ML20214R070
| ML20214R070 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 09/22/1986 |
| From: | Roisman A Citizens Association for Sound Energy, TRIAL LAWYERS FOR PUBLIC JUSTICE, P.C. |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#386-855 OL, NUDOCS 8609290061 | |
| Download: ML20214R070 (6) | |
Text
-
s
.g.
? S S' 000BEREIED B6FOR8 Th8 UNIT 80 STAT 8S NUCLEAR R8GULATORY COMMISSION 8dB6SE8E225PP3G5 setore the Atomic Satety and Licensing-Boarc' 0F6f7JE UR E N #"'
UNEhf[
in ene Matter of
)
).
T8XAS OTILIT18S GEd8 RATING COMPANY,
)
Okt. Nos. 30-443-OL et al.
)
50-446-OL
)
(Comancne Peak Steam 81ectric
)
Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
CASE MOTION FOR DISCOVBRY OF THE STAFF (CPRT)
It is CASS's view that wnen the Board ordered discovery to commence for a limited perloc witn respect to the CPRT it intenaea tnat sucn alscovery, it relevant to tne adequacy of tne CPRT, was proper against tne Statt, particularly witn regard to SS6K-13, the tacts and cases tor tne conclusions contained therein, and any contrary tacts or cases.
Tnus tne Boara nas determined that tne requirements ot 32.720th1(2)(ii) nave Deen met with respect to interrogatories accressing these issues, nowever, out ot - an aoundance of caution and to avoio unnecessary litigation, CAss suomits the following argument in support or tnis request tor interrogatories ana in support of tne request tor cepositions or tne persons named in tne attacned notices of deposition.
In SSER 13,-tne Start articulates its opinion or the acequacy or tne CPRT.
Since tnat is tne suoject of the soon to ce tilea notions tor Summary Disposition, it is ooviously r
~
relevant to Know tne cases tor tne Statt conclusions on these 8609290061 860922 PDR ADOCK 05000445 0
PDR WO3
1 s
matters ano to nave the Start explain its position in light of any contrary facts in its possession.
Tne questions are uniquely answeraole only by the Staff.
Similarly the depositions seen the sworn testimony or tne Statt persons. who nave the personal knowleoge upon which tne-SSER 13 conclusions are based, wno are tne principal authors or immediate supervisors of those responsiole tor SSEa 14, and/or wno nave personal knowledge of tne facts related to Statt 11ndings wnicn were a principal impetus for the CPRT.
Tne Notices of Deposition fully explain tne unique intormation tnat each aeponent possesses that requires their attendance and testimony.
Since tnis Board must decide wnetner the CPRT is adequate and since the Staf f is a party with claimed expertise on this issue and an opinion based on tnat expertise, it is essential to a proper aecision tnat the Board know, througn this discovery, the facts and oasis for and any facts contrary to tne SSER 13 tindings.
Our reading of 332.744 and 2.790 is tnat a document request is to De answered as if it were a Freedom or Information Act (F01A) request ana tnat even accuments that are FOIA exempt are produceaole following a Statt assertion of exemption and a Board ruling.
FvIA responses are uue in 10 cays.
CASE will accept document procuction from tne Statt on the same scheaule as its answers to interrogatories.
For tne foregoing reasons, CASE contends tnat the attached discovery ot tne Statt is appropriate and snould oe allowed.
4' '
Respectfully submitted, e
&%# ) Len ANTHONY Z/Rfis BILLIE P/ GARDE Trial Lawyers for Public Justice 2000 P Street, NW, f611 i
Washington, D.C.
20036 (202) 463-8600 1
Counsel for CASE Dated:
Septemoer 22, 1986 s'
l
s.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ~
00CMETED USNRC NUCLBAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSINhb dERd5 P2 :25 8
0FFICE OF IEa t Ap r
/
In the Matter ot
)
00CMETINU.s SE evicr'
)
SRANC6f TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING J
COMPAND, et al.
)
Docket Nos. 50-445-OL
)
and 50-446-OL (Comancne Pean Steam diectric
)
Station, Unitswl ano 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE By my signature oelow, I hereby certity that true and correct copies of CASS's CPRT DISCOVERY - STAFF, PROPOSED SUBPOENAE, AND NOTICES OF DEPOSITION nave oeen sent to the persons listea oelow this 22nd day of Septemoer 1986 by:
Express mail wnere indicated oy *; dand-delivery where indicated by **;
and First Class dail unless otherwise indicated.
Administrative Judge Peter B. 81ocn U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission wasnington, D.C.
20s35 Dr. Kennetn A. McCollom 1107 west Knapp Stillwater, Oklahoma 74075 Dr. Walter H. Joraan ddl W. Outer Drive oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 8112aceth d. Jonnson Oak Ridge National Lacoratory P.O. Box X, Building 3500 Oak Ridge, TN 37830
- - _ _, - - - ~ _ ___-_.
- - _ _ -,,, -.., ~ -,, -,.,... -.
)
s, ~
s Ellen Ginsberg, Esq.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission wasnington, D.C.
205s5 Rooert A. Wooldridge, Esquire Worsnam, Forsythe, Sampels k wooldridge 2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 32uo Dallas, Texas 75201 9.
Nicholas Reynolds, 8 squire Bishop, Liberman, Cook, Purcell & Reynglds 1200 17 th S treet,'N.W.
Wasnington, D.C.
20030-Geary S. Mizuno, Esquire Office of Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Docketing & Service Section Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission wasnington, D.C.
20555 Renea Hicks, Esquire Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Division Supreme Court duilding Austin, Texas 78711 Mrs. Juanita Ellis President, CASE 142o S.
Polk callas, Texas 75224 Mr.
W.G.
Counsil Bxecutive Vice Presicent Texas Utilities Generating Co.
Skyway Tower, 25tn Floor 400 N.
Olive Street Dailas, Texas 75201 Mr. Roy P.
Lessy, Jr.
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius 1600 M Street, N.W.
wasnington, D.C.
2uuJ6
'l
.L~
t 9
Mr. Tnomas G. Dignan, Jr.
' Ropes & Gray 226 Franklin Street Boston,.Massacnusetts 02110 k
ANTHONYG Q ROISMAN
~
O x
l I