ML20198P040

Refers to 981210 Open Meeting at Licensee Request at Region II Re Weld Discrepancies Identified on Various Auxiliary Feedwater Sys Pipe Supports During Safety Sys Engineering Insp.List of Attendees & Util Presentation Handouts Encl

ML20198P040
Person / Time
Site:	North Anna
Issue date:	12/14/1998
From:	Landis K NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To:	Ohanlon J VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.)
References
50-338-98-05, 50-338-98-5, 50-339-98-05, 50-339-98-5, NUDOCS 9901060284
Download: ML20198P040 (11)

Text

. _ _ _.. _ _. _.. _. _. _ _

i 91 w

i I

l December 14,1998 Virginia Electric and Power Company ATTN:

Mr. J. P. O'Hanlon.

t:

' Senior Vice President-Nuclear.

}

l.

Innsbrook Technical Center L

5000 Dominion Boulevard

' Glen Allen, VA 23060

~

SUBJECT:

MEETING

SUMMARY

- NORTH ANNA POWER STATION

Dear Mr.- O'Hanlon:

i

' This refers to the'open meeting that was conducted at your request at Region ll on

-l December 10,1998, to discuss the weld discrepancies identified on various auxiliary feedwater i

system pipe supports identified during the safety system engineering inspection documented in NRC Inspection Report numbers.50-338/98-05 and 50-339/98-05. A list of attendees and a 1

i i-copy of your presentation handout are enclosed.

It is our opinion that this meeting was beneficial in that it provided an opportunity for discussion of the possible causes of the weld discrepancies and their_ safety significance. Based on

. discussions during the meeting, it is our understanding that you will respond to the inspection report findings by December 21,1998.

In accordance with Section 2.790(a) of the NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10, Code of i

Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.

l Should you have any questions concerning this meeting, please contact us.

Sincerely, Original signed by k

Kerry D. Landis Kerry D. Landis, Chief Engineering Branch Division of Reactor Safety Docket Nos. 50-338, 50-339 License Nos. NPF-4, NPF-7

Enclosures:

1. List of Attendees

2. Licensee Presentation Handouts cc w/encis: (See page 2)

I' 99oto6oas4 9s1214 PDR ADOCK 0500033s G

PDR x

./

s-VEPCO 2

cc w/encis:

J. H. McCarthy, Manager Nuclear Licensing and Operations Support Virginia Electric and Power Company 5000 Dominion Boulevard Glen Allen, VA 23060 W. R. Matthews, Site Vice President

.. North Anna Power Station P. O. Box 402 Mineral, VA 23117 E. S. Grecheck Site Vice President Surry Power Station Virginia Electric and Power Company 5570 Hog Island Road Surry, VA 23883 Executive Vice President Old Dominion Electric Cooperative 4201 Dcminion Boulevard Glen Allen, VA 23060

'/

Virginia Corporation Commission Division of Energy Regulation P. O. Box 1197 Richmond,VA 23209 County Administrator Louisa County P. O. Box 160 Louisa, VA 23093 Donald P. Irwin, Esq.

Hunton and Williams 951 E. Byrd Street Richmond, VA 23219-4074 Attorney General Supreme Court Building 900 East Main Street Richmond,VA 23219 State Health Commissioner Office of the Commissioner Virginia Department of Health P. O. Box 2448 Richmond, VA 23218

VEPCO 3

Distribution w/encis:

L. Plisco, Ril R. Haag, Ril L. Garner, Ril N. Kalyanam, NRR R. Gibbs, Rll M. Thomas, Ril D. Jones,Ril W. Stansberry, Rll R. Aiello, Ril PUBLIC NRC Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1024 Haley Drive Mineral, VA 23117 NRC Resident inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Surry Nuclear Power Station 5850 Hog Island Road Surry, VA 23883 R

7 OFFICE Ril:Q@/

Ril:DRsgf Ril:DRP slGNATuRK 4][

]Q jap NAME QJienahin:pd Klandist BHaag F/ F DATE

\\\\

_12/ g//98 1_2/ W/98 12//y /98 12/ /98 12/ /98 12/ /98 12/ /98 COPY?

' /YEs)~' NO

/fEs ) NO (YEs )No YEs NO YEs NO YEs NO YL:s NO OF'FleikL RECORD dOP1f DoCUM'ENI NAME: s:\\DRs\\EB\\lNPuTs\\NOAsUM1.WPD l

l f

List of Attendees Licensee G. Bishof, Director, Design Engineering C. Funderburk, Manager, Station Safety & Licensing, North Anna L. Hartz, Vice-President, Nuclear Engineering and Services B. Leonard, Manager, Nuclear Engineering M. Walker, Supervisor, Engineering Mechanics NRC Reaion ll R. Chou, Reactor inspector, Division of Reactor Safety (DRS)

L. Garner, Project Engineer, Division of Reactor Projects (DRP)

R. Haag, Branch Chief, DRP K. Landis, Engineering Branch Chief, DRS J. Lenahan, Engineering inspector, DRS V. McCree, Deputy Division Director, DRS S. Sparks, Senior Enforcement Specialist

O VIRGINIA.,w'y

/-7

/ ; ~ f-)

~

/ J / rf W [

~

POWERM_%u l p')i, d.^q gg ](,

)

S,

.f~v.

1

~

c L'

g y'

1 N \\

n g" VIRGINIA POWER / NRC MEETING}3 o

s b

DECEMBERs.10,1998 r

ca m

na

1. ~<

g wW AGEt DA, $w

,1

~

NN C

N, 1

INTRQDUCTION:

Leslie Hartz u\\(/

p g

n'g[

'x {

w-)

a v

yu-f M

Vice' President

/

dl n

i

(

~

Nuclear Engineerind & Services

$)%[gw g

's

(

i

\\

)

) /)

eq Q RESPONSE TO INSPECTION REPORT:

/[/

J

) 0 1

s s

}

Bruce Leonard /

)

i t

a

\\

)y Manager-Nucidar Engineering V,1]

g l

e n ;y

(

CLOSING COlViMENTS:

Leslie Hartz t

I I

" Nuclear Safety First" l

)

i

_ - - - - _ _ _ _ _ = - _

t J

A w

VIRGINIA,2:x '.

-' f s'

n/,N i

P0WEWYh x

~ I '? \\f~' '

h

~

v~'

g q i

es

=

3; - y sr; \\(3

,4 VIOLATION A Y;;;3 J-K l

~

-a

~,

S.

A-p

'u

~

f p

i a ',;

'J'y 1.

N j

y

'ARW~su apor:s we,re not constrI)ctedxlAW;

+

u w,

a details slown on cesign drsVvings) s e4,, ye W*

j 7

Welc lciscreaancies ribted gn various A3VWgxg j

+

i w

su a aort.s l

jg

~' 9 7

7 f

( U[

(

l

./

\\

l

}

\\

/

y j

\\

,i

'j ~

g

/

r l

i j

l t

" Nuclear Safety First" i

I

-- Y

O H

N f'

s

/, els',D VIRGINEA4Tx. '.

W e

m jgg'A[\\f"'

POWER % 8 l

&~

(

.j o

,t-c ORIGINEL DESIGN PROGRAM e

Jo l

REQUIREMENTS i+3 i

nr l

u

~;

-w x

t

't

\\\\

~

N 0

+ Desig,n Requirement's Verified by Field Qublity/C,ontrol y

v, gs i

e; y

Procsdure,QC-11.4, insppction of' Pipe'Hangsr,s b

- Specificati~on,s

's,

('

$.! [Ehe

- Pipd Support Drawings' J"

[U\\

r-8 l

J

\\

- Hangbr Sketches 1

'U

)

/

1

)

's

\\

(

Engin'eering & Design C6' ordination Reports " _L/

j l

1 e

"o Hanger Engineer's Instructions i

I

_J

" Nuclear Safety First" t

i

VIRGINIA.-D h<'~'m I%

i

/

POWER?Q3% l j ~ j'([ G

}",

L_ff

.{gf C

WELD ATTRIBUTES INSPECTED 'J o i

oy r

- w c

3, e

~

e i

' [!JEl

's fv[

t s

r 9

+m 7

+ WeldAQracks

/

t D s a,

o I '@l* &

m n

+ Profi es e%-

\\)

t s

4 i

,s

+ Surfabe Pdros,ity 1

/

h, F hs i

)

m, w

+ Undercut

(

)?

r"'A, i

~

i

~

+ Leng:hland Location \\'/#

)

~~

_1

/

i q

t J

%)

h i

7' Ti f)

l c

u f

L l

1 l

" Nuclear Safety First" i

l

~

s

~

()

~

,,a a~

ny

,e gF

,o i

=

G, ESULfS OF PREMOUS K

NRC INSPECTIONSO,8v

Gr u

m' s

, 1T..

'l

%g

/

'v) f] [

l v

ug

+ A33ropimately 100 Supports;lnsp o

IVinorlcischsp,ancies r o, tec tb arevious J D4 D

i 9

+

insPe$tions

/

Jf

/N

.p

.s s

s

>a s

~

t Design 1 requirements c\\orifirmec h'

T /)

+

a r

+ Samale s~ize witlin c uidance of ANS!/ASQC i o#

i<

Z'.4-1993 i

l I

" Nuclear Safety First" I

i

O VIRGINIAb?.

/ ?

lO(p W(

'~

'w,

-.POWERWi~ l l~'

1,

, p+ s y

e

m p s

m x

a RESUlzTS OF RECENT ANALYSI c,nk,

<9 a

i.

yu a

r C -i

(

I" c l

'N, h

/

Jv' t

q

~

y x

+ Analysis,conservativ,ely assumedliFider I length weIds agd used conservative ddbsl loa'db 'rd 1

4

~

Postulated undersized welds mest design re:quifements

+

s x

x

/

m we Confirfned the weld is not yveaktlink (AISC/AWS" we9 1

+

Practics)

[

f

\\'p, l

l

-T O,

J j

Y'Q l

G

/

l l

[

" Nuclear Safety First" r

f

- -, n' l nl (ff ~ %.

POWER' f::.

y ~'

\\

c g-ga,

,2 (

[j[;)-

bk Q C, ONCLUSION j+',a J c3 i

' yp 7

(

~_ ^i l

,I( 7

'I M i

N La

+ Weld,s; meet design requirements prespribed by;:

.u so i

e x

n s

do'cu'rnejrited instructions, procedures, og drayings, as approp'riate-.

n i

+ QC ProgramVerified design reqbirements m%u (,

)

i fr -

e:ctduri@f construction

('

J0

,#d\\

r

+ Subsequent, inspections mpet$dhple size guiddjines

\\)

and verify dss.ign requiremen'ts were met

/ 1]

1 1

$g G

u i

F I

l

" Nuclear Safety First" l

.