ML20205C164
| ML20205C164 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/11/1985 |
| From: | Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards |
| To: | Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards |
| References | |
| ACRS-2326, NUDOCS 8509200169 | |
| Download: ML20205C164 (13) | |
Text
-
. DR l 8 wuuss AJ CERTIFIED COPY ISSUED: July 11, 1985 MINUTES OF THE MAINTENANCE PRACTICES AND PROCEDURES SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING JUNE 18, 1985 WASHINGTON, D.C.
A meeting was held by the ACRS Maintenance Practices and Procedures Subcommittee to review the maintenance and surveillance program plan.
Notice of the meeting was published in the Federal Register on May 31, 1985 (Attachment A). The schedule of items covered in the meeting is in Attachment B. The list of attendees is in Attachment C. A list of the handouts is in Attachment D. The handouts are filed with the office copy. H. Alderman was the ACRS Staff member for this meeting. The meeting was convened at 8:30 a.m.
Principal Attendees:
ACRS Members NRC Staff G. Reed, Chairman J. Koontz C. Wylie H. Booher D. Ward G. Cwalina" W. Kerr P. W. McLaughlin J. P. Jankovich ACRS Staff H. Alderman H. Bocher, Chief, Licensee Qualifications Branch, NRR, - Introduction Mr. Booher identified his staff and discussed each person's area of expertise. Mr. Bocher noted the objective of the Maintenance and Surveillance Program Plan (MSPP) is to identify factors that contribute to programmatic effects and aspects of overall maintenance effectiveness. Another objective is to identify practices which reduce human error rate in performance and maintenance. Also of concern is improving the effectiveness of maintenance programs for the operability of safety systems. The program aims to reduce, if possible, the radiological exposure to maintenance personnel.
RW 5 jR" 5 N DEICHTED onIGInt, 4
4 3 h
l t
ii a cerunea y,jgg 8509200169 050711 -
m.
=
me};h}
w 1 L m.
e .'.i $896 goy L
2 June 18, 1985 Meeting
- MAINTENANCE PRACTICES & PROCEDURES J. Jankovich, DHFS, NRR - Maintenance and Surveillance Program Plan 5 Mr.' Jankovich pointed cut that their definition of maintenance includes not only preventive and corrective maintenance but also includes surveillance and all the activities associated withinteractions surveillance.
Included under the broad definition of maintenance are:
with operations and post-maintenance, administration and management of maintenance programs, personnel selection and qualifications, procedures, documentation and material control and spare parts.
Mr. Jankovich noted that the first year's activity is to look at the The second and third present status of nuclear power plant maintenance.
years' activity will be to define specific actions for the NRC to take.
The n.ethods to be used during the initial phase include site surveys, maintenance indicators,-follcwing the activities of the standards groups and interactions with industry groups involved with maintenance.
G. Cwalina, Maintenance / Surveillance Section, - Survey of Current Maintenance Practices This work will be accomplished in conjunction with Battelle, which has a The components of this task include:
technical assistance contract.
data collection and assessment, reviewing the Salem preventive maintenance program, development of a questionnaire, performing site surveys, and, finally, a summary report. Phase one will determine what Phase two programs and practices exist in the nuclear industry today.
will look at specific problem areas and try to find out where they can be improved.
Phase one will determine what percentage of maintenance is corrective Of interest maintenance and what percentage is preventive maintenance.
The survey is.how preventive and corrective maintenance are planned.
3 June 18, 1985 Meeting
- MAINTENANCE PRACTICES & PROCEDURES The interface will look at the interface of maintenance and operations. One aspect of of maintenance and radiation protection will be explored.
the' survey will explore how much maintenance is done by utility personnel and how much is done by contractor personnel.
P. McLaughlin, Licensee Qualifications Branch - Maintenance Indicators Mr. McLaughlin remarked that the plant maintenance programs were bro administration, policies and down into subcategories. These are:
procedures, the human subcategory, and theThe technical overall category whic dealt with; tools, equipment and parts availability.
performance of the maintenance program is termed.the intermediate indicator.
The overall safety of the plant is the final safety indicator. One aspect of the maintenance problem is to determine if there is any relationship between the intermediate safety indicator and the final safety indicator.
Mr. Jankovich pointed out that there is some correlation in a statistical sense between the intermediate indicaters and the At this time the correlation is fairly low but they safety indicators.
indicate trends.
J. Koonz, Licensee Qualification Branch Ms. Koonz noted that there hasn't been any systematic approach to a determination of what should be the job-relevant types of qualification The reviews have been and training specifically for maintenance people.
fragmentary and occur mainly during operating license review for a facility.
She noted that part of the problem is that there is a lack of Another area of standard maintenance personnel job classifications.
concern is that education and experience and training for maintenance Part of the problem is that training programs personnel vary widely.
are plant-specific and, as such, are not participated in by temporary IP
4 June 18, 1985 Meeting MAINTENANCE PRACTICES & PROCEDURES Ms. Koonz also noted that selection and screening and contract workers.
criteria have not been regulated in the past for maintenance or operations personnel.
Mr. Reed canvassed the Subcommittee at this point regarding the full 8-10,1985). The Committee presentation (304th ACRS Meeting, August consensus was that Dr. Booher should present a shortened presentation of about 45 minutes.
The meeting was adjourned at 12:06 p.m.
NOTE: A complete transcript of the meeting is on file at the NRC Public Document Room at 1717 H St., N.W., Washington, DC or can be obtained at cost from Ann Riley & Associates, 1625 I St., N.W.,
Suite 921, Washington, DC 20006, telephone (202) 293-3950.
i
++w- -
e -e.
> - - + = *
~Op. . _ _
v ~ ~ ^ ~
- 31. 1985 / Notic;s Fe'd:ral R:gister / Vol. 50. N2.105 / Fridry. May 23206 Advisory Committee on Reactor meeting on June 18. Room 1046,1717 H Safeguards Subcommittee on
' n) agenda for subject meeting shall Street.NW Washington,DC. Systematic Evaluation Program (San ,
be ce f allows: The entire meeting willbe open to Onofre); Meeting Tuesday.fune.1& 1985-2:00 pan. until public attendance.
th2' conclusion ofbusiness ,
ne agenda for the subject meeting The ACRS Subcommittee on na Subcommittees will explore the Systematic Evaluation Program (San shall be as follows:
useef natural aptitude selection Onofre) will hold a meeting on June 19.
Tuesdoy, June la 1985~&30 a.m. until 1985. Room 1046,171711 Street NW, ye senIed by taIe ts the conclusion of business Washington. DC. ,
m;mbers of the public with the ne entire meeting will be open to The Subcommittee will review the l co:currence of the Subcommittee maintenance and surveillance program public attendance. {
Ch:irman; written statements will be ne agenda for the subject meeting cceept;d and made available to the plan.
Committee. Recordings will be permitted Oral statements may be presented by shallbe as fo!!ows:
only during those portions of the Wednesday./un,e 19.19pJo ain. unt#
on u nce i t e ubc mm ttee the conclusmn of business cn q s ion y e ske o y by Chairman: written statements will be ne Subcommittee will review the i members of the Subcommittee. its accepted and made available to the consultants, and Staff. Persons desiring Committee. Recordings will be permitted Integrated Plant Safety A '
ta m:ka oral statements should notify only during those portions of the (IPSAR) far San Onofre Unit 1.
Oral statements may be presented by tha ACRS staff member named below as meeting when a transcript is being kept. members of the public with the far in cdvance as is practicable so that and questions may be asked only by ,
cppropriate arrangements can be made. members of the Subcommittee.Its concurrence of the Subcommittee ,
During the initial portion of the Chairman; written statements will be consultants, and Staff. Persons desirin8 accepted and made available to the mating, the Subcommittee, along with to make oral statements should notify cny c f its consultants who may be Committee. Recordings willbe permitted '
pres:nt, may exchange preliminary the ACRS staff member named below as only during those portions of the far in advance as is practicable so that meeting when a transcript is being kept, vi;ws regarding matters to be considered dunng the balance of the appropriate arrangements con be made. and questions may be asked only by During the initial portion of the members of the Subcommittee,its ubcommittee will then hear meeting. the Subcommittee, along with consultants, and Staff. Persons desiring presentations by and hold discussions any of its consultants who may be to make oral statements should notify with representatives of the NRC Staff, ' present, may exchange preliminary the ACRS staff member named below as its consultants, and other interested views regarding matters to be far in advance as is practicable so that -
persons regarding this review. considering during the balance of the appropriate arrangements can be made.
Further information regarding topics meeting. During the initial portion of the , ,
ta be discussed, whether the meeting meeting. the Subcommittee, along with ,,
hns been cancelled or rescheduled, the ne Subcommittee will then hear Chrirman's ruling on requests for the presentations by and hold discussions any ofits consultants who may be with representatives of the NRC Staff, present. may exchange preliminary
- cpportunity to present oral statements its consultants, and other interested views regarding matters to be cnd the time allotted therefor can be considered during the balance of the cbtrined by a prepaid t-lephone call to persons regarding this review.
tha cognizant ACRS staff member. Mr. Further information regarding ' topics meeting.
J:hn Schiffgens or Mr.IIerman to be discussed.whether the meeting The Subcommittee will then hear .
Ald;rman (telephone 202/634-1414) has been cancelled or rescheduled thepresentations by and hold discussions with representatives of the NRC Staff.
between 8.15 a.m. and 5:00 p.m EDL Chairman a ruling on requests for the '
Persons planning to attend this meeting opportunity to present oral statements its consultants. and other interested cre urged to contact the above named persons regarding this review.
individual one or two days befcre the and the tin e allotted therefor can be _' ,
obtained by a prepaid telephone call to Further information regarding topics sch:duled meeting to be advised of any the cognizant ACRS staff member.Mr. to be discussed. whether the meeting l
changes in schedule, etc., which may lierman Alderman (telephone 202/634- has been cancelled or rescheduled, the 1 h:ve occurred. 1414) between 8:15 a.m. and 5:00 p.m., Chairman a ruling on requests for the ,
- g-Dated: May 23.1985. EDT. Persons planning to attend this Morton W.Ubarkin, meeting are urged to contact the above
- PP* * *['* *,3*'*l7 ,'," '.
3 ' jg Assistant becutive Directorfor Project Individual one or two days before the Ia e by ' d '
scheduled meeting to be advised of any , C f nb M Review. .l
[FR Don 85-13098 Rled 5-30-85: a 45 arnj es in se edule, etc., which may lierman Alderman (telephone 202/634- ,
auseo coca rseses a {ha 1414) between 8:15 a.m. and 5.00 p.m -
EDT. Persons planning to attend this
- Dated: May 23.1985. ,
meeting are wged to contact the above
[
Advisory Committee on Reactor Morton W. ubarua.
/
Safeguards, Subcommittee on named individual one or two days Assiston LeeutiveDirec'torforPro/ect before the scheduled meeting to be q
Maintenance Practices and j Procedures; Meeting . 3,yj,w. advised of any changes in schedules, (l'R Doc. 85-13099. Ried 5-35-85; 8.45 am]etc., which may have occurred.
The ACRS Subcommitfee on Maintenance and Procedures will hold a sun.o coot rs.o.ea s
- ATTACHMENT A
- 4
a ._ _.
VISION 1 6/14/85 A 77 mms'U7~ E TENTATIVE SCHEDULE ACRS MAINTENANCE PRACTICES & PROCEDURES SUBCOMMITTE MEETING 8:30 A.M., JUNE 10, 1985 WASHINGTON, DC TIME 8:30 A.M. SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN'S INTRODUCTORY REMARKS 8:45 A.M. BACKGROUND AND STATUS OF MAINTENANCE AND SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM PLAN (H. Booher) 9:00 A.M. PROGRAM DESCRIPTION (Scope, Strategy, Technical Issues, Phase I projects) (J. Jankovich) 10:00 A.M. -------- BREAK --------
10:10 A.M. SURVEY PROJECT, PHASE I (G. Cwalina) 10:40 A.M. MAINTENANCEINDICATORSTUDY(P.McLaughlin) 11:10 A.M. MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL QUALIFICATION ISSUE (J. Koontz) 11:40 A.M. SUBCOMMITTEE DISCUSSIONS 12:00 NOON ADJOURN ATTACHMENT B
- . - , _ 4 , , - , . - , . . _ .- - - _ _ - - _ - , ,_~ __.
.ACRS SUBCOMM2TTEE MEETING ON SAFA/Te2/#4/M7%T/ct5 & 7Mb LOCATIO:l: com /0$$ 9.' k f .y) _
'DATE: Ionic #181985 W M*rc ATTENDANCE LIST PLEASE PRINT:
NAME - BADGE ii0. AFFILIATION -
S097L VAA/.A6*A'8MT UHhV fdM L . FMEfr Eecide l oT'w corp.
XRic R. ossreect 5c9s4
/4 u,rL R Gs a sketA E 0 931 Sbi de rd Uni'Jecisfy
R(kcw-Gw SArsace , Aw Yu ~% Cc ~e %mNA %c - %ost% h _scnc N u A l</ N n i E DA3} SN C wn . , om puu Nr $di F 0 9 C/l; Ml78f
+Pmmb N'd> Ry?(O KlRC.
$cLee T. E -okAl. hk OS k.(
LT
. A -1) 2 9 iS R C .
rtTuA C Amt-NMu E Sib 4 Crs v7
<fisu i cgn,ea E tIsa se /f Po d6 koacem, E-oW3 W R%
T C. b e, W 6-o#ror K. A c.__
N$[Il& C0H? 55Z' j? EMui-rri Epo9 L fc fraw do i
ATTACHMENT C
WM4fm7C ACPS SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING ON MAINTENANCE PRACTICES AND PROCEDURES LOCATION ROOM 1046 8:30 A.M.
DATE JUNE 18,1985
- - ATTENDANCE LIST PLEASE PRINT:NAME AFFILI ATION v4 s ( t ,,
he;cDesble- hh4e_ i Tb-3 I3onsum la g<oc re [ co ,c u rs Am psrc k c _ n o n c e- %
YulN)N VfM
- 3 sa'L nnn
[ SW At/lS 2 co no kms
//, - //&7LA- M/2J
(- 40vfLiLf
/
ffd2S w
/J. ALN7LSAv' gas S7xt=:S C-2
ATTACHMENT D MEETING HAND 0UTS
. . ACRS SUBCOMMITTEE ON MAINTENANCE PRACTICES AND JUNE 18, 1985, WASHINGTON, DC i
- Dr. H.
- 1. Maintenance and Surveillance Program - Introduction Bocher
- 2. Maintenance and Surveillance Program - Dr. J. Jankovich
- 3. Survey of Current Maintenance Practices - G. Cwalina
- 4. Maintenance Indicators - P. McLaughlin
- 5. Maintenarce Personnel Qualifications - J. Koonz ATTACHMENT 0 h
l
'~ ' - - - ._
r, , . -
31,1985 / !Clices Fedircl Rrgister / Vcl. 50. No.105 / Frid:y, M:y .
232'06 Advisory Committee on Reacter
- l meeting on june 1a. Room 1046.1717 H Safeguards Subcommittee on l De agenda for subject meeting shall Street. NW, Washington. DC. Systomatic Evaluation Program *-(San .
l be es f;ll;ws: ne entire m.eting will be open to Onofre);Weeting Tuesday, JuneJa Iss5-1.100p.m. until
- , publi,: atter.fance.
- the donclusion of business ne agenJa for the subject meeting De ACRS Subcommittee on i .
' De Subcommittees will explore the usetf natural aptitude selection shanbe as followa:
Systematic Evaluation Program (Sam Onofre) will hold a meeting on June it, D
7besday,fune f a Isas--aJtio.m. until 1965. Room 1046.1717 H Street. NW, ,
y pr ed by ,
,w O em ts the conclusion of business Washington.DC. ,
' members of the public with the ne Subcommittee wul re' view thene entire meeting willbe open to -
concurrence of the Subcoramittee maintenance and surveillance program Public attendance. .
C5.cirm:n; written statements will be ne agenda for the subject meeting plan.
accepted and made available to the Committee. Recordings will be permitted Oral statements may be presented by g ,g g , gay, , .
those portions of the Wednesday.fune 121ss5-a30 an unt#
onlyd ubco ttee on nce ft the conclusion of business n eions y ske o by Chairman: written statements will be ne Subcommittee will review the unembers of the Subcommittee,its accepted and made available to the Integrated Plant Safety Analysis Report consult:nts, and Staff. persons desiring Committee. Recordings will be permitted (IpSAR) for San Onofre Unft1. ,
to m:ks oral statements should notify only during those portions of the Oral statements may be presented by
' the ACRS staff membernamedbelow as meeting when a transcript is being kept. members of the public with the far in cdvance as is practicable so that and questions may be asked only by appropriate arrangements can be made. members of the Subcommittee.its concurrence of the Subcommittee ,
Chairman; written statements wulbe Duringtheinitialportionof the consultants and Staff. Persons desiring meeting, the Subcommittee, along with accepted and made available to the to make oral statements should notify Committee. Recordings will be permitted any of its consultants who may be e
the ACRS staff member named below as only during those portions of the present,may exchange preliminary far in advance as is practicable so that meeting when a transcript is being kept, views regarding matters to be appropriate arrangements can be made. ,
considered during the balance of the and questions may be asked only by During the initial portion of the members of the Subcommittee.its >
hmmittee will then hear meeting. the Subcommittee, along with consultants, and Staff. Persons desiring presenistions by and hold discussions any ofits consultants who may be to make oral statements should notify with representatives of the NRC Staff,
- present,may exchwe preliminary the ACRS staff member named below as ,
- Itsconsultants andotherinterested views regarding matters to be far in advance as is practicable so that t persons regarding this review.
Further information regarding topics considering during the balance of the meeting, appropriate arrangements can be made.
During the initial portion of the to be discussed, whether the meeting meeting. the Subcommittee, along with *,
ne Subcommittee willthen hear has been canceUed or rescheduled the presentations by and hold discussions any of its consultants who may be Ch:Irman's ruling on requests for the ,
l with representatives of the NRC Staff, present.may exchange preliminary , -
opportunity to present oral staternents ,
rnd the time allotted therefor can be its consultants and other interested views regarding matters to be considered during the balance of the
.~
obtilned by a prepaid telephone call to persons regarding this review. '
Further information regarding ' topics meeting.
th2 cognizant ACRS staff member, Mr.
John Schiffgens or Mr. Herman to be discussed.whether the meeting %e Subcodee MH then hur ' .
Ald rman(telephone 202/634-1414) has been canceHed or rescheduled.presentations therepresentativesby and hold discussions .
between 8.15 a.m. and 5 00 p m EDL Chairman a ruling on requests for the with of the NRC Staff. . ,
Persons planning to attend this meeting opportunity to present oral statements its consultants and otherinterested -
cre urged to contact the above named and the time allotted therefor can beP80"" I'8"'di"8 gI' ###f##*
Further information regarding topics y,
Individual one or two days before the sch:duled meeting to be advised of any obtained by a prepaid telephone call to the cognizant ACRS staff member.Mr. to be discussed, whether the meeting j
changes in schedule, etc.,which may Herman Alderman (telephone 202/634- has been canceUed or rescheduled, the hava occurred. a ng o e aso T 1414) between 8.15 a.m. and 5-00 p.m., ,
Deted. May 23 tess, EDT. Persons planning to attend this (
Morton W.ulsarum, meeting are urged to contact the above and the time allotted eeh therefor n Hocan be )
Assistant Lecutive Directorfor rm/ect individual one or two days before the o ta e by aQ Aeriew, scheduhd meeting tobe advised of any .
if1t Doe, as-130es n!ed s-so.as, a es ami changes in schedule, etc., which may Herman Alderman (telef.one 202/834- ,.
sara,a caos news.e,
" "'" 1414) between 8.15 a.m. and 5.00 p.m., ;.
~
' EDT. Persons planning to attend this
- I-Dated. May 23. tees. ./ meeting are urged to contact the above
- Advlaory Committee on Meector named individual one or two days Morton W.taarMm. ~
e Safeguarda, Subcommittee on Maintenance Practices and .
Assistant Lecutire DirectorforPro/ect before the scheduled meeting to be g,, iew. .
advised of any changes in schedules. . 9 Procedures; Meeting
- {FR Doc. 85-13000. Mled 54545,8.45 aan) etc., which may have occurred.
1 The ACRS Subcommittet on satase coot news.ar M:intenan.ce and Procedures will hold a
- ' . ATTACH ENT A
. "r i , . , ,
c .
O
- , - - - , , . , . - - e --. -. , - . - - . - . . . . . - - - --
i
, 6/14/85
$ WMMMR)Y b TENTATIVE SCHEDULE
- I ACRS MAINTENANCE PRACTICES & PROCEDURES SUBCOMITTE MEETING 8:30 A.M., JUNE 18, 1985 .
. . WASHINGTON, DC 1
TIME 8:30 A.M. SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN'S INTRODUCTORY REMARKS 8:45 A.M. BACKGROUND AND STATUS OF MAINTENANCE AND SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM PLAN (H. Booher) 9:00 A.M. PROGRAM DESCRIPTION (Scope Strategy Technical Issues, Phase I projects) (J.Jankovich) 10:00 A.M. -------- BREAK --------
10:10 A.M. SURVEY PROJECT, PHASE I (G. Cwalina) 10:40 A.M. MAINTENANCEINDILATORSTUDY(P.McLaughlin) 11:10 A.M. MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL QUALIFICATION ISSUE (J. Koontz) 11:40 A.M. SUBCOMMITTEE DISCUSSIONS 12:00 N0ON ADJOURN l
ATTACHENT B l
.-w., - - , - -
e , .- , - - - + - - -
j ACJts sdBCOHHITTEE HEETING ON $) AlAITe2/hicQ4Srters A oce/04d, @ .* M d ,)F) .
LOCATIO:1:
N*N DATE: IvAtr#'}O ]9$[ g.
ATTENDANCE LIST 9 :r. -
PLEASE PRINT:
"fg , '
' ~
NAML BADGE NO. AFFILIATION .
i fdill/d(.?AA$EA f0VlL Vb//$58/L[ UN/Y go954 Bec. hie { Tow Co r p .
XRIC 2 OSSTLEELE Jh<nd_R [rvaske A ED 93I Shi de r1 0nTJerE&v
/C S/ ^ k9(e e t S#U -7 e.
ma% Ce nea- % 6( Qcrc. - %>L Y Mne-No s AlJA/n i 6 Of3l $N kog/ 1[/1c4 .+ - 0937 /he~N-
$'r $e5h I O 94b MIT8V L)1h J NRC, eemmkv-VAm' IS al-w I d.Am E-okAl bh_
LT 7' A -3 i zy FCR C-0S h ul C Avt -N M u EStd Cts vf
<flSu 7 m po ta E 6Itc q //
l b % b ac4c.4, E-o W3 fe911tt R%
TC %<bk c
G-oios' V.u c-l L'0$LL EbH? 55Z'
) NA 8 O rri fp4M & f& have do O
t l
l ATTACHENT C
g g 4/Zn7C ACPS SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING ON MAINTENANCE PRACTICES AND PROCEDURES ,
LOCATION ROOM 1046 8:30 A.M. ,
DATE JUNE 18.1985 ATTENDANCE LIST i
PLEASE PRINT:NAME AFFILIATION Vtd -s ' (._ ve , j' .;
.s s T F-hr'c Cesble- hh4c_ \ hw
"\k W ason ] w ocu ( co r e u rs
/? -i>wv psec
- k. c nsn e _
DA YMt M i [fM
.i- klL fit *1Kt
$ SW /1cAS 2 co n D pesr
/A) - ll8?lS Nbb _
C- wy4s r M 2S
//- ALW1LAN Ac,,ts 3,3r1 f
l C-2