ML20198Q588
| ML20198Q588 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Hatch, Monticello  |
| Issue date: | 10/31/1997 |
| From: | Kim T NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9711120266 | |
| Download: ML20198Q588 (42) | |
Text
__
fcuoy
- t UNITED STATES g-l[* .j 2
NUCLEAR REflULATGRY C MMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 300$H001 o
%s,,,,,l October 31, 1997 MEETING PARTICIPANTS: GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, NORTHERN STATES POWER COMPANY. & SOUTHERN COMPANY
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF SEPTEMBER 10, 1997. HEETING ON STATUS OF THE BOILING-WATER REACTOR POWER UPRATE PROGRAM On September 10, 1997, representatives of General Electric Company (GE),
Northern States Power Company (NSP), and Southern Company ISC) met with representatives of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) at the NRC's offices in Rockville, Maryland. The meeting was conducted in two ) arts, a management meeting followed by a working level meeting. As publisled in a meeting notice dated September 3, 1997, the meeting was open to the public.
Attachments 1 and 2 provide lists of meeting attendees for each part of the meeting.
The meeting was requested by GE and the purpose of the meeting was to discuss the overall status of the boiling-water reactor (BWR) power uprate program as well as the items of mutual interest between the NRC and the industry regarding the program.
The NRC staff began the meeting by making a 3resentation that included an overview of the power uprate program. The NRC is currently reviewing power uprate submittals for two BWR plants (Monticello and Hatch) and two ,
pressurized water reactor plants :D.C. Cook and Farley). Attachment 3 contains the overhead slides that were used during the NRC presentation.
The GE representative next made a presentation which included an overview of BWR's power uprate history and future plans. GE indicated that Brown's Ferry and Riverbend plants are planning to submit their applications for 5 percent power uprates within the next 3-8 months. The GE presentation materials are provided as Attachment 4.
The NSP representative and the SC representative each made a short presentation to summarize the overall status of the )ower uprate )rogram at their respective facilities Monticello and Hatch. ionticello, w11ch is the lead plant for the BWR extended power uprate program, submitted its application for a 6.3 percent increase in July 1996. The NSP representative stated that NSP plans to submit a revised application in October 1997, incorporating additional information the NRC staff has requested and also additional material based on its review of industry lessons learned in power uprates. Hatch submitted its application for an 8 percent power uprate in g August 1997. Mtachments 5 and 6 contain the overhead slides that were used g, during the NSP and Sr presentations, respectively. J Following the industry presentations, the NRC staff presented a summary of lessons learned from the NRC's reent self-assessment of the power uprate i program. These staff presentation materials are provided as Attachment 7. i\
9711120266 971031 PDR ADOCK 05000263 P PDR
... ~
ll Ilyl.Ill,II,II) ll mig FaE 85mn mpy
During the meeting, GE requested the staff to complete the reviews on the schedule requested by GE and the utilities. In response, the staff stated that it will apply its best efforts to complete the reviews within the requested time frame. However, as indicated during its presentation of "uprate review lessons learned." the staff's improvement plan, such as developing a power uprate review procedure, could potentially impact the staff's overall review schedule. Also, the staff urged GE (and the industry as a whole) to consider prioritizing, to the extent possible. all cost
) beneficial licensing actions (CBLAs) including such actions as power uprate submittals, so that the staff can better focus its resources on higher priority actions within CBLAs.
Following the management meeting, a working level meeting was held between +,he industry representatives and the NRC technical staff. The purpose of the meeting was to have an open forum to discuss any technical issues of mutual interest for the BWR >ower uprate program. No formal presentation was made during this part of t1e meeting.
I ORIGINAL SIGNED BY Tae Kim, Senior Project Manager
\
Project Directorate III-1 Division of Reactor Projects - III/IV Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos: 50-263, 50-321, 50-366
- cc: See next page Attachments: 1. List of Attendees (First Session)
- 2. List of Attendees (Second Session)
- 3. Meeting Agenda /NRC Handouts
- 4. GE Handouts
- 5. NSP Handouts
- 6. SNC Handouts
- 7. NRC Handouts on Lessons Learned f
DISTRIBUTION: See attached list DOCUMENT NAME: G:\WP00CS\UPRATE\MTGsuM.997 To receive a copy of this document. Indicate in the box C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E Copy with attachment / enclosure N = No copy 0FFICE PM:PD31 E LA:PD31 E D:PD31 /d NAME TJKim:dNd CJamerson* JHannor[
DATE 10/3//97 10/31/97 10/3 //97 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY
4 Edwin 1. Hatch Nuclear Plant 4
cc:
! Mr. Ernest L. Blake, Jr. Charles A. Patrizia, Esquire Shaw, Pittman, Potts Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker l and Trowbridge .
10th Floor -
- 2300 N Street, NW. 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue
- Washington, DC 20037- Washington, DC 20004 9500 Mr. D. M. C owe Chairman
- Manager, Licensing Appling County Commissioners Southern Nuclear Op roting County Courthouse i Company, Inc.' Baxley, Georgia 31513 l P. O. Box 1295 i Birmingham, Alabama E52011295 Mr. J. D. Woodard j Executive Vice President Resident inspector Southern Nuclear Operating Plant Hatch Company, Inc.
- 11030 Hatch Parkway N. P. O. Box 1295 j Baxley, Georgia 31531 Birmingham, Alabama 35201 1295 l Regional Administrator, Regica ll Mr. P. W. Wells U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission General Manager, Edwin 1. Hatch Atlanta Federal Center Nuclear Plant j 61 Forsyth Street, SW, Suite 23T85 Southern Nuclear Operating l Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Company, Inc.
! U.S. Highway 1 North l - Mr. Charles H. Badger . P. O. Box 2010
- Office of Planning and Budget Baxley, Georgia 31515
! Room 610 4
270 Washington Street, SW. Mr. R. D. Barker
- j. Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Program Manager.-
Fossil & Nuclear Operations
! Harold Reheis, Director .Oglethorpe Power Corporation Department of Natural Resources 2100 East Exchange Place
}
a 205 Butler Street, SE., Suite 1252 P. O. Box 1349 Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Tucker,- Georgia 30085 1349 2
' Steven M. Jackson Senior Engineer - Power Supply Municipal Electric Authority l of Georgia i 1470 Riveredge Parkway, NW i Atlanta, Georgia 30328-4684 i
(
}
k 4
DISTRIBUTION FOR GE POWER UPRATE PROGRAM MEE'ING
SUMMARY
DATED: 0ctober 31, 1997-Docket File-(50 263, 50-321~. 50 366)
PUBLIC
-PD3-1 Reading File
-OGC ACRS.
TKim l E mail S. Collins /F. Miraglia R. Zimmerman
-B. Sheron- J. Roe /D.- Matthews E. Adensam B. Boger/J. Zwolinski
=G. Holahan/S. Newberry G. Lainas J. Strosnider R. Wessman J. Calvo T. Collins L. Marsh- G. Hubliard C. Berlinger J. Wermiel
-C. Miller T. Essig K. Manoly L. Phillips R. Emch F. Akstulewicz C. Car) enter P. Cota R. Fra r R. Ingram H. Berkow M. Markley. ACRS M. Young. 0GC T. Martin (SLM3)
B. McCabe (BCM)- M. Tschiltz (MDT)
G. Tracy (GMT) T. Hiltz (TGH)
K. Connaughton (KAC) J. Williams (JFW1)
-S Mitra (SKM1) T. Le (NBL)
T. Ulses.(APU) Y. Li (YCL)
J. Medoff (JXM) H. Garg (HCG) '
Z. Abdullahi (ZXA)
V. Ordaz (VLO)
D. Jackson (DTJ) J. Wu-(CIW1)
C. Craig (CMC 1)- J. Schiffgens-(JOS)
G. West (GXW) F.-Collins (JFC1)
J. Lee (JYL1) T. Huang (JYH)
C. Hehl RI J. Johnson. RII G.-Grant. RIII T. Gwynn. RIV
MEETING ATTENDEES ON SEPTEMBER 10. 1997 1:30 PM TO 2:45 PM tuLme Oraanization R. Zimmerman -NRC B. Sheron NRC S. Newberry NRC T. Kim NRC K. Connaughton NRC C. Berlinger - t!RC J. Williams NRC M. Young NRC H.-Berkow NRC T. Le NRC J. Quirk GE B. McAllister GE W. Marquino GE D. Pappone GE-K. Seconde GE S. Hammer NSP J. Beres NSP B. Linde NSP T. Abney- TVA K. McElroy Southern Nuclear--
T. Lorig Southern Nuclear T. Hoffman Entergy T. Szabo Stone & Webster Attachment 1-
MEETING ATTENDEES ON SEPTEMBER 10. 1997 3:00 PM TO 4:00 PM
!GLmg Oraanization T. Kim NRC C. Berlinger NRC R. Frahm NRC G -Hubbard NRC H. Garg NRC Z, Abdullahi NRC V. Ordaz NRC
- 0. Jackson NRC J. Wu NRC R. Goel NRC T. Huang NRC J. Lee NRC F. Collins NRC G. West NRC S. Lee NRC -
J. Schiffgens NRC C, Craig NRC J. Medoff NRC Y. Li _NRC T. Ulses NRC D. Shum NRC W. Long NRC S. Mitra NRC K. McElroy Southern Nuclear T. Long Southern Nuclear J. Beres NSP S. Hammer NSP B. Linde NSP T. Abney TVA B. McAllistr GE W.-Marquiro GE J. Ouirk GE D. Pappone GE T. Sza)o Stone & Webster Attachment 2
i
} i i.
MEETING '
ON BWR EXTENDED POWER PRATE PROGRAM I
f x Se] tem]er 10. 1997
?r '
E ..
e .
i
-l i
MEETING AGENDA "
~
- 1
- 30 o.m. -
2:45 P.M.
. .: o INTRODUCTION / BACKGROUND NRC i i; o BWR POWER UPRATE PROGRAM OVERVIEW GE
)
o POWER UPRATE PROGRAM AT MONTICELLO NSP l
o POWER UPRATE PROGRAM AT HATCH SN o
MAINE YANKEE LESSONS LEARNED NRC 2:45 o.m. - 3:00 D.m. (BREAK) 3:00 o.m. - 4:30 o.m. i o WORKING LEVEL' MEETING TO DISCUSS TECHNICAL ISSUES INVOLVING GE/MONTICELLO/ HATCH. SUBMITTALS j 2
-. .i
PLANTS FOR WHICH POWER UPRATE AMENDMENTS WERE ISSUED .
' PLANT
- ORIGINAL UPRATED POWER PERCENT DATE LICENSE LICENSE INCREACE POWER AMENDMENT >
(NSSS VENDOR) RATING RATING (M#t) INCREASE ISSUED Brunswick 1/2 (GE) 206 2558 122 5.0 11/01/96 Callaway (W) 3411 3565 154 4.5 i
03/30/88 Calvt Cliffs 1 (CE) 2560 2700 140 5.5 09/02/77 Calvt Cliffs 2 (CE) 2560 2100 140 5.5 10/19/77 0.C. Cook 2 (W) 3391 3411 20 'O.6 01/14/83 Duane Arnold (GE) 1593 1658 65 4.0 03/27/85 Fermi (GE) 3293 _ 3430 137 4.0 09/09/92 FitzPatrick (GE) ,2436 2536 100 4.0 12/06/96 Ft Calhoun (CE) 1420 1500 80 5.6 3
08/15/80 Ginna (W) 1300 1520 220 16.9 12/10/84 Haddam Neck (W) 1473 1825 352 24.0 03/11/69 Hatch 1/2 (GE) 2436 2558 122 5.0 08/31/95 Indian Point 2 (W) 2758 3071 313 11.3 03/07/90 Limerick 1 (GE) 3293 3458 165 5.0 Limerick 2 01/24/96 (GE) 3293 3458 165 5.0 02/16/95 Maine Yankee (CE) 2440 2700 260 10.5 07/10/89
_ Millstone 2 (CE) 2560 2700 140 5.0 05/12/79 NMPoint 2 (GE) _ 3323 3467 144 4.3 04/28/95 North Anna 1/2 (W) 2775 2893 118 4.2 08/25/86 Oyster Creek (GE) 1690 1930 240 14.2 11/05/71 3
O e + + e y__, _ . . - _ . - - - - - - - - .
PLANTS FOR WHICH POWER UPRATE AMENDMENTS WERE ISSUED (continued)
PLANT ORIGINAL UPRATED POWER PERCENT DATE LICENSE LICENSE INCREASE POWER AMENDMENT (NSSS VENDOR) RATING RATING (MWt) INCREASE ISSUED Palisades (CE) 2200 2530 330 15.0 11/11/77 Pch Bottom 2/3 (GE) 3293 3458 165 5.0 10/18/94 Robinson (W) 2200 2300 100 4.6 03/30/79 St. Lucie 1 (CE) 2560 2700 140 5.5 11/23/81 St. Lucie 2 (CE) 2560 2700 140 5.5 03/01/85 Salem 1 (W) 3338 3411 73 2.0 02/06/86 Surry 1/2 (W) 2441 2546 105 4.3 08/03/95 Susquehanna */2 (GE) 3293 3441 148 4.5 04/11/94 .
TN1 1 (B&W) 2535 2568 33 1.3 07/26/88 Turkey Point 3/4 (W) 2200 2300 100 4.5 09/26/96 Vogtie 1/2 (W) 3411 3565 154 4.5 03/22/93 Wolf Creek (W) 3411 3565 154 4.5- 11/10/93 WNP 2 (GE) 3323 - 3486 163 4.9 04/25/95 i 4
PLANTS FOR WHICH POWER UPRATE AMENDMENT APPLICATIONS ARE CURRENTLY BEING REVIEWED BY THE STAFF D.C. Cook (for 5% Uprate) Licensee application received in July 1996 Farley (for 5% Uprate) Licensee application received in. April 1997 Monticello (for 6.3%. Uprate) Licensee application received in July 1996 Hatch (for 8% Uprate) Licensee application received in August 1997 5
l l
1 l GENuclearEnergy l
i Extended Power Uprate '
l NRC ReviewMeeting '
l l
September 10,1997 ( / !
White Flint MD
\ ~
AGENDA
) NRC Managemerit Session (1:30 to 3:00 PM)
! Hatch Extended Uprate SuSmitt61 & Schedule (K. McElroy) l NRC Review Schedule for BWR Uprate Pl ants Submittels & Maine Yankee Lessons Implementation (NRC) l l Questions & Discussion 30 Minutes Break 10 Minutes l Technical Meeting with Staff (Closed Proprietary Session) 3:10 4:10 PM Response to Monticello & ELTR2 RAls (are they adequate? any clarification necessary?)
l l Questions / Discussion
(
1 i
) Attachment 4
' , _ _ . - - - - , _ - _ . _ . - . - , _ . ~ . . . . . - _ . _ - - -
Economic Competiveness at l'owar Uprate 10% Uprate Case 90 0 g( . g.a ..i 6,1 sk 1 70 0 : <uu
~
gg $00 - - -
30 0
- sj 10 0
. . e i . - Y_
PenLing Combined Coal 1096 1096 w/o Oas Tutbine Cycle Nucleat Rotor Costs Gas Uprate Power Uprate History Upreted during Operating Stretch Upretes efter OL
- Stretch (105%) Upretes in Ucense(OL) .
Duane Arnold Progres
- Hatch t,2
- Laguns Ver'!
- Oyster Creek
- Susquehanna 1,2
- R'ver Ben 8
- Dresden
- WNP2
- Browns Ferry 2 and 3 Quad
- Limenck 1,2
- Cotrentes
- Millstone
- PeachBottort 2,3
- La Salle1 ndt
- Monticello *
- Fermi t Extended Upretes
- Pilgrim
- implemented FiuPatnck
- Nuclenor
- Brunsmois a KKM e
NMr. '
KKL
- Extended Uprstes in Progress
- Monticello J + Hatch t,2
- KKL Power Uprate Success' fully implemented tB
)
y .. -
l BWR Stretch (5%) Uprate History
- LTR1, Power Uprate Generic Guldelines 12/90 <
- Staff Position 9/91
- LTR2, Power Uprate Generic Evaluations 7/91
- LTR2, Supplement 1 10/91
- ACRS meeting 3/92
- LTR2 SER 7/92
- LTR2, Supplement 2 10/92
- Fermi submittal 9/91
- FermiSER 9/92 9 Plants Approved 2 Plants in Process Current Status of GE Extended Uprate Genenc Program ELTal Generic Guidelines to NRC 3/95
- NRC Staff position on ELTRI 2/96 ELTR2 EPU Evaluations submitted to NRC 3/96
. ELTR2 Supplement 1 to EPU Evaluations submitted 7/96
- Completed scope agreed upon in NRC review ELTR1
- NRC questions (ELTR2 RAl's ) 3/97
- GE response to RAl's 7/97 e Remaining Actions: )
- Draft SER 40tr97 Same Approach as 104% Uprate;No NewIssues Identified
Summary /RequestedActions Issue Draft SER for ELTR2 Approve Extended Uprate Lead Plant Application Review Subsequent Applications on Improved Schedule i
y '
l
i MNGP POWER RERATE PROGRAM HISTORY Project Initiation - January 4,1995
- GE Contract Issued License Amendment Request Submittal-July 26,1996 50.9(a) Letter Requested 8/1/98 NRC Approval - January 20,1997
- Clarification of Work Status Shutdown for ECCS Suction Strainer Replacement - May 1997
- \
l
- ?
_ v, I/oh191:Jao Page 1 of 4 Attachment 5
( D Startup from ECCS Suction Strainer Outage
- August 2,1997
- New ECCS Suction Strainers Installed
- Use of SHEX for Containment Analysis Approved
- Use of Containment Overpressure for ECCS Pump NPSH Approved
- NPSH Adequacy for ECCS Pumps Verified
- Containment Response Based on Rerate Work
- EQ Evaluation with New Containment R.esponse was Submitted
- ECCS Pump Room Heatup Analysis was Reviewed
- Torus Attached Piping Analysis was Reviewed NRC RAI - April 14,1997
- Response Submitted on September 5,1997
- ( f pgp
~
1/oh191:)ao Page 2 of 4
I
( l Schedule of Remaining Actions Complete Closure of All Third Party Review Items
- Typically Clarifications
- - Completion Expected by 10/15/97 Complete Work Identified in 50.9(a) letter l
- Typically Confirmatory Work i - Completion Expected by 10/15/97 I
with Exceptions
- EQ Files Update
- ECCS Pump NPSH Evaluation for Bulletin 96-03 i )
- . rap I/oh191
- jao Page 3 of 4
^
- [ )
Provide Submittal to Inform NRC of Planned Changes to 1R Tap Position l
! - Provides Extra Margin Based on i Detailed Review of 115 KV System
! - Desire to Implement Before Rerate Implementation Under 10CFR50.59
- Responds to NRC RAI Questions 7 through 10
, Revise LAR to Provide Clarifications and Corrections
- Completion Expected by 10/15/97 NRC Approval- August 1,1998 4
4 i 5 _
J 1/oh191:jao Page 4 of 4
PLANT HATCH EXTENDED POWER UPRATE 2
Presentation to the NRC September 10,1997 Ken McElroy g Southern Nacicar Operating Cosupany k
4 ext-pwr
MEETING OBJECTIVE e Program Overview e Licensing Approach e Plant Modifications ext-pwr NRC Slide
PROGRAM OVERVIEW e License Both Units for 108% of Current Rated Thermal Power, or 2763 MWt (13% Above Original Rated Power) e Modify Balance of Plant Equipment During 1997 - 1999 Work Windows
- Submit Licensing Report - August 1997 (Complete)
- Unit 2 Implementation - Fall 1998 (NRC Review Schedule) e Unit 1 Implementation - Spring 1999 e Operate at = 105% of Current Rated Thermal Power for the Initial Cycle e Power Increase 40 + MWe Per Unit (Initial Cycle) l e Subsequent Cycle Goal (with MSRs Retubed)- 900 MWe per Unit of Reliable Generating Capacity ext-pwr NRC SEde l
LICENSING APPROACH e NRC Approved a 5% " stretch power" Uprate in August 1995 0 Submittal Utilized LTR-1 Format 0 Hatch Units Have Operated Very Well e Hatch Submittal for Extended Power Uprate Is Similar (ELTR-1 Format)
O Most Analyses Utilize the Same Codes and Standards O Comparisons Made Between Current and Requested Power Levels to Quantify Effect on Safety Margins 0 Analyses Performed Consistent with Hatch Technical Specifications O Applicable RFAPs from Recent Submittals Incorporated
= " Beefed-up" Environmental Assessment
- Methodology for DBA-LOCA Radiological Dose Analysis Changed (Submitted 4/17/97) ext-pwr NRC Sikle
_- . .= .
LICENSING APPROACH (Con't) e SNC Requested a 13-Month Review Schedule
- NF.C Indicated This May Not Be Possible O Review Schedule for Lead Plant and ELTR-2 0 ACRS Meeting Schedule O Low Priority
- SNC Has Requested a Meeting with the NRC to Discuss the Review Schedule ext-pwr NRC Slide
! PLANT MODIFICATIONS
SUMMARY
i i i i i
l
! i j 0 Replace / Modify High Pressure Stages of the HP Turbine O Modify Generator Stator Water Cooling i 0 Modify Main Generator Isophase Bus Coohng !
O Modify Condensate Demineralizer System
! O Add Digital PLCs in Condeasate/Feedwater Pump Locations / Modify Pump Impellers, etc. i O Increase Condenser Tube Stakmg '
O Re-range Instruments / Change Setpoints
, O Retube Moisture Separator Rehesters
- SNC Has Already Invested Millions in Non-safety Modifications for Extended .
Uprate i
a i e Unit 2 HP Turbine Modifications Increased Plant Heat Rate 1
j ext-pwr NRC Slide i t
} I
UPRATE REVIEW LESSONS LEARNED R
if 3
~
l
- F m D
-l t
I' FINDINGS !
t i
i l
9 No standard review procedure !
l e Staff position on GE uprate program !
< t t
1 e Westinghouse methodology i i
I
- e All completed uprates about 5 percent or less i .
t I
I i
- [
t i !
1 l
t I
i . t i ,
i.
REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED IN UPRATE REVIEWS (BWRs are compared to Plant i + GDC 17 + human factors, and PWRs are compared to Plant Q + SBO + human factors.)
- l. I Notes:
'This uprate followed the GE BWR uprate approach.
2 This uprate followed the Westinghouse uprate approach or scope.
l 4
i l
i
i PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED :
! A,1977 CE reactor vessel / internals stresses
, CRD mechanisms SG tube integrity '
RCPs !
! pressurizer i piping GDC 17 :
SBO EQ fire protection control room habitability
, LOCA/MSLB containment performance safety-ielated pumps NPSH post-LOCA combustible gas control service water CCW i SFP cooling '
'HVAC human factors t
. _ _ _ _ _ _ __ __ j
.I PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED B,1978 CE GDC 17 SBO
, safety-related pumps NPSH post-LOCA combustible gas control I&C setpoints human factors (Systems, structures, & components were not specified; merely general statement that staff evaluated effect of uprate on structures & systems) i
PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED .
C,1979 CE reactor vessel / internals stresses CRD mechanisms RCPs pressurizer 1 GDC 17 SBO !
MSLB containment performance !
safety-related pumps NPSH '
post-LOCA combustibic gas control service water system CCW
fire protection circulating water system main steam main turbine human factors i
PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT' ADDRESSED D,1980 CE reactor vessel / internals stresses CRD mechanisms SG tube integrity RCPs pressurizer piping LOCA/MSLB containment performance safety-related pumps NPSH post-LOCA combustible gas control I service water CCW SFP cooling HVAC EQ fire protection circulating water system main steam main turbine SBO 6
PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED E,1981 CE RCS flow AFW RHR reactor vessel / internals stresses CRD mechanisms SG tube integrity RCPs pressurizer piping LOCA/MSLB containment performance safety-related pumps NPSH post-LOCA combustible gas control service water
i i
!' PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED
! F,1983 W reactor vessel / internals stresses !
CRD mechanisms <
SG tube integrity l
RCPs i l pressunzer l piping :
SBO i
EQ '
l fire protection control room habitability safety-related pumps NPSH t service water
~
SFP cooling l HVAC 1 radwaste i circulating water system j main steam human factors t l
PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED G 2 ,1986 W post-LOCA combustible gas control HVAC fire protection SBO human factors H 2 ,1988 W SBO human factors
i
- PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED B,1989 CE reactor vessel / internals stresses CRD mechanisms SG tube integrity i RCPs .
pressunzer piping ,
j safety-related pumps NPSH post-LOCA combustible gas control service water system I&C setpoints '
SFP cooling HVAC fire protection circulating water system main steam main turbine control room habitability
4 - ,
~
l PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED l l',1992 GE GDC 17 -
human factors J2 , 1993 W fire protection SBO human factors K 2 ,1993 W safety-related pumps NPSH human factors L',1994 GE GDC 17 human factors M',1994 GE GDC 17 human factors N',1995 GE GDC 17 O',1995 GE GDC 17 human factors P',1995 GE GDC 17 SLC
N D PLANT, YEAR NSSS REVIEW AREAS NOT ADDRESSED 2
Q,1995 W SBO human factors R',1995 W GDC 17 human factors S', 1996 GE GDC 17 human factors
MORE FINDINGS e Unclear what analytical codes were used in re-analyses e Code approval status unclear e Conformance to code SER conditions unclear o Unclear whether codes are up to date e Consistency of uprate with licensing basis a problem
STAFF PLANS i
e Develop power uprate review procedure o Review GE power uprate programs e Re-evaluate completed power uprates e Add guidance to confirm FSAR update me
- l. During the meeting. GE requested the staff to complete the reviews on the schedule requested by GE and-the utilities. -In response, the staff stated that it will apply its best efforts to compkte the reviews within the requested time frame. However, as . indicated during its presentation of "uprate review lessons learned." the staff's improvement plan, such as developing a power uprate review procedure, could potentially-impact the staff's overall review schedule. Also, the staff urged GE (and the industry as'a whole) to consider prioritizing, to the extent possible, all cost beneficial licensing actions (CBLAs) including such actions as power uprate submittals, so that the staff can better focus its resources on higher priority actions within CBLAs.
Following the management meeting, a working level meeting was held between the industry representatives and the NRC technical staff. The purpose of the meeting was to have an cpen forum to discuss any technical issues of mutual interest for the BWR >ower uprate program. No formal presentation was made during this part of tie meeting.
ORIGINAL SIGNED BY Tae Kim. Senior Project Manager Project Directorate I"-1 Division of Reactor F c,jects - III/IV Office of Nuclear Rec.ctor Regulation Docket Nos: 50 263. 50-321, 50-366 cc: See next page Attachments: 1. List of Attendees (First Session)
- 2. List of Attendeas (Secono Session)
-3. -Meeting Agenda /NRC Handouts
- 4. GE Handouts
- 5. NSP Handouts
- 6. SNC Handouts
- 7. NRC Handouts on Lessons. Learned DISTRIBUTION: See attached lis.
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\WPDOCs\UPRATE\MTGsVM.997 To receive a copy of this document. Indicate in the box C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E-Copy with attachment / enclosure N = No copy 0FFICE PM:PD31 E LA:PD31 E D:PD31 /d __
NAME TJKim:dM CJamerson* JHannort(
DATE 10/3//97 10/31/97 10/7 //97
-0FFICIAL RECORD C0rT
l DISTRIBUTION FOR GE POWER UPRATE PROGRAM MEETING
SUMMARY
DATED: October 31, 1997 Docket File (50 263. 50-321, 50 366)
PUBLIC PD3 1 Reading File OGC ACRS TKim E mai' S. Co' lins /F. Miraglia R. Zimerman B. Sheron J. Roe'D. Matthews E. Adensam B. Boter/J. Zwolinski
- G. Holahan/S. Newberry G. Lainas J. Strosnider R. Wessman J. Calvo T. Collins L.-Marsh G. Hubbard C. Berlinger- J. Wermiel C. Miller T. Essig K. Manoly L. Phillips R. Emch F. Akstulewicz C. Car > enter P. Cota R. Fraim R. Ingram H. Berkow M. Markley. ACRS M. Young. 0GC T. Martin (SLM3)
B. McCabe (BCM) M. Tschiltz (MDT)
' G. Tracy (GMT) T. Hiltz (TGH)
K. Connaughton (KAC) J. Williams (JFW1)
S. Mitra (SKM1) .T. Le (NBL)
W. Long (WCL) D. Shum (DHS)
T. Ulses (APU) Y. Li (YCL)
J. Hedoff (JXM) H. Garg (HCG)
Z. Abdullahi (ZXA) --
V.--Ordaz (VLO)
D. Jackson (DTJ) J. Wu (CIW1)
C. Craig (CMC 1) J. Schiffgens- (JOS)
G. West-(GXW) F. Collins (JFC1).
J. Lee (JYL1) T. Huang (JYH)
C. Hehl, RI J. Johnson. RII G. Grant. RIII T. Gwynn. RIV a
s
(,
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _