ML20205S759

Package Consisting of FSAR Change Request Forms & marked-up FSAR Pages Re Changing Commitment to Reg Guide 1.144,per NRC 850930 Request for Addl Info

ML20205S759
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	12/06/1985
From:	TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:
Shared Package
ML20205S757	List: ML20205S755 ML20205S759
References
FOIA-86-214, FOIA-86-A-82, RTR-REGGD-01.144, RTR-REGGD-1.144 NUDOCS 8606120851
Download: ML20205S759 (6)

Text

-

+ -

. ::.r.. .E

{ COMAtiCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION FSAR CHANGE REQUEST Referenced Section of FSAR:

Table 1A(B); Page #59

/,

Description of Change:

Change the' comitment to R.G.1.144 as follows:

From: "has elected to adopt, as an alternative commitment to the above referenced ANSI standard, the guidance..."

To: "has elected to adopt, as an alternative commitment to the external audit schedule requirements of the above referenced ANSI standard, the guidance..."

References:

NRC Request for Additional Information pertaining to Comanche Peak FSAR Amendments 54 and 55, Chapter 17. Issued 9/30/85. J Jus tifica tion :

This change does not represent a reduction in commitments in the TUGC0 QA Program previously accepted by the NRC. This change will avoid misinterpretation of what is intended in the exception being taken to TUGCO's commitment to R.G. 1.144 and is being done at the request of the NRC.

Orr .iniza tion Orinina tinc R'> cues t:

!Pecuirec) TUGC0 Dallas QA Originator: .gd* f/ Accre-q?.e/c~mer.ceocy: ,ocroval Recc=menceo Oate: ///d//I C3 2

/( 4 , ;2 , u; La-

.//// YV8 ,

rust: Request ;o. Cat 0: I' c ' * # )r' d Q) @ -

( Recc= mend-Aoproval "

b DisacprovalO By p/Q Date: g g , Accrovec Gy: @ ::otate:

Accreved C Change Provided in Amencment *57 8606120051 860603 PDR FOIA GARDE 86-A-82 PDR

I

',t}J8d5,h,;5 TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY OFFICE MEMOR ANDUM To D.R. Woodlan Date November 8,' 1985 Subject FSAR Change Request Please process procedure the attached FSAR Change Request in accordance with TND-LI-15.

R.G. Spangler Supervisor, Quality Engineering RGS:mlh Attachment cc: 0.M. - McAfee J.R. Wells e

i t

l

{

?" . .

" fn%&R fik TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY log # TUS-477 OFFICE MEMOR ANDUM File # 821 To File Date November 25, 1985 Subject

- COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION FSAR CHANGE REQUEST STATUS

- We have reviewed assigned the attached the following status: FSAR Change Request (FCR) and have Transmittal FCR Letter Number Sections Description Status QJB-030 85-110 1A(B) Revise wording per NRC request > in 1 discussion regarding Reg. Guide 1,44, page IA(B)-59 i

Status No. Definition:

1. Approved

2. Approved As Noted z,3, fr3 g. f e 3

3. Not Approved ,

4. See Comments Attached 5.

6. SER Change RequiredChange has been discussed with appropriate H JWA/grr D. U. . 'JnCdlan At tac h.?en t C - Amendnent 57 R. A. Jones R. T. Jenkins R. D. Calder F. W. Madden R. E. Ballard R. S. Howard R. G. Spangler

r- -

.. .. y .c c i f. * '

C, CPSES/FSAR Discussion This regulatory guide is not applicable to CPSES; however the desig safety-related concrete structures is discussed in Section 3.8.

Regulatory Guide 1.143 Design Guidance for Radioactive Waste Management Systems, Structures ,

and Components Installed in Light-Water-Cooled Nuclear Power Plants ,

Discussion This regulatory guide is not applicable to CPSES.

Reference Section 11.2,11.3 and 11.4 for related informa tion.

42 Regulatory Guide 1.144 N Auditing of Quality Assurance Programs for Nuclear Power Plants Discussion This regulatory guide is not applicable in its entirety to CPSES in that TUGC0 QA audits are conducted in accordance with A .. ,

Draft 3, Revision 0 for construction and ANSI N45.2.12, Draf t 4 ,

Revision 2 for operations (see FSAR chapters 17.1 and 17.2) .

TUGC0 has 52 elected to adopt, as an alternative commitment to the above referenced h t!Vd' N d h U @ @ gs o dkIe-tttte.kuthadttwt4cMxm l

,wz ne.& . ru

1. M.,. vap.0. % urn a. ~ - m . ~.

.u

~~:  ? ~'

w.:..n

{j.X f"dgufa tory Guide ,1.145 j. .'.. l' .' > b -:..: t r%>, s, , u - ~ >

m Atmospheric Dispersion Models for Potential Accident Consequence Assessments at Nuclear Power Plants k

1A(B)-59 AMENOMENT 52 AUGUST 27, 1984

- L r

' . * ./'

' r'

, : .. , , . rn COMAf4CHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION [ A - [S S T O b FSAR CHAtlGE REQUEST Referenced Section of FSAR:

lA(B)

Description of Change:

Change dis'cussion section of Regulatory Guide 1.144 as shown on the attached sheet.

References:

Regulatory Guide 1.144 Revision 1, September 1980 g

Justification:

The revision number and date of the applicable regulatory guide wAE in-advertently omitted from amendment 52.

0-aanization Oricinatino Recuest: TUGC0 QA Origina tor:. ,G,Pl Rand Approval Recomended by:

Date:

& L.% 4 Approval Recommended by Date: f, yyjf)gYwh&

_ Date:

TUSI: Request fo.

Recommend-Approval Disapproval l By: Date:

Approvea O riot approved By: Date:

! Change Provided in Amendment _

CP SES/FSAR 0 Discussion This regulatory guide is not applicable to CPSES; however the design of safety-related concrete structures is discussed in Section 3.8.

4 Regula tory Guide 1.143 8

Design Guidance for Radioactive Waste Management Systems, Structures, and Components Installed in Light-Water-Cooled Nuclear Power Plants Discussion This regulatory guide is not applicable to CPSES. Reference Section 11.2,11.3 'and 11.4 for rela ted informa tion.

Regulatory Guide 1.144 C

(< -

Auditing of Quality Assurance Programs for Nuclear Power Plants Ot scussion This regulatory guide is not appifcable in its entirety to CPSES in 52 that TUGC0 QA audits are conducted in accordance with ANSI N45.2.12, Draf t 3, Revision 0 for construction and ANSI N45.2.12, Draft 4, Revision 2 for operations (see FSAR chapters 17.1 and 17.2). TUGC0 has elected to adopt, as an alternative comitment to the above referenced ANSI standards, the guidance provided by regulatory guide 1.144, 54 Revision 1 September 1980, paragraph C.3(b), " External Audits".

Regula tory Guide 1.145 Atmospheric Dispersion Models for Potential Accident Consequence Assessments at Nuc1 car Power Plants I

1A(B)-59 AMENDMENT 54 JANUARY 21, 1985

J ' . . .

g =.

• t/ 'o, 8 o UNITED STATES

{ E NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION wasnincron. o. c. 20sss A...../ SEP 3 01985 Docket Nos.: 50-445 and 50-446 -

Mr. W.G. Counsil Executive'Vice President Texas Utilities Generating Company 400 North Olive Street, L.B. 81 RECEIVED Dallas, Texas 75201 00T4 -1985

SUBJECT:

. WILLIAM G. COUNSJU REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO COMANCHE PEAK FSAR ADMEllDMEllTS 54 AND 55, CHAPTER 17.

The QualityPeak to the Comanche Assurance FSAR. Branch has recently completed its review of A The staff finds that the FSAR acceptably responds to our was earlier enclosed request with our letterfor additional dated information concerning Chapter January 7,1985. c 17 w However, the Quality Assurance the FSAR by AmendmentsBranch54requests and 55. additional information concerning o revisi informa tion. See the enclosed request for additional Please advise amendment my to the F5AR. staff when we may expect a response and/or a c Quality Assurance Branch My staff will reviewer alsorequest.

upon arrange a conference call with the Sincerely,

[ _

/' /

tjer,att em tryan n. ,

ctor for Comanche Peak Project Division.of Licensing Office of fluclear Reactor Regulation

Enclosure:

Request for Additional Information CPSES FSAR Amendments 54 and 55 cc: See next page

~ 9"

- )

n

..' ,9 Enclosure a

REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION CPSES-FSAR Amendments 54 and 55 1.

FSAR amendment 55 added the following items to Sheet 21 of Table 17A-1,

" List of Quality Assured Structures, Systems, and Components." under Item 22, " Containment Ventilation Systems."

f. Containment purge supply and exhaust ductwork and supports dampers and supports containment isolation valves and piping

g. Containment pressure relief ductwork and supports containment isolation valves and piping suction pipe debris screen This is acceptable except that the suction pipe and debris screen do not show a note under the column headed " Quality Assurance" which indicates a that these items will be subject to the pertinent provisions of the 10 CFR 50 appendix 8 QA program during the operations phase. Add such a note (i.e., A, B, or C) to these items or justify not doing so.

FSAR amendment 54 revised the commitment to Regulatory Guide 1.144 [pa 1 A(B) -59] to say that TUGC0 "has elected to adopt, as an alternative commitment to the above referenced ANSI standard, the guidance.... " To avoid misinterpreting what is intended, the commitment should be revised the external audit schedule requirements of the above ref standard, the guidance...."

doing so. So revise the commitment or justify not

f'

~.

Log i TXX-4634 TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMP File f 837

=,... .-. n..u.. ..v. ....u .ANY December 3, 1985

."'.t'.7 3./?.Y."'.'.'.

Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: Mr. Vince S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project Division of Licensing U. 5. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

$U8 JECT: COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)

DOCKET NOS. 50 445 AND 50 446 FINAL SAFETY ANALYS!$ REPORT (FSAR)

CHAPTER 17 REF: Letter from V. 5. Noonan to W. G. Counsil dated September 30, 1985

Dear Mr. Noonan:

We have reviewed your letter of September 30, 1985 requesting additional information on FSAR amendments 54 and 55. The following is our response to the two questions listed in the enclosure to your letter:

Question 1 We will add note B to the column labeled " Quality Assurance" for the suction pipe and debris screen listed under item g of Table 17A.1, $heet 21. p Question 2 We will incorporate the revised wording as suggested.

These changes will be incorporated in an upcoming F$AR amendment.

Very truly yours, W. G. Counsil

'es .

By:' p ,N/ ..s l.. ( Y J. 5. Marshall Licensing Supervisor JWA/gre

. c $. B. Burwell

.s t,m.u.n nr rrun ununen racrnw an nwar 1

j_j .4-  % **'