ML20211N728

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of 870210 Meeting W/Util,Bechtel & Science Applications Intl Corp to Discuss Employee Concerns in Engineering Category.Attendance List & Util Meeting Handouts Encl
ML20211N728
Person / Time
Site: Sequoyah  Tennessee Valley Authority icon.png
Issue date: 02/19/1987
From: Jacqueline Thompson
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8703020208
Download: ML20211N728 (9)


Text

Docket Nos.: 50-327 w wn" **w and 50-328 1g g g LICENSEE: Tennessee Valley Authority FACILITY: Sequoyah Nuclear Plant i

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF MEETING TO DISCUSS EMPLOYEE CONCERNS IN THE ENGINEERING CATEGORY On February 10, 1987, representatives of the NRC and TVA met to discuss the employee concerns in the Engineering Category. Enclosure 1 lists the attendees. Enclosure 2 includes handouts provided by TVA at the meeting.

. The review status of the overall employee concern program was discussed.

Also, TVA provided responses to the staff's concerns. The issues included Employee Concern Element Report 224.5 (Raceway Support Design), Element Report 209.1 and 209.2 (0-List Subcategory), and Element Reports 213.2, 213.4, 235.2 and 237.6 (Electrical Protection Design).

As a result of the meeting, the staff is: (1) requesting additional information on the Raceway Support Design (Employee Concern EN 224.5) and may include site visits to follow up review efforts, (2) gave indication that items identified on the 0-List (Employee Concern EN 209.1 and 209.2) were to be resolved prior to Sequoyah restart, and (3) Employee Concern Element Reports EN 235.2, 235.4 and 237.6 on the Electrical Protection Design are items needing resolution prior to restart of Sequoyah. The staff however is requesting additional infonnation on Employee Concerns 213.2 and 213.4 (inadequate IEEE Electrical procedures) for further review.

John W. Thompson, Project Manager PWR Project Directorate #4 Division of PWR Licensing-A

Enclosures:

As stated cc: See next page s7030 PDH g $ $ $$27PDR P ,9 id P

3i

.- } q

,a I

{p ,

l PWR#h!)pNRrA PWR#4/DPWR-A PWR#4/DPWR-A EICSB/DPWR-A PWR PWR-A JThopipson/ rad JHolo ich MDuncan JKnight F BJYoungblood 02/ ff/87 02/ 87 02///8 02/() /87 02pn/87

,/'[

- . , .. r

W Mr. S.A. White Tennessee Valley Authority Sequoyah Nuclear Plant cc:

Tennessee Department of Public Regional Administrator, Region II Health U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, ATTN: Director, Bureau of 101 Marietta Street, N.W. , Suite 2900 Environmental Health Services Atlanta, Georgia 30323 Cordell Hull Building Nashville, Tennessee 37219 R. W. Cantrell ATTN: D.L. Williams Mr. Michael H. Mobley, Director Tennessee Valley Authority Division of Radiological Health 400 West Summit Hill Drive, W12 A12 T.E.R.R.A. Building Knoxville, Tennessee 37902 150 9th Avenue North Nashville, Tennessee 37203 Mr. Bob Faas Westinghouse Electric Corp. County Judge P.O. Box 355 Hamilton County Courthouse Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 Chattanooga, Tennessee 37402 R. L. Gridley Tennessee Valley Authority SN 1578 Lookout Place Chattanooga, Tennessee 37402-2801 M. R. Harding Tennessee Valley Authority Sequoyah Nuclear Plant P.O. Box 2000 Soddy Daisy, Tennessee 37379 Resident inspector /Sequoyah NPS c/o U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2600 Igou Ferry Road Soddy Daisy, Tennessee 37379 H.L. Abercrombie Tennessee Valley Authority Sequoyah Nuclear Plant P.O. Box 2000 Soddy Daisy, Tennessee 37379 1

i

/ Enclosure 1 NRC/TVA EMPLOYEE CONCERNS MEETING Feb ruary 10, 1987 NAME ORGANIZATION POSITION Chuck Jordan Bechtel Engineer Manager Lee Anderson Bechtel Engineer - Programmatic Bob Wolters Bechtel Engineer - Programmatic John Thompson NRC/NRR Project Manager Joe Holonich NRC/NRR Sequoyah Project Manager Gene Imbro NRC/IE Chief, Licensing Section G. Bagchi NRC/NRR Section Leader M. Martin TVA ECTG Licensing S. Hou NRC/NRR Sr. Mechanical Engineer N.D. Romney NRC/NRR Structural Engineer J.E. Knight NRC/NRR/EICSB Section Leader John Bankert Becthel Engineer - Civil Robert E. Shewmaker NRR/IE Senior Civil Engineer Igor Don-Doncow Bechtel Engineer - Electrical George McNutt TVA Engineer - CEGH Bill Neely TVA OE-DNE-CEB B.K. Singh NRC Project Manager David C. Jeng NRC Section Leader R. Stark SAI Consultant

Enclosure 2 0-List Agenda

1. " Prudence" resolution
2. Corrective action before restart
3. Scope of operation 4 Construction specification N2G-877
5. IN-86-090-001 resolution - Non-0 items in S-R systems 1

k LJCk&C 6(.1\h.

o .

T

-  ? ~.

l .

s

.t --

. a, -: '

s

,3 ,

3 ; .*

  • 1 2

?

j -- ,

. ~ . . .

. .q, i

,----2._

. w - .

._ 2 ... .-~.

4 -

5- CEG-H i '

' ~~

-J

{' ' I G. R.' McNutt

  • 4

$. j e

. - ~ . - - - i..... Administrative 3 J. D. Merritt i .

. s .- 5 % g ~- . 3 i

4 m5 :- '

I . .

. . - . . - - ' r--.

7

.; . -, . 7 ;,

.i , . r .c t

i ....

, . Electrical  ; Huelear ~~' 'Mecha'nical J Civil

. ~ .i i

Engineer ,Eng)neer Engineer

. Engineer' n, I l M. C. Brickey . D. 7. Clift H. A. Mahlman N. A. 'Liakon.i.s. ;i l .

, ~ ,

faut NoV.4 . ,. ,

y. 7 ;-

g.n Reese . .

O

, g _.._a 4 .

. 4 i .  ; .*

. -i t .

  • ~

a t

.. i

. O a

ll1fj 1 l

'l' s

n f o i it e c we et t n

fu iivm g e in N Rm lu O o rd I

C oe T T iy f

rh CA o E

J T R nar sSc ni l

OS aI I

o pg RN PI B .

we e si n M J t n iett i nn D

A vm e laa l Rmo PP C

4 le L w h A o c

s C cn I (

g n R o m n

l e T D - a _

L o H C n g r

A E o M .

o I

R e M L D E .

P r #

l O h c

1 T o n I

D H o E it E

ya u6 n G n t

2 T R o

s NR a t r

iro la0v -

R E dr e h I

C E in E G k E G c N k t u

E 85 JA r a E A J O L ne I

As9 ON P .

S V n6 RA NN AW I I B yr e

1 C

I e c G

N MC PM L. W. l o ,

G E J

von la n e Cb ee o se J syl N eot e r

  • G is nlph R e n n

ern e I

N S c WE EG d n B E h h

TEB ie W D C V A I

l T

NW E A N S.

R .

A S M K L P

C I

T s A r e

R e

t e N M o EG lo F l AW V A B R I

l iV E N .

G A.

RAM B. O R e J R NR n P Eidr G a _

l A H ' L N . A A

D.

C no I 7 P CM K 8 S

N m 3 2

I A a 1 H D /

1a C L s E A A

M V Tw NI M

R 9

8 1

Illl 1 llllll ll l

O O 4 l

1 W

o z

e w9 CE a <=

m Ce~

C

>- wa mz

<wo D- E gg

a. o - 5"o WDW E5 ow Ee o. w ac W>

' ,z t

MMoN IEz h w

w

~ EDE94 w mogg

> u o -oo C QC w < Cs omo Oc U 5b E- $

o a

<z M

w M

-v

.- o. wa < w-z #;:

  • E5~b 5N w

Rw oc o=o o

<m "w "

2E* R80 <

l I- l 1 I E! WEh

- - n.

~ z oc m4 M

>= N z Ege zwg Em cd

=W 8804

_z a . g m ~

- =J i

>= zO*O- w 4 *

[ Oc 4E o o

  • vs A g> -

l z o vw8 -

I W$w>

5t w<=

m 5:e

._4=

e sw o.

"4 o.

t l =Es3 fue e e Ems m

%N E m

es> z>z wp o Eb2 20 W "MO a ce v N c':n zso >- O Oc < '

g w CL

    • Es8 W Q

co CD gw Q&O3 T" uto *l-lll*

= o O EEE z o MOmG) N egCR z

~ M sn SER

  • v iC C l :>=

MLg)

H U C3 C O t.>

W CT C o- "f m G) U sm o ccz s scom

<zwaz Om C w** < zOcwCz <D a cx C v o g a NbN aw Cog aw-se b  ::>=

bhoh $ Ehac wWooz o $EhSo w o o 4w (:> _a o.

CK uwg ocW=m " O.

w E

\

d lElementEvaluation1 v

--> l Evaluator Prepares Report l v

Review , ,_

Lead Evaluator One Comnittee Menber v

4 4 TVA Review BPC Line, Facilitator, & CEG-H Review Comnittee l i v

--> l Evaluator incorporated Connents i v

e  ! BPC Approval l o

' Facilitator/CEG-H Approval l 4 v i TVA Line Review Review Prepares CAP TAS SRP t t 5-Incorporate

SRP, TAS Comnents and CAP 4
ePC Approval

+

TVA Facilitator/CEG-H Approval 4

TAS Approval 4

1 2P Approval l

ECTG Approval I

tanai Nepori to NRC 2217A

MEETING

SUMMARY

DISTRIBUTION

/(USNIIT?

NRC" PDR*"'

NRC Participants J. Thompson L PDR J. Holonich NSIC G. Imbro PRC System G. Bagchi PWR#4 Reading File S. Hou M. Duncan N. Romney OGC-Bethesda J. Knight J. Partlow R. Shewmaker E. Jordan B.K. Singh B. Grimes D. Jeng ACRS (10)

J. Taylor B. Hayes N. Grace H. Denton T. Kenyon J. Thompson M. Reinhart G. Zech, RII K. Barr, RII C. Upright, RII T. Alexion S. A. Connelly L. Spessard TVA0P S. Richardson (3) AR 5029 OTHERS bec: Licensee & Service List

,