ML20205P998
| ML20205P998 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/19/1988 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8811090038 | |
| Download: ML20205P998 (27) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:~ o _ 1 i 1 MISSION BRIEFING ON CASK DESIGNS FOR SHIPPING AND STORING OF NUCLEAR NATERIALS OCTOBER 19, 1988
\
0$$'*l$iND"'* P79,7 PT)R
v 1
<,- o ,
, i l i I THE SYSTEM VIILITY DOE ,
-~~-g/ , - .
SPENT } REPOSITORY ,
- [RX
's FUEL P00 . -
lf
) OR MRS I
1 i l
\ V\ g 's /\
I i
\ st I
\
V O l
'g TEMPORARY \ /
(STORAGE Jt::_. _;_/ O h
V o SPENT FUEL STORAGE REQUIREMENTS IN YEAR 2003 0 TOTAL SPENT FUEL DISCHARGED: 54,000 MTHM 0 MAXIMUM REACTOR POOL STORAGE CAPACITY (WITH RERACKING): 43,000 MTHM 0 ADDITIONAL STORAGE CAPACITY REQUIRED: 11,000 MTHM 0 SPENT FUEL DISCHARGE RATE: 2,300 MTHM/YR l 1 3
n m.ma4e _ue 4 ai . e m , A u-'.2as a am _.3 --- m-a *A- m am*--- --A --.m - - - - - - - - - - - - - -----'- ) . - w 4 l g 4
- 1 1
I ,
- \
- . ~ ' - .
) ,. g -
,, m ,
l ,'
-, ' ' \% .
4 -- g- . . , - - ' l % 2 f.%* .. . z e r l
.N " .
' < g (([/ '
w- y.- e .. : ._ t -
.' . e ?~ ,s.
.a:
yg., l
, g . . .l.j s .
4 o .I . t y -
- r. .
. .. c.
-I'l}l.I, -
3 - { .
. I e I ' '
p . J. = i . a t:. !, ,
. *. - g ,3,
,j L.. ,
f .
- _ q i x, i N 4
I c h ' \ i
,. a,
,1 = -
\
I
.% 9 ' .
y 4 k, ,- I l 1 3; list Y"L e 1 l 4 l
l .. - 4 i BWR,6 FUEL
, i ; '"'
,g',j,,,
ASSEMBLlES
& CONTROL i s 'v, j 'p l
i f)lj ROD MODULE ' r..
)I
,I Y-
- 1. . ' . -
- ; s. e . . ;
3.2 i
.', 'f
( /
' " "l \
j ' ' ' ',t ?
. ~ . "
i k ' 4'
, i 52 [.
.j
";[.;[.'
4 _ i;$k
'\ l
' 3 .
i
., . ?,
2:3 . { ' :.' '::,T
- GE N E Rat @ ELECTRIC *
* .e l' l
5
,, - e . LWR FUEL ASSEMBLIES PWR TYPICAL DIMENSION (RANGE) WIDTH 8.4 INCHES (7.6 - 8.5) l.ENGTH 13.3 FEET (11.4 - 16.6) WE!GHT 1,482 Las (1,096 - 1,515) (0.464 MTHN) BWR WIDTH 5.2 INCHES (4 - 6.5) LENGTH 14.3 FEET (6.8 - 14.7) WE!GHT 562 Las (328-619) (0.174 MTHM) G 6
EXISTING SPENT FUEL CASKS NO. MODEL CAPACITY WEIGHT-LBS. Bu!LT NL-1/2 1-PWR 50,000 5 OR 2-BWR 2 TN-8L 3-PWR 50,000 2 TN-9 7-BWR 80,000 2 1F-300 7-PWR 140,000 4 OR 18 BWR NL-10/24 10-PWR 195,000 2 7
$ p
- N ,, .
.- . / ' '
n
~, .
l ' I*{
- l g .
y .; g 4
\\\'Ir o.
/
/ ~
S g . N ': .
\
1 .
.' h
.? 4;.
J '
.s i.g ,
in >f fs p:
] -'
g W i p i
,jl i .
. i -!
A -i 3 8
DOE OCRWM CASKS COMPANY W1 CAPACITY GA TECH TRUCK 4 PWR 9 BWR WESTING, TRUCK 4 PWR 9 PWR NUC, ASSUR, RAIL / BARGE 26 PWR 52 BWR NUC, PKGG, RAIL / BARGE 21 PWR 48 BWR B&W RAIL / BARGE 24 PWR 49 BWR 9
- ALTERNATIVES FOR ADDITIONAL CAPACITY 0 TRANs-SHIPMENT (INTRA-UTILITY) 0 FUEL I.0D CONSOLIDATION (STORAGE IN REACTOR POOL) 0 DRY STORAGE l
i l l 1 10
DRY STORAGE TOPICAL REPORTS APPRQyER - RTTHSER 0 GNSI CASTOR V/21 NODULAR CAST IRON CASK DESIGNJ 21 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 WESTINGHOUSE MC-10 FERRITIC STEEL CASK DESIGN; 24 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NAC, S/T STAINLESS STEEL CASK DESIGNi 26 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NUTECH, NUHOMS STAINLESS STEEL CANISTER / CONCRETE MODULE DESIGN 1 7 PWR ASSEMBLIES / CANISTER 0 FOSTER-WHEELER MODULAR VAULT DRY STORAGE, CONCRETE STRUCTURE) 83 PWR OR 170 BWR/ MODULE i l l 11
. .4 ~%
'(
3 b ,' ,
.p I
l 1 / , 1 J. l > e - e kh. r m i . ' (,. ., J I , i$kg$ [ , l p .h',-t ,
/
I :; j 1*
- -{s; I
12 x ,
~
- .. 1 4
i l .I .i l l l i 4 1 ( l i I 1 !, - / j
- a .
e - t l } s + j c r, 3 .,, < 4 J j c c.
. . .- .d .
. . oQ) ' "
3
.., g e ., .
i - - . j . , ; ,,
. v *
- : : :.g - "
l . . Q. .. . . +- .s b lt a * -'
-,y' 1- '
l
-[1' - { .s
, a. , g . , -
..- ,, ,= ,,.
u -s*J -
- *-6 . g* *~ ". . .
e 4 g.- &
. AJ
- v' 4 " -
T .e. ', - e g, ., ., . 3,sm%.~ q ,. tT . g yf ,' A. s.y 9 q '.-. , ' ' .
-a . . , > . __
"* ,!*}' 44 m- -
%%1 - l
, ~ ' ==g . .. ; ). .
;- w *: ?
*
- h* * '- *
- T g,
i w- t i .
%s N
1 . . .. , ,. -
.- .. s .
] . . , g , ,
. . . , lmt, ' ' ' . ' * . . : N.;-
' -' . 4 **' >
.k,? J.
. . . .on= .
Lk"* - j, 4 4 l r I & 1 'l l I j k l l i I 1 d f I l l 1 ! 13 I t i I
sI S 5
+ a l
5 h!k, _l li. l.I! 3
.s.e.! .,! II: f 3
.ges g-1
=I , og. 81 551,,1 6 1Eli a .e a s e . . . e g g g
-~/
N; % o L
/ -Q' 1 o g /h !
/ \ 5 I '.
T -h.-= ' d.:* :.k*.;i0 v__ - . _ I.__ _ __.. _,
==-*C ll
.i o 0
o ... .' I 9 3 . j o gO,_e ,:.'
. ,:., i 1
0 r@- . . 4 $m m
" u... .
Mw%. W
-}
3 e s
< : , \
f, ki ;lg.. l o x
., _ _ _ _ - Tl-O
. 9 1 .
! /
Ig 1 - - te
= r, 1 s i
N i I - f,, e I fy.) j..*'
. . . ' h. ;d, c' Q i 4
w $ .E i .,. 9 . 4 Y%
... i J $
,.w g 1[.E. '<
a &'l
'Wii 4
c o r -' i ul s g yg -
. M 4:
ei i i
- 5 :> !i
% m.h i 1, '
Y k ~ =-
\\ ,
\b
' N _"g/ ff!
7-S! I
,< ob :
'. 2#jy%
,i t l l: p) '! '
' \i? E$E
! / <\ .
.j eg#
'i ,i
,f , . , ,,_ _
, 4 n . . . . ..
\ /
fj
/
,[
l '
'9l$.W
-1 if.
, ,. ,l( ' l & -
'Qg } -
M. ; x( 'Lj~\ - ? " Q JfT ~>c%w . l l i
~ x . , :
' l tj [3 g[- 1
. , .A . !'
~
ll
// NM k j
/ R
--J l
/ s . / -
1/ f I._ .
" " ~ "
\ f f
] g ,' -. L= ,.' , . w
~'
R y! j 3
/ l i % i AI)h ll 7.,
!l/ V I .$ 1 l [ n
} l/ .}' l ,7 ,
~
I l et
-Q'. . c.f .. - m .- / l 3 3
~/
,( >4~}7 '[ j Y g l
] p l g, TU3 7 , , y . - - g .,s L_'N/ I l
~s7 l -
\ o
~~
\,_ .
I (
/ <! ,
15
DRY STORAGE TOPICAL REPORTS UNDER REVIEW 0 COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, DRY CAP FERRITIC STEEL CASK DESIGN; 24 PWR OR I 60 BWR ASSEMBLIES 0 TRAllSNUCLEAR, TN-24 FERRITIC STEEL CASK DESIGNi 24 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NUPAC CP-9 CONCRETE CASK DES!Gil; 9 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 NUTECH NUHOMS - SS CANISTER / CONCRETE MODULE DESIGN; 24 PWR ASSEMBLIES / CANISTER O OTHER: NAC CONSOLIDATED FUEL CASK DESIGN; 28 CANISTERS (RODS FROM 56 PWR ASSEMBLIES) , j i t a j 16
e- ,% e.- .-m.a m .- -.--.a .m .s -a. L--= . . .%~ * - A - - - - - -. .m b L _ * - - -
-- -A 1. L -2_ - . .-a f g 0
<X O
A. h% ,
\
\
- \
t ( - , f,
~~ -
/
~~
\ 4,
$ .. k$EE s i
l L
, - ,, \ s, s 4
s '%
.. ! ! 44g % v
/ .. '
/ ~
y *%, _= i N>,, k"g , e:s* i f Figure 1.3-1 i ) NUHOMS-24P DRY SHIELDED CANISTER ASSEMBLY COMPONENTS ] 1 _. _ __. . -_ _. _ _ _ _ - . _ _ - _ _- _ - _ . _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ -.. _ - _
7= AlH OUTLET SP HELDING BLOCK - N
=
n x
~ '
' ~ .<% . .- -
l ACCESS - .
~". ~
~
~
',- N
% \qs 2
. . , I AN4 R ET '
-[ - *~
PENETRATION % [> * [ { g &/ _.
~
/ -
(- S
)% -
/
N Q_~_ _.. ..
- DSC SUPPOHT ASSEMiii Y f'
N., / ~ *. DHY Sif:ELDED CAtaSIEH i ACCESS - - FOUNDATION St AB OPE 6 ~~- I Figure 1.3-la HUlf0MS-24P IIORIZONTAL STORACE MODULE COMPOf4ENTS 1 i Y >
d 1 4 l LICENSE APPLICATIONS Slll .P12.I.fl OCONEE (DPC) 4/88 i CALVERT CLIFFS (EGSE) 1/89 l l ROBINSON 2 (CPaL) EARI.Y 89 BRUNSWICK (CP8L) EAP.LY 89 PALISADES (CP) 1989 I SECUOYAH (TVA) 1992 a i I { 1 j i' l l 19 :
PERMANENT DISPOSAL CONSIDERATIONS 0 WASTE FORM FUEL ASSEMBLIES FUEL RODS EFFECTIVE USE OF REPOSITORY SPACE (70,000 MTHM AT YUCCA MTN ) 0 THERMAL LOADING CONTROL OF CORROSION / REACTION 1 WASTE PACKAGE GEOLOGIC MATERIALS 0 SUBSTANTIALLY COMPLETE CONTAINMENT FUNDAMENTAL ASSURANCE OF
- SAFE DISPOSAL PACKACE MATERIALS PACKAGE DESIGN r
O 'l
s. 4 CONSOLIDATION COMPARISON 0 AT REACTOR
- DONE IN OPEN POOL UNDER WATER
- 2 INTO 1.1
- UNSEALED FOR COOLING
- CANISTER SHAPED LIKE FUEL ASSEMBLY To FIT POOL RACK 0 AT REPOSITORY /MRS
- DONE IN HOT CELL l
- ABOUT 12 INTO 1.1 (LARGE)
- SEALED FOR DISPOSAL PACKAGE i - PACKAGE DESIGN AND MATERIALS OPTIMIZED FOR DISPOSAL CONTAINMENT ,
)
\ .
1 4 21
=
1
. CAN))DATE MATERI Al.S FOR d,_.DISPOSA. PACK _Aff A
0 TYPE 304L STAINLESS STEEL 0 TYPE 316L STAINLESS STEEL 0 IRON-NICKEL ALLOY 825 0 CDA 102 (0XYGEN-FREE, HIGH CONDUCTIVITY COPPER) O CDA 613 (8% ALUMINUM BRONZE) v CDA 715 (70 CV-30N!) 22
i STAFF ANALYSIS OF TWO ALTERNATIVES 0 DASED ON OCONEE APPLICATION , 0 3 PLANTS /2112 PWR ASSEMBLIES 0 10 YEAR COOLED FUEL, STORED , FOR 20 YEARS ' 0 IF-300 SHIPPING CASK l 0 RISK BASED ON NUREG-0612 (GI A-36) 0 NUHOMS-7 ASSUMED SHIPPABLE 0 NUHOMS-24P ASSUMED UNSHIPPABLE , r l i i l l l 23 l
SM I P' ',.B L E UNSHIPPABLE RESULTS 2NISTER CANISTER NUHOMS-7 AUHOMS24P DOSE 532 MAN-REM 204 MAN-REM RISK 2 X 10-6 3 X 10-6 (P 6,25 REM) COST $58M $34M 24
~ ,
CONCLUSIONS l 0 MOST SPENT FUEL WILL TRAVEL FROM l REACTOR FOOLS TO REPOSITORY /MRS l
- O FUEL VARIETY AND SITE VARIETY
- DICTATE CASK VARIETY l 0 ONLY MODEST SAFETY /ALARA BENEFITS AVAILABLE IN DRY STORAGE OPTIONS l
0 FINAL DISPOSAL CASK WILL PROBABLY
- BE REPOSITORY-SPECIFIC, RELIABLE i
COMPLETE CONTAINMENT AT STAKE O NRC SHOULD REVIEW VARIETY OF CASK DES!cas - AS COMPATIBLE AS
- REASONABLY ACHIEVABLE 4
)
i i _ as J
- o. d ,
l 1 i 1 a f i a j t 1 ; RANGE OF FUTURE ACTIONS 1 l PaLEMAKlfLQ , O PART 71 - TRANEPORT CERTIFICATION O PART 72 - SEPARATE STORAGE LICENSING
- COVERS MRS ALSO
- REVISION IDR GENERAL LtcENSE AT 1
' REACTORS IN PR0 CESS O PART 60 - HLW DISPOSAL :
1 LICENSING ' 0 DUKE POWER COMPANY - Oc0 NEE ! ] 0 CP&L - H. B. ROBINSON, BRUNSWICK ! I i j l 1 i , t i i
- 26 I
%%%%%%dd%%%% 6%%% 6%%%%%%%%%%;( Af ffggggggigig i tPAHSMITTAL T0: / Document Control Oesk. 016 Phillips b
The Public Document Roem 7 4 ADVANCE 0 COPY TO: 0 ATE: /0lAYlf? A FROM: i - SECY Correspondence & Records Branch
/gx ;
g F F Attached are copies of a Comission meetir#g transcript and related meeting 5 document (s). They are being forwarded for entry on the Daily Accession List and ! placement in the Public Document Room. No other distribution is requested or j required. j Meeting
Title:
Suhe cu, d444 Amhw & M, aw6 h v p v' 0 > dk$f^y- rd llAbebas 7LLftdgle o& Meeting Date: /ch4 /# Open X Closed I ( Item Description *: Copies
- h, Advanced DCS C
/
's to POR Copy {
is i
- 1. TRANSCRIPT 1 1 a } l,!< h m go
-1 b ) j
/ t
- 2. l l
- 3. ;
N I
- 4. f 6!
- s. . i c
5 6 j y _ PDR is advanced one copy of each document, two of each SECY paper. C1R Branch fil"5 the original transcript, with attachments, withcut SECY l pacers. ,7p., t mmmmmmmmunmunmumh{ums
._. _ _ _ . -}}