ML20214A275

Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-73,consisting of 820730 Employee Warning Record.Related Info Encl,Including Read & Reply Messages & Rework Repts

ML20214A275
Person / Time
Site:	Braidwood
Issue date:	07/29/1986
From:	COMSTOCK ENGINEERING, INC.
To:
References
OL-I-ROREM-073, OL-I-ROREM-73, NUDOCS 8705190363
Download: ML20214A275 (31)

Text

.

5 0 - Y S 6 d 5 7 - C ( -

.h 7/2. f /g s

. :,. m.

4

[_ _

j/c 2c y g f;y __,3 li.shibit 20 '.0.45 A

/

L K. COMSTOCK ENGINEERING COMPANY, INC.

'87 AFR 22 P7 :05 EMPLOYEE WARNING RECORD hlCiiL ' -

Employee's Name2cAda

/97,*mb Section $.

Date at Warn 1ng Jui 30 198)

~

/

./

Nature of Warning Substandard Work Conduct C Tardiness Carelessness h Disobedience Absence 1st Warning y 2nd Warning C Witness to Warning

[

h.h. bwwh Supervisor's Signature d, C

/

8s Date % $ 21 Employee's Signature

[

Date 7 d t'

Remarks:&i m ~75 YA{s M J;~ S-yp R/ v /4h1l% /E3*pr76

~

f;t)0Rk Ah mim x>JM A7' Gnn Ni) o# 6 7,4 A.' C l A >>< e d

$N-e*77r/

• u S ax-a m A.

du 7lZ9 $3--

fM 4e/dd 33

/

/

l

/

Original - Personnel File Copies: Employee Supervisor fIrrisMA*M

'uman_im' W ^'995

.m_ - _ s o

(,#

M I}I*NI aJ 8705190363 860729 PDR ADOCK 05000456 G

PDR

M PeLa 088 >

1. M/8,# g g

neuen pesa oss.-==

Alphe Swness F i--.;, PA 15424 naAoaaeeLv nsoncan som no. ssps r

e)kREPLYE

t. x. cousTocx a cowun, me.

~m

~

r m p L,5c e s s/fl_lha!1

~

l'.9 s4-koro %me,d m

.u.,c7 L

.__..._........_._J j

d fo'bo (09 ll 29 6+ I rgu.s4ek O come IN ca.,rly 81l2:30. I w%s h\\&. hkI cs\\d d werK

%se, kwc; Mwse e vMde.s sMe piity,yd p dew.

c h es b te m 1 9 ecst\\y d 6:00 $w ec.mp it NN 5yce.

I.St.e \\ ihis is tw Sd r o.d the d.essiou was nyah 6 c seL weew ver%"%.pstb 4 t.c, 9f0NED C&19*

SQ ~,A;;)

h M p.- $tt.O A

• 7A>J- -ev-w h Y,a J an W.e

fY wfasW gA -

~

s n&.

n xe SIGNED --

0 Aft --

A e

MtCENER: WMlit Mt9LY, DETACH STUB. MEEP PINK COPY, RETURN WMITE COPY 10 SENDEn.

EXHIST B s

j F

! 4 6 & CORANY NC; 1

f 4

nq,p;-64.,%<mn W m y.g %SW?.ig g p

- q,r..

p. -

. xx,.,.., sm.. ht

:_

,qgy...

i

~ %g;gy.52;py-d. 9-h m-

/ /- M - % -

yo.

i[h$ /

- d6/Au I d-G k wne Z

-. A E M E d i

-e

? --

4

.e.w.:-2.

• , Lw.nx.. acwmm

  tE.:r:

1 kag;r-dD.. = -

'v

~4

=.. e

a. * -

a.

e 1

T

..' -;.xg.... -

+:Ct....' -...3;,::?

,1z ;w.i'3.-.%.qic '.. m --

o r.

IO Y L.-

$96 nD' k hJ Ct N W e.~d \\1 cvk & : 6T (?.43 N 0Al Da ylO o

y--

t ON & betiAF,.

g b

O[

(L M [V D, U, s*i l in

(; (-

.7 Old Du. R M T Gvt, r>. 'tciv.c k. nk' T'MdOr ahon Ah 6

f ~

kr..

. : s x L.m. w 1 " -

L" -aE- ^-

3. _'

a e

. =

.y

~

t.

' ~

B o,e 9

.pn

+. $ e t ^ .

? 1 - 5.

'$ h n'

!! A E.'

-s

? '..

• l g-

)

I

,.=

h "_ A.

.1 b.

db'

/I4 ha - '-

a b s- -

i y..-.-,

7 vr.

A.ls ~~ '

.A. N e ' e., Y ~.- ?

- - n v " 5 ',

,m.

'fC MA30 4'L p;u

_- f '<.,,.,. J. L _i A n i./As;b;a Qv. 3 ', h, -x -N A' 2..

l l

h

=I*

M'"'

SIGNE DATE

.....x A

M.. ~."'c'"*.n""n"L'. %*'2..c%fW...'w*".". "M. *7z4'!?"".5. "c".k. c%.. %'.'"*'"=EW 9

l 4. :....._.. _.

l l

l l

l l

t pu e.

,p.'r g

,5 4

• s.

e e

a n,-,,,.,.----,.---

EXHIBT C F

L K. COMSTOCK & COMPANY, INC.

2*

!g""u' n"a'"sN w

R REPLY m.

A M

r D;,

I O./

Mu3

__/Mo-M

)

1 yo:

4..,.S e x s c Od^d-h L

i 0

r

~

y46L--

(

l kY

/$ A 'O

• $b.

/AU kA $N 5

oof &elhe.ogp WUL PGu;6 r) f kmpk_ WrFf Wg.qur l

?&

S m/

o.-- rna.

W a)/ J S,see/dhe

.A w M8ir

>AAid dee -

howes.

jWM~-Q SsGNtv_

s yr

.y

/

stoNgo

/

/!'

OAtt

/

L J

RECEIVER: WMITE REPLY, DETACM STUE, KEEP PtNK COPY, RETURN WNITE COPY TO SENDER.

C00151C>C' b

• e

l l

EXHIBT D PACE 1 of 3 l

F L K. COMSTOCK & COMPANY, INC.

• e.

luna m,

READ REPLY l 7

~

=

i l

'aso empty bM g

lNECESSARY r

7 cAu _ M. M._ O TO.

SUBJECT l

l IT

[E 06W GC c2

<PWk f dN WE

, h if'.{....

. f&

-f

... h*

-.... -... -.W N

$/

'S fcv4 ~T58.[834o..

...M-

-..!8"

(

6

• = ~ -

J-4. s.

.., g,.. i

.t.

2 -

C D

A#

., p.y

..y.

.., 7y:

x4.%.f q

nw f

_..p. s,_

(.

..= O -

b*'

• 0

t

?.

L

~*.

?,

.w,..

~

j 1

SiONED DATE i

I

%L

, \\

e a

SENDEM: DETACH AND FILE TNIS COPY FOR FOLLOW UP.

i JA i

l

.......,.._--...,,c-r- - - -. -

- - -. - - -. - - - -. ~ - - - - - -

',' p exhibt d page 2 of 3

.=

,nn REWORK REPORT Srs:owooo 4.3.24

'g3 { ! " SN 4k.p

%v N.,

-s COSTCODE b - b b ~ Oh NUMBER /Ob3 AREA A (A v' S LO (~-

ELEVATION 4OI hHIS REWORK IS:

C Safety Related Non Safety THIS REWORK COVERS DRAWING l '333 l REV. Ab REVISED BY:

C Design Change Due to Interference Re install to Original Design

@ Other NOUel I NUM.C.T Df"iECTO R REWORK EFFECTS:

@. EQUIPMENT JUNCTION BOX HANGER anz::- m

_e r==

0 ce^(Tr eier"o-co"ouiT < Footage i

o CABLE PAN samu ~

h CABLE NO. I d D 0 44 C SPECIALITEMS Az--

@ TERMINATION C OAD INVOLVEMENT (Recuest No.

8r'0 2 3 g= :.;a

'~:-M8 DESCRIPTION OF WORK k ELO OPd

~ X Y - U h i O ?_

@ROMhl1 D ET ER M 1

~ CABLE IVDOM W

E iw 4h8

• w ummyamm ISSUED BY

/ % /) IA DATE 1 'l P 4 APPROVED BY:

M8 I

DATE M-N Eb

- QUALITY CONTROL A#ROVAL/COMTS d baoke3 ca 9 w of R m.-Ir.

E,. o. t 8' I o (. 3 io famismJ Fo r m 3 6 6. r..d. 1 F. e m n O ivn o"e ;. w s z-r-ty c Wf ffg An CaAeho. %.0-#st' l

APPROVED DATE Quality Control ITEM REMOVED BY DATE F OR EM And ITEM RE lNSTALLED BY DATE

' ORE"*N (form attached)

C IF CEA PTL REINSPECTION COMPLETE ON COMMENTS:

REWORK CLOSED DATE COMSTOCK ENGINEERING REWORK REVIEWED DATE Quaiety Controi

( 10 A $l n r r 2 = c:-

o a: t:

=. a.m:

.=

cai.. can as. cin e e n,., N a a LG3 IFO PROCEDURE 223 03/29/84

EXHIBT D PAGE 3 of 3 REWORK REPORT Braia..coe 4.3.2:

9 9.st e.tva. \\N C, \\ GCi

\\O6i COST CODE 93 - O G - C 1 NUMBER AREA Au

\\s-23/L ELEVATION 9 '- D "

'THIS REWORK IS:

Safety Related

] Non. Safety

, THIS REWORK COVERS DRAWING O-33(al REV.

?)M REVISED BY:

C Design Change Due to Interference. Re. Install to Original Design y

@ Other IDra.Meus hmAwA-7 m.a Ewst L a

REWORK EFFECTS:

EQUIPMENT JUNCTION BOX HANGER CEA (Traveler No

)

h CONDUlT(Footage

\\~C

)

CABLE PAN

] CABLE NO.

SPECIAL ITEMS W:muMI TERMINATION C OAD INVOLVEMENT (Recuest No.

1 DESCRIPTION OF WORK Me Th ACE. 9C* h mewAv T' m i c G. O WW tu SM C,*

we, h be u.h g

C e t e.l % w e w r.e m u t e h y % w e e 7 E m c e s_

C s (c. %w 4=a h,, m e-.

@ T '-9" M h 8 2 '- d S h p..

A*-c" *- lio 2.a + - + r.v m.ze % c ~ ce m,_ m, m. v a m s s

A.od Ds_ m e, t Au._

( N e, N J 4 t m m er. STA.ww%h. Pe.unntW. 9 A. Ghb W

,co a.o eo%9%m cc.c,s

(. no eteem h, _ a.C., A.S - h \\

a M

Abw h e -"3:.c e n u_

ov t Gintus A4 As Mr_stn u w r

Asu r,e. ws Awtc. r Co AG a.GA.

Loimsusw.

ISSUED 8Y h A\\c.u-._

DATE

\\*2. BA q

COMSTOCK ENGINEER

.mac e APPROVED BY:

h DATE

\\9. W)

QUALITY CONTROL APPROVAL /COMM TS No+hiaa en C le, a4 % 2s 1 ;.w e.

.M h e.

Q.C.

va. If fo r COA 4,2 G1/ w E*i fV CMS.%

APPROVED DATE Ouaiety Controi C ITEM REMOVED BY DATE FOREMAN D iTEu as insTAuso av o^Te FOREMAN (form attached)

] IF CEA.PTL REINSPECTION COMPLETE ON COMMENTS:

REWORK CLOSED DATE COMSTOCK ENGINEERING REWORK REVIEWED DATE Quality Contros CGO'.,~51'.1 PREPARED APPROV ED REVISED TITLE ORIG. DATE REY.DATE FORM NBR.

LGS IFO PROCEDURE 223 03/29/84

EXHIBT E 9

r PRIORin L K. COMSTOCK & COMPANY, INC.

Q3 vsvan, w I"".

nwan oxuw r

.-r u.x.

i=

L I lucis'Eiv t

r

-1 ro,}lARh_5tes&

/O.-I-9 4 am._

susact_ A/C.8._fEEZACEB1EA/ /'

l L

I 7Xes w as ~m m

y L\\)CE* I495 wAs GEHEf.Aftd_b62_9uCL CLbitx

/ A70 t_7,_

^ ^ ^

OI8,Is'S__ (q.sE} w E.4C_a S.Th_LIs.cl_ (fulls b&la.!.TH.o 01~ Q. C.__ ylyN~ dt.s,

__ (.%

ku\\A Ta eg_uk I,cs7:J 5'eId. R' P1pe.r;h MAOc 2 geplace I

i MMT T4 6s oa 14 is #o/J T4d,.Soktigv y BW en Aic eE F24cr_rr^r

__74.6s LisYch -TM&_dssc4 P[7,s Soc. NNce As cAszs.:s 72eme d u M Df JT-G C-WRAT h _ W E _ d o_ _ ? f 2 f/l

_f l

/5 SIGNED

~ "rW',

/

/

h h

C.Ok OY A,)0 4.,_

6v. fx._ s m.- a d da a rl1m.7b

.h AsME '

4 a'e.. ERfce S~ahn j%- # c:en3r er &k / % 70"Sdb, siongo h

1. ~1~

DATE L

MECEIVER: WMITE ME*LY,0ETACH STUB KEEP MNK COPY, METUMN WHITE COPY TO SENDER.

I 1

C001i;1~. 2 e

e

i EXHIBT F 4

i r

M'e 'EPLY L. K. COMSTOCK & CNANY. !NC.

unestr

+

READ w'R m,a L

no mr m

s..re. % (

.)

neceee m n

. ~,,... - ~, e... w t:.. Y. K,_g y _ j.x_. -.,;, g..

e

c. ;;;p..7.... -. ~. e.: -

~. '.

y-p

.. --}

... h, y s-fd,:y s.7 /-E(/

~

om

• f t

h h ;. 1..

~

hsW MAA 2 **-

.~

., in we-r 4--* ? 7-g.

;K.;t.. ".

[WW-l

(

-Mb

['

m: e f Y'

NMk =Y-e

>S l A nl' X 4 an>p Ke chi l

( A. f.i_, I c e ', A __ s A. s-

,h.a idh he l

t

... - j

.n u Ah.s

1. y

,> - '- : J. eiw e t ::L+.

- 6 j: ; ^

~

-/

a-j.

1 w-

~

4 a. -/ s' * = >

' -d 1

-y

~-"

'*W

~

__e TRmrpgEJAga.'re.M. _.E:r% *2 I

.. ci.p.Tc. 3.9th_out.eisiiS?;cM@Jr.tW46 J

s s

I seasco oars i

3

. mg wth$ps.nasqiusaxx4&w.answ.'ca;

.h"'.w e x, usey:.mpww,,.. -

w ':w;v:.sc. *.w,.'rnucsuss: warra nun.r curacn stue, xu19 nux corr nurunn wners corr to sanoun.f r.

.;-. {r-

"".v ~ m.'. ~ ~

~

I t

i l

1 I

i 1

i

.I l

l 1

0001 T.3 i

'rt kWwn A - Ht,G*Y m"M O v 4 4wr.ut:

';.... s s, - 44..% reare l

l l

EXHIBT C r

6 i

sanota roto om >

mtruta PcLo om -

Alpha Business Forms. Delmont, PA 15626

.i v ~

.?

=ra r

momn____

L K. COMSTOCK & COMPANY, INC.

7,3

. C' O unaan c

i*d) REPLK i n=,1 READ

' ~'

.L

e.t,=

r

. - Q"=

Ia - f.- C'l p

4:+i

. QA.-

.u.aerWc# Add ~h-e.WIi

.m

,a.

L

......._.__J U

m.-..... -

i.

"5." ~'

W L.6

q. S dh. p._tk c.u..- 2 3....

p_ ~ l Af.o '? e,__-?..W uce 2.vw -41.J4 g. $wg t-eb r! &'..hlur MV_.2 44L m_. el-J ~ 8 -:-9-8.V 4

0..b. s

_ h I b ~ tv u - u. k b j.a a A

&...N C $

b_ Y Y+- l

$.-. A tb w

_W W1 &Y

-U 'd W f

9

'.m.___

8' "_'o_

.Ahh ve s

' " # ',&,,e-2 & 6,.sg" /../ ;r- ;-{Q pf.w=

sfk,D s$ihAu' N' $ r'e., - M '- k + # G/SO WJ g f,, A j ',_ W r,- E n -a-ac. V40- t' A 'O y,W,/ca-e p.'.: O 2~d~ '&.NEa 25

~ lS2-

'J'/-Y

. e..

p, C 00'01i4 SIGNED CAtt

\\

MECE!YER: wMITE ME9LY, DETACH STUS, KEEP PINK CO9Y, RETUMN WHITE C09Y TO SENDEI

EXHIST H

'l F

PRI'ORITY L K. COMSTOCK & COMPANY, INC.

. V unatur

' READ REPLY

.~.

t Pos.iSta Same M L

N CE Y

Aa )

m c-m,

,s-xy wcveu DATE - / [ -- [. ~h

)

TO:

SUBJECT -

C#,

I al

!.'/ $. A [YA. hp63.h k

cs c..- Za~ sac.da.c csscy_Sas_.say 4

/k)$r h

k A f_.-.-

h/

S s.-

-rxLssA su a so zzW aw G%%w Asn. G m

~ V

.c:ch d : z o A k-r.

l Y f$4e00bbhe$WO$E$$ Nh0YEih,X t-S Ea. W & % Z M W 4 CC: n 9 M s b 2 M h % t w 1 4 W s r

= arm'Ti 7WMm758!293pT7;4 melt d.a.:2 47

- EC

& A s h _. 4.rc m/.ns,e Af>1 /

A O P

})]

f d>D.

/*3, wn:-

k4 d' Y

s J <*

A

/

A, SS/ lA

/

2p r/

.rY/ reno s-ar' w w se & <-,

SloNto ' e C J J

N DATE

[" ~ -

/.,2-g -g [

.,a

.......g :.,.:p

.;...

• 9, SENDER: DETACH AND FILE TNIS COPY FOR FOLLOW UP.

e e

e g

e$

e S,

e,

_ p p

p p

l i

i

_.___ _......._ b.

mmo%

O I

y l'

?

}

M V

N*

L i

k f

S.

k

[

M 4 ()

.x g

0

~

d 1

9.

s g'

k bI 3

m e

d

$kdJ

[t

}

a a

t w

. O y'

j WN u

$ ($

sb' 4

4*

, ah4 g

h4 y

C' l

S' q-y I

3 N

n f @, }

w b

I 4} 3 A d (e, ts 4 g

4 i

s i

t a

\\

5 N

2 W l

tt

% n{

.{

M

'k w

sa $

3 GG

'n it 4

-M o

g

_)

c5 7 c t

e t

R-

'4

---

.,m...

, _, my,,

OO 5

READ REPLY' l URGENT

~

p eem.a

-N ieRT L

IISCSSSMtY n

y.dy

[) ad O

./

-Q.._c nm s

o,,a,

L l

W u.',,i 's.w-A

$hhh Y

//).'T dio f Vs Os /. S., 0 A t_2

,2cpa,?,-w s1Ab s. 8,:sb, wNN.,

,, l $ j '-

qn,1 72 & **

D O

>*% \\

Ys A

So i na P[

e

\\

$ld:s de AS,) i c

A/

D r%, r>

,.';2 K,c e DE

>s,,3] d &

1o n ' 2N < & S 5~ <c. /.t 1

a a.,,,'d,&< % &'&,.i w,,;# p.,

u 9

-iv51' k a,,km w,.,w,, mg c w/

- n-z -

n 7x-ma un -n ay,-

.1

/

f.,

r

/

/

/

/

/

!/

e 1

C 0 0,,.. q...; * <

t mm._my:

r.

2

@I-VO

>untant j

g READ REPLY

lMM muses

%AMly_

I e

r

. A 28 _u )' '

//

I

/

'4 e

g.

nAtr 5,

o 1,,,.

w, -zw.s.. >

L J

y

~ G)

JJ

,1 - A.C ^

• sd g S W / M.'4/d** b },o Q.._

<- f.'

s rk ",,24 A / s d :.

,,js- _ :, WS x, o 2. -

s,.

Jh hk

.A 8

)

y g

sk DW

_D>A A

at e

if

.~

r%)

ns-OJ

,&f l>.,m]N $2

%: X _

~~

.n.iM Ofif12,W

.s f. 92 W $

A_ d Mhf/jh Y

/*[,o _,

S80NED C-C A7 MUEFd

~

E--d f^!&. L" iz' ?f,

'i:

J.^ a'

% ~.. i

_ f,/.

0.,, m,....

m, p,.

1 I

~

2; :

SaGNEO L_

A

'?

L

.f MTE - I JA~,

\\

4

___ - :)

RECE!YER: WRITE REPLY, DETACM STUS, KEEP MNC C09Y, RETURN WNffE COPY TO SENDER.

t C00151'6

r

-- 6O yew 4 c-we

' ~

READ REPLY l l unaswr POceseLa P'

4.j

.M

'-(

4.

teceseARY g

'W s.

v.

.,. - Q,#... -

p

.,c.

.. '* ' }

f;'. f * ' '

4 s.

7,

g_g ges p.,...

1

.NQ%.s&M '

1. 2&D%E4%TM !btf2y dGAM?Mki%_

n. y v 4 pp y.v. m.. n. w. g w g,L.~

g s

Y 4

,.,.{ry c%hv{Q 1 {-- '

'---- - *%1-~Jw4 % ?.

,' f '.* b,4(-4m:'j.s.J 1, } pal &W. ~.g ~ Q ',

-s

≫g-;;

' D,:8W ~ 4VW

)

g-1

_y

.~

,,, ?.m..,

p,,k-% ';,' m.f gy,,,.

l T'

u...e..,

.r.4..

y^.m

\\

-n o~~

n#m,. f ~ f. l u -w 433pfdi,, y g -

c. ". a ;

.&, pg.

r v-J.

- ; q.

g t _.

.s,.

' ^

Ly, l

yy

? A,Q+

' ;,e.

e.

".. 3., >,,, e sjp,4y,,m

t

.U.

7/ ' ",

.x g.

e

+-

~

k

-Y. f[r..- f; r$ T.,'av.>. b. '.,_ "N,,#

• ?

~ yr..

g,. _

...9._

lw.

-;_ _y

,z.

+.

- me

,' '. 'l.h

. I $'l ;

k b '. l

• • <1

Y,,

.. ~Y-

u s -

x.

v.

?r

,,k,

['.

[.r4 J

• hR*. & ".'.' ' 3'.~.

_') ' '

l

{' _ ' -,._ '~..',;

'^

'A*

- 5 2-f

~

-v I

m. ru w;T

.w.w.

a

.. ?

n

? W-I f

f ',- S 5.*

E 3-es-s

1. ~y.. -.. ' ogs..

g..,.,.

_ fh -

. (>' d.. ', ' [M4

~' ',.5bg.' '

I,**

" d'."_,_'~~a

_.--r.,.'

.IV

~ M fp

\\

__ l

~

l'

%,V,f v:r',

• .e f

Sloboto DAT7.

.J MECEIVER: WRITE REPLY, DETACH STUE, KEEP MNK C09Y, RETURN wMITE COPY TO SEkOER.

1 1

j i

o -

Q,s o a a k * <--

\\@

REWORK IEPORT B raiowei a 4.3.24 b~OA NUMBER / O [o 3 COST CODE AREA A04/ SLOS ELEVATION 4CI hMIS REWORK IS:

C Safety Related Non Safety THIS REWORK COVERS DR AWING i *M31 REv. A L REVISED BY:

Design Change Due to Interference Re install to Original Design

@ Other S R,o <Cr4 L MDLt.c.T De'isc. Tot REWORK EFFECTS:

@ EQUIPMENT JUN. TION BOX C HANGER e

O CEA (Traveler No.

)

CONDUlT (Footage

)

CABLE PAN gg

@ CABLE NO I d D 0 M SPECI AL ITEMS

@ TERMINATION OAD INVOLVEMENT (Request No.

)

or..

3

=Laisus DESCRIPTION OF WORK NEWDRT 1 X Y - U B l D ~2_

(BRDRW)1 DCTERM CABLE l \\fD 089 C5 JEl iw Thfm!l "N

ISSUED BY i% /3 IA DATE 12 6-f54 APPROVED BY:

M8 N

/#- I-~ 2b DATE 1

OUALITY CONTROL A ROVAL/COMN TS

$ Nackd co P %

of Ra.

w.-L E<part # 10(. 3 to Suu&m3 Fo r m 36 Orat.d. 1 F. c m 37

f. c ivoo"s i. w iz-r-ty c 6 f ff,, y fe Coa &h40. % A2&ff APPROVED DATE Quauty Contros ITEM REMOVED BY DATE FOREMAN ITEM RE INSTALLED BY DATE FOREMAN (form attached)

IF CEA PTL REINSPECTION COMPLETE ON COMMENTS:

REWORK CLOSED DATE COMSTOCK ENGINEERING REWORK REVIEWED DATE Quanty Controi

{QO *,, $1b' PREPARED APPROVED REvtSED TITLE ORIG. DATE REV.DATE FORM NBR.

LGS IFD PROCEDURE 223 03/29/84 l

l

l I

'ORfGENA;L aswoax asaoar s,.le-e 4.S.24 ES7 c.fM, *. \\NC, \\GQ

\\OG\\

l COST CODE

'"\\3 - Co G - C~2.

NUMBER AREA Am

\\s - 2s / _

E LEVATION k

-D" l

'THIS REWORK IS:

S.fety Related

] Non-Safety THIS REWORK COVERS DR AWING O-3362-REV.

3M REVISED BY:

Design Change O oo taiat r< r ac R ia>2iita oris'a io >isa Other h'eseus 2.e'5hNa E N 't L REWORK EFFECTS:

EQUIPMENT JUNCTION BOX HANGER CEA (Traveler No.

)

CONDUlT (Footage

\\E' )

CABLE PAN O CABLE NO.

SPECI AL ITEMS TERMINATION OAD INVOLVEMENT (Request No.

I

)

DESCRIPTION OF WORK M e. F L A C E.

90* 'WmewAv E t reg CD Me m\\A E b t. C W g

Cet \\9,.l h s, Naem zeme.e h-how uc, h ~ B m u.'N We. meet G ro %w asa n, 2,,ac.s @ 2'-9" Mhs-T-c" % h p.. A'-e t he -

r c %, w.v % w_ % w - m,m.

~~s M e W e_ w s T A u _ ( Ne, MjetnMao, STAwtzsh. Pe.ctty 9 A. Ge.tb box ec % 9wewt Cc.G\\

(. Ne e ex;e m % tr e o..c.

A.s_t ve e 1

Abd hs.:rt ~'I.o s m u_

oe t c i u n.o A a A.s M t.it w,_ w A%.\\- Z te ws A.CVE.c r COAG 2.GA.

63W2EuSAW.

p N ISSUED BY bh hke-DATE V2 - E- %

M COMSTOCK ENGINEER APPROVED BY:

M h

DATE

\\9-3-B'l CECO PCD QUALITY CONTROL APPROVAL / COMMENTS No+hia*

On (I le, ca + % ?s L; n in a O '-

O. C - v a s I t' hr C O A G 2 G L$

-Mme. I t. 'V!Y (Y..,,x. h

_ ?kY k

^ l

/

1 APPROVED DATE Quality Control ITEM REMOVED BY DATE FOREMAN O ireu Re i"STAaeo av o^Te FOREMAN (form attached)

IF CEA.PTL REINSPECTION COMPLETE ON COMMENTS:

REWORK CLOSED DATE COMSTOCK ENGINEERING REWORK REVIEWED DATE Quauty Control COO::;152 PREPARED APPROVED REVISED TITLE ORIG. D ATE R EV. D ATE FORM N8R.

LGS IFD PROCEDURE 223 03/29/84

f%

3 a

a t u

IM 2

9 4

g 3

N8 c

t yg k

1 m

2 'a i

d i

@g I h)

)fE g

o k

M

(

lt 7

f i

( 4' 3i 3 g

ej e

< M [f g d 3-d j)g, $j sEs 34 h f k

0 Nh '4k i

=

sr 4

_.O d

i "N

.l N

i i

5E k ph8

s d

3

_+

x 1:

? ::

{S H

J 37

u L

i9 Ol H1 N

3 E

N 5

k i

j I

^

GdO.15152 l

)

[0 ! $rV 0' BOG S Y Om /'

N Z

G w

N sem a mym

-4 W

Aua L~

asp..

pu m

ep d - m ya f " p ~k, D a & -

W P

' 'Ar PM.

"v T1s w

k4 GA~4.,

wsn dw..a zL ofS r tu@.5 c~ M 6 A

TAe& /N

-xpx-wya w L a} SA w4 zh L (9.ar) D M & f y A aL Jy2 &

.y k A y du & Q o1 a p p p.

e Jnl J of p ad y b A ~ & n su-s D a

&A A6 D

a~' M r GEA. y& claA R

~ns

,n y

c 4 w7eh 4 y

,t.

rwrs a au w &

L~

eJL/ - 4 fe A p1 n-g l

3/S/N cw21sa

o N8 m' y & T & N h

M

~

tA w

AA.

C

- z% m at &

A p y w 1;/1 L -

w p & A ~j

~

e p m 6 4L d.4 6 9-Aww nn n x.

anup un fe w &

st

.M wAsw uA>~

C M 4 d'cm~1bb ne h

.a -

.~a a %

M.

f a

A<lE~J W, udal Add o.f<

4, A2 Ap te p

.s p.

p es.d W&

A z;r 1 Sm Nb a ~d A W & g, na BA

• /3/h 000151Eri

PRcr itp3 To :

r,

f=.

b E U A d HATE.' o3-oS'-SV FRotti:

3~ P.

A'/l SUBJtcY: rAlc/DEArr of o3-oa~8'/.

i OA.) /71A A C H o7, /78f' A CodF/6uRA77&O //14tr/AIG-to/4 NELb PEA A b/AEC7?LT F20#7 Yod 4SELF AAO L. SEESE. THE M437M.)G 4.)ns ScHEDdcch vb BE JE' u FAew

+'.*eu 7/r/ 76 Y30 P.#7 tdry TNc Zaredr re ce VEK 77/E AJCd Asvi,ssad '?& PAccEDvtE +f 3../AL. THE silEE7 16 B s' Ad Ar

+'.'oE ?.r7. hue 70 7#E 4/JLa9t LM7E mat 2iVAl.S AMb

/A G

cwfr/Atoch UAJT/<-

'/ *o?S A /r?,

THE prenWo Br&MA) Bf cavntidd 7)e.ccEbveE Y,3. /2., TNE conNCES Zir/PLEir/CA/7s:b, RNb YME/R EFFEC 7' uPeA) ceNFIGORAY/c4 rA) spec 7/uJ.

TWF /71A/Al CHAAME.r4 77/E heocEDlME 4)As 7,rE Rbb/r/M of rNG cJct.h/A.)G.

IN5?At L*97/oA.) REccAh AAlb LOPS cbAfr79/Altb THEME -rA). 7p/3 tu?S covCREb uNT/L. 'l:/7 P./77 t M EREBP -[

AS/rE2 27 'ffEAC 4<XAE AA)Y QtJESrio^.)5.

HPAoxtir1Rrce Y Half of THosr IA) 877EA/b9AJcE BEGAd 7M4k/ Ale 7b cad C A A)o'rdfk ASWr ~rMS' AJEk) PRocEbtMQ TNE UPCon/AfG LMEA-CA.)b, \\fACM77es.)

)

Pt.4As Aub orACR Sden 7DP/cs. CA% r^1stYaoe, ALYHecxW, bib Ash 1

fbA DE @S Tb BE C4MA/F/Ed AAb ht4.27 ta)OM )9FFEcr H/,5 raspccr/od, wais.c z u>ns exPtA/2/A.)d-TH/S 2 /7?MA74 PA.oceEDCD To LEAD THE /?rEE77A/C.

[ Bre>9str AuMAe of TNc t&EA) Sosnczde Aske inE saExt HE u.ws cevas. z RErura 7a rycrAsprem rsAr x pib Abr KAJoQ Bur YNAY snnyBE /VE sJMS 60/A)& ~ro TME BA7H& Zr u.A6 C0015165

PA&r.2 er3 a

rbo apre 7b Ask me. iristrix.) fog #r ynh ni,erADV Pnssch Anawh THE ceRAlta uwrAJ.I &cner Aubeer of s'is MPA)mser. % rned RETURA/E) Yb /7W ae/ sis)Ac 2>/sctssied ed 7NE ts)PG, AF7[A r

/

WAs rat.oacH r Asweh svexpi s.w ra ser7zehoc)D AG Ac.nis) d Cnti-Q for RA)Y QUEsrionJs ae Pe.skres ox)r of rxe rasPre7aes ResPcA2eb wirs A Flo&E.er cox)ccAAksicr AA p? csx>2ccricA). s.ye PRoccEDc2 To rss.BescA-BORAG 12> ru.vS7Auf7E' YMC blSCREPAACY Mb 7-Mc Gaeu? DisceAsseh r#E PAbairst nab VARious souvricas F8R.

A Fcd /7)/Ajurg.5. AfrfR-LJC #A2> f/AjisHEb X REcift4ED 7Wr?Y CA2urX

.rs) 7M~ WEE /: 1'1//s SAsnr.TsISPEC7bA #RD A GUE3YN 645 YvBE srEEc. siEEs 30.2 PAbcEEbEb ro hee 2> ASRL mrir7eed fad ZY edAs AA.) ExecacA>7~ auf.sr/oD 1"#pr evcePo4E Coat,b bcAJEnr FAdd.

tur biscdssmb YM/s 707/c JOR. A l'Ek) M/NV72C5 AAW THn/.r Alcrierb

.tr uns W.2.3 ??/ry.

AAlb eMur) 7ME MEE77Ald-To A eso3E.

m. ktAcHko ANb mysOF PAccfEbEb UPS7M/A.S LdWAC t.d6' AAA) AcRoss

/7/l. AIRL7/Al /rl/wd6 Ala/AO wir/ His cedr oN. I ZAfoen1rb Hun FHA 7" r* D/2 A.k:7 APP)lEc/nTE A/3 LEnv/Al& r#r /7/ei!c7ss/6

/

BEs%2r.2:r iJns CVe2 RAJD 7Nnr HC n7iss6.50irrc w;O' Goc.h d?us,s nos.s By boidG.- so. /hA. inAkris/ svDDEA)& }ccMMC VEL 1' kFENst VE ANb REPurb YHAT TNr precr/Als i.JRs ALor" 0F Buu. MA.D 7ND~NE~ &s+.Vr Geis.16 rc wAsrs m.s rme sirnas-rsxouse 1'r; -t REPuch T s A r M F << A s 7a <. h To BE nr 7WF MernAJS MAb Tfxr r sxRrer#ss? 7'o~ ser zT 7"o 37~:s ecose. he rses/ Bec4/tre VEA Y znAre nAR) 7cs.> /rir ^77/xr HE D/DA)'r HAME 70 3i7 7Ak5eE AAO 4/s7EA) TD PCO)VE 70A'r AADyAlb.

I r#Es) Brens nAJ&AP AAlb Ask9 Apr TNr atesr/ ode BAeuwr UP.rsJ 7;%c /77Ec7/s/+ AA>D aoesriodEd NM fpA yhtr eeserer-AD5 wets.

00015156

.m-

.,,_,.,.v n.n-,,,

PA6 f ? CF 3 AT TH/5 #E~ Menme V6*LP 4002), ABus/vf Ar/h EUDE ANb Tes2 /7/E TNMr Z sJM s 4J's.dd,

THAT N6 6LOEs7~/ oaf 5 OJEA?E~ AskEb 99).@ THAr Att 4.)E~ 3lb kJAS xib AA6UAD. ' AY 77//S Po/A)Y /77. h2Ac#h'o.ZU'rW AAb ToLb O)A. /EMAT/Al TNM7~ #r AJAS 4JAtA.)6 kJAtCi?rDr' A/ car TVAN'Eb Tb RM1 AM.b SAth, r.oss) 'T HAVE~ 70 Td k E T M /3 /I M b J Ton.m ED 0 0 7~~

o f 7WE" ??Aonf.

.Z~ THD) TV2x/cb TD E AlcoJ^d AAh Totb H/M

'7~HRY ZF Z u)MS$'T $sk H A AlrE Gu y.r'b k)A./TE A/R M UP Fe%<

745s)3cAbisJAT/oM, AY s]H/cM /112. BAadd AGAfEb. Z YhtS~s/ BrcAA) To caw? mysEzF be cad. A fcd irtsirreuTs sn7tx I & ins.r~&vAceb THRY ir7A. /CAA7?Al a. ins zA.I l SEESO OFF/cr ccs7Ac4/Al/MG ADeus MY.setF A AJh YHf n7trr/.4; ses.b. I THed rus. Neb To orn. DRausJ AAlb Tach Him THar.r HA.b A%D FA) ouch Aub roar r uxarc3 Hiri u)4iTTED-Oh FoK JA) s u D e x.hi e n rie d. /77A. B A e w A.) 7ach as TMsr NE Dibrl'r Denstr re R4h Trnr He u> ova 2> sea-- ABour-Danuaisf6 04 Tor PAPERuJeak od meAJb/9 Y n?OG <2/AJG -

mt. /rtscsxo RiJb siy.sezF u)exe rssa) cxus2 zA>ro.ws:.

.dEEsE's OFF/c E FCK 00/ VDES/cd cf (J/Mr 700K R.Mcr. 4)e FMcaig7tRE))

nyt, ent77A) nr 7pc poon ajwo coar7s)mb TD B6^ o&doxtous, I

DE6xD 76 AA&ur Mex Bar enuckT mvS622= MAJh JUSr~ LEP7-H/n? S179db/46;- 7/6;Q.E". 17~ u.)A s 7 M~AJ 7kn7 Yod BreA/nE dirJARe=~

of aJHnT* Hsf?M7.)ch MA)b REaufsm tr rd p)As77s/s, 03-dS-ff C00Y

a Cooce rtm eag fi cdiN3 g/tp by 3. h i. 00 3 4 84

\\

O GThe. obsekexc. as lu, ald f pios ccow.tsoinoe opioS 09.

4 Wwus,hotcL40 concedede ou wkd ums Soib.

@ Cochd e5 whd was 64 by ~5. Hil w%s f lih wa.

e He. wo4 apre,pred O k. nat. wroup asswnybust We hoJs S lot as toco werk relded, remcks O %k<. J. Hi'i osul E4here wcc<. *"y commeds, we commcok wuc bime<L %* wwt. utk rddeL. A+ %d Ife kd Ac nedg ws ove.c a.uL i9ste.a1 6 ce.muoin3 + ca. cry;me, co new wock ceidef couvusdiots I wah edues omL teviewe1 Acynudare, @a.td)

% d h mcdioj wLs oM.

F 4 He ode. k speuwid;ws.+ Bs wzR waaM. be aLk.L io +iw k ?.

He also sa.iL%f ccE w< dica insgudkNoLTb$v?k he cerMeL 3

in w ldig -lo do w cws:3unkien inspwtioc>.

G0015163

r unatur L. K. COMSTOCK & CCa#N4Y, M.

g9 READ R E P L YF,IPoseseLE

' soo mayLi-

}teeceseARY l

L l

f 1 MLE.2...

\\

......___.g.

,a. y...M p:w&

El i%d,..-lw-b

~~

L. ErasA;;

i

?

,w.

k.

s' A !..sl; -4y7tk 0,f u.? j _

l:. 3 4

-/

-)

~

-/,

,, 9, A. n s.~ o L

a.

Dk

=..c,d,4 ;;

l p

Dr~A:-

kd*

Ylu CY '- /G f). A"E) #

/

l-A,

,c. n

/

/6s-S-.~..do

,v 6, l ', 4 7,4' l

i s-g

-,f 4....--

f

?. J's' ? ~ _ $,, z /> Y <*_. af. 7{;.

k$t gjN.s..,

,,1Y,.' ?

ss

i.,. R

.? -_:

f&a r Y~ J/ _v:

/ &

J I.o ' /* A 4 ?9 h4l.'

d a-> \\

cd 4 64a 4

mm M

N

• • • h

( d~. o.,

.5/

t 0 iss'im A

~

~'

1. 1. 1. t CATE sloNED g,

J RECENER: WRITE REPLY, DETACM STUC, KEEP MNK CO9Y, RETURN WHITE C09 L

1 C0015207

I., K. CSTC< & CC'?.CiY. DC.

?A2C;G SESSICN

'N"E:.

December 2.1983 b SN 3 ## F M' N 4#5 P M '

CONDUC ED BY J.'A. Hii.

POSIUCN Project Encineer I. DeWald Q.C. Manager D. Bradfute d ) W.' d k Area Engineer St.?JE.CT: Welding Installation Record Form.

All attendees were instructed in the use & preparation of the above fom.

All attendees were given copies of memo C83-12-02 dated 12-1-83 and attachments.

f.. ----.

~

{~-]','; 'r(

l;

~

/u a e :

i, '..

NAME (Sipaese Badge 1)

NAME (Si pac.==

3adge #

NAME;(Sipae.ma) '

3a4 As

[SO La hN (o ~3 V hY0$b 19 - / <f.

Y

/m Ic28 i $$$

b 9.2.

++ hyyfW

p. ai U A. & E93

'}pf0bW S e w. s p.e/n xa f{ _

f.to B&

h.

H. J : S

+ - r-Y.N 0A Nefo

), A.. $...

[

$;Y

//J Az2

/Sff A$

k i /'s L

//f-i 73 ]

$/

Wl b ])/] } [

4 yY Ahh e.d.0-/

h -l2 Y A 112 E80 %4 S

A J/

$ YY

/f]

fMo/L ex. wG' erc EAQ % ses n

s

1. A m

& i W d 6 73

& q prz.

c:::

i*, C. Y-Ma, D. 3.mu, I. De Tald r

C0 0,,.,3 0. -0

..s -

L

- -.,,. + - -

L. K. C:2-STC< & CGAW, I?C.

-"!A2;T.NG SESSICN

'A~Z:.

December 2, 1983 EME ST.M 3?oo m E N D 4 l o r 1=. u,

CONDUC 7D BY J. A. Hii PCSIUCN Project Enoineer I. DeWald M M 'e T < u Q.C. Manager D. Bradfute O.10.6.--

Area Engineer St.3 T C T: Welding Installation Record Form.

All attendees were instructed in the use & preparation of the above form.

All attendees were given copies of memo C83-12-02 dated 121-8 and attachments.

,r, ' -

?p, s

.- c s

Aur b:

i NAME (Sig:.aere Badge t)

NAME (Sig::arme Badge #

NAME (Sig::arra)

BadL l PBhtcM 78 d. L -- Ada

%.A EDL s <<

W d.W NOLksR 4 7D Y

/3o73 1'

k-hd /3d Y'O Wd.1$

157 A~o&

n,1 7sc f). # M d53

/Mc ror e st;s h?1 d k ~

/191 X w w _',

fg9

{0 i }kb.s4/7 v hx ))/h

&/(c

/>

AM

% ; L dae m A

• 2-A /l'1 Y $7 A-U c fx A-LG

~.

bdE f

E >,L o j l' rn 5/$$

k _;

AsbmAbH A-Q3 ff(,e.,

f N3 M

1 &< i

.,c.,

nL75%

na-k' %e o n.

u Yinn

-k - 60.-

kn. /),$.h

,h A-$3 4

9f, M

is, u c:::

la, C. Macnacka, D. 3rcwn, I. De Tald r

~

d

_._.m,

-r r c

N l

January 30, 1986 4

8 MEMORANDUM FOR:

W.

S. Little. Di r ec t or, Braidwood Project FROM:

L.

G. McGregor, Senior Resident inspector, Dresden Nuclear Power Station

SUBJECT:

BRAIDWOOD PIPING INTERFERENCE PROBLEMS The present work load and Dresden plant circumstances have prevented me from researching Braidwood records or inspection reports so that more accurate dates could be assembled.

The interference problem of. system piping I

to: (1) electrical conduit; (2) electrical cable trays; (3) HVAC duct; (4) pipe hangers; (5) equipment supports; (6) other piping systems; (7) electrical junction bones and; (8) electrical conduit or cable tray i

interference to HVAC duct has been identi fied by the NRC as early as February 22, 1983.

In April of 1984, (in conjunction wi th a BCAP meeting held in Re'gion III), this problem was also directed to the licensee through discussion and photographs.

The problem was again addressed (photographs also submitted) by the Senior Residents during an April-May 1984 meeting with the licensee and the Architect Engineer at the Braidwood site.

The conclusion by the licensee at both meetings was that the problem was real and that system walkdowns were necessary to document these interferences and resolve them.

In January, 1985, during the NRC CAT meetings and again on March 11, 1985, in a DRP meeting, the subject of clearances and pipe interferences were discussed.

During the Braidwood SALP meeting of January 22, i

1986, I did not enpress dissatisfaction with the CECO program, (which has changed from a system walkdown with resolution of walhdown of only systems which are elevatedclearance problems to a j

in temperature prior to licensing) but a question as to the ability, within the time i

restraints, for Ceco to adequately inspect, document, evaluate and reroute, if necessary, all systems with negative clearance or i n ter f erence probl ems.

?

E I

.n-,

,e,,

-e

,.or-v-

-m, w---

e W.S.

Li ttl e 2

January 30, 1986

.e CECO responso to the pipe clearance problem directs attention t <3 f atture installation and ini ti all y onl y addressed pipin0 systems.

This did not prevent a clearance problem developing to a piping system once installed per drawing and the electracal system or ilVAC system being installed at a later date.

L.

G.

McGregor Senior Resident Inspector Dresden Nuclear Power Station cc:

A.

B.

Davis C.

E.

Norelius C.

J.

Paperiello E.

G.

Greenman J.

J.

Harrison R.

N.

Gardner J.

W.

Muffett N.

J.

Chri ssdtimos e

9 1

l 1

i l

Y L

h M/-

M.

gf i

.O

$ h.h.h$k,

\\

$b

. v.. -h,

. J. h> y

-

\\.. : q.

w

sy

~,_e

.... p-M +.+.

$f; _..~, ;.. c:. 5

..y.,....

.%..?

UW -.

'4 ";.g.. W.9

? % A.f ?,.., y ;&,b?,%)4.~ /y :'!:... v.

.hig. -

. ~

a..v'

?e l M:'

& l l?l. $ j.{Q.y & t

.I..

l..e;

?'. h fl...}hk?; :f': *.:.$'.J.,

.:.-l~^

Jjb i 1

.U?.i kl'-Q

f,. l:.

Q.

- Y

l. ~ '.

[.Q

• f y

, s.;.;;y'{;.y ; a.. 3. s.,..;y... pg 3:

.r. ' N f. 9 7 i, Y ' '..?i.

q j 3.g..

y;.

4,. 4 m;,. d.4.Wf.%,;ys:y,n,.; y

-.f. 4 ;;.f. *w%,7;y, L.. A .i _: ;. "_.L n.

sp:-, ;; g..

-, q,9.,k ;_,

n..

.m -.; ;b.

p....,-_.:

w

,. i,.

• ,: p<g,y x

. : n;...~. :

.. ~. -.

.,N u' I k ' [r...

f<.<;

e 1-

> V : y,y y.,

.n

~y

.g.

..;.v g.

~r u w Y _. q..,., a :*

s;..a.

....-v;_<

. $ sw y

1,. y

...v.r~

c,.

g..

e pl :... ~,74

.. ;y.t - -

[ j.[

^^fn 4 - Q~.. [Jg = ?:y(, ?

.h:. 3 j.t h

-V J,..

.(;.

J't

.NY.h N cc &.,. il " 5 N ? 2 T # *' ' 1 '.. ',';. ' ' ' : 63 or W [ '." D ' S

.. e.

,,,.b 9..,... i L.

;T

< -a

4. A:: ;-n,. _ :. : -

w-..

"[_

• f.g'); Q ~.'. y y... g 1.;..'=~?,

7 a,-

? e

. 2. ~..

g.

...a 1 w.

,: 3 :

.f.f. ;'. '*'........

g...

. =.., f.,g ;.9;l*.q 4

%[_' : h: % -$y;:c Xf j.::..n' j.;$is& l! l'y$$Q9 &,Sf f.'Y[ ; [f. [..

i

[-

'},;' i T.

.., 3.$

?

abi;:~.~.:. ;: -Q M

&l & *

~ ~ ppt,.;:: +. 7.; (; g. -l. f... : q)y.,'):l;,

.s y y.;..,...m... q...D

_ 5N

. ?-. % ' F.

. * : T \\ g: ' 'j.:.

NQIN;? :s&@, '

iQ 5 ;. g..wli.l$f..%WIQ :. 2.,

.v.

.. FL

'. : *.c..$. - '.;,. \\ J W

?.<:.:

l L.~

,;. +..

? '

)..,. :....N ". : %. ::F.-

y y 4.. +., 4.y.3e 4

W.., ~. :f. c,.

m

..... 4.g

,y. y p_... ; :; ;.

.g,

-e..

s c

9

.a. ;:- u. ;

h.,:;., g T..

D k.

.'.7.,W~, : D " ::

. ;. ~ < Y....Y N '.i g.i. j ).

O 4.

v

.a

. m:.

.. 1..,...

,.4.,.r_,.,.

..w y

w. a Y.

2,:

', f,.,. F

?

~. i.f..f.

S,sY...

. ;;,.,.g,...:V....,.

f,..

w$:

. -.Q s.

1

.s f$k,..v...h... 4 ;,..

.;.Ey4 Wlfff.Yhh Nb.'

.c

~.

.o p :.,.

-fA$ g.k.j.f jik..I

.Y; ' ;Y... Y.fQ'i,

^

y.;

[ C 3[.,k!

f %yI',h..

hy,[.4'h.wf.]dk:.. ;. ;.

. '[.

[};:k.. m.

y

.N yp ic - A..,a.. %. -- :

..n. ;46.;

,.m.~

.q.

i g ;.::s7. =... - y.y>.c

. Y J.,.,..i yc._..~ n.

,-;:f n:,

.p

.a

~

c y.9

'...y..

4, - t :y,,e,. y. 4.k 9,..

9

• i 9*N - y

. ::t : > :.e... g-3$.&.., f

.s

t..

s q.,.' y >. s..' ;. 4.: 7 p : e..

• g'

..V..,.

+

(, s. "

' 2:p

.[k { f' h.

' ~.

f

]f 6.y w, w, g:9 m@ @:yt a m;.; m.w'k.w q p %., y;;'

,.. w.'g.

c u f. w.:; y $v.y p W ".: M.< M.,s. p:.ghW:'9.ey s

(.

r

. ' [g.. h..... t

. fr 4,

s ;;.y t. ~-

.:n g:f[b,'

...,;;k, l:

I.{.f, l

t1 : ' a*

f 'l '

_ [?-

k h k,

--'[f k ) h.[ M h-[ 1.7,.k{ d U%I h.kN1(} (.

y i.:

' g '. '. '. 1. f",

g., ?

4[

i 3

h e,"

f k.

.y'

(

(h, M k', ( \\ '.e 4$

i

~

/

..,. 62,

..r w.

}-y. :

• Wgy-! g.'

. T.....:

.v

-e.

M*~ s.

po

.'b

).DRL

% Y}

W. '

h f-

[S43,

?*

'Y"#^ d$..hT

~ N ).Y, $ W.,.V k.$ C i. M, ben. 'MW, A.V

'M i W $Nk.#'9Y b

y'

'2

'f &

Y 4.Y

)

C ~:Qi?

• f +.h.?

9 9, 'Mg,1 'a t -;.l, } h

. w

., t'

,c.' 2a, ;

4 w-8./

• v

'",,t, g,.

3 % N.f g.g t g S.M Q[q< "q, g.

.s,,,-

9 q-

,; if-/

s.,

...m

,,y g' g.. [Q %.gp %

y,.,\\.g ' 4 i

q y; 4

, 7, $..j :.:.. *.. -. h g:

b.

g.

-. gag

. x g g h:

y.-

.. y, j

,4, e,'_'.;

is 47,'.

..., t;.

6 +

4-

.p.

.S

,9Wf p'

'*.{. :. l _ i...

~

E.. k';, : :.f. ' f t ii, & r.

W

_ 3 ' +*p :

.;. y,r5

'- '<' r

~

7 e

'. ' ~Y-J:'4,,,. ' ~ -

%..~

c y;.[

V

• l gg l.A,f'.'.

f.,.

, ~^ ::

.,. Y ^

W,.y.....g 5th.j: }:...

\\

; p q$J Q.' $,,'+- *."

'}~. j,_n ;Q.:

-: l

, $c y.

4 N ~...

..,,4'M g.."(Q j.p%

n..

.c.

2 f.

fT

[{;p..

.h:

m. ;..[ a.a.~.,k.

x.w f,

., m e, nm.,

x.

w.;

~w.

j.

f lL

- })..

g.:.

~ h. Y y}Q v.- -

.m..,,.

gw, __ p,;w%. ?r

,,Qg.., qc

%e; ;.g[y {w g. 7.Q. eft Q3 4

. J,,

y

.y.,

. ;, f{p

.R.g

+:,

y

' p,[

u a.

F

.Q.y 3 yyp a

t y

mmtw

.s y h hkh NNh b

. b n m,n n;mg,y,;nyygay;sna, nn

> - m.m...e~;.y.

w

.f

...y

+.. :$, GM}V. r.

4 f

. ;~;:.. & :,,~. ~. &.:.f:9,{;u.y.-4.J.T_:e:.,_:.[ f H'._t+4 ?.

2

, ~.,e. ~.y

,. /.

.. L,. ~.

n.; 3 Q n > ; ; t.:-

4.; 2 ^ " p

. ;.2 i:L;s x ty;

..~ ' / =;.:y.,,..y., K -R y-Q.:',,..'. ;h ; 4.

.y', ; f:Q J ' _ in.c:: :!,;;% t'f

. Q '[.y, % _ j.Y i:..i..a :: ) '

'. ?. ' -%; y q.n...

• f

. >, ; :. ;. :#.....W \\

.. ;. z..>...,..'.?

l.':.m-4.. :.. % a:.

e a

. ~ ' ' -.. ' '.....~

n+,,.

'-y4w8,'.

n.,....'.h>-

... ~

.y '; :

, ;...... ; :. 6...,;.s' s ' 1%~

- 4,,..nq 4

.c.s.2

.q. s.c '.. r a

.q r

%f,M.i O. 3

.., ( A...*-h;

3.. )

~.K ' * *W-~.O W * ::4:

~

4,.;.

-e e

' ;.f '.... ' "9..a r

,E.g*U;p.

[ h N$ * \\,.Y,.ilJ.

J v

/;[. k.. D.i

,I' h

',[ h A' k. 7.?l,k h fh'

... '.j. 3.l ' l. L.f ~ i. 'I.'. 5$ ~ _. (b.

.k.f:k

?

9

.(

1

-[

..f s:f$$.2'i}~l[::.?

A ' d.jkll :.k;.. -S..[ f ~ Q,'l l l:b'(,k C'

cf. e.

p

.??.E; g((5 N.d 4.

b*3Ig T

. ;:4;g

' S.k, M,j,[l[

$. '},"

ri}f, h ;. i j* [y.U U N c ' S,.[,;*.~ g

,'T. '.

. f l@ f ;

',t

.2.T C M[*['.UE i

i O '.I

' (y..'- -*,' -). '. 't

\\ %

i.

'd i

E

[,5g ':' *. 3

,i 7

. g ; %.. \\'.." f. N}g"

[ a.'-

M.s i:*

pl<., f. +

. l. : & k'.f.', ef.:[.....).)

,.i

-.y 4 4d: y. - q

^ V:

^

qy; y

i ff.-

+s a -

. ~<,

l-

t. m. ? ::

.,c.

-Q

..?

v

. ' 5.[' f.jk.,. %-l%Q_.

A...

,f v Gy * } fR '*.

-~ f.) y' L

. Q:l.- {$l.;'&2:

5.%

.?.. v., en ~

c-

,.p n

.?.

y. r. ;...

NY *? f.;b l. ^ fS...h,.b.ll f..:.:n'..&.k,f.. n.f;j h.k b h.,, t.

.l. ) ' "

l Y h.g:!!. f '.,k.j,:.$

n.g.,. h.:.f.l$ h -

.~ 2:

.e s.

.,1.. :.,.

y 5V W. y p'.. g;,~g;.~l3,,;.;: :,q l4-L.r., ;T.:' '

n

.:g i.. g.

3,:....-s y

• 3.; - 13. ~ :. ;.,.s.. y...

. u hg. h.fl, &.T.Q ;. ;ff ;-Q_-W b.:

f.[.;h.':N :

Y::

.:7. ::6 b, s s.

.3.- 1.f::

g., i,

..i., h; a '.f.

..l'!{i :. N;' l l.f.Yh

{

y e'l.' '. '

( I-c' c

((.

b.

F i

..)

.;:*. 1. f,.._;.' f,.l [

.f..:.:.{ff..f_*f:f l& s.I Y $ ;.N E*

N:&

S.

% :.M.:f.. ;,.

3l f..$

9, W. ^ ; c..:

~

'v a

/.Th' k.c.g Q[:s:,y.

.u.

..a:

\\

t

.<.q c

,-:-~, n

.. - -..., r :.

n

n e v v.,. s. WL

... J.R,.. e ??. y c.

h

v. [.C N... ',

l.

'h.

'k I.

1. k [.

.: 2

• k;

.pr I

I J

< m 7:? '.y!:r;f;fi W 'p.;.;r:~.

\\t I

d

', pg..

f.l-(. h~x[;f Q:?., a

.2

-yn

.Q. w

.,._. Q.,c.g;4. 'p.sg',. 2.y *;hg; A.j n.

t L '...

c. I. ;t %-

+:'..

?Tf ' m '

e.iy 9 y.:

n m

,q.k;_..

7.:

,n..

1.c a.;

Y A,3

~;

y..

}-&

y

.e - W * ? @..Y.;s. W.V.\\. e x,l ml_.l,j V.

../.w..

y x.sy f *.

] g y.'4 :

T.

hA

~

Q l

. y' m e..s.s %' (c'D's.x

-,,.3. 7., Ig., w*w-$,.:C.

u.

.c

.n..

- e,.e..

n

,- $ e? Mgrg.h.. t. e, m*k.:.

1. -w'M A - 1; f ;. c e~,. -

..C

.Y g.

t

..c 331 ',,

'.5 1 P.

f.

f;-

^'v,.

e' ' _.. y ( ['f'.* '

Q:0 kk.}% ~ x[,. i'g..

.: ;. hj- &

fl 5

'?

c#p, f. f '%.; & :. s'L,. %.g.p i ks: I ?- l

. c : n' &. W :' N G # L 35 y-

-u

. r.. -

)

..nrV.. j

/ <9g,.: W.%. -

..V t.

c d. g, '} }. 4. s.,;g. \\.; '. y,3.;.V.. : *. i,. r;vy c. ;

, h,:

T c,

.g ~

g.

i t

..t:As..,y

/,,.

.. 23 g._

nap %:

n

. %w.

ea-.v

., 3 m. y- - a ~..

..v %...

+...

s

.U s.

i[: -

y. v. b.,j

.t-

s.. /..

a.; - >

• f l%[& s: l c - Y Y ' ~ ;' y;..,;w M

?;..'

p J 9 :,.1

c

. y f t; ' y,*. ?

'%gg,)o ~

x n.e

> ;d. pi f.' l ;

s;W:

.~.

[

W S}y ;,W '.

/Y<Y.h h.

w.g s 3 _% 0 %,& h..:'.~-

l l;.;;?,$;i.th l Wl.)%3

&_ 9

, w.

G'N mp$U.n Q.. yj.. :4.

R,,

y y

.[![Nkpk hhkhyh j[

R u. h m=. x. c. w., y.. m y. 4. n y e..,

& + 3. y. g. J...

Q. f 7 f 3,'in:[.;., m. w: a

+4 x y c.

z g. m~p y.4 ~v. ;=

a. s e

..n

..s.

c x

. Q. g :_% f, 4 $ f R

4QQ ? w.

a1z.

f..j. g.y R}

y p h r3i k" 't.?

- + : A.%

.jg :.& g 4::.g.Q & R%

l%[-yjg.y:~. w:., %)

J i

v r

-n'<-

y'...

n L Mtff" a%_ aMid. - - y wp ggm r.2.Q;g;8. ch.m.wm.n#w..

QQ3 s

m s

4, m: n..:

...x m

m a;.sany w n

Wrt5lw.eW l,.

.. f,%.... -

${ n..l-f:&w.N:.hI.i'lw.* j.T lYMQ.QWh&w.k. 3 J

V i Q.!

A+ n.,.::.,n.m, yy q ~:

r w.

.- m u[

m <

a,

... e 7 7.c

.m p., w.4 x

'e

?

I I

gg n. <.. ::C;.. %:Wfwwp pgg). '

s g@w@mee$gy X n,

G n

1 in g ykgg4 4 g g; se

.n A.n

( tiapke JeroMe.

md1(&d p%.~ V ng+k.yapy %.

m.Y., iCNfyE'7.-nn

• i m.f~k W %

U:

Q f.

m g f $ $ {%p &r.w.~ %

emeka

?m,Q'

. A <

. : 4NO W A%

2 9

l N

o'ne xa sw em

.n

. _. 4 m

(.

k y

' ~ ']'

,M

.R ^

sw.w m. g...... :: w.

A;5ya x ~gu~

.L.4,4y q_..

.j r.,

s

_