ML20211J107
| ML20211J107 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/02/1999 |
| From: | Jerome Murphy Committee To Review Generic Requirements |
| To: | Travers W NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20211J113 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9909030043 | |
| Download: ML20211J107 (17) | |
Text
g 4
. jOe nog %
3 y
4 UNITED STATES j
j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION t
WASHINGTON, D.C, 20555 4 01
+
June 2, 1999 gg MEMORANDUM TO:
William D. Travers Executive Director for Operations FROM:
Joseph A. Murphy, Chairman Committee To Review Generic eq irements
SUBJECT:
MINUTES OF TH5 CRpR MEETING NUMBER 341 i
The Committee To Review Generic Requirements (CRGR) met on Thursday, May 6,1999, from 1:00 pm to 3:30 pm to hold the Committee's 341" meeting. This was a special meeting to support the staff's schedule commitments for draft final amendments to 10 CFR 50.59 and to its Part 72 counterpart. Attachment 1 contains a list of attendees.
D. Matthews and E. McKenna, both of NRR, presented for CRGR review and endorsement the draft final amendments to revise requirements of 10 CFR Parts 50 and 72 conceming changes, tests, and experiments. Attachment 2 contains the presentation material used by the staff.
Pending issuance of these minutes, the Committee, via a memorandum, dated May 10,1999, (Attachment 3) informed the.EDO of the following issues raised by the Committee:
i 1.
Without reviewing the associated regulatory guide and inspection guidance, the Committee is at a disadvantage with respect to assessing the backfit implications of the rule and was concerned about the implementation aspects of this rule. Therefore, CRGR requested the opportunity to review the associated regulatory guide and inspection guidance when they are available.
2.
The Committee believes that the different components of this rulemaking identify a seamless process, each step of which is necessary. Thus, this rulc change must be considered in its entirety. The proposed amendments taken integrally are definite improvements both in the regulatory process as well as in the use of staff resources, and net relaxations in requirements. The Committee recommended going forward to the Commission with these amendments.
i 3.
The Committee also noted that if individually considered, various elements of this rulemaking may be interpreted as backfits because they will either require the licensees j
to modify existing procedures or codify voluntary actions not previously required by the I
NRC's regulations. Therefore,in parallel with developing the guidance documents, the Committee recommended consideration of the need to make clear if a burden reduction is associated with specific subsections (namely (2) vil and (2) viii), and if the Regulatory Analysis should b od 1 l. %g 6
9909030043 990602 PDR REVGP fWtGCROR gr MEETING 341 PDR I
[
. J In accordance with the EDO's July 18,1983 directive concerning " Feedback and Closure of CRGR Review," a written response is required from the cognizant office to report agreement or disagreement with the CRGR recommendations in these minutes. The response is to be
{
forwarded to the CRGR Chairman and if there is disagreement with the CRGR recommendations, to the EDO for decision making.
Questions concerning these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi (415-7584).
Attachments: As stated cc w/atts.:
CommisJion (5)
SECY M. Knapp, DEDE F. Miraglia, DEDO J. Lieberman, OE H. Bell, OlG l
K. Cyr, OGC 8
J. Larkins, ACRS e
L. Reyes, R-Il
{
H. Miller, R-l J. Dyer, R-Ill E. Merschoff, R-IV C. Paperiello, NMSS A. Thadani, RES
{
S. Collins, NRR D. Matthews, NRR i
I l
l
I j
,, June 2, 1999 Jn accctrdance with the EDO's July 18,1983 directive concerning " Feedback and Closure of CRGR Review," a written response is required from the cognizant office to report agreement or disagreement with the CRGR recommendations in these minutes. The response is to be forwarded to the CRGR Chairman and if there is disagreement with the CRGR recommendations, to the EDO for decision making.
Questions concerning these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi (415-7584).
Attachments: As stated cc w/atts.:
Commission (5)
SECY i
M. Knapp, DEDE F. Miraglia, DEDO J. Lieberman, OE H. Bell, OlG K. Cyr, OGC J. Larkins, ACRS H. Miller, R-l L. Reyes, R-!!
J. Dyer, R-Ill E. Merschoff, R-IV C. Paperiello, NMSS A. Thadani, RES S. Collins, NRR D. Matthews, NRR Distribution (w/atts.)
BSheron JJohnson, Ril JJohnson, OCM MFederline MVirgilio JMoore WKane BMallett EMcKenna CCarpenter GMizuno FAkstulewicz MMiller GWest DISK / DOCUMENT NAME: C:\\CRGR99\\ MINUTES \\MTS-341.WPD To receive a copy. indicate *C* = Copy wio attadvnent/endosure. *A* = Copy with attachment /endosure *N* = No copy NO MARK w NO COPYI OFC CRGR C
C CRGR C
kL, n n
NAME RTnpattu JM
[/ 0 /99 k 199 2
DATE OFFICIAL RECOND COPY 4
/
~
)
c Minu. s of CRGR Meeting No. 341, May 6,1999
\\
a
\\
..a:
.r.
~ :.pO;+ g$
kb $ N..:,, k +,9 N@;N.. ~,hjf)ly w-3xy,.7;[g@$;NNI.
','..', p.Usty '
Y!
X
>y,ug(:l y.
c.-
,,- rw r;(i., @.
Jggk;..L,,ng.
axth d qi u n w..t a:
CRGR MEMBERS NRC Staff J. Murphy (Chairman) f D. Matthews, NRR B. Mallett for J. Johnson (via tele,conferencing)
E. McKenna, NRR i
W. Kane for B. Sheron C. Carpenter, NRR M. Virgilio G. Mizuno, OGC M. Federline F. Akstulewicz, NRR e
J. Moore M. Miller, OCM CRGR STAFF R. Tripathi G. West (on detail) t ATTACHMENT 1
)
i Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 341, May 6,1999 i
9 w
I e
PRESENTATION MATERIAL USED BY THE STAFF
)
I ATTACHMENT 2
l lj i
c$*
Y q4
,d D
N
'A 84 no 2
i t
7 a
lu o
9 g
5S e
,f R
.N 0
r 5 O9 o
WR 9 t IT9 ca FC1 e
D CE
,R
)$
2_
0 ya S6 r
Da e
1 sN R T
. r l
EMc u OA N
l
.s g
FL f
E o
G R e
N c
i I
f K
fO AM EL UR e
0 0
6 1
4 y
ro 5
a f
s 0
M 8
drl 9
9 s
a a 9
9 t
v e
w o Y
s 1
r r
op C
M 1
f E
p 2
8 S
R D
8 a
r-S 9
9 N
9 n
e n
1 o
b 9 i
e U
o1 d
2l i
,s t
e u
O 0
s c
d h
r 1
r cl O2 1 i R
ym a
r a
a n
2 w
Mf d
r G
um ee l
i r
K J
o hb o
gf dC s
m f
o C
n i
l e
s er b
il c
n f
a A
af e
o et t
o u
B d
p it i
r e
D t
b m
i e
a l
1 g
d nb 7
u lu n
n ou r
1 r
i d
d e
iss d
8 e
e n m
s r
9 s
s e
o i
m mf
-Yo o
Cp ps o
me o
oy c
t r
a e
o a
Er Sp Pd R
Cd e
e e
e
1 l1!
K S-
~
s T
N ET N
OC 3
E n
L o
U i
ta R
z in a
L i
a r
A g
e t
s r
i
~
N o
r e
~
C g
I d
n F
s n
a n
n a
o h
o i
i t
c t
t a
a i
r m
n u
e i
l r
f a
h o
e v
t F
D E
O e
e e
e
r o
ir p
tu s
o t
h n
t i
e V
m w
I
)C e
t s
S H
a e
S t
s G
s a
U e
e_
y t
r c
l t
u O
a c
n s
r n
e e
R a
u r
i q
p l
H e
a t
e n
s m
r T
f e
4 i
(
r o
n e
I t
i s
f n
m e
f A
i i
g d
t n
I i
s a
a R
p l
w h
E s
h o
c t
T a
l i
l I
r a
g w
i R
e n
t e
id n
C i
l r
u r
o s
c r
o i
t l
g d
a w
c n
e v n
r s o u
i i
r o
f ts vp n
la ix ep i
E R
a M
M e
e e.
e W
9 s
d is s
e r
na t
e ob imlt
)
e a
i i
l i
h i
r
(
t s
o
)
i 2
n sad
(
i
)
ad b
e l
d
(
e n
e l
9 n
i V
5i ge
.f i
0 e
s c
ex D
5 d d
e A
N gas g
n A
n
)
y i i i
i st v
e t
b e
l
(
i i
xf V
e a
ns 5
r s
o e
r i
A of er r i r
f o
I t
a i
R a
n r b c
i ~i E
g t
rer r
c T
t a
o u
ir f
IR cm d
la o
C t
n s
r ni" p
o e
nS pn mot oo eit r i ccy ps au n
s f
i a
f f lpd e er a
r R "r o t
o f
Sf e
e
s d
os h
e e
t s
e ey su mla o
n r
i n
d n
a e
e ts o
v d
i y
i n
s i
t t
at e a
e s
t a
uf v
n la a
r o
i v
s e
t
)
s r
d e n n
o d
i f
t o
o e
r n
t c
C p
o o
s s
R o
l t
N e
e s
c ge l
(
s u
v n
s y
e a
b e
b d
n 6
a A
h f
r d
eo cn s
e b
t i
I i
R glas v
a r
E ois vle o
ot T
eon er t
n f
nd ump d
e r
I p
p em R
o h pd a
a ee i
s s
r C
ei ao nl m
t h
ed p
l ibCt h o
l l
r i
c aR et h wi t
t sNmye t
l m
en a
e l
l n
gd a
c e
o onei nt t
a s
t i
s i
n ai r
t i
i id uvet d
s d
o n
eqes i
r s n u
o d
s e
Gc Aur e
e e
4
s r
t e
r d al P
o n
y h
e r
c e
oe n
wR e
f t
s a
t t
nic eA s
m i
oi bS s
f t
n is r
yd o
v e
c n c
i c
na e
S e
s r
d t
i l
E en s
o h
r i
t l
U b
a st as n
n e
S e
o o
v r
S e
c c
e aps i
r e
h l
mn eg c
2 o
e t
n a
7 7
cic a
a e
o h
l r
t dI gc T
eS e
r R
dF t
l h
o u
uS f
r A
cI u
d g(
l P
no o2 e
i t
s7 s
e e
i sd v
l l
ub n
e r
a e
r r
a t
)
d c
s n0 g
i el e
a s
p 5
n h
op m
it s
a f
pa mt f
r d a
o2 o
ap t
rP7 CP u
S e
e
s k
y t
s t
i r
a l
a i
c b
P f i e
ot r
a os t
p f
o r
p am s
r po S
s u c
ep s
E c
ar U
ol o
a sf r
S pu e
d g1 S
or n7 s
l I
r o
at d t
r f
1 n
h r
oy ca a
P d 7
cl r
n r
a er a
T el d
ot gu f
s i
R nc s
8 ngn i
at A
r on o
h i
a ck P
c i
t p
aa l
t l
mt D
h
),
i r
w eo gn E
p uo d
u s
l T
oit nr n
s a
A ad a
t s
r s er L
r o
en t
E ep enA t
R n
s r
aE e
n gl a
apA mr I
f r
m (t f
eh o1 ah t
i t
t C7 S ow e
e ll!ll l
j1 l
1 l
]
~
I ec 0d r
n 5
n
,i ae e
a t
ch d
ran n t 2 r
iu P
o a
o7 o
g f
i n
r sd t t
w oii s
r l
vu a
oa f
t t
egn o
icn er oPl l
r ni oa l
eet u
ooit s pmn r
v o
i f
N s
e f
ent e
t nl a
ipm owt r
or O
e i
d p p n
onf s
eoi t
I o
ol va l
T nul a mne l
a s
e t
i A
- v aoeoR s
)
h T
7 ne t
t l
i 0iod n
pt a
.t e nmt g
n N
E 6
ad mioin o
t s
n d
eim t
9 c
e e
a n
nmi M
i l
f e
pc a6t l
ia e
i E
Ed n
r n
mlb npt l
t e
L No s
u
~i u
r P
mi s piomo om
(
e f b p
e t
d t i r
c ao M
cei n ee e
l d
r i nic et e
l p
nd e
a u
a mf l
sn ae v
a s
d qf ur 2 msi es d e
e n
i nd ohf ce g e7 ct ol i
r ee umc gct en r
owodeman r
nn r
a a
me cod i
f f
t P
f sd a
d oci i
r 2
v ii t
u xu o
e nr e
E gf S1 r
apr g
e e
~
k'
~
s a
n n
i o
e si b
n t
f o
d a
t i
i nl o
t o
s e
ei n
l r
mv e
c d
v s
n mo u
e o
r l
idi l
of o
t y
ec c n w
t e
s a
o i
r r
i r
u f
t e
e t
T f
e t
v
,n N
ar t
e ge t
c a
s nim E
s s
s m
t ed ed e
i M
,d c
d ef u eb nc l
l ar ot p
r c
at o
i E
in st ut sf 0
r C
e nd d p r n
e a
1 R
pm ee e
e e
e s
r cd e
cmi i
e vf cnm O
n c
f i
or cc eoa u
o F
io er s
r r
t esif N
af e
po e
ci m
n c
s nhi f
t E
ne n
t t
n n
i ef a
s e coh a
r ait r
e moc t
er md i
f b
ca i
paf e
enf i
i r
o n
r lpon cr g
sf u
egd d i
mt u
n o
n ais ennnio i
u di a
gn a
oiy g t
niw l
i r
r t
nr y
r t
o ef ao e
c oi r
nl pel cd f i
l r
o n
o u
of a
i Dco P
v u
p e
e
s d
n g
n o
n i
i a
st w
a a
dlo e
c t i c
f nl i
o f i n
k af r
ea cl s
n a
S
_hd ac d
e i
I t
u b
r S
es od f
g r
r o
a Y
a c
u f
L s
o t
eb t
os r
A ce n
e n
(
a c
g ni N
pn s
n on i
a A
ma eh ci i
t o
u i
l t
s u
c e
c d
s r
l Y
u ni e
lod 1
R a
d s
s c
1
,n e
u n
e O
s o
s a
o n
r ei ici o
v T
ut et i
c e
a t d l
A a
a x
a e
r b v
t 9 a
ms L
o a
s l
0 e
r U
d n
h r
o e
r n
e t 1 r f f
G eo s0l nd o
e i
d t
i i
E d
s 5 b R
s eg n
n aa i
i s
t o )g n nv n
on s
i i i e
i oit k s
s n
caa ud m
m t
i er ct l
nm cne a
ol r
e f
r fa ee nip p p p f
o er mem t
t lu l
S ar Cd o
r i i
e e
e
S I
l Minutes of CRGR Meeting No. 341, May 6,1999
\\
f CRGR MEMORANDUM TO THE EDO, DATED MAY 10,1999 4
ATTACHMENT 3 O