ML20203C572
| ML20203C572 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 07200022 |
| Issue date: | 02/17/1998 |
| From: | Chancellor D UTAH, STATE OF |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#198-18817 97-732-02-ISFSI, 97-732-2-ISFSI, ISFSI, NUDOCS 9802250211 | |
| Download: ML20203C572 (15) | |
Text
..
/88/7 00CKETED UNITED STATES OF AMER'"A h ' CLEAR REGULATORY COMMld.:ON
% FEB 20 P1 :41 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOARD OFFIC C :-
M
,.Rl)lf.' ' li
,y,
avuu w -
me
)
In the Matter of:
)
Docket No. 72 22 ISFSI
)
PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE, LLC
)
ASLBP No. 97 732 02 ISFSI (Independent Spent Fuel
)
Storage Installation)
)
February 17,1998 i
STATE OF UTAH'S COMMENT ON REVISIONS TO CONTENTIONS AND PROPOSED CORRECTIONS TO THE PRE HEARING TRANSCRIPT In a Memorandum and Order dated February 9,1998, the Board prepared a listing of the agreed upon revisions to the language of various petitioners' contentions and requested comments on these revisions by February 17,1998. In the same Order j
the Board advised that proposed corrections to the transcript for the January 27-29 prehearing conference must be submitted by February 17.
A.
Revisions to State of Utah's Contentions The listing of the State of Utah's Contentions, incorporating revisions
. agreed to by the State in its Reply to Contentions fued January 16,1998 and at the pre-hearing conference are correct with two exceptions. First, Subpart 5 of Contention T, Inadequate Assessment of Required Permits and other Entitlements, should be deleted.
The State withdrew that portion of Contention T dealing with Part 75 requirements.
Second, Utah Contention V, Inadequate Consideration of Transportation Related Radiological Environmental Impacts, subpart 4 should read:
f!l ff fff f' I II I!!f!j[.jffjjf 9802250211 900217 PDR ADOCK 07200022 l
C PDR m
-m
a 4.
New information hot s that Table S-4 grossly underestimates transportation impacts in that:
The words 'in that " at the end of subpart 4(a) should be deleted.
By accepting the rewording of contentions, the State does not abandon the bases for its contentions. The contentions must be read as a whole, including their bases.
B.
Proposed Corrections to the Pre Hearing Transcript The Transcript of the Pre Hearing Conference held January 27 29,1998 contains a multitude of mistakes. The State has made a diligent effort to correct substantive mistakes, in trying to discern the meaning of baffling statements, the State sed its best judgment in suggesting changes but there were some instances when it u
was impossible to make any suggestions at all. In such instances the mistakes have not been corrected. On a minor point, 'Rowley Junction" has variously been spelled Rally, Rawley and Rolley. -We have corrected some but not all of all these misspellings. The State's proposed changes to the Tranxtipt are attached as Exhibit 1.
The State motions that these changes be made to the record.
2
DATED this 17th day of February,1998.
Respectfully submitted,
)
/
!]
JC 4
1 Menise Chancellor l
Fred G Nelson i
Assistant Attorneys General Diane Curran Connie Nakahara Special Assistant Attorneys General Attorneys for State of Utah Utah Attorney General's Office
- 160 East 300 South,5th Floor P.O. Box 140873 Salt Lake City - UT 84114 0873 Telephone:
(801) 366-0286
- Fax:-
(801) 3660292 1
_ _ _ _ _ _m'.
3 3
4
-v*
f g ra
+e-r r
=
3-r,----
-+-
.,w.-
- ---_w,---=-,
v.--,.
,y
.w--
w yr,-rw--w+-'r
DOCKETED USilRC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE l
I hereby certify that copies of STATE OF UTAH'S COhihi$NT 6E420 P1 Z1 REVISIONS TO CONTENTIONS AND PROPOSED CORRECTIONS TO THE PRE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, were served on the persons listed below by electronic mail (unless otherwise noted) with conforming copies by United States mail first class, this 17th day of February,1998:
Attn: Docketing & Services Branch Dr. Peter S. Lam Secretary of the Commission Administrative Judge U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Atomic Safety and Licensing Board hiail Stop: Ol6G15 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11555 Rockville Pike, One White Flint Washington, DC 20555 North E hiail: psl@n:c. gov Rockville, h1D 20852 2738 (originaland tuo copic.)
Sherwin E. Turk, Esq.
Catherine L. Marco, Esq.
G. Paul Bollwerk,III, Chairman Office of the General Counsel AdministrativeJudge Mail Stop 015 B18 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 E hiail: set @nrc. gov E Mail: gpb@nrc. gov E hiaih clm@nrc. gov Dr. Jerry R. Kline Jay E. Silberg, Esq.
Administrative judge Ernest L. Blake, Jr.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2300 N Street, N. W.
Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20037 8007 E-Maib jrk2@nre. gov E Mail: Jay _Silberg@shawpittman.com 4
i
Clayton J. Parr, Esq.
Danny Quintana, Esq.
' Kimball, Parr, Waddoups, Brown &
Danny Quintana & Associates, P.C.
Gee 50 West Broadway, Fourth Floor 185 South State Street, Suite 1300 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101
-P. O. Box 11019 E Mail: quintana @xmission.com Salt Lake City, Utah 84147 0019 E Maib karenj@pwlaw.com James M. Cutchin Atomic Safety and Licensing Board John Paul Kennedy, Sr., Esq.
Panel 1385 Yale Avenue U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Salt Lake City, Utah 84105 Washington, D.C. 20555 0001 E Mail: john @kennedys.org E Mail: jmc3@nrc. gov
. (electronic copy only)
Jean Belille, Esq.
Land and Water Fund of the Rockies Office of the Commission Appellate 2260 Baseline Road, Suite 200.
Adjudication Boulder, Colorado 80302 Mail Stop: 16 G 15 OWFN E Mail: landwater@lawfund.org U. S. Nudear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 (United States mail,first class only) 7
.l htuc b/
J Deitise Chancellor Assistant Attorney General State of Utah 5
4 W
EXHIBIT 1 STATE'S CORRECTION SHEET TO TRANSCRIPT l
~
4 CORRECTION SilEET I
SUBMITTED BY Tile STATE OF UTAll l
FOlt Tile TRANSCRil'T OF Tile IIEARING IIELD JANUARY 27-29,1998 RE PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE,1 LC 72-22-ISFSI - PRE IIEARING CONFERENCE 1
Page Line Delete Insert h
001 24 Marvin Resnikoff Connie Nakahara Lawrence White 034 09 other order 038 20 recently frequently 047 04 maybe maybe there is 062 22 underneath under 080 02 didn't 080 02 were 080 04 we're were 080 04 On the lhe 093 06 effective affected 096 14 Why not. You Why not. Provided you 124 15 caps casks 124 16 caps casks 124 17 ceps casks 131 23 Rally Rowley 131 24 Now the danger's theory.
131 24 cask store casks stored 131 24 Alpine offramp 132 05 themselfon missiles from 1
Page Line Delete lasert 132 11 FAR SAR 132 12 There is There, it 132 12 transport transfer point 132 13 thing building 132 20 Rally Rowley -
132 21 pier 133 01 Rally Rowley 133 03 Rally Rowley 133 15 at without l
l 133 16 the connected they connect 133 17 installation instrumentation 133 18 taken from taken them from 133 21 Rally Rowley 133 24 Rally Rowley 134 09 does meet up does not meet up 134 10 Rally Rowley 134 24 The sure shipments The Shorham shipments 134 25 33 large 33 cask 135 01 another reactor, or another reactor from 135 03 drop down into not be the case in 135 03 Rally Rowley 135 06 DOE DOT 135 17 Rally Rowley 135 20 Rally Rowley 135 22-Rally Rowley 2
_~
Page Line Delete Insert I
l
- n. --
136 18 moving. In maneuvering in 137 06
- Rall, Rowicy 137 08 transport uansfer from 137 08 Lingueras country 137 10 existing ISFSI 137 10 Rally Rowley 137 11 Rally Rowley p
137 10 Rally Rowley 137 21 Rally Rowley 138 01 Dolcinells dose analysis 138 11 Rally Rowley 139 06 Rally Rowley 139 08 Rally Rowley 139 11 transport transfer l
139 19 there they are 139 21 Rolley Rowley 140 04 and this is Bob Cahill, his under subpart id of this part partner 140 09 Rolley Rowley 140 09 not as the not at the 140 10 assistant.
140 12 Rolley Rowley 140 14 Rolley Rowley 141 02 the page 142 05 a car a cask l151 18 Rally Rowley 3
o
Page Line Delete Insert 154 16 bill making rulemaking 157 08 falsity pausity 157 23 PAS PFS 158 21 trucks around trucks turn around 158 20 them at them and 162 11 Bear Bearing 162 11 just said. I'm just said, I'm 162 22 and on and in 163 3
New reg.
new reg.
NUREG 163 14 applies apples 163 15 new reg.
NUREG 179 23 witty wordy 180 17 Holpeck and transfer Holtec and TranStor 180 20 Holpeck and transfer Holtec and TranStor 183 1
radio nuclides radiotiuclides 183 4
new reg.
NUREG 183 15 radio nuclides radionuclides 184 22 any aftermath in the aftermath I85 1
radio nuclides radionuclides 185 18 radio nuclides radionuclides 185 24 report annuls of the ICRP report, Annals of the ICRP, Publication pullication 56 j a which 56,in which I85 25 ICRP (60) which was ICRP (60), which were 186 11 teir in its 189 10
.eathe the fumes, Retrieve the fuel, 4
Page lLine Delete Insert a-195 25 think as think that 197 10 carlier, March earlier, a March 197 10 Cane Kane 197 11 Deligadi Delligatti 199 21 contention or our reply, contention, but in our reply.
200 5
Holtech Holtec 200 6
Delagatti Delligatti 200 7
Holtech.
Holtec.
200 9
requirements are, of requirements, of 200 14 clatting cladding 203 4
anslysis analysis 203 6
that they,
- that, i
203 20 clatting cladding l
203 24 clatting cladding 204 7
satisfy satisfies i
204 10 boht both 204 10-11 new reg NUREG 205 15 New reg NUREG 209 22 new reg NUREG 213 24 staffthat staff that stated 214 5
And as amatter And as a matter 214 10 adequate.
inadequate.
215 12 new reg NUREG 215 24 clatting cladding 220 O
the citations with citations l
5 D
Page Line Delete Insert 221 13 2526 25-26 221 23 commitment from contmitment through 221 23 agreements where agreement for a 221 24 fuel."
fuel.
l 221 25 begin.
begin."
227 01 apply applying 241 24 Manin Resnikoff g
Lawrence White
]
297 09 nuclear industrial transportation nuclear, industrial, transportation, and m
297 12 significant significance 313 13 ETTR UTTR 328 01 Right. Any Right. CIIAIRMAN BOLLWERK:
Any 336 08 out our 336 10 urban earthen 336 16 out our 337 13 This is That it 337 13
- this is
- that it 337 15 occurred to, to occur.
337 21 take other take place other 338 03 then fall into then flow into 338 04 is on the is at the 338 11 pond of the pond on the 340 18 what the pad usage what the peak usage 341 04 State meets the contention State's contention 341 05 are requires are required 6
Page Line Delete Insert 348 23
- fill, field, 348 23 we thin we think 351 08 what would be what we are 390 12 contingency casks contingency costs 392 14 line liner
~
392 01 compact.
compact, or not.
392 12 decontaminate, decontaminating 393 05 redemption Rowley Junction
,393 14 may be reburfed may result 393 17 Iknow And now 403 05 are are not 416 15 proprietary use proprietary l
416 20 equation to equations of 417 22 with which 418 06 constance constants 445 03 I work I worked 448 24 wood WIPP l
448 25 wood WIPP 449 01 wood WIPP I
455 15 expert and expert on 456 05 Rawley Rowley 463 07 say saw 463 13 Reservation Reservation, 464 24 that's that is 464 25 been tested contested 7
s
+
' Page Line Delete Insert 465 06 plant, an plant, and an 466 11 Rawley Rowley 476 13 NELSON QUINTANA 500 24 Marvin Resnikoff Lawrence White 504 15 radii nuclides '
radic: uclides 504 16 radii nuclides radionuclides 522 16 sic;et sheep 523 2
burst causing burst, causing 523 5
referred to referred in 523 6
D V
523 10 Limeric Limerick 523 11 Limeric Limerick 524 13 Limeric Limerick 524 15 Limeric Limerick 526 10 increases increased 526 12 Limeric Limerick 526 25 Limeric Limerick 527 1
Limeric Limerick 527 2
Limeric Limerick 536 22 evidence evident 537 6
reasonable reasonably 539 19 in 73.1, in section 73.1, 543 23 contention V. It's contention V,it's 548 9
this is there is SSI 2
Cabarello Paperiello 8
__j
Page Line Delete Insert 555 16 Like to make I would like to make 555 17 pass.
casks.
557 23 1000,000 100,000 558 11 Landmark Limerick 559 10 supervided - superseded superceded 600 10 GOCD air TOCDF 600 21 road slows road swells 654 12 e
and 654 24 1812 8.1.2 657 01 Tanaque Tenakee 657 02 Marshal Marshall 657 03 Benella VanAbbema 671 04 study
- study, 671 05 nd and 1
720 15 its informaut its imprimatur 736 03 731 7.3-1 736 10 5145(c)
S t.45(c) 736 20 731 7.3-1 736 22 1,244,000 1,244,000,000 736 22 976,000 976,000,000 789 20 of face value on face value 791 02 into the doctrine into the Winters doctrine I
791 03 and whether the and the 791 03 to the tribe to the tribe, 795 24 has worded has alluded 9
_j