ML20199E365
| ML20199E365 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 11/14/1997 |
| From: | Racquel Powell NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Williams O JRA ASSOCIATES |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20199E369 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-97-375 NUDOCS 9711210178 | |
| Download: ML20199E365 (5) | |
Text
us.uuCttAa ctulatoRv comuuos
,m u.o. uau wm m, 1
FOlA c;r_s' i
}\\p, RL % EON 5L 1 Yet Lf, T 1
RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF lwt LKl ematiAL / "M (o.a..)
@ p6 i
INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST crit g )4 g' DOCD.11 NUMtil A(W Urasp4cabde/
.L out St i s.
+ r 4"
M-
/
/
/An t-we'.-
PART 1.-ADLNCY RECORDS HE LE ASED OR NOT LOCAT ED (See cherAedbonesl No agency records sucject to the rouvest have been la'.ated.
No add.tional agency records subject to the request have been located.
Requested records ere available through another pubhc distribution program. See Comments section.
Agency records subject to the request that are identified in Appentba fes) are already available for pubhc inspection and copying at the k
NGC Pubhc Document Room. 2120 L Street, N W. Washington. DC.
Agent y records subject to the request that are identified in Anmndiales) 8 are being rnade available for public inspect 4on and copying X
cos NRC Pubhc ooeumeni Room,2i20 t siretig. we,wngion. DC..n a side unde,in s FOlA number e
The nonproprietary vwsion of the proposat(s) that you ag+eed to acecat in a telephone conversation with a member of my staf f is now being rnade avvabic for public inspection and copying at the N RC Public Document Roor i,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC, in a folder urJet this F OI A number.
A<pncy records subsect to the request that are identified in Appender(es) may be inspected and copied at the NRC Local Pubhc Document Room 'dentified in the Comments section.
Inciosed is information on how you may obtain attest to and the charges for copying records located at the NRC Public Document Hoom,2120 L Street, N W., Washinr} ton. DC
[
Agency records subject to the request are criclosed flicords subject to the request have been referred to anne., F ederal egencybes) for review and detect response to you.
Fees You will be b3 led by the NRC for feet totaimg $
You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of $ __
in view of NRC's response tr* this request, no further action is being taken on appeal letter dated
,No PART ll. A-INFORMATION Wi1HHELD F ROM PUBLIC DISCLOSUHL Certain inf ormatic*n in the requested records is being withheld f rom public ditClosure pursuant to the esemptions described in and for the reasons ststed in Part it, B, C, and D Any released portions of the documents for whic*, only part of the record is being withheld are being made available for publ6c inspection and copying in the NRC Public Document Room,2 t20 L Street, N W., Washington, DC in a folder unrter this FOI A number, COMME NTS RI7U /j 4ll1110lll15p!!1 EIGNAt Rt DIR(C
.IVth OrF(N OQ OF INF ORM A110N AND eUBLICA f LONS S( HVt0l5 w
Ay (1/
x w
9711210178 971114 PDR FOIA WILLIAMS97-373 PDR j
~
,--.....,..,o
PQiA edupe taf&i DAts RESPONSE TO FREEOOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST FOIA -9./.hF e
,.m.
(CONTi"UATIDst)
PART II B-APPLICABLE ETEMPilONS Records subject to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendis(es)
C are being withheld in their entirety or in part under the 0:ernption No.(s) and for thei teannn(s) givsn below pursuant to 6 U S.C. 552(b) and 10 CF R 9.17(a) of NRC regulations 1 The withheld informaten es propeely classefed pursuant to Executive Order. (Esemptiori1) p 1~ we,ee f.ma_.e_es.osety fo he m, ems so.me,, s.~ed,es of -
a.e.oo,
,, - w _._f _._. s_,...t....,,.d f._.
m._. b. s _ e _._.._,,
$ecttons 141146 of the Atomic E riorgy Act. which prohibits the disclosure of heste cted Dets of Formeety Restracted Data (42 U.S C. 216121651.
Certson 14? of the Atomsc E nergy Act, which prohibits the disclotuff of Unciaisif,ed Se'eguertis Informat.on (42 U.S.C. 2167).
- 4. The withhoed mformaten es a treJe secftt or commercial ot financial mformation that is bestig withheld for the seasonial ihd cated. (Enempt1n 4)
The enformation es canadered to be contdentief business ep'tionetary) eformat.on The mformaten se conssdered to be peopfeetery entormation pursuant to 10 CF A 2 79DidH1i The mformeteon was oubmitted and veceived m confidence puesuant to 10 Cf M 2 790tdH2i ite w+thheid e$tormation cons,sts of enterogency o' mitaagetic, records that a'e not 5.suster 'Nough t scover, opng tit gation (E mempuon 6). Appucatne Previ6ege Deitte'ettve Pro (ess Disdosure of peedeosional mformation would tend to inhitut the open and trank enchange o' ideos essentia8 to the de'iberatwe p'ocess Where esto#ds ese withheld m these entnety the f acts are enestncably eriterteined a rth the predecas.oress eriformatiori There also are no fessonabsv se regable f actus-po'1 sons tocause the totease of the f ac's would permst an mdaect mours mte the predec4eonal process of the agencs Attorney woes prodsK t pesveiege (Doc uenefits prepared by sen attnincy en (os,temgdstait, td s.t.uatiori Attorney thent privHege. (Conf.dential communecations between en setoeney and hister chent.)
l6 Tre withheid enbrmaten es esempted hem putet disUnsee t.etause its 0.actowe nou'a 'esult in a rican / na" anted iroasen of orsons' p< wen 4sempt:on 6; t
i
- 7. The esthheld mformaten ccmsents of records compiled foe law entoecement purposes anc is being e4thheld io, the reasomst mdica'ed {Esemotic6 7)
D<sclosure coutJ reasonably be espec1ed to Pterfere wth en
- atorcement pf oceeding because #1 could reveal the scope, daertiott and focus of eMurcoment efforts and thus could posutBy ellow tecipients take adsori to snield potent at wrongdang o' a violettori of NRC esqu4eemeros from invest'gato's it mempt.on _7 ( AH D.scionwe would conshtute en unwansated evas.on t.1 personel pnvecy. iE mempt on 7lCD The in'ormation c onsists of names et endwiNew ni utbe informat e it.e t suuwee ut e.be n ( wM caushu t+ e neced to re.ca urnt>t en o' c onbdenhei sources, timemption 7 (D))
oint it
~-
"~
PART11 C-OENYING OFFICIALS Pu want ta 10 CF R 9 h1 and o' 9 750 cd the U t Nuc+ee Rwry, Comm o on rv9m4Mn* t ne neca nvivro net that the etw rnoon * <t %e d >$ eseme ' om DU r
- d. ction or dwoewe and that,ti p<ooutt.on o+ d cove a contery to in, pub-c.n'ew The Omnns moewe 4 eny oen a re t%c utos s aew m den n dew rr I
e pif.c.ais amt t$e D.<cetot D>v i.on of F emtom n into mat.on and Pw cate Sers ce OH ce o' Adm n st at on f r ar v den a s that me, de opina co *a the E merutve Daen e
for Operations if D01
-1 DINYING OHICIAL fiTu Or$<f Rf CORD 5 Of Nit 0 A8'sig nATE Ors 4ci At I
-.TE.dM M '.
h~
y
- 1 ' ED0' I
a f
m+w l,,w%
Ay&LLK[
j 1
n i
t w.
m, t
t u
l t
i
(
PARTll 0 - APPE AL RIGH E S j.
The dew b, each den,m, ofoc+ identif ed n Fet ii C ma, e4 apoea ed to ts. Aprewe o,4 e a, cent f ed ihre An, so nones ma b. maae #.. t,g. e - 3a m, e,c, c: 4 of thts reigk5nse. Appos's muni be addrested $3 apprSof Late tQ the { necgtTg D recto? for Opersms to the Sec'etry o' tne Comm sie o+ t a the lascezm Geva U 5 % es Cegator'y Commissioss. Washington, DC 2Q566, end snodd citarly state on the tevWDe and e the ietter thr :t tl an " Appr( Nm as INr EC O Dec1 y N"C FOZM 464 (Part 21 (191)
U S. NUCLE AR REGUL ATORY COMMISSIOa v
.___. _ _ ~.. _ _. _. _ _ _ _ _. _ _.
s s.
e Re: FOIA 97 375 APPENDIX A 3
RECORDS ALREADY AVAILABLE IN THE PDR l
l ACCESSION I
MQ, DATE NUMBER Df4GBlP_ TION /(PAGE COUNT) 1, 03/29/96
- 9604080088 Letter from R. Cooper, NRC, to R. Sylvia, Niagara 1
Mohawk Power Corporation (NMPC).
Subject:
NRC Specialinspection Report No. 50 220/96 05; 50-410/96-05 (26 pages).
t 2.
06/18/96'
. 9606260077 Letter from T. Martin, NRC, to R. Sylvia; NMPC.
Subject:
Notice of Violation and Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty - $50,000 (NRC Inspection Report No. 50 220/96 05; 50-410/96 05)(8 pages),
3; 07/16/96 9607230423 Letter from R. Sylvia, NMPC, to J. Lieberman, NRC.
Subject:
Reply to June 18,1996 Notice of Violation (NRC Inspection Report No. 50 220/96 05) (14 pages).
t 4.
08/15/96 9608230214 Letter from R. Sylvia, NMPC, to J. Lieberman, NRC.
Subject:
Supplement to Reply to June 18,1996 Notice of Violation (NRC Inspection Report No. 50 220/96 05)(4 pages).
SL 12/03/96 9701300173 Letter from J. Lieberman, NRC, to R; Sylvia, NMPC.
Subject:
Order imposing Civil Monetary Penalty - $50,000 (Nine Mile Point, Unit 1)
(13 pages).
G.
02/03/97:
9702040022 Letter from J. Lieberman, NRC, to R. Sylvir, NMPC.
Subject:
Public Meeting - Nine Mile Point, 3
Unit 1 (49 pages).
7J 02/19/97 9702260429
- Letter from N. Reynolds, Counsel for NMPC, to J. Lieberman,
Subject:
Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation Nine Mile Point Unit 1 (5 pages).
l
- -w w
e-w-8-ew e t7 m J w-N w
e F"wv k
t'--r'*W*hWW em W -ms' 9 98
?
S**
g7 w--
' t grg-w= im m 13--
!-+T+-
7 9"W'**"r-r-E--T**W9%c'h-eg-Wre' Tser wh'tr wy F-y" T7 Tt EPP W "evd" h*
o Re: FOIA 97 375 APPENDIX B RECORDS BEING RELEASED IN THEIR ENTIRETY
- NO.
DAIE DERGRIPTION#PAGE COUNT) 1.
Undated Design basis document from Nine Mile Point Final Safety Analysis i
Report describing pressure relief design with handwritten notes by J
J. Lieberman, NRC (1 page).
2c Undated Hand-written notes by J. Lieberman, NRC, used during Public Meeting - Nine Mile Point, Unit 1 (2 pages).
Drawings from the Nine Mile Point Final Safety Analysis Report 3.
Undated -
describing the turbine and reactor buildings blow-out panels (2 pages).
4.
04/12/96-NMPC presentation at NRC Enforcement Conference with hand-written notes by M. Satorius (NRC) (16 pages),
i 5.
02/19/97 Letter from N. Reynolds, Counsel for NMPC, to J. Lieberman.
Subj: Niagara Mohawk Power Corp. Nine Mile Point, Unit 1. (5 pages) with handwritten comments.
4 b
~. - -
Re: FOIA 97-375 APPENDIX C i
RECORDS BEING WITHHELD IN THElR ENTIRETY j
MQ, DATE DESCRIPTION /IPAGE COUNT)/SEMPTIONS 1.
Undated Note to multiple addressees, NRC.
Subject:
Background
information used during n 4/11 conference call conces.i.ng proposed reply to NMPC t31ow-Out Panels Vicistion (14 pages).
j EX.5 t
2.
Undated Note to J. Lieberman, M. Satorius, and R. Zimmerman, NRC, from E. Rossi, NRC.
Subject:
Draft NMP 1 Blow Out Panel Letter (1 page). EX. 5 3.
Undated Draft NRC response to the NMPC's denial of a 10 CFR 50.72(b)(1)(li)(B) violation (5 pages). EX. 5 4.
01/03/97 E mail to multiple addressees, NRC, from L. Doerflein (with attached draft NRC response to the NMPC's denial of a 10 CFR 50.72(b)(1)(ii)(B) violation).
Subject:
NMPC - NRC January 6 Meeting (4 pages). EX. 5 5,
01/03/97 E mail to multiple addressees, NRC, from L. Doerflein with hand-written notes by J. Liebel. nan.
Subject:
NMPC - NRC January 6 Meeting (1 page). EX. 5 6.
07/08/97 E mail to J. Liebertran, NRC, from D. Ross, NRC, with hand-written nctes by J. Lieberman.
Subject:
NMP Letter to R. Sylvia (1 page). EX. 5 l
1
.,.--..-.r,
....ww, y--
v 3*
y w
,e
--a
,9---,
w--s