ML20213D787
| ML20213D787 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Columbia  |
| Issue date: | 08/06/1981 |
| From: | Schwencer A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Eisenhut D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| CON-WNP-0375, CON-WNP-375 NUDOCS 8108200464 | |
| Download: ML20213D787 (3) | |
Text
h
~
~
/g
)
AUGUST 6 1981
/
/
0 e
L n2 Reading ASchwencer RAuluck DLynch NOTE T0: Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director RLTedesco Division of Licensing MService RAPurpl e THRU:
Robert L. Tedesco, Assistant Director for Licensing Orf nel igned byr Division of Licensing doenCW" FROM:
A. Schwencer, Chief Licensing Branch #2 Division of Licensing
SUBJECT:
NRR INPUT TO SALP CYCLE-2 REVIEW OF UNP-2 On July 23, 1981, the current PM on WNP-2 forwarded the NRR Performance Evaluation for WNP-2.
It was based on his experience and that of the review groups.
On August 4, the former PM on WNP-2 proposed a revision to that evaluation (attached). While it provides an historical insite to applicant perfomance during the early part of the appraisal period, I prefer to go with the balanced evaluation of the present PM as submitted to you July 23, 1981.
Original signed by:
A. Schwencer, Chief Licensing Branch #2 Division of Licensing
Attachment:
As stated N
,3 '.
eq 3 (/
0 d AUG12iGSi kg O
~
., "' % "E " D yv7 i'
/g 1
\\
0'.
N h08200464810806ADOCK05000g7
,,h'
.'sj
~w d.y, i --
i h/ I omen >...aL:.LKh........f. h.
su=um > %.c.b.w.e.n.v.e.r..:.1.b..PJ..Ted b...
.. 9f..1.a).............. 8L :M 3
e:.n >
sac roau sis oo-am nacu o24o OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usom mi-us sco
'I m
ATTACH"Elli A NRR DERFOR" NICE EVA'.U'TIO*
racility:
u ;o _
/M '.b X
/.
Dro1ect "anaaer:
..mv w-Aooraisal Deriod:' '
July 1, 1980 to vs..u O 1981 1.
Derfor=ance Elements
.a.
Qualitv of resnonses and submittals:
The eGhay.-of responses and submittals by the applicant was considered to be average uality.
b.
Efforts recuired to obtain an acceotable resocnse or submittal includina:
y
[
(1)
Timeliness:
Thefpplicant's effort towards responding
/
e,3 W =
.urbelow average.
S 4, u J L v in.iu r sa; E t' M T re-# r :
"P-2-=F6AO,
Q2M99WinenppiairaritTVBN
^' '"
de ' %evest=for w/.oomtraoraM.icraabaovveas'inW4ctobeT=t9Mk r @ " ' ' % s ear Se ' r-W m pp;,w u W - e rJ+)
.r
==aese9tc wPPS's dfort in preparing these responses is average.
(2)
Effort:/;t A
(3)
Resconsiveness to staff reauests:
The applicant is W Ard/
resoonsive to our requests.
(4) Anticinates or reacts to NRC needs: 'hsmostscEse g apoiicant reacts to our neecs.
Workino kncv.'ledae of reculations, cuides, standards and ceneric I
c.
I issues:
R i
The aoplicant and the contractors have fairly good knowledge of the reculations and the standards.
d.
Technical comoetence:
IeChnical Competence is G6 C M M ^# " M d, C2W'MQ'- 9' i
l
r
~
~
7
. 1 p
s G
e.
Conduct of meetines at IRD.:
C The ap icant is usually well ce/ pared for the meetings with
-A-r;RR>
Y
)~
f.
lonc-standinc open itens:
Apolicant is ouite slow in closing long-standing open items.
R. i s b - 2:-:r 1: icd P ' - tr
... 6 m a s f ' ch R. u5n a y 1. n ';, j thocoeoys' a th 9 ' ;; L 1.;T. E..- b -a %,
u.uq ng
.oc a n -an-. v - n 3, m -
gw _,
4.
Oraanization and manacement:
j gf o
/
Ouring dest =W this review period pmebeMy' -M... F> eeanage-
-"m roject.
ETismesu
<im ment attention was given to this U-e hs 1) ad M{
@5 g h '9!ry & P *%'
v h.
EP" C
L Y
~
i.
f
)
2.
tfterved trends in cerformancey NPPSS manacement has been mpletely reorganized since er + 1980 8
^
I.t,-apoeewhax-ic-r.have more control over the projects wm amWC
/
d2 M_gfrinoWiE-e gd =ENun cc Tpa na g eme n t a tt en t i e nj As-4.cesdi1r, y
edeirmamountvof oro resschasxbedda,recenuw.n -the4 icensdno-W ce M M7W / l,f,w & GK F W iy W W M E
/7-l C&(?, /YVMW Wp g 5/
t,
}
'i.
'lotable Strennths and Weakness:
g, pgj e kmaf.Mgj They have utiliz'ed the services of well known e 75 /quR.h'9/
M.-
.o Strenoths:
a.
geoscientists and consul' ants to resolve coen issues in theMU
( % ss y fA,c. # /a.P'f,-Tr,$yrz ye ote nf, msn17 y),t 9eosc1ences area.
e
\\,/
<.,r/
r o.co/w r/ a y o yg '
1 8
b.
Weaknesses: They have been slew in respending) tGC.' rec (uesW
~
for.information in mo trof the review areas'. /,e '
.L t
p'*<I
'4 bo. Q/? Q @k'IE
.N( G 5 j'b O/ce 5 ff 4.
Overall Summary:
Tb Jdrior. nanceeinsreseWingrandecesoondimnto-t4CxoccernsrI%
ce. asave, ff imoreved.,inw.ecentwn U ap. _veY? dor--thc. a _, x
- 2. :
The overall performance for the appraisal teriodXs yated as 'b-4+w M2/g g average,tc c;cr. ace:S Q e.)Mdo R Fd/J'.)@)
lIJ w
f, i
(U P D $
G.
/h;tff C SQ W fT
}
/
n J
- ~ / ' }
- ? /
f/ht /W Mrf2 Y /Jf Vof o
Q c,f ST Wh j
&as d.a 4
re.c!es/C ayah S M vi /-
7q WY wk a ed)/ e O'
R 5 c s w w w ' 4
,,r e
Ci s
~
,/
7 L44
.J.L.,a L.
~/
, i<
~
I m
7 Docket flo. 50-397
^6I 198f MEMORANDUM FOR:
A. Schwencer, Chief Licensing Branch No. 2, DL FROM:
R. Auluck, hoject fianager Licensing Branch No. 2, DL
SUBJECT:
FORTHCOMING MANAGEMENT MEETING WITH WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM (WPPSS)
DATE & TIltE:
Friday, August 23, 1981 8:30 AM LOCATION:
Room P-110 Phillips Building Bethesda, MD PURPOSE:
Discussion of open items in the containment systems area PARTICIPANTS:
NRC F. Eltawila and R. Auluck
)
WPPSS R. Nelson ISI R. Auluck, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 2 Division of Licensing i
cc: See next page a
b.
PO
-ST0871024t-etOOO7 PDR ADOCK 05000397 A
PDR A
o,,.c., 0.W 3.LLLB.f.
sua mir> %
k;.nb....Aktunt un> D L
.../.8.1....E/.. '...... /8 1....................
p anc ronu:is po+a meu eso OFFICIAL RECORO COPY viceo, in> _mw I
l
m Mr. R. L. Ferguson Managing Director Washington Public Power Supply System P. O. Box 968 3000 George Washington Way Richland, Washington 99352 ces: Nicholas Reynolds, Esq.
- Debevoise & Liberman 1200 Seventeenth Street, N. W.
Washington, D. C.
20036 Richard Q. Quigley, Esq.
Washington Public Power Supply System P. O. Box 968 Richland, Washington 99352 Nicholas Lewis, Chairman Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council 820 East Fifth Avenue Olympis, Washington 98504 Mr. Albert D. Toth Resident Inspector /WPPSS-2 NPS c/o U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission P. O. Box 69 Richland, Washington 99352 I
Roger Nelson, Licensing Manager Washington Public Power Supply System I
P. O. Box 968 Richland, Washington 99352 Mr. O. K. Earle. Project Licensing Supervisor Burns and Roe, Incorporated 601 Williams Boulevard Richland, Washington 99352
~,
~
$EfC*Ba_IEUCE DISTRfBUTIDIL DATED du. h t 7, / r11 F
/
egeW' M 9 M ?J98 I&E Region I 6
I&E Pegion II 4WIWU'P9R I&E Region III Branch Reading File I&E Region IV 6
I&E Region V 6
6 NRC
Participants:
E. G. Case D. G. Eisenhut/R. Purple N. Hughes T. Novak 4g\\*
S. Varga T. Ippolito
/C N
4 R. A. Clark
, y' Q((
4 J. F. Stolz (ORB #4)
[q-A U O ' [ @,I k S I
R. Tedesco B. J. Youngblood P maigp A. Schwencer gs
%p F. Miraglia
\\
fi e
bec: Appli G. Lainas Service List D. M. Crutchfield B. T. Russell Branch Licensing Branch tio. 2 J. Olshinski R. H. Vallmer Project Manger R..Aulucke R. J. Mattson e
S. H. Hanauer Licensing Assistant M. Service T. Murley.
J. P. Knight
- 11. Jornston (AD/ Materials & Qualif. Engr)
D. R. ?!uller P. S. Check W. E. Kreger L. S. Rubenstein F. Schroeder M. L. Ernst l
ACRS (16)
~'
Ol&E(0) 050(7)
Attorney, OELD l
J. LeDoux, IAE I
V. Moore B. Grimes i
l l
l 1
L
/