Text

Transcript of ACRS 464th Open Session Meeting on 990716 in Rockville,Md.Pp 500-503.Closed Session.Pp 504-544
	ML20209J544
Person / Time
Issue date:	07/16/1999
From:	; Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards
To:	;
References
	ACRS-T-3085, ASB-300-856, NUDOCS 9907210227
	Download: ML20209J544 (7)
	v • d • e

W' m-M%;W'ha ' ?' ; :# KrM e----

..F l' S \

i >

wM 2'

i M %m%w y%n f M M 2#m.

m Aww,x s %; W a n %v n%

WMW;')

NW

.s J P ,. N, T WlJ ' 1 [$. : y

.F n,

y w~

?

, $ Q;;R~

m. p<'< ~T ' ' "

i an w~Q EW,

p nyk s %?M;j = Vd. r ng s. a..v nyML. c, %w M mm . , ,,, ., ,

+ , + , +

, %,;f; udw QH Q& n .

Qy c @m p y a^ y* 6? s ,'l' , ~Of.P.gy ,

w s h ,q ' / m". r ,' +fy s Q; . ?

s*

z s -

% s ,. ,p ,,

, r w- s. i Qg: -

A@9W ga M$w)ny;gdOFFICIX v:s . ; wm @;Q;.,RANSCRIPT@QlqFMROdEE e ? yaw g Waww p c Aw. nu w w -

w a m m a Mkn WD 7.p .=4 %. +vp 4. @7x .m .m,R. ;RE,G,U,EA ,s wTORYbCOMMISSIO,

.~. - .. . . 8 NI m (

3. . A g_ jg y .

jf~*%q &.c- UC. -s LEA.s 3 s- -

r -

cu =

(U j% zQ

- = - - -

+* x1 m

~

m h.$yM Q rm 'a m#m, , x, m . m & , :Q q i

'):&Q4.(e!h:

y t " '

WMp%;f wpm E a&M;&jl g$gn$eR i:MK;a MMADVISOR Mnamn-f c Qwgni m~WC,O,MMITT,EELONTREACTOR!SAFEGUA~R,DS! - a - J M

%w ;:

m :n Aym M aiN w

,4 w i p.t sN tn g w g n ,.

a.1:n ; ~

s um w q&w::m .

W q:

' r

-' x, u

g gg%@%.9w:M f ggyWiOR;&.:n $p p Qj, - x %

=

~.

n;;MERS%O,N( N ; JFML ' M , o P&

m w &onpg qwe ,QQu m . eA Mg%sa%a ;1 ~w$w%a<a rh mo . N< * ' '

w ,m - <

, o . ,

. W^%4 ~

u .

. a anh m e,wa Yk

,m %._,sw MTitleiMf sif 1 n %w ' ,g%MEETINGfM64TH%DV .

num'S ny~S:. w# @w m <s -n & & y^ ps 3 %M uasn i m + +

h %m ,*?' m4 u W L M n ,R ' v x M M

M F' .iu e%* M, a' M'a'g,7. dM" M ~my i gM'MB@, " m' nPE" 4 ~

W, ag;C'+"O'S"

M" ",ITT"'E"*E!O' N' R" 'E'"@ ACTO" i,- w R s wsa :ps &~ ; a' n n; , 4~ < c -

m+ e'- ew x < .

em ra em ..m- ~ m~

+

8..y.s ,

w- .n

,m J- M M P W L b , &w&s

( zm%m &c,5y n w.,

,Psu gM NG, L, y"w ~

Q, y~.W _UAWWyL a - y, S,AFE. G$aM,,,, R

.n c

- m mr vdb4 sM%mq+c::; yya l g s- . ), y , ,,ne'M;yo ~;y%:% z. l

n. , a .

a

+yyhv '4 n As;;ny yu p c m;b-x:a i g b _ ,, ;- p, ,,g y 4::q e e' .

yg7 - &p % g':; Q ; s Q f y,s;yjg an }pp ypg .- p,-m+ -. ~y - ;;;

w.

&:a: xr.an #y a,g',q hb. t ,1 .

'um ' ;:y v ,w w: r s 1 ::m , ,4 1 ; p

\e .g'R @- y9.9 y

L p:sb n yl;,., if y% :. q i , f qu y; 3.;; Q'37

. ~ .s,; h a. ,a a s - w!g- e ': 7sy. cW x- shp =.y,. :

',.c. k.'d ';;

A'w r

1

.p

<g 4#

it . , , - w '}n <> . . 3:ym ga;

.f N'

" ,y:3 ,- g ;_ y - y p

't .

.* (y' f p 7:r 4y , y a%., } ,

geMe

-p m,.'

y w.e

..m v r m,. , w4,, t qh..;?, .+ ,ew,1 7,;&.

t a.. xa y.S i

.g .u-<:(:.L, ~

n c l, , q ,'u.<- -

..' e " y 1f34 x , y-t

.( y g v79,:g s n

g. i m- Je s y1 i

nh .,

i 3

%m9 e..w- w i.

W yo+hJ%m fg q ,gMh b h ' , dIh h N TR04 (ACRS)

+ ;jp - , , ,

u. ; w< ~ w, l @OCbt

< ggm ygg vy 7 L M.1,]q$ua O $o //t , T,k RETURN ORIGINAL EA M$!

p f4 w' Me , e , '< m .

3 or- s. >

t !

h,x ~%

g+f. wn nN ', i J TO BJWHITE a ,

~, w ~ , , wn. w, .

^ ~

4 6y~a-MAMt o.

y,y @f.m. g f. w+~ .g w>~4~ ,g . Q. 3 s v%n. g p y ;i n #g g <1 y g. wisc g g gg<AM 4

. s 'g<hu M/S T-2E26 '

w- ,

s a

s ,d - r. ~ ' & , ,L. 4. , . b ycm wW 4 >

415 - 1,130 %w M.g u; -M.:J . ; LL 3 .

e& ,

y .M %@m ? yT.

d.. y ,d.y M.1' . , r.-7:.y- ~

r

.g .n - # eg M.e , .b, , .~ W.;i .7 T J*C,.yn. .l .

.4 n THANKS! %6 <

4 ..: %. ; '

ls .a. ^

Mf' m)yd .smi . , .]

fi 7.l -f: ' L:-

,' yMUTC H{r L. M ,q"7

? . YY

' 'a ,.- >Y I, y 2 .Y f & Yf 'y ~ ' 43 n00 ND4 w

%: % 9,fpig.2TjnApe fd;g.:09VWOrderiNoWHAS.B2300;8566. ',yq,'

' Wm"m " u q; l ;uwn , ; m u m ' , ' ' a ' '

4 LW " ' 3 +{%x J '

'a&' %e a

L % :"Y Q; -w ,

,y'& iy . <

%w '

~ < <

.'"4W8 , WM pg J y n?p<

, : M

, jpgp,g g % & ' A9R k .. . a - GQ; <

q , L, a

m,.? ;e W chhD *n O ,y ;%r yL "

1'\, ,

Q , 4:1 ;4

, 4 vg. % , o +

t (]F ij 7, Q[N,3y, ? g{y% i; bTQV ypm >::J ,pb %, ; ,

- ~ Y

, QMM ;3

. . m, m

4 M;{ i! Q~ f W" ,

'MQ

&,'1,t , w.a M M P{ y'}p % { 4 h 3

z% : :.[

>Ml /

ly 8

y 1

,+ %:, g. ; , s_.gy

h. .

3,. . p rp ~ k@%.gf jo cq 5,

, &*:tg w-;c;Q 3s%r.;f;

. ., m. om ,

r i s fp o %Nw Jh m

,,, u.m ' W W.,\<W & p< W W ^ y.

x..ps: o ;g -; n ppa . a wq_ y :

a. w %. . e,w ja Y l &; w

$W m l ', '

A,. ?"- :'o y.v ,; as. ,s,,r mh s. e, o

*f.Em mm 3 :,

e , . ,y f a: y + e

,s ~3.. .c , ,

m

. :%e v'x ;scw% Mg3 q%w.s c,s;$r4 ' h ih . <m ,-%

f .4.: .nc,y' e . . wi ..g c ,9 yp a.,

g >; y : 4s- 7 Mn. ,

o .,

,t 7 a. ; eu s L m . s 4 d ..wy' ny:(.,mv.M!e - . Q:', 2 n~?

c x .

n ~-

l .A " w-(, / @ - t "4,9" 1 .,6e ,..[. ,

gy lw&, n. 'p' m'A o ,,s. A,v'; 4 ;msfy. a .

?.

..~%.A

. , , r

,< +:e [,,r , / G1 y s,w, pf v: ve V

.. jM- G Yr m t'a p 3j f4m@ ,M@y4m&.u M.~6d, M %@,,. . .,i;$z 7 .

4 Q,<

s .

c . f-., , p 1U p- .f r '

c.. LOCATION

An.si m M4'.k/j -

L'.'

W . ryWe.

&~ l;64, #

P 1RockiillR' &A, '

e, V M. 1 e gV , L h ' "MM%6,n

d> fm MDj MM;&aWM;@,?G mm 3

.1% J o 4 m, Q@

s -- "

u 2

A,t~y' fM J . % Ay a, Wy. yia;@, y@ ;,

y A @p < @

@u Q gH

,a t, n: ' .;. i*W 9. X. 's. 4 i;3, ?. y./ ; , #p); . dj f " ., :#^ U,ea" #'O 4, + fyj)M3 JJG.',O, j,',u @, ' R,, , ' ,';4%. .u, K @yWSy)g@Gg ' f pP

.v.

gy Q,m >

>m V f:

n ~

~n vwrew n -w mw-,- ~.L p~

o n ,'o%:yc:n. . .~ *, , .

s m , u r- am- e w f [$k~ , , j a-. - ,

[p@r[g%&ap%*w,h,$;,YATh.myyaputyJ6[199Qq[a.,ndyj;gg+u i

y.

c.

w m. C"o f W4 . 4 Ap p. , / n u.a 7x.&y. , +,p;c . (n ..ws , , n .- m,ra ,

c r g l . af ,~f PAGEgth0 p503J . jp n,{+ n , vw y y' ; 'w; , ,

.n x; g

w.7 t %"w 3

m!N.; r 5 .

. . , n t~.,. h.., ,.

fp. ,

r sn.-%, :Ey:a g yx , w wamu%www.;uwww

8mdpr r.

a n. . u,z

$M; 6MM 7. <

m*y

-1 TMN 9907210227 990716 L,,,&:M L / l% ' 4

~

$gj,p,M $ @$ l' PDR ACRS ' '

M T-3085 wM};QNFGTZE"W PDR [N( Nf M %,. P' . s j*. W s

hygK MRWh*MF1 e n%NN RILEY%%SSOCI TE$15TD3 $..?,< w ,,

Tz y$s p%z.x~g g n gm$1025'conmdicurAv6NW,$ulteD1014%w m sv' ;

w a w n.c

"~

a 3 om s ;s ~ w ; . puan , m t~

~ - .

e m .

w ~

. ___ m -,. - _ _ .

- - 'l

. 4 '

OR G NA_ S#

OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS OPENSESSION

Title:

MEETING: 464TII ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS (ACRS)

Docket No.: Tao 4 <Acas aerre caIs:nn TC E' WHITE

/"'

M/S T-2E26 415-7130 TFANKS!

Work Order No.: ASB-300-856 f) 1 LOCATION: Rockville, MD

' DATE: Friday, July 16,1999 PAGES: 500 - 503

{QY hf/60l '

9907210227 990716 T 085 PDR

~ ~ " ' ~ ~

ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES, LTD. '

1025 Connecticut Ave.,NW, Suite 1014 Washington, D.C. 20036 (v~\ ap ADRS_OfS,ce.sc.onuOopydifiB i

I(fleLife0 Mile Committec

_ l

t"

\_

DISCLAIMER UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION'S ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS JULY 16, 1999 1

l 1

The contents of this transcript of the proceeding '

of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Advisory (l')j Committee on Reactor Safeguards, taken on July 16, 1999, as j reported herein, is a record of the discussions recorded at I

the meeting held on the above date.

This transcript had not been reviewed, corrected and edited and it may contain inaccuracies.

l l

l'\

500 l' '

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3 ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS 4 ***

5 464TH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON 6 REACTOR SAFEGUARDS (ACRS) 7 8 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 9 Two White Flint North 10 Conference Room 2B3 11 11545 Rockville Pike 12 Rockville, Maryland 13 Friday, July 16, 1999 14 The committee met, pursuant to notice, at 8:31 15 a :. m .

16 MEMBERS PRESENT:

17 DANA POWERS, Chairman, ACRS 18 ROBERT'SEALE, Member, ACRS 19 GEORGE APOSTOLAKIS, Member, ACRS 20 MARIO BONACA, Member, ACRS 21 ROBERT UHRIG, Member, ACRS 22 GRAHAM WALLIS, Member, ACRS 23 WILLIAM SHACK, Member, ACRS 24 THOMAS KRESS, Member, ACRS 25 JACK SIEBER, Member, ACRS 4

ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES, LTD.

O- Court Reporters 1025 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 1014 Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 842-0034

501 1

l'

PROCEEDINGS r~

(gj 2 [8:30 a.m.]

3 DR. POWERS: The meeting will now come to order.

4 This is the third day of the 464th meeting of the Advisory 5 Committee on Reactor Safeguards. During today's meeting, 6 the committee will consider the following, Highlights from 7 the Incident Report System, Future ACRS Activities, Report 8 of the Planning and Procedures Subcommittee, Reconciliation 9 of ACRS Comments and Recommendations. ,

10 Portions of today's meeting will be closed to 11 discuss information provided in confidence by a foreign 12 source. Organizational and personnel matters that relate 13 solely to the Internal Personnel Rules and Practices of the 14 Advisory Committee and matters, the release of which would

) 15 constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal 16 privacy.

17 The meeting is being conducted in accordance with 18 the provisions of the Federal Advisory Committee Act. Dr.

19 John T. Larkins is the designated federal official for the 20 initial portion of the meeting.

21 We have received no written statements or requests 22 for time to make oral statements from members of the public 23 regarding today's session.

24 A transcript of portions of the meeting is being 25 kept and it is requested the speakers use one of the ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES, LTD.

[v} Court Reporters 1025 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 1014 Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 842-0034

.I 502 l' microphones, identify themselves and speak with sufficient

() 2 3

clarify and volume so they can be readily heard.

The first order of business today is to discuss 4 some disciplinary actions that we have to take, and I want 5 to call the Executive Director of the ACRS before us to l 6 straighten him out severely on some serious considerations 7 here.

8 DR. SEALE: Flogging will cease when morale 9 increases.

10 DR. POWERS: John, if you will come forward, we 11 have to discuss this serious problem you have of showing up 12 for now almost 30 years.

13 Maybe I can walk up here. He is getting so 14 decrepit he can't move around.

s ,/ 15 [ Laughter.)

16 DR. POWERS: Interestingly enough, for one of her 17 last acts as the Chairman, Shirley Jackson said, boy, I have 18 got to honor this guy for 30 years of service to the 19 government, and I hasten to add -- what, the last -- how 20 long have you been here?

21 DR. LARKINS: At the NRC?

22 DR. POWERS: No, at the ACRS. Too long. j l

23 DR. SEALE: Six years. !

24 DR. LARKINS: Since '93.

25 DR. POWERS: Exemplary service to the ACRS. The I

[

\

ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES, LTD.

Court Reporters l

1025 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 1014 Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 842-0034

503 4

l' plaque and then the little diamond weight.

() 2 3

DR. WALLIS:

DR. POWERS:

Only diamond like.

And my heartiest congratulations.

4 [ Applause.]

5 [ Pause.]

6 DR. SEALE: John had his "gotcha" smile on there.

7 Very good, John.

8 DR. POWERS: I think the ACRS is truthfully lucky 9 to have an individual of the technical competence and 10 dedication that we have in John, and it is a pleasure to 11 work with you, John.

12 Now, we will turn to another very interesting 13 area, the Incident Reporting System, and, Mario, I think you 14 are the cognizant member.

()

D 15 DR. BONACA: Yes.

16 DR. POWERS: And introduce our honored speaker, 17 whom none of us know very well and hardly recognize. )

18 [Whereupon, at 8:35 a.m., the open session was 19 recessed, to reconvene in closed session at 8:35 p.m., this 20 same day.]

21 22 ]

23 i

24 '

25

[) ANN RILEY & ASSOCIATES, LTD.

\- # Court Reporters 1025 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Silite 1014 Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 842-0034

REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE This is to certify that the attached proceedings

() before the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission in the matter of:

NAME OF PROCEEDING: 464TH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS (ACRS)

OPEN SESSION l

CASE NUMBER:

PLACE OF PROCEEDING: Rockville, MD (O

,j were held as here'in appears, and that this is the original transcript thereof for the file of the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission taken by me and thereafter reduced to typewriting by me or under the direction of the court reporting company, and that the transcript is a true and accurate record of the foregoing proceedings. j l

l h.bk1 _

Mark Mahoney Official Reporter Ann Riley & Associates, Ltd.

i

\

C) l

ML20209J544

Text

Title:

Navigation menu

Search