ML20205P998
| ML20205P998 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/19/1988 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8811090038 | |
| Download: ML20205P998 (27) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:~ o 1 1 MISSION BRIEFING ON CASK DESIGNS FOR SHIPPING AND STORING OF NUCLEAR NATERIALS OCTOBER 19, 1988 \\ 0$$'*l$iND"'* P79,7 PT)R
v 1 o i l i I THE SYSTEM VIILITY DOE -~~-g/ REPOSITORY , [RX SPENT } 1 ) OR I i FUEL 's P00. - lf MRS \\ V\\ g 's /\\ I i \\ st I \\ V O l 'g TEMPORARY \\ / (STORAGE Jt::_. _;_/ O h
V o SPENT FUEL STORAGE REQUIREMENTS IN YEAR 2003 0 TOTAL SPENT FUEL DISCHARGED: 54,000 MTHM 0 MAXIMUM REACTOR POOL STORAGE CAPACITY (WITH RERACKING): 43,000 MTHM 0 ADDITIONAL STORAGE CAPACITY REQUIRED: 11,000 MTHM 0 SPENT FUEL DISCHARGE RATE: 2,300 MTHM/YR 3
n m.ma4e _ue 4 ai . e m, A u-'.2as a am _.3 m-a
- A-m am*---
--A --.m ) w 4 l g 4 1 1 I . ~ \\ m ) g l ' ' \\% 4 -- g-. l f.%* e 2 z r .N " l ' < g (([/ w-y.- t e.. : . e ?~ ,s..a g., y , g .l. s o .I. j 4 y t r. - -I'l}l.I, c. 3 { I e I J. i p = L.. , j ,3, a t:. - g f _ q i x, i Nh 4 c I i \\ \\ = ,1 a, 9 I y k, 4 I 1 3; list Y"L e 4
l 4 i BWR,6 FUEL i ,g',j,,, ASSEMBLlES 'v, s l'p j & CONTROL i i f)lj ROD MODULE )I ,I r.. Y- - 1.. '
- s. e 3.2 i
( ' " "l .', 'f / \\ j ' ' ' ',t ? i k 4' . ~. " i 52 [. .j ";[.;[.' 4 _ i;$k '\\ l 3 i ?, 2:3 { '.' '::,T GE N E Rat @ ELECTRIC l' .e l 5
e LWR FUEL ASSEMBLIES PWR TYPICAL DIMENSION (RANGE) WIDTH 8.4 INCHES (7.6 - 8.5) l.ENGTH 13.3 FEET (11.4 - 16.6) WE!GHT 1,482 Las (1,096 - 1,515) (0.464 MTHN) BWR WIDTH 5.2 INCHES (4 - 6.5) LENGTH 14.3 FEET (6.8 - 14.7) WE!GHT 562 Las (328-619) (0.174 MTHM) G 6
EXISTING SPENT FUEL CASKS NO. MODEL CAPACITY WEIGHT-LBS. Bu!LT NL-1/2 1-PWR 50,000 5 OR 2-BWR 2 TN-8L 3-PWR 50,000 2 TN-9 7-BWR 80,000 2 1F-300 7-PWR 140,000 4 OR 18 BWR NL-10/24 10-PWR 195,000 2 7
p - N / n '~, l I*{ l g y.; \\\\\\'Ir / 4 g / o. S ~ g. N \\ 1 h J .? 4;. .s in >f fs i.g ] p: g W i p i l i ,j i A 3 - i 8
DOE OCRWM CASKS COMPANY W1 CAPACITY GA TECH TRUCK 4 PWR 9 BWR
- WESTING, TRUCK 4 PWR 9 PWR NUC, ASSUR, RAIL / BARGE 26 PWR 52 BWR NUC, PKGG, RAIL / BARGE 21 PWR 48 BWR B&W RAIL / BARGE 24 PWR 49 BWR 9
ALTERNATIVES FOR ADDITIONAL CAPACITY 0 TRANs-SHIPMENT (INTRA-UTILITY) 0 FUEL I.0D CONSOLIDATION (STORAGE IN REACTOR POOL) 0 DRY STORAGE i 10
DRY STORAGE TOPICAL REPORTS APPRQyER RTTHSER 0 GNSI CASTOR V/21 NODULAR CAST IRON CASK DESIGNJ 21 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 WESTINGHOUSE MC-10 FERRITIC STEEL CASK DESIGN; 24 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NAC, S/T STAINLESS STEEL CASK DESIGNi 26 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NUTECH, NUHOMS STAINLESS STEEL CANISTER / CONCRETE MODULE DESIGN 1 7 PWR ASSEMBLIES / CANISTER 0 FOSTER-WHEELER MODULAR VAULT DRY STORAGE, CONCRETE STRUCTURE) 83 PWR OR 170 BWR/ MODULE i l 11
.4 ~% '( 3 b,', .p I l 1 / 1 J. l e kh. e i r m (,. J i$kg [ I l p.h',-t, / I j 1* -{s; I 12 ,x x~ ~
4 i l .I .i l l l i 4 1 ( l i I 1 - / j a e t l } s + j 3 c r, 4 J .-.d j .. oQ) ' " 3 c c. g e . j i . v l Q.
- : :.g -
.. +- .s b lt l 1- -[1' - {.s a
- g.,
,= a. -,y'
- -6 4 g.-
. g* *~ ".. .,sm%.~,. t. -s*J e u . AJ
- v' 4
T.e. ', - T g yf,' 3 q g,., e 9 A. "*,!*}' m - %%1 - l q '.- s.y 44 -a.., >. _
- h* * '- * *
, ~ '
==g... ; ).
- ?
w T g, i w-t i %s N ] 1 s ..., lmt, , g 4 .on= ' ' '. ' *.. : N.;- Lk"* - j, .k,? J. 4 4 l r I 'l I j k l i I 1 d f I l 13 t i
5 l S sI 5 + a h!k, l.I!., _l li. 3 3 .s.e.! II: f g- .ges 1 =I, 1 og 8 551,,1 1Eli 6 a.e a s e... e g g g -~/ N; , -Q' 1o L o g /h / / \\ 5 I '. d.:* :.k*.;i0 I.__ _ __.. _, l l T -h.-= I v__ -. _ .i o o 0 3
==-*C 9 j gO,_e ,:., i o 1 r@-.. 0 4 $m u... . m Mw%. W 3 e -} s \\ f, k
- lg..
i l ox Tl-O / 9 1 Ig 1 = r, 1 N te i s f,, I i I e fy.) c' Q i j..*' ... ' h. ;d, 4 w .E i 9 Y% i 4 :.'. &'l ,.w g a J 1[.E. '< 'Wii g yg 4 co r -' i ul s 4: i i M ei 5 !i % m.h i 1,
k Y =- ~ ff! \\\\ \\b ' N _"g/ 7-S! ob I . 2#jy% ' \\i? E$E ,i t l l: p) '! .j eg# / <\\ ,f,. , 4 n.... 'i ,i ,[ \\ fj / / l '9l$. if. ,,.,l( ' l & -1 'Qg } W M. ; ( 'Lj~\\ - ? " Q JfT ~>c%w. l i tj [3 g[- x ~ x ~ l .A. 1 // NM / --J ll k j l R s. / / 1/ \\ f " " ~ " f I._ f ] g L= w R y! j 3 ~' l i i 7., AI)h / ll !l/ V I 1 l [ l/ .}' n ~ I l et l ,7 } l -Q' f m / .. c... -. - 3 3 ,( >4~}7 '[ j Y l g ] ~/ p TU3 7 l g, g.,s y L_'N/ I l l ~s7 \\ o ~~ I \\,_ ( 15 /
DRY STORAGE TOPICAL REPORTS UNDER REVIEW 0 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, DRY CAP I FERRITIC STEEL CASK DESIGN; 24 PWR OR 60 BWR ASSEMBLIES 0 TRAllSNUCLEAR, TN-24 FERRITIC STEEL CASK DESIGNi 24 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NUPAC CP-9 CONCRETE CASK DES!Gil; 9 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NUTECH NUHOMS - SS CANISTER / CONCRETE MODULE DESIGN; 24 PWR ASSEMBLIES / CANISTER O OTHER: NAC CONSOLIDATED FUEL CASK DESIGN; 28 CANISTERS (RODS FROM 56 PWR ASSEMBLIES) j i t a j 16
e-e.- .-m.a m -.--.a .m .s -a. L--= .%~ A .m b L -A 1. L -2_ .-a f g 0 <X O A. h% \\ \\ \\ t ( f, / ~~ - ~~ \\ 4, i k$EE s l \\ s, s L 4 s '% .. ! ! 44g % v / / ~ y *%, _= N>,, i k"g, e:s* i f Figure 1.3-1 i ) NUHOMS-24P DRY SHIELDED CANISTER ASSEMBLY COMPONENTS ] 1
7= AlH OUTLET SP HELDING BLOCK N = x n ~ ' ~.<%..- ~ ". ~ l ACCESS - ~ ~ N \\qs I 2 AN4 R ET -[ - *~ [ PENETRATION - [ > { &/ / ~ g (- )% S / N Q_~_ _.. f' - DSC SUPPOHT ASSEMiii Y N., / ~ *. DHY Sif:ELDED CAtaSIEH i ACCESS FOUNDATION St AB OPE 6 ~~- I Figure 1.3-la HUlf0MS-24P IIORIZONTAL STORACE MODULE COMPOf4ENTS 1 Y i
d 1 4 l LICENSE APPLICATIONS Slll .P12.I.fl OCONEE (DPC) 4/88 i CALVERT CLIFFS (EGSE) 1/89 l l ROBINSON 2 (CPaL) EARI.Y 89 BRUNSWICK (CP8L) EAP.LY 89 PALISADES (CP) 1989 I SECUOYAH (TVA) 1992 a i I { 1 j i 19 :
PERMANENT DISPOSAL CONSIDERATIONS 0 WASTE FORM FUEL ASSEMBLIES FUEL RODS EFFECTIVE USE OF REPOSITORY SPACE (70,000 MTHM AT YUCCA MTN ) 0 THERMAL LOADING CONTROL OF CORROSION / REACTION 1 WASTE PACKAGE GEOLOGIC MATERIALS 0 SUBSTANTIALLY COMPLETE CONTAINMENT FUNDAMENTAL ASSURANCE OF SAFE DISPOSAL PACKACE MATERIALS PACKAGE DESIGN r O 'l
s. 4 CONSOLIDATION COMPARISON 0 AT REACTOR - DONE IN OPEN POOL UNDER WATER - 2 INTO 1.1 - UNSEALED FOR COOLING - CANISTER SHAPED LIKE FUEL ASSEMBLY To FIT POOL RACK 0 AT REPOSITORY /MRS - DONE IN HOT CELL - ABOUT 12 INTO 1.1 (LARGE) l - SEALED FOR DISPOSAL PACKAGE i - PACKAGE DESIGN AND MATERIALS OPTIMIZED FOR DISPOSAL CONTAINMENT ) \\ 1 4 21
= 1 CAN))DATE MATERI Al.S FOR d,_.DISPOSA. PACK _Aff A 0 TYPE 304L STAINLESS STEEL 0 TYPE 316L STAINLESS STEEL 0 IRON-NICKEL ALLOY 825 0 CDA 102 (0XYGEN-FREE, HIGH CONDUCTIVITY COPPER) O CDA 613 (8% ALUMINUM BRONZE) v CDA 715 (70 CV-30N!) 22
i STAFF ANALYSIS OF TWO ALTERNATIVES 0 DASED ON OCONEE APPLICATION 0 3 PLANTS /2112 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 10 YEAR COOLED FUEL, STORED FOR 20 YEARS 0 IF-300 SHIPPING CASK l 0 RISK BASED ON NUREG-0612 (GI A-36) 0 NUHOMS-7 ASSUMED SHIPPABLE 0 NUHOMS-24P ASSUMED UNSHIPPABLE r l i i 23 l
SM I P' ',.B L E UNSHIPPABLE RESULTS 2NISTER CANISTER NUHOMS-7 AUHOMS24P DOSE 532 MAN-REM 204 MAN-REM RISK 2 X 10-6 3 X 10-6 (P 6,25 REM) COST $58M $34M 24
~ CONCLUSIONS l 0 MOST SPENT FUEL WILL TRAVEL FROM l REACTOR FOOLS TO REPOSITORY /MRS l O FUEL VARIETY AND SITE VARIETY DICTATE CASK VARIETY l 0 ONLY MODEST SAFETY /ALARA BENEFITS AVAILABLE IN DRY STORAGE OPTIONS l 0 FINAL DISPOSAL CASK WILL PROBABLY BE REPOSITORY-SPECIFIC, RELIABLE i COMPLETE CONTAINMENT AT STAKE O NRC SHOULD REVIEW VARIETY OF CASK DES!cas - AS COMPATIBLE AS REASONABLY ACHIEVABLE ) 4 i i as J
o. d 1 i 1 a f i a j t 1 RANGE OF FUTURE ACTIONS 1 l PaLEMAKlfLQ O PART 71 - TRANEPORT CERTIFICATION O PART 72 - SEPARATE STORAGE LICENSING - COVERS MRS ALSO - REVISION IDR GENERAL LtcENSE AT 1 REACTORS IN PR0 CESS O PART 60 - HLW DISPOSAL 1 LICENSING 0 DUKE POWER COMPANY - Oc0 NEE ] 0 CP&L - H. B. ROBINSON, BRUNSWICK I i j l 1 i t i i 26 I
%%%%%%dd%%%% 6%%% 6%%%%%%%%%%;( Af ffggggggigig i tPAHSMITTAL T0: / Document Control Oesk. 016 Phillips b ADVANCE 0 COPY TO: The Public Document Roem 7 4 /0lAYlf? A 0 ATE: /gx i FROM: SECY Correspondence & Records Branch g F F Attached are copies of a Comission meetir#g transcript and related meeting 5 document (s). They are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession List and placement in the Public Document Room. No other distribution is requested or j required. j Suhe cu, d444 Amhw & M, aw6 h Meeting
Title:
v' 0 f v p dk$ ^y-rd llAbebas 7LLftdgle o& Meeting Date: /ch4 /# Open X Closed I h, ( Item Description *: Copies / Advanced DCS C to POR Copy { 's is i
- 1. TRANSCRIPT 1
1 a } l,!< h m go -1 b ) j / t 2. l l 3. N I f 4. 6! s. i c 5 6 j y PDR is advanced one copy of each document, two of each SECY paper. C1R Branch fil"5 the original transcript, with attachments, withcut SECY l pacers. ,7p., mmmmmmmmunmunmumh{ ms t u -}}