ML20207C615
| ML20207C615 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Braidwood  |
| Issue date: | 12/19/1986 |
| From: | Guild R BUSINESS & PROFESSIONAL PEOPLE FOR THE PUBLIC INTERES |
| To: | Callihan A, Cole R, Grossman H Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#486-2024 OL, NUDOCS 8612300191 | |
| Download: ML20207C615 (17) | |
Text
} 03 8 k
BP hM Business and Professional People for the PublicMerest Telephone:Dl2)'641-5570
)
Chicago. liknois 60602
)
4 109 North Dearborn Street. Suite 1300 u
'85 DEC 29 P7 :04 December 19, 1986 Herbert Grossman, Esq.
Chairman Administrative Law Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Dr. A. Dixon Callihan Administrative Law Judge 102 Oak Lane Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Dr. Richard F. Cole Administrative Law Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Re:
In the Matter of Commonwealth Edison Company (Braidwood Station, Units 1 and 2)
Docket Numbers 50-456 and 50-457-di.-
Dear Judges:
In accordance with our discussion during the last conference call I am forwarding copies of Intervenors' Exhibit 98, the Comstock 1,215 weld inspection checklist and related documents located by NRC Inspector Mendez during his Braidwood inspection.
These documents were produced by the Staff after Mr. Mendez left the witness stand, and were identified and admitted as Intervenors' Exhibit 98 August 27, 1986, Tr. 11, 339-40.
(
h r = u, = = "
"T, fero..,--,
".=,' a=;' L
- o."_
n
2;;.al-
- =J!=..
=:, ret.,,
n=r :in',.,
- ~ ~ -
-->~~.
~. ~
7#.',* *c f,'.""'
C","'
c RT.i.'.T."o in i. !!'" " i:r.Utr"
';."J."a%,
lToi'o"c"AL.
' ' ~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~
un.,u..:.:~c.,. w,;t.1
- '.m.. o.,
a,n, o.,
==
- a --
= =~ oa~ < - - * ' a ai.
~,
so,. ooo..
oo.
a
$;;,a,y,a-
- P=4"a *.c*;""' s"*.'"O.M';om. MrMO!
??*.=T.,
T@^',%M
?C"*111"'"
2%%i" ~..... "T*#=.*O
%"iO',
".~.0 M'a, q,.;.,, ;o.
8612300191 861219
)
PDR ADOCK 05000456 G
PDR 0303
}.-
By copy of this letter I am inferming the parties of this submission.
With best regards, I am truly yours, t
r
\\
I Rcbert Guilt RG/sp Encl.
cc: -Parties Ace Federal Reporter (444 N. Capital'St.
Washington, D.C. 20001) 4 1
1 i
...-.-.._ ~_..-.. _..~....___..- ~
.. _ ~ _..... _..... _
b kef us'.St'.Y // /2&.f.)
f) y
/89 NvX
- r. O
.f').
Dl DOI: // D g o g',
e hoi: ' R. A..Brho.....h 70:
- .1..
Snetana Pittsbtirgh Testing laboratory * * '
L. K. Comstock 6 Ccnpan Braid. cod Station Braid. cod Station
.-. z - ~
- Z, p *p Oc-I'(
'Ihe attachec S!%W znd Stud Welding Inspection Checklist for the isted beloa is being forwarded to you for your inspection of locat d
4 *o faA e in li
&M-wW pa tin / o wSp-9A.re,er tr j
d4N d e J
S,emp.h48d. b[W)p:
M 'AW
/
nitial Inspection ( [ ad//M,Reingsion
(
'~
g( A,s - A s+ee I )
NA AI.- %,Ac << 9 - 31 A.,
., e s ke 31.. cce9 - 31
~c.c 9 - s y
- ec -is - 37
'v.cegfAs,37 s ccW4,-4 7
.g,
_ 3g c 4 7 v cc 2 3 -y S,37,.c c si,qs. 3 y n a c.5"C R S - 4 1
. cc yi. 37 34 c c,.yg45 39
~3' - 6 7
%cc 34-94
\\cepp.37 9 ec5g c_37
- c p
.c ~t9 As
.1'N f
. cs a-G -37, e+fy( p e.37 f
~
. c S3 A 1. 9 7cc.p g y
,cc 2 7 - 6 7
.gyg5 9,,
y 45.gy
' l"' I'AS ~# l v## *~&b ~ Y
'
- A A ' 9'
- ' "" _~
'vc 7-47 3y I ~~g3
*A**#9
' " l ' ~ 31
~ ~ ' '
c c?.2 - 39
% cc 3eps-4 7 c.c p>. g 39 reegg-3 y
'ccens-37 W 47 ccis-g.2 (p.3_ yy
. cc sy-4 7
,l'C2*39 M e' / ~ 4.1
- c c N ~. 8 2.
e f.') As - 39
"" 3 9'AS-4 7
" 32 - 4 7
'" cc 7 o 4 3 o
y
%e g k V 2 - 4.2
< < c vt.g 2
.!ee 3.c -4 7
~
M
- R""***"' g '7 ce
..gg.
- ,ayo.p
,% *' 2 - 4 2.
cc;
= <c sins-cap
.sy A" '2 ' N
'ecGg -c r c ;j-y TL1e c'- 7 4 - 6 7
\\ cc. &gg s -. c.,.) 21
. c 31,,
see nins-s u d 3p. C W S W 003-17 Document ve m
s
([j
_'%i 9 ; ' t es g.
tyi
> g.., j
,. _ _ m._
A // Il 80 A hnktNVfik
. D5 E.
t sYO L/bf II l7 '
O DM; FRai:
R. A.. Bro.m.....
.L. Snetana......
L. K.,Comstock 6 Camam 7t).
Pittsburgh Testing 1.aboratory Brai,6. cod Station Braideod Station A.and Stud Welding Inspection Checklist for the Ine attache ded to you for your inspection of locations listed bd if the installations, f
Initial Inspection (7 Reinspection
( )
cc'/CRs -82 cc3.,-61 cc72-s1 cc -31 AS-gg 41.s x.
,,ya 45-42,22 cc 4s~ - 22.
cc 97-C 7 u 24- %..
cc 3 I -
'=
" 'I l *
'" "#A ~0 2-V"S]~S7 cc'l1 ~81
' " '44-4 7 cc a3-4 y 4 3-41 cc ? 7m c u l'/
- 4 2
'* ' I AS ~
I
' o A3 'L T c eSTA S -4 3 ' cca -
cc L vAS -4 2,82
/cc 41 -39 cc 2.rMS.3?9 ccsy-")
ecs,-
eg g; gg 4484 -47 1:
~~~- M ccgy-39 cc4cm e g y g - g 2.-
J o y y - C.L.
cc84 AS-67
^ St-G 7 c.c a g AS-ST c c.cC-v r.?,
.- 6 2 cca t, - 31 W 7-4 7 cesg-yg cc g-j-f; e
et 46 ~61 Ce 2 4 MS -94.
cc 2947 cc 9e p.5 - 4 7 n % 45 42,82.
'cc.Qg-4 )
cc if -S7 cc1o-4]
c.: vi~ 8.2 CitSRS-S]
CC7/A.S-57 ccf2-4 y Project Superintendent ge. 73, g I cc:
L. Facchina CCfo ~ 02 File
(;
Cc80HS-G) d Ibcuvent rece
,y :
t-3_w.v.sg !. _ c q Q A St CT L. K. COM510 K & CDP.*PANY 7vcy/- # //Ofo8 WELD INSPECTION CHECKLIST 3,I FILEi ME.TAL E309 0 00tIo 0
DOGB [ ~ DocL3 OS I ~33t, pg
~
DCS/DE. AILS jk4 Se e h-M D
- T
/
C O I G.T S
'T39 og 4 -fo (L-C g).
Di+. a-h hEK=s m
~ Q;) Ilt '
6 ACC REJ N/A 32 FIT-UP CCMPONENTS IS CORRECT.
gi i
3.3 UNIER Cl1T IS WIMIN MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS.
GL J R.
3.4 CRACKS /DISCONTDATITIES DO NOT APPEAR IN JOINT OR PARDIT METAL.W L 35 SURFACE POROSITY IS WIMIN MINDC4 ACCEPTABIE LDUTS.
L_d1 1R 3.6 SIAG OR OIHER INCLUSIONS DO NOT APPEAR IN FINISHED WELD.
[_dl ll l
37
'IH:E0021 FUSION DCISTS BE'IWEEN WELD METAL AND BASE METAL.
QL_JI l
3.3 FIIIET SIZE /IHROAT, GEGEIRY OR PROFILE CONFORM 70 PROCEDUPI l CR REQUIPN AND DRAWING DETAILS.
39 ARC SIRIKES OLITSIDE OF PERMANENT WELD AREA HAVE BEIN GROUtO @[
lR 900IH, OR REPAIRED AS NECESSARY.
WEID AND SURROUNDING SURFACES HAVE BEEN THOROUGHLY CLhJ:E Ldl ll l
3.10 OF SLAG, SPATIER, FLUX, AND OXIDIZED PAINT, ETC.
WEIDE'R AND INSPEC'IOR IDENTIFICATION API DOICATED BY ASSIG!!ED @l 1
3.'11 SD60lS SIAMPED NEAR THE WELD JOINT.
l 3 12 WEID IS A RESULT OF A REPAIR PER ICP., NCR #
l lRQ l
REPABXS:
Meb SIG!ED Y__ -
77DA'IE //.D A SIG.NED g
DATE //./J-f1D
~QC DISFECIOR
~
IN:'.dII INSFEKA F0p'jIrFGQg;g
~~-
- .
- c
..;.c.
- _ _ _.... _................_.... ;...... c, _ _ _..,;_,_,,,._,,,,,_,,_,,,,;,-
rom vwI-1 Rev. 3 2 14-79
. r.
,. ' .f,,t P.lTTS.PJ.'.R U l.1 '.f.ld'.l'.! N O.I LA13 O RN t' O R.Y
.t a
a **u=* * **as u
.f INMl'l cTING 1:NE;INif t lts.sNI CIll.$11878
.......o....
I aiu iu..u.iam...iu ClItr.uzo, Iu.iNots
.,. g/
./
..e4coesa.a.cm.cas........
..uc.............a......
Order No: CH-3175 Client: Connonwealth Edison Report No:
74/ //./
/
Preject: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date: //./9 F4 of Visual Inspection of Structural Weldini,g, i
L K/~nshdad Page l
of d Contr, actor:
1 Actual Specified Length,, Acc Rej Rej. Defects Noted Drawing Weld Wald Wele Size Weld Type I
No.
No.
'f
.L.
C4Hi 44-5 M14 $ F?lld As
^f
,4
X k
9" X
l.3% I 4E
^
0('1R AS C.
Ie 8*
['
s
.V //i/As 3P x
m I'
M f(,
hh.* 7
)(
F k
INME%
X c
4 i
Wh
,y H
'k k
3h k.!/ g, y
f6 4
3*
XV x
4 4
3P x
/
W L
/
8 4
b h
% Conforming
-l i Non-Confoming l
l Not Aprlicable i
Acceptance Criteria: 4 Q.5 0 1. 1 '4 6 "
Remarks:/7m Ma Fl. HMTa). (e-lCPk-G,- Q<c hamund IlI2ioM y
m..,uunsJ ws ws Dw-wwa.d.xs.aao.e.m e i
Inspector: E L W1. a)
Level:1 Inspection Date:
- 1-i f-fo u
l hvigwed by: d. C.
O Level: #
SAFETY RELATED s
.........a
.e.....,
....u........
.......c.-
....;.w.=.........=...;.--
... =
Form VWl-1 Rev. 3 2-14 79
.f.F.I'3E.F.Cl4 (I.I.I 7.lWl'.l Y(.i ltoil3 014Xl'O 14 Y v. 2/*\\
f-INSI'l r.TINil 1:N(ilNitl ltS.\\NI) Cill:.'llSTS I*
,=
..ie=
acosavete...
Cili (*M 30. II,Lt NO f S witte.es.e66saois ooies ansa coot sia. cuicaco.:..sa.o
.' W e5 -
..c.co
.is.
.v............
e,.;,
- .=.==::=.::.:=.==.::= :.:= ::
Order No:
Client: Comonwealth Edison Report No: Wfl VLJ Project: Braidwood-Station REP 0RT Report Date: 11-1914 of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding 1
LM6vndd Page [ of d i
C ntractor:
Drawing Wald Weid Weld Size Weld No.
No.
Type Actual I!5pecified Length Ace Rej Rej. Defects Noted 5
.L l
ommeOcN rn FdiEf-
- 6 4
33' X
l-DML g
{
~{
3*
g P
- 3 i
31" y
~
i a
lty ;p p
y,
(
'Q k kjyja.
3 f
3 k
$$i ~??"
i s T 4,
$'M,-R;_
)(
ymAs d I
kb Ih2' f
7 d4aC
?=
k 3
$ */
l h
A C
4 4
3" j [
~
I
/
\\
D f
k N
3$ "
N i
U Conforming Non-Confoming l
l Not Applicable i
Acceptance Criteria:
s ta s bi 1. h~
\\
Remarks:
M i17nnme f I
y 6
Inspector: E L m.2eJ.aA L,
Level:1.
Inspection Date: Il-1? to
~
L i
sview.4 e
/7m tevei: 4 SAFETY RELATED s
.e....
.e we..
ee,e6.e6 * * *
- 6.. e. e. r 's 9
.a
u z
- . w
=
. w. =. u : - - ::
Fom VWI-1 Rev. 3 2-14-79
.. '%^*s P.I'1.I'dB.ti.ld I.) i i '.I',.t-lM'.l'.l.S' (.i.I t.il 1 () ItV.(' ().14 Y
-a u
- a..==
( /. r.
1 issm:crixo exuisi:::ns.wn cin:. sus rs o...'..
..o....
F aiu =. au.ia..
.u a% w
..-... i t.u x o s s cuic.wo
/e f/+*
+-
0r6er No: CH-3175
- '
- ,'.T.'1'.';.':..','. l ';' '.'::.':.:. l..':.:.'.','...' l..:::::.'.:.':.'.'ll.;:ll.. l:'
~ ~
- client: Cosenonwealth Edison Report No: W/ vt4/
I Project: Braidwood Station REPORT Report Date: // / f. f'O of i
Visual Inspection of Structural Welding Contractori A k' Co Moe k Page 3 of /;2 Drawing Wald Weld Weld Size held No.
No.
Type Actual 15pecified i Length Acc Rej Re.i. Defects Noted k
I
/
A'd G.!B93A 3 MfNis E F'. lld II L
l*b h l Q
Q Q.
g gL p
a G.
4 h
3' X'
L 4
X
$(o
.5 '
X 05-Y hfk l
wru/h,.k si" y
a c
W74hk r
x m
41 WU ns.!-
x n
M M
'MV x ac
~
P N
A ST X
r x e r
if i
3" X
U Conforming Mon-Confoming I
I Not App 1tcable Acceptance Criteria: A t13,h s. t - 7f' 4
Remarks:
hi /u *br th # 1 l
r
. Inspector:E kFA.1aM41 Level:1 Inspection Date:
1 (-l E-f C s
l 4eviewed by L f C.
m G r J Level: g SAFETY RELATED g
Form VWI-1 Rev. 3 2-14-79
,.."'.?*x Pyraianar.ta oli'.I' tes'.tila o.luxito.itva' o.ia y
't ixspecrixo nxcixin:ns.un em:.'ns rs
..,,:l';.;;,y;.,,
'u *
'u'-... ~...
./c emi.u:n,Ii.uxois
<<.g p>'-
.s I
i l
> der No: CH-3175
" ' " " ' " ".. '. "... '. ". * ". ".. ".. '. ".. '. ".. "... ' "... ".. ' - ~.
- 11cnt
- Comonwealth Edison Report No: 76/(/t,d Project: Braidwood Station REPQRT Report Date: //./9-PO of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding 1 E [n e<Mr-I.-
Page N of d Contr, actor:
f Drawing Wald Wald W'Id 512' Weld No.
No.
Type Actual SpecifiedI Length Acc Rej Rej. Defects Noted (ciM5 R Ffllh X
i 6 3393e.s i
m se m n 4
r x
I 4
1/ "
h acot-A nflWs 4
1'"
C 62/MPA v~
x ac fone-cm /
%$WA 4"
y ac 4
~'
6
@W/8A 4
X aC s
(*(/q g AWl V
Ot.
x A
}r Y
T"l/
f*/*/ $ A
'f' b
?f h
Y Y
f B
/
I I
Conforming
@ Non-Conforming I
I Not Applicable Acceptance Criterie:
A w 5 o 6 t
-J r hubi-4=r-Daaa l Remarks:
j
(
j f
3.L.#.2.M Level: S--
Inspection Date: 11-li f'0 i
Inspector:
l c-iteviewed by.84./ C.
M- #G Level:L SAFETY RELATED t
g
O Fom. VWI-I Rev. 3 2-14-79 P.iT'.i's.af. cia a i i 'Psa't'.t s o.lusia o.itv t' o.it.y
.f.y.'
- z,,
(
h
,I INSl'l;(*.TINti 1 N(IINiil:ltS.\\ Nil CIll?.SilSTS
,,,,"l ' ",=,,,,, l,,
- "**8' a' u..<. w a ai ** "
.e CIIIc.Sco. ita.txols
- a. a co.: ais.cuicaeo.a..aaeo
... co
.....u.v....
' " ' " " * " ' ' " " * " " ' ' ' " " " " * ' ' ' ~ ' ' " " ' " * " ' " " - * ' " * " * " * ~ "
Order No: CH-3175 Client: Commonwealth Edison Report No: 7/e/v4/
Project: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date: //-/ 9- (d of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding Contr, actor:
A. V o nt<foc k Page 8 of 4 l
Drawing Weld Weld Weld Size Weld No.
No.
Type Actual 15pecified Length Ace Rej Rej. Defects No 6 339sA-8 [C1Y k $h>S 4'
V b W 1-3%I 4
6
,ff i
e/"
X J
J-(Y34 A N
</
1' N
l 6
Ehl/J
> N
'l "
Y C
ms x F/ IMn s'
x 6
4 WNN433 '
A l
C h
"ffa h
a
+
f k'f0Ms.
/
8 s
VM u p
4 as-xV r
\\
c e
4 4
3
x U
Conforming K Non-Conforming I
I Not Applicable Acceptance Criteria:
LVCnm Ltne Ie 4 u.> 5 D i I - 7 5 '
htMu is mm. /
Remarks:
f
'i Inspector: M d.aa d u b Level: 1 Inspection Date: /I t Y TC uviewed nA / E.
A mteve1:g-SAFETY RELATEC 4
Form VWI-1 Rev. 3 l
2-14-79 es.. z,g Prt.i'annaalt'.I'tes'.t'aao.[i.xa.o.iwt'o.ay
(
i *,
I INSl'l;CTINti l:NGINiil:ltS.\\ Nil CIll:.IISTS
"*'ua..7s,.l,,,
S
> m..
.u.
............ Itu No u s cant wo
./.e
............._..........,.......................-.....s..........
Order No: CH-3175
",',".".*",*,,"...~.~..""....'."..'."..'."'.."..'~~.,'"....s......".....,.........."..."...
, " ' ' " ' " " " ~ * " * " " " "
i Client: Comonwealth Edison Report No: 76/ (/U Project: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date: //#-/9-ft of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding Contractor:
LW trwA AD page h of }
Drawing Wald Weld Weld Size Weld No.
No.
Type Actual n5pecified Length Ace Rej Rej. Defects _Not
}Shh}
35' Y
'3 51 8c 5'
X aC t
x 4
4 34*
1 e
f 4
3'
'$P
(
h 4
3k' i
't s'
dk p
x.%
a t
a-x %
3 4
4
+
ai' x
eexPA' f+
5%
3~
y
\\
B
/
I 33 *'
/
U Conforming
@ Non-Conforming I
l Not Applicabl Acceptance Criteria:_
4631 an/ /. FC Rosaarks:
M M udJa n [
/
r Inspector W / M u d Level:1 Inspection Date: I f t Tr To hviewed d
2.
Q Level: g i.
SAFETY RELATEC
~...
=
.i Form VWI-1 Rev. 3 2-14-79 1
ft;M'.
P.l'.I".l' Mali:R (3 I I 'l' lci'.l'.l N O.I n A I1 (litV(' ( ) H Y P
ixsiencrixo usuixnnits.ssn cuin. sus rs
'u
- a=aa==*
=>
.. m,....
a'66.i.e.itu=oi.
i.:
CiI:(
- A G O.1i.1.1 N O i.'i
... co n is.cwic.co......
.... con s i a..w.u...a....
l I
Order No: CH-3175
,,,,,,,.,.,,,.............,.......,.,,,..,.......... Report No: 7/f/ 6h/
Client: Connonwealth Edison Report Date: //-// F 0 Project: Braidwood Station REP 0RT of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding Contractor: Ak'Imm h Page 7 of Q f
Drawing Wald Weld Weld Size Weld No.
No.
Type Actual n5pecified i Length Acc Rej Rej. Defects Noted J.3%1 Cc3osu c F. lid 3"
k
.D 4
4 3 3 **
E SC )
f' X
F h
YA 3$'
)(
A
'h w-/L X
i
(
G.
9 7
H "SN).
>(
5 1
d D
k 4
'I a.! ' 'T4IA L
'h 3~
Y&L in 4
4 a.! '
y "VA S"
d T/L f
A r
I No. -Confonning i
I Not Applicab1E Confbruing I
1 Acceptance Criteria: Arx>_t
/3/. /. M Remarks:
Ish, /
/
'f Inspector.M/.Mo/M Level:d Inspection Date:
1l-JR ? o L
e 4eviewed b e
/. C. m #
m Level: (
SAFETY RELATED g
6......(,
...... ec o ge.,
gogue. a e,s.t e#
.9 9.Gif
$9 6.w.6 S.888.4
. 46%69989
.t v.6.. u. S
- f-8.**
48.' *.4...e e e.
- a..
Form vwr-1 Rev. 3 2-14-79 P.I'.ii<i'sar.ca 13.tt '.P.ss'.t'.t a'.o.I i.is a wur' o.a y e.........a...
g a
,I INSI'l (' TIN (i I;NiilNiilittS ANI) (*.1110.5118T8
...."..'".sm,"....
aiu==s. iwaoi.
in
........ II.LIxols CiticAco e
y s..................
............,.....................................s
' " ". ' " ~ ~ '
rd;r No: CH-3175 l
licnt: Cormonwealth Edison Report No: Yd///.]
t rojcct: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date: //./P-r o of Visual Inspection of structural Welding i
A W [mou./drI Page
[ of g 1
C:ntractor:
s i
Drawing Wald Weld Weld size Weld No.
No.
Type Actual Specified Length Acc Rej Rej. Defects Noted
- f. A M, /
ccMdi ffOa4 Y
X 4
.3 "
y G
\\
R 1
.Y 3a.t Y
J-k Ctb4 i
I N'
K C
Jg 4
4 y,
y cen A 4
4 v
y A tw 4
4 N
)(
ccM A 'lll ? / AIL
'N 4'
X a.c A
"N D A *m T
V s
ran /
4~'"#ll Man x
4 4
~'W//W 3
1 I
I i
Conforming C "on-Conforming i
I Not Applicable f
Acceptance Criteria:
Ar.n,n / /. v'('
<tsaarks:
- ilr odd s a
/
r f
/
i i
E I M A > M A V Level:1 Inspection Date: //-/ T-TO Inspector:
g level: I SAFETY RELATED j
9eviewed b p
......................... ~
r
~ -, - - - _ - - _.
Form Vk't-1 Rev. 3 2-14-79
- a .
Pf.1".L'd.B.i T.14 0 I l '.{' lim'.l'.l N ( i.l t A i 14 ) 14 N t' ( )
.......o...
g-
..=
.... .'a**** a, (i* M.
ixsm nrixu i.xuisi:::ns.on eni.:s.iis rs
~.. a. w -... u a ru n.u a s. li.i.isois
...u.......e.e..... u.
t
)rder No: CH-3175 l
- lient: Commonwealth Edison Report No:,/// /j4./
1 Sroject: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date: / /-/ /
- f 6 of l
Visual Inspection of Structural Welding i
/N3M Page k of d Contr, actor:
5 Orswing Wald Weld Weld size Weld l
No.
No.
Type Actual 15pecified '
Length Ace Rej Rej. Defects Noted
- i. w.i 1m.1 C fdloJ-
'h k
4' Y
\\
D V'
X
\\
a I
1t6lA$ A
$L S~
l
'j
'Vk A 5t-x i
a
(
(
[ [kh 3'
/
D kVN#4*
)C i
r
'r
&~%%h, JC I
c s'
MVt>.
h h
3$'
)(
f
/
\\
[ k h4 0
X S Conforming I
l Non-Confoming I
I Not Applicable I
Acceptance Criteria:
ALu b i 1.
- r
/ 2 d _. ine o s u /
Remarks:
V~
I Inspector:@l /> den://Y Level:1 Inspection Date: //-/ 9.fd
(
1 geviewed W
/ O. m # - r Level: #
SAFETY RELATED g
l
..... ~.
.. ~.....
w-w+..
=w.--
.--e..----
Forr. VWI.1 Rev. 3 9.
2 14 79 I
i PJ'FA9.BI.'.11 B.tl '.l'Ed'.I'.l N U.l:4i13 0.lW.l' O ll.Y
.p exsi ecrixes excixinais.sxn cun.siis rs
.....~.~....s.,....
a
.L.
1
.. u= =. u...
n Civic.wo.li.uxois
. -;,fe/
.e l
)rder No: CH-3175
" " ~... *. ". '. " ".. * ".. *. ".. '.. '. ".. ".. *. ". ~ * ".
- l llient: Conconwealth Edison Report No:
74/l/4/
3ro. ject: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date:
/ /- / 9 P" 6 of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding C;ntr, actor:
/
rnuIre Page M of g f
Drawing Wald Wald
No.
Type Actual 15pecified' Length Ace Rej Rej. Defects Noted
.l-
.L-L,
/-A M /
Tec. ins M CCin+
4 4
34 X
i L
3, X
L 4
bb' X
s'i h
8 s'
8 n
i (
e n
t 33-x ce PfAO.1 s"
7 I
R 7 M/A 3A' k
s CC3G A VIW? O
b
\\
e 4
t Wihk X l
ns A 4
4 W %,.x a c_
/
(
Y
/
\\
h w
U Conforming
@ Non-Conforming i
i Not Applicable.
Acceptance Criteria:
Araa & /.v'f
[
3P( rus /
Remarks:
r
/
(
Inspector:/41' /YEM Level:M Inspection Date: //.19-n)
- .b _ A ed.evel: g 9aviewed byF SAFETY RELATED g
s
,3 t
t
Form VVI-1 Rev. 3 2-14-79
+.**.%' '.,
PJ'J.I'dJil?.H U l i ',.l'1-lM'.l'.l N () I n A 11 U.liNL' O.R Y l
l (i'-
'l exsi.ia nsu i:xuisninis.sxn eun. sos rs
,,,,; ;,;, y;,,,
~. *.m
.. - a 1
i.i.i x o i s cnic.mo Ord:r No: CH-3175
" ~'
Report No:
7 /f / # 4 /
C1/snt: Comonwealth Edison Pr ject: Braidwood Station R.E P 0 R T Report Date: // // /'d of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding.
2Mbder Page // of M Contr, actor:
Drawing Wald Wald
No.
Type Actual 15pecified I Length Acc Rej Rej. Defects Noted fi A1 N
4 1"
Y< aC
- j. w b,/ t't* *13 A l
h k
Y
/
. uC.
h b
I cgye il
- r 8(,
L S'
X A
b/L i
J/"
7
(
C.
U// (s,t s*
y fd/fM/), 3.! '
,/-
w l
's 4
.fli) '.0)py,_
y f
4 f
' Wf/h x.Yl) h l
3
.n 4
4 3r y'.i Y
f
]
/'
8*
4
/
\\
U Conforming Mon-Conforming I
I Not Applicable Acceptance Critaria:
4z.)e A/ A [
Mes [
Remarks:
f Inspectord1/1/uu Level: 7 Inspection cate: // / f P'n h viewed by h 4 Level:I SAFETY RELATEC
.m l
i f
............ ~.......... ~.
,-mw--=--
,,a
rerm vvi Rev. 3 2-14-7s
- . 'i'D Pyr.I's.s.tr.it oli '.I'.r3'.t'.ta u.liaa onvI' o.t< */
.\\.
(
l ixsi.i:crixu i:xnixiu:ns axn en::.sisrs
,,,, ;l3,,..g.;
.t cnn.mo,1u.ixois
- - m..
-y t.
..........u......................
Order Mo: CH-3175 Client: Comonwealth Edison Report No: 7//bk/
Pro. ject: Braidwood Station REP 0RT Report Date: //-/9 of Visual Inspection of Structural Welding Contractor:
/M Page 1 o Drawing Wald Weld Weld size Weld No.
No.
Type' Actual 5pecified Length Ace Rej Rej. Defecl i.np i n' MASK F;*/AI i
N M
X C
rn,.
'Ud Hl:nna.
vali'lMinn m...
"WF ON/ V i
Confoming I
I Non-Conforming l
l Not Applicable Acceptance criteria:
stas Or.i-7 f
. sb. Aer au /
Remarks:
(
y InspectorhAl/1//w Level: [
Inspection Date: //-//- TO 4eviewed M. Z'.
- 4 Level:
y SAFETY RELATED s
.,,,.............:............*.a=
.an -a.
ia..... -+-+-*
,, m.ga,,s.
.oe.taa.
.ma.===.=*=
.* '** **w. e s.e e.tn e = ** * * ** 8 8
""********'**'6**'*
gaud G.(W.4 9Abb.e.
ff 6 44.D$. Wee.as e6Webe4 89 886 6 4 8* ' ' *WW O*' *
- U M M.I
'" * ' O ' 0 '
N'
-