ML20202H663

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Final Response for FOIA Request for Documents.Documents Listed in App A,Being Released in Entirety.Documents Listed in App B,Being Withheld in Part & Documents Listed in App C, Being Withheld in Entirety (Ref FOIA Exemption 7C)
ML20202H663
Person / Time
Site: Beaver Valley
Issue date: 12/04/1997
From: Racquel Powell
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Xander K
REED, SMITH, SHAW & MCCLAY
Shared Package
ML20202H668 List:
References
FOIA-97-387 NUDOCS 9712100337
Download: ML20202H663 (5)


Text

. _ _ _ _ _ _ . - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _- _ - _ . . _ .._ _ - . . _ _ _ . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ . -

U.$, NOCLE AR RLGULATORY COMMISSION  %% e oin ut uviu Nwet Nia c FOIA 97 3a7

,[(4..sc\ pg M() RESPONSE TO FREE 00M OF u l "Na' as sesu m I P ^atiat

~

INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST oa't

g%.,7,/. .* M 0 4 W/

ovat i suvei msi m mmw l PL Out tt t H

,(. Karen M. Xander PART i,-AGENCY RECORDS RELE ASED OR NO e LOCAT ED (See c*et Aed homes /

No agency records subject to the request have been located.

No additional agent y records subject to the request have been located Requested records are avadable through another pubbc distribution program See Comments section.

Agency vecords subject to the request that are identified 6n Apperuf ates) are already available for pubhc mspection and coprmg at the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 21?O L Street. N W., Washington. DC.

Agency records subject to the request that are 6dentihed in Appendia fes) A are be,no enade avaitab!e for pubhc inspection and copone XX at the NRC Pubhc Document Room,2170 L Street. N W, Washmgton, DC,in a folder under this F OI A number The nonproprietary version of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept m a telephone conversation with a member of my staf f is now being made available for pubbc snspection and copying at the NRC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street N W . Waihmgton DC, m a folder under this FOI A number.

Agency records subject to the request that are identst.ed in Append sfes) may be inspected and copied at the NRC Local Pubhc Document Room identified in the Comments section. __

triclosed is mformation on how you may obtain access to and the c.harrs for copying records located at tbs NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N W , Washington, DC XX Agenty records subsect to the request are enclosed Appendi x A and the releasable Dortions of Annendi x A dnrumnnt e.

Records sutyist to the request have bet'n referred to another Federal agencybes) for revien and daet.t response to you a re attached, XX I"' We have already recehnd advanrod naymont in tha-amount of $52.07 for-UwwM+es You wm be bined by the NRC for fees tot Ang S fOr proce5Si09 your request.

You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of $ _

in oew of N RC's respnse to this tsquest, no further action is bemg taken on appeal letter dated , No, PART 11. A-lNFORMATlON WtTHHE LD F ROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certam information in the requested records is beine withheld from public disclosure pursuant to the enemptions described in and for the reasons ststed in Part 11, B, C, and D, Any released portions of the documents for which only part of the record is being withheld are being made available for pubilc g inspection and copying in the NRC Pubhc Document Room,21?O L Street, N W., Washington, DC m a folder under this FOI A number, COMME NTS l'

p.1 I

O gc sAtunt oistcryar. ivims o+ r apt &sior estoevAtioN Asa ruaticAtions stavects L ,a h k h ..t Y J -

9712100337 971204 I,li111Ill.illlll11:'

o s o ll PDR FOIA XANDER97-387 PDR

f ot A fuvM3 8i t s , DAt3 RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF h

5 INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST FOlA - 97 387 3,b s ,, .-

  • y /

(CONTINUATION)

PART 118- APPLICABLt (XtMP1 TONS Records subject to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendiates) b b b are bemg withheld in their entirety or in part utider the Esemption No.(s) and for the reason (s) given below pursuant to 5 U.S C. 652M and 10 CF H 9.17(4) of NRC regulations.

14 the methheid edo,metion is properiv ciaisAed pesvent to taecutive order. ttnempten 11

2. The ..thheid mtormation seistes welv to the miemal personnel ruies and peocodees of NRC ttiemption 21 3 The w*thheaf mformanon is speedecelty enempted bom pubiec disc 60swe by statute endicated. It nemption 3)

$ections140146of the Atom 4 Inergy Act, which prphibits the deciosu'e of Restoctert Dete or F ormeriy Restricted Data (42 U S C. 21612166).

\

l Section 147 of the Atomic Energy Act, wh+ch prohituts the disclosure of Unclass+f.ed Sefeguards information 442 U tl C. 2167).

4 The withheid m'ormat.on is a trede seceet or commeetial p+ f manosi m4<mation that is bemg withheid fo' the #eesontal endic.ated (E nemption al The mformaten is conside'ed to be conhdent ai business (peopoetarti mio#mobon The mtosmaten is c ces.dered to t,e proeneten informat*on pwouant to 10 CD R 2 790idit ti The m'o< mat.on was submetted end ecceived m conf dence pu*suant to 10 CFR 2 790idM2 i

16 The withheid m'oemet.on tonsists o'interagenc y os mt'asgency eec oros that are not e.eostue menavS dmove's de ng ti.9ation it nemption 61. Apphrabio Privilege:

I.

D Deiterab,e Proc ess D.scioswe of predeus+onal mfo*mahon would tend to orthOtt the open and bent enc hange of totas essentiat to the dehbeseDve p*o(ess Who's vect eds are withheid m then enurely. the f atis a+e meetnc abi, mtert a med with the vedeos.or ai inf ormenan these eso s'e no veasonabiv sed'egatue tactuat portions because the release of the f ac ts mould permit en end*et t mou% mio the p.coec sionai FN ess c8 the egenc, 4.- A t t o< ne , n o. pec.dm t po va ege .Dm u+ents n' era cd tw en attome, .o .t ecmpeu 4 vi +vom wiens J, Attorney.cs.ent pr*voege. (Contctenbal communecabons between en attoreev and h+s Mr ci,ent I l6 The w.thheid mtwmeten is esemoted t,om puenc o stiesse inause is d : wise wouidn ,esst ,n a cica.g u e s, anted m=asion of tersona1 prnecy ti semption Ky 7 The a-thheid intoemet.on cons,sts of <ec ords canoised f oe tan enf orcement peposes and is t eing withheid fue the eessen 66 mtt cated (E memption 7)

~

' Dmiuve couid reasonaui be t eipecied i ntea .e ..th e en ento,<ement p.oceed no because ,i couid reve.i ihe icoue. <brect sn. and vocu, oi enforcement eHotts avi thus could poss t9y ai!on recip.ents to take acteon to shield potent al weongrtoms or a v.oistion of NRC requirements

' hom mveit44 ton (E nemot on 7 ( AH yy Dwiosu re *Md constitute en uncertented invas.on of pe sonai pr'vecy (E nemption 7tCH

. _ . _ _ _ _ . _ ~ . __.,.__ _ - _

t he etwmpibun c Qr's.bls Dt f' names t I -fid vela d'% And ot'.e 5 dM Mt M thf i f b hM e d Ah g e- i rid 'e 8C mdhlt oc e t Di'{ TP#110 f t' e cai i de@t'es o' t enboent a+ sour ces it tempoon 7 (DH IV nlH _

PART41 C - DINYING OF FICIALS Pmmt m 10 CF H 9 ?MM aN m 9 Mici M the U S Narra 144% Ccem u w w at ei t t as bon netem ned that ine demv on a tee +d s enempt %m os auct.oa m d sctwe amt the a poiat un w a w we i to% 4 y to me put - . mec T he neww mow +tec 6 tu iten a e.e thme ouc 4 i dent,f ed t.ee* es ceny mg othc a a **t the D 'ecte D v m of F,.m1gm of IMomp on ew Pute cv es 5m 4 s 0" ce of Axim-vet e ir a% den n that chae be entwe ed to the iurubve D"ettes tovOne'et eiitD0i DtNnNo or FiciAt

__.-_. .._ _ _ _ . _ tif tt or t ic t _ ..___ . _, _st CosDs DE N>t D l APet t t a t t ot tici At . . -

Hubert 3, Miller ire ional Administrator Reg.

( _, - - _ . + . - .

%- _ _ . _ . _ . _ __ . , . _ _ _a M d'AM n. L .. _C-..% H.____..e'_ _ _ - + -I - -

t I i 1 )

_____._-_.__.4___.__ _ _a --+ .- ~+---_ -

t . i I= i l

i.  !  !

4._ _ ._. t.  %

i.

I i i 1

.4-~~_.,_.- _

+ q.,_._-.. _ - .- p --_

i 1-4 I i

, . _ - . _ _ _w' J---_- '

l I i

i PARTI 4 0- APPE AL RIGHTS Tha cen-a t y each dent mg oH c at dent f ed in Pe*t il C a m y t e appea ed to **e Appe we O'! c e6 .dect t ed tve Anv se epoer v 9e rvie >n ant mg * -t* r 30 de vi oi r<ce pt of in+s teignns+. Appas s m u st be addeemd as approprate. to twe i necutwe Deec'o< 9 Opera'-ons to the %=c.e'a v o' the Con

  • sien= o' to the twecto' Genera- U S Na es' Reptory Comm as.on. Aasn4ng'on. DC 7Mb5 and Rosd pes", stre or the eave one and m the etter ' rat tien' App.4 ' rom en le t 4 F O:A Dec i on i

NRC FOAM 464 (Part 21 (191) U S NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

t s

t Re: FOIA 97-397 APPENDIX A RECORDS REING pimen IN TIEIR ENTIRETY (If copyrighted identify with *)

h DMX DESCRIPTIM/ (PM COUNT)

1. 01/24/94 Handwritten note from Dave V, to Bill / Dave (1 page)
2. 02/12/93 Allegation Management System (1 page)
3. 05/04/93 Combined Inspection Report 93-05 (23 pages)
4. 03/17/93 Sample Record of allegation Panel Decisions (2 pages)
5. 06/16/93 Telephone Report (1 page)
6. 7/9/93 office of Investigations handwritten notes.

(1 page)

7. 7/22/93 Memo from B. Letts to T. Martin, subject:

Closure of Case No. I-93-008: Beaver valley / Alleged Harassment and Intimidation.

(1 page)

1 1

I Re: FoIA-97-387 APPWIDIZ B MCORDS BEING WITERELD IN PART  :

E D&Ig nummrperomr/ tn=<== r4rner) /=wummtr==

1, 03/09/93 Allegation Receipt Report. (9 pages) Portions withheld, EE. 7C

2. 11/02/93 Ltr from David J. Vito to A11eger. (? pages)

Portions withhald, R. 7C

3. 11/2/93 Ltr from David J. Vito to Alleger. (2 pages)

Portions withhald, R. 7C

4. 03/30/93 Ltr from Roy L. Puhrmeister to Alleger (2 pages) Portions withhald, E. 7C
5. 03/30/93 Ltr from Roy L. Fuhrmeister to Alleger (OFFICIAL RECORD COPY) (2 pages) Portions withbald, n. 7C
6. 02/10/93 Allegation Receipt Report. (3 pages) Portions withbald, n. 7C
7. 03/30/93 Ltr from Roy L. Fuhrmeister to Alleger (2 pages) Portions withheld, H. 7C
8. 03/30/93 Ltr from Roy L. Fuhrmeister to Alleger 6 # FFICIAL RECORD COPY) (2 pages) Portions withheld, n. 7C  !

k e W **

. . , - . . _ . . . . . . -,_._--m . _ _ - - -- - _ _ _ _

1 4

Rat FOIA-97-387

'l APPEIDIX C RECORD BEING WITEIELD IN ITS INTIRETY E L. DEEE DESCRIPTIW/ (PAM COUNT) /EIEMPTIWS

1. 12/30/93 Handwritten " Corrective Action Plan." (15 pages)

RE 7c d

f

-~- . . - . . , , _