ML20206C418

Forwards Zero Power Physics Test Info for Cycles 4 & 5 in Response to 881025 Request

ML20206C418
Person / Time
Site:	Mcguire
Issue date:	11/01/1988
From:	Tucker H DUKE POWER CO.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
References
NUDOCS 8811160267
Download: ML20206C418 (18)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

11' I

Duke 1%uer Compauy II'I B Te kr 70 y31jn Vue frwar,t Chbrione, N C !k242 hd* a 1klution (104)]73 4511 DUKC POWER Nova ber 1, 1988 L

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Document Omtrol Desk Machington, DC 20555

Subject:

M:Glire helear Station, thit 2 Dochet No. 50-370 Rod &mp Methodology Review Criterion Failure Report C)cle 5 startup Physics ' Dest - July 27, 1988 NRC Dequest ibr Mditimal Information Centlement

[

My letter of October 10, 1988 subnitted a Pod Saap Wthodology kview l

Criterion Failure Deport in accordance with raguirments contained in the NRC safety evaluation report for Duke Power Company's "Jbd Swap Nthodology Nports for Startup Physics 'Desting" (TC-NE-1003-A Revision 1,

Deewter 1986). This reviw criterien failure rt$ ort concerned a July 27,1988 McQ11re thit 2/ cycle 5 startup physics test.

(

In a telecon between Mr. P.B. Hartkci et.al. (DPC) and Mr. D.S. ! bod and Ms.

M. Chatterten of your staff on Octcher 25, 1988 during which this startup test failure was discusred, additicnal informaticn was requested by the NPC in order to aid in the NRC's understanding of this cwmt.

In respcnse to the NBC request, please find attached zero pcwer physica test

[

infonnation for Fcolire thit 2 cycles 4 and 5.

the attached infonnation t

includes rod worths, taiperature coefficienta, baron endpoints, and beginning i

of cycle pcner distribution ccrparisons.

The M:Glire thit 2 cycle 5 toren dilutico rate for slutdown bank B was 348 pcrt/hr.

Dilution 'tates for Natire thit 2 cycle 4 were.147 pm/hr for control bank D and 386 pcWhr for shutdown i

bank B.

t should there te any questicns regartiirn this matter or if furtler infonnation i

is required, please advise.

Very truly yours, i

g Ih1 B. Tucker i

FIE/122/mf Attachmnts l

8011160267 801101 PDR ADOCK 05000370 P

PNU

o Document Cbntrol Desk

!bvtrber 1,1988 Page 2 xc (w/attactrwmts):

Mr. M.L. Ernst Acting Ibgicnal Mministrator, Ibgion II U.S. Nacimr ^,egulatory Ormission 101 Marietta Street, !M, suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia 30323 Pr. Darl S. Ibcd, Project Panager Office of IbcInar Ibactor Ibgulatica U.S. Nuclear Ibgulatory Cbmission Washington, DC 20555 Mr. P.K. Van Iborn IRC Ibsichnt Ingector McGuize !bclear Station b

o MAlire Unit 2 ofele 4

'aro PWer Physics Test P4sults and Carpariscn l

l

7 "C30!RE-2 ;YCLE.4 ZERO F0WER PHYit;$ TEST 8E3 ULT 3 AND COMPARISONS CONTRCL 3ANK WORTHS BY 90RCN O!LUTION "EASURED. DUKE MEASURED CUAE

% O!FF 8ANA.CRTH BANA 0RTH m

IANr3 INSERTED

<FCM)

(FCMI

((M-D)/0)*188

>TL 3 641 e6e 3.75 LD. 8.!N 399 915 1.75 d

l l

I i

l l

~

l

(

l MCGU!AE.2 CTCLE.4 f

l

!EA0 POWER PHYSIC 3 TElf AESULTS AND COMP AAll3NS f

i 400 EXCHANGE AESULf3

?

MEASURED DUKE 4

MEASURED DUKE PREDICTED t 3!FF BANK WORTH BANK WORTH i

IANKS INSEATED (PCM)

(PCM) t(M.8)/P)elas CTL D IN e33 e61

- 4.24 CTL C !N 72:

384

.tg.23 CTL 3 !N 758 737

• 1.74 CTL A IN 295 346 14.74

$t IN 460 580

. I.40 l

3D IN 474 491 3.46 a

SC IN 463 491 5.78

$8 !N (Reference Bank) 499 915 1.75

$A IN 323 327 1.22 l

TOTAL WORTH 5419 5272

- 4.88 Preatttes bank merths calculates at a crittcal seren I

concentrat on of 1349 esas.

i f

i I

i t

[

MCGV!RE-2 CYCLE 4 IIRC 70WER PHYllCI fllf RESULil AND C:MPARISCNS ISOfMERMAL ftMPERATURE C.9:FFIC!!NT MEASURED - DUAE MEAlyRED CUKE lORON DIFFERENCE BANKS INitRTED (FCM/F)

(PCM/F)

(PPMI)

(M-On 2.4

+ :. a 1499

- 1.2 ARO

+

i i

1 McCERATOR TEMPERATURE CCEFFICIENT MEAluRED - DUKE MEASURED OUAE 30RON O!FFERENCE B&NAS INSERTED (PCM/F)

(PCM/F)

(PPM 9)

(M*Os 4R0

• 4.1

+ 3.1 1499

- 1.4 d

r i

i 3C30!AE-2 ;)CLE.4 ZERO FehEA saV51C5 TElf RESULTS AND C:MFAR!$0NI 10AON ENDPOINT 3 MEASURED - ; UKE MEASUAED OUKE

!FFEAENCE lANKS INSEATED LPPmi a p p.= >

is.0) t ARO 1499 1431

.ti

30. 4-IN 1398 1:89 i

f l

i

l

'M2C04 tODE-P 36 PERCDR RADIAL POLER DISTRIBUTICtf Sta-CDRE: MAP 16 - 08JUL88 1

H G

F E

D C

B A

.............***...**..............................**.........4.....s...........

.8800 *

.9382

• 1.0894

• 1.2599

• 1.1282

• 1.0608 *

.9446 *

.7910

• 8 *

.8940 *

.9620

• 1.0650

• 1.2570

• 1.1460

• 1.0810 *

.9610 *

.8040 *

• -1.5660 * -2.4740

• 2.2911 *

.2307 * -1.5532 * -1.8686 * -1.7066 * -1.6169

• l l

.9382 8

.8790

• 1.2886 *

.9412

• 1.3249

• 1.0819

• 1.2002 *

.6490

• 1 9 *

.9520

• 8590

• 1.2250 *

.9350

• 1.3000

• 1.1020

• 1.1990 *

.6710 *

• -1.4496

• 2.3283

• 5.1918 *

.6631

• 1.9154 * -1.8240 *

.1001 * -3.2787 *

• 1.0894

• 1.2886

• 1.0133

• 1.0915

• 1.0263

• 1.3095

• 1.0487

• 7256

• 10

• 1.0860

• 1.2280

• 1.0020

• 1.1270

• 1.0530

• 1.3030

• 1.0530 *

.7280 *

.3131

• 4.9349

• 1.1277 * -3.1500 * -2.5356 *

.4988 *

.4084 *

.3297

• I

• 1.2599 *

.9412

• 1.091' t.1898

• 1.1780

• 1.2064

• 1.0835 *

.4413

• l l

11

• 1.2740 *

.9420

• I d. 2 Oe*

1.1830

• 1.1920

• 1.2020

• 1.0690 *

.4540 *

• -1.1068 *

.0A49 * -

.5748 * -1.1745 *

.3661

• 1.3564 * -2.7974 *

....................... L rd *

• 1.1282

• 1.3249

• 1.0263

• 1.1780

• 1.2064

• 1.2234 *

.6635

• I 12

• 1.1450

• 1.2960

• 1.0340

• 1.1860

• 1.2220

• 1.1980 *

.6740 *

• -1.4672

• 2.2299 *

.7447 *

.6745 * -1.2766

• 2.1202 * -1.5579 *

• 1.0608

• 1.0819

• 1.3095

• 1.2064

• 1.2234 *

.8246 *

.3687

• l 13

• 1.0800

• 1.1040

• 1.2980

• 1.1860

• 1.1850 *

.8190 *

.3810

• I l

l

• -1.7778 * -2.0018 *

.8860

• 1.7201

• 3.2405 *

.6838 * -3.2283

• l t

.9446

• 1.2002

• 1.0487

• 1.0835 *

.6635 *

.3687

• i 14 *

.9640

• 1.1970

• 1.0540

• 1.0610 *

.6710 *

.3780 *

• -2.0124 *

.2673 *

.5028

• 2.1206 * -1.1177 * -2.4603 *

.7910 *

.6490 *

.7256 *

.4413

• tEOFrP 15 *

.7990 *

.5670 *

.7280 *

.4560

• Sta-CORE i

• -1.0013 * -2.6987 *

.3297 * -3.2237

• PRC? FRIOR j

toDE-P CCRE AVDWE 1.0000 S?a-OJRE CORE AVERNE 1.0002 PRCT DOOR f.fRE AVERNE

.0164 l

tooE-P MAXD4.N MM2EIUDE IS 1.3249 AT ASSIMBLY D - 9 S!M:CRE MAXIMLN MAGNITJDE IS 1.3030 AT ASSINBLY C - 10 PRCP IERCR MAXDiN MAGNI *IUDE IS 5.1918 AT ASSINBLY ? - 9 FIRCDU DUCR BL'NE221 UE MAXDut VALUES IS 1.6807 AVDWIE ABSOLUrE RELATIVE ERROR 1.6879 PERCDR ROOP MEAN SQUARE OF DE RIIATIVE hRROR 2.0689 PIRCDE ROOT MEAN SCUARE OF DE DIFFERDCE 2.1099 PERC22R

(

MCGUIRE 2 CYCLE 4 FDQ VS. MEASURED ASSEMBLY AVERAGE POWERS CONDIT13N hfP. D AT 218 SWD. EQ IE. EQ SM. 249 MWD /MTU R

G F

E D

0 3

A e....eeeeeese.......ee..

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.......

e++++++eeeee....e**eee

.9837 e 1.2064 e 1.2839 e 1.2485 1.1126 e 1.3565

.9331 +

.7506 +

8 e

.9590 e 1.0220 e 1.3910 e 1.2523 +

1.1332 e 1.3723

.9540 e

.7980 e e 2.5756 e 4391.

.6508 2796 * -1.8085 e - b 4 459 + -2.19 28 + -2.1885 e e ee e eee e e e e ++e e e e s e e e e e s e e ee e ee e ee e ee e e e e ee e e e ee e eee

,e e e.....o oe....... e eeee e e

1.3017

.9028 e 1.2598 +

.9443 e 1.2780 e 1.3791 e 1.1721

.6545

• 9 e

9978 e

.8833 e 1.2440 e

.9360 e 1.2898 e 1.2890 e 1.1868 e

.6640 e

+

1.4894 e 2.2424 e 1.2731 e

.8868 +

.8534

.9091 e -1.1722 e -1.4307 e

(

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee...eeeeeeeeee..............................

+++eeeeeeeee,e.....

e 1.2836 e 1.2613 +

1.3228 e 1,1317 e 1.0393 e 1.2842 +

1.2394.

.7219 e la e

1.0970 e 1.2460 e 1.J120 e 1.1323 e 1.3532 +

1.2910 e 1.3353

.7160 e e -1.2215 e 1.2279 e 1.3672 e

.0265 e -1.3313

.5267 +

.4251 e

.8240 e si e e e e e e.....e v e........e e e e e e......... e e........ e e..... e e.

e e........e e e e e e e e e e e e 1.2506 e

.9477 e 1.1361 e 1.2036 e 1.2134 +

1.1816 1.0553 e

.4526 e v

11 e

1.2860 +

.9473 e 1.1320 e 1.1940 e 1.2240 e 1.2016

• 1.3523

.4490 e e -2.7527 e

.3739 e

.5398 e

.8840 e

.7837 + -1.5903 e

.3137 *

.8818 e eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.........eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee e

1.1129 +

1.2809 e 1.3426 e 1.2153 e 1.2535 +

1.1893

.6755 e 12 e

1.1410 e 1.2910 e 1.0340 e 1.1970 e 1.2458 e 1.2033 +

.6790 e e -2.4628 +

.7823 e

.8317 e 1.5038 e

.6827 + -1.1388 e

.5155 e seeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee>

e 1.3614 e 1.0833 e 1.2881 +

1.1855 e 1.1922 e

.8234

.3841 e 13

+

1.8638 e 1.3918 e 1.2940 e 1.1790 e 1.1870

.8200 +

.3790 e

.1505 e

.7858 e

.4568 e

.5513 *

.4381 e

.4146 e 1.3456 e seesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeseeseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee e

.9392 e 1.1779 e 1.0422 e 1.0586 e

.6763 e

.3859 e t

.9460 e 1.1850 e 1.0380 )

1.0490 +

.4720 +

.3810 e e

.7188 *

.5992 e

.4046

.9152 e

.9375 e 1.2861 e eeet : eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, e

-7852 e

.6584 e

.7248 e

.4547 700 15

+

.7898 e

.6633

.7200 e

.4500

• MEASURED e

.4816 *

.2424 e

.6667 e 1.2444. DIFF seeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.eeeeeeeeeeeeeee PDQ CORE AVERAGE 1.2000 MEASURED CORE AVERAGE 1.2003 OlFF CORE AVERAGE

.8846 P00 MAXIMUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.2881 AT ASSEMBLY F-13 1EASURED MAI! MUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.2943 AT ASSEMBLY F-13 DIFF MA11 MUM MAGN!fuDE IS -2.'927 AT ASSEM8Lf H-11 PERCENT ERROR BETWEEN THE MA11 MUM VALUES 15

.4568 AVERAGE ASSOLUTE RELATIVE ERRP1

.9183 PERCENT 000T MEAN SGUARE CF THE RELATIVE ERROR 1.4751 PERCENT ROOT ;1EAN SGUARE CF THE DIFFERENCE 1.1036 PERCENT

MCGUIRE 2 CYCLE 4 NODE VS. MEASURED ASSEMBLY AVERAGE F0WERS CONDITION:

HFP. D AT 218 SW3. EQ IE. 52 SM. 249 MWD /MTU H

G F

E O

C 5

A eeeeeeseeceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessesesesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee se e

.9659 e

.9885 e 1.1089 e 1.2560 e 1.1243 e 1.0568 e

.9421 *

.7859 e 8

e

.9590 e 1.3020 e 1.4910 e 1.2520 e 1.1332 e 1.3720 e

.9548 e

.7950 e e

.7195 e -1.3473 e 1.6407

.3834

.7679 e -1.4179 e -1.2474 e -1.5163 e eeeesseeee***ee....

eeeeee........

ee........ee.......ee.........s

..........eeee e

.9005

.9223 e 1.2876

.9644 e 1.3205 e 1.3752 e 1.1706 e

.6536 e 9

e

.9878 e

.8830 e 1.2440 e

.9360 e 1.2890 e 1.0890 e 1.1010

.6644 e e

.1527 +

4.4507 +

3.5848 e 3.0342 *

.8922

-1.2672 e -1.2Vd5 * -1.5663 e eeeeeeeceeeeeeeeaeeeeese.....ee.......ee...e eeeee.......eeeeee.......

eeeeeeeees e

1.10J7 e 1.2876 e 1.3339 e 1.1003 e 1.0363 e 1.2302 e 1.3334 e

.7256 e 10 e

1.3978 e 1.2460 e 1.3120 e 1.1320 e 1.0533 e 1.2910 e 1.0353

.7168 e 1.3848 e 3.3387 e 2.1640 + -2.8004 e -1.5859 e

.3366 *

.1546 e 1.3408

• eeeeeeeeeeeee....................seeeeeeeeeeee...............eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee e

1.2568 e

.9644 e 1.1003 e 1.1874 e 1.1787 e 1.1857 e 1.0640 *

.4513 e 11 e

1.2860 *

.9473 e 1.1300 e 1.1940 e 1.2040 e 1.2010 e 1.3520 +

.4490 e

• -2.2706

• 1.8374 * -2.6283 *

.5528 e -2.1013 e -1.2739 e 1.1437

.5122

• eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee...................eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.

1.1243 e 1.3005 e 1.8363 e 1.1787 e 1.2256 e 1.2268 *

.6736 e 12 e 1.1410 e 1.2910 e 1.0340 e 1.1970 e 1.2450 e 1.2030 e

.6790 e

• -1.4636 e

.7359 e

.2224

-1.5288 * -1.5582 *

.3159 e

.7953 e seeeeeeeeeeeeee.....eeeeeeeeeeee......eeseeeee..............eeeeeeeeees e

1.0568 e 1.0752 e 1.2802 e 1.1857 e 1.2268 e

.8321 e

.3841 e 13 e

1.0638 e 1.4910 e 1.2940 e 1.1790 e 1.1873

.6223 +

.3790 e

+

.5833 e -1.4/82 e -1.0665 e

.5683 e 1.6601 e 1.4756 e 1.3456 e eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee...we eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee e

.9421 e 1.1706 1.0334 e 1.0640 e

.6736 +

.3841 e 14

.9460 e 1.1850 e 1.8388 e 1.6493

.6720 *

.3310 I

e

.4123 * -1.2152 e

.4432 e 1.4299 e

.2381 *

.3136 e eseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

.c.

e e

.7859 e

.6536 *

.7256 e

.4513 e NODE 15

.7890 *

.6600 *

.7200 e

.4500 e MEASURED e

.3929 e

.9697 e

.7778 e

.2889 e 0!FF l

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee l

NODE CORE AVERAGE 1.0000 MEASURED CORE AVERAGE 1.0800 l

O!FF CORE AVERAGE

.0849 NODE MAI! MUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.3005 AT ASSEMBLt 3-i l

MEASURED MAI! MUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.2940 AT ASSEMBLY F - 13 l

O!FF MAI!NUM MAGNITUDE IS 4.4507 AT ASSEMBLY G - 9 i

PEk.ENT ERROR BETWEEN THE MAI! MUM VALUES IS

.5323 AVERAGE ABSOLUTE ;H6ATIVE ERROR 1.3411 FERCENT l

ROOT MEAN SOUARE OF THE RELATIVE ERROR 1.6297 PERCENT l

ROOT MEAN SOUARE OF THE O!FFERENCE 1.7415 PERCENT l

1 l

McGuire Unit 2 Cycle 5 Zero Power Physics 1bst Results and Ccnpariset 4

f e

a

.s I

i McGuire 2 Cycle 5 Zero Power Physics Test Results and Comparisons Control Bank Worths by Boron Dilution Measured - Duke-Measured Duke Bank Worth Bank Worth-

• Diff Banks Inserted-(PCM)

'(P2)

((M-D)/D)*100 GTL D 634 633 0.16 SD. B-IN 748 842

-11.16 I

i

(

i l

t i

i i

i I

.. n 1e D

McCuire 2 Cycle 5 Zero Power Physics Test Results and Comparisons Rod Exchange Results 1-Measured

. Duke Measured Duke Predicted Bank Worth Bank Worth-

% Diff

.5ANKS INSERTED (PCM)

(PCM)

((M-D)/D)*100 CTL DltN 634 633 0.16 l

CTL C IN 826 828

-0.24 l

CTL 5 IN 696 769

-9.49 i

CTL A IN 346 299 15.72 2

SE IN 407 397 2.52 SD IN 452 484

-6.61 l

SC IN 447 482

-7.26 SB IN (REFERENCE BANK) 748 842

-11.16 SA IN J11 332

-6.36 TOTAL WORTH 4867 5066

-3.93 I

l l

L

t McGuire 2 Cycle 5 Zero Power Physics Test Results and Comparisons Isothermal Temperature Coefficient Measured - Duke Measured Duke Boron Difference Banks Inserted (PCM/F)

(PCM/F)

(PPMB)

(M-D)

ARO 1.87

-1.97 1460

-0.10 Moderator Temperature Coefficient Measured - Duke Measured Duke Boron Difference Banks Inserted (PCM/F)

(PCM/F)

(PPMB)

(M-D)

ARO 3.85 3.95 1460

-0.10 l

2 I

l l

i i

l l

L_

.p.

'p

, r.

.t McGuire 2 Cycle 5 Ztro Power Physics Test Results and Comparisons

[

Boron Endpoints i

Measured - Duke Measured Duke Difference Banks Inserted (PPMB)

(PPMB)

(M-D) 4

'ARO 1460 1434 26 SD.-B-IN 1376 1349 27 t

E 1

I b

3 t

6 f

f e

t i

e I

r 1

- - _...,. ~, -. - -... -..,, -,,,,,,,

F2C05 tODE-P 30 PERCDIP RADIAL F04ER DISTfRIBUTION, D3 XE SNA-CORE: FRP 01 - 28JUL88 H

G F

E D

C B

A

.9575

• 1.0294 *

.9221

• 1.2497 *

.9310

• 1.0356

• 1.0000 *

.6545

• 8

• 1.0050

• 1.0790 *

.9850

• 1.2490 *

.9640

• 1.0230 *

.9800 *

.6360 *

• -4.7264 * -4.5968 * -6.3858 *

.0560 * -3.4232

• 1.2317

• 2.0408

• 2.9088 *

• • • • • s***************************************************************************

• 1.0294 *

.9317

• 1.2753

• 1.0569

• 1.2978

• 1.0028

• 1.2122 *

.6371

• 9

• 1.0920 *

.9940

• 1.3030

• 1.0800

• 1.2580

• 1.0010

• 1.1750 *

.6270 *

• -4.8614 * -6.2676 * -2.1259 * -2.1389

• 3.1638 *

.1798

• 3.1660

• 1.6108 *

.9221

• 1.2753 *

.9848

• 1.3065 *

.9685

• 1.3263

• 1.0775 *

.7779

• 10 *

.9840

• 1.3080

• 1.0300

• 1.3130 *

.9840

• 1.2730

• 1.0380 *

.7450 *

• ~6.2907 * -2.5000 * -4.3883 *

.4950 * -1.5752

• 4.1870

• 3.8054

• 4.4161 *

• 1.2497

• 1.0569

• 1.3065 *

.9767

• 1.2498

• 1.1899

• 1.1499 *

.4237

• 11

• 1.2970

• 1.0950

• 1.3100

• 1.0110

• 1.2480

• 1.1950

• 1.1070 *

.4160 *

• -3.6469 * -3..'. 95 *

.2672 * -3.3927 *

.1442 *

.4268

• 3.8753

• 1.8510 *

.9310

• 1.2978 *

.9685

• 1.2498

• 1.1389

• 1.2383 *

.6632

• 12 *

.9670

• 1.2760 *

.9750

• 1.2370

• 1.1810

• 1.2000 *

.6640 *

• -3.7229

• 1.7085 *

.6667

• 1.0348 * -3.5648

• 3.1917 *

.1205

• 1.0356

• 1.0028

• 1.3263

• 1.1899

• 1.2383 *

.7946 *

.3271

• 13

• 1.0180 *

.9970

• 1.2560

• 1.1970

• 1.2240 *

.8090 *

.3400 *

• 1.7289 *

.5817

• 5.5971 *

.5931

• 1.1683 * -1.7800 * -3.7941 *

• 1.0000

• 1.2122

• 1.0775

• 1.1499 *

.6632 *

.3271

• 14 *

.9810

• 1.1690

• 1.0500

• 1.1340 *

.6980 *

.3420 *

• 1.9368

• 3.6955

• 2.6190

• 1.4021 * -4.9857 * -4.3567 *

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • c

.6545 *

.6371 *

.7779 *

.4237 * ! ODE-P 15 *

.6270 *

.6270 *

.7540 *

.4280

• Sta-CORE

• 4.3860

• 1.6108

• 3.1698 * -1.0047

• PRCr ERROR tODE-P OCRE AVERAGE 1.0000 StMIRE CORE AVER /GE 1.0001 l

PRCP ERROR CCRE AVERAGE

.0134 PODE-P hmKDU4 bmGNI'IUDE IS 1.3263 AT ASSD4BLY C - 10 S!M-CRE MAXDO4 MAGtTI'IUDE IS 1.3130 AT ASSD4BLY E - 10 t

PRCT ERROR FMXDU4 MAGNI'IUDE IS -6.3858 AT ASSDiBLY F - 8 PmCD7r ERROR DmWEDI THE onXDU4 VALUES IS 1.0129 AVDVGE ABSOWrE RELATIVE GROR 2.5884 PmCDir ROOT MFR1 SQUARE OF BIE REIATIVE mROR 3.0924 PERC MT l

ROOT ! FAN SQUARE OF BIE DIFFERDCE 3.1217 PmCD7F l

l

MCCUIRE 2 CYCLE 5 PDQ VS. MEASURED ASSEMBLY AVERAGE POWERS CONDITION:

HTP, D AT 224 SWD, EQ XI, EQ SM, /.71 MWD /MTU H

G F

E D

C 3

A

• a :. - :. a :. :. ;. ;. * ** a a a :. :. ;. u :. ; * *** *** ***+* ** ** :. :. :. :. a ;. a a a :. ;. ******** *** ******* *****e ww*,

• 1.0368

• 1.0817 *

.9692

• 1.2336 *

.9717

• 1.0603

• 1.0215 *

.6814 8

• 1.0700

• 1.1300

• 1.0130

• 1.2900 *

.9870

• 1.0440 *

.9880 *

.6540

• -3.1028 * -4.2743 * -4.3238 * -4.3721 * -1.5502

• 1.3613

• 3.3907

• 4.1896

.

. :. :. :. :. :. :. a :. :. :. a ;. :. :. :. ;. ;. a :. :. :. :. ** ** ***< ;. ;. :. :. ;. :. :..u ;. ;. :. ** :. a ;. ;. ;. ; ;. :. ;. ***** ** **........,,,,,

• 1.0797 *

.9843

• 1.2511

• 1.0658

• 1.2531

• 1.0338

• 1.2000 *

.6633 9

• 1.1270

• 1.0270

• 1.3110

• 1.0940

• 1.2720

• 1.0080

• 1.1620 *

.6420

• -4.1970 * -4.1577 * -4.5690 * -2.5777 * -1.4858

• 2.5595

• 3.2702

• 3.3178

• ** u a ;. c. a ;. e. a * ;.. ;... e. ** ** *** ******** *** **** * ** ****** ** ** * +** ** *** u. :. :... ;. ****

.9661

• 1.2474 *

.9984

• 1.2613 *

.9852

• 1.2593

• 1.0633 *

.7768 10

• 1.0110

• 1.3020

• 1.0390

• 1.3040 *

.9870

• 1.2440

• 1.0410 *

.7550

• -4.4411 * -4.1935 * -3.9076 * -3.2745 *

.1824

• 1.2299

• 2.1422

• 2.8874 i

• * ; ;. :. :.. :. :. ;. u ;. * ;. a :. :. :.. :. :. :. ;. ;. * ** ** *+****,,,,,..

.,.,,,.., *** :. a :. :. :. a :.. :.

...,,,,, a......,,

• 1.2296

• 1.0620

• 1.2598

• 1.0021

• 1.2423

• 1.1792

• 1.1124 *

.4406 11

• 1.2580

• 1.0860

• 1.2980

• 1.0310

• 1.2380

• 1.1690

• 1.1010 *

.4320

• -2.2576 * -2.2099 * -2.9430 * -2.8031 *

.3473 *

.8725

• 1.0354

• 1.9007

• ******** :. c. :. :. :. ;. a ;. ********** :. :. u :. :. a a :. a ;. :. :. ; :. ;. :. :. :. :. :. ; ************* *************++.<*<

.9691

• 1.2502 *

.9839

• 1.2410

• 1.1907

• 1.1884 *

.6822

• 12 *

.9830

• 1.2630 *

.9870

• 1.2420

• 1.1720

• 1.1730 *

.6840 *

• -1.4140 * -1.0135 *

.3141 *

.0805

• 1.5956

• 1.3129 *

.2632 *

• • a - a a a z a a a --- a a a a a a a ----..s a a --- a. a a - a a a - ;------ ;-- ;- a

• 1.0579

• 1.0315

• 1.2573

• 1.1774

• 1.1884 *

.8119 *

.3527

• 13

• 1.0510

• 1.0110

• 1.2490

• 1.1700

• 1.1640 *

.7950 *

.3440 *

.6565

• 2.0277 *

.6645 *

.6325

• 2.0962

• 2.1258

• 2.5291 *

• a :. u :. :. :. :. ;. u :. a ;. a c. ;.a c. :. :. ;. a :. ;. ;. ;. *********** :. :. :. :. a :. ;. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. ;. :. :. u u :. :. ;. ;. :. :. c.

• 1.0194

• 1.1978

• 1.0615

• 1.11:3 *

.6824 *

.3527

• 14 *

.9890

• 1.1670

• 1.0270

• 1.0840 *

.6750 *

.3420 *

• 3.0738

• 2.6392

• 3.3593

• 2.5185

• 1.0963

• 3.1287 *

• • • • • • • • • • • ;, u u :. :. ;. :. :. u. u :. :. :. a a a a a :. :. :. :. :. a :. a u. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. a :. :. :. a :.****

.6800 *

.6623 *

.7756 *

.4403

• PDQ 15 *

.6510 *

.6410 *

.7460 *

.4230

• MEASURED

• 4.4547

• 3.3229

• 3.9678

• 4.0898 * % DIFF u u u ;. : :. :. u :. :. u u :. *++ :. a :. :. :. :. ;. a :. u :. :. :. :. :. :. :.

PDQ CORE AVERAGE 1.0000 MEASURED CORE AVERAGE 1.0002 DIFF CORE AVERAGE 0139 PDQ MAXIMUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.2613

.'.T ASSEMBLY E - 10 MEASURID MAXIMUM MAGNITD0E IS 1.3110 AT ASSEMBLY F - 9 DIFF MAXIMUM MAGNITUDE IS 4.5690 AT ASSEMBLY F - 9 PERCENT ERROR 3ETWEEN THE MAXIMUM VALUES IS -3.7910 AVERAGE ABSOLUTE RILATIVE ERROR 2.3542 PERCENT ROOT MEAN SQUARE OF THE RELATIVE ERROR 2.7001 PERCENT ROOT MEAN SQUARE OF THE DIFFERENCE 2.7251 PERCENT

MCGUIRE 2 CYCLE 5 NODE VS. MEASURED ASSEMBLY AVERAGE POWERS CONDITON: HFP, D AT 224 SVD, EQ XE, EQ SM, 471 MVD/MTU H

C F

E D

C B

A

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .:.:.e::.:***.:.:.a.:.Aa******************

• 1.0370

• 1.0741 *

.9636

• 1.2545 *

.9588

• 1.0440 *

.9988 *

.6677

• 8

• 1.0700

• 1.1300

• 1.0130

• 1.2900 *

.9870

• 1.0440 *

.9880 *

.6540 *

• -3.0841 * -4.9469 * -4.8766 * -2.7519 * -2.8571

• 0.0000

• 1.0931

• 2.0948 *

+** ** ** * **

• a :. :. ;. u u **** ** ***** ** *** * ***** ** * ** ****************** *** ** * ** * :. :. :. :. e :. a :.

• 1.0741 *

.9749

• 1.2765

• 1.0748

• 1.2811

• 1.0119

• 1.1836 *

.6484

• 9

• 1.1270

• 1.0270

• 1.3110

• 1.0940

• 1.2720

• 1.0080

• 1.1620 *

.6420 *

• -4.6939 * -5.0730 * -2.6316 * -1.7550 *

.7154 *

.3869

• 1.8589 *

.9969 *

• • *** ***** ** ** *** ** *** * * * * +** *** * ******* *** * * ***** ***** *** a e e a :. a ;. :.. a a +* *** :. :. e e ta t.

.9636

• 1.2765

• 1.0119

• 1.2922 *

.9883

• 1.2922

• 1.0583 *

.7742

• 10

• 1.0110

• 1.3020

• 1.0390

• 1.3040 *

.9870

• 1.2440

• 1.0410 *

.7550 *

• -4.6884 * -1.9585 * -2.6083 *

.9049 *

.1317

• 3.8746

• 1.6619

• 2.5430 *

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .:..eeeeee 1.2545

• 1.0748

• 1.2922 *

.9971

• 1.2317

• 1.1645

• 1.1113 *

.4352

• 11

• 1.2580

• 1.0860

• 1.2980

• 1.0310

• 1.2380

• 1.1690

• 1.1010 *

.4320 *

.2782 * -1.0313 *

.4468 * -3.2881 *

.5089 *

.3849 *

.9355 *

.7407 *

. :. :. a a :. a a ******* ********* u :a :. :. :. a ************** ******* **************** :. :. :. :. :. = :. :. :. :. a

.9588

• 1.2811 *

.9883

• 1.2317

• 1.1500

• 1.2073 *

.6712

• 12 *

.9830

• 1.2630 *

.9870

• 1.2420

• 1.1720

• 1.1730 *

.6840 *

• -2.4619

• 1.4331 *

.1317 *

.8293 * -1.8771

• 2.9241 * -1.8713 *

• • • • • • • . u :. :. :. :. a :. :. :a :. a ******* *****: :. :..:. :. :. :. u a :. :. a :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :a :. :. :. :. :. :. :. a **

1.0440

• 1.0119

• 1.2922

• 1.1645

• 1.2073 *

.8005 *

.3449

• 13

• 1.0510

• 1.0110

• 1.2490

• 1.1700

• 1.1640 *

.7950 *

.3440 *

.6660 *

.0890

• 3.4588 *

.4701

• 3.7199 *

.6918 *

.2616 *

• • • • • • :. :. :. u :. :. :. :. :. :a :. :. :, :. :. :. a a a a :. a a :. :. a :. :.* :a :. :. :. :. :. :. :a :a :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :. :a a :. :. :. :. :. :.*****

.9988

• 1.1836

• 1.0583

• 1.1113 *

.6712 *

.3449

• 14 *

.9890

• 1.1670

• 1.0270

• 1.0840 *

.6750 *

.3420 *

.9909

• 1.4225

• 3.0477

• 2.5185 *

.5630 *

.5480 *

• -:. :. :. :a :. :. a :. a u :. a :. u :. :. :. :. a a :.***** u :. ;. u :. u :. :. a.********s a :. : :. :. :. a a :.

.6677 *

.6484 *

.7742 *

.4352

• NODE-P 15 *

.6510 *

.6410 *

.7460 *

.4230

• SNA-CORE

• 2.5653

• 1.1544

• 3.7802

• 2.8842

• 2 ERROR

• u. u :. :a :. :. :. :. :. :. : :. u :a :. :. a ** *** **** *********

NODE-P CORE AVERAGE 1.0000 SNA-CORE CORE AVERAGE 1.0002

% ERROR CORE AVERAGE

.0148 NODE-P MAXIMUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.2922 AT ASSEMBLY E - 10 SNA-CORE MAXIMUM MAGNITUDE IS 1.3110 AT ASSEMBLY F - 9 2 ERROR MAX?. MUM MAGNITUDE IS -5.0730 AT ASSEMBLY G - 9 PERCENT ERROR BC'IVEEN THE MAXIMUM VALUES IS -1.4340 AVERAGE ABSOLUTE RELATIVE ERROR

1. 962 PERCENT ROOT MEAN SQUARE OF THE RELATIVE ERROR 2.2558 PERCENT ROOT MEAN SQUARE OF THE DIFFERENCE 2.3819 PERCENT

- _ -.