ML20207N907

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Summary of 881006 Meeting W/Licensee & GE Re Forthcoming Reload Submittal for Feb 1989 Reload.Attendees List & Nonproprietary Slides Presented by GE Outlining Scope of Reload Application to Be Submitted by Nov 1988 Encl
ML20207N907
Person / Time
Site: Perry FirstEnergy icon.png
Issue date: 10/12/1988
From: Colburn T
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
TAC-69525, NUDOCS 8810190461
Download: ML20207N907 (35)


Text

s i 4

. October 12, 1988  !

i  ;

l Docket No. 50-440 PDIII-3 r/f " JHannon LICENSEE: The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company TColburn OGC-WF1 l i EJordan BGrimes t FACILITY: Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit No.1 ACRS(10) JClifford I i TCollins WPaulson l

SUBJECT:

MEETING SU MARY TAC NO. 69525 WHodges  !

l '

I On October Electric 6,1988, Illuminating a meeting Company w(as held licensees), between General representatives Electric Company (GE) andof the Cleveland [

, the staff to discuss the forthcoming reload submittal for the February 1989 t

Perry Unit I reload. Enclosure 1 contains a list of attendees. Enclosure 2 [

j contains a copy of non-proprietary slides presented by GE which outline the i scope cf the reload application expected to be received from the licensees in l

< November 1988. The licensees and GE have indicated that the reload application l 1 will rely upon pre-approved fuel designs using pre-approved analysis methods. .

l The application will contain some cycle-specific Technical Specification  !

j changes. The licensees also indicated that any other outage-dependent license .

j amendment applications for Perry Unit I would be submitted separately in order [

] to minimize complications or confusion with the reload package review.  ;

I i The staff indicated, based upon the licensees' and GE's presentation, that they should be able to complete review of the licensees' expected reload t j application consistent with the scheduled reload. {

5  !

!s/ l l

l Timothy G. Colburn, Project Manager l 1

Project Directorate III-3 Nvision of Reactor Projects - !!!, .

l IV, V and Special Projects J

Enclosures:

l

As stated [

I

}

j cc: See next page  % Q' l

k

Office: LA/PD111-3 PN/PDI!!-3 SRXBMyd PD y /PDI!! p e_
Surname
PKeeut'zer TColburn/tg WHodges JHannon , t
Date: /o /a, /88 /O //A/88 ft) /[k/88 ,*// /88 J  :

i 1 f

! l I i

! t i i i P ss1019c461gg@$4o DR ADOCK PDC p/

j /// [

1

  • ?

Mr. Alvin Kaplan Perry Nuclear Power Plant The Cleveland Electric- Unit 1 Illuminating Company cc:

Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Mr. James W. Harris, Director 2300 N Street, N.W. Division of Power Generation Washington,D.C. 20037 Ohio Department of Industrial Relations David E. Burke P.O. Box 825 The Cleveland Electric Columbus, Ohio 43216 Illuminating Company P.O. Box 5000 . The Honorable Lawrence Logan Cieveland, Ohio 44101 Mayor, Village of Perry 4203 Harper Street Resident Inspector's Office Perry, Ohio 44081 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Parmly at Center Road The Honorable Robert V. Orosz Perry Ohio 44081 Mayor, Village of North Perry North Perry Village Hall Regional Administrator, Region Ill 4778 Lockwood Road U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission North Perry Village, Ohio 44081 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn Illinois 60137 Attorney General Department of Attorney General Frank P. Weiss. Esq. 30 East Broad Street Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Columbus, Ohio 43216 105 Main Street Lake County Administration Center Radiological Health Program Painesville, Ohio 44077 Chio Departmeit of Health 1224 Kinnear Road Ms. Sue Hiatt Columbus, Ohio 43212 OCRE Interim Representativa 8275 Munson Ohio Environmental Protection Mentor, Ohio 44060 Agency 361 East Broad Street Terry J. Lodge, Esq. Columbus, Ohio 43266-0558 618 N. Michigan Street Suite 105 Mr. Phillip S. Haskell. Chairman Toledo, Ohio 43624 Perry Township Board of Trustees Box 65 John G. Cardinal. Esq. 4171 Main Street Prosecuting Attorney Perry. Ohio 44081 Ashtabula County Courthouse Jefferson, Ohio 44047 State of Ohio Public Utilities Cossnission Robert A. Newkirk 180 East Broad Street Cleveland Electric Columbus, Ohio 4326%0573 Illuminating Company Perry Nuclear Power Plant Michael D. Lyster P. O. Box 97 E-210 Cleveland Electric Perry, Ohio 44081 Illuminating Company Perry Nuclear Power Plant P. O. Box 97 SB306 Perry, Ohio 44081

  • ?

ENCLOSURE 1 I

PERRY UNIT 1 FEB 89 RELOAD MTG 10/6/88 NAME ORGANIZATION I Tim Colburn NRR/PD3-3 Tim Collins NRR J. S. Chernley GE/LACS R. F. Parr GE i R. A. Loeffler CE!/ Licensing i

8. S. Ferrell
  • CEl/ Licensing  !

R. A. Newkirk CE!/ Licensing  ;

8. M. Burmeister GSU/ Licensing W. A. Paulson NRC/NRP,/PD-4 i r

I i

1 I

i i

l h i t

)  !

i r

l l

$ i i

t i f I

! l i

l i'

e ENCLOSURE 2 l

l t

4

. RELOAD FUEL LICENSING FOR l I

PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT UNIT 1

! l l

) OCTOBER 6, 1988 ,

b l

l l

i i

)

l l

i j

GE FUEL LICENSING IS BASED ON:

i 0 PRE-APPROVED FUEL DESIGNS  !

0 PRE-APPROVED ANALYSIS METHODS

, l 1

i l

0 PRE-APPROVED GENERIC RESULTS >

?

! i l I O MINIMAL CYCLE SPECIFIC REVIEW  !

t t

i  !

) >

1 l 1

4 l

)

4 l

3 l

( l 1

i I

s I

! l i

l 1

l GE FUEL LICENSING CORNERSTONE l

GESTAR-II

! O SINGL,E REFERENCE DOCUMENT i t

t i O BASIS FOR ALL FUEL LICENSING  ;

l 1 0 CONTAINS RESULTS OF GENERIC REVIEWS i j 0 FULLY APPROVED BY USNRC

O HAINTAINED UP-TO-DATE AS GE CONTROLLED i i DOCUMENT l
F 1

j l

l i

i l

GESTAR-II CONSISTS OF 0 STANDARDIZED BASE DOCUMENT 0 STANDARDIZED COUNTRY SPECIFIC DOCUMENT 0 PLANT SPECIFIC SUBMITTAL 9

"s u .__--..-- ,_--____mC d' _bm_ =- A.C__w_- 4. .M 3--4-----ha-.m----. 4 -- --- - A E a- -m - --.me._

- - - - . - . . _--, Ac__n ..--

1 .6 GESTAR-II LICENSING PRE-APPROVED BASE COUNTRY - CYCLE REPORT SUPPLEMENT SPECIFIC 0 FUEL MECHANICAL 0 REACTOR LIMITS 0 CORE LOADING DESIGN METHODS PATTERN 0 NUCLEAR MODELS 0 BOUNDING ANALYSES 0 CYCLE-SPECIFIC ANALYSES RESULTS 0 THERMAL-HYDRAULIC 0 COUNTRY SPECIFIC MODELS REQUIREMENTS 0 FS*,R CROSS 0 PLANT UNIQUE REFERENCE INFORMATION O IMPACT OF PLANT OPTIONS J

e L

i

!, GESTAR-II APPLICATIONS l I

O REFERENCE IN FSAR/ RELOAD SUBMITTALS O PROVIDES FOR CONTROLLED CHANGES I

O PROVIDES BASIS FOR ELIMINATING RELOAD

! SUBMITTALS PER 10CFR50.59  :

O FACILITATES FSAR UPDATES ,

l

{

i l t l  !

FUEL LICENSING STANDARDIZATION ,

ACCOMPLISHED l l

i  !

3 I i

! I i l t

I, i

GESTAR-II  :

APPROVED FOR REFERENCING BY NRC 0 ONLY COMPREHENSIVE DOCUMENT FOR BWR FUEL ,

0 ELIMINATES REPETITIVE NRC REVIEW O REDUCES NRC WORKLOAD  !

1 1

0 APPROVED CURRENT FUEL AND CORE ANALYSIS METHODS

):

0 INDEPENDENT OF ONG0ING GENERIC REVIEWS  !

j 0 MAINTAINED AS AN APPROVED UPDATED DOCUMENT l I  !

RELOAD FUEL LICENSING SIMPLIFIED l

r l

l i

FUEL DESIGNS t i

1 0 ALL 8X8 DESIGNS IN GESTAR-II i

t G NEW DESIGN REVIEW SIMPLIFIED l l

l -

REVIEWED ON GESTAR-II DOCKET  :

PRE-APPROVED HETHODS AND CRITERIA  !

1 1

l t

l i

t 1

i

! \

i

! l I

! l l

l l

! I i

i

\

l I

l

--, -- _ m 4 9

'O I

APPLICATION OF NEW METHODS t

O APPLIED ONLY AFTER GENERIC APPROVAL i

k 0 INCORPORATED INTO GESTAR-II F

l 4

i t i I I

l l l

) i t

4 i

r 1

t

- -- . = _

og i

STANDARD UTILITY RELOAD LICENSING FUEL DESIGN AND ANALYSIS MODELS PRE-APPROVED IN GESTAR-II CYCLE SPECIFIC VALUES IN SUPPLEMENTAL RELOAD SUBMITTAL '

0 TYPICALLY SEND TO NRC 3-6 MONTHS BEFORE STARTUP ',

0 NO SUBMITTAL POSSIBLE (10CFR50.59) 0 INITIAL APPLICATION REQUIRES TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION CHANGE I

NO PROBLEMS WITH RELOAD LICENSING t

RELOAD WITHOUT NRC SUBMITTALS 0 BASED ON 10CFR50.59 0 FUEL , DESIGN AND MODELS APPROVED IN GESTAR-II 0 NO UNREVIEWED SAFETY QUESTION 0 NO NRC SUBMITTAL REQUIRED IF TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS DO NOT CHANGE i

OPTIMUM FUEL LICENSING SIMPLIFICATION l

l

4 FSAR UPDATES 0 WIDE RANGE OF OPTIONS AVAILABLE O MINIMUM TO MAXIMUM USE OF GESTAR-II 0 UPDATING REDUCED BY MAXIMUM USE OF GESTAR-II GESTAR-II CAN HINIMIZE FSAR UPDATES l

l


,--....-.----,_,-------..,__,_,,-,-..,--.-_-_,,,._,_.,.___----_--,,-,-g_ _ , - , . . - - - - - - - -

D PERRY 1 RELOAD 1 LICENSING BASIS

RELOAD 1 BASIS 0 GE8X8EB FUEL DESIGN 0 GESTR THERMAL - MECHANICAL ANALYSIS 0 GEMINI PHYSICS ANALYSES O GENERIC SLMCPR ANALYSIS .

O GEMINI ODYN ANALYSES (OPTION A) ,

0 3-D SIMULATOR LOFH 0 VERIFY BWR/6 RWE i

0 0DYN PRESSURIZATION COMPLIANCE 0 GENERIC STABILITY BASIS 0 B0VHDING CRDA 0 SAFE /REFLOOD LOCA 0 ELIMINATED FLE l

4 GE8X8EB FUEL DESIGN e

GE8X8EB FUEL DESIGN APPROVED BY USNRC 1985 0 INCORPORATED INTO GESTAR-II REV 8 0 INCLUDED IN MANY PLANT RELOADS 0 REQUIRES SURVEILLANCE OF LEAD DISCHARGE BUNDLES 0 PERRY IS NOT A LEAD PLANT IMPROVED DESIGN FEATURES

0 BARRIER OPTION INCLUDED IN PERRY INITIAL CORE 0 HIGHER PREPRESSURIZATION AND BUNDLE ENRICHMENTS ALLOWS HIGHER BURNUPS O AXIAL ZONED GAD 0LINIA INCREASES MARGINS AND SIMPLIFIES OPERATION i

l i

l b

-=y,~e,e----n - . . ,- - - - _,,,--------,ww-----me--,, - , , ~ - - . - - --wn,.,.,-.--e,,-----,-- _ ,,,y---ww - e--- <-,-------w -

A SYSTEM OF NEW METHODS Pressure ^

Transients Thermal Fuel R Hydraulics Behavior Best Estimate Models Loss of Core Coolant Physics Lattice Physics O

EVALUATION MODELS 0 PHYSICALLY CONSISTENT BEST ESTIMATE O STATE.-OF-THE-ART 0 SUPPORTED BY TEST /0PERATING DATA 0 STATISTICAL CONSIDERATION OF UNCERTAINTIES i

l

.c NEW LICENSING MODELS SYSTEM OF NEW METHODS 0 GESTR-MECHANICAL FUEL DESIGN MODEL 0 GEMINI PHYSICS MODELS 0 GEXL-PLUS THERMAL CORRELATION 0 GEMINI ODYN TRANSIENT MODEL 0 GESTR-SAFER ECCS ANALYSIS H0 DEL ALL MODELS APPROVED ALL APPLICATIONS APPROVED i

GESTR-MECHANICAL INCLUDED IN GESTAR-II REVISION 7 GEMINI AND GEST R-SAFER MODELS INCORPORATED INTO l REVISION 8 GEXL-PLUS WILL Bi IN REVISION 9 FIRST FOUR METHODS WILL BE USED IN PERRY 1 RELOAD 1

GESTR-MECHANICAL SIGNIFICANT MODEL IMPROVEMENT 0 GAP CONDUCTANCE O FISSION GAS RELEASE O CLADDING EXPANSION /DISPLACEM'.NT 0 FUEL EXPANSION / DISPLACEMENT l

0 INTERNAL PRESSURE 0 ANALYTICAL METHOD BASED ON SIGNIFICANT IN-REACTOR /00T-REACTOR TEST DATA MODEL APPROVED BY USNRC 3/82

9 e9 e

GEMINI PHYSICS 0 IMPROVES PREDICTION OF GADOLINIA BURNUP O IMPROVES PREDICTION OF POWER SHAPES AND REACTIVITY MARGINS AT EXTENDED BURNUP l 0 FULLY INTEGRATED METHODS APPROVED BY USNRC 1

l \

l l

I l

.e MCPR SAFETY LIMIT  :

0 GENERIC BOUNDING STATISTICAL. ANALYSIS DOCUMENTED IN GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.1 ,

O LIMIT FOR GE8X8EB, S-LATTICE RELOAD CORE IS 1.07 INITIAL CORE WAS 1.06

! l 0 NO CHANGE DUE TO GEXL-PLUS CORRELATION  ;

1 l

l i 0 FULLY APPROVED BY USNRC  !

l l

f

GEXL-PLUS CORRELATION 0 NEW THERMAL ANALYSES CORRELATION FOR P/BP8X8R AND GE8X8E/EB FUELS 0 ADDS TERMS TO ACCOUNT FOR AXIAL FLUX SHAPE O LITTLE EFFECT ON TRANSIENT ANALYSIS 0 APPROVE BY USNRC MARCH 1988 0 REQUIRES T.S. CHANGE OF MCPR p I i

i L

ANALYZED TRANSIENTS 0 LIMITING EVENTS DETERMINED FROM FSAR SENSITIVITY STUDY 0 EVENTS TO BE ANALYZED GIVEN IN GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.2 HOST LIMITING OF TT OR LR W/0 BP LOSS OF FEEDWATER HEATING FEEDWATER CONTROLLER FAILURE (MAX.

DEMAND)

CONTROL R0D WITHDRAWAL ERROR PRESSURE REGULATOR DOWNSCALE FAILURE 0 LIMITING POINT IN POWER / FLOW MAP ANALYZED 0 POWER C0ASTDOWN GENERICALLY APPROVED GIVEN IN GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.2

I ODYN TRANSIENT MODEL AND APPLICATION INCORPORATES O APPROVED GESTR-MECHANICAL 0 APPROVED GEMINI PHYSICS 0 MODEL CHANGES IMPROVED PREDICTION ACCURACY l O CHANGES MODEL UNCERTAINTY FOR MCPR OPERATING LIMIT i

0 REDUCES MCPR OPERATING LIMITS I

USED FOR PRESSURIZATION EVENTS ,

l l

l

LOSS OF FEEDWATER HEATING ANALYSIS 0 ANALYZED USING GEMINI PHYSICS 3-D BWR SIMULATOR MODEL 0 USE OF 3-D SIMULATOR APPROVED BY USNRC IN GESTAR-II REV. 2 0 GEMINI PHYSICS INCORPORATED INTO GESTAR-II  :

REV. 8 ,

i i

l 1

ROD WITHDRAWAL ERROR ANALYSIS O GENERIC STATISTICAL FSAR ANALYSIS FOR BWR/6 PLANTS O ANALYSIS RESULTS WILL BE VERIFIED OR PLANT SPECIFIC RESULTS REPORTED ,

i ll I a I

i i

. I i

P e e

PRESSURIZATION COMPLIANCE O ADEQUACY OF PRESSURE RELIEF SYSTEM DEMONSTRATED BY HSIV CLOSURE ON FLUX SIGNAL '

SCRAM 0 GENESIS ODYN ANALYSIS BASIS USED GEMINI ODYN DID NOT IMPACT THIS EVENT 0 DOCUMENTED IN GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.3 0 RESULTS MUST NOT EXCEED 1375 PSIG LIMIT

STABILITY COMPLIANCE O DEMONSTRATED ON GENERIC BASIS COMPLIANCE WITH 10CFR50 APP A GDC 12 INCORPORATE SIL 380 INTO TECH SPECS, OR DEMONSTRATE DECAY RATIO <0.8 a

0 APPROVED BY USNRC 4/85 0 DOCUMENTED IN GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT .

SECTION 2.4 .

O BWROG ANALYZING EFFECTS OF LA SALLE INCIDENT I 0 NO FURTHER ACTIONS REQUIRED AT THIS TIME l

i L

I L

t

.4 -.

6 CONTROL ROD DROP ACCIDENT 0 BOUNDING ANALYSIS DOCUMENTED FOR PLANTS WITH BPWS EASILY MEETS 280 CAL /GM LIMIT l 0 GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.5.1 l

0 PERRY HAS BPWS i

t l

l i

b i

, l l

s

I e

LOSS OF COOLANT ACCIDENT ANALYSIS 0 ANALYTICAL BASIS SAME AS FOR FSAR ,

HIGHLY CONSERVATIVE O BASIS ALSO DOCUMENTED IN,GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.5.2 i

0 MAPLHGRs FOR RELOAD FUEL IN RELOAD SUBMITTAL l

0 ALL REQUIRED LIMITS WILL BE MET FOR RELOAD 1 i

l I

i

._. _ __ _ _ _ . - - _ _ _ _ _ _. __ O

FUEL LOADING ERROR  ;

0 FLE ANALYSIS REQUIREMENT ELIMINATED FOR BWR/6 PLANT. RELOADS 0 MISLOCATED BUNDLE LOADING ERROR FOR ALL RELOAD CORES ELIMINATED BASED ON DATA FROM .

PA3T RELOADS I

! i 0 MISORIENTED BUNDLE LOADING ERROR IS NOT PERFORMED FOR S-LATTICE CORES BECAUSE BUNDLE i SYMMETRY RESULTS IN INSIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN '

MCPR l l

0 DOCUMENTED IN GESTAR-II US SUPPLEMENT SECTION 2.5.4 .l i

l l

I PERRY 1 RELOAD 1 ,

l O ALL FUEL DESIGNS APPROVED BY USNRC  ;

O ANALYSES PERFORMED WITH HETHODS FULLY 4

APPROVED BY USNRC O ALL ANALYSES RESULTS HEET CRITERIA APPROVED BY USNRC 0 N0 UNREVIEWED SAFETY ISSUES 0 N0 SIGNIFICANT SAFETY HAZARDS 1

e i

4 i

4

_._,_.--g~-,. . - . . -