ML20205B413
| ML20205B413 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 09/23/1988 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC |
| To: | Bauman L GARDE, B.P. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20205B418 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-88-224 NUDOCS 8810260240 | |
| Download: ML20205B413 (6) | |
Text
U S. NUCLE AR REGULATO7Y COMMIS510N w + va mewi > svu a.s.
ch FcrL A- %,,e,2.24 s
/.sm x e
me
)
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF l'"'"
W '"
i
//
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST SEP 2 3 WH
\\, e.....
oocatt eeuwsta S seecenc ese, t
his.
l-. : n
%omn AtoutSite PART 4.
RECORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATED 15ee reveaed bonesi No agency escords swbr ct to the renweet he=s b.en located e
No sddetoral agency escords subect to the reewest Five been lor.atM g
Agency recoros Ebett to the teowest that a+a centded e A Denes
_._ a9 al'ead, awedatde los public arsc*cton and copyeg e the NRC PM DocumentRoom 8 D
1717 H Street. N W Washegton. DC l Ageacy records svt<ect to the reowest that are ceatsled e Appeeda.
_ a e being maar ava.:able for cut 4 escecteoa sad coOveng e the NRC Pwpc Dm-e" l Room.1717 H Street. N W WasNngton. DC, e a fo60er wreet the FOta numte aN reowester name The monorocewtery version of t>e poposalisi t'at you ag eed to accept e a te+ohoes conversation aveth a %+ of rev staN e now M t=stse aveasW for pwbl< NCtire DC. e a 'o6cu u de tre FOI A numt* and 'eowew name and coveg at tre NAC Pu%c Docorr4ai Room.1717 H 5 tint. N W WuNegion n
Enclosed e eformaton on Pe* vow may obtae access no and the charges for copveg records placed e the NRC Popc Docwment Room.1717 H Street. N W. WasNngtoe. OC X
Aeoner <eco os.eb,xi io i~e <e est a. eacJev 49 8 case co se 'o, coa es o' ihe eco,ds e c-ded and navnene p<ocede es a,e noted e the <=mmoeia sci -
Ano,. sa-, to ihe,emst he.e ee.n e.e,.ed to aeotse, f eee+ a,ewesi io.,e,.* a,d d.,ect, esc. se -
no fu the acte e te.ng taken oe appeal new ested __
In *** of N AC'S respoete 16 tag reovest r
PART la A-INFORM ATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC Dif CLOSURE Cesa.n eforma'en e the rooveswd records e tem et eeid t'om pspc dcie,sw e ov svant to the FotA esemptces dewted e and for tPe feasons stated e Part 11. sec.
h e
e K
tsona 8. C. aM 0 Arv re++4 sed po< ices of tri decwmeats for which oa*v paa of tre 'ecord e te.eg *<thacd a>e tem made svadat4e for put4 capecca and coom e the NRC Pwuc Docweeat Room.1717 H St nt. N W. WesNegton. OC. e a foide* w de' th.s 50t A nuent+' and reowever eam a
f 0$0 D%
(D C Q$
I l
i i
8810260240 000923 PDR FOIA DAUMAN88-224 PDR t
t o atctoe Drv'Sc mutts
'acconos 7
l
~
FREEDOM CF INFORMATION ACT f*ESPONSE FOtA NUMBENSL 'k k"M BEP 2 31988 DATE:
PART 118-APPLICA8tt FOtA EXE' APTIONS Rec.ords subject to the foguer 'het are described in the enclosed Appendices are being withheld in their entirety or in part under FOIA r
Exemptions and for the reasono set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552tbl and 10 CFR 9.54a) of NRC Regulations.
- 1. The w*thheld informanon is property classded pursuant ts Esecutive Order 12356 (EXEMPTION 11 I
- 2. The wthhe6d information rotates so6ety to the intomai persorcel rules and procedures of NRC, IEXEMPTION 2)
- 3. The wethheld informanon a spec #cacy eierrvted from putAc deciosure by statute indcated. (Ex(MPTON 31 Secton 141145 ef the Atorme Energy Act wNeh proh bets the declosure of Restncted Data ior Formerfy Restncted Data (42 U.S C. 216121651.
i
/
Secten 147 of the Atomic Energy Act wNch prohetzts the declosure of Unclassdeed Safeguards informatson 142 U.S C,2167).
- 4. The wthheld information is a trade secret or commerctal or fnancel informaton that is beeng wthbeid for the reasontal indicated- (EXEMPTION 4)
The information is consa$ered to be conidental busaness (propretary) informaton.
The informaton is conssdered to be proprotary informaton pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790(dMIL The mformaton was svtmtted and recewoo e confdence from a foregn source pursuant to to CFR 2.790idH2L 5 The n+thheld informaton coes.sts of interegency or ritraagency records that are not ava4able through decovery dunng artgaten. Deciosure of predece.onalinformaton would tend to inhatwt the open and frank ev.hange of deas essental to the dehberative process Where records are ethhold in their entrety, the facts are mentnceth etortwned wth the credecisenal eformaton. Thare also are no reasonably segregable factual portons becavne the rolesse of the facts would perrrwt en mdwect engway eito the precocoonal process of the egency. IEXEMPTCN 58
- 6. The wthheld inforn iten e esempted from putd.c deciosure because its de,ciosure would result in a clearfy unwarrant.J invason o* personal pnvecy. LEAEMPTON 61 3
- 7. The ethheld informaton cor mots of Westgatory records comc3ed for law *^forcement purposes and a being ethheed for the reasonds) indicates IEXEMPTON 7)
' O sclosu e would riterfere wth an enforcement proceedeg because 4 could reveal the scope. dwocten, and focus of enforcement efforts. and thus could r
possery slow thern to taae acton to sNid potentel wrongdueg or a violaten of NRC recursments from evestigators qEXEMPTON 7l AH Dectosure would const4wte an un*erranted invason of personal pnvecy (EXEMPTCN fiCH The informahon consets of names of indevdwa's and other a formaton the disclosure of *%h woud reveal iderstities of con 6 dental sources (EXEMPTCN 7(DH PART 11 C-CENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 9 and/or 915 of tre U S. Nuclose Reguatory Commeson regutatons, it has been determeed that the informatoa wthheld e esempt fica producten or desciosu er and that #ts producten or declosure e contrary to the u.rbhc enterest The persons responsele for the derval a>e those orfacia!s iden%ed be ow as deeveg office's and the Drecto-e Devoon of Rules and Records. O'fce of Admenstraten, for any den.41s that may be appealed to the EneCwDve Dwector for Operatons 'soos OENylNG OFFICIAL TITLE / OF FICE RECORDS DENIED APPELLATE OFFICIAL M
i h..
MMdh th d]
b MM M U
PART 11 D-APPEAL RIGHTS The denial by each denying off6al ident food in Part li.C may be appealed to the Appenate Official ident4ed in that so; tion. Any such appeal must be in writing and must te made writhin 30 days of recest of this response. Appeals mi,1 be addressed as appropriate to the Enocutive Director for Operations or to the Secretary of the Commession, U.S. Nuclear Reg *ulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20665, and should clearty state on the envelope and in the lettee that it is an "Appeal from art initial FOtA Decision.
hac Foau aos iPort a U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$10N oasi FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION i
I
1 Re: F0I A-88-224 APPENDIX G
RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUM8ER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION
"* *h5 =1d entirety 1.
2/6/86 Typewritten notes re allegation received by
,ent to FOI A Texas Dept of Health unemption 7(A)
(1 page) 2, 2/6/86 Typewritten notes re allegation received by Same as above
'exas Dept of Health, same as above, added
.te at bottom of page (1 page) 3.
2/10/86 Handwritten note, named individual 1 ;erview Same as above by (initials M.E.)
(1 page) 4.
2/12/86 Randwritten note, named individual interview Same as above by (initials M.E. and Cain)
(1 page) 5.
2/12/86 Handwritten note, case no. 4-86-A-016, interview Same as above with named individual by (M.E., Bangart & Cain)
(1 page) 6, 2/18/86 Handwritten note, several dates with different Same as above individual interviews (1 page) 7.
10/27/86 Memorandus, Request for Investigation, from Same as above Robert D. Martin to Donald D. Driskill 01 RIV re H&G Inspection Company (2 pages) 8.
12/5/86 Handwritten notes, collage of memo calls, etc.
Same as above (1 page) b
Re:
F01A-88-224 APPENDIX f
RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUM8ER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 9.
12/9/86 Memorandum, Vandy L. Miller to Mark E. Emerson, Withhold in entirety RIV, subject; Allegation Regarding H & G pursuant to FOIA Inspection Company Exemotion 7(A)
(1 Page)
I 19 12/22/86 Response / Status to Request For Investigation Same as above form. Donald Driskill to Robert D. Martin, on H & G Inspection Company, Case no. 4-86-015 (1 page) 11.
6/1/87 Handwritten note. A-016 Same as above (1 page) 13.
10/26/87 Allegation Management System. Allegation No.
Same as above RIV-86-A-0016. H & G Inspection Company (1 page) 13.
Undated Handwritten note re doctor, etc Same as above (1 page)
Re : FOI A-88-224 APPDDIX H
DATE 900UMENT DESCRIPT10tl 1.
9/17/86 letter to Robert Martin from Congressman Bill Archer (1 page) w/
9/16/86 letter to Congressman Bill Archer from Harry Gibson transmitting his letter and newspaper clippings to NRC (5 pages) i 1
Ite: FOI A-88-224 APPENDIX H
DATE DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION 1.
9/17/86 letter to Robert Martin from Congressman Bill Archer (1 page) w/
9/16/86 letter to Congressman 8111 Archer from Harry Gibson transmitting his letter and newspaper clippings to NRC (5 pages),
I l
I a esovist wwstalsa U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY C".MMISSION hacNoTA 88 224
/ -es :e.
e
.u o~u n,.
[
C i
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF l ' *
IXI "^'
(.eee. /
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST nr 22 e DOCat, en,WetA SI L# appara3esi Ms.
Ahm PART l.-RECORDS Ritt ASED OR NOT LOCATIO (tee checaed eenesi NJ ogency records svtst to the west esve been located No odd <toral agency records subsec1 to ee roovest have been tocated Agency records wbr ct to the reqwes' tP41 e's dentifed e Apper4s are enroady eveAape for puter, rececten and copyeg in the NRC Pubhc Doeweent Roc %
e 1717 H St'oet. N W. W se wyton. DC.
l a
agenc,uces sa uno the,ewn., ce oeeued e Apreed..
,e toeg -ede...aave f pwu.c escuton.nd co yes e u NaC puw.e oocw,,e.t moom.1717 H $treet N W. Wastegton. DC. e a foldee under the, FOI A numbe' and toowester name The nonpeopeetry we' son of the pecc%.**' t*st ex# ag'eed to accept e a te.ephone conversaton veth a wentee of any staM e now boeg made evelable for public recocton and coveg at the N AC Pwtec Docwment Room,1717 H Street. N *. Wasmegion. OC. e a folde< wnder the FOIA nur,ter and reaweety name inclosed e eformaton on how yow ma, ceta.n eccess to and the cFe< pes for copyeg records paced e tre NRC PutAc Document Room.1717 H Street, N W. Washegton, DC Agency records subpect to tP4 rewt a fu reve..ad d<xt respon.e =,ow r
no tw ttee action e teeg tasen on erfeel letter dated
{
in vea o8 NRC s 'espoese to the west e
PART li A-lNFORM ATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC OISCLOSURE Certaa info <*aton e tre %eswd 'ecords e be rq *<thAoid from putd.c d.sclosu e pw<suant to the FOtA eienetees de.c' ties e and for the reasone stated e Ps/111. esc <
r X
toes B C sad D Arv re'essed conens of the docweeats for *NM orW part of tte record 4 beeg w*thbeid are teirq eede avslatde for pubhc inacecten and copyeg e the NR C PwWic Dc<weent Room.1717 H Street N W. Washegton. OC. e a foide undee the FotA numtea and t>Jwaster name C-is 4 D o cvWnt H i is e u;os d.
)
4 b <d,W y
... ~.,
-,,,_....h.e,-
MMtJl
.A
,,,, R,. U,
..., _,,..-,.. B.., h Ch.m.w, y,,
. y %4%
.%,nC.
- y M
. ng 0,,,c i
........ =..
.:. c.. f..:
...... '&J.ef / // / b.ho.ms y
o..
-. E...,kl
- h S ='~...
HN BW 09/n/ 80 04 ').o /98. 9 '2./ / /T
/
/
/
/
NIC FORM 464 e
- o
+,/7 4i /_
Y
- r. 9 0
FREEDOM CF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE FotA NUMBELSh M~M OATE:gD 9 'l MAA PART 11 B-APPLICABLE FOIA EXEMPTIONS
~
Records subject to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendices h
are being withheld in their entirety or in part under FOIA bomptions'and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CFR 9.5(a) of NRC Regulatione.
- 1. The wthheld informanon e property classthed pursuant to Enoc
' Order 12356 (ExtMPTION 1)
- 2. The withheld informec. 4 tse soiety to the estemal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. (EXEMPTON 2) 3 TN wethheid information is specifcasy esempted from public deciosure by statute irocated. (EXEMPTON 3)
Secten 141145 of the Atomic Ermrgy Act which prohibits the osciosure of Restricted Data er Formorty Restncted Data 442 U S C. 216121851.
Secten 147 of the Atomic Energy Act *Nch prohibrts the draciosure of Unclassfed Safsve ds Informaten (42 U.S C. 2167).
r
- 4. The methhe6d information is a trade secret or commercial or francel esformaten that is toeg wthbe6d for the reason (s) indicated. (EXEMPTION 4)
The informaten is cons.dered to be confidentel buseoss (propnetary) informaton.
The informaton is cons.dered to be propnetary informaten pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790tdH11.
The informaten was submitted and recorved e conhdence from a fore.gn source pursuant to 10 CFR 2.790(di(2).
5 The wthheld e*formaten cons sts of ete'egency or intraageficy records that are not available through decovery dunne lit 9aten. Osclosure of predece.onal informaten would tend to inheit the open and tram enckange of m3eas essent.al to the descerative process Where records are withbe6d in thes enteety. the facts are centncabry vuortweed *'th the odecisenal eformaten. There also are no reasoeaba segregatdo factual portens because the rodease of the facts would permet en comoct inquwy into t predece.onal process of the agency. IEXEMPTION
- 6. The wthbe d informanon s es Mted from public deciosure because res declosure would result in a cleafy unwarranted invasen of personal privacy. IEXEMPTCN 61 n
- 7. The wthbe64 information conosts of evestgatcry records corm ed for law enforcement purposes and is beeg witmeld for the reason (s) ind*cated. (EXEMPTION 7) a 0.sclosure would interiore with an enforcement proceedeg because it could reveal the scope, direct on, and focus of enforcement efforts. and thus could possety adow theru 'o take acten to she64 potenter wongdoing or a velaten of NRC requvements from investgators (EXEMPTON 7(All Declosure would coristnute en un*erranted invasen of personsi pahacy (EXEMPTON 7tCH The informaten cor sists of names of indiviouais and other information the desciesure of which not.ed reveal identtbes of conridental sources. (EXEMPTON 7(00 PART ll C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 9 and or 915 of the U S Nuclear Regulatory Cornmesen reguistens, it has been determeed that the in'ormaten wthrwad e esempt from productice or d sciosure.
and that its producten or desciosure is coetray to the putAc interest. The persons responeMe for the dened are those orfca!s identded below as denying officials and the Qvector.
Devision of Rules and Recores Of0ce of Adminstraten, for any dorss4 that may be appealed to the (secuirve Ovector foe Ope <atene if ooi 1
DENYING OFFICIAL TITLE OFFICE RECORDS DEN +ED APP 5LLATE OFFICIAL l
VP" $ h
'gh h;M%k ge e
6 Moe. W--a
\\, )
PART H 0- APPEAL RIGHTS The derval by each denying official identifed in Part ll.C may be appeated to the Appellate Officialidentified in that section. Any such appeal must be in l
writing and rnust be made within 30 days of receipt of this resportse. Appe,Js must be addressed as appropriate to the becutive Director for Operations or to that it le en "Appeal from an initial FOIA Decision.gulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20556, and should clearty state on th. enve the Secretary of the Commission. U.S. NuJear Re
.c ecaw see iP.a a U.s. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION casi FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION l
Re:
FOIA _88-224 APPENDIX G
RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELO NUM8ER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 1.
2/6/86 Typewritten notes re allegation received by Withheld entirety Texas Dept of Hea:th pursuant to FOI A Exemption 7(A)
(1 page) 2.
2/6/86 Typewritten notes re allegation received by Same as above Texas Dept of Health, same as above, added note at bottom of page (1 page) 3.
2/10/86 Handwritten note, named individual interview Same as above by (initials M.E.)
(1 page) 4, 2/12/86 Handwritten note, named individual interview Same as above by (initials M.E. and Cain)
(1 page) 5.
2/12/86 Handwritten note, case no. 4-86-A-016, interview Same as above with named individual by (M.E., Bangart & C&in)
(1 page) 6.
2/18/86 Handwritten note, several dates with different Same as above individual interviews (1 page) 7.
10/27/86 Memorandus, Request for Investigation, from Same as above Robert D. Martin to Donald D. Driskill 01 RIV re H&G Inspection Company (2 pages) 8.
12/5/86 Handwritten notes, collage of memo calls, etc.
Same as above (1 page)
l Re: F01A.88-224 APPEN0lX G
RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELO NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 9.
12/9/86 Memorandum, Vandy L. Miller to Mark E. Emerson, Withheld in entirety RIV, subject; Allegation Regarding H & C pursuant to FOIA Inspection Company Exemotion 7(A)
(1 page) 19 12/22/86 Response / Status to Request For Investigation Same as above form. Donald Driskill to Robert D. Martin, on H & G I spection Company, Case no. 4-86-015 (1 page) 11.
6/1/87 Handwritten note. A-016 Same as above (1 page) l j
12.
10/25/87 Allegation Management System Allegation No.
Same as above RIV-86-A-0016. H & G Inspection Company (1 page) 13.
Undated Handwritten note re doctor, etc Same as above (1 page) i
Re: FOI A-88-224 H
DATE DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION 1
l-9/17/86 letter to Robert Martin from Congressman Bill Archer (1 page) w/
9/16/86 letter to Congressman Bill Archer from Harry Gibson transmitting his letter and newspaper clippings to MRC (5 pages) l
....