c o n fide n c e , then, that-an. !
'12 ear thqua ke r' sabo te ur mig h t not cause a disaster involved -
- 13
.- . in this. hig h-den sity - stor ag e ?
14 How many members of the ' NRC h a' v e been 15 e mplo ye d by the nuclear power ind u str y ? How many will 16 work for the . n uclear power' ind ustr y after their term as
~l7-
, commission is over? Can these members be objective? -How 18 can the public have con fiden c e in the ob j ec tivit y of a commission which- keeps an unfavorable report, such as the 20 Brookhaven Report, a secret? W ho se in te r e st did that
-21 serve, the public's or the nuclear power industry?
22 The supp r e ssio n of this report appears to
-23 _ r e fle c t badly on the NRC. The ~ stability of democracy 24 . depends on the trust that the pe o ple have in the integrity l
I 25 of their government. If the people have the pe r c e ption !
Oi ,
i
l 1
'94 2
l l
,, j q
YN.
--g that t'he ' a ppoin tee s . o f-. t heir government are willing to q
'2 sa c rific'e I
.t he' liv e s and safety 'of the' community in - order to. help their friends-and-associates, peo ple's ' re spect f or 4 l that government can only_ suffer. When that respec t goes, '
5 the ~ whole system of government is in danger. l 6
Thank-you.
7
'(Applause.)
0 JUDGE COTTER:- Frank Booth is it, or Bush?
Fr an k' Bush.
10 STATEMENT OF FRANK BUSH MR. BUSH: Ye s, ~ sir. My' name is Frank Bush, 12 t ha t 's B- u-s- h. I-am here r e pr e se n ting myself and. my
~ 13 f amily, . which includes three c hild r e n. I am also serving O ,4 as the con serv ation . c hair man of the San Lucia Chapter of 1
15 the Sierra Club.
16 On behalf of the Sie r r a Cl u b , I would like'
]
17 to - welcome you back to our b e a u tif ul San L uis Obispo. 'l
-18 County. .I regret that it too k a co urt order to do that. !
19 l I know that wasn't entir ely your f a ult. '
20 I am a 15 year r e side n t of San L uis Obispo !
21 County, and I am here to express the Sierra Club po sition 22 that, b a sic all y, we oppose the reracking plan. Of co urse , -
23 the technical discussion of that will begin tomorrow with 24 Doc tor ' Ferg uso n, re pr e se n ting the Club 's position.
i 25 At t his point, I wo uld like to mention that 10:
95 I
< .1- -
. 7 3,, . number 66 on t he ' list, and that;there are at le a st 12 5 . peo ple sig n e d up. I know that we are running down to
.3
-about-the last h alf ho u r. A'n d , it at all possible , I.
4
- wo uld ask you 'to pe r mit more peo ple of this. 'co mm unity 5
spe a k,. and .let them have-an o ppo r t unit y to tell , t heir; 6
. o pinio n s a b o.ut this pro po sal. In other word s,. give the m-7 some more tim e .
8 I wo uld also like to point out that I thin k 9-that.the he a ring ' site here, w hile . it has a ver y bea utiful 10 ocean view, is inadequate for the size of the group that
'~ ll re ally 'should have been expected. I personally am glad I
'12 am a Sie r r a Club member, because'I had to -hike in from a
~l3 n . parking-lot down by the beach.
14
-One of the t hing s we see when we loo k out 15
-the door here 'is the beautiful Pacific Ocean, and the .long 16 st r e tc h o f c o a stlin e swe e ping so ut h , whic h - we refer to as l It has been ' proposed as a national the Nipomo Dunes Area.
18
- se a sho re sit e . And we do not want it to be, as someone .
19 put it out here, the Nipomo Dunes nuclear f allo ut site. ) ,
20 It is for these r e a so n s the c o mm unit y, the I
21 natural environment, that the Sierra Club had filed to be. I 22 in te r v e n o r s alm o st a year and a half ago. We feel that 23 one of the things that has been missing so f ar 'has been an 24 environmental review of this project, in terms of the NEP A 25 g uidelines at the fed er al lev el, or the SEPA g uid eline s at LO- .
l l
1 96-m y
l:
I C .the st a t e l'e v el. This hearing, and the p r oce ss we have 2 -
L . g on.e . th r o ug h ' so f ar, does .no t- constit ute an en vironmen tal 3
' r e v i e' w : o f - this-.' p r oj e c t,. of this e x pa nsion. . I t! is a 4 ~
completely new r e r a c kin g d e sig n. .It. deserves .to be 5'
e v alua te d from an- environmental. standpoint toward the .
6 '
community and the natural' resources'that are out there.
-7' T he' 'histor y of accidents'in the nuclear ,
8 industr y is a reason for out in te r v e n tio n , . I thin k. i 9
'l People. have spoken alr e ad y abo ut C h e r n ob yl, - T h r ee . Mile 10 Isl'and ; : and ' so me reference - has been made to so me min o r ,
11 quote, " minor" accidents alr e ady at; the e xisting plant.
12 Coolant. loss _in the pools is a r e alistic p o s sib ilit y.
13 Ev a c u a tio n pr o ble ms are evident: it -is - v ir t u ally .1
' -O> ,4 impossible to get o ut of'here in L a fast manne'r with 15 ~
hundreds of: thousands .of people. trying to do it.
-16 When we has fire here two years ago, Hig hway-17 I 101 ~ was - locked down, and there was no ' tra f fic through :
18 :
there. I came in to town to work, took a si x- mile detour ~
19 through Morro Bay, and the tr a f fic was stacked up by 20 Hig hwa y 41 for six mile s. So, if something re ally serio us j J
ha ppen's with an earthquake and the plant, and the roads 22 are knoc ked down, we are going to be just stuck here.
23 The other thing that is apparent, for 24 e x a m ple , through the Brookhaven Report, is that there is 25 disputes among experts about the technology. And un til we A.
I
97 i
5 i
b v
go forward with more research about the g e n eric issue of r e r a c kin g pl a n ts, especially on earthqua ke f aults that are 3
a c tiv e , we need to have some more studies done in a sake 4
manner. The technology and the experts need to come to 5
some consensus abo'ut that.
6 So the prudent d e cisio n , r e all y, is to store 7
this stuff off site. If it is going to generate this 8
material, then we need to look at alternatives for ha vin g 9
the Fed e r al Gov ernmen t live up to its responsibility. The 10 Federal Government has put this PG and E in this position.
11 I am sure they don't want to be masters of this stuff for 12 40 years at these hig h levels. The Federal Government has l3 got to take it off the hands of PG and E and the pu blic 14 here, and put it in the Federal Re po sito r y that is 15 handling it alre ady f or the militar y ; or, order a current 16 utilit y that is capable of storing this st uf f to take it. 3 i
l The other' alternative is dry cask storage. ) i So we need to look at the alt e r n a tiv e s. An j 19 environmental review would do that, and we ask you to do 20 the same. Don 't risk our c o mm u nit y here, our natural 21 environment, don't make this a hig h lev el waste d ump. 1 I
22 Thank you.
1 23 (Applause.)
24 25 to s.
98 l
1
[ E .Y { N_1 g G_ {3gg1g3 2
6:00 p.m.
JUDGE COTTER: Jeanne Girolo.
4 STATEMENT OF JEANNE GIROLO 5
MS. GIROLO: Je a nne, J-e- a-n-n-e , Gir olo, G-6 h 1- r - o o . I am a teacher who has taken time off to raise ;
7 two young c hild r e n . I have lived in San ' L uis Obispo 8
County for over 20 years.
9 I ask you to r e alize that this is an area 10 whose re sid e n ts witne ss, with ever in c r e a sing disb elie f ,
Il the c o mmissio ning of a nuclear power plant near an ac tiv e
'2
' earthquake f a ult. It is an' area whose re sid e n ts do not 13 have a - wor kable emergenc y evac uation plan ; we simply do n
U not have one. Now, we are expected to standby' and watch 15 n ucle a r waste being stored in pools that are'too sm all, in 16 hig h- d e n sit y racks that are too close together, in a i
17 manner that c o uld cause an accident twice as serious as a 18
. core melt down in the event of an earthquake. i 19 The le g ac y of safety pro ble m s for n u cle a r 20 power plants is a matter of record, and the NRC is
-21 supposed to protect the pu blic . If you don't r e g ula te 22 n ucle ar power plants with the public safety in mind, how 23 can you justify occ upying a seat on this board.
24 Please, attend to the facts of the sit ua tion 25 wit h common sense, in tellig en c e , and the f ull measure of O
LJ
e
'99 2 ,1 .
7
' . y o'u r h u m a n it y . Not sim ply as agents of b u r e a u c r a tic e x pedienc y.
~
e There is still time ~ to- halt this po te n tially -
I 3'
,xp10,1y, cycle t ha t .co uld c ulmin a te in de adly silence.
4-Thank you.
5
( Applause.')
6 JUDGE COTTER: Lynne Landwehr.
STATEMENT OF LYNNE LANDWEHR
'O MS. LANDWEHR: My. name is spelled L-y-n-n-e
'9
~ L-a-n-d-w-e-h-r.
10 As a teacher-parent, and long-term resident
'll of this community, I join my. c olle a g u es, friends and-1 12 neig hbors . here ' tod ay as .we r e gist e r o ur' objec tions .to PG 13 and : E plans to increase on-site storage of Diablo Canyon's
.O.
N/ 14 spen t- f uel.
15 In this .co unty, we have, unfortunately, 16 -
- y,3rned to live with the lic e n sin g of a nuclear plant-l7 ' b uilt - be side an ear thqua ke f a ult. And we have had to 18' accept the u n c e r t ain tie s of an incomplete and l0 unsatisf actory evac uation plan. But we have not accepted 20 the inevitability of PG and E fiv e- f old ex pansion of waste ,
i 21 st o r a g e on sit e . To do so wo uld be to add yet another 22 safety problem to a scenario that has already gone on too a
23 long,'and at o ut expense. We ask a mo st careful and l l
24 re sp on sible c on sid e r a tio n of this matter. I 25 Thank you.
i .. !
i i
~
100; l
( Applause'. )-
2 JUDGE' COTTER: F r a n klin W a ke field . .
$ STATEMENT OF' FRANKLIN . W AKEFIELD 4-MR. WAKEFIELD: Tha t is ' W-a-k-e-f-i-e-1-d.
5 7 - am speaking out against the proposed 6
e x pansion of spen t n ucle ar f uel..
-7 I have read about' Chernoby1 and 'the' 8 '
stupidity, the human error that caused that disaster, that 9
caused an : otherwise prod uctive and habitable . area of:the ;
10 - - i U k r aine , the breadbasket of the Soviet Union, to become a j 11 useless wasteland ; and is, and will be c a using , much; human 12
. suffering and loss of life for so me time in to the future.
13 I don't want' a 'similar mista ke to be made here. 'l 14 It win be plan ned and' premeditated ' human 15 error to allow the e x pa n sio n of on-site radio a'c tive waste I0 which is storage at the. p r e c a rio us Diablo Canyon site, 17 already a huge and co stly ' mista ke.
I0 This area , our home,' where we have invested 19 our f uture, and the future of our c hild r en , is one'of the 20
. mo st p r o d u c tiv e and habitable places there is on the 21 planet.
22 So for you, who are involved with the 23 nuclear ind ustr y, and the d e c isio n s, to approve of a 24 disa st e r here'-- for it is a disa ste r just waiting to 25 wo uld be, happen --
wo uld make you all c rimin als in the
[;
101 i
(q g/
1 eyes of future g e n era tion s. For you who are re spo n sible 2
for the prolif e r a tio n of plutonium and other long-term 3
l poison s are c rimin als.
4 t The crimes you are committing are a g ain st i
5 humanity and the future life on this planet, our only l 6
home; the only habitable place around the sun. I know you 7
are all just doing your job. And in t his , you are like 8
the Na zis telling us Jews to tr ust you, just get intc the 9
railroad car, trust us, you and PG and E say.
10 l (Applause.) l i
11 Tr ust us, just le t us store a little more of 12 plutonium in your yard.
13
_ I ask you to stop. Don't set us'up for t his
! A J-'" 14 disaster to happen sim ply for the expediency and 15 convenience of a sic k and d ying in d ustr y. Don 't make it j 16 worse for yourselves or your c hild r e n and our 17 g r a n d c hild r e n . It is going to be hard enough for out 18 c hild r e n and g r a n dc hild r e n wit ho ut leaving them this 19 poisono us le g ac y.
20 Thank you.
21 (Applause.)
22 JUDGE COTTER: Willia m Dennean.
23 (No response.)
l 24 JUDGE COTTER: Paul Crafts.
25 (No response.)
l O l
V
i 102-l 1
>MI I
, -JUDGE COTTER: Pa ul Cra f ts, C-r-a-t-t-s?;
A
- j (No! re spon se. )' ' 'l l
-3 1 JUDGE COTTER: Bill W alper .
( No , re spon se.)
5-JUDGE' COTTER: Melanie Harpe.
0 STATEMENT OF MEL ANIE HARPE MS. .HARPE: Gen tlemen,- my name is spelled M-'
8 e a - n -i- e H-a-r-p-e. I_am a registered nurse with the 9
San Luis Obispo County C hild Abuse, Sexual Assa ult-10 Response Team, 11 ~
I'am here r e pr e se n tin g myself and my 12-l fif teen-year old twin Jda ughters, who have g rown up in this 13 co unty under _the spec ter of Diablo Can yon.
14 I wo uld like to begin by saying' that I 15 belie v e that n ucle a r power tec hn ol'og y, -in theory, and 16 in p r a c tic e ,
~
n ucle ar power t e c h n olog y, are lig ht years I
apart. Yet, they are on a collision co ur se .
18 S pe a kin g for as member of the m e dic al 19
- c o mm unit y, I wo uld like to sa y that the members of the 20 medic al co mmunity are, in fact, not able to cope with any
- 21 manner' of disaster at Diablo Canyon. Don't ask a hospital
- administrators; go to the hos pit als and ask the n u r se s, 23 ask the doctors. Ask the peo ple wo r kin g in the ho spit als 24 what they would do? They don't know what they would do.
25 I am also a member of the San L uis Obispo g ,
t e
D 103.
/
l g .f L :
.- Co unty' .Sc hool -District Co mmittee to write a plan f or 2
e vac ua tio n for' the. school- children. I worked for two 3
years on that committee with members of PG' and E,. the i
Of fic e ' ofi. Emer g enc y . Ser vic e s ' f or the State of Calif or nia ,
5 and r e p r e se n ta tiv e s from the district. As'I'said, we f
'6 worked two' ver y long , hard years and c ame x up with a pl'an 7
whic h, in fact, was un wo r kable .. .The majority of the
( 8 committee members urged the board not to adopt that plan, j
' 9 because it was u n wo r k a ble --
and is un wo r k a ble. They 10 -
- i adopted it, 'however, t hin king that' any plan is better than. !
'll nothing.
12' -In my work wit h ab used c hild r e n , I wo uld 3
. like to contend that the threat'of the' impending disaster 34 . .. l at Diablo :Can yon is, in . f a c t, a psyc hologic al ab use that 15 the children of this county have to d e al wit h d aily.
16 The last point I would lik e to 'make is,
'l7 that, PG'and E.has been c o n sist e n t : They have been 19 c o n siste n tly dishonest; they have .been c o n siste n tly.
L - 19 lacking in - in te g rity ; they have been consistently lac king .
20 in concern for the members of this community.
21 (Applause.)
22 I wo uld like to end wit h a quote by Daniel 23 Ford, a' man who has written and studied the nuclear power 24 ind ustr y e x te n siv ely, quote:
25 .'When standing on the edge of a pre cipic e ,
..D j
A
'104-
{
I J ' t he only prog re ssive move . is. a step bac kwar'ds. "
- i. I . urg e .you to have the co urage to ~ ta ke that 3 '
step backward and face r e alit y , and d ecommission Devil's Can yon. Power ' Plan t.
c 5 Thank you.
'6 (Applause.)
-7 JUDGE COTTER: Pat Renshaw.
O STATEMENT OF PAT RENSHAW 9
MS.. RENSHAW: Tha t is R-e-n-s- h-a-w.
10 I just' want to go on record as asking you' to 11 vote against the r e r a c king system that the y are pro posin g
. 12 at Diablo Canyon presented by. PG and E.
13 It is always ama zing - to me to se e the NRC-i '
just- king of shut t heir eyes to all the blatant errors 15 th'at go on, you know, out there at the plan t , done by PG 16 ,and E. Then, I read in the paper that, with. all the money I
that wasLspent on buildin g the pla n t , the y. co uld ha ve 18 b uilt three plants.
19 Also, I just want to know if the same 20 m a n a g e m e n't' that b uilt PG and E is going to b uild the .
21 r e r ac king pools?
Pe r so n ally, the management that I have seen 23 o ut there, and the work that they have done on the plant, 24 and ~all the errors and all the money spent, I would rather 25 see yo u all somebody else in and let them b uild the p o ols.
L, ,
' 105 m
+g "
'3'
() : Because I. personally don't trust them to do the work.
2 Also, I just hope the y don't b uild them 3
- backwards.
'(Applause.)
5 JUDGE. COTTER: Amy, Shore.
0
. STATEMENT OF AMY SHORE MS. SHORE:
Tha t is S-h-o-r-e.
O I have been a re sid en t of San L uis Obispo I O County for about' four years now. I currently am a student 10 a t ' Cal . Poly. I don't own an a utomobile, by the way, so i 11
.d on 't know how I would get out.
12' But I work at the - En vir o n me n tal Center of 13
.: ISan L uis Obispo, and we operats a r ec ycling o p e r a tio n.
'34 4
.The- reason I bring this up is bec a use, what we are talking 15
.about is nuclear energy and nuclear wa ste. I wo uld just 16 like to go on record as saying that I read fig ures that 17 indicate- that, if our Government put the same amount of 18
. energy that it puts into cor porations interests, such as 19 oil and nuclear power, if we put as much energy into the 20 c onse r v a tio n pr a c tic e s that the W e st Germans and other 21 Eu ropeans use, we would save enough money in one year in 22 this country -- one year alone ! -- to pay off our national
- 23 debt.
24 We don't need oil. Twenty per cent of the 25 energy that we put into just packaging, like pla stic that
.n
L 106' 1
(we all use everydayi they could be done dif f e r en tly, and
~
that we cold : sa v e ene rg y. b y rec ycling ., Twenty per cent of .
3
- our: energ y is put' towards that. ' W ell, *2 0 pe r c en t . of ' o u r 4' .
I energy needs are met.from imported oil. :It :just kind of 5: '
.makes-you think of 'what's happening in the.. Persian G ulf 6
rig ht now.
Is this necessar y? It is not.
8 '
N u cle ar Power is not n ece ss ar y ; we don't n_ e e d , it . . Okay?
' 10 -
I just wanted to sa y that because'of'my Il conn ection ' with the recycling e f fort. - I wanted to say it ,
I 12 for a long tim e , so here I am.
13 I wo uld- like to address the n ucle a r waste
_14 e x pa n sion issue. It is the European Scientific 15-Community's general knowledg e, and it makes me wonder why 16 it is.not g e n e r al k n o wle d g e here.- I haven't read it
'7 an ywhere' in the- press of the United States. But the fact
-18 is that the . European Scientific . Community has e stablished 19 that the se c ond plume that passed over the So vie t Union,-
20 and all of Europe, and par ts of the Northern H emis ph e re ,
21 . .
as well --of the Western Hemisphere -- were caused by the 22 nuclear waste sto r ed on-site , r e ac ting' f rom t h'e fir st 23 e x plo sio n that happened days.before. You can pretty 24 e a sily - t ell this. You can c he mic ally a n aly z e the pl ume that goes over from t'he e x plo sio n . You can ' see that it O . v l
1 l
J J
107
( came from f u el. You a n alyz e the plume that went over 2
three days later, it was clear. It was caused by the 3 -
r adio a c tiv e wa ste stored on site r e a c tion from the heat, 4
whic h has been addressed v e r y well here alr e a d y , how 5
s u sc e ptible it is to heat.
6 I wo uld like to ask: Are we going to wait .,
7 u n til something like this ha ppen s? U n til we do, like, 8
what Cha n c ello r H elm ut Kohl of West Germany has done, and 9
go in a g ain st n u cle a r power --
not un til a f ter C h e r n ob yl, 10 by the way.
11 I wo uld just lik e to read a quote from a 12 paper r e c e n tly put out in March by the World Watch 13 In stit ut e : " Re a sse ssin g Nuclear Power, the Fallo ut from
(,-) .
I C he r n ob yl. " I recommend everyone to read this. The World 15 Watch Institute is an ind e pen d en t n o n pr o fit rese a r c h 16 o r g ani z a tion funded, in p a r t ., by the United N a tio n s 17 Org ani za tion :
18 "In some n a tio n s, the debate has begun over 19 whether to close existing reactors. Three countries 20 with n uclear plants have decided to abandon nuclear 21 power, and six that have se r io u sly c o n sid e r e d 22 n ucle a r power have decided not to proceed further.
23 Antinuclear advocates are no longer con fined to the i 24 politic al f ring es. Included in the ranks are the 25 Prime Minister of Austria [ w h e.t h e r he is nazi or
^3 t
V o
108 l
("')
%)
not; he is against nuclear power now]; the P re sid en t ;
of the P hili p pi n e s , and the leaders of the main 3'
o ppo sitio n p a r tie s in Great Britain and. W est -
4 Germany.
5
" Prime ' Ministe r Ingvar K a rlso n of !
6 -
Sweden, once pronuclear, assessed the damage to his 7
country after Chernobyl and ' concluded nuclear power 8
must be got rid of."
9 I, for one, wo uld be most grateful, and I will do everything in my power to see to it that we do not I
have to wait for a Chernobyl in the United States, and 12 here is our community, bef ore Ronald Reag an, or whoever is 13 p r e sid e n t, has to say that.
(
'- 14 Thank you.
15 (Applause.)
16 JUDGE COTTER: Dia n n e Randazzo.
17 STATEMENT OF DI ANN E RANDAZZO 18 MS. RANDAZZO: I wish it was as easy to 19 clean up this act a s it was changing a diaper; but, alas, 20 .
It .is not. <
21 My name is Dianne Randa zzo, R-a-n-d-a-z-z-22
- o. I attended y first an tin u cle a r d e m on st r a tio n in 1977.
23 I have attended v ario us r allie s and d e mon str a tio n s and 24 other f u n c tio n s, stated my f e eling s and vie ws on nuclear 25 power, and have said all along that I am ag ain st it. Now
-!3 V .
l
U . 109 ll-
- e. 4'-
' you' are ; allowing us one more chance to state our- f eelings.
So, he r el I a m tod ay'-'to sa y : I a m 'still . a g ain st ^ it . .I 3^
have more reason than ever, now: 'I hold him in my hands.
. And . I 'just hope that, one of these times, (yo u will listen 5
to us.
- 6. '
Thank you.
JUDGE COTTER: Tim e ;.is getting along. I 0' thin k . We will ta ke two more and, then, sto p.
'O
,. Terry Drury. Is Terry Drury here?.
10 (No. response.)
11 JUDGE COTTER: . Evelyn Delane y.
12 (Applause.)
13 STATEMENT OF'EVELYN DELANEY' 14 SUPERVISOR 15 SAN LUIS OBISPO COUNTY BOARD OF SUP ERVISORS 10
, MS. DELANEY: I of f er. this testimony as a 17
. member of the San Luis Obispo County Board of Supervisors, 18-
.the supervisor who represents the district in which Diablo 19
. Canyon is located.
20 (Applause.)
21 When the plan t was first pro posed, there was
- 22 '
skepticism. We were assured and r e a ss u r ed that the plant' 23 would be built properly 'and the waste would be stored in a 24 repository somewhere else.
25 W ell, the con str uc tion is histo r y. We are 6
9 110-
-1 f
f aced now with the prospect of 20 years of nuclear plant 2
waste being stored at o ur . doorste p. Storage of n ucle ar 3
waste next to an active ear,thqua ke f ault is in sane.
4 The' pro posed '. r e r a c kin g will raise- the 5
maximum - number of f uel assemblies in the ' plant storage
-6 pools . from. 270 to '1324. These rods will be closer .,
'7
.together, so close, in f act, : the y - could ig nite t hemselve s 8
without touching each other, it the c ooling water was lost .
9 for any reason.
10 A recent report from the Brookhaven Natio nal I
Laboratory rec'ommends that high-density racks not be used 12
. a t all .
i 13
'It is clear to ' me that 20 years worth of 34 ~
spent f u el -- that is, 1324 spent f u el r od s -- in a hig h-15
. d e n sit y con fig ur a tio n is a real hazard to the peo ple of-this county. With the history of errors.at the Diablo 17 Canyon ' Nuclear Power Plan t, I certainly am opposed to the 18 high' density reracking and further operation of the plant, 19 as.long as no safe waste storage f acility exists. i
- 1 20 Thank you.
]' 1 (Applause.)
22 (The document was proffered to the Board.)
23 JUDGE COTTER: Ka t hle en Hilt o n .
STATEMENT OF KATHLEEN HIL TON 25 MS. HILTON: My name is Kathleen Hilt o n .
"O .
i 111 f
es 3 C) I r e ally don't have a lot to add after you 2
all yo u have heard this afternoon. But I did want to add 3
my voice in o ppo sition to PG and E's plan to store fiv e 4
time s as much r adio a c tiv e wa st e , as the spent fuel pools 5
were designed to hold.
6 I am a teacher at St. Pa tric k 's School. I have lived in t his county for 20 years. I speak for my 8
f amily and _ for the studen ts I teach.
9 I ask you to ple a se c o n side r the lives and 10 the safety of the - people of this community. Remember that 11 our lives and safety are on your conscience.
12 Ple a se , say no.
13 f (Applause.)
14 I STATEMENT OF COLI'N MOULTON 1 l
15 MR. MOULTON: I am Colin Mo ulton.
16 I didn't come prepared, b ut I guess I am 17 sort of fig h ting fire with fire. I agree strongly with 18 Ann Morgan, that I sort of so und lik e a broken record.
But, not r e ally, because of the insanity at hand. I agree 20 with I think it was Teresa Des Hotel that my death 21 c e r tific a t e is being sig n e d. I don't t hin k I sho uld have ,
22 to plan my future when all livin g bein g s liv e for, the 23 so ul purpose o f lif e , my f amily, my future f amily, around 24 a po ssible n ucle a r disaster. And I won't be told that 25 there is nothing to worry about. Because tha t is sort of, m
,/
112 r~^3 1 kind of--
'w)
Nuclear power is ing enio us. But the ab use 3
of it is q uite the contrary. And I would r e ally like to 4
grow up. And my choices may be denied because money has 5
to change hands, and so me individ u als --
or more than 6
in divid uals, groups of peo ple -- belie v e that that is all 7
there is. You -may not want to listen to the inexperiences 8
of youth, but you really oug ht to consider who is going to 9
be around when it really counts.
10
-I have been ta ug ht, as I grew up, not to Il make messes because of the inconvenience of cleaning them 12 up.
13
, (Applause.)
'v' 14 But I thin k we ought to prevent a le sso n so 15 t he c hildren don't have to clean up their parents me sses.
IO Thank you.
17 (Applause.)
]
18 JUDGE COTTER: Thank you all for coming.
19 You brought a broad section of the community in, and we 20 a ppre cia te your interest. It gives us some clear sense of 21 how the people in this room f e el.
22 The hearing will reconvene at 9:00 o ' cloc k 23 tomorrow morning.
24 We are adjourned un til 9:00 a.m. tomorrow 1
25 morn i ng .
m ,
L)
113 I
( W her e upon, at 6:26 p.m., the hearing in the V(3 2
above-entitled matter was adjourned to reconvene at 3
9:00 a.m., June 16, 1987.')
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 11 ;
12 13 (l]
v 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
()
m i
g-g CERTIFICATE OF OFFICIAL REPORTER
( .
]' 't, .'
.This is -to' certify that the attach'ed proceedings before-
'the UNITED STATES NUCLEAR -REGULATORY COMMISSION in the matter of:
NAME OF~ PROCEEDING: PACIFIC GAS AND-ELECTRIC COMPANY (Diablo Canyon Nuclear. Power Plant, Units 1 and 2)-
4
)
d i
DOCKET NO.: 50-275-OLA, 50323-OLA i PLACE: AVILA BEACH, CALIFORNIA
(- .
D DATE: . MONDAY, JUNE 15, 1987 were h' eld.as herein appears, and that this is the original transcript thereof for.the file of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
/ I (sigt M -
(TYPED) MARGkRE DEVERS b
Official Reporter j Reporter's Affiliation O- !
~
k m E m o__._ ._.__
. Tom.Merkel '
"g
) ll PRMotti 80 < STnC PE ' ' U'*E 'a DATE JECT Id D W'TM Y) G .fic #i G i 7- F227 Ntnr: I44 l in we rlLMet q v se e v- 1970 l bog 'r <,ci s Mecc Gis ts eu coc o n c twine-
_.hM$2LA C t_? gspacTLD A qu y gg 60 c r. \OO g
. ,m_ze m ~ ~ > ~ mr<> ~
-wt yveg carn av a m cy Ew Per21 m cc, NW �l ? kLC. ? Y TU - _ . . . .
CAllV GJ A 5 l A bhTS D 61 ( U lilD into &-CldCCIC VU}.T'i._% ;. .N l d_1%1 Ali 7Ht 95r+GTIFJL Tt M4 it]_ . _ _ _ . _
j~ . _
71DtT tm SttysS__cg5cvriAtty_ Sc;gpiscAlgy
. _ _ NE.i OM.E _ J .382___.I I' _!I2.N1# 6 wrtoven ter .
Ge Duce _ _D. . T o. . ._.. . _.
. . _ . . _ . . . f. . . v. . e v. i.. . . t. r ov:,c.. t T. _i E_s_. . _ A t%
- . [--
2V. . d. . , M.. .D$T hb Vb
_ ;. g e ..-.W- .i d. -.-.k-I..N
-- . %d 6 . - . _ . . - -
. - _ . _ . . . . .. [. .b b d @_k.. ..[_bM S. .I$ Y _.. $.b N/fT. _
rn c ro nic acir>c s Ave coaten
- I. .. . . _NI$ A . 6b.ffS9k _f..._8D D .? II h___ ^ MMIM_RAAEaP
- E EMe15 W _
90 fu e . in wr 4r L <.t sf '
Q c_19 U. M.M-t m c k n_y, s C'h%c 481c v a A n incManoit M f}:e CF W A _L f t ,J T abutr$ 0 S g q TC)Vt b h EHW9CA tg2vac t s a s,n w k.is As &% TW s Aut! A s e<W 9' #1 n i~
0 I' f _5 f_____" W f l} f) g
O fe r A
'(_
-u).
e
' t} 4 :
34 1, [ '
3 Sf30 -
s,-___._
7 .
3
, 2220 pu DQ- a J~ A t
f, D D Y ttlt (t/ '
p ( WOft k Q v
- .3 ^
b L 0
- O O (/v gAft : f sf l $ s.#fft 4
9 I
I l
f
'fe l
i l
h O
d diiilinetwo... ..,, . . __
memo
~
FROM Tom Merkel DATE TO T* M U' SU8 JECT O M N 'M . [Lf NM vc &civw TC (:Tt Th t' W el2 D CW, l@
unix C O M M u u t t. ATs o.4 L A f' C Cuf MTL ft A QvA Le .
((cp A RS, WC (yo p(,e TV CV+CV4T5 ,
8F OjA F F-$iW A13 Mt flock <D uttil COLL A f5 ED O v e (19M.*>c 5 f ki c Atts (r u m ( A PIGG , DiW GLc CA A)'1 og iS A (rOfn 64 MCr.
L cr s__Gi v e g c< np T <str u tte r T5eH NG LD6 7_
g clen ,. pot-cos nc m ou v WM0I.NJbb3._IO2[_ bN.NIkbW _ _
2 4'H *f4 N IMf E f_M W __.
- M9WYk%MW3hm SK@h__
- M L. B&T-. % e M' M v.L M ChcW?fs-
._._ _._. W L .P 0 M 9 ? I N M M Ef __ _
9tG1neas -
.- A .-.'AUT?2M. ?? L L Hl'r2('*L -
.--- ._. 3! ' en ..E't 1 < L ElD * .
,9e+ .
O. .- .. -. - --
e.kw*st e*p9)***.+.e=h-#w
-he..ew.w m a
- e kur twem e.mwum
,..r+~.
I T bli$ li JN P fl^fTi Q .
'9
, jbd ) bM g h 16 M cr%A , a T% moo dwnynem A CAD-6wL .L tiv (M% Tha cw .dia , e d s l wA a u ggu m coa .
\
>% H A~W > k c1m M* J O ksnmmo ,
ed ,Le gnam;) qn m - .
c 9r k ^\1d W iNod
}
rk a ns 6 %, nem ud- , 1 c <J '
4 a wne, ~ , L, mm sa-> ~ n tug m , r% n at < v 4 4&~1 a slud.
gY am c) u ka.G L o nq 4 W sL U na<$LM fet Oh . /
b Ld d C > vrw sjIfv T- L kW q w M '%0 unc v1am ,rhs J.m '
a um
/ uw e.c nww A ,
bl n5 & sAu e rua c2ca w ,~ - > van os um a w 9s e dm-
'C1 a av s S c4 cLuv> b Mo S
/ 'M fnN St& y hC U!n sE o
-l & xv .us , sw J Nr pm
& ~1 ~1 uh id n m %udAL% .
b l io l 7 '
$ - nnc 9 pr uw4 sa cis&)
i l 1 i OI
% ? n 1 h ik ~ 72 n shsunt b :~ , si n )
. i sf ydee m& ummut x awp& ..
_ ec ue mad cQ sf uh . 7M _i3. p sle avaJd4 _j TD Tk f als h c .
./&LF' ' $r- tcy i
[Sga44~I C G MV Op G/7 Ca< v U>sh wwsi . - e- - - -
o_. .,m o== .,,o w _me_,_, .
gs ,,,e em-se. * -+ + - -w4*- %e+-,,o e _-. n.
u
..,pa..ee,i,- #-- e-,-,e.m.-. .aps.e. +w--a,.w.,m am.,..ep.._,-w-a. m.a ., m.--.-- .--,s- *-ma -.=***-=-*a ' w--.m. ,4.i.-se.- -me.a.m- -ee,-4-e-i
{
~1 1
I O ,
1 N . i -- - - - - - - - - - ____
- sn 3 o N A ME+ADDRE S s Scsm b A/lt* % k
// / den /9'&yj~rf Sr4x M he t35 Cet4 9] cts 3 g, 9goww wa% AM5yv%ct s.L,C. .
9340i 3 o Qcyy g 238 Smbjg .y.
k [ kpidiC' @\, 1 M - ~ ,
OYVD ~'55%
C W\
% Killaitch% fyaa.o At DCcum hj\. & dadic ufg.f&es" e A ' 3 a : u cu cm u C am ca w 30 s Azu coloer aa Lun & Oc d Lacs cong,an4q f blS B te86f- 1 2 2 045As.) 9LO Q Sif ELL 3GMd, & cf '3W9 1 STus KM .sys /OGsx An laps ennte, M.f:59s/
lD CRAdr EMrH&h P.O.$ct 956 ka ac fo 6th W d E 0 4 W 26 lI Deo q l ee4 '^7 3 I P.,'cek'c51A C , 'l 3 9 0/
f 2 . h e_, t 0 M g Nat,Ne- SbS.,.,]_s0613baw Ed. Awpe A (1 A93
(] B Weivw beauu t%- itmus 4,0. s& ton sesmce'%l (Y do L % c e;, S h r N e. 1 4 h r' LA c/cy k ,G orn yCr Lu LF 2;~u .rra %sa(}f b'i c.
/s 6 a. Ro A saz. Aq dA 9390 A7 sa2,?.'sda%Qo
& & P390' g /Gdlw db b asys Gy ' no 14tosn 4 x 3 o /. s4 ' ' .4 y svo y vd 9' fcdi/EBec/A'eris27 RIs'n Ge 12>rgs A Ju ne uc..}C&e- niis piew L,w na-ag
}
0! & lo; w Re:c wn L%y.uy k L BJ,.73 yay
- 22. % L W nnc go, a a a sa %g w2 Jache Oleeleu)
- M23 ($Ueiee Ms /okhmz y Maue LXLc4f'9 G a5 Ann 14f% a- /s70 3:,w,a p NL tn, eme A6 917ardVk/7};M7a&n P O fle, 153/1 1, St D. '7560 G 21 (349ce //oweawd 23y 50 Ac
{ szc>uy,wc nw
$4 e 2r Gaz vate as ran 2m n n
skeeL{
(~' ,
m N e4 ME.+ AWRES3
{D! A l l l // f j k, , ? l
" 10 ff fEMcK kz5~/v$c, hv b gr
- g. n; wa - z'- n;n-1, g%;w '
cl cy.y cho M) &,& A>w &
d .6,f //d \
~ 33 A~L4 4 mr4sA4a4
- >d(Lsa, a y n J s<o vsre, \
n9 As ' S -- wrs s rv un c ,,2 s. 5 Lo n m; 3G eulut Ak R cs C* a d'& % 934of l
- 37 Ccd l(
" OS - N: b'N2 lVqp$GlQ 1 L. & @3920,w]T%kti Jh ap la%
%JtLJ v'ss w u am
()
~.
N}A a- j/ i e
e37 Nov&w%p,%s s t a c n v a vei
/
42 c& ve & M m s % %uoca w i
" W3 'htk cWg/ <ez?/L/$naf&& & 939q'/
% daaw t-c s k J n n & 6 < p aceC p A cf ?
% 01 % lt bnuefy 93nt
' fs kl5O. 'D25hebj M 0)Mn } SAYdN 03, kf TbW!
- V7 D]O6 T%stn z?m y sr #er wiva dq a 1940/ \
-9 -W acw sce. S e c 6 =L d s% em % i ve v3D-
- hv6L 66o ocaua S6ahuPytt '7'lS' Mlkwc/s 5 M, sidb vel. nodn~g usi O r k,~ a u SLb i f2~ f Og5, h Wdm> aooua a ao %
/0s 76un .
+>s&th no qseo i i
> BT ]?$whSyz ,9h /6Cf &/)fcaLit))r. 'ACy 98y23 P fL F9 es usq q ,w s w a n\ b % ++v l k[Sc.u p$odimus H m 9mme j e br Dr[(A j
ww me ft N AME+ ADDRE S S cd'7. 5 h iile 13tkuc h i, n'7 den $deo a CdIfd j (Antbet;+$h $r tss5'fwn*t3 13 8 % Sck.fm a20t
- 6' $% Jhymutev Elas(c-.Sf. 5LO , 3L 6 75Wat 1 0 CS A Cdli lM LOyLv &LD 'T3YoI )
dal y au fa . %n 71+Bf/ M . sto pyoj
- 3,I e QTflO kb S LO' 9 3 'lof
'ATC4Y lM( 6805 TO2O (P F4170 CA YY?-L >
M d,hM tc., k kN OEveme n. ?!!CCRPNfo,q"4Ld RC , i y 93'/ C'l 4 V[OS l11)?/2df/q ' /72 GES c % ) S n > e R c)t O ALC). 739'd/
$k THOMAS SC//s)h/)WN fo30 PG2Kms #S $10 9 8 <} o l i 4 7,
- Y w h 8 /J k M 8 T V 5 }f & 9 3 't > 1 h? 44 % e h 5 /o / 730vfule M O- 93V6I
$ h7 '
nt bedwelc.e 364,9 Fwi% & 73%/
r%k m ake4 43++t 7(
72-70{Wba.1rL' J2+r&& l<A 40 /OYO 7 OI$r h evk cNuo '
' fu.
(fA kG (1(2A T5 ()So &ccrn /r 9 (eS OSo.s
% r u y Q. Lo y W 6J J M {it % %T % poi k , 3L.9G- 3 T 2- 6
~7T b l\ L _)d4b.e r) '7Tb b a6.
45' M/9ie dagP Sir kram b & 9Naf L/f(o fR(TkE/V5ffAf.o /da6 6t=6L6E ST. SLQ '/Plc( ~
97 /]7Wf $HCtE S'OA fl5Md ~540 O'/0l-78 %2 wpAzzo PN> Wcu& Cwm Ci5 438 b%
t('; (EVGh*ht/ b)GLA SOAAD AlY/2316tOffed 6 F %PG?L/ISd/CS %
0e % o a t - m 't ~ -u we,u sot,*suo e n Qo w N U c h (( tkv H n n m 2 M s a ct " o 5
?'-l 00 (doW C s1, Pd Hctd 0<p'X . , % U Y 07 8 Shycs WL%,d t%g S, A3,qo Go A Ga.
i n
v NkWE+ AbbRES3
[0erkmwr 156. 314 }#gueA St S% la8. obisp
- 36) Y .9 pvt N/ M RO W u s'3 CA p C25.
67
-pd) sprtTh#.gwe CRwsL PO BM e5 CMecA
- 1 gybggl%,. y /, .
q 44' -
j S8 "tM SHo % /d &Ao 7340/
3T W3s c2arwe to Sto 9 5 y's t "
Grt-entA/-l}d To. D i n a.i ta 2 B A t o u)< D S6e Ownt;sk, Sto 9Ffoi 11 94L 6'uipv.s solo Enueu sin su-o 7 340/
93 /7//C/e/ )Ttvd/o/en 2
Ad. Ony D07 SLO 9'L7d 3
'l S '77b <
9'f- L t Oned./ 2_ /9a 0 Q/&cA.4c , g02, c737ag f3 e,3 bD 70ht+ % ;;oSwl1 p%
(70 llin h ,eut(g TOD <409TEkt$ Acc fA0Eto B4j CQL(41 Y Okw b hkmC, 24'; (:s %A sk le3 (%3 9.ht 106 9I'rvv 1 . 65Y 59een I-ene SLO ]' MDI fof /.ul' fl'c (cJ7 M ykua W 9 No l utc I/9 3 ((a t Lir L L y% S Lo ) 'jp6(
/03 Da c,o w c>u Cow,o '76y')hwna$,1n 3n 0% sbu %A, cA 93e+y im u>m,% t. waas ss s. wgm h , m.0, cA. ma DG M GlacBurrui Po.coxiow Gaar>uact, an 93 cng-AQ~ >GQ /$60 Wgg &73YBf
, l06 Q @l C D/
IDT mo -
m Ms[/1'2/.5f %
Jzoosc"]
89060Sr.
Sw, 4m/
to r Q g k co Q . bw M 40 So 9 moi
/a f' Ito Mb 1 bMbe &
go Fox g,Ar9 Af os e f 7 9'/ 7._-
g4 GA so '7310/ l' C tu. 4 pin #% t n351e st hy%fc spu
((a Duna Kanaw 77a feiauyRe Nipwcn WW I esse / M ao Q B n ( 2 )\ c m b i m , Ca . 93LR6 ;
IO(5 x STB!EAMEl&ideer'- hv1 Row 0,$A%PD OQdQQ NM 7
~.- .. ._. .. .. _. -. .-
, 1 County of Scn Luisdbispo EVELYN DELANY !
SUPERVISOR DISTRICT 3 3
-s TESTIMONY BEFORE NRC
( ) ' l
~ ' ~'
JUNE 15, 1987 t l
,c _ , 4 EVELYN DELANY, SUPERVISOR " " ""^ '"*"**
I offer this testimony as the member of the San Luis Obispo County Board of Supervisors who represents the district in which the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant is located.
When the plant was first proposed, there was skepticism. We were assured and reassured that the plant would be built properly and the waste would be stored in a repository somewhere else. Well, the construction is history.
7 s, V
We are faced now with the prospect of 20 years of nuclear plant waste being stored at our doorstep.
Storage of nuclear wastes next to an active earthquake fault is insane. The proposed reracking will raise the maximum number of ,
fuel assemblies in the plant's storage pools from 270 to 1324.
These rods will be closer together, so close in fact that they could ignite themselves without touching each other if the cooling water was lost for any reason. A recent report from the Brookhaven National Laboratory recommends that high density racks not be used at all.
O
.J
g
) l t
- u. ,
l j
/~) ]
\v l
It is clear to me that 20 years worth of spent ' fuel - that is 1324 i i
spent fuel rods - in a high-density configuration is a real hazard q to people in this county. With the history of errors at the Diablo - I Canyon Nuclear - ' Power Plant, I certainly am opposed to the high-density reracking and further operation of the plant as long as no safe waste storage facility exists.
I l
.# # # l 1
i l
os i
i I
i j
i
(_)
L ,
i i
June 15,.1987' PG&E's Plan to store High-Level Radio -
f)
' active. Wastes At Diablo Canyon.
Meeting Place for today's hearing by the NRC licensing' staff ist Bay View Room', San Luis Bay Inn, Avila 1 l
Beach, California'.
Mr. Chairman, Staff members:
My=name is Willard N. Jonee. My wife, Elizabeth, and I are P, I here.today.from Downwind country, Santa Barbara city and )
county. Other hearings we'have addressed in this area of l Diablo. Canyon'have been about Emergency Evacuation planning, and we stress today that there is still no adequate Evacuation )
Plan for the entire Southcoast Area.
Because 'we are Downwind, just as Scandinavian countries were
.t p)..
Downwind from Chernobyl, we are the normal recipients of Airborne Matter generating at Piablo. Our City of Santa Barbara is located in a. basin similar to Los Angeles, the ocean on one side and encircling mountains on the other - any fallout therefore settles in over the' City.
l There are only 2 exits in and out of the City other than by water'(ocean) so any block ~ ages of roads for any reason would be catastrophic. . Add to this the potential < disastrous effects of polluted water supplies, obviously cause for deep concern.
Today - we urge you to REJECT PG&E's plan to store Radioactive Wastes in an inadequate and overcapacity manner, which courts o disaster. Whentthe. Original Planned Capacity for Waste Storage U is reached, the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plantrshould be Shut Down. ma. & yms. w. s. ;oses US 71',T.b 4ms
-l I
-June 15, 1987 '
! To: NRC I am beginning to feel like a broken record - but when I realize that the nuclear industry is still dealing with the same problem too, i.e., nuclear waste, it is no wonder that the content of my comments have. changed so little.
In view of the fact that the problem of disposing of nuclear waste -
.has not been solved, it seems reasonable to request that further storage at an unacceptable site be halted until the problem is solved. We have the classic " cart before the horse" scenarib-~
We can no longer hold to the 19th century belief.that science will solve our problems before disaster occurs. We have every right to insist that problems of the magnitude of storage of-nuclear waste be solved - or if' the best scientific minds cannot provide us with a solution that we cease creating further health hazards until such time as we can get the " horse before the. cart" Please place the health 'and safety of the people before the needs of the industry.
Th Q$qnkyo$.On f/kW u^-
Ann Morgan, hD Associate # fessor Psychology and Human Development Dept.
California Polytechnic State University San Luis Obispo, CA uCALVIN AND HOBBES e ,A ff: ($; BILL WATTERSON HEE 5 A OVER. WE B25.TMESE uf WE CAMCER 'RATE IF %Qg
. HERES A MERE COMG M BVd.901ER, s LITRE PUSLllNG TejsAtADSOF SIEAM5 HOVEL DAEER00S TOSORS SEEPk 0F THE HEA9B(' WAMT ME, TOWN. SC00Pl% OUT BARRELS OF TOMC R\X1 EAR Vgg (HDEMDjRD WMERWMS[ UME TOWti, lu. BE
. A GtAMT HOW. WASTE t%TO % G\ ART H01.
l M\PLES. DER THE h
Mg?&M
~
oi $gyh@
eeee me -
m_
)
l 2727 Rodman Drive !
p- Los Osos, CA 93402 J ,)4 June 10, 1987 Office of.the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Docket Nos. 50-275-OLA '
Docketing and Service Division . 5 0- 3 2 3 -OLA' i Washington, D.C. 20555
Dear Sir:
)
A few days ago,.a letter.from Mothers for Peace alerted us to the fact that PG&E intends to store nuclear waste from Diablo
' Canyon, right there in the canyon. Naturally we were dismayed
.at this, for PG&E had promised that the federal government would find a-place, removed from any community, to store the waste before Diablo went into operation.
We learned that: l
- 1. PG&E plans to store five times as much waste as the waste pools were designed to hold.
- 2. The waste may have lost its efficiency, but it is still active: One hundred-tons of dangerous, radio-active stuff, to be contained indefinitely, in a steel
.( shell only k" thick.
3.'If stored improperly, the quantity and density alone, of this spent fuel could create a nuclear disaster -
without'the worse possibility of a major earthquake.
We feel that saving time and money is not reason enough to harbor
- a. demon.. Life itself is more important than that. Instead, we implore you not to allow radioactive materials to be stored near populated areas.in San Luis Obispo County. And certainly not in pools at Diablo Canyon which, by being overcrowded, could affect everyone who lives nearby.
The following are signatures of friends and neighbors who have read this letter and feel as we do.
Sincerely yours,
&amb 24}LU Mr. and Mrs. Edw d L. Fisher cc: Leon Panneta, Congressman i Jeff Fairbanks, Managing Editor Telegram Tribune l Rich E. Fergusen, Ph.D., Professor Cal Poly J
(")g
(_ June Von Ruden, Spokesperson Mothers for Peace !
r' l:
e, t
i f
June 8, 1987 Office of.the Secretary Docket Nos 50-275-OLA U.S. Nuclear' Regulatory Commission 50-323-OLA '
i
Dear Sir:
We= agree with the-Fishers that.the nuclear waste from Diablo '
Canyon should not be stored there, but in a remote. area, !
f d off~from humans or wj).dlife. !
l )(,o{<? * 'M '
~
28 ,3as swis br. Los Csos, C4.934og
/gi gw + ,,
m ;
%.n dygns en LuaJacys.ce 7su/
hwg 9 aeLdy m r~svs.~ ~ wn+
$g. p cxyLL sm hv%& jG p gj o JLaMay 7/ gn tosm n/&g, L B"~l a, g/ , 9 3 Vo 2 s u r s w A }, #g'~Q,D7 3 %r -
4
, c? 75'7 En fl^ p~a pf 2 7f 6 rhrsq L.;Y & W i f,4 >{u$ 27er % dx Ls As'y ""
- 4 /24 xual nr rom sx 4s a e @wt W $c < % i0.0 }i%nm,,,- % Dp. ,L w % CA 9""
u a n
~flf gu17(, l% C D 3 / 3 b c d ' * " A ~' '
j / J > r Y' Y hf' i
....Am usswc-scome=
i g9 46 m
3 c u
g{fgl,gg@d'sds6Lw i~
_J
{i ') l '
T
- L U
T A D
)
A F A Y
D E
'(L E R
K A
E M
F DAM N I N A E A O U H E N N T Q C R E OI
_ S H S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S E 6 C R U U c O R E U C )/ ).
T E E e a V G H
C YOB O C E l f E I N R c T T L w A
S C 7 D
d A
W A N
D N
O y.
A b "5 A
8 9
E V
I A
R D N
'A I
T A
P d u ' d r e 9,
" d e
u L g S & 1 3
T C
A A
E N
E T
U C
't
- s. & b W n .t l1 r g 6 N h c
O I D H
G I
C O b R S' S a r
D E S g M ~
A R - c y R O T o f ~
T R o m " b Y g S O A 69 L t o o H / r, H E S W - S b 2 R M a ~
G I
H B
S G $('o n 0 "* e c
U Z y d r
e
&a E
T I
H ft o a - a i F
O S
A T a Ms m g ,L b n
l1 t
2 f B -
3
/y P e
W O w r m
M
- g
'J T T )W x, 4 A d -
3()
N R S N 0 6 Hb Y
U O
M A
A E
L C
U O
N Y
A S
E R
D f
f h r
R
{
b M
O Y
3 I 7 C Sp l
a r
r o
D o ? 6 G)
N $ 10 W
^
E N C H
S A
/ m R
/
T(2 L P.
P y,,5 T Y N Y
/ L 6 N A T Y. % 4 I N n 6 bI T U r i ; h ~
E S
A H
O C b e
F e -
em 1
q,.
- n g E m
Y A T ( )u s C E O e 'r c
d n f
~f A R S P E n r E C
N U
O S M a %a % /m P
A
- h. 0 n %
I 2 I E G
B O
N r T M n e L R O
D A D e v F L R S E e v,bi [
dr t E O T 4 f. c S I T N k
(([L S
\
F U R U N t
E O L I o t o d & s uo dr E V
I F
S I
N A
R P k H b d b j
w a
f t
H T
O A T S ) g )p ft M
I F /,M O G
N I .
O S L l J L m.s 4 T
N N N N D b p hQw R
)j( 0 Q N O h n,. .nJ E f
/
A L
P Y
N A
Z I
T E L_' M~ k E
R C R gA- .
{)
S I
E O
L I
C U
T A
N % c Y
a b 1
v U
f) E S
A B E N k' A i 't -
E uh'/1
& A o y>
W t .
L G G O o -
I I P P D S 1
/
/
2 3 4 5 6 7 g 0 _
9(
!!!lf l l l ! \\ i
~
T 1 -
L U
T A A F D -
Y
.A DO D E E F DA N E K R M I N MA A E A U H T Q E N N f )(
S H
T C
S R
E H
EOI MI A T D , N -
E R S N A E a B A U K P S g E 5 6 C R U U ; }
O R E U C 5 g T E E H O C E }
V G C YOB j g E I N S
T T C
A D
g; g 7 A A N g t- 8 b
- W D O q r C s < 9 E
N A
N A
I g r e b l re ,1 V
I R D.
T A e @ k u c a Ov Q "t
t3 y 3 P h T A E U 3 d o._
- u /w C
A E
N T
H C
C f J t
< b a
I s ]v o -
d h.
c O
A N G I D G O tj s Q N
/ b r
a.
I D E S q M A R R O T
).
V
@ o y T R
- c b c s Y
g S O s
{
L H E H
S &g A u
. i b O S r Es a G B O b c 0 r I S L a 6 4" d -
H E
T I
H f
j n t, ,'
S v b] i c
F o $ f. a P S T L s O $ 2 0
T N
U A
W R
A O
T O
S S
h n A d &
t E
W a r
w i
2 4
M L
(
h d
l e
f hrm O E N E ag 4 4 a M
A L
C Y R
D D a
- k I
c 0 r r
B U A W 9 o D (3 _
E
{
E N S A 4 7
( C 1 9 H
T N
Y N
A Y
T f
7 l T
t 8
3 9 h 5 6
4 G
4'h I N 6 T U C 5 E
S A
H O
C
/
9 c, t y w y E A T s 6 C E O f m d r-e- w d A R S P E n E e
C s N
I D
U O
E G
A S
I B
O M
A N
', L u
h
\_
OE a
a 2w
/
q n
o h'{ P R
O F
D l
.L R ,
,F O T U U S
I E
T N
j i
o o M N /
r (%
b S
R
,E
. O L I n n A at r, t
yI r E
.V R H s
t i
I S N P J, u 1 T
b
.F I A 6 ha_ T. lA b O -
A T S
b r,
[ J M
~
I F O
,G O w -
l T
N
,I N N
'. S N
&q e '
w_ N R
N A
L P
O Y
N A
C E
Z I
T I
E R
}
be a_
Qm [ &
g ff 2
2 U
T E
R _
s w S C U U E Q
]w O
OI S T
Rh b{ A m
L ,
A E B E N )( E G
P A
I D
W G I
S 1 2 Y b
//
i s
l L
P 3 4 5 6 7 8 d.
9 l _
t { L
=
T I
U T A D O D E
A E
K F
E M
F D W I N MN A
A -
R A E A -
O U H E N N T
S Q
l i S C R E O I E M I V C V V / b ._
T ~
H A T D E R S N A E B
E A
D U K P S C R U U Te O
T-E V
R E
G E U C H O C E C YO B d/ T p
u T
E I T
N A
& S .
S C D N 7 A A 'N r 4 Y 8 nd '^"' A be' W D 9 O
E N
A 'A N I T A o
e a t A
N Y 1
/ E L ,
V A
- W'E L d""' ge 'N r-
/ 3 D
I T
R A
D E
P U
Nk %s s '4 W Md D /
C A
O I
E N
D T
H G
I C
C O CBC /aAS 1
/ @ $
c Y f
G o
$ 0 T W h c
r /'0 a3 M
D A
R E
R O
T S
T R
A e b
y f-Y L
H S
E O
H S
l, e b b R D
a r
Ad.
G B o .
1 i d I S & '
rs
? b E S P #
H E I /
F T
S H
T C C u i
P .
O A np 'h S 0 M c
OT N W
R O
T S l e
i l
E
)A %c
(
i l
l 08
} [
m M M
U o }
d l
e U
O M
A A
E L
C Y O
N D
S E
R A
/
1.
P 3
b 4 t
b l f 5 3 1
o c
L_
A r a
r o
63 U A D N klf*
D 1 4 C E.
H N S A 3 1.
3 1 t 3 l 5
)
/
4 1 5 T Y , 1 / 6 N Y 4 N A T lC I
T N
U 6 12 0 # ' M i K
6 E
S A
A H
T O
C 3 0
c cn h e
2 6
Uq/ IX
/
M l n S w
a %. -
3 c
v E C
A E
R S O
P E 2 N o
i n N S
<0 E P -
6' o k
N C U O
S I
M A L o v
B
>- . M $v R b PW I E B N L O G O L 6 ' f D
L O
F U A
R T
S I
U D
E T
N t e v
kr/n i
e $
dc g
o m
a c n
0' O
N F
S R
E p;,
t i -
e E O L I e h H V
I F
S I
N A
R P b S 1
/
k v
u /O I
f l
\
A F
i 1
D 4
7-A O
M T _
A G
T I
S F
O Wi - k 6
a -
O T
N r nPc Af c
h N b
l I .
S u R c/
N N N N
A L
O Y
N E
Z I
) '.
+
1
)( . l j 1 m i
U T
E R
OSP I
A C
O T
I C
E R
U T a _vI
//h Lt b ft f
p; d% W v E S
A
'Y L A E B E N
f- $v~ MJ E -
G P
A I
D W G I
S h s.
1 f
?
e3 {
M ' c L P
4 5 6 7 8 9
T L
T l
I.
A D ,
OA D E
E K
F E
M F
I D WN N MA A
R A E O
T U
Q H
C E
R A
N N E O I X,
X X k S l S N B
E i
T R
A S
E M I H A T N A D
E h
U K O
E D R
P C R U E U C S
U p E
b ""
T E E H O_C E w E
V I
G N
C Y_O B Q, w I
j
- s. re T
S T
C A
D W , 1c w 7 A
W E
A N
A D
N N
O I
A K &
~
W u F9 h
% dF T" o-o r
8 9
1 V
R A T A W i e
Y, L
T D 6
^' G 3 WW I D P T A u/ b C E E
T U
C W h/m & k d % 0 3
h c /o/
I D
A O
N D
E H
G I
S C
O Q'% 9 f )
FA I" 4 d M
r' a3 7
A R otY y R O T i
Y T
S R
O i AM B
3 95 y{U -
' rS r
b rO b rM SAo!-
L H o ,
H E S ' .
m R. ,
s 0 a r
G B
^' 1 A .
O )R d H
I E
S I m3 f
% 6 r .
T H T em WW i
- n. f 4 a i
P
\4 r
F S T s 4 e m f %l 4 a
O A cs t n e OT W O T u s eS 0
c b r d N
U O
R A
E O
N S
S E o s 9 5
_? M 5 E
&k l a
r M
A E
U N
L C
S Y
A R
D D
A 5y 5
S s
s s
9 F s X n- L f
1 kO ok 6 b$ C r
o l
O E l N i
T Y , e 5 6
N Y 4 N A T 6 I N T U g L k
E A O s f
5 f E ge 4 C S l C k C A
i T m }
f l
E O (A e_ 1, f f A E
R C
S U
P S
E M .
% f f w .
A L r l t P N
I D
O E
G I
B O
A N
{
A 'k kg .
hC A - o C h R O
F L
O R
T A
S I
D E
T s
e u WA w t
r Q. A 4
e A M S R
F U U N n n E E
V O L I R
h W/
m 1 D U k k M E
b L
IS hO T H
I F
S I
N A
S P
) -
b
\
f) b O M
A T I F h O G O
+ o T N
N I
N A
N O
Y S
N E
Z Wb00 f W N
uf f -
i, c
k k
b
_h r N
R U
T E
L P
N A
I T
A.
V R oS E
C I R /
C U d s E
I O L
T A M
% k, Nb, S
A b/
} E E
6 G
B A
I E
W N G
I 8/u k-
^
L P
P D S 1 2 3 4
/ 5 6 7 8
0 9 1
% ;. u x q
g T L
3
~
L T
U A D 7- j .
QD A F -
A ;
l Y -
E F D1 E N E K M I N MA R
O A
U E
H F A
N N V
T S H Q C S
R E
E O I M I
" / - -
T /
E R H A T D -
S N A E -
B A U K P S E 0 C R UI I O 'R E U C T E E L
T E i 2
" G N
A H
C O C E i OB 'y .
S '. D 7
'a.
A W D N
O
_~
b /e Le &,
8 9
E N
A N
A I
T ra rf o O 1 V
R D A
P
'q f -
b /er );;e s
r c
/g (y 3 yI T C
A O
U A
E H
G E
T 5
,C 4 C U
O h, fg YQ NS t.
u u%.
r A
E h
c ra ?@
l I D I d7 f- ()
D A
E I
j S
MD R O T
T R
./. i w '
?
8 ' 3 b y -
Y L
S O H b, o 4 d a
~
F H
G I
H E
B E
T S
S I
H I'
_~
0 idN 4 g ,
f y
/
4 S
L f
/.
/; )f d d i
P r
S T y d-S O A W O L
/*t %
N
\
I m e O T N
U R.
A T
g S S
b %gg s T A
I t
y i
g b ro d l
O M
A E
L C
E R dt lk' -
H Y*
L b a r
r Y D 1j s ) o d A D D Y
!6g
/
E N S A l 1 2,
C -
H I R W S g Q-T Y_
N Y
, I f 5 6
N T 4 A.
/j I N 6 -
T U h., f E A O 4 . dr $)
E S H C 2 t t 6
A T d C C
E R S U
O P E Ttc L ~
r e
s A V e 3
T
- 1 o
fy h l A
E P
S M N O A
% f W i c & r
,k I
I E G
B O
N 2g S y R O
E7 A F D
L A
R S D
E V
Ng
, Si K fr a
O F
T U
I U
T N R Tg g e
$ w ja
& h S
R E O L I A y
t W' N r u o E H
V R Eg c d~/Agn S
s T N
b [c ho I P F I A O S
N ( M -
A u /
T ,.
O G
I F w t T
h &z jn O
Q N
I .
S g , N R
N N N
h h N .
f U N
fWf O E j A Y Z 0 p T L N f a E
'h I
P A T E R oS I C
O L
I C
R U
T A
Mg h -
M
- w. E S
A 0
E B E N E 6 A W G L _
G I I P _
P D S :
(3 1 2 3 0, 6 7 8 9 1
, i
T
~
~
L U
T A D A F A '
D E E F D uN -
E I N MA K M R A E A -
O U
/l H E N N T
S Q
H C
S R E O I EM I W V l - -
T H A T D E R S N A E B A U re O
E d R
K E U C P S C R U U n e d [ R f
W U
~
3 T E E H O C E r ,
c E
V G C YO B M u- &g M y M T
S I
T C
N A
D 4 I l r sn r d^ / 7 A
W A
D N fo /
y W S E c 6 r
e W, 8
9 N N O
/* df g d e E^ k r
1 I
e E
V I
A R
A D
T A
P ff
- s o v dc ); t r
o S w o
3 h
i -
T C
A E
E U 37 7 e i h !
T C 9 s 5 w " d c A N H C u J h r O
I D
D E
I S
G O R k &
k sn 4 M
a A R 3 71 l.
R O T 7 3 u
- y Y
H G
L T
S E
B R
O H
S e
i ct b
O S
]
v a
e t<
S.
c u
9 e D
[L r
1 C
Y T
0s S o f d
t h r r
c d
b a
r I
H E T
S I
H c
a bO c
a 0 l b G o
r/
9 /
4 M
o C i P
F O
S A
T c ? j n 7 / i D ~~
W O 4 , o m sn e T
N R R a Y b t k C d U
O A
E O
N S
S .G fC v %
< K o S C i a l a
M L E
R 0.O I Z b S I. l e M r _
h 3 r A C D 4 _
E U
N D
6 b 1 v D 0 kl a 8 6 C o _
H T Y S
A N l5 t 7 ?- h 6
I 2
0 {
5
/
N Y 6 N A T N 4 E
I S
T A
H N
U O
C V
n J
W v
e o
&y a t.
hf- f (
6 E
b r f- s / C A T a he 5 A R
C E
S U
O P
S E
M C
t Y s
t c
& f d
l t
t E
d 7
E P
N O A 5 I
v e S R I
D E
G A
B O
N D /
t c
e 7/
7 w hgjE/s S v
m f'/
S i
/
/
c l
0 i
n O F
L O
F E
R T
U O
S I
U E
T N n d Z
U
/
s 9 t
9 w S
S A 0 E 6
6 n l
} S R
E L
)t e i
I S n $n V
I F
S I
N A
R P #a S c a Y N
/
?-
fm M k r H T
O _
A T S
bt d< &
f Q M O
I F y T G O t a N C /m Q W M
/.m I .
S ~
N N N 0 v I (o
l T
N O E L I T
A L
Y N
Z ~ / vb l 1
( E I
& A
[)
P S
A C
T I
E R f a
M
(
A t a i l~b
/ .
t R
E
( I O C U T d r
m f 'v h f 'S A
M E
L B
A E
W A
N G I[ b g ((4 M $'
f l/ I G
P I
D I
S 1 3 4
? 6 7 8 9 1 0 M
T L
U T A D A F A O D E
R E
K l
E M
Y F D4M N I N A A E A V -
" /
O U H E T Q C R E OI N N V /
E S H T
R S S E M I H A T D N A E V
B A U K P S O
E d R
C E
R U U U C a p w T E E H O C E ~ u E
V G N
C YOB r e c ~
a y
w I
T T A z s c M C
p lTp p S D 7 A A g C 8 W N f r D O M. 9 E
V N
A N
A I
T A m N
- 4 0
h1 7 r h o
k M
7 a 1
I R D P e 5 f c k 3 n m P T
C A
A E
N E
T U
C W O
M A e o M se h c
O I
D D
E H
G I
S C
O w T S
i $c G fA T 9 Wg M r
a A
R R
O T
T y k/ k49 9, i,
sc,e y Y S R
O 1 f 4
' b S s '
L 3 o
L+ 2of H ,
H E S o a G
I B
S bA o r wM Q 0 s d d r
H E s n a h a g T
I H
r s s &x,0 u4 e5
/
'1 nb o 5 i F
O S
A W
T O
Me 4
s i
P "
J C
$e a a L mus P e
ah n w<$cO O T N 'q g r N R T t ni d U
O A
E O
N S
S Mc 9 1
w A L o o[
b
% / ce l a ~
/M $g M L E -
a 5 n rb 3N 5 s s r A C Y R
D 0 -
t a /g r -
n 3 p a o -
U A D 3 H
T E
Y N S A {M %o3 u 2 2O i i a/ ah sk Ch 6 Q "i f
7-3 5 C
N Y 6 N A T R 4 I
T N
U K A
y l^0 r& & f z 6
e E A O r ,
"5O ec W E hu dm S
A H
T C N r a 5 fl E C E O A o f g A -
R C
S U
P S
E M W h $ a W s E
P l
A S $ B -
6 N O I A A N(N Cp I E B N c R -
G O h i -
g O -
D L
O A
R S D
E 3 0
L kf D. $ g y, o u7 F S
T Q}f I
I T Y F
E U
O U
L N
I f
y e R
/ o P gs l
's [f"- R E
V R A e s {'o B H -
S M & k/ Em u A9 T -
N b D I P s
F I A 9 t 1_ O -
M A T S
g j' llM k c
I F S d 4 [ d T
G N
O S a m$ t kklf d w~,,
I h,~ hl1
" d f A
N h
L N
O Y
N N
E Z
I d
%Y A ,k T E
P A T E d b. R -
OS % b , Q' C I R -[ >
u
~b E C U M'))]7
- k h%L.
I O T l S E
L ,
A e e '
h
\ A E
G B
A I
E W
N G
I L 2'h b~~ [~ L P
P D S 1 2 % \ 0 3 4 s 6 7 8 9 1
/ l
y T
L U
T A D a A F A
,]. . !
Y D E E F D \
N
,N E K M I N MA R A E A O U H E N N T Q C R E O I S H S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S E d C R U U O R T
E E
V I
E G
N E U C H O C E C Y OB " g ,
- k. I' _
(g S
T T C
A D
re TA f 7 N N N' ""* ""
A A N 6 1
8 W D O g ( 9 N g E
V R
A N
A I
T A g
- g, g
du n
4 a
1 I
T C
A E
N A
H D
E T
P U
C C 31 W nn 4 3 j;g eN e
a 3 h
c O G n R r I
D D
E I
S O
t I
_j; 1 M a
A R - o ,
D R h O T W / E y J
Y L
H G
T S
E B
H S
R O
wcA i
(
p t t e ? D 3
NE y
g b$
m&
9 b9 h
C 4
4 3
b r
a CA I d
/3 A A uYy t
H e F
E T
I H wG '
O D0 oa b i hB O
S A
T oh l J
/ L k ds P Lc YsW me 4 n W O o o e
). T T 0 p i r o )d N
U R S " o }f i t M A
L a
,,L O O E N S
E ots A )C l
a D. YXA (A SL M
L L R A (
r nam fa r&zf t
A C Y D W i ss 6 r E
U N
A S
D oq 7 A 1
d n C o
H T Y ,
A aC o l s/ f0 '7 u 5 0 5 N
I N
A Y
T N
s R & b N 4
6 6
T U h
l E A O n ,
S H C o / ln f E A T p 5 ( l A C E
5 e m PE n
O A R S P E h J d _
C N
U O
S I
M A w e S a W N(p R
E B C
I D
G A
O N
D W ih f O F
L L R S E D l Ml/
q l
O T I S F U U T l /
R R u
N a /
L d kW E O L I E -
V R o G H I
F A
S I
T N
A S
F P
L $
1 2
C W >
/
h i
(
T O
M O
tL I
G N
O )
y / ' 'f T I
N N S
N NE K r
m d e
N R
3t N O E & .
k U A Y Z J / '
- pT L
P N
A I
T E h( l df E R
b C
d du I R h S C w E
-.x]..
.,L I
E O
L B
A E
W U
T A
N ^ $ d h ,
J &gh /,
S A
E L
G I G / ~
M P 5%%
I P D S 1 3 4 V"P 1 0
T L
U T A D a A F A ~ .
Y O
D E E FD\ N E
R K M I N MA A E A O
T S
U Q
H H
C S
E NH R E OT E MI V
7 T H A T D #
E R S N AE _
B A U K P S E d C R U U O
T E R
E E U C H O C E g V
E T
S A
W I
T C
A G
N A
D D
C YOB N
O WhW l f
e r
e Y
N t 8
9 7 _
so 3 r N N uM I 1 E A A T u r
V I
T R
A D
E A
P U
My u /
e 5/ &
3 C D l b f E T C h T
A O
I D
A N
D E
R H
G I
S C
O W 5cg
]
8 r
S M P4 M c
r a
R
- g w. y
_ O T
T 4 n V 3 R g_ b _
Y L
S O W) g ,R ) f O e O H
na W.
H G
E S d DOsbl e C L a r
I B
- R 9 S k w d H E S.
- y a
s>ge$ V e F
T S
I H
T $C %. 9k! v Y; Y 4 i P
0 A N
to C Y
i W O O'3 .
$ e M
s O
T N
U R
A T
O S
S 1E
'o S w$ s> l0r t f
/
X9 d
l n04 O e a
$ b hJ k N
E M L E R
l hM n, hN O h r ._
A C Y D ~S r wY i
U A D r mm a S'A o o E N o. C l$ {O S A '
H T Y ,
^S
{/ th <
l O -
- lD $ 5 _
N Y @ 6 _
N A T f 4 I
T N
U t
E l
I T
1 6
n A E
S A
A H
O C_
~
i g
G e PI M h 6
fc q E E
T H d C A /lr k
( N C
A R
C N
S U
O O
P S
E M O R
C h 0 )
$ fl i
f l L(
E P
I D
E G
A I
B O
D A
N ~
f Q
\
n e
i G ll 6
$/ hf A R
O F
L R S E K o dr O O
F E
T U
O I
U L
T N
A H
g\ p d b \ P T
h M A
ci S
R E
V I
F S N A
I R
P c
t E l W .
& % t fu H
T O
A I
S h { W l 0 M T
d b C 4 F
h O I
G O i T N
I N N S
b M fc N R
N A
O Y
N E (3 (( U L
P S
N A
C Z
I T
I E
R 6c - & 9 ,
T E
R C
U ' E OI E O
L B
A E
W T
A N
h,U )
5~
1 S
A E
G e L G
P I
D I
S 1 2 3
- ~
4
. ' t h 0 P .
5 6 7 8
- 9 1 .
T L
U T A D F
O 'A !
Y A
[/
D E E F D\ N E
R K M I N MA A E A O U H E N N T Q C w\
S R E OI -
H S E MI -
T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S E O C R U U O R E U C T E E H O C E V G C YO B E
T S
I T
C N
A D
s $ 7 A A N f r: 8 W
N D
N O
I G Q e r $ D 9
1 E
V A
R A T A d k u G Y
/
3 I
T C E A
D E
T P
U c.
u.
L I
/ $ 6, R & hcfo/
A O
I N
D H
G I
C C
O M .I J f 0 ]4U ,
4
& r' a3 D
A R
E R
O S
T ri s
&p a
& o My f d ;r T R i b Y S O I- .
M h D .-
L H B ,
M h
/ a -
H E S t t .
L -
G B - L r -
/no $ d
$, Ou f I S .
H E I mr f h A 5 .-
F O
T S
A H
T cs h d
c s
f w Mp ( Y b
i P
e d---
W O sv b Re O T N R T
S dc o f,
/y O u \
(
i
&n l' -
i Y d -
U O
M E
A L
O J
I S
E R s o
s }3 f
v 9 G 9 a
4 J l 'l a
r A C U_
Y A D D Ye da, z o- T L' r o
E H
N S A M 0
/d % 4 M C 2
f A ]/
yM 9
y C 7 2 l
T Y ,
I
\ C 5 6
N Y 4 N A T /
I N n 6 E
S T
A H
U O
C 5,
z o n &t G
Q a,
p s
E 3 C -
A E
R C
N T
S U
O O
P S
I E
M A e w
n g
C
/
J A
y, b fC n
OC dfA m
(f-hp
(-
d y A
E P
I D
E G
A B
O N
D e
t h
l O C t
(
ee )/
f
, M Q F R
O L R S E D w e O
F T
U I
U T
N O lno m G h
t e
A E s S
R E
V O L R
I m H C
i p h?
y n
i h i
u g E H
I F
S I
N A
S P
M $ S D ,
, b )p T
O M _
A T O I F v T G
N I
O S
m m s
c j
g ,. N h bm N
N A
N O
Y N
E Z
y \
sc f( %
4 T R
U
( E L N P A I
T E h e h -
R oI
\
C I R ,
S C U -
)y 4 E E
6 G
O L
B A
I E
W T
A N
G I
ek
- d. -
=.
h %
t N-( h
/L S
A E
D C8 P S 1 0 3 4 5 6 9 1
T L
U T A D A F O E R
O T
S D E K
A U
Q H
T E
M E
H C
S I N E
A Y
F DA N M
A A
N N R E OI E MI H A T D V
vd f / W / -
E R S N A E B A U K P S E d C R U U O R E U C T E E H O C E t w
V G C YO B d E I N T
S C T
D A
r d .
A A e e 7 W N k w 8 V
I T
C E
N A
R A
N A
D E
D O I
T A
P U
m e
a
%v" d
i w
s &
& a a !" ,
9 1
3
~
E T C m yN e c h w
A N H C c O o I D G
I O
k c & @
r a
D A
R E
R O
S T
% $ a M y
2 n, w x
T R b Y S O !g b s L
H s.
a H E S U a s a G B l , r e
I S d H
s k x
%ew m .
E e F
T S
I H
T e as W a 5
i P
O A W O hf f 9 e O N U
O T
R A
E T
O N
S S
E
/ h h, B $
2 ( d l
a a
M L R r A C Y D 0 0 0 7 c h r E
U N
A D 1 6 e % o o H
T Y N
S Y
A /
M c
% s m P c h
C 5
6 N A T k r 4 (f
((ql e.,$h I N 6 T U E r e E A O v he 6S ye S H C S , E A
E R
T S
O P E L
t a {
kc C
A E
C U S M Q U e s P e -
N O I A I E B N f n i R
G f r O O D
L A
R S D
E Gj Mr 6 s F .
u a O T I T E t S F U h a U N R E O L re E o s v m I 2 V R g c H I F S N P (A G T A I T A S O r' d M O n F L I ' O U he s-G O a T _ N w n-W h I . S N N N N O N E l n R U s ~ A Y Z T L N I h n a E T P A T E R C I R S C U E OI O L , T A S A kQMi0%wYu E B E N 6 E
& A W G L G I I < P P D S
~
L 2 3l 6 ,S 9
3 T L U - T A A F D , A O D E E Y k W () x>-x F D \ N E K M I N MA X 5 R A E A O U H E T S Q H T C S E M N N R E O I I W E R H A T D S N A E - B A U K P S E d C R U U ~' O R k T E V E E G N E U C H O C E C YO B r e I T S A W T C A A D D N O h c f e m e u
- r m a'"
Na W 7 8 9 E V N A N A I T a h d ;m a w A _M It t 1 A e
- e,h I R D P 3 T A E T o d u C
A O I D E N D E T H G I S U C C O W c r s m S wM i e 4 uD n c h M a r _ A R - ? C u R O T T O1 O L s 0 y R L# b Y S O L S S 5 fy L S k xc ~ n H , H E S a - G B c "> a. c a r ' r s -
" d I S o L ek H E I ei a x e T H - i
'V s 9Y h
\
F S T \ w O A W O u t A ~
- c e O
T T B 6 u c w S PwH '^ W[P N U O M A R A E L C O N Y S S E R 5 0 M 9 d,s O=n s o p ~s u mM-H 1e l a r r - [l[ D U A D 3 9 a L o E N
~R 'y C
,i S A H
T Y N Y 3 8 s 3 s ,s
,r ' % 5 6
N I A N T 3 e n 4 6 T U n , i ,M. g A E A O
)
E i S H E A T C r i c f fi l ad C v E R S O P E U a e Q r =Y u b A E 14a C U N O S M e @g . H P I E G I B O N A L l B w r .L M (G R O D A D a 1 L ,T F L O R S E 4 e t F T U I U T N l d v i f 9 g S R h-fa n w(6 i
?'
Da E O L I f E V R ?w E H S
-w T I N f F P 5*
I A \ R O S M A T I F y t P t T'h 0 G a d/"_?A&& n n O l N b . c - b I N N N O S N E
}y, a v v .
N R U a b - y w1 A Y L P N A C Z I T I E R f w e, T E R
/x
&}c kh ' & n Lh 0;q g S C U df E, OI E B O
L AI E W T A N G 2 / 0} S A E G ,%r I i P D S 1 2 3 4 s 6 j 8 9 1
T L U ~ T A D ,~ A F A Y D E E F D6 N E K M I a3 A h R A E l A O U H ~ S E B T Q H T R A C S S U E R EOI E MI H A T D K N A E N N P S S' fj w 'f d o g v w> E 6 C R U U , Tn O T E R E E U C H O C E p ~ E T T V I G N A C YO B t
- m a
, y W
S A C A D N ce _ e g - T Y 7 8 D O 9 - v J' N - 1 N I 4 E A A T d n V 4 e I R D A P g c_ hu Af n 3 T C A E E T U C t e u 4 r t u d h - A O N H G C 7 rc T o d c Sl c r - I D O W 4- i - a W l - I - D E S M A R R O T
/g i 'n . ~- y -
T R 9 h f o b - a f [0 A_Z Y N L S H O 3 C c. S , H E S rf k A a H G I B E T S I H h G h* uC r ve Em. t 5 N A bt j f r
%m% X
;- V.
o r e d i r g
)
F O T S A W T O T C
/
y u
? L
%3 G f
Nw G b K 0 y 4 W EE lq d' 4-
}
er;.Y Qt' 9
~
A C r P i
,o d
e - N R S /- S
/m
/
( U O M A A E L C U O N Y A S E R D D f O s s o D j R L 3 So e / 3 u 7v 7 h
]
a-c w 4- 3
/
Y Ln k l a r r o h m' 1-E N S N L 3 C A ' 3s +6 l H J. O - T Y , 4
' L E' $ % 5 N
N A Y T v 6 4 n v m I T N U u C- m 6 E S H A O C a t, t d a T. j, E A T E C h i E j- A O m h 6 u j - R S P E [y u p E D L C N I U O E G A R S I B O S N D E M A k A s m t E G 's t V h r-R ya
%m w C
M 5 E F Qp y J 5 e P R O F - O T u v S I T F U U N f'/ e C ) R e E E , O L j f O i E M F 9s . I V R H H a A I F S N A P ' b J=, c T O A I T S ^ M m [ 4 T J-( R w M O I F p A = G O O T N w 0 I N N N O S N E lf'f Q L(
=h d
c c, e 1 g U N R _ A Y ~ )( b T j Z
/j ~ _
J L N I f E _ P S I A C O T I C E R U T ff h m. dw f,,+v h
/
e k b f /a k j E S R E L , A
// <
( J E b v k, A G P B A I D E W N G I S 1 2 s C 3 e g% s 6 Op s 7, L 8 n
$0, E
L P 9 1
2 T L U T A D A F A Y O I D E E
/
F D \ N E R K A M I N MA E A
~
O T S U Q H T H C S E N N R E OI E MI - E R H A T D S N A E B A U K P S E d C R U U O R E U C T E E H O C E V G C YO B E T S C I T N A D r 7 W E A N A A D N A N O I r s,J t e Mp 9 1 8 V I R D T A A e. n 3 T C A A E N E T H P U C G i
# u T
w h c C O I D D E I G O S s M r a . A R S g - R O T T R 0 b y - Y L S O H 1 3 o a , H G E B S s a r _ H I E T S I H 4 s m d i e F O S A T k V a Me P W e O e r 1 y T T c d O N R S S M U O M A E O N S E 0 t I W - l a r A L C U Y A R D D 0 %v r o E H N S A 0 m r h C T Y , 5 N Y 6 N A T 4 _ N r 6 I T U o E A O e i S H C E A T o C E O l m A N I R C S U O E G P S I B O M A N E
$ 61 A
w E P R O D L O A R T S D E e F S F E U O U L I T N I 0 u w R E V I S N R o m H T - F I A P J k O S M A T I F O G N O . e T _ N I N N N O S N E y R U A Y Z T _ L N I il l i E P A T E w R OI S C O L I C R U T A 0 A l K S A E E B E N E G P A I D W G I S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 L P
^
T L U T A a
/
D OD A E R E K F A E M E F I D N A Y
\
A N
- 4. A m,
O U H E N N T Q C R E O I S H S E M I w T H A T D q E R S N A E B A U j K P S o E d C R U U j O R E U C T E E H OC E V G C YOB E I N T S A T C A A D N
&r A
7 8 W D O k 9 1 N N I . E A A T V I T R' A D' E A P U
& 3
/_
C E T C h 0 A O N H C rc9 G O I D W a3_ N I D E S M A R - J. i l y f. R O T f % T R A 3 b Y S O
&nI L H H
G E B S C d a r h.- I H E S I T H e i P F O S A T h (_ m OT U N W R A O T O S S k 8 d l e a O E N E r M L R 2 P r A C Y D o E U N S A D A 3a 3 I C H O 5 T Y , 6 N Y N A T S 4 _ I T N U ; E e C A 6 E A O ) S A E R H T S C O P E t ( y he t L t A E P E C I C N U O E G S I B O M A N 2,I
- f. f R
O F Q A.
)
D A D L R S E V K A S O T I T b R F U U N / A E Y
\ .
E V O L R I N H T - I S N P O F I A A T S - u M I F O _ G O T N I N N S N ? ,.kO" N R N A L O Y N E Z I 8 V , U T E OS P A C T I C E R U I},- - h e_l ' R E I O L , T A
% r S A
E E B A E N 7e L 6 G I W G I P P D S 1 2 3_ 0 4 5 6 7 8 9 1_
T j L U
.-T A D A F A O.. D .E E
K E M F DAM N I N Y A R A E A O U H E N N T Q C R E O I S l i S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E -
.B A U K P S E O C R U U O R E U C T E E H O C E V G C E N
.T
_S I T C A D Y_OB% ' t 7 8 A A N' W N D N O I
] t
~
9 1
._E V
A A T A
)4e 3 I R D P L T A E U
_C E T C hc O/ A N H C l' c r O I D G I O M aW _D A E R S y
?
R O T b T R / G .- Y S O. (l L .o , H E H S q 1 a r G B 1 3 d I S H E T I f e i F S H T [ A P :
?
0 A C e QN .U T O W R A E
~
O T O N S S E QoL l d a
.M L r R r A C Y D O o PS
._ U A D C E N S A H
5 T Y , 6 N Y 4 N A T 6 I E S T A l N U O C E E R A i T S O P E {9 C A E P C U S M N O I A R -
.I E B N O G O F
- D L A R S D E n - O S 1 I T ; y R F U U N E E O L I H V R T - I S N P O F I A M S
. A' T O I F T y
G O N e N I . S R N N N ( U N O E T A
^
Y Z E L N I R - P A T E 0 .S I C O L I C R U T A \ E S A E E' B E N / L 6 A W G P G I I P D S 1 2 3 0 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
T L U _ T A D A F A yDE R O T E K A U Q I E M E H C E A Y F D\ N I N M A N N R E OI
/ V / W rv U
V / 1 S H S E M I 0 T H A T D 4 E R S N A E 3 B A U O K P S C R U U O .) Y L 9 - E - . E O R E U C A A T E E l O C E / & C {j V G l C YO B T E T I T N A f D e , I o S C D 7 E f D p A W A N D N N O I 7 WM/ f 7 en 1v Pt F i b s hA6W s TJ{ Wb 1u ( E A A T E L / d < 1 G . O V I T R A D E A P U 6t 'Z/ f o lA
? h
?u.
i s C A E N T H C C c P / tG A M u O G O c L I D I w n D A E R S 2 a h
)
n v V a j
- 5 e =L 3 2 A S R O T T R 8d 'J 3 fo % n
"?
h B G ( *'i Y S O L H ia ; t& M r a l i G E B S 6S N / c uC e9 h r s e rk d r e I S S4 1 ac i A {'j oS o w i H E o uc I P MC #% T H "
', G F S T e O A W O 0 kA-l eh v ve t t
o s,
&0iCsS d O uO3 uer j} /s Pe T
N R T S f tc / x/ l a U A 0_ S A o T. s O E N E wo vw< o +s N r N$ o r M L R f l 5 s zL m& o A E H T C U N Y N Y A S Y D D A i L B IY f U J' a2 c5 n uF-s { y 2 c /t 4
/ L K
i sd pO C 5 6 4 6 N I A T T N U G L w dH o k f C I
/ E E A O a Jn h
/
/ C H C dj }'p -
S A E T O
/
h " 6 Of0 s a Y f< I Z' - A E -
// a P t b, R
C S U P S E M O A G 2 } 5 k _ N O I A l a k R _
)u /6 nb 6 O _
I E B N D F C G O L0 h I D A D / .a P e E n S - w f R L O F T U S I U E T N k 2 B n5 e h 0 m, A R r E E O L I klVD /. f. 420 e ~ ,% k f 7 y b a H T n h % V R 7 I F S I N A S P 0 ? 1 65 h h 'S rc O M O A T
/, .
"p /f y T G
N I F O L Do g u d' N I N N
. S N / lP R U -
N A L O Y N E Z I
/g '&
bl N 1 J 8 &'hbg T - OSP A T E ~ r ' E C I R " ' C U u b g S I O T h; d / da A E G L B A I D E W A N G I
$' T % ' A O j h
0 E L P < P S 1 , 4 5 6 , 8 9 1 ._
T L U T A D
/ A F A
! Y
,w
\
_ D E E F D MN E K M I N A R A E A O U H N N
/
E V T S E Q H T R C S S R E O I E M I H A T D N A E U V # B A U K P S O T E E V O R E G C R U U E U C H O C E C Y OB l) u . E I N A G ]T 7 T T Y S C D y E 8 9 A A N r 1 W D O E V N A N A I T A i m & C H
/c e.-
fi t 6 9/ I T R A D E P U u
~
K k ur e w 5 3" hY n s c h fs u $ C E T C r'
~
T '( b $ A N H C f~ O I D G I O Ma9 D E S d
~
y A R - l lc. R O T S b) n D T R u . u aU Y L S O H P ' e J r 0 H E S : L a n T r dS K G I B S b ((b L A J x N i e H E T I H d a O y x s P F O S A T
& a hr/ .
.. o,1 r S T.
d e W O
% - w 1, ) T T ,
u i 1+ l
% N U
R A O, S S [ ' h v e h
/
r o O s a r O M A E L C U N Y A E R D D N O T s d C 5 r M 6 lI I' C r o E H N S A ( D m b 2 5 o 5 N 5 6 T Y , u e 4 N Y 4 d 6 N A T M zc r f E 1 I N e T p Yo U S E E A O ? i 8 h C S A H T C n rr t lE t A E E R S O P E - / h N i nr / P C N I U O E G S I B O M A N h 1 w a L d E p p. a S
$u R
O F D L O F A R T U S I U D E T N d hod ! P w
/r n
c d t c n hl S R E E O L I a , H T V R h da . (a i L O I F S I N A P d k,. - 7 M S n t O A T dl ' a,.r T I F ' s ae kr ko G O u fi ET N N I N N A N O Y S N E Z k d k A Y.h J. c i l E R U T E R
)
L P N A I T E l a U# 1, S
& E C I C
R U K x c u S L S h'd t A I E O L B A E W T A N G t r e h b E L P G I I =
- 0 P D S 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
T J
/
L _ U T A D A F A F D W
- / / /
1 - D E E N E R O K A U M E H I N M E A R E O N A N Y 7 T Q C I S H S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S e O E O R C R U E U C U rt b T E E H O C E s / e V G C YOB u a, . E T I T C N A D MW u k k A 7 8 S A W A D N O k z a 7m r o u r o m aua 9 1 E V I T C N A R A E N A D E T I T A P U C t-
's C'
O m se a v n a t e e f e e w a w a l s d u o C 3 c r A O I D N D E H G I S C O S c : S s o m w'h M a y A R - a i s v b R O T A" sy os s d e w a T R e o , Y L H S E O H S lm x
/u s o s
5 e av a s d a r G I H B E S I s o A. u . L u h a L i P e T H o s d
.d A
- s e
F O S A T A a A m s t d e W O O i s r h n T T i 5 y _ l N R S k ~ w a U O M A E L O N S E R 5 a, t s (= h9 c i h[ u r r o A C U Y A D D 7 7 m a o u s e 9 z i r m C 3< E H T N Y S A 4 a n n 2 9 i f o i 5 6 4 N N A Y T n 6 _ g^
,3-I E
T A N U O a e j,
% aa s E C
sn g-xn
.(- _
S A E R C N I H T S U O E C S O P I B E F A N l t
/.
o g hA ar e cc t 5 r c n. e k
\,,
w O f Y I L E
+
S G F
-a O A
E P R u k q - b D L O G A R T S O D E T ni h_ a m, \ cw e sa Y N r S R I 6 E F U U N d A "o i vN T - E O L I k d h A 0 ( n R d V I F S I N A S P b r~ f o 9 O M O eu a 1 A T I F e M T 4A 0 7, a G O [ M,dA N N u d R I N N
. S N (
w[h . b' M U T Y/E N O E A Y Z i R . L N I P A T E n E 0, C I R u , S h b
~
C U Lh S A I O T 4 za k E L B A E W A N G d M !o'P f G P I D I S 1 a 4 5 6 Y" 9
T L U _ T A D A F A Y Ov D E R E K A I E M E F I D_M N A
\
N A g S O T S U Q H C E R E E O N N I fj. gs hb k s Y E 0 m WQ 1 H S M I l. 0 T H A T D 4 E R S N A E 3 B U K P O A. E O R C R U E U C S U F 9 A T E V E G H 0 _C C YOB E d r r C E T S A I T C A N A D N k s 3 t s T ke v e c
~ o p
s W E V I T N A R A D N A D E O I T A P U A c
- A -
"r.
c D u L a ds W T l t A g c i b O s T c ? i h] pw C E T C E u n u A N H C S w O D G O 3 M (o M L I I n D E S ? a A R - s o S R O T T R hi-w df m l D V Y S O s 5c 9 a L H % 4cM H E S fV w q ml r sO k; ~ G B d g,6 t
%, o e I
H E S I g & 5 ef p 4 i P
~~
T H 3, F S T i o $ e O A P A' l
~ a.
d O T N U O W R A E O T O N S S E hh w $ 3 f ( 0 E
^
hS L D
$ 1 n0 n
. l a
r r e hD M A L C Y R D w 3 L o
$ 9 .
C U A D G h ~ o6 E N S A 1 4 5 H T Y , ll w }. G L t 6 Y 4 N 6 N A T I N T U N r E E A O "l n O e C S A H T C hb a o T w f sa e A
&C E
/ S a 4 s
~
E O P L uoJo tcc R S P E C U S M h P A 0 C R n N I D L O O E G A R T I B O S I A N D E T (t h h i J, h g t S
+
f e d f O 5 s. O F S R F E U O U N fk a 4 e e R I l 1 E H W - L I r 5 T V I F S I N A R P k. $4 c a H C & o w O M S
/-
A T
, ' O 3 T g
L I F G O f e M N L Q y N I N N A N O Y
. S N
E Z
)/
h,L. b i nf /(h'h C~ R U T E yp L N p / R P A I T E w t (./f g E O S C I C R U w l t e S hl A I E O L E T A
' %.&p - m G
B A I D W N G I k y p < P S I ' 3 5 6 6 9 1
T L _ U T A D A F A O D E
, l E F Y
D \ N
/ J f pER O
T S K A U Q H T R M E H C S I E R E H N MA A N N E O I M I A T D
/ r 1
0 4 E S N A E 3 B A U K - P S 9 E O C R U U O R E U C A T E E V E G N H C O C E Y OB
% A C
T S A W I T C A A D D N O b DYS {Wc i T W k c s
- W 91 o
p, s N N I
&x 1 E APY R
'n O kv C 5
i b E V I T C A R A A D E T T A P U 7 lo E$ I$ S W a ( H $ l
)l h
o O i s E C
% f5, t? u A
O N D H G C O & A b L I I n D E S a A k K N .h A R - S R O T R ( p D:~ ol o
& [g T e Y
L S O H p g hD a r a H G E B S S J ,
,,N2 WM . l l' h $$
d e I H E T I H w A e 6 % w n f ( : i P F O S A T t vi i n U R o f D ( d e W O o \ T 'l,h / W ) >t 3 O- T N R' S m y O B e Q l a U O M A A E L C O N Y S E R D h h- s s, g u'f W M 0 7 / 3 9
\
r r o E H U N A S D A 9 0 8 9 se g ig i j W l h l O { t C 5 6 T Y , 4 N Y 1 6 N I A T T N U 7 rr u % u
) ,
/4 E
E S A E A H T O C O f;, k E~ W A $e d h l y e ^5 o f K C A E R S P E
\
~
9 r n 6N l L P C N I U O E S I B M A N R l$ ~ W 4r1 r 3 ( ) T [ O R O F D G A O D m ( $'yLk , sr y L f S R a L S E y b
) t T ' R O T I T t W f E F
E U O U L N I m Jik= j w \ V ( O bf p H T V R G 6- L k I F S I N A S P L.m L v lE O M O h b[fi A T - T I F A w G N I N N A L N O Y N O S N E Z I k O &w 2 n /
&< M
/ S W
)C B
k~, 1 h N R 0 vE R - P A T E O S C I C R U A A e c Y - d q'E (r O T J k} (a I L A x, On t E B A E W N G '
- h. P G I I 0 P D S 1 3 jAV5 7 8 9 1
T _ L U T A D _ A F A _
)- D E E F D WN M _
MA _
,L E R
K A E M I N A f / D O T S U Q H H C S E N N R E O I E M I
'@ . /s~^ Yl V 1 0
E T R S H A T D N A E
' bu 4 B A E
U O K P S C R U U 3 9 - O R E U C A T E V E G N H O C E C YOB & J.- " C E I , T T A ee J o S A W C A D D N O o h &e i p s N N I rm ' 6 du b A A T E V I R D A P s & T 5 AS4e. ' t s O s T C A E E T U C w Wb TG ' d m i u A O I N D H G I C O V Q N I lf T g L n D E S : a A R 9 t S bl
/
R O T 8 )O Y . T R 0 TG % t 2; Q 9H u y Y S O 03 a L H 5 S Y A k e p O r H G E B S 3 A 4 */ 8 S W 3C v9 d q +9t #_ 5 9 Y 4 A
}3 e S
I g H E 9 D 3 d i 9 i F T S I H T e u -
- h. C m r 6 a F%
S C et v (s, r. 6 P e O A t Ru C mO [L 6 d l W O t c yD T T L c 0 C A a l
'C0mn s. bg o0 b
i N R S , c a U A O S L r O E N E
&"f aM g Mf$
l M A L C Y R D 7 l 2O C ( L~ o 2 x b0 r o U A D '5 5 0 (2 d 7I S 9 8 w %s o C E H N S A 3 l b t 7 N,% 1 3L 5 6 T Y , 4 N I N A T Y T N U L l M t k A T 6 E A O L U E C u t Y S A E R H T S C O P E lK h t 0) E t i t M b 6 T ,M A E P M I C U S M V R N I O E I B A N l0r A O F hT G O N D A D E E S L R S E a R
=
O F T U I U T N H 'd y c N G 5 1 E H O E L p' I f V R d l R L 0 T O N I F S I A S P b .Up 'C b M O - A T I F u & d o V T G O h l N - N R I N N
. S N CK U 1 V U
- N A O Y E Z Y T E L N I / r R P A T S I C O I C E R U T %
' W W h f -
E S A E _ L , A M $ 9 L E B ffa _ E N P
& A W G G I I
$ d 0 P D S 1 4 s 6 7 8 9 1
T L U - T A D A F A T J_ ! Y
/% D E E F D \ N E K M I N_M A R A E A ,
O T S U Q H T H C S E R E H M I N N E O I A T D X K f 1 0 4 I B R A E S U O K N A E P S C R U U Y d 3 9 O R E U C N A T E E V I E G N A H O _C E C YOB [ s t l f - L C C o, T S T C D j D n2 A W A D N O dt g o & c a b d. i p s E V N A N A I T A e cc hc & k l C L k~& h b b I R D P
/e hV f
&,4. s Y h T
C A O I D A E N D E E T H G I S U C C O 4 ra y s
}
e h b W i L u n a A R R O T T R c W 3 t e i W L ,2c h 3 t S Nl7~H f An Y S O 4( C D a L H [ hpr% o L r H G I H E B E S S I Ic a Gm D Aa c L O b, 5 x* S t 6 d i e - w Dz }(( T H S L , t P F S T /c D c4, 3w cyC f5 A / b e
\)
O T A W O T 0 b vb, \
, i c,
n d L N R S C , u n h.e. l bN-
/
Jc z K7 w - o(A.- U A O r a O E N S E 7 J <y [ e d !! M L R 2 cc b b i f N r o G c A C U Y A D D m W x, 'b 0 2 )- G O C E N S A l i E //d $ i
?
l j
$ N 5 6
T Y , N Y M- 4 6 - N A T 1 I T N U L Wc c; y . , s
&T t; , E E A l
O C a F a g G:
~
- y. C S
A i T i c c A^ . A d E O i
^c r
N e w zj c 2 E P R E K 9 C N S U O P S I M A b ( (o S I M (
- d c
h d R V - C O . I E B N k av F G O w b h E D A D t a M g S L R S E e t t i g . R O T I T b u Y S t
,,. /c E F
E U O U L N f r e g A m (d ' l n
,- K H V
I R n 6 O' l W T A { e_ n O fY I S N P ( T+3 F I A 5' T d ' M S O A T - T _ I F G O + w f r \ N N I N N N O S N E b u a t h f O l l't i [ - R U T Q * , A Y Z , E s R L N I / }f! Y i a/ kw L 4
') ) P A T E w E
C I R
~L N M k ;h.][y.h$ k S ~( S C U i n A I O T M t b h L ,
A f l f e E l N L E G P B A I D E W N G I S 1 fi - D P 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
*A D ~
, j T _ L U _ T A A F _ m/._
- . 'D E l
E F D W^ M
)
(A E K M I N R O T S A U Q H T E H C S E A N R E O E M I H A T j l V V 1 0 4 E R $ N A 3 _ B A U K P 9 E O C R U _ O R E U C A _ T E E H O C f C V G C YO t _ E T I T N A L l o S A C A D N rE W h p s S' W E N A D N A O I T v t G G wL A O # h i b O V R D A P K k #
' A '
I T C A A E N E T l i U C C 1 8 ( 6 6 0 T h Co W ( e t t i L s u O D G O W" / _ I I n _ D E S a A R - S R O T 2 Y L T S R O H @ 1
+s W3 ) a r
H G E B S C}b f 9 N EW de% T C
& re 4 d e
I l E S I o M a H# n1 e3 (. A6 l T H A c t t
'iP _
F S T J
& LD Ci- i n a e O A l A L ' >e f, d W O S o b M mf -)(
T N R T S h G w Y 8E ( J t c& fkS b l a U O A E O_ N S E ib ' O n# S %. t 5 m r r 3'n M A E L C U N Y A S R D D A L t It 1 y v y w o o p* e ()g 1 o, h 1 NQ 4[ g ( j C o H !
/ ~ 5 6
T Y , 4 N N A Y T 0 6 I N 5 , T U S 2 E A O t s h n E
" r C S
A l i T C ) N I r3 V d f A E W O 1 E O b P R C N S U O P S I E M A i(
. 2/
o W* N n a ( o R O I D E G A B O N D l M U Wh f
} F S
L R_ S E o / Y L R O F T U I U T N \. E ' Y I % d Q E E V O S L N I R P k / V L Y / df i f o / f d I q NO I F A I T A S N Q 3 ' f / M O I F - T G O k d V Q N N I N N N O
. S N
E k
&h h
! o J R U
T I A L Y N Z I l [1 7 /. / R P A T E g i E
,d \
S C I C R U T U b u f d A I O L , T A R o $ ) ' E L E B A E W N G h P
,4 G
P I D I S l 3 4 5 6 y 8 { 9 0 1
I;l (~ T _ L U _ T A D A F A
.O F D W D E E N vE R
O T S U H K A Q M E H C S I E R E OI E M N MA A I N N
, V V f 1 .
0 T H A T D 4 E B R A E U O S K C R U U NA E P S 3 9 _ O T E E V I R E G N E U C H O C E C YOB N' A C T T A o S C D A1" c o a p A A N k s W D 2 g O N N p :t Ts .
,L i
err I b E A A T s O - V A L W ' T e fi cV I T R A D E P U P p A J W wb t e i n5
/
i s C E T A~ o C u _ A N H C 9
- T v n
m L O G O - I D I n D E S W/ / T - a A R - ?> m V~ 9 2 S R O T T R n y 3 >A y i a 3 8 2 n4 4 , Y S O n 3 f 4 4 L l i E H S , ug I A
't a
V$99
$/ J fC A g.
3' 9 D9 r3 o o3 kd a r G I B S C Ak g A c i
. w9 i e
H E T I H dg n Qul EE ' i Q t. aC a Y P F O S A T. e (e a 'u 4 v t/ 1 A r , A ob f i e ON g d NBgG ghC n/ W JL T O T l A q o r i m I uii B Rra sdN
\ l l
s Y s. R S Fb c a U A O S o t gd s r O M A E L N E R 0q 0 t o 3, t
~
7 f c gk M ovd r eA 0 r o C Y D M) n n- A R r1 C 1g U A D
,, '(&, C 6Cm a4 1
i E H N S A l I ( h 2 f c &,We S g t gS 1 5 6 T Y , lJ 4 Y N N A T 4h' I 6 hp
~
I N z~ 6 , T U x~ A E S A A H T O C 4" G7 M'N A' M
/
n o E C A _ E O '
~
* % E P
S 0 R E S P N ~Q l C U MI _ N I O E S I B M A N D' A v /* Mo [ f R O F D L O G A R T O S I D E T O h "- H /_E g L' t a J y A R y c s S R E F U U N b " l d o r A I H E O b a L I b i V R H G6 T b 5 I F S I N A P
$ M W 4 O M
/
i S - O A T A ' n
/r T
,f4 h ,
I F a G N O H d j m N R JL I S f k- T U N N A L N O Y N N E Z I h ' x X k 0 b T E R oS P A C T I C E R U Wl> Q ^ / A q N
- 4l L
E S I O T bd J m h, A E X ,h L A l 0 E G B A I E W N G I (~ I _fb )/ Q L P
< P D S 1 3 4 5 L 7 8 9 L l ; l ll l
i T L U _ A D _ A F A _ Y V[ D E E F D_\ N E R O T K A U Q M E H C I N_M A E A N N R E O I l /
/ r 1 1 S H S E M I 0 T H A T D 4 E R S N A E 3 B A U K PS 9
'O E O R
C R U U E U C h A T. E T E V I T E G N A H O C Y _C OB E g /'gR M C o Y o S A C A D R g p W E V N A D N A N O I T A h h w ht n n e M C i t t t [l L
&H gO s C
hx h t a t r i b O s A I R D P E O W: 4 s T C A E E T U C m G g(b, u i A O I N D H G I C O
% 3 L I fr< af .b ~ T L u
n D E S ] y - a A R - f S R O T $ c_ Y T S R O h.1 C Q T 3 47 b ( l I c a r, L H E H S W t
&(
4 .
% 6 MC G
I H B E S I f y D n c W b r d i e _ F T S H T A 7 e i
% S )
/ , d o P.
e O T A W O T 2he d L l 7) 7r $ do M d N U O M R A E L O N S S E R We d_ L ( o f e 9 O I U
/ f
(, o 7 L L t t l a r r o A C U Y A D D & 7 7 0 f Qa y T5 3 3t C E H N S A } l
@ (3 W 3 5 6
T Y , s N Y 4 _ N A T g 6 I T N U b U mg . Ir_ E E A O S A E H T C O
$[ (
M C
)
L T
+
n o 1 b [(u d C A E P _ R S P E h \ nW C > C U M (, S ( f R N O I A p O I D E G B O N D e f b O El l s l F _ A L y! S _ L R S E -r O T I T t s r M d [ n T R F U U N a e t L n 'g E H h E O L I 4 t V R f e i
/ V f
' T _
H A1- O N M i I S P ( M F I A / S O A T T I F G N O f f x s y p N Y
. u R I
N N A N O S N E t , w g 1 m d U T E Y
"(
Z ,
) R L N I l ( ) P A T E ]
h _ C R w E I w M S S I O L C U T A
]
l
]
L
.- kb '
}
Q A E L E B E N P ( G A I W G I { f P D S 1 - 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 s
j yUT A T L A F D A s Y O D E E K E M F I DW\ N N A d
' 5 u
d R A E A 6_ &r A >% 'V O T S E B U Q H T R A E H C S S U O E N N R E OI E M I H A T D K NA E P S C R U U ( / PAr b (" W 1 0 4 3 9 O R E U C A T E V E G H OC E C YO B d / t C _ M WN E I N o , o T S A T C A A D N bn ~ p s v W N D N O I T u.F ds u i b _ E A A T A I
- g. o s O V A \
r I T R A D E P U 4P u s _ A i C A O I E N D T H G I C C O W "9 / L L u n D a A E R S n yn s o 0C S R O T T R y bD a , Y L H S E O H S qQ q(@c _ / ?(p O U l a r kM Mso b d G B e I I I F E T S S I H T q m,s^' tl W hr d D u ?u i P g c - e O A n Dko Vp , _ M d . W O nw O T Nk /, T N U O R A E O N S S E M a 0 6, W h t}&' 5 n l a r r sJ R M A L C Y D Q 0 j G & 7 )4 o _ E H U N A S D A
\'Q 7
Q 6 ( 1 / OW b C 5 6 T Y , 4 N Y ! 3 6 N A T I N w h u , E T A H U O C h o E s ra / h D K b E C _ S w s A _ A E R T S O E k ft S n ig3 .G d] /o k E P - Yll kli P l C U c k S M e & R N O I A h b r + W N du O E B N T gM I _ F G O l d[ _ D A D i L O R T S I E T k ?
?
7 v
- S R
E U U 5 , yM i F N E V I O S L N I R P d D n n o Y w e D H T O F I A S d i l f M y O ._ A T JD N p _ F n T, T g~ I
)
h G O . N N I N N A L P N O Y N A S N E Z I T E R N g 2 7J a 1 t u_ c
]
f' 1 1 ( A r
/
/ Wb 6 1
/ _
R U T E R E _ O C I A S S I O C U T y y h S 2 m A E L A bk L E B A E W N G b -
}% /s P _
A4 G I I ; o P D
< S 6 8 1 2 7 t
j T L U _ T A D A F A
)
f D E E F D W (y N E R O T K A U Q M E H C I N M A E A N N R E O I
/ _
l % 1 S H S E M I 0 T H A T D 4 E R S NA E 3 B A U K P S 9 E O C R U U O R E U C A T E E H OC E 1 C V G C YOB l 0 E I N O u T T A , o S C D t , p A W A D N O tt r % E d'5 s u c
}g+ i r' u e"
~
N N I e E V I T A R A A D E T A P U M T' a d s f m s[W yM v c i f6 l i v n b O s s S uM i C A O I E N D T H G I C C O s hP Mob
&~& L u
n D E S N t O o a A R - c / i p l 4' S R O T k af L o n e T R f c3 f r 4 M g 4 c 3 W , Y L H S E O H S S w s9 Y k9 3 t K pA 9 d a r G I H B E S I Y ", m nO I
%U3 9 wA 5 0
0 w f i P e T H s~
%[
; A S ac F S T Y r O A W O t
a 4G u uC o A v k s e
'd n u0 M a , t j l <
T T t u ( L N U R A O_ S S k M a L. e H t y L t r b4 @ G l a O E N E cS H o c t f is
/
A r r M L R - T 6 M / A C U Y A D D N )# y! c! 9 m. 5/7 n 9 S C o E i l N S A lb 3 3 aa 2'
/
\
c u P m 5 6 T Y , R . 4 N Y 2 N A T F 0 1 E W 6 I N L a 9 R T U m e F 41 E A O o L 6 RE 0 K E C Y% E S A l i T C m W H C l z F E A E E O y% b& F d ~D P
?
R S E L C U P S M 41 a IN L M R N I O E I B A N A T P. y l' u O F G O % l
& A D A D i R E~
y t s S L R S E W E A 6 A o R O F E T U O I U L T N I $ kv h L 6 o N E I R M x R E H T
/ V R l i
fn N c C( t> W O I F S I N A S P k p ht b M E M O A T _ T u
& W I {d xUdt I F r G O p A
N I N N S N ) L ll @ uUR a r I E N R U T N A L P O Y N A E Z I T E haig L d S* [ h
" +
b'da l E R E C I R v o - to # S c )t S I O C U T A X m t G b ( A E E G L B A I E W N G I k 9 k.
% E L
P
- P D S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
T y L , T U A D A F A O Y l D E E 'F D6 N E K M I N5 A R A E A O T S U Q H C E R E N N O I ' 7 V v 1 H S E M I 0 T H A T D 4 E R S N A E 3 B A U K P S ~ (= 9 E O C R U U O ~ R E U C v - A T E E H O C E C V G C YOB Y@ ,r e w cn E I N ' r T T A o S C D #'t lx,O p A W 'A D N O dl e
- M/ l i s
N N I J.c K n s b E A A T h R
\
1 s e O I V I T R A D E A P U d L L s u 2 7 %.
) e m i s
/o l
M s C A O I D E N D E T H G I S C C O W S c h P l S Y h Fu L u n a - A R - L o S
< bS R O T /
0 - o T R o L l D Y L S O H 0 L i d S b L t h a, - H G E B S o s S U) o B l{'t 3 u S ,S d r e I H E S C a 5c l % ts i I m T H ht 1 O l P F S T i d $ # u A e O A W O 7 3 t i a k F u a d a o d . M 0: T N R T S 0^ i e i c h C k s B v l a
& E -
U A O. S i k O E N E R 0 'S s S r r M L 3 R 4 o
+n 6 9 4 A
E C U N Y A S D D A Y B' o 3 2
/
9 l C
/ 4.
3 5 C _ H T Y 3 T 2e i. 2 3 E 3 I n 5 6 N Y s N 4 6 N A T N I N s N A , E T A U O g 4 b w N Y M r E C S A H C i .
- pJ c n M A E
R C T S U O P S E M
/g f,
/t K.
s c ht y r g, c, g, D' dt l-e l i I b H C e E P R N I O E I B A N l Y k C ]- T m O G O / t G d F D L O A R T S D E T As t t k ]f) M e,
)
u G 5 N I A 5 S R F U I U N c. S i f( li 3 c l I t il L E H - E O L I M r c e 1 E T i A a V I F S I N A S R P f V
/
1 o k b D k 4 f b 6 w h O M O A G N T I F O u $ u u T N R nn n w - I N N A L N O Y N
. S N
E Z I Mf, b i ht m s U T E R . P A T E G / E O C I R S S C U 4 i A I O T 1 2 w h E L A 6
$ h B E O L s G
A W N G gh P CE I I
& 0 _
P D S / 3 4 5 6 '8 9 1 e .
T L VT C A D E U A F E K E M F DWNA I N D A R A E A O U H E N N [ / / T S Q H C S R E E O I M I V 1 0 T H A T D 4 E' R S N A E . 3 B A U K P S p 9 E O C R U U ( O R E U C $ A
'T E E H OC E l A, C V G C YOB C Je -
E N r I T T A t / / o S W E V I T A C A N A R A D D N A D E N O I T A P U d e T y c
-p a
r c h ca d V r e h e Y bn t A r j b4 O , W i b O p s s C E T C h E h S 5 W i u I D A O N D E H G I S C O % L n a A R -
- S R
Y H L O T S E T R O H S h t w k n o s 07 0 7 f t . [ f ( w A a r s A d G I H B E S I b,'5 M G D r e ~ c Y k o M i e F O T S A H T l ( 1 p+ t v b h e M 7 i f s h r o D P d e W O F 'o a l ao ( O T T N hD R % l N S S f a A O f U M O A E L C N Y S E R D 8 0 m a q q U 5 5 {- C r r o U A D 0 t
%* H - O E N A o H
T Y S. Y 8 G x 3 W R % M 5 6 4 - N _ 6 N A T - I N k W , E T A U O p E - S l i C o u df w C A _ A T l o E E O y e t R C S U P S E M r n d t r & V R P N I O E I B A N a c A 1 A x C ! 6 Y) - R O F G O R ( D L A R S D E e 1 S S n xt ,6 R O F E T U O I U L T N I d he r ; v c H H wa b l 2 1 Y ) M E H T V I S N R P c P J b K A
)
O M F I A t-S [ A T O I F T G O N N I . S , Q , fb R U N N A L N O Y N N E Z I f ky O r OG (( l M. j l T E R O P A C T E R O l" I g - u E P I C S S I O U T fg 3 1 c b
/ b A E
E G L B A I E W A N C I U b JL {! y f_ L P D
< P S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
a. T L U , _ T A D A F A . DE D E. K E M F DA N Y I N M A l / p' f AS R A E A . O T U Q H C E R E OI N N U + 1 H S E M I 0 _ T H A T D 4 E R S N A E l 3 _ B A U K P S 9 E O C R U U r O R E U C s A T E V E G H O C E C YGB ur e & C
^
ho h E N
#r I ,
T T A if o S C D Fc h. p A W A D N O iy C t -/ s b i
/&- k i E
V N A R N A D I T A Wiq s h n 3
,7 3h na c
b O f&a I P r T C A E E T U C aJ e u a Q i s u A N H C M M n [q L O I D D E G I S O M 3, n R a A R O T T R W0 4 V % I r 7 T 6 } S
"~'s>o/e ik r
Y S O 3 3 } a DW L H E H S 9 T l { 9 v l ) r G B A 9 s4 e e () - r 8 h$ d e I H E S I Q r, 3 2 kj i F O T S A H T M0 1 oA NO o nv
, k>
m i o n ,
% P d
e W O @#%& c8 AA % O T T i 7 A2D <. G a% s ie o l N U O M R A E L O N S S E R Df W f A 0S r$ o r i s Ja u gs .'75 l Mw%, 4
)
6 a r r A C Y D f.d {L 9L 0O o ro l h, C o U A D 6 c, E H T N Y N S Y A 6 d D' / 4m S G s~ 6 bWS
'C 5 6
4 6 N I A T N e T U o , , E A H O y /
/ ,,
, 1 E C
S C G c ., 4 A f 'f A T e E O L i t MMy E P R S P E l v S h M C E l C U S M m N O I A r o 6 f _ C h R O O E I E B N i _ s- n T F D L G A R O S D E k l/ a i Q L D S O F T U I U T N g Kt t i h r e u 0 e s R E H E O V L I R w a % L 1 L h T N O t E I F A S I T N A S P Q - A I /
~.
M O T _ G N I I F O S 7k h' /, A m
,c N N R
U WNC N N N N O E m L T E W 'W . m,_ A Y Z 4 R _
//
n L N I l A P x
/kV T E E O S C I C
R U W,,D S A
'I 5
E 3P O L B A I E W T A N G I j f [a u / %e V % p [ \ N 0 E L P
< D_ S 2 3 4 5 7 8 9 1
} .
W T L U _ T A D
/ A F A
! Y e, w D E E F D65 N E
R O T S K A U Q H T M E H C S I E R E l l N A M I A N N E O I A T D
/ A^/ i
" U -
/ 'v 1
0 4
.E R S N A E 3 B A U K P S 9 O
T E E V O R E G C E l l R U U U C OC E C YOB
" m g
g p A C E I N , T T A o mY S C D c p A W A D N O A s N N I - " i b E A A T g a
'l g
- O V
I T C A O R A E N D E T H G A P U C C O nm a s, & I 0 S 5<f y w s s g l k"l l u c i L s u I D I n D E S a A R R O T a 6 ' S Y T S R O Wc /e D w a,
/+
1-
/
L H /~ f r l i E S r 5 d G B o + 6 e I S w6 2 Po a e b lw M H E I i D P 6 e. T H i h F S T P P y 2 O A n , SU M m e e d y) W O
%g % O T T ,
(L N R S ae [ c i l a 7a wso (H 9 b3m U A O S O E N E A& f . r M A L C U Y A R D D 3s 7h m6 M m Y~ F 6 f s n ", Ag
)
l 0 7 3 o C r o E H T N Y S A l fb
/
y i 4 5 l' t 5 6 4 N Y 6 N I A T N 6 r p k y c U A'c c T a 6t E E A O f C S l i C C e o nc A A E T O e k s w E R C N I S U O E P S I B E M A N
% & FM M #
S( v I S 1 a [
\
\
o l A h 5~ P R O D L G A R O S D E 0r Mn v M s 3 6 E F S R w $ O T T / i , W e F U I U N V u / b -p S <, o E H O E V O L I R A Pb v Q 2 T O I F S I N A S P D _ l l
/
y 8 M A T u T I F ;y z G N O a)k ;/
' o k /, N k
d'a SU I S L U
,l N N N N T N
A O Y E Z oMa (
/ , E L N I l I L # #R M_
P A T E - E ,, Q C I R e y$ 4 O - S S C U .E A d A A 4Mb
~
I O T ,'a t E 9.Y L A $ (\, b L E B A E W N G l P G I I 0.
. P D S 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 ,A
T L U ! _ T A D 4 A F A t
! Y f O
\
D E R E K A U E M E H F I E D N MA A N N N N 2 [ l O T S Q H C S R E E O I M I ] T H A T D E R S N A E . O B A U K P S L - r E O C R U U c O R E U C e u T E E V I E G N H C O C E YOB 7 0r
/
t e b u 7 T T A ch 8 S A C A D N fa et J9 W D O o rb 1 f N N I y. s D icM o E V A A T A i S i( p3 4 I T R A D E P U n m, 2
^
0, M b g e hc 7 C A O E N T H G C C O '( e L , E f 2z 1 C , M F1 M r a5-I D D E I S y* n y , C 2 A R R O T ce 0 8 u 3 Y T S R O H 3, 0 G g d 1 o m r 4 W ba &- L H E S 4 Pt s d f- N r e dd N N G B a b w. e I H E S I p !A-
/ k OL 0 bW iO T
S H E b O b L E h P u Mk F T e O A V i c O C O 7 d i W O Wc f 1 O T N U R A T O S S A b, n h t n D A h f' d& wlra O M A E L C U N Y A E R D D G Oz 6 M 5 7 e 2
/
b i l O C o r& E N S A 9 O b l'2 N (3 $ 4L 0 ( 5 H .? i 6 T Y N Y
'r 4 N A T ( c 6 N nl r I
T A , E A U O c n e G ,
,& 6 E
C S A H T C 5 o (C a G N n- 9uW A k'N n E E R S O P E & 7 w a n m 0 5 I a W S P C U S M 2
/ Al S R N O I A ?< gb NC O I E G
B O N ( m 0 kQ F D L O F A R T U S I U D E T N c h s t e E2 o m 8 O C { M4 Ad l l y' \ d' S R E H l4 .N E O L & V I R d* b T I F S I N A S P s$ S n l O b
)
- b O M
O A T f I F hc e & be C T fui t T T / k G - O N N a n R I . S a c /h f f m. m U N N A N O Y N E Z ,0 i. M Y2 Y , T E R L P N A I T E ~- w N u+ i 2 M E O S I C O L I C R U T A
)
b A G
,,b h h b t
/'! a S
A E L E B A E W N G k S l h P G I I ' ' 0 P D S 1 3 4 5 6 Y 8 9
T L U T A " A F O D E l E F D W^ E K M I N % "^ R A A O T U Q E H C E N R E O "' J S E H T R S S E M I H A T " N A " k B O A E U O R K P ' C R U " E U C b$ T E E H O C " $ I V G C YO" . E I N #
' 7 T T A 5
; P 8 S C D ' 9 A A N d " E 1 W D O / "
N N I $ t , E A A T 3 V A R
- N*
- I D P h T A E U / c C A O N T H G C C d )j / b r a D O A W~' M a( I I D E S ,G 4 y A R / 2, 3 b R O T T R i g 6
- h' b
0 l b Y S O o A a L H E H S C m D 1 1 5 f4 r
$ U"0 d
G I H F B E T S S I H T 0 3 nh 9 *M q r4 e M G Q 0 S lb 9 9 d o3 M K i P e e O.N O T A W R O T S g s h 6o , hn g l 6C A c l gl
- Y S
ua D y A C d l a U O A E O N S E R Y t g 3 O j
, h . O r
r M A L C Y D ML 4'h 5 f A Pb 0 ' o b l A C . E H T U N Y A S Y D A
-Q 4 E(r t H 3
K 3 S f S 5 6 4 N N A T
@[ N M 6 fk I N 2 ,
R E S A T A H T U O C N
\
O (A kI L 0 n VE s u b
' M d<
E C A d h E E O 0 o $ P R C S U P S E M I 1 h k $+ l gk p t l h t ' R N O I A b i M Md O 0$ c k I E B N m W ' F G O e K D A D l { d- E l S L O R T S E T M t E W $,~ ${} ,M R F E U O I U L N I M I (x 6 3 T T p w 0
& E H
T V I F S I N A R P
&w b I % N 5, I D O M
',J S O A T ( W ~
T I F ' d( e G O N 1 h~ N R I N N A L N O Y N S N E Z I ff J. U j
]
ft w f ht M7 U T E R P A T E E
$n hE 11
[. C I R
* 'E 9h S S C U A O. L t T
k d-I O O E L A h' L r-3 E B A E W N G [ f/ ! (
' ' T P
G P I D I S 1 2 3 g / 7 8 9 0 1
T L ) U o T A D p A F - A s
! Y i D E E F DA N b
.O E R K A M E I N MA A W W O O T U Q H C E N N R E O I V s s i S H S E M I u T H A T D L E R S N A E B A U K P S n E O C R U U a O R E U C T E E H O C E L- (S F V G C YOB c E T I T N A
~
' o / + 7 S
A W C A N D D N N O e F S P b( s- t s S o lMo 9 8 1 E A A I T e, . 0 c n ks , V A Lf c c . e - 3 - re R D d 6 I T C A E E T P U C n [% OP S 5 S 5 5 l u h 0 h c r fQ S A N H C a f f S b #" a O G O M I D I D E S y A R R T
- g' 4 yj l s
r, $ l b em Q/c O T R C c y / n .M o f rf z Y S O a3 r cA 6/' , L H E H S ( e? 3 <3 y k q y aW g t e a r - G B S e
/'o,l' D9 b p
uo a f n 2 4 X 2 d e spa +m I H u o Z V i E T I H a 8 (tc r o ts s i lA lc yah o t . s a W 2cV S P F S i6 e g z. a MC s:P wL T_ v. e O A W O coC ei c h cs r R p<t R Js d _ O T N 'R T S m us ou n i iu 36v m r u o f s<.rL(- l a pn s& Ak coc I - o U O M A E L O N S E R f ,3 i s :_ u c Y y L o o m l b B b r r o A C Y D p# / e s L , 9s l 70 m U A D na gw o u o A L C E H N Y S A sy g i o )t n t S a / N C. s 9 s 50
/ 5 6
T , 4 N Y 6 N I A T N f V n _ E T A U O e W /a o E S H C r c, 2 l t ! e S n C A E T O
&ed X /r 6 a 0 m 6 l
c A E 9 IP
-r R S P E E C
N U O S M A / B G W 3
^ % & b
/ f R I
I E B N t e L S a O F G O c R w
/) f F e, D A D G n C t h
S L O F R T U S I U E T N , A es
/ce %6 E H
f t h e let
- o H R
E E O L I u d V/ - a ?r T M N V R . I F A S I T N A S P P
- f<
- b N O $
0
/
\
k O M O T - G I F O
'f)
'w k in N
I N N N O S N E
,/wf~
& f,a,/ & md 5 s n yI N
R U . A L P Y N A C Z I T I E R d? t u /{ W 2 E A 5 hg,h m E S O S I O L C U T A n8,
,fy u
,qn f$, w n L b u 4 A E _
E
& A G
B I E W N G I - ' 7c i c n llg, P 0 L P D S 2 g 4 5 6 y a 9 1
.. l 1)l 11 T
L U _ T A D A F A O Y - l D E E F D E\ N - E K M N5 A I v
/ /
R A E A O T S U Q H H C S E R E E O I M N N I V ' m 1 0 T H A T D 4 E R S N A E 3 B A U K P S O E O R C R U U E U C ar 9 A _ T E E H O C E C _ V G C YOB E T S I T C N A D a g 4 - o p - A A N cn J s k W D O c i W~ N N ' v J I b E A A T e O wb V A _. a s mEf" I R D P s T A e E U i C A O I E N D T H G I C C O N S E & L u n _ D E S ' h A R wm Y y S R O T y T R sb _% , Y L S O H w n ts a aa Y H E r S M G s d a $' I B S d w [g ) e k i e amL1 au ? l l E I n a P T H Q / O F O T N U S A W R A T O T O S S 5 ad eY Ca3cV i_n a s
%G g
%a? A d
3 0 h O G K d l e a r y._ j
,d"l O E N E M L R 0 a v m $ r nn , o
\
2aS I A E Q C Y D O C E H T U N Y A S D A ft C RS i- ml ( A c 9 1 5 6 4 N Y N A T A 6 I E T A N U O bi - m r ( E S A E R l i T S C O P E A l
/- w e e
c k 6 m @ u n0 C C A E P C N I D L U O E G A R S I B O S M A N D E DV i a a ) n
~.
1 c n d 4 e" hl b
\ 8 it Y b
p R O F S O T I T N a 1 g R m E n AlM F U U N h E V O L I R
)t xn i c 3 l ,
H T I F A S I T I N A S F P ? ! 2 1 U ho L M 4[ 4 $ O M O T G N I . O S m l n <I C N R U
)h~o N N N p N O E A o h' A Y Z l i h y E e Ik44 b f R
L N E 7 I ' 7 A O P A C T I E R v - E S _ E dik S C U < A I O T E _ L , A E B E N - u s L P
& A W G )/
G I I D s 0
< P S I 2 3 4 5 6 8 9 1 l l l Il l1
~
T L U _ A D A F A OVT D E E K E M F I D\N N Y M A R O T A U Q E H C E A N N R E O I ,V f 1 S E H T R S S E M I H A T D NA E V 0 4 3 B A U K P S 9 E O C R U U O T E V R E G E U C H O C E C YOB jf b A C E T S A W I T C A N A D D N O s s* [ &. $ d> h u T Y
- o p
s E N A N A I T c
/
//Ac M o @ O %'mQ7_ -
%D lT A n 7
% i b
O V I T C R A E
'D E
T A P U C b 4m
%m g S T
%5/ i s
u A O N H G C O Nef s_ / 1 CP 6 ? - L I D I D n D E S sc a i4 a A R R O T s s y I 0 o 4 1 W. ( h S Y L H T S E R O H S O o s f m D 4 4d 3 G] 1 c u 7 R M a r G B
&s bY W d
e I H F O E T S A W S I H T O LH 9 N
$ O o.
L. s o c Cvk b it fo r B E L ss R 0w0 U b u
/c i
P d e O T N R T S #c rm
/
/ 7d l a
U O M A A E L C O, N Y S E R D 7 0 N 9 3 W o l #l 5 9 3 at 3 Fs 2 s r r o E U N A S D A 3
/ 3 r % ff l S 52 }Mf C C
H T Y , 1
/ /V 5 6
4 N N A Y T S
) a G 6 k
I N x S L 6 , T U E A cKC )/ 4 E S H O C \
\, Z N C A
A E R C N I T S U O E O P S I B E M A N r e ' 4M c /
?
/
b d y o h k ( i l E A C A h m e )/ t ao R b N E P R O c 1 G O g 6 F a Ml h D L A R S D E d
'w Ny ? t
/ w f
/
0 2t S R h h1K
]p O T T 4 / -
I F E U O U L N I jb ua $
/ N u /7 E
H T h h @ V R V' O I F S I N A S P A M. $ % M _ A G N T I F O
)
d w e {/ w O T N I . S u f R U O N N A L P S N O Y N A C N E Z I T I C E R U G k l s m t w f)j \ M lE T E R S A I E O L B A E W T A N G f Yg ) l E L P G P I D I S y,I 3 4 5 7 8 9 0 1 - 4
l, l l a T L U _ T A D
) A F A
, l Y (t - D E E F D6N E
R O T K A U Q M E H C I E R E N5 A N N O I A
~ f 1 S H S E M I 0 T H A T D 4 _
E R S N A E ' 3 B A U K PS 9 E O C R U U O R E U C A T E E H OC E ,. C V G C YOB E I N , T T A ~ o S C D p A W E V I T C A O A N A R A E N D N A D E T H G N O I T A P U C C O I f Q g L, y b I F-d g e r CA t i 4 K J u W h Y6 1 1 M r W w f W i b O i L s s u I D I n D E S L a A R - Y S R O T , V T R t A , Y S O m j ' 3 a L H ~~ p, f 't r H G E S 1
- 7
- n d B
S f I 5 2 3 F k 1 r e -
- WM n.i I
H E I - 9 {C P T H a F O S A T
- l< o O' p or e /
y, t d e - W O E nl3 t ]
,V uo h@>o T T l o n 0
'T ' vaS
' l R J/
, N U
O M A E L O N S S E R 5 3 U L R Cm f a r r o A C Y D b 3 e A eLn i. ft o
/v u0 WmC U A D 9. o 7 T E
H N S A 4. 3 I nk P 5 T N Y N A Y T N
, I
~
t 4 6 f( 6 4 6 I T U . V , m 0 E E S A E R A H T S O C O P E n i . g N h m1 6,.'W t f A,A f C E P C N U O S I M A S. e , c c e l a O Aa,.R b I E B N q f y- ,F D G A O D 3 <. D b > L O R T S I E T I g dA Q o .SR
>5 E 0bfM U U g
F N C R \ b H E V O L I R R O a ) 6 T b'S O j I S N P M F I A N Y3 i S O A T G I F O ] h U m d.TN N e. r.
% U Y I
N N N O S N E d b ' l Y
)
f/ J-A e.U
.E R
T - A Y Z 1_ 1 h, nM R W u L N I ' 0
) P A T E . ,L S I
C O L I C R U T A u, . g M l
?
v b_ dn.E eA S A E L E 6 G B A I E W N G I g y ( ~
'kR 9 P
f _
,4
- P D S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1
9 1 I. .
T L U = T A D _0 A D E F E K l E M F I W M A
/
N J_ / - R A E n O U H E N T Q C R T f S E H T R S. S E H A E D f < $r B A U K P S n E O C U U e_ t R - h
= O E i
/b T E E H E Vr R
V G C B E I N 'O O e E 7 T T A h S A C D ' nu 8 9 A N e!nam k 1 W D O E N A N. A I T N S' M n e-f c fa U V I T R A D' E A P U W d'e+n A( Ao
/) SO l
rh 1N i r A-P K h c n C A O I E N D T H G I C C O M XO
'Y +
f- 2 ( + b H e M r a D E S s M y a A R - b R O T f c o l T R 2-s I o Y S O l& D L H E H S & w C. 4 O R
% a r -
p,L( d G B w d'( 0 # e I H E T S I. H 1 M I r f Wu% h 4 A e i u R o i P F S T T [ e o e
'n 3
O A T u R Sn W O C R n d O T N U R A T O S S & 7) kO lkB'!N h t e n-A P H
%r n
a c e l a O E N E R D h H o O Y r r M A L C Y D 1 7o ) C 0 Gc o E U N A S D A 2 ll G %) (4 CX X 0 m 8 o A C Y 3 H T Y , a A b ( l 5 6 4 N Y e N I E A T A T N U 0_ O. t e s' df M I f O Y s 6 E S H C D ) b r Y- u C A M/ e b s W A T l e u E E R C S U O P S E M h 4 C e f M l o R o G [A S P C n R N I 0 E G I B O A N 6 3 d Se ~ Q N D e c A b naF O D A D S G 3
/ L a SR c
b R V <, E i L S E A O T I T d 7 2 L 4 i E b F U U N f (; L / _ E O b Y
- e t N H L I l b D T L
V R 4 O I F S I N A P k GAM b h 6 A 5 M- M S O A T , I F h, _ $ , J gYBS w T G N I . O S h W" f C I i r aR O d [dr ba N R U hA N N N A O Y N E Z W h aC h 71
/ T E
R k MR L P N A I T E M v l u aE D a E o S O S I C O I C R U T W L u C
'A m ai A L L O
d A E O _ L , A I mA D L Y I $( E B E N - P _ G A I W G I _ L 0 P D S
/~
/
I 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 u
1 T L _ U T A D _ A F A U D E E F D \ N Y E R O T K A U Q M E H C I N M A E A R E O I N N V S H S E M I - E T R S H A T D N A E h _ s _ B A U K P S V' t O C R U U p _ E O R E U C o T E E V I E G N H OC E C YOB
' /
n re - cu 7 T T A U h 8 C D / de S A W A D N
% e, y I
a r e g& 9 1
~
O i N N I 8 r bi r_ , E V I A R A D T A P 0 o ha h ce e r h c gbC 3 h T s a M T C A A E N E T H U C C
" 5 0 2 e
]jN S e Y c r ro aV O G O 0 7~ S d M3 I D I D E S s e A R -
h s mr rc_ b y7 R Y L O T S T R O H d lM r k c_ k c h D,Mt W
/ a rb H
G E B S hcA b i t
% Y ) dL eS I S y' d /- n ,
se U i r e m. yO Do H E I V P
.NX T H t 2 F
O S A T u"9 n t c b
& % ar em l d
e 6 h b$ e n W O c d kr 4 ho h O i T T L.
*U N R S O3 i l a
eb ss C. i - 4 1 L L U A O S i r O M A E L C N Y E R D G A" " n 3 1 Z Y 7u MI 1 T C r o 3 B O 9
~,Y(
A D A
? -'I U
E H N S A
/ E" 9 /
/ ,
3 5 6 T Y y 4 N Y , o n 6 N A T r e w D, S n ' a N h) ' aM _ I , T U ; a l i M" E s_W t Q E S A H C O d ny q v uv C A A T 3 E o a' e
& fi O k E
M P 1 R S P E - de r r e't O n C U M d R t S ] N O A
>d C e I
c 0 O E B N F I G O D
- e. &n 0 n 'dt D
L A R S E l da. e vr e n i S R _ O F T U I U T N - a a b W C E H E O L I h S d( d M lu T V I F S I N A S R P b f,- l d u 0 U c AM v M O M O G A T I F O a e,Y4 w f d r kd b 0:
/
T N I N N S N i d J b e u N R U T N A O Y E Z n a E]f % h E R
'y L
P N A C I T I E R e O: dl L u, TM " E S S C U I< A M',O I O T 4 ha, d d t CO E E L B A E W A N G %eb 0 t N 0 1 /
~
L P G P D I I S b 3 4 5 c 6 lI 8 V Up l I ll Il ! l l lll j
~ _
T _. L ) U o T A D p A F A s l Y i D E E F D t E K M I N RNA b O _ R A E A
/
O U H E N N s T S Q H C S R E OI E M I v V 7 i u T H A T D L E R S N A E B A U K P S n E O C R U U a . O R E U C S T E E H O C E ( V G C YOB / . E T S I T C N A D r W S 7 8 A A N ~ la S f J 9 1 W D O e E V I N A R N A D I T A P e r v t v+ - w u 3 T C A A E N E T H U C C N, S u Q h s h c r O G O f a I D I
/ M D E S y A
R R O T R
- n f /o
/
b Y L H T S E O H S R c i k ( 2 a a r G B o n a d I S o L e H E I O 5, $( l '{4, i P T H e L g F S T (. s SO rr k e _ J O T N A W R O T S ~ o d. B l % ( % d l a , U O A O N S a / E r E E - M A L C Y R D i r E T Q r o a 0 7 r C E U N A S D A o N 6 S 6/ H T Y , b 1 0 5 6 N Y 4 N A T 6 I N v 6 , T U L E E A O ld 4 I I C S H C ' ' A y 1G,A E T O h l a d p o E P R S P E h k f , gy, C U S M : t' N I D O E G A I B O A N D
?
?
a Y 9 . R O F L R
/ )l S S E ,
l W . g R _ O T I T , t f E F U U N - i Ks H E O L A d g MTO I V R d I F A S I T N A S P f
/
N 0 s h' O I F s 9 T l d 0 G O g,
))7ld, N N -
e R I . S J - N N N O [q l T N A L O Y N E Z
/
w }f b E R I P A T E " N" C I R l E Y. A S C U S , I O T , ' f' A M E
& A G
L B I E W A N G I k Y [
? % 0 E
L P P D S 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
T L _ U T A D _ A F A _
! Y _
\
D E E F D _ E K M N MN A R O A U E H I E A N N V _ T S Q H C S R E E M O I I v _ T H A T D E B O R A E S U O R K C E N R U A E P S U U C M
/
T E E H O C E C E T S V I T C G N A D C Y O B L I ~ I r 7 8 A W A N D N N O E w & 9 1 I , E V A A T A H N 3 I R D P C S O' b G A h T C A E E T U C P
- E c
r A O N H G C O S T C a M I D D E I S t o m $ mo 3 y A R R O T g k A 1 b W b T R S N NZ t A L S , - Y S O g @t 9 D V e. C 4v 'A a L H v f r r f/ $8 H E S 6 v . d c DM f# m G B e b e I H E S I df lf L L m 7 /C c 0/'A
/ ac f r 2 '
1 A iD i P T H 0E is .$ak o S V Y F O S A W T O m r Wh 5
/
7 D Wo Sf cc a es RS { R O W x, de u l T T F c X V/O %( v u u S _ N U O R A E O, N S S E /
/
# b R
- C f
PJ f/ h ,bc a '051hC ' b S G'U
$ 6
(' c a r r M A L C U Y A R D D 3 2
)c h
toj D D/ j$ o 7/ / fSU b 1 f A'S Y 0 7J 5 4 5 C o E H T N Y S A / ( . P G& J 5 6 4 N N A Y T L E 6 I N f D E E Y T U U L h E Nl L E S A H O C w v T ? O L A L_ L E wA C A E T O d
/ e MF D G-s E
R C S U P S E M I T N(t.W . C~ . I
&gb N O A 8
5 h 8 dn I E G I B O N 6
- T S E
- n 0
F D L O A R T S I D E T
< 4 l
W Wl M L O
'l T
AE N 0 /A S R E F E U O U L N I M M C K M ?A A A G-o N. i $ 1 H T N h N V R ~ C I F S I N A P g / E
/
R. t a h O M S O kk W A T g T I F G O M N NM"k N I N N A N O Y
. S N
E Z y W . w
) -
y Y 5 t qh
&I E l
U R L N
)bk N t
I P A T E ( M o S C I C R U a $ o t O l f r E S A O T
&l w E i
I ~ L A yy 6 L
, i E
B A E W N G h j , I f P G I I , .
, 0 P D S 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
T L T U A D / -
) A F Y
A - (yR l D E E F D W\ N E K M I N A - O T S A U Q H T E H C S E R E H A N N E O I M I A T D d V l V " l 4 1 0 E R S NA E 3 B A U K PS 9 E O C R U U T, f _ O T E R E E U C H OC E - g g s A C V G C YOB E I N n c 2,_ y n , T S T C A D e, w c y A o p
$c Ye M A A N a s W D O n e Rr 7 i E
V I N A R N A D I T A P h i k E e M f_( i Ag Rs i
'vr 'W u b
O s f W h Q< "llc T C A E E T U C F c e Bs I h
/
i u A N l C Lp L i O I D G I O / n D E S s. Vj a A R - ws $e y dc 03 Ay g .S R O T - Y T S R O 0 w
% y G3 'M n) *2 k
{ L H E H S b K
-~
G c, Kj N9 A o-G I H B E S i C E g,3 e% %v,P e T I H h
&g / 5
/ p, f d w%
A o t F S T < H . e
,)q O
T A W O T X V H y g g, h
/
E ,u, MC 5 (p s d h
, N R S e a Mc O U
O M A E H A E L C U N O_ N Y A S S E R D D A R WT { O z-y V S V 79 r 1 n oy
/
85 V
/
L d5 3$
/
o O
%L s
j g _l C 5 r r o 6 T Y N Y P y 4 N A T N
%. W P o x, 6 I
l h g(u c x W T U u E A O C a b n g /a 5 n 5 C S l h p, I } A S i t A T c o N d E Sd ff E O c t P R C S U P S E M u g YN I E & L i s R N I O E G I B O A N k g h [ A 'V A 4 f E > O F D A D O n L R S E d n B w S O F T U I U T N u t T E m W H a 1 W L R E H E V I F A O S I T L N A S I R P 9 1 7 WM A l/ ( A
/
Y Q R 5 ' N T O M O T u G N I N N I N O F O S N E a
$ JE Q5 i 2
/
y T N R U A Z [M Y L P N A C I T E R A
~
~
" Q'e E
/&W/
I
.V S l
( S C U k A I O T E L A S L E G B A I E W N G I J $ ' / 0 P _ P D S L 2 $ 4 5 6 7 8 ' 9 1 M i \
T L U _ T A F Y^ _vA l D E E F D \ M E R O K A U E M H I N E A N " M T Q C R E O 1 S H S E M I 0 T H A T 4 E R S N A 3 B A U K P 9 E O C R U " O T E E R E U H O C C ie fj A C V G C Y G j t E I N j [ T T A a (, o S A W C A D D N O Qt
- e {- )k 5 M
t / T C i p s E N A N A I T c 5 ne E i
]
I o b O V A & V 6 R al h/g T p W I D P s T C A E E T U C & U rg b S p S i u A O I N D H G I C O
'f
~
p
& k T
S L n' D E S a A R R O T n b [, y % o S Y T S R O O w Y# 7 7d 6 0 T S t , L H E H S j R 0 9 A 'M N 7 , U
% R lt d
a r G B K 3 ( - o e h.g
~
k.b C S I R )v A a i H E I c
/
t l 4 > P - T H 3 i A9 [ A 5 D F S T q k/ l 9 W / 0 ~-e 4 c.MM^ )9 0 A 0 M
" d T'
W 0 T hgb 6 cs L Ab b(, 7c CJ C U W l N U O M R A E L O N S S E R [ t o o aa 0 ' 5, o o b 0 a r r o A C Y D l t r o 5 i
% C E
U N S A D A
+2 M nC w'a(i3% d o f 0 h % 2 t
H T Y ., m 2Y f 5 6 _ N N A Y T lC M 4 6 I T N u 5 , U A E S A A H T C O $) n L t l}
,, C E
E C A - E R C S U P S O E M k[ l e o S r h S h. b W l L g g y X E P R N O E I B A N T M O W& I F G O D A D v c ,2 W. 0 S L R S E %, [a R
/ 6 O
F T U I U T N o ,n C L '
^ N E
H [ u E V O L I R Na N - g L A T s O I F S I N A P L 0 R [. D. ]O M S h A T f O I F / l T G O & N I S T, d ,/ @ Y N R h W /u U N N N U N O E T A Y Z / E h R - L N d'f I =
'y 0
P A T E 5 t E C R S I O I C U T y a. M, U S A E E L B A E W A N G h b L P m [W^ G P I D I S v 0 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 k-
dr w [ T L U _ T. A D A F A oD E R E K A E M E F D\ I N M A Y N A O U H E N N T Q C R E O I 1 S l i S E M I 0 T H A T D 4 E R S. NA E 3 B A U K P S 9 E O C R U U O R E U C b A T E T S E V I T C E G N A D H OC E C YOB e 6 a
/
h o w d f \ C o p A A N v/A
,i " a N s W D O /I
~W e i f
N d N I b E A A. T T D O V I T R A D E A P U hA e M n i s C A E N T H C C p ur bM A S T" u O I D D E G I S O A. # L n a A R - o S R T c O T R k I , Y L S O H
> k @d c 'r a
% ,M. g E r H
8 S d G B e I S i H E I t b T H m c .P
,*pg,.l i
F S T h . d\ e oN O T A W O T u E p n% eA
'I ss -
d U O R A E O N S S E V 6 8 n o a r M A L C Y R D J Y_ em T e A s .ro E H U N A S D A b y A' I
'L l ao 3' 2
C 5 T Y
, 2 ~ 6 Y 4 N 4 N
I A T T N U
"/ h
\
E M 6 M C Y I
- wr 6
E E A O C @ b z ) r g a C S C k^ l L z D c A i A T 6 A r k E u L E R C S U 0 P S E M 8, Bb &) L C f # $r c P N I D O E G A I B O A N D TW EG d p i ali / E [A L 4 0 6 R O F S L R S E T v O F E V I T U O S I U L N T N I R P Mw #sG ht K G M O a d/ fO
@d3 r ~ W L
R E H T O F I A [M a u M k h W S +. O A' T d % 6 k T G I F O ]X k4d m f f
#s .B fte 0/
# l ~oL N
I N N
. S N
L -
#i S N
A L P O Y N A E Z I T E w sc O 01{- A T E R oS C I C R U A k $
) s +
2 S % E
.S A
O L T A [/ T 8 d' u/ , E nI E B E N h L 4 l/u / b,I P G P A D I W G I S 1 / 2 3 %/)& 4 5 6 , 8 9 9 1 r
~
T L _. U _ T A D A F A - O F D.W N D E E E K M I N M A - R O A U E l l E A N N d V
% Y -
T Q C R E O I S l i S E M I -. T l l A TD - E R S NAE 3 1 A U K PS e . E O C RUU l c _ . i O R 'E UC _ - N T E E l l OC E :- - V G C YOB E I N t _ - 7 A W T S T C A D A D N O o n o f f 9 L
%c r 5 !
W 8 9 1 f__naU yd l. N N I h 1 - - rn du-E A T I V R A D P A E
/c 6 5
tpA r mc W - 3 T A E U Mof bA yg fMh t iL c s C I A O E N D T l i G I C C O E 9' 1_ je N 0
- _C S 4
r a D E S _ _ _
. _ y R
A R O T u y- _ - - _ b h. T R 2 - q Y S O l e o E_ __ _
- l. r, a
L l i l i G E B S o k s w _ A <o S e d l i l E T S I n N C j a 6 W _W t-
.- c .m h o '
i P F S l i T w .' G* h_ gg c N c o _nO r e O W A O e c. r M
- pi kG6 M V w hu d O T N R T
S F d7 t l f L o b. l qD n r e l a U O M E L A O N S E R i M bI bm i [L f
- ^
L r r 4L .f A C U Y A D D o 6 O 1 f h h V ? '5 i C E l i T N Y S A R_ n C t l~6 2 4Mh 30 S S 1 lOk L S> z "# . IQ.% l 5 6 4 N Y e 6 T N A - I N d _ T U x i E E S A E R A l i T S O C O P E e sr o a f y
'A Y
A c, n
?.- 5 0rE f tP A
C C N U O S I M A C sn (2c A [L 1 OF I D E G A B O N D b c o s i M_k G N W - S L R S E Cv R O T T u d M - I J E F E V I F U O S I U L N A N I R P
~ B a
r iN N h__W f
$c t
W J 3 U h LWkT y A/I t l l O M S O A T M h _ s L_ T G I F O p ~_ R. N g ~ % N R L Y* 1 I . S e _ U N N N g & T N O E b s O A L P S Y N A C O Z I T I C E R U T Q% l d l v o O p L n d b
, s,wSEAL R
E I E L B E A N t e A a } { M
& A W G l T P G
P I D I S 1 3 5 6 7 8_. 9
- l. i i
T
~
w
T L U T A D A F A O WN
/ /l l
D E E F D M E K M I N A R A E A O U H E N N _ T Q C R E O I = S H S E M I T - H A T D E R S N A E I A B O E U O R K E U C P S C R U U y r , Nb IFb 5 T E E H O C E 4 E T V I T G N A C Y OB M o 1 k# l 5 5 g t e 7 8 S C D 'I bo h G O 9 A A N 1 W e. W N D O T % M 4I6 C' k N I d C h E V A A T A . f> 4 e 3R n P - l nd u 3 R D O g u T t' I P q @ A' h . T A E U D 4 M gS G F $. c C A O E N D T H G I C C O T S i h W E M' $ 6 M r a I D E S M A y A R R O T
- 9 l 1 kfd b Y
L T S R O H b90 $ 1 O V10 A 3 ln W k Dl l Nlo a r N hd$r *W 'us s3 I H G E B S E g f 1 1; % '
\
L d e I S Ve h,
@< W ,-
t i H F E T S I H T A t Ag Y N% 0 bsh ta i 6 MO AA c i L aQ P e N;> . i O A F c oL o l . h d W O O g i$r Vg g AO e O T N U R A T O S S A S Po % ,
?7 ., (
m f $ 5dMC f D l a C O . 5 or O r i O N E 2c 0 ! E Jt r M L R 44 N g r ( p c T B . ()a L - o 7A lS WWL A C Y D C 9 ea V 1 m. s ( U A D d4 q6 E H N S A iC D% UQt t l r
/.8 ,
5 6 yY 4 T kg N I TNU Y 0 u 6
&y ,h T 1 E
E A O $ . s g C S H C e A u b/ 'TO c W, A A E T O g LI N b o E P R S P E 3 t C U S M (a M s ,
/ R N O I A S L NA b O I
D E G A B O N D G( n D f O V bi f!
\
L L A u F S loG L R S E e I X R O T I T er W 5 t re \ E F E U O U L N I o 1 l b g t M J V
'1 H T
V R W 9 k \ b ( O I F S I N A S P
' [d '
M O y A G N T I F O s bl M Y 1 A &O Y jQ T N R I S
)(f U N N N l lG T N
A L O Y N E Z I
% \
# 1 K M [p(h6 u
E R 1 P A T E 7 Q E O S I E C O L B A I C E W R U T A N G Wh
/
f 3 4 9
?
fp
,f
% M S
l O_
\
S A E L P - G P I D I S L 2 3 4 s 6 7 ( 8, c_ 9/1 0
T L _ U T A F A D A
- / _
O D E R E K A E E M F
.Y
\
I D_M N A N A I/ O T S E B Q H T A U R S S U H C E N N R E O I E M I H A T D K N A E 4, / 3'10 4 3 P S mi 9
,E E O C R U U O
T T S E V I T C R E G N A D E U C H O C Y_C OB E R O r o S i de A C o _p A W A D N O d N tn i s N N I R w r / _b
- n. F E
V A A T A E N w n e d e
- d. d a O I
T
'R A
D E P U ( e u Ms > h s hb i C E T C m n . u A N H C L N $ i O G O T u f I D I n su D E S a M L< a A R R O T M D S Y T S R O R o Mk r n a f
.b L
H G E B H S g G o
' G sa S d G d
r e I H E T S I H p c u P o %W ? e s,. /
/
4 o k i P F S T c % L J 7 1 O A W i B l.
/ 3 d O T N
U O R A O T O N S S H 6\ ( s 0 h m y l c M3.'e 0 1 l a r M A E L E R 4 W R 1 s 3 d/ X 9 r o C Y D
- v. n l
E U N A D A 3 o H 3 - i T 4 0 C H T Y S 9 P 1
- u. 9 5 6
4 N Y , 6 N A T I N r U J D o T U E S H A O C m l r K C u t e n. . Wo E C A T s dv e G r A o.mc e E i E O t w f. s P R C S U P E y i J m I f i t N O S I M A C A!c N. ~O D c R I D L E G A R B O S N D E g r R M n (c d.h R b h Q W o O F S R O T T H r. a F E V U O I U L N I R 7 g a w- w i e.a m_W M r-n y __ 4 m a E H T O S N P h I O D M F I A S G T (.- i t A T O F J T I a b G O N I . S g l e a
),'
m N R U I_ kk1 $: W t N N N i = h u , T K b. N 9 O E E A Y Z R L P N A I T E h . R E h k O S I C O I C R U T n &, , S A E E G L B A E W A N G dQ 4. h b f M L P I D I g 0 P
- a
< S a S 1 5 6 7 9 1 _ T , _
T. A t l . T lA D
)
A F A _
.( &N
//
D E F 0__ E E K M I A _ R A E
"? N I_
O T S U lQ i T l l C S E R E l l LI
#D
/ h t
_ 7 E B R A S U K "gSE - C_ I bl _ . E O C BU _ O R E 8 - _ i _- T E E 2E fe _ l N_ lam l C 1B V G e _78 . lg E I N - T T A S A W C A N D D N N O I w %cd o 9 1 E V I T C A R A E A D E T T A P U C b h 4 o - _ ($_sf IF i 3 h c r A O I D N D E l l C I S C O h 6* 0_ 0 _ M a y A R t i xPv ca
- b O T Wd, R
Y. T S R O 5 0 0 %_ _ a r 9 l _ 3 l i E S w,wN_ L l m9 i G l i e l S 1 i E i e P i l
$la l
T <A i l F S T e r)
*C - T O A W O T
R s- *r c_ d l M N R S U O E A O N S E 2 5 e S - prr M L R
/_ _o D
R[ A C Y . . C xMm8 J U N S A D A 2 % O . _5 E l i
/ i E_
6 _
' $s T Y ,
N Y - 6 N A T __4 - N / _ , mWM I T U - b E E S lA i O C - e _ __C A . E A R T S P O E w-n h r P t Q___ E P _
^o C U S M N O A W
W 5_ O l I E i N i ._ F m,n l G O t A D . _ S R D. I O F E V R T U O S I U L E T N I R T T A e ch nS W W k 0% %i R E l T O I F S I S N A P s L - W ?v M O dS A T T I F - L i _ G O
~.
t 1 N N I N N
. S N (m .
R U T __
~
N l P A. O Y N A C E Z I T I E R g I _h5 , 59 E R E S
^V S
I O. C U T a
- b. h $k $s A
E fj%/L l A L E _/ E i N P
& A l
W G h G P I D I S p ; ' S 7 0__ 1 8 ) E
i T L U T A D A F A
'A '
' D E E F D WN I N MA E
R O K A M E A S E 4 T S U Q H H C E R EOI N N V QI S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S E d C R U U O R E U C T E E H O C E E V I G N C YOB f m T S A W T C A A D D N O T wW c fc 4 7 8 9 N N
&m 1 E A A I
S m V I R D T A P nd -
%r 3 T A E U o
i C hiS %& C E T C N v h A O N H G C b [ t G u c r I D I O a i D E S M A R - g y R O T n, b , d:e T R b Y H G L S E B O H S P- e
'd h *l "K' / a r
I S li n b b l Y OC d H F O E T S A W I H T O 7 5 6 i A C u ec l u O
!T
&eQ i
P e s N d T f
?'
,/ l i T x N R l4 O M r
; C U O
M A A E L C N Y O S S E R D 9 6 h b b bk
?
(t
< C%
l a r r 0 o U A D 2 m ' ~ E N S A h l 2 C H T Y , l Y M I 5 5h.
% 5 6
N Y 4 N A T n A' n I N 'A c ' o 6 T U T t E A O D ' N' E S H C r A T P M kc C A E O , E R S P E E L i n P C N I D L O U O E G A R T I B O S I S M A N D E T f W 7 U/
/
M b kt # L d' b f a t h a # fA f e R S R O F am F E U O U N u M W i n r s E V I S L N I R P s
)k~
6 b bv C
\
kN H T O F I A /_ 0 hm y M A T S F
~
g _ O X. I G O t ~ /a,
- T I
N N N S
/ d' k
f
% 1 /
d N R N O N E We V dg U T A Y A kn~.&w h Z L N I l-& E R P A T E # L. C I R D. , e E S C U
,'j I O T .
! q( g t c k[ w S
( E L B E A N A, .h i-y k-LE f, G A I W G I g 0W I' P P D S T 3 4 6 7 8 9 1
]
T L U _ T A A F
)- ~
( D E E F D W I N M E R O T K A U Q M E H C E R A N E O 7 V }O
/ /\
/ _
S H S E M I f T H A T _ E R S N A B A U K P O E O R C E R U U C L T E V E G H C OC YO dl C . E T I T N A R d 7 u f 8 S C D h e 2m 9 A W A D N O $ s w h c r i 1 E V N A N A I T A g s d x, / c ' ' e cS 3 I T R A D E P U a c- d e^( c # C ElC ( h i f e c j M c C E T C r A N H C Mk t, a O G O M I D I D E S y A R R O T A ,T n 3 5 z c Q b T R C c (4 Y W p Y S O 0 C cs M 3 a L H G E B H S U 0, .) L 3 p g A ci aD e 9 d r e
?
I H E S I r \ g i L/ 3A & i P F T S H T
$m s .
.M yo g
%& nd, C %g d
- O A r 0 As n
$gp d eu
- T N
U W R A O T O S W b a h> t
-: c s
V e Ma I' t i Mw& dv i f i e e f % ) lS a a 1 S O E N E O n a 3 r r M A E H T L C U N Y N Y A S Y R D D A M N h /._ 5 t 1 4, st s o O0- 5a
~
OA S t 9g trk 1 o A P 6 o. 4 > 7y 0 9
- I 4
/
5L 1 6 4 C 5 o 6 N A T I E T A N U O be y i f N E C S A H T C b L r m l Q !
)I A
E k c m E O V P R S P E Y n C U S M 0 m /N R N O A W $/ I E G I B O N N K b h ' f O F D A D b ( h S L R S E c d R
. @l i
O F T U I U T N & n t y' .b E b A H E O L I a s I T V I F S I N A S R P b - o iD O
)
f}c O M O A T T M2 G N I I F O S
) 6 j
m [2 y O 5"' N R U N N N O N E W g b . T E A L Y N Z I l 4 y (" $W' E R P S I E A C O L B A T I C E W E R U T A N G (, , h t L h
% l'"
$ h S
A E L G
, I I 0 P D S 2 3 4 5 7 8 9 1
_/ T - L U _
.T A D
' , A F
! Y A -
( D E E K E M F I 4A N R O T S A U Q H T R E H C S E R E H N N O I T D
/ " / a V J 1 0
4 - E S " A E 3 B A U K eS 9 E O C "u U O R E A T E E EE fn d l
. C fH l
V G C B a E T S I T C N A D c r: d r o e y g le o p fn O e r A A N e d T na s W E V N A R D N A D I T A O n v e e
+
%O W W
J G t i m- [, b
'ei NJ i b
O G& w P m I T A E U A FJ s e s C E T C e TU n u i u A O I N D H G I C O E s G a f ? L n D E S C a A R R O T o n y L S Y L T S R O H h i s L g u J a r H E S O 8-ga %S M /c h G B d I H E S I O T S a s 4 i e
- g. P F
O T S A W H T O T- gca n e m - A4 M , y I 6 la
? d e
$ d
/
{ T T 8 &y C s R C R l n~ N S U O A E O N S E - w
~
pd% & O i 9 3 a r r M A L C U Y A R D D k 20% % , t A o I 0 0, 3 2
,c 2 0
n n C o
E H
T N
Y N
S Y
A 1 6
1 g /
gn5 6 4
N I
A T N
H C 6 _
r A
T U E A l
O C
A =
e s
E C
S A
A E
R i
T S
O P E N
c u W m V
S U
x-c u
x Ye 6, J A E
P C
N U
O S
I M
A \ s m
5, g P - H t R O
s 1
I E B N D
L G
A R
O S
D E m
T A D o A F A
! Y O D E E F D \
MN ' q;v 4 E K M I N A - R A E A
~
O T S U Q H T H C S E R E H N N E O I M I A T D G l ? c E R S N A E S B A U K P S C y E O C R U U g O R E U C S d > T E E H O C E S n E T V I T G N A C Y O B R L k u s l-e
) hh M -
7 8 S C D - D- s 9 A A N e 1 A l - W D O T e E V N A N A I T A S 0, C u e \ a Oa g 0 . 3 I R D P M A f h T A U A Y E d I~< c C A E N-T H C C ( I
- h j,w! $ %
r a O I D G I O Q h C M D E S . . ) y A R - s i b R O T e c e S R , G
+
T v d Y S O A V a L H E B H S c, 6c A A d r G A i e M o
%a I S i H E I N nJ c U P T H I F S T E 8 e O A j
p hc 6 lu 6 d T W O T h l F i
% )d
/d l} l O. N R A
S a U O M A E L C U O Ni Y A S E R D D I 3) J L f "s I' I b5 0
%r ns n
W Y 56 l M C r r o N H N S A 4' 4 ,Y d G 5 6 T N Y N A Y T
' ft Y b[ 4 6
I N t
/t 'v % /] ,
V t N E T A U O fg e f E S H
~
C
+V - <
W s P J' e C A n A E R T S P O E l a e-JA v I N 5 SS l&[i 8 )! L l'6 e E P C U S M l R / '( R N O E I B A N @ u A /p -
$ O I
F 71 F D L O F G A R T U S U O I D E T N
'r k
lc
~
le M a f a k
+ kg,- )
n 'd a '&R l S R E H E O L I
}{ v f
r fx, )y L T R V i a E O . I S N P M _ F I S A L L _ r - 8 O A T f . - d l / /,- T I F k()f G N O f p n u, a - N R I N N S N u- m h - EL' 0 U T 2 QU N O E 4 t A Y Z i i E _ 0 R _ k L N I 0 P A C T I E R l E ( G r E S O S C U
,N A _
h $" I O T t E _ L , A - L _ E B E N ' . P
& A W G G I I .
, 0 P D S 1 T( 4 5 l6 2- 8 9 1 ll! (' l l l l I
T L U
~ h-
/ T A A F D A
~ n:
OE Y , D E I E F D_A N / - K M N_M A Y U I R A E A V V O T S U Q H H C S E R E N N E O I M I Y ~ 1 0 T H A T D 4 E R S N A E 3 B O T A E E U O R E K C E H U C O PS R U U E h P $t ~S 9 A C V G C Y _C OB A ( tr ' E T I T N A
.f f
7 a t l - 4 o S C D 1! h p A W A D N O v=m ( f
&o P A t ,
s 0 b +s e i E V N. A N A I T A L r i Ar &' M' b O _
\
c D X I R D P 7 s T A u cy C A O I D A E N D E R E T H G I S U C C O & 0 S wQO gg /P i
/
e s s s 0 N & f R R i L
.da u
" M R O T $ e W#A
} .
T R x s s Y S O r a s o M _ M a L I E H S
- c. 6 f a o P T
?'Y , r s
I G B A X d I H E S I A [ A . o a s : ~ E i e F O T S A H T ' a h 3 7 7 L A k Jt 5"A /
^
P e O T W O T F o h( W :s & h % D a
' d 4
N R l S / : U A O_ S c
% *s $
1
$ M 6 Wrra O
M E L N E R
&>
- w g
\
Y
- 2,? -
o
$$ lM' A C Y D E
U N A S D A A so i {
- o. 8
/
s 7 '* C H T Y , R l
}
f N n J5 K 5 6 4 N Y - N A T s s u 6 I N - e s di dd /W". d , T U E S A l i O C { & u u { c_ (, b H V o E C A A T y s u L u E E R C N I S U O E G O P S I B O E M A N . E b o c b r g i e D 2 r u z Q A
$ 7 4
C pV i k P R O F h a L D L A R S D E A L E O M V D)J~ f S R 4
\
O F T U I U T N m nc z ( A W V T E E O & l l o u H L K w'a c I V S N R P A O { { T T M i f j j
\
T O I F I A b h h 6 e . i i M S O A T i T G N I F O & A u g 2 a a N I . S 8 i h hjm r t h R U N N A L N O Y N N E Z I S 4b f d k 1 J X nG o i
/
1 R T E P A T E I C $ A A E O C R m M M I I S S C U _4 1+) NL - js O T f L I E G L B A I E W A N G I {f 7 % $ , e
/
' h b/
z w /M P E
. P D S 1 2 3 4 5 6 y 8 A' a
- A'^ <
i' 1Illl
/
T g/ _g L U T A A F D A 3- _- s} _ ! Y y N 3 1 D E E F D M N E R O T K A U Q M E H C I N E A R E O N A N I p S H S E M I _ T H A T D E R S N A E _ B A U K P S E O C R U U O T E R E E U C H O C E p
'd S Ac d V G C YOB E
y n " . E N d hf w. '& 7 I 7 - T T A ' S C D R Ic f f " 8 9 - A A N y O 1
/ %
1 W D O s f-f r b Eu
~
N N I T E A A T m f va O 3 V A n S2 q/ aa I T R A D E P U b+T
& ds Y f N b "' h c
W ! t i C E T C r - O A N H G C O & O s L 8 M a _ c, I D I _ D E S y so Y A R - , b R O T Ns rg s
- T R Y S O O. 6 o. 4
- a L
H G I E B H S S I 5 ~3 sw, 5o i, d
*c S L L k cme 5 h
d i r e H F O E T S A I H T 7/ 4 j< P O 1 c, _ 0
% $ U )o u s d C
P e . w ,s d S W O
$ O 8 s
_ - 7 _
,U T T C 7 _ , N R S )" % c_ 1 z l- M l a
O M U A E L O N S E R 3 5} c s 1 i T M /
~
o 6 C b r r o A C Y D u a t 3 E U N A S D A ( p L u p b
/
M W 2 o 2 0 S 7 C _ H T Y ,
/
A 9 a 5 6 4 .- N Y 6 d./ ' N I A T T N U C b y m e e E e a, a E A O a e C n l' S H C S / C A T L A
!c m n Y E C
E R S U O P S E M b L Cg % h
?
i i i c,
, % S A a P
R N I O E I B A N 4,?.
/
t s 6 h l r ri 0 c O F D L G A R O S D E f~'j ( ( A
/ c c b 2 no D e Q t, S R
T r O T q a _ I l E a L, F U U N n V E V O L I R C ? r b w T H T Y b G d 74 i I S N P k H h O F I A S a M
- A T [ c O G
I F O L dc k ows. r T
, N N
I N N A N O Y
. S N
E Z l" k/ 9 l k
;[d 0
d
&x A
c L R U T E g) L N I E l/ k [ R g w 4 P A T E ,& l E
. C I R L n S k h S C U t o O T
/L O A j I E
L B A E W A N G Qb' M / , 6 _Nv0<f E L P G I I o P D S I 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 fllIllll!llll\ ll ll !1 L
T L U _ T A D A F A
! Y
\
D E F D M N
;V E E
R O T S K A U Q H b E H C S I N E A A N N R E O I E M I
! l v f.V f V /
T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S S,,- E O C R U U O T E R E E U C H OC E m, T o V G C YO B # E T I T N A C n o 7, A
/ 4
/ w n, 7 S C D V e 9 r U /zt 7, 8
A W E A N A D N A N O I T 7 d k hs Eu c W J W d E L f
?s 7
7 an / 9 1 bl g p 3 V A
" dd u- ,e h I
T C R A E D E P U C ac T(.lM T o h J J ys S h c T RoS h D r pn A N H C a O I D G I O 6 v M D E S i y A R - [c D R O T R w o L b T a
)
Y S O sG S a L H E H S v. Y g h O 0 m.4 biA l o
& Q d r _
G B 5 c r A e 4[ l h i e I H E S I 9 o - xo gl M ed T S S f i P F T S H T o r S w d@ mS w O uP n 0 ' vY a 5 e O A W O i C
.G Ea l
c )t
- 33 i0 r
fS m u d
"> 0 Qt T T L- H /
o H ' J.
\
N U R A O S W> E- l 3 f
\,
0 fey H D l a . {\ S k S G /'O '8 l) r O M E L N E R O L oh 4u7 l o c[A- H4 0 o r C r o y6 fk o I A C Y D E H U N A S D A MS 7sE 4 9L t R A4 D 2 S ' L W 3
)
4 C 5 6 T Y ,
) 4 N Y ,- I 6 N
I A T T N U b 0 6 % 4t C w R C 1j a n E E S A H O C
/
u F
/
o N w C A t A E T O \ M .d= r o y l
/
)7 m
e o r L j a E P R 7b l S P E ( C N U O S I F A f C , _
)
b b g
)
t y R O s I E B N E at f F G O e b
- d. $
i D A D < n t S L R S E j Q s _ C l R O F E T U O I U L T N I j 1 f p YO w f. p S ~ ( A a n M H T t n u T E H d V R h << O l - R J I F S I N A P f)- Y ) ][ , M
'W ykd S
s A T I F
),
e d a h< y L n Mh G O p _ o d N _ N I N N S N q w)0 3 I i R U T N A O Y E Z 2( , b,h }- . (
)
U E R u
)
L P N A C I T I E R 'U h u m 2 , Nl, % t
*7 Q h,g p
V L E S - k S C U ( ' rV I O T
,[d~ f -
h ?, A E A P/ 'v" lU L , r / U E B E N G A I W G I fl [.,_~ { J l 0 P P D S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
e,
, T L
U T A D A F .A f
/
Y O I D E E F DA N E K M I N M A # / V R O T S A U Q H E H C
~S E
A N R E O E M I N I / [ T H A T D E R S N A E e A U K B O E O R P C R U E U C S U E c d I T E E H O C E A t_ , V G C Y O B C O t - o n 4 k e E T S I T C N A D m O 4( t
& A%G 5 U l 7
8 9 A A N o tc M y S W 1 e e l W D O E V N A N A I T A [T rd S1 6
& CI C m n h rM c a S
[r 3 I T R A D E P U A o A hL 9 ucw
~
6 E Mn h c C A O E N T H G C C O P r g & o o se T C M M r a I D I - ) D E S % A R R O T 9?o f o S 3 D m m 9 b y Y T S R O S t .h cu 3 o mo o t t A hw q a L H G I E B H S S PW U
-Lda aO cN O'w o; pk 3 6
A q m nfc 3( y C tC Q h p T 3 d i r e H F E T S I H T s Hs o% e N$ c t 4 $ t G i T% F C $ ( c P e O T A W O T pi hbc eD N 67 w8 D r de 2 e h f l 3 dO
.O N U
R A O S S 0t Bb ud I s C s"'ou rco O co 1 e o r. e um 9 e l N l aS r O M E L N E R 4P n c r o A E H T C U N Y N Y A S Y D D A 3 1 A HA S$ D 3 t
% a qG Q6 4 tP s
t - Jk C 5 6 4
'N A T w n I I
e 6 I T N U o s f c a I l y o 7 E E S A H O C c
% d~
l v n C A A T u t" W'h 7 s E E R C N S U O O P S I E M A h & s e,. ht n V le l P M ROF I E G B O
'N -
CN J m' av' e D L A R S D E s m/ i M a p M h - p S R O T I T s A
\ t l A C o E F
E U O U L N I i lb l r O x F~I U I S H T - V I F S I N A R P L d W % l E'
]P
)
O M S O A T A T T G I F O 3 8[/ ~ M b 's i N N '- R S U I N N N O N E C Q ' / # 7 f k T E A Y Z v k " ~ , s R L N I \ - P A T E i w O S I C O L I C R U T A @ h w &
?
t
\
'7 a
u d E S A E L E G B A I E W N G I
; W /
/m 0 P _
P D S 1 2 3 4 \ 5 5 7 g 9 1
^
T - L U - T A D A F
.A/ y Y
O / 1 D E R E' K A E M E F D \ N I N M A A
/ " ,
O T S E U Q H T R H C S S E E M I N N R E O I H A T D N A E L l ' V _ B A U K P S , E O C R U U . O T E R E E U C H O C E 3Me d e V G C Y O B L f E T S A W I T C A N A D D N O wA O TO & Ak Of
%c " ^
( t e G i 0-7 8 9 1 E N A N A I T
%g N uw n s
e
^MNr'N 3
V A 7 I T C A O I R A E N D D E T H G I P U C C O a p~Aa f W U N w,'
- f. Y' 8 Mk 1
1 u N s-r u h M c r a D E S : y A R - ,
*' 4 b
- $ 4y,% [ Cdf R T O
T R 4 0 Y L S O H (Q e f ~ A a r, H G I E B S S t e e h f i
- u. W2 ' d e
d.
- i H E T
I H 'y 4. 9 w C v h. L PO T f F S e O A W O p&<y r 6 h0 d *//b ldb O T N R T S r r o0 T L 4W E U O M A E H A E L C U N 0_ N Y A S S E R D D A [7 7' 3M WC {
/
$ Bk n 7 Us 2 o4 2
a J, S6 s6 j6 [NEV [ i M0 C
/
F 1 C 5 6 a r r o T Y j 4 N I N A, Y T N l o f b > - 6 E S A T' A H T U O C ko Y 3 x < b c V d uA A 'u 3
,7 E
C A f 0 E E1 b C Nl}/ &o E O n R S P E G ( P C N U O S M A xu # V R _ I B C d- e O E N Nh MDM 4, fc I r F. vd y-G O 1 6 D A D f, F 1 S L O R T S I E T [f oD n e/ 'K w n e R E n R F U U. N ip. f, An H E V I F O S I I N A S I R P pBh " 9,. l g 2 la 2
/u D T O
M O A T s T G N I N I N F O S N w d@a k y,,h: s/ /t t p V Im d< i bU T N A O Y N E Z W h$. / l'
,Yr: ' %il q
lw d% E R O L P S A C I T I C E R U g, s
- t. h # k 4 fgL )
w E S A I O L , J A e ,d f fD f E L E 6 G B A E W N G I [/ h i cB ( 0 P 1 P 1
)
I S 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1
'F _
l I T L U T A D _ A F A
! Y D E E F D 1 N E K M I N M A R A E A O U H E N N T Q C R E O I S H S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E B A U O
K P S C R U U
" d. _
O T E E E V R E G N E U C H O C E C YOB r/ a w p ' t "v g k r/ I 7 T T A f 7s _ b f f 8 C uu S A W E C A N A D D N A N O I T d s - w e o u 44 T W *e%c t o n gC 4MG
,ou Y G tg wo, 9
1 3 V I T C R A E D E T H A P U C b M M r s s 2
$ W a S PS s
s gs t $ tug o c h c r A O I N D G I C O '
% t M
a D E S i o C y A R R O T o m d b Y T S R O O w a s d n l L a L H
'C I
H E B E H S S I l u s s u o N A i w W J. o d i P r e F T S H T w e s O en y e O A " u f p, u d W O u e ? [i T N U O R A E T O N S S E C d m w t a M 5( k h M C
/'
. S l
a r r M A L C Y R D l r 0 A O 3 f C o U A D t n O l 0 ( 4 . 3 E H T N Y S A 3 2 o t m t, 6 2 [ .
$ 5 6
4 N Y 6 N A T
,- C-I T
N U e a k( } 3 E E A O S a. n ( f li c, C S H C s u f) y A A E R C N T S U O O P S E M A M
\/
3 a A r c A- m e
/ll' -
ko e y. L E P R o~hL @ I G S I D E G A B O N D 41 P - C F d S S L O R T S I E T L e w'C 1 2% k k0 R E w u dwL F U U N H e t s E O L I 2 T V I S N R P P l R 73 A di i l e A h), O M F I A S S' . 0 y A T I F
/ e/ s ,
T
/f G
N O d '!, Iw N R A uL' I . S b w l' , _ b
b N N N T J
/g,j/T.
AL N O E E A Y Z M ' R n'7 "4 d< L N ] I N ck P A T E E C R I '1
/,2 S C U Iz S
I O T [r 1 ^ . A
/ lkd 3E
/
lY6 ( L , A , L E G P B A I D E W N G I S~ k. 1
]
3 l \ S 6 7 8 9
/0 1
P l fl j ll
~
T L U d T A D
/ A F .
A Y o D E E K E M F DA N I N M A Y R O T A U Q E H C E R A N N E O I l a" , (O S H S E M I e E T R S H A T D N A E v B A U K P S
'O E O R
C R U U E U C d w i
~
'f T E E H O C E
V G C YO B - Wn E I T N A i s e v, p 7 Ca T - r 8 S C D ? 9 .t W 6u Ml A A N m =. e n - 9 1 W D O i p e N N I is w r mL d
//
k pL E V A R A T A NlPo y u' lm y s iu 3 I T C A D E T P U n u Y K _ s h. t i u S dt
/
h c A O I N D E I H G C C O Fu4 c t v
=W S n' t uht fe M r
a D E S i e / A R w M Q y R Y O T S O T R mi\t o kO
?i
;g T
,,,C,49%
i Mt I b a r, L H G E B H S 7 e Cv$s n*II'm' p o Y
/ s - p;
&C n s g A
BW A p d I S r 5 r- , q s **r e ke y, H E i v r i6 I U , s s F O T S A H T.
- lp t
w3 su yO n l r o i u So03 nT P e W O M ' s b kb nc S h'h d o T N U O R A E T O N S S E Ga. O 9 S i u, [ e ' ni L o 7 I s s' w~?uma os h iW oO Ss A l a r r M A L C U Ys A R D D F l
/z' /
7 n mr cu una o [I 5 C o 3& 7 q E H T N Y S A 1 t c4 ll Sa J23 i 7% 1 5 6 4 N Y T R 6 N I A N E $s no / T A U 6 4c i P E E S H O C m 7 1 n 1 W D C A T i g p lJ 7 d W m o N A e
.M o E E O l h V i
e S U t P R C S U P S E M o Q t I C so N I O E G I B O A N B ( D [r i N' .. U w e a k t R O F D L A R S
. D E
g lbg ' d< J f ii S R O F T U I U T N #e h j s y mt Y I y O l s E H E O r Y ;~. ) T*A s L l ~ V I F S I N_ A I R P J [ C M S e lI e
'(
T O M S O
$w h A T ' T I F
/ f I
{h'[ gz '" N h/r (' G N I N N O S N h g? f u
; N N
R U N O E y A L P Y N A C Z I T E R Ah k7
! u& m &,
fd
,f q
E E S I C U fw c c h /4
' q S A
O I E O L B A E W T A N
- f. w 9,y "
b a f 6 M V& O W WJ
$ 7' 4
}S Y p E L
G P D I G I S I 2 3 4 5 v 7 8 9 0 1
T L ) U o T A p A F
! - Y O i s
=. D E E F DA b E K M I N M M O R
O T A U Q E C H E A R E N O U
/ i s
S H S E M I u T H A T L E R S N A B A U K P n O E O R C R U E U C M a T E V E G H O C YO C
% & r f y (S E I N Y V z I7 C
T N$ T A o S A C A D N t G y 8 9 0 *h f S W D e 1 O r L E V N A N A I T A Y'L m w# s '+ur^ & 3 I T R A D E P U P O a ' 0E )/ it. U 0 C A- t h C A O E N T H G C C O d L A ms r Oa Q$l,S Ac ' Z e
< M c
r a I D I hf n' D E S 5 f y A R - - 5 R O T R 2 41 W - wS b Y T S O 0 1
%1 6h 4D A eE W a a L
H G I E B H S S g 3 9 cc O ^s 4 0 'D d A c e n aS d r e
"- a& 'f c H
F E T S I H T g y g (A T* e4# L' W& d O ss nL i P e
,~T O
N U A W R A O T O S S g 5 gsv g y, O
~
N= &"% e-A
@g O jW Moh "kc o G f a- nO u rc 1c<.
1 Odl a O M A E L C N Y E R D g p 5o o s9 8W n
/ O
~
{S / o L Y9o o 2S 5 a_ r r o U A D o t " 6f 4 i 7r 'v / C E H T N Y N S Y A y g
'I 1
/
1 ~ f 4W 1
' 9G / 5 6
4 n N A T )A 6 _ I N 4 _ E T A U O % y u u V E S A H T C b A i l o W p C A E R C S U O P S E M h t] l. t
% G f
i
?
D I M</ )L sE W g E' k E P N I O E I B A N Cg
) A s .
S' =t ge R O D G A O D D s M E 2' 8M )L H s2 0 J eb yf ep mK U F S L R S E , s-y M &M nR n ggi R O T I T L m r f 0 AN OW JD '/9 p:/ E F E V U O U L N I R di
& w M
o N A eE K 4 7 yiM 7 s HN T I S N P M c e T N O F I A D O. k ' S O A G T I F O J %
?
/
t yWL T N M 7 N
//
f d t/ f R I N N S N I( C t f b{ G 2 U N O E 8_ /,& A f $' T E
/Wg A
A L P Y N A Z I T E { C c r h 3L 7- - R E S C I C R U ? W L Q/
/l f.
r S h
; A O T " z ,w ff I
L , A 7" E E B E N h 7 ' :e L 6 G A W G 7 P P I D I S
'\
I 2 8'
; ~
3 5 6 7 9 g)g
+
1' , T L U _ T A D A F A D E E F D W N
/ _
ly d' I N M A V E K M R A E A O U H E N N T Q C R E O I S H S E M I c E T R S H A T D N A E u B A U K P S r n E O C R U U hc. O R E U C T E V E G H O C E C YOB m - 7 E I N A [/ s 7 T S A T C A A D N lmmW u o WS (d t
~
S /
/
8 9 _ A"64 1 _ W D O E N N E A A I T A b m o% , 0e d mo 3 V I R D P si r z%
/
Or h T A E U u e ; b /a c - C E T H C A fkL/ l
. r A
O I N D G I C O
/
i m e/ 5l k M a D E S y - A R - b R Y O T S T R O b o #
' a
+
L H r H G E B S w me . l-c d e I H E S I d w -[$ i z T,s G i
*c i
P T H cu a F O S A W T O l t mw s rD g s
#' /n e d
e T R T O s a d w #h l G N U A O S S a W% p ' a r O M A E L C N Y E R D m sp fy kD. M oM qq t s #1 9 C r o E H T U N Y A S D A M@2 e yc N 0 E o 02/- 5 6 4 N Y 6 g 6 y N A T i c z N I T U a 2 - g E S A A H T O C - W 5X C 4 l f A E 5 du p E C A E E R C N I S U O E G O P S I B O E M A N v-mf w d - I D b l 0
~
' J y
r ec P R O F D A D i f S _ L R S E 5 Aa p R O T I T / $ E l
- s. 7 E F
E V I U O S U L N N I R P ^ Sl
/
4
/mu h& j 0 M a 7 b
[ H T O M F I A 7 t S O A T F
/ ~
' 0 M % T
'# /kw I . 3 G O .G N N % l> C R I
N N N O
. S N
E b
\ ,5
/ A W
/
l fy - N U T A Y Z R
)
L P N A C I T I E R /
\
Mglf :-
/O JJ f
E S S C U 0 \ 1 / a ( I E
& A O
L B E W T A N G 3yLf I s h k df f 7
'L E
P G ( P I D I S 1 2 ff 5 6 7 8 0 1
, L
a J T L U .~ _ T A D A F A f O D E E K E M F D iW~ I N t. N A R O U A E l l E A-N N R E O I
~ -
T Q C S l i S E M I T l A T D E B R A S U l K NA E FS r
~
b E O C Rli U u O T E R E E Uc i OcE s di$_L9 l V G C Y. O B . e E I N S T A T C A A D N a r
> c 7
8 N1 W E V N A R D N A D O I T A P Y' M ww$aMA
, d d k M
D3 Ml t , or" bf I i i T A E U Yf 1 e h_ 4n _ C E T C _ r A O N l i G C O ,_ W 5M a I D I D A E R S & o 4 1b, y k 3d R Y O T S T R 0 s w _ / s - 4 _ a L 1 l i G 1
'l E
5 1 E 1 S S s 4 s N i A'/ k_ 5 f i d Ad 5 f e i r
% WAtie l P l
T l V l
}
dde _ i F S T r O A a fu m M> h W O i J T T hfk o t l O- N R A O S E V 6 a m U S Rr r _ n % O N E M E. l R s 7 7 9 . o A C U Y A D D
$ i 9
s 4 WC E l i T N Y N S Y A
}s M _.
r e H 3 b _ Z J 6 5 4 N I A T T N U m y I p, 6 E A O i a " 0 E f C
)f& r so uM S l C
%_ A i
A T NEP E R S O P E p q s G U MR C N I U O E S I B M A N 6 L 6 i s w m A T S k O F D L G A R O S D E u 54 L_ fl l H o S R O T I T a u d h-(C. E w MMD o F U U N e l t f G i E O L I
- V I
F S I N A R P d E 1 I W ~T t - T(aMO T O S A G T I F O k . v (N ,.E N T N I N N A N O Y S N E Z h _ a upO hQ b a N R U T E R L N I kA A-ad &Yk tad P A T E _E
/u ri C I R 2 S O S I O L
C U T A A E. c E B A E W N G c T l P G I I 4_ 0 P D S 1 t 3 _. $ 5 s t a 9 1
T - L U T A D l .
/
A F A l Y D E E F DnS N E R K A M E I N A A U H N N d O E _ C R E O I T Q - S H S E M I E B T R A E S U O H K C A T D N A E P S R U U e t o R ]f N h O E U C T E E H O C E v v G V G C YOB i s h ts 9 A
. l 2
E I N O 4 a o ' h 7 T S A T C A A D N y07 i dV I L 6' t r 1 n/ 1 i t t A:. L f A 4 8 9 1 W D O A 1 4 $c c p+ s. r6 N N I R 97 w m~G 1. j en se , E V I T C A R A E A D E T T A P U C gME 9 T teO r S A %Y e r VJ sA Q) 4 S i u ,n o uDeR 1 lb nA e4 6 s e 3 h c r A O I D N D H G I C O p,
- b. nO uA h C r
]/cA Yl SJ r t
d- M a y E S A R R O T
- , 3 o
h e u b T R eov e- 0 , t g , Y S O Dy o b k / yl q,2- a L H G I H E B E H S S I d S 0 9 3 Q. e u4 D J
- h. 4 6
% 7 uqv 2c i k S
kc x O s4 o3 2 M 9 3 d i P r e F O T S A H T 2
/
d 4 1cc 6 ]% cW 7 f. I ;A y h c o~', R u9f/ + d e c A o Al yf n W O Ec >dO ra
/ .
T N U R A T O S S K N, GA <
't s c,c 4 g c
Y, ew a U- l e Er 0
/h 1
9o a[06s XN o 5 O E N E - e r R r Dot sO
/
M L js L a Mgi s 5 A _ A C Y D 7 l-4 C U A D T 1 N ks zS f )u yh oI 3.6 5A ll N _ E N S A z$ S a ' 5 H - 6 T Y ,
- 4 N Y _
6 A T Zj xq i _ N t eo& _ I N o i , E W T U - E T q.iH 4 E A O / C
}g H C t S
A T f , y A f 1 ye E O Y 7 E / - P R g 7 C N I S U O E G P S I B O E M A N ( D f y y ,M W e<- a n n 5 4
\
l n-h {e g R O F D L A R T S D E T I L
, A (r 6 I
C m RE S O I
, d 4 F
E V U O U L N I R 2
)W t
h b t i l f e C S a *Y t~L M J7 m H T O I F S I N A P St N C 0 f O M S O r c. u 1
,h' + 4, T T 0 lC A
G N I F O lf/ A g OL w x 9" i n 'c u v 0 0 1 Pf.J
)'
cd j N R S
)a l1 U I
fa
/br J'(
h'g m o N N A N O Y N E Z g g$ t [/ h/ t - l E A g E
,_ T R
S L P N A C I T I C E R U 7 h, o 5
/ t n_ h M
1 P r E A E y n A E S T J fu L
/n t O
gI E
~
I NFa Ge $g r :. b O L , A .b n % L [ l E B E N
& A W G && 'h P G I I V 0 . P D S 1 2 3 5 6 7 8 9 1 4
l I l ilI l lt l lI t
T L _ U T A D A A k / F Y f l F DA N
/ J g D E E E
R O K A U M E H I N E A M N N A y '
'V f $
T Q C R E OI S H S E M I T H A T D E R S N A E B A U K P S c T O E O R C R U U E U C v i c A' W Q g de T E E H O C E / y - V G C Y OB t ( /r a E T I T N A v,I T t (w b/ w 7 8 S C D . A t N4 s , 9 A W LV A N A D N A N O I T A JY
/
( F v r r YA d u
& W W
j g h'g W M 1 3 I R D P gg bh h _ l a fp T A E U f c C E T C f- h d4$ eeN r _ A N H C h a - O G O I / M
,i I D I D
A E R S . n & b y md R O T T R M S A 'e a
'E eg ,
n Y L H S E O H S 6 9j
' h
/ m
'S u 4, h y J d a
r G I B S d
/ )0 r 9 &n + # wC i e
H E P T I H db fT
/e ^
nA F O T S A W T O T i / 5 o / cv wt
/ ,
tc ,, z o Cr 7 c Sb W h, AC s d l e N U O R A E O N S S E fU i b Q d+$r 9, /w.o f
^ e a
r r O
}h h l M L R o Urr l o A
E C U N Y A S D D A /
/
ha 1 E 2
/ fA 'd
$ %b C 5
H 6 T Y , 4 N Y L 6 N A T I I T N U A n O E B 5 E A O M / N) N E C S H C 6 N A A EA t A T h L E E O S A 2 .P R C S U P S E M 7 e E b(4 uf_R Ed{ N I O E I B A N m n
}l '
H O F _ G O D h a o O L y N D L O A R T S I E T f
/
w h I d l R ! f L
! y S
$ R E
f m$ O t U U N l H H F E V O L I R [
< b N V ti M f M t T I
F S I N A S P F
' b M O
A T dy n p y T G N I F O p d 0 N U {c m M } hW e ' 4 N R I N N N O S N E 6 d & n )' g U T E A Y Z @ t i g v p R ac L N P A I T E p 'c t 41
& E S
C O I C R U T ) %u L t p h'L h l L R S A
%~W f I E E
L B E A N [U V j I L P
& A W G 0
G I I
'y P D S
- 3 4 5 6 9 1
_ e
,, ll
.f T
T L U A D krh ^
)
_ o p U'd? A F A s I Y i O D E E K E M F DA N I N M A % b O R A E A O T S U Q H H C S E N R E O E M I N I - vWf y v / i s u E T R A S H A T N A D E Ch V L - B U K P S n O T E E O R E C R U E U C H O C U E S ( a V G C YOB - f~/ s E I N . ) 7 T T A ~- e S A C A D N ** m e W J i 8 9 e 9 c-W N D N O I r. OM s m s S k/
/e 1 nre 1 W/a E A A T ' e c u rH V
I T C A O R A E N D E T H G A P U C C O u aM e nS s f r lL U f 1 x [*M, e G.< v c i a u T s I/ u/c su n9 3 h c r a I D D I s M - A E R S g' . y . R O T y . w b E T R t o e Y L S O H g'
- I F
m yy. a c
/
b t
.n t a H E S I A
a u
^W e - r G
I H B E T S I H M,db C D 4 c hn
' c 2-3r 23 e
o y
-l 1
7 2 e/ &/'
/
6 t d r u b' O d i P F S T j C{ T m
,e so iG f s e O A u u e n7' u3 W O rc 5
f o "% s nr i f. cP.@ 2ES 3 d ov L% S z % 7 T R T m3r o , a Uu i l _ O N U A O_ S S MC C s, P~u *o c w i x OL a O M A E L C U N Y A E R D D 7 lt D 3 t o
't e c 7 t s
. o f3 qW
'O
@/' 2 r, 0
8 -
+
C r r o -- E H N S A 12% a g x u 3 r e
'2 ~ zS o
ag x j '3 1 3 2 0 MS 5 T Y , 6 N Y 4 N A T 6 I N dr w v s _ T , U ml i A O m m R E E S H O C H J r Ws e r e n e e C A A T I. l ,p c k 4 E R S O P E U r g w S ,D R l E P l o A C U i W S N N O I M A C F e .B Ms Ne ! B
& R O
I E G B O N N h 7r h
'y o J F D
L A R S D E S I T A o a ln T' U y S R O T I T f e C D/ n. M y E I F U U N r u k ? - l R e N h E O o H V L I R 4 R % l t T _ k I S N P 0 o oM ( h f s O M F I A S N ( E N A T o O k :e k T I F - 2 n ^ d g G O l
~ A 8 l _
N l 1 t N _ b I S j R W N N N I
=
'0)A' U Y [
T N O E
'L Q /)'
,,c~ E A
L Y N Z I 'u J 0 ht h R 6 P A T E i
/ f l i _
C R b E . S I C U f M ( b, a & MT A i S _ O I O T h A E E G L B A I E W A N G I l L gl ,"
$ D h -
? 0 6; L
P _ D P S L 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 h
T
- L ,
U _ T A D A F A
/ d Y
D E E F D A N _ K M I N MA . I P A E A l O T U Q H C E R E N N OI ' , - S H S E M I T 'H A T D Y' E B R A E S U O K N C R A E P S U U )] r e b O R E U C t w kM T E E H O C E V t E T V I T G N A C Y OB h bf a W r c a 7 lb 8 S A C A D N s h 2 e s 9 1 W D O / s s N N I O E d L _ n E V A A T A
/ w # S 0 1
r ~3 kS hS I T C R A E D E T P U C
~ $
0 w+M
)
h c
% Y o r .
A O N H G C O t M D l M a I D I f D E S l A R R O T h / d o-b y T R
% 0. ,
Y L H S E O H S
)
k m
%g d k@'
h h
$ a r
5 [$ c-f- d G B e I H E T S I H hC 7 s w f s { d k.l ! i P
)
F O T S A W T O T N a
][ K
- M3 f{
69 h~ f [ n ef kj z. z ' Y d l e N U R A O S S e " 1 y 3 t a r O M E L N E R s 1
~
3 [. r o 7 A
& a C Y D C
"?
U A D 1 $' 6 8 A f $' N E N S A \ , 5 H , 6 T Y , 4 N N A Y T [ & m 6 _ su i I N l v , T U r ], E E A O O ) 'v o - C S H C M /j A A T A b y - f E E O 6 T v k P R C S U P S E M E N ae E
,W R h a b1~
? l-N O I A t ( O I E B N b n F G O h' c A D A D f k
R f i h S L O F T U S I U E T N mqdi A
\
/
0n
/
j)r.o W R E H E O c V I F S I L N A I R P kc r A ( e l h f T O M S O A G T I F & ~ c g /
'/
f, n y T N I N N O S N l d m /(J lt f W m t
#J" M R
F U
/
t n T N A O Y E Z u k E R L N P A I T E G &._
- h. l$ -
bvd R E C I O* S S C U j . /h- h A O I O T 7 E E L B E A N 4 H 4
. p- n L
" P
& A W fj G -
G I P I D S 1 4 , 4 5 6 7 8 9
. 0 1
l l ! T , L _ _ _ - U _ T ]A3 D - A l- / A j
., u D E' E F D' W MN E
il O S K A U Q l i M E l l C S I N A -..A E < N N R E O I E M I - 5 / / f T l l AT D . f R S NA E . l i A' E U K C RUl i PS
. g _
O R E UC g T E E V I OFl E G i OC E C YOD Ig 7g
~
T T A e S A C A' N3' ^w+ % N A D
'N ~
i
$ e AwY l
W O
- e _
N N d g, [_ I . T - E A Ae' > V I C T R A E D Ef;C T P U C A i Ac v r J n 7_. . A N S_ e_ l _ S_ g i O I D G!O I n D E S g _ [ig A R - T m4 R O Y T S R O
,g, -
L l E l I I + W> c 1 c WY , i G t 4 f-l i Sy' WY 5 E g, %
" F i
l I T T il l _ t F S Tg , _ , J l b ,,, 7 WYu& ^g"V l
).
O T N W R A O T o S t 9 L D t y, p P h1 U A S h
- gC" l i
]-
l O M E N R R-ki C y L c L A C OgE Y D o"o
- AC E
l i U N A S D A \ .g5 ?p _ O $., T N Y N A T Y _ g h _ R I E S T l A N C U Ob e"r [ f W Auno f V d d, W_E . f$ A i T _ L. E b_ gy, p C _C R S Oa AM P E Gd oe% C U S N I O E I B N 4 gif- G O n . D G A OgE D A w L O R T S T Mg,, g W n s m e L /_ I g F E U O U Ld R N I Q. m l t Q% n V I F S I N A S +s P
^j-
- Wf WhG i - L et A T G
I O KbM A d Fd N I . S - N N A L P N O Y N A N E Z I g E W. mh i d t {} Q d w Q f_ E J S C I R u j d e O N' v *$p W_s E [AL b E I J y L , A ,es a E 6 l A l W E N G 9 l' f z f G P I D [j C@) ! I S
!l L 2 3 h
ll s 7 _. 8_ e 0 1
T L _ U _ _ T A D A F A ,_ O: D E E K E M F I D4WN Ni A. YMv v A E A
'v R
O U k l E N N T Q C R E O I S l i S E M I T I I A TD _ E R S NA E _ B A U K P S E O C RU U 9 . O T E T S E V L T C R E G N A D E UU l l OCE C Y6B 3* c .Y^ m = aas 7 A W A N D N N O I
&i$a y '{ ,
w_A"?$jM E A A T 3 V A , I R D P
~
T C A E E T U C C r gr (g hacr A N t i O G O _ - M I D I D A R E R O T S T R
,e a -
xEe e o b y as%s t , w Y S O cu a f t s s L l r l E i S f c d i G B 0 t e L S j b i l l E T I l i A S s ac a s P F S o a. e wcut n. a T-O A t>
- d O T N
U W R A O T O S S 7 I Ns o l a r S sc pahmn w O E N E r M L R o A E l l C U N Y A S D D A s.s i s A 2 a s 1 5 6 C T Y , 4 N Y - s ._. 6 N I E A T A T N U O Ac y-t1 s a E C C 9@aw A l S i E hahf w a. A T O E O T e 4 P C N R S U O P S I E M A S A
,g}}