ML20211J238
| ML20211J238 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 02/26/1999 |
| From: | Jerome Murphy Committee To Review Generic Requirements |
| To: | Travers W NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| References | |
| TASK-*****, TASK-RE NUDOCS 9909030094 | |
| Download: ML20211J238 (28) | |
Text
'
t i gA AI*
p 1 UNITED STATES s*
j g
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 'mm 'm1 y,,, February 26, 1999 MEMORANDUM TO: William D. Travers Executive Director fx Operations
[
FROM: Joseph A. Murphy, Chairman /
Committee To Review Generic quir nts
SUBJECT:
MINUTES OF THE CRGR MEETING NUMBER 322 The Committee To Review Generic Requirements (CRGR) met on Friday, June 12,1998, from 9:00 am to 12:30 pm. Attachment 1 contains a list of attendees.
G. Lainas, J. Strosnider, T. Reed and E. Murphy, all of NRR, briefed the Committee on the steam generator tube integrity package consisting of a proposed generic letter and a draft regulatory guide (DG-1074). The staff's presentation material is included in Attachment 2. The CRGR made extensive comments on the scope and contents of the generic letter, which were addressed by the staff prior to formal CRGR review for endorsement on July 21,1999, at CRGR meeting No. 325. The minutes of that meeting, which were issued on February 26,1999, contain details.
Also at this meeting, J. Roe (NRR) presented for CRGR review and endorsement the final rule on financial assurance for decommissioning nuclear power plants. The staff's presentation material is included as Attachment 3. The CRGR had deferred the review of this rulemaking at the proposed rule stage. At this meeting, the Committee made minor comments and endorsed it for issuance.
In accordance with the EDO's July 18,1983 directive conceming " Feedback and Closure of CRGR Review," a written response is required from the cognizant office to report agreement or disagreement with the CRGR recommendations in these minutes. The response is to be forwarded to the CRGR Chairman and if there is disagreement with the CRGR recommendations, to the EDO for decision making.
Questions conceming they meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi (415-7584).
Attachments: As stated cc: Commission (5) SECY )
F. Miraglia, DEDR M. Knapp,'DEDE M. Springer, ADM J. Larkins, ACRS l K. Cyr, OGC H. Bell, OlG ,.
. Collins, NRR 03 b,1 @C. Paperiello, NMSS A. Thadani, NMSS J. Lieberman, OE 6g , ,
(
~
H. Miller, Ri L. Reyes, Ril h -<
i E. Merschoff, RIV J. Dyer, Rill J. Strosnider, NRR D. Matthews, NRR OM,_l ' l y"(1 *-~~
GARMON WEST, JR. I 9909030094 990226 T-4D18 l PDR REVGP NRQCRGR l MEETING 322 PDR j
MEMORANDUM TO: William D. Travers February 26, 1999
{.* Ex:cutiva Dir:ctor for Operctions FROM: Joseph A. Murphy, Chairman (Original /s/ by 3. Murphy)
Committee to Review Generic Requirements
SUBJECT:
MINUTES OF THE CRGR MEETING NUMBER 322 The Committee To Review Generic Requirements (CRGR) met on Friday, June 12,1998, from
- 9:00 am to 12:30 pm. Attachment 1 contains a list of attendees.
G. Lainas, J. Strosnider, T. Reed and E. Murphy, all of NRR, briefed the Committee on the steam generator tube integrity package consisting of a proposed generic letter and a draft regulatory guide (DG-1074). The staff's presentation material is included in Attachment 2. The CRGR made extensive comments on the scope and contents of the generic letter, which were addressed by the staff prior to formal CRGR review for endorsement on July 21,1999, at CRGR j meeting No. 325. The minutes of that meeting, which were issued on February 26,1999, contain details.
I I
Also at this meeting, J. Roe (NRR) presented for CRGR review and endorsement the final rule on financial assurance for_ decommissioning nuclear power plants. The staff's presentation l material is included as Attachment 3. The CRGR had deferred the review of this rulemaking at j the proposed rule stage. At this meeting, the Committee made minor comments and endorsed it j for issuance. .
i in accordance with the EDO's July 18,1983 directive conceming " Feedback and Closure of CRGR Review," a written response is required from the cognizant office to report agreement or disagreement with the CRGR recommendations in these minutes. The response is to be fc3 warded to the CRGR Chairman and if there is disagreement with the CRGR recommendations, to the EDO for decision making.
Questions conceming these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi .(415-7584).
Attachments: As stated cc: Commission (5) SECY F. Miraglia, DEDR M. Knapp, DEDE M. Springer, ADM J. Larkins, ACRS '
K. Cyr, OGC H. Bell, OlG S. Collins, NRR A. Thadani, NMSS C. Paperiello, NMSS J. Lieberman, OE H. Miller, RI L. Reyes, Rll J. Dyer, Rill _
E. Merschoff, RIV J. Strosnider, NRR D. Matthews, NRR Distribution:
CRGR SF CRGR CF File Center (w/atts.) PDR (NRC/CRGR)(w/o atts.)
STreby - JMitchell RTripathi JJohnson, OCM BSheron DDambly JJohnson, Rll MVirgilio MFederline GWest GHolahan ESullivan Treed EMurphy SLong RAuluck RWood . BRichter ASingh DISK / DOCUMENT NAME: S:\CRGR\ MINUTES.322 i To .K 4 a copy of this document. becate in the bor "C" = Copy w/o attachment. "E" = Copy w/ attachment. "N"= No copy OFC CRGR' b C:CR I NAME RTripathi JAMu oATE 26 2a/4" f- OFFICIAL RECORD COPY -
. . i Attendance List .
f CRGR Meeting No. 322 l June 12,1998 CRGR MEMBERS ~ NRC STAFF T. Martin G. Lainas, NRR B. Sheron for F. Miraglia D. Matthews, NRR J. Murphy G. Holahan, NRR D. Dambly J. Strosnider, NRR F. Combs for M. Knapp E. Sullivan, NRR J. Dyer, RIV (Video teleconferencing T. Reed, NRR S. Long, NRR R. Auluck, NRR B. Richter, NRR R. Wood, NRR CRGR STAFF OEDO Staff R. Tripathi J. Mitchell ACRS STAFF I
A. Singh Attachment 1 l
Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 322, June 12,1998 l l
l PRESENTATION MATERIAL USED BY THE STAFF l
i i
I
'l l
l Attachment 2 l
1 l
a
^
nD$
3s$
. ' g sE K
YR .
TO I
F -
E 8 G BY 9 -
N U R 9 .
I F TOT 1
E I
R R
OL A 2 1 -
B R
TU AG E
N --
G RE U R ER N
J EO C -
GT M N O
AI ES o
TV I
c +
q( M)# SE e
n +
a + R e# +
l1 .!
1 A
D N
E G
A X N X- O I
8 N I
9 P L O G L D A E N S O O I S
P S S O N E R O F N P I O
F T R O C P I
T O .
A C W Y G U E R NI D I V T R O R S E .
R E U F .
T V D F N O N I D
I I
- e e e C
2 T E _
N D B E
)
N T O M A S T S E S N T D O
E l E S I T V i
E S A N A L E E K
)
U H 7 T G S 9 G A I
R 9 E D K
)
1 R E A L D L I
G L
I E G E R N A L M P I F T O G R A N (
N T N O I R S E E I F H E T S L K R C V N D U U A E R O E I
C T R M P A G M C A E , M E A T M L E R R S O U D N E I N .
R R I I
P H U I L
F U D Y C Q S _
D G ( A G E T A E E H S T O R S N G Y E I
R R A S C A R L K E U D A 4 O P G E
P S R O O 9 T P I E 9 M T A R C R S R 1 A O N L N
G O P P Y L
U C I E G W I P L
( E R K O A R G S : B A N O C R Y A E I S S U T R T O S A P R O
E, T
Y N G
T I
F L B N N L O E K A O T I F A I S S L C S A N A N U E B A O 7 L A R A R B P _
9 U D L A O 9
G G Y C U N Y R 1
E E E R N S E L R B L O O N M L P R
E T U T C E A A A K S B D R R A S T : C I RI R M E O T L I O E I R
E S U S U E I F F Y N S E TH T V F A G S N I P E E R E L OIS S E RI T E R D R A DA I CW S Y N E G R
E R D D E A SB T G C T RD I
G H
T O E Y N O AE R
T A
P M R R TN NI A N P T ER D O O ES I
L D C E L U
L E
O F T RN P L RO P D S A RE E S G V R L M U WP F U E E E U UC I O O EU E C R D P CL C C NS I
S G R I E _
B D - - - R - - - -
e e e
~
{ l lI
~
. . 3 7
9 9
N 1 O
I 0 e S 3 S E I
M N
U _
M J ,
O D C E e E T H A
'T T D N O M O T R C S S N N D O I N I S H U U C L A O C O -
R N R G O P P
K C A _
C E
V D A
E B O S B I A V _
E D R E
D O I
V T O D R E P E 3
R 1 G 0- A 7 N 9- O Y I S
C S E I S M M M O O C C e e
m 4
T E O -
S O V I
T B O S EC T DD W M- D LY B E N I E UH HA M -
TID V
)
I SP L
L RTIT SD I O LE R X EA ASW HE BF I
F X
T N SN N S N I
A NE EO EE I E
I R AG A RN O D X R U S EI N E E DK S R BY O F T EA .E F L L I AG EN P I
R TE L T T I D
S C CL A P C I
( E L MIDED HM E F I
S B RA UI F SOR S S A D EM " LI S D N S CL B N DR E P N O EO E NAU RE A I A T G TN I
)
SS UR l i
XN I N CA" E S Y A . N 1 C
I XS 1
E I C O 1 F
- L RFE SB E N
I C
MY I
8N A BOR O ED T T
C O E 9E V AYU R CE I E
I P
LC U I
F TT P P OH "
NA L
S T
C S s
,I LRS DL U I
GL Q I API L OU E E L S E EBR Q S AT I I DY CLP T M R NA EAM CO S E CY ET I O GB S I S PIC O AT A M I
NB -
SR 1 3
SO O ER R S EC EE )
- S A HD CE OG FPC VS S PE 0 DP G OSA I T R D O E T N OT 3 EWF L TD C E V
R T OE R
RN 4 BOO LL O AN E D A
D D
E TV 1 D R HA R A PI LYN T R N N SO N TD E C AL .
OS A G TG B D HE A O EE CN T L C URLS UI S I
S S SME U G LE " O E T ( "
ER "
S OR :T I
D D A F N A B PTL RU X:SRU I I VD N S EI O G S CXI I A NE TD XN A T DT S E RE A NO S N I C C F NO OC OC E E XE I
D :N 4A G OT CO I I RT D N NP S N:E 1 EI N RD EE E R P EAD O C
O P
O N I
ER R THE TI P
E I
R TT
(
a M CG 5 O ES GH G C RE EC I
AT N A CLB GI NIF 5 C S 0 AOP B I BUR 0 B E -
5 TA P TO PTS AT AL PSR 5 P M00 RR PSO R C PSR PSE U F S 0 FO AAP AETQ AAC C R A2 CP 0 0M 1I - - -
1 e e jlljIfI 1' f
j 5
E S D P E O C S A
C R - ,
C E
(
9 RD I
1 AE E M PS M S C ES O A D RE S
- G R (
L D WD G -
E N TD S _
%A I
N A D N 0 0T 4 ,O P O 0 G S 1 SN 0 R T : EN 0 E R )
S I
P T D I GA Y O
'T N R M XN A E I
L EC TI R E P E AIFO G -
XO
- S D G CLG A 8C E E " AE K
R A A 9
S U Z Y
K C
" QUT A E LI D A C L -
GS E L) E RE L A C AR L E D "C A DB O NT G PN" T E R AG S N DF O
SS SG T P T O EO R I OIN NB SRN M T S N E L I NIAO P PS E VS O A PT I G
ON M EM C L
P EC X
1 RE P 5 N
E RN Y PC I 1 G /NU L U RIO I S E EF L L Q ET (
L A)G E TC S P HY CS T PE N MWC I P/ D .
C E
AJ HE OI AE SL E N Y P T T G F CA A LB U :
Y C AAR Q LCC O E s0 I
F I
T S5 N LR I I ER T1 O A , C E
NP F EO CR I I
% ,N TI P O GT AX F O O I
T S 3AI AD CN I CO L : I T KE AC I
FO ER A sRC I
L T I
P C SEE EU AC S D I TTP I LD UE RK
- E N H
GR S N GE SR QS
~ AC C SCI _
SO E _
- FL T - -
e e -
_ 6 S Y S E E A L N I
TI D- Y S DI I TC _
I R A S F
C F NX NE G G O FN AP E B O N E OO TS TG T- I T N T I
SN NN U Y C BI I I O A T N OC E UD ES R I E
I TS SN BN D E R UE N P G G R
A E E A O E C BA TC A T E I M I L
P S NR I
G L E R N M SD V O I E P A AET EN I
T F E Y AD CI RA P Y B B EN SR US I
R T U D HA EC XE SN C I
R T E TS T AIR XU NO S G E T NT RAP
- EI T E E R A OFO 8S TA R T U V H E 9S OL P N S A D TR L Y I
NU E I
N R NE WS _
G PO R E E U F EC E DO OR R T L E
A G S N GE NT SA EN P S T E E: NH ON OL T I NN I
E G I I Z E T I
PU OR R N Y BM I AR B ES SD DO OG LE AV D
N I
R T VN I
DS I
AF RE sO A U O AA NT RD PR SG N S
N N HH AU GE T Y O E S SC NO EW TB I E GE OE DO N T N O NM TR I
DL ED C O I MN NL RE E D CA AA RR P S U S OO EH T T
EIC I
UU I
Q TA DH S OH HE I
O E RD R T TR R
O F
T R OA HR CWT R EN I CS N A WS A F O N
S T SG SE E GH E S T G SD sE E UM LQE R NT L CD S T T I
A NE 'Q E N BINI ZR V I
AIN E O I
T TN AHU SER R D E NA I LCQ E HE LA I
P T S S E E RIN EEE DIGT MIN T T M RM RTR NHI N OA UO CM - - - CD - -
e e r lll
7 D S O N E T T S I E S E F B B E B YU U H A U LT T T T WY L T N E T M XG E R I
E A O FN R UU H R TD I
U Q S T F SR S E N E ) G EO N
E R E R 6 N BC FO U 0- I M DC O NT S 7 EA T NS 9 M D
OST I EG L E D U
T' G T LD E AQ OIN S N DE TM 5 CE G AR SO 0- M NN I I I E OA S RE SC 7 L CT E GD AT 9 B FN
N T DC " O G R XO O TD CH 3 P AM T
N NN OS 0- Y SS XC A HS C A I
- E T 5 1
- CY 8E RD D T 9 9
I S F t
RT U AE F T A "N
L A NIR SI R G I
Y E
SU EC
(
O NI S R E R S T B s N E E E E N O GI I WS S H I S KB O T NYT N T D I OU P A I LI SN E N E RT PR EO CNE R BE OL MG EI T I A E "R RU AE SC L V L
s H AUX PG ST N N
E A) S HI G T G T Y
SSN8X -
E I
EI CTS WD I
S L R BE L N EE E "M E9 I
U T L UR C SN O N EO G TO SM GE O TI A R E LT C T BD D D F NL R A E R OE E NE RIN I
PP M R AB M MC EA U U RD S YD OI O TM N CS PE
" E P O
CE T COH : N S F Tl E ENO N T R T D N I O LC E C HS R I
O F UA UP E
O YR( A I T
FY T E
C SU TA P QS H A C AI TR N EQ TsD E N S SY A SG A RE AS E RI SST U AD HT PO FE TE R I
M CE T DL SR I
RN T S S A NN E NCG R S AI N TA EEE VN T E
T NI I EE VME I
V I
GITN I N
I - - - GAD e e e
8 G T N T N I N E N E T S
S R L A
I N E V V S
N D
OO I
I U N O TG C Q A C AR E S S E T N N T
A P N O O
~
HY E I T
I T
TIT M TY C C EI A N DR LR U NG PG D F AE T MET E Y
sN I
N T SI RN I N E TE O E A F TB L A NU EB P S ET CU G NT R X RE AE N I E
X- RR DR I
S H UU I UU S T 8
9 CS GS U HN C G L SE T E S N S N I
T E ! I G O WOT LO D M GT ) R DP SY f
EA 5 0
R S PH E OP i i
BS sC 5 P P t OE SU R F O L RC TS F C O R C PE DS E P
R : B N SR MIT D A E EA AC E P L E E P G Es SA N AS SS EU I CS I
D NT ED SD F EA E ET ESI E NE E D BB S CN NF OH O I LE EC I
PC Y TG P
R RS CE SS T SN O I L SP E G I
R UI S R
P W UO RN S R N G M N F
P S
CI T T E SI T E R E
T SE EC O DA SE R O N M NL ES I I BIL U
E R OU UN UP E TH S
O O YG QE EC QP EU B
'GI T .
P F EE I U SW R
N BR I RL RS T
~
U G P - - - S -
e e
\ 1 lll f I l R Y O T I R R A A
I DG E RK NE Y ES I AN T E TR I
NI N RH OE O C T T B S I
I N CU R RW I
A T U O AT F G C I
T P E R C RO OS O A P EG T M EP SN A R VU I RN I
E F T N R
T A I
S T E N T XG L I S LE E S M U E E XN N A AN OD M O I
O D B ,- PN E 8T I O s OA L G T G SA 9R A M N TI R RG P N I
LO M R I T EE PN M L E
GP R E P R L T FI R O O I
- EU N S P P A C OIN F
E R
S SI I
G T U XL I TO L T OS E S EA PM U X PN N I
S I
H R R I D E T V T EU RR N OO R E I P C T )
C S O E
H O RIT O R W SU f
( E F C T _
P PC 4 -
P O E T R4 5 DS S R V
I -
A U T I XT7 0 ASA A O L S S T ES1 5 E I
D D E A L FI C1 R E D B D RG P
E E N TG E Y I F
N I
S R E V T V SI SR T A S P SO -
S E E
T L OLR I S RF R NT U
N D A PB E N PA P OA O D E OA P O OS O D Q I T A S RBT PON P TG T E M
G E C S SN S M 6 O YR E N '
R A S E ET I
E I TI D
T S
P O APM R ER E T SW E E R MF S S D SO S N
E S AO T U P OO E E NP E N E L S Q ,
SES R EP C O L L E E R LSS I U CU P TO AF I
U I
R O AUA Q LS L S
Q E E E R R - - - R - - -
e e e i
l
. 0 1
C I
F I
C E E D P _
N ,
S-E T SG _
N E CA YE S RK TA EM O D SE KSS UL EE X JD TS E DE AS L AC R
O A F
" OU P L T TD S NE RA N N I G
- O O E EE TN S CI M T NT E S NA A N EH EIDC I
G ) L S G R E P
X N MO I
A X- E O O R R ,
T T EDE 8 - R GN H YT R 9 s U RO I S TA O L S C CT I I LL F G LT E DD I
W I C E N )A O B CN I
T ST S F CD O R E D AIR E 9IN EN P M O N HC E
S E SM O T I
VS R D ESN E S P E SSA C l
OA RE T N SEM L P RA G
I UR! F R CR S CU0 ST F O ONO TI E I FH DE F D DE AR SC s E TA E LD -
S EF P EO D BE T BCN ,
LR N AE E NN L OIT O PP T E E E T
( AI MP NOH D sMT AA I O SM A XT S TT M TAI C EN TYTUT S LRF SE "X V O I
E EGL I
EM H H DOA HS CS EIT L CIT C ORU AE F AW A MPQ TS T
T A -
TS AA -
e
- 1
- 1
, N I
E D S E N S F E O O F P E O N D R O
I F P T O H A N C C O I
H O
L I
T W D A R N R O A E F
, D I
N Y S O -
T N I I
R O T E C A V D E H A S T R X ,
I W G XS N T
T E D
8L U N 9A )
O E H LS 0 M M C E 7 A GO P G
A 5
1 A S S E
- E ES R D G E O K H SE E A E T SN S R E R N ~AI D O P I
L U L S D N O KE N PW E T SD O E I I OE C S T
E NE EC RU C RN U S
( DIV AG OD P D X S NR Y 4
I E E DP m
A L P T O E S D1 I
R N F I EG E P E A E " T DN T EA E A RR I
S O
I R T D F O C ET NG P E I
R I
C I SF OG TN T C C N L P AE PN NIE O I A O EL P I
EB R R C I M RN U W M P C N T I SO SS Y R I
T S
I A K CO NI T L S H I
S T S E L E A I A
I L E N I I
E B L DF S
R A A E
M E A MA LH AO E B R I R UT KP R
E W O L
P T KG OP SP S
N E R C N SE I HE I N P N M E RD SD RA E I I T
C O I
L - - - - P - - -
e e
2 1
L .
A E C N H O O T H I T
I H D D T
I A D W O A E T R C E E N S H N A N T O I
O S E I L P N H T P O A M
S E
I W C T E I N O R C N F
I C N N A I T O E I
( O R M S h I
E R U T
I s T I E E J S
XA N R
S I
S H T L XC I E S O
P T
T E
D A
N 8F C T 9I I
L F N O O T M F E T)f I
T L S Y U A M F(
I F T D GU I RY M I S U
C F 4 A 5 D DJ EIT N I S O T0 A E) f VL I M E D S 5 R S( 4 OC N H Y EO O TA S LT O5 D F A I L
L L BT F
D P 0 EE H B A AN E O5 T DH E A M NA E RR ET R T R EU N ER S O LS P F NO O E F LR O N
C M Y WPU I
SF L O -
0 I G T A 1 DIS N L A S NY I R
E S I O M E OR E TA D E I
TA T SB R S AS I E G E O R U N R F N ME S C QI A L E R C )
C O F E ES S G I f
(
RNE E D L
N N 4
5 E S E N
OIC S E
S E I
DR 0
5 I L N: O R EA S T T I T
E P U C )S A N SS E ME I N O Q 'E N I
S NC I PA - -
e e e e i
s 3
1 X
D O T I E T N D T X E N L D X- R E U E 8 P S E N 9 R P E N I L SA R ) S G
C N0 T T S N N F DO5 A E E O NITR H L A
M T O Y AF LC D E L N V I R U E B U0 A U I
U S G1 N Q Q E SED A E E R )s NRN A S O GA N
O C
S S
T I
R S
T ST T
I T
CIN )T
)
i
(
)
4 I
T :
T N
R AN A RE NN (
)
" O M SE L EL a _
A N E M
(
U NR A VA
(
9 C
I O
I E
4 1 M I
ORU I NOV 0 1
T R C N T O GU l
XI F P I U D I
M CC I T HQ 0
- S X E E LN DI E R AO A WE 8 H 9 UJ E RY E T NY H P L T E SI T P N OE E YT L F C TR DS I B K PR O GI F N MG E N T AN T I
S A M( O A A H TIO DN T DK UE NE I
I D T O4 R ET AIO T I EC L P MN AM TE RA S C1 E T
SA UOC I
N E I
L T M NR OU EC MTD I
R O
P B O I
MB I
AU I
MG K A A SD G C C TU MQ O 09 "
NT OE TE K EEA N R1 ) S R E DR OA ER X O i
( EG I Y C T T SIUI I
T P 0 )
RS Y D T S LO 4 P 5
(
) R T TH DO N E QN E UG E EE E T a I N C R (
9 CIN R GM ED C I
L R P X F 0 EN E U RA ND E SP E C 1 HA I.
TM RF YE RIS A E 0
0 5 TT NN I
UF AN WI PH5 0 C YN I
EM I
CA T M Y
,TR N 1 G L A I
SS SL A N N B N E EE X X SF OM I -
P T H S T 8N 0V O GO ET NE SIN NI 9E1 X M V NN R O N I U E ES E F CE LMY GEL N C I
D OIRL O l S
O LW NO L TU AR E F LP EM RS RL PE I O OO WE Wl EQI UECI T F
S S
I FI N TD PR P( W DRNRC I T
S I A ,SR A B - - - - F TPB I S e e e llL
4 1
T T Y U N T G O E I
RN N M A H T D E GIS T I E L E M T N WS A P E A S M E N C K D B D I R I
I S E -
TE G D A EL I S N S GD R NC EN S A E AN S N MA E P U)S K
A A I EM R O S E SU I
E S A LR U L I LN T Q E LS N PO V S DIO I MF E E AI NT A I R R CN E E D AAL M I BP R NO L U E E O HIT 4
T TT I E S E EE E1 U YW W TT T - T R C G O E S YO UG CE U R
OT H N ER UL L N - KP BD RB T S OE T T E C TD I
TA N S M AA
'RD N SC Y HI G I
L HR s
GL I
R CS M R T iA E N NP O C W EK As I P T TO P RI S NA I
I A SC F YS I AH L E( I C O UR RT TT U HW E T S NS OL NI G CE P S EM I
W E AV I
S E TE A R OE V :E HT AD MT N E RR N I T CS LO NE H P F O
I N AY UM G
T P F AA T
AD E C
OS R S ,
ER US A DE N PL RO CN H WT S AP I P
F OO T EI NN T RO E AIA FC E G EL D L R R EE E V I VY E D :E L U L M DE OG AT EC S L B D ED RO CA I
SY A N L E PL NM A NE N B B H B C EV E E :O ,
A SN C Eg G :E M NO EN D E L Y:A ET EH Te (
CI TS) VC NT M LE ITE Y: E S
I TE DD AA RB L I R TI NT E T E OA BR EE S MR FT U LG I
AS R E P AOT I E CD RE O NP TF C BT NN GR F OS l
PDU f
I KC E
AER XA ER I
EW ED RRS SC DET DE TD EOA I RA ANS LT FS NN NA PFB I e e e e e e
'~'
~
PROGRAM STRATEGY / -
. STEAM GENERATOR TUBE INTEGRITY .
Cd.)n t 1
1 r NDE I '
Oualification/ : , , ,
Validation 1 r Condition Monitoring
. Per-inform NRC no formance s
g Criteria tisfied
?
1 r yes 1 r Corrective . Operational Actions '
Assessment n 3 7 l
Per* )
no formance Criteria yes i r .
Ping / Submit Outage Repair Report h ^
- l Preventive .
Measures 1 r Planth
. Monitor Restarty -
Laakage ,
- l
a
.h .
6 _
1 F
E F A B A U T N T S- I
- T G L ) L F U S G F A S G DY T E N EL S R -
I S ) SG )
F O S W ON PI O
T F T E E A Y R OD D T R R I
D V :
E S L E PO P E D R C O D O K A ":
I EC L V T I L
R H E T A ES O D VE O L V R E S TIN I
F E P D I AL D: O T G D I X T V X-TE I
D t
ED O E O I
NIU i
VE I S T Y R 8 9
Y T S
N I
NG I
M.
B TO AP R T
S E
O N
P T
E L
GSE -
O AM U NO S N (
I TA S RR U I S Y D E H T PR T E T P D L E E T S C C OG LN N O O A O N D A DO AO N P O -
I I N D I
U L (
Y AR (
T S
I T
I T E CM S
U A
G N
I i
U G
E N
I L
R P P NY A -_
A E M, C R T E OR U TA M FO S O N D ST D OR R F EC A ) T E I
U TS VE N O NY H 4 S I
N M G NU -
I DN F 7 E O S ED NE N AR T T 0 1 N S G MN AG I SS R - I M E N I R O G L M D I
,M AU D E E S T D A O 6D F D G S S ON E E P
F 0N F
E S I A A E CA T F 7 I L U K Y T CC OS F 9 A T Y E G A I
L" A R L T E LR E6 T l
EH O L I
S E I R R BN V0 - S NT T A I L G U U F E7 R O L S P O D9 O SD A T A E S T L A N T E F
S E l
WE T U P 5 O
N R OE C AN D E S G
(
N I
P NN E I VE E 6 I T E H: D R 0- O A B U OE YY I V YG 7 I
S R U T TG I
RIT O RG S 9 I V E T I S- UR TR TU F l
E E P G LE SG R SS N OV UE P US F N R O S I SN DT A EO NN DA T RC I I - NH I S - - - - -
o e e e
7 1
)
E L
SU RY ER U GU L
S T F RJ S A CR FO I
OR I
L HA V RU T(L E D e WG V H E OD O C N Y HE FS RS _
OT OO OY I
NR I
I RO PN PG OR DE R OE PP FR T EE L N RH OU AI D T NC N E EF OG OB TO I TN I AT AIT SU RN GE RE ST EM E E DM EG TP I SR F
O S NO N O G I
RG N L AV E C R C PN I SE ST GN T D F' A I
NR NE F All M
E C E EH TA -
F N UG CN L D I
E FO I
C OIR A T N D DU E I
ND DS S _
SN I
DS I
CE DE H OR T PE OIS DW NW e e _
Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 322, June 12,1998 1
I l
l l
I I
I l
l l
l l
PRESENTATION MATERIAL USED BY THE STAFF l
Attachment 3
y'2 )
7 .
t c 3 9
]
' s e I 5' M ( }6 .
21 G S C
R R RO O
MR E E R RWO I
G R
-QU P C 8 EER E H
9 9
LRA U E T 1 RC EC L F O
2 1
E LNU G N A
NA RN N
I U
J I
F FU G E SN I I
R .
CIM N
AM NO F C I
E D
. T R E S 6 E L E 9
R 9 2 T U R O1 4 AS R EE F DG I ET .
8 ,M DS N DS L O EE 0ENI ETI R PR O
0SEC 2OCI SNRF L L I L O T
OEP PMA S T EA RP LB OE NN VR EO VR RU E
C EE OP OP RR OEI DDE DE S 2 N A
PU R M CF NH E s, D FQ OETO EM R E AT EC I U
N H SU E RSC SN ROEN P L G
ET I
CEG0 A D T CE56 I
H TI N ESCRU N D
N O NR Y R,D I
I EL OD I
I A -
NA E U 5 SV .
U R L L P E L SS2 EI PsE O E U AE NH TI MC N I
D R L R
G CS NS RT EA AISL N0O NI S U R K AA EI DM EB E5 R ED T V H T U MRF GE F D D ALFX C AT AE A O P ME S A RS B AICH E R N T7 O V REI DO N P OI C OE TL P A NT P S T9 3GiAI TF F DO DNI ANA T A9 NH 1
3N I
ESA ER U
S P I
EIFGD E T0 DRL5N SNI NV E H ME1 EED VV E S
,U SE I
H L ONIES I
OT BGIOC T O C RB CCUIOD SY UN E S LT N LN PI SEKI SR N E D N EE DM R TCA A AA CNNZ S CA MC N OST I CP R MMR O DO P REI ENP RM N EON P EP E NM S AU NO ELCES SO S E ME GO EC HUEHE ARN HOH RR HC TA TRDTR BPO TCTOG -
.O
. " C -
Y I
i R _
l L TM : F L
I CO E E T ER C L D S U L F R A U C E L D I
" G S ). NN C N R G NIN( ER N A T N AN R HE I CI TT ) T ED TO O T T X (
e N ASA I
LI E E . 5 E E V HSL EE E 7 R "O TI MH C 0 A E NR S MU S TNA 5 P L E P I MG E 9 D EE R U EO NO R OC ES N N R WTE SU U
. I A _
T E E S D I
T TTC N DS E T N ECN CDA T E C NA I
E BEA NFO R A W D R S PR I
T S I
L" N G O E R E SU SST L R U HES I RYI L C S 2 C S RS D SY TI OITD A F D F U HA I
SOB TLN S O O _
I HC D CIT UF D O GITG T SE AU O S H Y
R NWI I
N DTT E
RICO F H R E
T E
A TSD N I
A T I M S RN I RD RRD E I E
M I
U E H F EV A WE H E L NT -
S L TG BO M NC OL T N ;S ANA C
U ON PE E D S;R RDN I
T NO NAI S T
PNS AON R U EOE A U MA R YNU S MBT E
REISS UCE LOF SYY N G REM Y A PERE ATAR USM S S "Y P A LIT G AI UNI N R ERAH CNO AITL E TIF K ERUUT EEC EI T REN H T PSGO HICE HTA TUR I
VDS I
O- - -
TLD - -
~
E D
N I U
" L Y C N F T NI G O I
L I
A N ;S "
I OT I E
K E T TR N )D U F
CE N
MC LOSS ET I
L A I
CA A D NP RP H C P ER H US N ;E A TO LM LU C ,TT C N R AI E ES 5 P RT L " S 07 E DC X R Y O EN U
R FA 5 MNAE EARNFNI ET F DA EC L O G9 C S TO /E LP C FI "F
A NN N NE N SU M I EI M I
N ODI :AG O GP RS N .
FN I
F I
TN N ERR C NFI O OG N UO I I F I LUAMI N ,UOI T I NS O F F T I
US HR R RQT A OO Y E GC RS CEA AE ES M I
TN R DN N I L S TE TRD R I
N; AE EG REA G N O I
M OOID NL R N F BI I
ORI TF NU F E E .
DT I
M E S N -
U CIST A FWE AWO L FG RGI O OLS ,T R OINS EC RE S I NM H I
F A MT SLBE DOPN H F TLAC E(EOS G T I
TA LO E CE S NASN R%RI E S SA C2 AS N N
EI S -
R ET M N ATAF I I
MA SDA E E PS S O SM C E T EV E
T RR L
E D BU YMWSS ME L T E
AO FO AC ROLDO Y N R P R ON NP OL CL RL EN I
M 2. 0 O OROI J BNCAFI LUM DC EO HO I
L5 C A T E9I N O-M- - -
.T E G N E
TI N D AN R RO I U RS B OS I F TM C T O AM OG EO NN RC I
L C EY LE N RA AS O DM NE D F R I
C P S 4
A TT T DN w
YS T A NE Y
A A S I S T TL M S EE I
M E UC S FR U C SN EK O VC T S EIS A EAC NN R U I
L B A SO S EAE I I B R E
L LAA TS FNR T
U FEE RU GIG ASW N
A RN EP _
N I EU HEN FDF TRO
_