ML20210D065
| ML20210D065 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/19/1999 |
| From: | Marlone Davis NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Carpenter C NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9907270119 | |
| Download: ML20210D065 (50) | |
Text
I
)
@ Wu o'
UNITED STATES
$)
U E
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION E
WASHINGTON, D.C. 2055% 0001 g*****/
July 19,1999 MEMORANDUM TO: Cynthia A. Carpenter, Chief Generic issues, Environmental, Financial, and i
Rulemaking Branch
['
Division of Regulatory improvement Programs f
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation I
ped
]
O FROM:
Michael J. Davis, Project Manager 1
'j
\\
1 Generic Issues, Environmental, Financial, and
/j Rulemaking Branch
,P Division of Regulatory improvement Programs Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MAY 25,1999, MEETING BETWEEN THE NRC STAFF AND GENERAL ELECTRIC ON TRACG METHODOLOGY FOR 3
APPLICATION TO BWR TRANSIENT EVENTS 1
On May 25,1999, members of the staff met with General Electric Nuclear Enginqering (GE) representatives to discuss the program plan and schedule for NRC review of the TRACG thermal hydraulic methodology. A list of attendees of the May 25,1999, meeting and their affiliations is provided as Attachment 1. A non-proprietary copy of the handout provided by GE for their presentations is provided as Attachment 2.
The TRACG methodology was originally submitted for the Standardized Boiling Water Reactor (SBWR) some years ago, and, after several rounds of questions and answers (RAls), the review was put on hold. GE now wishes to reopen the TRACG review for the DWR-2 through BWR-6 only, not for the SBWR. The scope of the review requested is for BWR transients only (Anticipated Operational Occurrences -AOOs), with no review of containment response or LOCA/ECCS analysis originally included in the submittal for the SBWR.
GE commented that the use of the TRACG code for transient analysis would benefit the industry by providing a single computer code for integrated analysis, more realistic prediction of plant transient response, and better quantification of margin and uncertainty.
GE plans to issue Revision 2 to the Model Licensing Topical Report (LTR), NEDE-32176P, and
)
Revision 2 to the Qualification LTR, NEDE-32177P, which will incocporate past RAls and delete SBWR models and qualification studies. These documents are scheduled for issuance ir October 1999. Also, an Application LTR, NEDC-32900P,"TRACG Licensing Application Framework for AOO Transient Analyses," was issued on June 19,1999. GE is requesting a 4
safety evaluation report (SER) solely on the Application LTR by July of 2000. The stMf
/Q./
commented that it would have to enumerate the limited scope of the review contained in the p
SER.
noon gg%1I %'"
h 9907270119 990719 l Q
, pJ '.- 1 h b PDR TOPRP ENVGENE f
C PDR gh
E i
o m
C. Carpenter 2
July 19,1999 Another meeting with ine staff is p!anned for July 15,1999, to discuss the review process for the App;ication LTR.
The staff commented that a draft regulatory guide and standard review plan on thermal hydraulic code reviews were being prepared for issuance this fall. The regulatory guide is a joint effort with the Office of Research. The staff is now able to run the computer codes and is performing numerous in-house reviews in this area (vice ebtaining technical assistance).
Reviews in this area are now handled quite differently than in the past.
GE next briefed the staff on a draft of the Framework Application LTR document. The staff commented that the LTR needs to show how the TRACG code meets applicable requirements and to demonstrate that the modelis capable of simulating events and applicable operating 1
The staff expressed some concern about the proposed review schedule, but committed to work with GE to keep the review moving forward. The schedule will be further defined at the July 15,1999, meeting.
Attachrrants: As stated cc w/atts: See next page
l b
C. Carpenter '
-2.
July 19,1999 Another meeting with the staff is planned for July 15,1999, to discuss the review process for the Application LTR.
The staff commented that a draft regulatory guide and standard review plan on how to perform thermal hydraulic code reviews were being prepared for issuance this fall. The regulatory guide is a joint effort with the Office of Research. The staff is now able to run the computer codes and is doing a lot of in-house reviews in this area (vice contracting out reviews). Reviews in this area are r.ow handled quite differently than in the past.
GE next briefed the staff on a draft of the Framework Application LTR document. The staff l
commented that the LTR needs to show how the TRACG code meets applicable requirements
- and demonstrate that the modelis capable of simulating events and applicable operating transients.
The staff expressed some. concern about the proposed review schedule, but promised to work with GE to keep the review moving forward. The schedule will be further defined at the July 15,1999, meeting.
Attachments: As stated cc w/atts: See next page DISTRIBUTION: See attached page Document Name:g\\RGEB\\m]d1\\MTSUM525.wpd
- c;ng provinns concurrences OFFICE RGEB#*
SC:SRXB f*
BC:SRXB *f SC:RGJpg BZa[crh NAME MDavis:sw RCaruso JWermiel DATE 7/15/99 7/15/99 7/19/99 7//$/99 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
- WE PREWCd5 l
l
, LIST OF ATTENDEES AT MEETING WITH GE ON TRACG METHODOLOGY IN ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND ON MAY 25,1999 -
NAME AFFILIATION M. Davis NRC/NRR J. Klapproth
_GE J. Andersen
.GE C. Heck
.GE B. Shiralkar GE T. McIntyre GE~
R. Caruso NRC/NRR G. Thomas NRC/NRR U.Shoop NRC/NRR -
R. Landry NRC/NRR J. Staudenmeier NRC/NRR/SRXB J. Mitchell NRC/OEDO M. Razzaque NRC/NRR/SRXB l
ATTACHMENT 1 i
i t
n y
em g
hc r
a e
tt n
A E
rae lcuN E
G a
dneg A
d R
n yW a
gB C
o R
o N
n lot s h
t St o
dn n Uo oo e
op r
i t
hi v
t p t
'c te aE na u
Mitc l
oiK n
t d
p l
o G pi aF e
9 t
99 n s r
CAs 1
e e t
Ar n
5 s
a em 2
n Ror y
r a a
TFT PJ M
I
2 n
0 o
0 3
o 3
1 N
9 1
0 0
0 3
0 3
1 9
9 1
s tn e
i s
s e
n ss a
r e
T c
s o
R m
rP W
yg e
t d
B o
i e
l s
s s
o o
n t
t d
o e
oh v
p g n s o
i t
h c
t i
ol on i
t t
t e
e A
r i
c h
eP g
a m M
d jf i
e n
b oH c
a e
n n i
nO wle pE lt it a
l l
o i
d u
n o g e u
p w
a o
ini vd A eOc t
n i
ci r
e s
t i
u e
eh GivR p s
l e
d e v
c C
eT p u
oMOS A RL A c
g r
s R
t i
n T
D A
I e
e
3 w
o e
i t
v n
e o
y R
i t
go G
a c
C lo i
lp d
A a
p o
R n
A h
T i
t G
e C
s C
M R
t 0
l A
w N
u0 R
e S
s0 T
v U
e2 i
R d
e r
y e
R o
t l
au i
s r
o n
P hJ p
o t
f y
o s
o n
sb s
r e
o e
s P
g e
eR i
v h
~a a
cE e
t l
r u
s d
e d
o i
t S
e n
v e
r t
fos e
e h
P c
y e
wl m
L c
C e n m
d S
aR a
j f
b vA o
e d
oN i
r c
s e
eg e
o s
t O
vn R
r p
o o
p a
Ois r
t g
n n E
o S
P r
a e G
n c
e P
i t
eL n
b w
i t
d e
e ir iR s
c e
v i
s v
e oW e
e e
r r
PB P
D R
M
4
)
O OA
(
e s
p ec o
ne c
rr S
u 6
c c
w R O Wl e
B a
i n
v h
o gi t
e u
a r
o e
R r
h p
O R
t n
2 W
d o
R e
?
B Wa e
S t
i t
r p
p e
a Bi s
s o
c oinR oi c
et n
s o
cy pW t
plyA Sl sB i
a l
n e
p on o
nAR A c
ot o
p i
S t
S n
n t
t n
o o
oC A
e n
C a
a NE mio i i nt t
t n
i c
c
/i a
G sl sA a
c i i l
i t
p p iC n
p l
i C
t p p t Oo p
aAA aL CA A
h h
R W-W-
T
5 es s
n e
e o
dd p
ooc s
G Cn e
r e
R C
e e
s wn A
t t
o n
utei t R
pb a
e s
i z
T mni s
r o
n o
y n
t t
oia c
n p g a
t a
f Cir i
r F
a r
o o
T t
c r
esl y
e g
l n
a t
t e
ga n
c c
n l
i i
y a
nk s
nt b a
r s
p U
a i
l u
st s
P O a
m a
a O
C d
s n
n e
y ad foA o
t c s n
ai n
or o
a
~ni s b
gi r
o ns pt nt P
l c
a ig e
oe r
f l
y
/
is o ou s
s r
d i
r g
t n
a t
r r
d i
t Ue ge co m
M e
nR i
p s
i s
d s
yL r i/
s od s
fo a
u f
n s
eet g
b t
i r
e sl ay r
f n
n d
yat a
Pl ai k
l s
a st o
s i
l r
n n
a t
n an eA cot i
i r
t r
/
n e
a nted a
p c
o I
i i f
t t
o nf t
o Ap a
sral i
pO n
f ut i
i S
e t
o l
t d
ed apd d ni t
o e
e at et en a
a v
a e
v v
u c
s t
n r
t aioP Re o
o l
Ql i
r r
r r
mp p
t i
p p t
f r
p gi m.
ee mm eA e
eEI l
r BI I
t o
e t
n t
M-n B
e I
B
6 te kco D
R ep GW o
o c
CB t
s w
AS s
w ee r
t R
e n
e h
igv Td e
v i
e e a c
n m
t f
Rn r
u a
o u
n a
d o
s eP c
Cv i
t r
ww76 o
o Rd p
ee1 d
n i2 N A p
v v3 P d
n i
l 7
er E 7 e
o r
e a
o i
A Rd D1 E t
a iu t
t 2
r t i
E 3 G m
m Pu n
w CaN E r
eM y
b s
o D
Rd R ~E b
u ef e
NteT sin gr N d s
n au i
t L e
s i
eO v
s mnoR v
yo u
r p
i l
e ubiT e
s s
vo o
t e
ouipL c
u e
v c
n e
r n
et R
r s
i o
a L
s o r
I s
i et et s
vat r
i g
a r
nD A
eR x
l c
P el e
i n
md r
f el i R p e a
e n
o u d
i t
u s
o cMQ C eu e
l l
R s
c e
oa n
d D
N vInD i
l e
iu e
c B
R iL e
7 s
tne isna rT O
OA ro f
n kro S S x.
T E w
N I N
L 3 pg EL G
A ME e
C d RC e
NS
$eau.
I E
ED Ao m
EO IR U RC TD m$
UG T
N Q D a
I E N r
k R A F
n v
o r
i i
tac i
lp p
A GCART
^
no o
t 8
i t
r a
a c
l t i i
py mty
-ek nl epg is e mao f
n h a l
o ut o cSi di cnd t
a 0 oe o oNa
,1ih u
d 3l!
dish rYl n
5;pN v
p nt pD a a
=%p l
n e ia e l
v ii R Wt m AOE
,MM!
r n
}
}
o f
y i
tug o
l ol so s
ed e
Ro C
9 s d
h i
l I
R 9 A u
t Ae
/
t N
9RR S RM y
d sWn b
eeBo sin ut d
saSt o
i e
r a
wi s
t w
osc ea i
2 epef i
1 e
ic r t i vi v v v b olela i
e e e o ceu elp RTiDQ Rp n
R R yA r
h a
C 9 s
,6 li c
R 9 A m
l
/
a N
9RR i r y
d sW P
o b
eeB r
d saS ut p
e r
s w
os s i
1 2
epele p
e r t v v v b oled i
A e e eo ceo R R RTInDM 1
1 l
9 E
t i5%
~
~
~
ll llllll 9
9 9
9 9
0 0
0 0
O 9
9 9
9 9
9 0
0 0
0 O
9 T
T T
C C
N R
R N
L LU C
C C
E E
A A P
U U
J 0 0 O
D D
J M A J
J 6
1 1
3 3
9 4
8 7
8 e
l llllll 2
0 0
1 1
2 1
2 2
2 l
9 9
9 9
9 9
0 0
0 0
9 9
9 9
u 9
9 0
0 0
0 Y
Y Y
Y T
C N
R R
N A
A A A C
E A A P
U d
M M M M
0 D
J M A J
5 5
5 5
2 4
0 5
9 8
2 2
2 2
1 3
1 2
2 e
l 0
ll1lll e
h lu rk d
o e
w 2
c h
e v
c S
m e
/
a R
R S
k r
T F
P 2
L to 6
w n
7 v
y o
1 e
g e
2 R
lo n
e o
d m
3 c
7
..a m
C 7
d io r
o F
2 h
ta D
1 e
c.
E 3
t w
t u
N e
n 3
t C
M ie e
R nn R
D n
e e
S R
v s
1 2
3 E
so do T
t t
t E
io r
e e
e E
C L
N t
R P
S S
S s
S t
t n
a e
E e
e e
a la f
n e
io R ic c G s
s s
r in T
n p
L l
n t
a n
n n
D o
p ic c
c F
k e
ir n
o o
o s
n e io A
tp g
s p
p p
e t
a s
e M
s s
s u
e K
o t
d c
e e
e s
u a
r C
e D ic is e
c C R
R R
s E
M le i
A R
ls J
a 8
8 is f
r A
C d
la n
C k
i A
C C
E R
o u a
R E
I A
I R
R A
P r
G N M Q T
N G R R
R N
N E
E EEE E.,
0 1
no n
i t
a a
lP c
i l
w p
e p
n A
i o
ve t
i t
n g
a R
c e
ni i
h s
il t
t p
ni n
t e
p e
w a
e A me T
r M
g u
c e
f n
c n sG f
n oi o
el aC o
k s
r nD A
r t
c t
ek uiR t
s i
e K c
r c mT o
n i
l M CL wob i
r t
u s
Ri eC Sf o e
N m mC
/
b R
R n
E u
aR TE r
o GSF NL S
t se l
i M
0 9
0 y
e 9
9 9
9 0
t e
a 9
9 9
/2
//
/0
/
K D
5 6
7 1
7
ygrenE rae
~
lcuN EG yg o
lo d
o h
t e
M s
nton C
ie t
R i
a s Nn c
in e
a os l
t r pr e
pT n d o
A R k
in taAc GW t
.e nMH CB e
99 Ar s
9 eGL 1
Ro y
r a
TF PJC M
l
2 s
)s t
t n
n e
e s
is e
is n
sy n
a l
r a
a T
n r
(
A T
t s
s n
t e
e n
R c
s 2 e
i i
n n
n s
W e
a o
n r
s s
a i
r Ti2 e.
B r
r T
v n s u
Oe o
y r
c y
ORil O
r s
a O
o c
o N
A
,i 6 v n
t f
O n
Y 7
eA A
r e
G a
v D
o R
R l
f 1
t n
O k 2 n
n e
r 3 7,e Ws s
t C
or i
n o
7 s
'B t
i r
t e o wE n
e u
n r f
1 n
A i
i t
s a u eD2 a oie s
d r
s n
a s
t t
lo a e mE 3 R
n a
r e
T Ga r
er o r T
pP wC e v aNE T
O C r o
p o r
T r
F R E O A
O
,D 6 OoF r
ro mp e
p nT N A R O O
f
/
l o
5 T O A
t t
/ d c e aTA c
oL r
A r
4 ea i
r t
n
,o o
f n
/ t e o et y
a oRf o
or f
nl 3
aRCR ciTR nf y
t o
a n
/
i t
g 2
p n n n o e p pL T oG o
l l
i i
i
/
i C
l iii r
nL aA p r t
t c
o r o
Ri e e eC u A
c a
s o n
c d
c Wtna a a e
s s s R
o C
g et o i
i l
Bare e e r s nD ai pT h
t t
i c a pf e
r r
o a n
sl i
l o
f c
A nM i
c c c p
e e eC s o ed a p poil it n
el i
er y i
l t
i o n t
p DDD n
ni c o u p
f o
t o
b ai i
A
///e e
aLiMQA cR t
v t
ic a a
e e e s
cf i i c E
nGGGGSEi la p s s s a lp l
a a a e
e eCCCC S
p u p mmAAAA weAQA se e e r e
st r
r r c c c c e a uRRRR e
n t
n n n nDS cTTTT vO*
i p
n eI I
I a
o v
o e
l c
PE D
R S
ill
!l!
3 lo r
t k
no ic r
ta C
pz w
it F
ro o
d s
l l
l o
p F
m o
r o
n A
t o
o e2 n
ni L
a m o
i t
u r n
a D e C
F l
o u
w r o i
e c t
c pi o
r a
r o n l
oE i
u c
C F
l c
e
, 1 2
n r
R
/ k 1
e o
ic r
k e i
r t
lo icC e
ol t e w a
R e
l c s ain p u
t r n u o c
l H
a eo B i
r r
n nM
, /3 2
c) r e
e, / 2 eD e
Gn1 m RS o a tx
/r ls n o t
t eA i nt E
l a o oMh B
v(
1 t
h o mu c a
l n
, eh s2 o
t a
et t
Miq Vvin n
i r
w lg s e ol i
i uP PC i
hPS t n i2 3,
e, hr 1
st ef, e
iDl l
t t
i u
/
M G w/
wd nio 1 2 k
/ n aP s1 a ed siyY sein e
n e
l Pl t i r t
t eN a i
t r
M nC e n r
np2 G F o pe ad m
- aSPd, n
i l
a s mN P
r l
u n e n
u QwV pen e
WB o
l k
4 p3 6
pb P e
/
r 2
, r m/B/
5 ma/e
/
2 e
2 1
v 2
t 3
r 1
n2 k
/
t i
s
/eC
/
ue/
u sleR Rj R Pd h ic R
Pula y 1
r e
r t
s c e nts Wt et m Wt n
woo r
jS r y
r a i d a e eDHL e
L P a
B N
B J
B JA l
P
4 g
g n
n i
is w
)
sa a
r e
e o
e l
r s
r f
c s
c ee u
d e
ee n
v v t
e d
laa e
vv r
a v v i
l l
aa a
s l
e vv r
e e
ru nn lu nn p
r poo c
l s
k oo ia oi it ia m
in pp f
aii ot f
et l
l la a e
(
t mm a a r
l r
l r
ppuof cc lenuu T7 e uu eeb uu r n r
l l
oc c t
oir r t guo n l
C nnit ai z r r t ic ic i
io r r nnl t i ooenh c c nl ee at ia ct i
t a
S wi af e c t i sos ee ur r l
o oer je t
r r wc c
a nj A
ol la pc peo eo oh e in r
o n w r
l uumwmnw wc ot Ce loSI A
i l
i T
F l
c c r r u ouot F
r CC E
/
eiipf pf f lo e l
r f f t
oo eatnP P c c ooe ef e r woHH C
r N
oreennn g
r nl gg od ct A
r ooo ee a oodinn t
Y Ceoiii uuk Ct Ce r r N
t t
t i f in in e eee A
r n n notnwla a a s s c
a o ee nf t t t
o D
P l
l l
uuuool nupp p if a r r i
c c c c cb ic uoo e owee it l
l f f h
eoor r r r
O sppc c c s s v v w
ei t t s sd d d w
t iii t t r
o sc a s s s e aiieeea al et aa a oe a a r r n n d
r eTTRRRFFF aRSF F eL F e
r e
r I
I o
z c
r c
y f
e - - - - - - - -
c - - - -
e - - - - - la D
n D
n d
A I
e vo rp p
s
)
A m
n
)
w w
y c
io a
o r
lo t
y f
l c
yf r
s d
l e
r d o
e t
n n
oe t
s n
s io n
e t
s n
a c
e l
na e
e v
e a
it o
s s
v a
ee v
r p
d r t t c y
e o
d l
v v c r n
r e r
n a s
nnta r
b s
pr r i
ad e ev I
t e
r o
lo o eg r
I i( S t
s u
s(
pf m/ml a
t n
e e wr l
u oe np nrep ec
/
u C
s a
r r a
s wr i
u o
eleoy aul m u
l eu nf -
s r lo d
r ib r
oiu nil s s niu u os r eu t
l aP owaf a
oa l
f af s
esif l
ci n e r ia e
or o of iat r y Copr a
a a w P
r at r a
P pc ef vl r f
g p g Cer l
ie y el r r ot o j l r r n n
l a
r f
r lo t
l b eo oes r p ooioi r loi or r
s o
r r e p r t
t n
n or il t
t si ey a
S t
t t
o t
a newr cl e e
t t
x ca mt pD p c n u c/d nluen oia n
e epl c en l
pi egoA o a oA awuo n
a wa ogdi l
au mC
'R et t t e c ed pc o
x t
r n R e u
r n nn R e e r r r r r r o v
Ri e ee ote ec e n e eee aA a t
nf t
t t
t t t
t E
net a a r f t
f f i
r r r na r i f a a r
inr w uos oo u eee i
s es v v v v
e oww we i
s eb ed s s ns s ssd d d ed d s sdd e
sr n e e si s s s ee a u e er o a oo a e a a a se a a oe e t
n n n a e r
n me TGF PL MLL EPI I
I n
eL F F F
r e
r I
r c
r c
e a
c - - - - - - - -
e - - - -
c - - - e - - -
S D
n D
n v
e I
i e
E
w 5
C C
P 6
R R
7 n
N N
1 o
2 i
3 ta y
y E
ic b
b D
lp E
p s
d d
N A
u e
e d
)
n R
a w
w T
t
)
a L
1 e
e i
i t
v.
m
(
t r
e m
S v
v o
R e
e p
e w
R R
R 7
e l
7 1
a 2
c 1
3 i
1 ip o
E v
v v
T D
e e]
e]
g E
R R [1 R [2 i
N n
(
s n
n e
o l
ic i
2 L
ta 1
l c
i s
e w
e
's li
)
i f
E 6 t
a c
l n
n c
a G9 u
9 n
Q e
2o-n 2
i
(
1 r
e
.iE e
s t
i'c 5, G
m e
r nvt r
C nv t ly e
eie aD eie a
c u r
A f
c f
eJ R
edRiE edR M
lE f 6 r
T i
f a
u Re i N Re e
o9 qs s P,l 2
s P, y la r 9
a r
r eA w1 e e ms 6u n ms7 a
ns e
e iv r n e
e m i7 or7Qd e or7 s
t Ge e2 t
i rd1 e
n yl R e rd1 f
t r e eR s
n oy f
f l
f i
d2ad d2 rd u
e od s
f wS ta J, s a3 pe a3n u P, g
- ov ie r t i m
au g
o S
)s ol s
t foR m
uG neEic7 nee r
e c o
R l
a T.
ib P
t e
s gd d
Din 7 ib D m
f R u1 di d
f nliE Ee t
t ta
(
t o
e n 1
a o s
l nliEd e2 l
S S
r t
C Ra FwNAb3 FwN GR i
i
,d
)
e
. o Et Ep p a
e Gl GR e
n R
(
( l n
n a c
o n1 ini y
iu n u
p i
o t
e n
ip g
Qo QT i
o Ei E g s
r v
n o
c n
l
. e
. is o
R J
J s
o d
t n,
t p
o o n t
i e
n i
t e
c t
o a
a
)
o i.
o e
c D
h Ci C1
)
t c
Rip R) c m
eP t
0 i
P e
Nr N.
i l
l f
a7 M
(
w p
(
v i
S e
p d 6 y e ye l
aD aR E
Ak o7 u7 l
u u.
l n
Qe Q8 w
go M1 Q2 o
R. d
. 1 r
1 ir R
7 2
2 f
w nw G-G-
a i
. A 3
3 T. C T, 3 t
e e
se CE CE c
G E
i e
teD r
r i
i v
v nm AD AD p
- e. I L(
A E
i t
l t
R ten e
e e
c a RE RE p
I 2
I r
R LF TN TN A
i R
L
6 dep s
o e
l s
e y
d v
1 1
e e
la sD s
v v
n e
e eA r
y R
R d
g t
f f
n d
o l
o o
9 9
e Ao 9
w 9
wi s
d s
o 9
e 9
e n
nh t
i i
1 1
v v
a et e r
e r
e rT m
e r
e r
mM R
b b
s T
mR mRO C
CO on R
L o
e e
Ci N
N A T
np p
t t
t t
L oe mR e mr c
wac o
e ei iS oTS of p
t i
l f
L r
r v
p o
p f
x f
2 2
R e
e p ir s
n sT RA t
t e
c v
n ov nL o
t l
n s
e ei e
e t
l a
An t
n t
eR mar m
o9 i
e D
l h
i c
miP mi9 t
s u
P ofi7 o
a9 w
n t
le6 f
a O
d 7
c c1 7
c l
o r
1 s
a1 sl T
i r
/
o2 e
u2 e
p e s
s s
pb s
e M3 sQ3 w
sA mt p
l n
E e
G eG E e
e e
m r
r D
D Gt t
d d
p n a
C E d CE i
d C e
o x
v ANAANAAS cE re R
R R
v T
T T
O e
7 s
tne isna r
T O
OA ro f
w)z k
r
- I o
S S n
T E w
[o N N
. Ni?nQ -
L I
EL A
G NSNt S.
ME e
C d RC e
a r ED 3mt R U Ao m
EO RC T D )3nsM IUG T
N he a
Q D I
bh;s$b E N r
R A F
N' Ev' p
e n
s
.t o
[fv i
tac i
lpp A
GCA R
T
8 s
tg g
f.
Sc fE gi u
g ll yr d
te n
m a
y o
e tn l
t e
la a
e i
g b
s c
l i
s c
i t
o n
b n
i f
a a
g od l
f n
e l
i p
p s
t a
m s
al s s
s a
e e
e e r
l l
C d
ed s d o n r
o o
sd r
s ofri d
r o eh et mn a
omc a
l t
pl e
o C
or o c o
e u
oi o
d pMt t
t t
t l
o y a ys d yl ya ui e nial t
t c t
t M
ei al i
i s
l l
r b qbs aiu l
ie i
cbl b d u
aE ae s
ai r
ab i
G v
t p
pc pi e
pa l
c c
ai a o e
ad ai C
uC sCpd Ci mCe l
r n
r A
a o
u r
t R
s B
M N
e T
9 la
)
ir P
e t
6 a
7 M
s 1
y w
r 2
e a
i 3
t v
e e
ird R
E pe D
ov r
o o
r d
E Pm ir e N
Ee P
ss
(
GR me r
R od r
f d T
d A L
e s gt n
n n a e o
h m i
cn m
tp UoC ir e
c n w i
s e
l t
i e
e s
uv l
l l
D d
e n
e Oe od o
d R
i l
M o
t o
e l
a s sl e
cM aM v
l l
ei p ey ed e
d r i d on s
r t
n a l
L u uaim ob y oh oc m
l r
o o
i t
i i t
e h
c r t
n at Me st M
ud c eCc n
et g
n i
M i
n a o t n
l ei s
ot y u md pt r
i i
nl y
H r
t np e a f
iSHd a ct e a mK i
S n g af n
t o
c r
n ci nl n
l u
a a oe o u moiD oo e
s mCRl r
el e
d u
l eg e e p e e
r r
t n
od wd nd p mmet n l
r t
r u
r e
a a o oh el oR m ouh e
o o
nMTHF M MI CNTNC i
t l
t I
u 0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 O
1
0 1
's
'e E
"N L
A S
5 c
N i
E R
i E
'u T
E IN "4
s f
e o
i t
a n
s y
d t
i ae at t
D s
c n*
rb el R e
a ay cit l
t nwL eT u
n u
l n
c q
ei sy ys n
s drg e
da n eo o
t t
gs a
c a
t l
t e
e mfet d
ot aeo r
smd i
a A
Me e ao a
t T r
f srh a
oE D c
aat c
r sf f
f pe i
r n
b c
e mt o
o T M t
i t
n s
U eRn l
f S
eP e
a nl n
dI o i
e oPi l
f t
l l
id oa mda o
t a
nf sP t
E n
y t
ec i
u o
e eSle t o t
gki a
a n n np l
i t
n a
nM n e inap Q
a a
o a
c t
l i rA m
eyn f
i i
r c
p r mgS mG mi ia dl G
i h
f p
r n gd el rC r
oie l
i e
ot u
tA e e ihn C
aSCInF l
e t
t p cl a i
e lat A
u eR ex s
n r
R Q
DT DE Ao o
f c g
e
.e*
T l
/
/
la i re ta M
y s
)
r P
a w
t e
7 e
i ir d v
7 pe e
1 ov R
r 2
P r
o 3
m o
Ee id r
e E
GR P
ss D
mer E
od r
f d N
d A
(
e s gt R
n n
T a
e s
h m
L t
c s
s n
m n
et Uo s
T C
o e
e eT n
w i
t c
n i
s a
s nt o
e l
t i
c yt a
ci u
v t
g s e
f e
e mf a
Oe i
r f z
R T
i t
l i
a oE e
l l
a r
sf a
v t t r
u S
c e md e
eP e
o L
Q N
s h
n nf t
t s
n oiEof n
yt g
f it eS n
a o
i o
t t
H c
a e
n a
a s
i e
uict l
l a
oaP D u
d f r
p r l
n ol t
c i
pmgR a
n n
a t
u e oteWl o
i r
a l
tu nQSCInBP C I
O 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
2 1
s t
ne n
m o
S i
E t
e s
"l a
N u
L L
u A
l l,
N r
n l
gt E
^,
R a
"U E
r I gei v
T N
E D
o E
y N
yg j
t a
e o
l f
M a
o S do Nh y
Ye t
g DM o
O U s
l re o
oA te e
t t
d a
m d
a u a
r l
S
,t p
aC o
n a
o s a t
ic C
sD n it l
r e
a y h
m P t f
i r
i o
Tn r yC mh e
t t
i t
t r
i a o l
o yi i
e nl t n o S
w t
n eb s
t n
eP c i
f c
M a
at f
o e
a r
i c
ne a i
h t
t m
n h
Si ei t
ol e r
i c
ma pa R eL a
e P s l
l n
c nt ie a p r c p
,u n
mS c
t os l
f n a o
o noi sNi ol o
r i a
gi A n, m Cl Uic t
r u
p s i
i o s r t
t pn t
t eC ein e s,F c
s t
l i
r t
Ao n
e e ai t
a ioa nd ao t t
t pC o out e ss f t t
a C
i et f a oS f
t c
e C qlaD TeEt T s
d s
D mt t
n c Ee i
d sTf S r r e
e af r
l f
ee r
i cr p
t f v p oio n cs od o pt u
t e
n oE m n aC a et s
p c n n nUm p
e t
i f
c nd f e ie y oBd n Ef o a o
a v
A E
of b u
sidra r
,n oy eE f
i i
t t
t e
eait ii t
l ar adP g a r t
t t
d a n n n us amtaa nte ni S
G iSy n
c ei t l r r k
c e ca ag i
i t
e aid n m ud pe m mrm efe C
it f i f r oie i
l r
na t
t l
a r t
et rn n nAR eSMl ac SI ea eOS A
t r t
t a
e e
un ea e
R P d D
QU DP D l
I T
e e
e e
e e
1lIll1lllll I
I 3
1 devo me R
la l
r a
i i
e re ta t
M a
M yr y
a ra te t
rd e
i y
pe ir g
ov p
o o
r o
P r
m P
lo Ee d
GR E
G o
h te M
no i.
tac i
lpp A
1
lll\\\\
)il la 4
i 1
re ta M
kr y
r o
a w
te e
ird m
pe
)
ov a
r r
o F
Pm Ee no GR i
t a
E c
s D
r i
lp e
E p
e s
t N
A mis
(
e a
y r
l h
a a
R t
sP n
T f
e A
s o
i f e
L t
oyi i
3 l
t i
n b
gt n
ni 1
a ni a
o 3
p gt r
at i
i a
n e
r t
n e
C a
c a
o c
c d R n
n i
tc nd U U i
l e
S a
n f
p S
d o
p T
s a
n n
N t a
n s
t A
n n
n o
n s
o E
i e
e yi oe d
h Mm mia c
t i
f t
t i
o e
c c
E e
si n
s n
v s
b a
u L
r u
t it e
od E
u e
s sib i
s i
l l
r u
c r
t c
r o
q s n ms nf e n
s pr e
pt We s
e oe oe e
D AIn ERASCR CR I
t V
n 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 E
o R
C l1' l
l llll 1
I I
5 1
la i re t
s g
a e
n M
ik y
i t
r n
n a
i l
t o
a e
ib R
rd i
it pe a
c p
e n
ov r
o o
P l
a ei m
C nSt Ee o
a t
c GR i
d nf t
i n
a ai cl t
a P
n if e
i s
c r
d t
e ei n
p wa e
S oi r P
e m
o m
i r
e r
a o
r a
e nl n
iu e
c e
q c
uh e
SNP R
e l
l
6 1
la ire ta
~
M yra te ir d r
pe o
ov r
f o
P as m
Ee nt e n GR e
mis o n n a er hT P
O t
nO aA troR pW mB I
7 1
sno d
i t
e a
v c
o m
i lp e
l p
a r
i l
A a
re i
t r
G a
e t
C M
a A
y M
r R
a y
t r
T e
a i
t d
rd e
pe i
e ov pr w
o o
rP e
m r
Ee P
ive GR E
R G
/dev o
rpp A
y lsuo iv e
rP
8 1
s re te m
la i
a x
re r
s ir t
a t
e a
a s
M P
M a
y f
r i
o n
sB a
o e
t sd e
g i
i a
n rd t
n ai a
pe cB ov i
r g
s o
i f
P n
id e
m la ni Ee t
a u
a n
GR R
Qs a
i et d
ni r
n y ot e
n c
t i a
i t i a
a n
l i
t b
ct U r
n ai e
n l
e p p c o
m a
p ni t
CAU a
s c
l l
l s
e e
ei l
e d
d d p
s ooop s
MMMA A
e F
l
l1 9
1 la i re ta x
M ir yr t
a a
te M
ir d pe y
ov r
t o
P i
m l
Ee ib GR a
p aC le do M
GCART
02 la i re ta M
y x
ra i
t r
e t
ir d a
pe M
ov r
o P
h m
Ee o
GR i
tac i
f i
lau Q
G C
A R
T
i 1
2 s
i l
s a
i y
re l
t a
a n
M A
y ra y
t t
e
) )
i n
5 6
r d i
pe ov a
3 3 s
r o
tr e
et P
c m
l l
e b
b e
Ee c
a af GR f
n T (T E
(
s U
s s
gt r
n u
d n
ei p
ot d n
n e
oi i
t a
mN y
id t
y n ad n
r t
o a
ni i
a v
CP at i
r at e
e l
t i
nl a c
s t
a i
n c
n i
l nPSU e
I S
~
llll
22
.se i
tn ia tre c
n U
no i
t i
dn oC la i
t in i
dn a
l r
a e
ir t
e t
e a
m M
y a
r r
a t
a e
i P
r d p e t
ov r
o n
P m
a E
e l
GR P
~
32
-sa iB dna y
tn ia a
l t
i r r
e e
ta c
~
M n
y U
ra l
t e
e ir d d
pe o
ov r
o M
Pm Ee fo GR no i
ta r
t s
n o
meD I'
42 O
s la g
i r n
e t
i a
k M
n y
a r
R a
t e
T ir d pe R
ov r
o I
P Pm Ee fo GR no i
ta r
ts no meD
52 h
l c
a i r a
e os t
r n
a s
p o M
e pi t
y i
t A
a ra n
l d
u te ia e
c ir d l
t d
a pe r
nC ov r
e e
P o
c mn m
o Ee n
mi GR U
oa t
f c
m o
e r
Ri f n
f n
o oo t
sC i
a ed l
n p e b
mn i
n a
m xl a o
E P
C
6 2
d e
v o
m e
R la i
l re a
i t
r s
a e
e M
a t
i t
y M
n r
a y
i t
r a
e a
i t
t r d e
r pe i
e ov rp r
o c
P o
n m
r Ee P
U GR E
f G
o no i
tan ib moC
7 2
)deun i
t no la c
i r
(
e t
s a
e M
i t
y n
ra i
t a
e i
t rd r
pe e
ov r
c o
Pm n
Ee U
GR f
o no i
tan ib moC
9 82 s
no i
ta a
l lu ir c
e t
l a
a M
C y
r y
a t
g e
i o
i r c pe lo ov r
o d
Pm o
Ee h
GR te M
no i
tac i
lpp A
9 2
a taD o
t de rap mo d
C evo t
m c
la e
e i r f
e R
f t
l E
a a
M ire e
y t
t r
a a
a M
t r
e y
a rd r
i p
pe a
ov t
e o
r e
S P
ir m
p Ee o
fo GR rP n
E o
G i
ta r
tsno meD
~
1 03 RPC I/RPCA n
i y
t l
n a
e i
ir a
e t
t r
a e
M cn y
r U
a t
d e
ir d en pe ov i
r o
b P
m m
Ee o
GR C
fo n
o i
t a
r t
=
sn o
m eD
1 3
la ire ta M
)d y
r e
a t
u e
ir d n
pe i
ov t
r o
n Pm o
Ee c
GR
(
no i
ta r
tsno m
eD
s 23 epy s T s
re O
t t
y e
n me O
G t
i C
a v
A l
s ib A
E r
t a
R n
aR P
l c
l e
T s
yA W
y et i
l is pf g
i e
r B
t p o o
nf o
n a
i A
el aS o
f o
a c
r t
d t
r d
nd ela e
s o
c c
t n
T t
n a
n at h ni a
o t
O e
s pt Ui r
r i
it y e e
t t
C s
a r
O s
ni cM e
t r
n c
n ei cl e
o l
t A
a mb A
a mt m
p o
i f
l r
a c
a me p
R T
e i
r pd i
r t
W Oia n
s aL D A
i uC ai P
B O
q t
la y
G A
el s
a tn c
g e
t o
R d wS ai o
C ts 6
e Pi l
lo A
t y oid t
oM v
n d
a 2
r d
R n
/
t e
nS o
o R
t u
T y a f
Wl oR ot a
r h i
n s
et r
t r Si n
p e o
u n
o a
o pM a
B c
g oid t
f r
i neiU ei r
t i
R a
a cd d n
R t
P lp r
e n
n e
o E
r A
s v
sU o
l p
y t
d i
l ul Ci t
S a
S A
i n
s oel c
ae s
o n
r d a
ei n
pt i
G moe mt ooi n
t l
i e
p a
gMInO c
e e
xi C
p t
mSMDE R A
b A
u O
R S*
T
m g.-
3 y,
t GE Nuclear Energy ' -
ec:
Joseph F. Quirk, Manager Industry Programs GE Nuclear Energy.
175 Curtner Avenue '
San Jose, CA' 95125 George B. Stramback Regulatory Services Project Manager GE Nuclear Energy.
175 Curtner Avenue -
San Jose, CA 95125 James F. Klapproth, Manager Engineering & Technology
-.GE Nuclear Energy 175 Curtner Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 Charles M. Vaughan, Manager Facility Licensing -
GE Nuclear Energy j
P.O. Box 780 Wilmington, NC 28402 L
- Glenn A. Watford, Manager l.:
Nuclear Fuel Engineering GE Nuclear Energy l
P.C. Sox 780
- Wilmington, NC 28402 -
l.
l.
\\
w
l
' DISTRIBUTION: Mtg. Summary w/GE Dated July 19,1999 Hard Cooy
/Co.
't File PUEuO ACRS-OGC MDavis SDembeck EMail
~ Scollins RZimmerman' WKane BSheron DMatthews
' RCaruso
. GThomas UShoop RLandry JMitchell MRazzaque GTracy I
J
<