ML20202J438

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Zion Fuel Evaluation Info,Per Discussion
ML20202J438
Person / Time
Site: Zion  File:ZionSolutions icon.png
Issue date: 02/03/1999
From: Robert Williams
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
To: Gaskin C
NRC
References
NUDOCS 9902090134
Download: ML20202J438 (14)


Text

... c i 1 a...=ww wc ur u

.-m va - u. va, ncas i.wavut - Liru-60014155355:: 1

\\

)

s.

\\yestinghouse Electric Corporation P. O. Drawer R l

Columbia,SC 29250 Fax Cover Sheet DATE:

$,*PIB Y TIME:

$ YI M TO:

_CNA4/*f b_'?sa7 PHONE:

(.7a 0 V Lr - B //1 l

FAX:

(3eh *//f_ 695$

FROM:

Robert A. Wittiams PHONE:

(803) 776-2610, Ext. 3393 or WIN 4393 Regulatory Affairs FAX:

(803) 695-3964 t

RE:

yona Qo. /*An CC:

fp m. Air D odALD Number of pages including cover shoot: /Y i

i Message l

Staff /J Y3'e &sJ p* Wet E M L d m e d J Jo % s.fr D uc w is D. A m asf e M L M A l

2f wfeL6 DUtJ,lue J /J JFCKffMY,

?

i

{

D.

l n n00 '.' 3 9902090134 990203 PDR ADOCK 05000295g PDR[

P

I a,s.s n

+a a na

-u^

' * ~ ^ ^

' ' * " ' ' ' ^ ' ' ~ ~ ^

-+ -'** " ""*

~~~

,,_,,w

    • g

'. 2

  • ~'5',',. N

'?. '

~"87 3 I,,d fh '

W' i [ ' 4 kk

<h ShK;spYk N'r%.,,

%;d.k,,.h's;[gh kd$:Jd $1 Ihid.b4's Wh.

k?.$fh. k hhh khEhlf k k( ?k?h YbkN kk b

a gegg $$$

l BtWg$g$h?Nk@e?Ri

\\ $$$$

$g$$iW

$ e g@ 1 $ p$

g%A~d!I_$

aW E C.

k k(,

f' Tb.y 3 M, bdlArfkR&hlif

!?% ' Ntp[

e m

w-a u m ~m, -s_3.._a, m _30.

u we p

9 m.,.

. n, a a A t

a., w. as %-

m, Wi

. y, gym k a u as a n[weg g

f

j db h i b d

  • flbe) 4 4 %de dVL Yb b 84' O b, ' te d

~

4 e '.' f I'LJaa*V.4swJb il v ~'

Oc'U214JJ.)JJ 0 0 u

l o' f.'. I'#& l M 2Y'4; PTC.'i.'5 7,lT@.'f'F ~'i,\\d'.Ng/. 7??,. ~'* y f}l P'*T, ? % $ P'y

'" C I

th /W,h h h k j* i D

$k 9, h d' $'.

k((h

f g&;N)yh'chF.n%g.sg e

unw gwas anw ye m$ Q 4 f Q W g e.t*Q %q w -g9 fj fsyf Q

ey q

%3

.geh z94(. j

,g;n.p

%w;;q-Jaa ga 31 a

Q.y

,,% ;p.

h w

g
s.;

% y_ x p,J nfpi ly}i;*p l

gj 19

'jyi

%p y

k su y

!kI hk hhfkg h$,k

$,h5f.f,kkNkP~

hif i hhN w&

,fh k

kn h

dhffs jip y\\c&u

' !n A %. eA m 1.y t

m l am.j$g; M, $

,kh ' /

f.M, g@jl

.jp.

y jb)1$. d%,1

$i JM h

y m ),%

r.

es t'

4 l

$r.g%y.m.W

, m..Qapy

. y;sqfy Aj 9 4.

W 4 Ag 43

~"

l

[.

i;[no.(

Qq m,

o

&,_ g j,.>p'!!g

-1 m

j t/A h

T Wf hSWf. f n, v g' ? a;m.%

..y if

-(?-mh' f

,t l

m

- a' bQ ~'

l %gf 1

.g c

. ;qy l [

Q.

Wk

^

?

?

f,k N h f _ ___ _b,

...,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,4,,-

),-

O e

@sa$~$gLqpi;cggy:gttatsmg%,h 4

I a

a % s.e.

- - ag3

.g,kW'?,7q:yw 3 m.%..

nwp

.. m( 7 7 m

w 2.

.e ey

.p! h f.'

YE

?

A:V

$ N h

1 h

jh,hkM,M$k hf$[.k,,, h.g,y f,,% k $

I 6y py e glb,w$

. m9y m.,

>psbA q $ j{ %gg u

,$um a

i l

{y% p(

g;.

Mo",' W3r, m,k

@y l 4 n q f.a w

,f l

W.

l yrg9 i

g.. i l j.ep 5 &gg,

,,e?

b

.,e j

f @NY*

.e.

.m e

v.

e d

~

' ' p.?

i,.I +A l hk r.,

j w.t!

.:. e J,,,A2 -

i

q

3

g o

7@4P}$

4 I %"z.E 4

4.1.lyg:M.M k EU'3m..j j

j 3

g.

s9 a

l

-}, y hC +. jk p r M gyY ^3 mot >4%f !@@$,p. q%MOEM,h n;p135" 3,3,;O ~'

" r

~

OL \\ a 01 6CJ 4 4. vuil A.:

  1. 3 a

,, s-64 6

'.'W Q. d W e ys,p. % m m. g m u g g g: : m g g

yweme c

m c q e c y4rQ.A.c e. ped m:.&

.y

.q.

e J

i m 4.dm",

e.~-

ua.n 3e

.3. g::

Q;, '%yp '-%

X Ip ga

'. ', a y

%%;.,g.W, Q g -

\\:

Y*it

' ' M' ? ; j

(

v,(9[,, 3h'[p y',gg I'" IS-g ap.

i

.i J., 4 - 4 b,4 i.,, e., '. -, _,,

A ; d ( J ;y,y,.;,.e g w'

'A.

j g

l hf

'f f,

. ~ h'$t h 2

ap%y$s$

a m m..e w$ Ed Ah IfM s%s%nt sW M F M p#w~))]0 D

a/$$u)f

$m$

4

':(.

yb L

.[44 igd l.

i

~..

s,:

v

m. m' o #

,m

-d~

P. g..

fl

".a f

u -

M 5 7..,

?? Ji

. '{

!P

. )g l - e.

5 b,M Q.h

!L T

T.&

4, f y, r.

W

i W.s. ~

.w.

p.m.

.Ef v

t 4

tr$g

'l N

t. ',.

(, s.

,4 r

5 41 e.

,.3 4

Lj

- ' y, M

' '[l f ig,R.

y,,k i,E ',

g, c[v,gc.

'y

g, t 4 w %;[

eg r

a c.

.. +

,A

,V,.

'.I

..[

4 1

w a

e i

is:l

(

3r..

ed.

T y.

?;,,. J, i

4

-e ~

1 l r y.

.t y

1b%

..l h :...

.{.

l k._.

m( ' $w' b.a e pA g

e a

1 ed.

y*/8

% a v m. w._. w rwu m. m w w.N =

5 3 3%wwr

.m a e e n n w m.k m./

..a mr

i.

.ctu or atst ounut2t- -. - - - - - -

-~ _

- Wu

- c od li mi 6tsi O W uLdt - W D-63014155955;:: 6 e

ga.

.~.q, e'.

a.

. k.3n

e 4,m,gf q " r"* 7.

g,y(p'gr.

~ i +

a.

'y.

g' 3"p =,

j 3 ; 7s,.

9,a,,.

4

,6

.s. 4 y.

7. C c

e -

4 4

a.

g

% ' v. s.,p e

N,

--hg T'

n..g *h.p.)'. h,.xM a n...w,, 2k,-

& t 'g

,,y #

?

m? Nv.m. b'.. y, Q,

e.m c a. v.:q$

f

/ Q.

y

. M h g @a,s.,'

l

Ff WT :;1 up.o cym zws v.a. d'"FN.,w? l% WM,M %.R i;;,Gy.r Q i ?.?':

4.

swk.;;.,1,4...f>%.Mrj,g' t ve

. p ax,

.. a n. t WM.;g' y... t.glh.;/p - 3 \\u m%./1,...Cq. M v

,w i

e

. 6,g Y.,C 4 a.. q'L..

M*o '

  • %q,%,g p. %g 9"p -

.z

.. a c

j e

,. w.,)'

Wr W

+ %c. M. :.y.ty ; @,% -E j,,9 A,g ' A.

1 i

p "h.g* ;.E i

?.*y j

i.. '3;.

q ? h y,,.

  • %1
4..~*,

,t r*

. %,S.e.g.:f. 3;a# a.. %

q

( yg.. s ;. %,

, :$A. ~,.,. m,Wa7

.y g.r -

n.,

'*.$w. j a+ h. + f g,,l, 7

.a=r, 4.g

.t r-

,4 M +T w s

s k

k K'.g,'"@ @. 1.'...

!'MM, g s.. N4 4

WM.

F M.

N r

I

.i3 h.s.,

N_h.gi ' Q,,' M I,14. ;.

y&.,N.'.m.

7%y $m M %. 1 E Sch.-

Q R+@X}p) %g

%y, a.

r a %c % m' n +n p. e.-.

.d 4 i

g w gc 4y g}%

b

B~

GA 7

Y

.vga 4

gy Vy ;w:w.

9 yts N

ns

.p m

W w.

2 p 1M.y%e. tag W M.4 a

empWe i

s

y. ; w w e a n &g..M@%.%...

w5 6.-

wW 9..

1. q,s $r %.

t i

3 e,,. m w

c r. 4 g, '%:

f g '. 4 t $,,, g% g..

L rgwr.n g

. m.,

g5 i

.hn T. t 1 7,!= w., 4,.w.%

. g,,, ;;h..

.V k @%g $ '.4, q-k; b:. N,,. k

=:.

qg

.q.

e.'.

p.

.,ve

..n

,Nk. 3 33 9

.4_ j

},,..

(f*

a h h,

.. E St y[

j M

M.. yy 1

-w

=

m.

l d b.

s_

my Y'

h '.h

.h 5

h.

hh@.h

% %.3;aw. doLh

+:V,a%z xMOL'

.ygg w:,,4y%% '

w ) $q % w L

DU

.S.Ag.m.

4..

3 4

w f m.@,,,.go%a g,,, p[g._

n<:,j e. + b.,% y.t

,.u. y'.. gem y

+-

,(

w n

['. ',,.,.h8%. 27 ' ( shD[q..4 3 yQ' ' #z 4 3 g4 p*.

c n

[,.,9 ;g %y,

[

Y [..$

, %y N {g 340 m, T' C

m&M t.r. m W ;sg #n. 4 c. A &e8 Mrhk 4

s, s.

m m,Nea M.ory4.,MW,?

Gi h x-4 k_M.,. g.%..,d..,W.,y..:. A

/4.a.D pm o, d a M. %. 8. k,,, e %.M. h.4, J

WM3

n. S
n m.v-T W ' M,-4.,.,.p. h'[Q.

7s

,,qp,

+,,

6.i. 4 g, -

' 4 c.c

=,,.

<'e

.. %m

.c t

,g. - 4*p g

Aye

,p

$ ** * ' ggN f j

.'M 2

'Y; t.q

~:;.

3

f. -

%, %q[,f

" y p{,, a.R,y - y W &u h5.. ge h

jY y. 98,]*

d p

I.g 4

g...

.y t,

gj r

r,

hni ( b.. hk...-Q.w

. 0. C h...

,r a x

.. M..%

.f..

O q ' N~Lp _ mf f.<N v

.t

@ 'Qs..

pg. g-g

, 'l*

Q :p&+?;$if(

n,p r

+ f

$y-

,l, n

f..QQ'.

i Oy. %. %", u y&Wh Mpri. fM X,% %a.w,QQ;Qs,.y gg **

. % + ;g&,,,,n. Q.. p.4, K%

'N O

.. kwe k,

~

~

$m

. 'M a

".w s

e. y,

.s -

24 kDD5%.hkhh j#h NM,NNd rkf5Y%..

mga we&h?w m > AlNfhN n

by..bs,s.,,.h,kM. h....

~

x,D Y. - h

.,._ W k

c L

.s

,w..

kh q!"c,pMhl

.?.Mhk.d.Mk N..

g.

,y.c

., i a d,: e. k h s h. h$n YN

.g-o

.o, ut 1

ew.,e.c t r

~, A~ %..;te a

g. %,m. 4 s,%

M. m... +

r.

9 9.

y..~

vn.. g@,$ a q@f$@heg. c

..,. J 4 eA fM ' '.

h.J.k.,

3 wi a

s.,

O NS 9EN e.a AW y h,g%pA 4, 4:.g Y.

1. 5, 4

4 c

m.

q-,

v,,

A m wM.

a

. 2., vN.n..WN.d ms.

.,s f..h. N D %g.g., w m u n.-.

+

a w.n.

T.# m. _y D U. T 3 d,>k p.4 v.M.

O.s &.m, IWi T.

Ns..,

R.

.2w.,

3 a

s.

s c,f 4 g.

,.m }ryg

- *** *j 1eb I

I,

- " mar'8aA***g **9,%

      • yir, M.*
    • =

IP 6.

h

.b...

h

~.. - -.

......11 a nt; i.\\GrtvLat - L\\tD-o3014155955 : 7 5t\\i BY:4tdll.\\GHOLdt - L\\fD 2-d-33 4

3

., N eg.

,,, b.y

.S,

, y,.6, i,

.,e

) # 'n b, E $I s.

  • 1
  • '6 14.,3.%

e '#

+.

's. '.$.<,[p,,.g,

p

.,7 m

i s

5 y 4

  • k..,4

~-,,

Y h'w.

$II

. I. <.. ;

,,f*f 4.'

e, %.5,29ka

+ s... w.

-."c. [,.,, (m.,[>.~,1 {.%g k

,.c p,

w r k. ' 3.4 a4 i

i

w w a

.'s N,e,d,'I 4

g,, m *e ; +*:[!3

[p.h.*Y."' h,8 ff.hh* ' i_('f tf,' hU'

)

3;. a. (vib7 N

' 35,7.

  • 4 g.JJr.ymzm,p$r;.tge.g.

/

)

vw

. gp c@er4.;

gk es A w.

[iy fid$ng2-R

$3;%j cd

. WD e%Wj!$JNDP.e w s }i y

'yA.

l g;g;4%g%%

e yMe Twg.Yg& p%g%aw?x ?

g gg@g33 111.

M gps.* 4 A 4

$9hM PC13mf r

d%L:skww e 44e 4

v e;

j 3%NhhNidEkf$kd l hfk$

A W(e%njMWiRg%r$

M 4n

! sen:s am ese wpm:.: en ma s s db e

i

n. oe.

. o,.Q

e. Q -

a.

ay.

4 3

.,m..

,& e c.

.-.+.,s.-

4 h.akb r

g.

k h k h-k f hf wh di Ih; 4[

h

.h l

. f.%

hh$h hgh ?qbhfk k

m au g.

g g

a.,

g&w ; k,y

" ?

g%Q q.yf

o,g gg M

AfE Es sM l NM lisI M3$}gd A 9

4 t

V 4 ?, k k,i k ja

. % g l.kW t4 8g i k3

. %q

28 H t

ib O

dWamhh sn r

e mem w4

mycf Jp.%,gupm,_ magy.-,a.a 4Wg,o.

wL ymwc vacuzwc b.

SENT EY:KESTINGF10ESE-CNFD2-3-Si.

11:5u nca i$unuux.

J

^

^

Fission Product Comparison Scale (MeV Sq/KgU) 1 I

646 3,000 5.000 7,500 440,000 i

i i

e s \\

s i

a i

\\ \\

646 = level measured in fresh uranium samples @ 99% confidence.

3.000 = average level measured in Zion Region 17 samples.

5.000 = specification limit for commercial grade UF6 (ASTM C787).

4 7,500 = level meusured in Zion Region 17 samples @ 99% confidence.

1

)

i 440,000 = specification limit for enriched reprocessed UF6 (ASTM C996). Note -

this point is 220 inches to the right on u linear scale.

Penetration of the Zion materialinto the reprocessed specification is i

2.500/435.000 x 100 = 0.57%.

Actinida (Pu/Np) Comparison (Bq/KgU) 3.300 0

5 17 25

\\ \\

1 1

1 i

t a

\\\\

5 = level measured in fresh uranium samples @ 99% confidence.

17= average level measured in Zion Region 17 samples.

25 = level measured in Zion Region 17 samples @ 994 confidence, j

3.300 - Specification limit for enriched reprocessed UF6 (ASTM C996). Note -

the 3.300 pciat is 412 inches to the right on a linear scale.

Penetration of the Zion materialinto the reprocessed specification is 25/3300 x 100 = 0.76%.

37,-

i mc, em ;my m,..x.y. m.: m ;u, rr.,,: w w w

.q',.

r l-

  • k'*

lJ b' -,,

,k.c;y

.h.,

-).3 [.'

Mi j '_

N f f,.,

k

. f ~ 'N l

f

~

y

[

.y iL. n

..s.

'"1 j+ l ;,

~

4343, *t " '

"9 p

7 s

,f.

,Q 2;:,V k"..

'.7) f@

~' ~

j S

6 w.

g

.t 4

u.

.he 9

""(.,y.

n

..;w

n w

~.

if.

~ $1 ; y

'y,

"['

3

.a 3,.,

. 12,.B..(.

/;

W,,

,,L

1...,. ~ L e 1. ;.-

'r mm:som_ m.m sA en a.

$t;

+

h..!LMt R & & c " ' m L A r w y N e l. m i:Y.F w i a a E U:?

.af 3

h!

hh*

kb S

JL34 OI.6CJaa.huGVv00 L.'s' d V~JJ 4vd "CJa*'u'*-'0w w ** d" OU V '14 3303 54U

$gg.k' [, %p*'Mjt',. e.fggf.8 faj;higb) F..l (f I: V.T "7C / k IE 4, g.4f g' ' N[.Ih,'I'-g!;gg'I[*NMM-f't. pgA

" \\'4 t

g i

a: wane.ns nnme M*

peye u= w< e s c +

e w' fl~ 'Ildf4;f-eqmleg$gdfh gy - f )m a-

. yY5 "%'.h? h 9

t e g; e a k h If N i l,2 3 (N.

fQ" 4

.g#gb.;f ebm g.BM s ngnq,p Wggm e,p.w

.t gA a

N;fkg,;.g

$[ khk kI;ff!fik94$$

hfh

%gyyNey)kh%{$

R; h

. >i fG ay m p$

f

@u;m 4ygdRl$

Mb

^

,g

. ) 9

, r w; f,y

c p

g fEh YM M p; papy

[ g.g

,s h

% ;. C 1

3 l:

%4 b

3 A N

~usuhnkh,y w

s;a at N

Nk

2T.\\ 1 01 AC311.\\lJflVL3C -

L. if s u-ww

.4 11

' u. - 6 0.. - ' *. s '

U-41200v J 4 A

-4 i.-

gy:

r w : r y g g c w,l y,k p..

m,yjf.l%{,.M x mg.

e g,;,. r;., (;.y a y r y

x.

,. pgl tyg.

N

}

j

Wp jeg..g. ! 4: 7 1 A w . st g. .s i ~ $$~j M ?g. N(. n.iMh $y$ li. 5 ex m .r ~~ as j ,J g j Qx gW% g,.,ppk ~ u n s 3 g- = i a w ( mL % A 3 u k I I + f.. n m2r -,'b* A-g. . _. iv:MR ts < a' vgsm ) F. v:3.g.g;gN) yq,ggm..s _;;; g. y,_;y m yym;pg j m-p: g >v 3-w;. g g.g.-~_. w ggyggn g_r .r. -ms y

  • t,{

1 ?i _..; g _7 _gg -.7 ) 1 1 e bf.kAS-jkk['fff.$jddhqh'$id.kykNjfdi,(, .k{M.Q,; fhQ b,, D ( ~ 3, "4 (g, -

  • k I, %

'r U' g' ' ' jd I b[ f a w R l az(: Snacquggagagene;,%nggy.p)Ts;. 4 Ig4hS 89D R,jp g w w: om $ade[a!ynd4l$ SW%fag y g$e$ghT 16 i l a... s h 43 s ,s a) .m m.m.4.... b 3 ,2, 3 yw .m i~ f i J , g4 t %jv y, 4 9%$

te j gn 4-c e

'm mr v v yr

  • A 1.b.

My.e y' Ni [} l &.-... 1Q fl (*$' e ~ d' g~ ja,:g r A a w%

arst,

_s a .s y$ gg s i 4.; i e. 2.Nkk b !d fht ki hi

  • N i L:.M;,

man %c :i : mum A.m ar_a==wwaxmem.am M4 awe,mn~aremawmen;smm .at. $lWh Sb u I. 4 1 ,,a__,,n.n h-. 22,,?- ~A i 5 \\i D1 6C.311NUrlVLSC. - '.\\r J 0-JJ . A L.> 't_.- WI.ct c s. Lii U~ OJUA1aJJu)) ~A0 L t o' ~ kM g w w$)g!k@ggg$ggts$hM N Nff! fkhMM fAh 5 4 g wp g8R edghgbiig w.$ h U gie i h8kT IhR i (hkh kh!)# LN94%M%thh .. n, ~ ~ .....i + 9: s .w w w .e w 4 qs 4

r.
  • i;;

c ~~ y

p %.
r-v~e.

' ' *n f l k rgg y,. f 9 %":$$$ t, - (!y 4 + t r y. g y; y.. p./.w-j .? 3 Y 'qh; 't ? 7

  • [

.f.$..i a, y 1.. t O w.;

2..

./+ H.. b 'y ,j, ?h ) { Y-f$2 45 .;. spS)S ~ j;; m i m'. 4g ].. g pp.. ..s s gke; a wA. w e . _w.mp.nw_msw_xwcw&s_wA,Lm i ~;. x. k'a Y ii A5u .ma4_,e-Au ==,->J-- 4 4 MsA _---Sa- _k E 7;.. " p $, ' TQ f N; k'{Wi* 'D I.1 % d i i r :/. M d 1,_8 4[?pcia 1 TV.fi.<f;%;f L..W9;f Ti.%(D fg4 ' M%,, 't V Ng 3 h ifb[ -fikkk[!$ khhki$hkkklk kh? h Y e c eig % g m(g $btp% id t9 ih ! $$lkM MQt a g%&e#N,m, lV% ya..gd I { , n_ h,n,if.. - 1- -k k *i-d ' ifIv ,L ld 9 $p 3 J ~ g f$( 1,/)Agggpp i L,,h M %3 m s.

  1. 9 y

(, _ k _( d [ U " 7 3 3 4 p' 1 ?gli" ' 3 % _m c w ~ 1 5 b rt'I W," ' W g +; s y,., h \\ /