ML20214A550

Partially Deleted Memo Re Recommendation for Diablo Canyon Board Notification Concerning 831019 Allegations

ML20214A550
Person / Time
Site:	Diablo Canyon
Issue date:	05/14/1987
From:	Bishop T NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V)
To:	Eisenhut D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML20214A391	List: ML20214A388 ML20214A458 ML20214A550
References
FOIA-84-21 NUDOCS 8705190495
Download: ML20214A550 (3)

Text

_ , .. -

'dfr*k) fA, g 8 .

M GION V 1450 MAOIA Lt.evt, EUlf[ 210 WALNUT cht(K cctif o;NIA Mb86 ooco'*

Docket No. 50-275 50-323 l

MEMORANDUM TOR: D.

G.. . Eisenbut, Director, Division of Licensing, Nur.: lear Reactor Regulation 1 1

FROM:

T. W. . Msbop, Chief, Reactor Projects Branch No. 2 S E CT.

ECO).TiMENDATION FOR DIABLO CANYON BOARD NOTIFICAT EGAERDING ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED OCTOBER 19, 1983 The purpose were requestedof by thisMr.

me-emorandum is to forward the subject allefations ubich L. Chandler on October 20,1983 (enclosure). We have not been able to cont,..ct the alleger and consequently cannot be sure ubetber or not that person der:1res anonymity. We therefore recommend that the enelnsure be treated ses CONFIDENTIAL and presented to the appropriate h7C Boards "in camera".

Sis is consistent with recent guidance from the EDO and should safeguard the .;dentity of the alleger.

Subject to the restra.ints described above, the Region V staff recommends that this appeal and information boards.be br-ought to the attention of the Diablo Canyon licensing l  %

$.L a T. W. Bishop, Chief, Reactor

. Projects Branch No. 2

Enclosure:

Copy of allegations re ceived cetober 19, 1983*

allegation No. RV-83-A-0046 cc w/o enclosure:

J. B. Martin, RV D. F. Kirsch, RV L. W. Chandler, OELD G. W. Knighton, XRR N. Schierling, NRR P. Morrill, RV I

l 870519049S 870514 PDR FOIA OARDE84-21 PDR ..

fu p i p

i i. '

Problem Statement Allegation #: 20 ATS No.: RV-83-A-0018 .

BN: N/A This document lists each allegation or concern brought to the attention of NRC personnel. The purpose of this statement sheet is to assure that all points raised by the alleger are covered. l l

If the problem statement is not clear as to who, what, where, l when, or why regarding the issue, the commentary section will amplify the statement. The commentary section will also be used if there is apparent conflicting information or if there is n2 or ,

very little original information available which describes the  !

concern (s). (This can occur if, f or ex ampl e , a line concern was I received in an interview).

Eroblem Statements A11ecation # Verbatum Statement or Reference 20 This concern together with those described in allegations 21, and 22 were presented to(Mike Malmrosi former senior resident inspector at Trojan Nuclear Power Plant. The concerns were expressed by a former Pacific Gas and Electric, Co. employee. The identity of this i ndi v i du al is not known to the reviewer.

These concerns appear to have made more as a casual comment and were not intended as a formal allegation. They can be viewed to be similar to statements made by an employee at an " exit interview" (an interview performed when an individual ceases employment wi th a company).

'. These concerns were made dfMike Malmrosfsane time before May 19, 1983. almros[first conveyed these comments to the reviewer by telepho , and after the urging of the reviewer almroffsubmittedtheattached Allegati Data Form.

The specific concern was that the Health Physics staf f at Di ablo Canyon Nucl ear Power Information in this record was deleted individual menti ecifically as not

a accordance with the frettem Infctmallon qualified are /

i Act, excm ' ns 9 C 4 9 He (She) stated that

f0lA- 4. Ib l .,~~- on y had experience at Diablo Canyon and therefort was not ANSI qualified.

The other Individual only had experience at 1 Ch N O b-d k

Y Humbolt and Diablo Canyon. However he (she) 4elt that [r.-1--

very well qualified.

'. " - ' ;. ., _ _ ;_ ~ ~, ' "~ ~ "

were i

l

)

i l

l sC t l$ f . $=^

.s !f! .)

Technical Reviewer Signature 2

_- . - - . . -- - - . . .