ML20198H368

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Advises That Change to Current Threat Statements Unwarranted Based on Semiannual Design Basis Threat Review 5 for Jan-June 1984
ML20198H368
Person / Time
Issue date: 08/03/1984
From: Mccorkle G
NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS)
To: Burnett R
NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS)
Shared Package
ML20198H337 List:
References
FOIA-85-534 NUDOCS 8601310012
Download: ML20198H368 (1)


Text

-,

  • / ,

. 1 l

. DISTRIBUTION:. .*

i

..*;.  : SGBR-rffs.z . %.

l

c. x, .; :

~

...;. ... c- ..- .: . SGPR s/f o. . . : . c..., . . .

.Q.

. . 4. ,

'c m; .. ...

Section File:F-

.- W . i -

.-e

. .a. . -  : .

.  % . >.g .... .. . .. JDavidson'...t .- <..e... .

.v e ; . c  ;...:. w: c.:n. .bg ,w. t... ?. . ....v.t.- 6, ,: &..-x '- NParadiso u.: .:... -

s:.. ..,  :: -

.. ,, e.. . .. .,

.s ET. en. Ey.c. k* :...., m. ,'*. . ... . . .

. . . . . . . - , . . . . . . . . . . . . s..,.

.' .*s. . ..

,,%,. . '.  ?** *

. f at .i.; ? - .

  • 4..'-?

',N L:. . .. ' . ~ . . ;. . .!'.n-  ;.s _ Q ' , . ., . *. . ..: . h7 . . . ; ._ . ~ .

-~ .

'. -- i :. .^ ?.  :.

n .-% 4 3. h*.;: .x

- - .; 8. s. '. ' N- q . .y' .m. - . p. ..* .f.*

NEM FDR er. . . s , * .,*.Robert y s onF. Burnett. g01i , Q ecter4*n.f.e

..;s. .,.,.n . s....V. .f.,'...s~ .:.~.o... .

  • .L .p m- . . . . , .

oT,$g s .' .f . , . .

.e.....

_. . . cs. . 5 .

... ., . o. ..

.'" - d L es.

.. . ;4 ao . *.iv .

. . . , ...:...,.ar..

.. g . .a. m .

J. r.

-s

..,..~...L,,.". 2.. . .; - .

.. X FR n I... 7..2 -

f... P '.. George W. McCorkleb. Chief C.- F. . s .. 2 W .a

. . .,. . . M,:r '.. . .: .

W.wM h .. ~

we

. c;. ..r .-:. ..~.w.

n.

.. v g;.w.r. .. Power., Reactor. h.
;rw.r SG. A.n. r Licensing

. . >  %. . : , ~M.

- 4 NRSS v. %, W.r.:;.c.

1,:.v . . %, .

. m; .-- .

. c.v. . n. s. . .

. Division of..Safegua.r.ds,c

. . ; . . . . . . . ; . , . , .. p . ...y.. . .,;.,.- , e . .

e".

.y.v.

ie

. . m&:' '..

.. . e < W*.~.r.. .=. . .

M.s:c

> . ps .. ..

s. . ., t .. . . . .s... ..

M.s.SUDJECTE.'.:.v.~....r.V.s .: , .v . . . m. ..

.. 2. s . ,.. . . . ,m_,.

SEMI-A!ONAL. .

. e. w,...-. . - .. , DESIGN..

.. . w .

BASIS

. .. . . .. ... s,; ,. .,

a T..HR .

.u...m..,..,.....,..s,..; . w.m. o.w., .. a.. .,:e..s, . .. ...> u. .c .:=.....e. y .~. . . ,. ,.:: g .. . e,. .- . w .-

w. , & , . ,;

...... . . .- . m s. . .m.a. m...

.r .g .  ;.

n ' desig~ ' ba'v.:..,....,. .. 7.. r. . . . p: .. ..%

.s. . e .. ... . . . s . e. .. .

.. .. .. L q . .

'~

M.V The staff'hasi completed'the~s'emi-anh .,s.o.ual sis"threatFveview;:.E~n

.hi.' for.'the period January.through June'1984. . Th(review. formally doed MT i d%I

+@i.f ments.the staff's evaluation of threatTand incident;dataf bothfdomestic'n '-

~

- 39.j]andjoreign';;and the-staff's conclusions. concerning the' adequacy (of, the f^' . iQ t Ne 'deitgn- basfi. threat' statements.

~

in'10 CFR. e73.r.'w:r J WP.-.WP..% iN@

< . n:= . ,. -.c.:

.. . u  : , .

. .WW .?.n -.n . .. . p:- sw .v~ u... me u . n. .v. .  %: .n . - . 47-h .v v . -

.. ~.ve 3 t- p, 5 . ~' ,;, e-" ff" ; . . - 4' 4 ...)- -

- . %* . .T .-

.. .. W,j. .<; s ? ,* *.. > _;f...= In the' last semi-annual; 6 ' l .'

' :' ":.m w -"a* *No. revie.J

.4) the -(~ ,;.,:~ use.of vehicular bombs wasff

. J.Jb. identified 'as exceeding the e. sign basis threat and a recommendation'.-

.%4 was made that the desige~ basis threat be modified to int &ude the use 4 -

~

?.9 '

.W:'

d'T

" '. ~-T.i "of vehicles bf an adversaryl. Subsequent staff' analysis ind evaluatiod W"

?f. of the domestic threat environment resulted in the conclusion that' a . .

a: ~ '

"- W modification to the design basis threat statements was not warranted --

'c. 9 at this time. . The details of the analysis and evaluation upon which . - .z.

5 '. a

.i.. ..Ml

'c: . . . . this conclusion

. y .>- .:. z is.. :based. . m. . ....,...a.. are b.eing provided to' you by separate ... . ..a. , .

p

. .s..

.. - , memo. . ~

.....s,...

s.:. .

s: u....

< . a e nn .i. :~ . 4.s. ' .t G:. . .;r ..;. : x; . 'ke .p; ".%. .:; r .~1'-r.7 M..? n":ne .. .. . . %2-'.f7.

< . .'.w'.;.t

. . ;.g.

,, . % .g.' . : . x.m.s.1 .r w wsym.u. .s . a.r.

.r p . .., w y

M.,M:m . a ..~  ;:

.yg>. ,,wr. w

.r .-ea c. . 'x;-

r

. ,'. 2 ">.,;.sy.:g; w,.n.,.3.nM..u.i. e. n.ct-?.: -r. .

.;n.., a,n-

  • z a;. x.:: ..

x.E_.E Information'on more than'two thousand incidents or. threats has been . ~

~

@D. P;y

? (.:ii ' reviewed for, the current reporting periodi,. Based on its r'eview. the . ~

,' staff concluded that available data does not' warrant a change to'the -

~

?P.W. '-

current threat statements. If additional data is reviewed that would 3f-change the staff's conclusion.- I will notifywyou inmediately.*: c.z. : ".;

~ . : t -:...p..wc ~.

~ -

.-::;-. . - ..v. ~ -

n. e. ~ -

. .. ~. a . u. . . ;e. . .;. - .

.. .c . . . v. -... ,q.

L ...: L .

oras g.g.:....-....~..ye..- Q a, y, ungf 69. ;..

- Q : . .n . .

. ..,as..... . . . . . . , . . . e.... >.. .

.as.e.,..-... .. m.s= . -

.+- , e. . .

...= m, . m . 44 t,.O.'.lb.;:.'..:sfMh5Ed George W..McCorkie2 Chieff.::s; .s.L

~

3 . ;. . . . . . .,. . .

- &:2. T' 2 ,31:May.P P Reactor.SG Licensing. Branch y r- M -

3 ..p.;. . EYN 99'n.M;g::;.%qq.7,Q. W J.c;.i. Divisica ower of- Safeguardsr HMSSNF!b. ::- 4E?k ~

. -. M.c.,%.v. r . . .

,. o w. .c..e.,. ..: .g.,.w. .: . .:. 2. g,,.9, y. i

.. .. . . .. :,n .:.: . .y

. .. ,a. ,.:.r ..... ,

c.'... .

- : 4.. .. .,.-

- .< .-. s .

... - v.

. .. , .i s,: . 2.  ;.. _ .. .V,.sa.:. G.., 2 ;u :. i y Q.lg;4:4  ;;f&. ., c-QQ( r q *g*gsy,{:. .p g.. .

.;'.J: [.a; .

. . . . , ... ,. w . . r .+ s. , a .. . ... ...:.  ; . .. ....

9601310012 851223 .. .. .

, ~ . - ... . .- . . . . . . , .

<; W F0IA f. - L ' . .-~~ Y a'v- - r - .'-- ; -

-: h. . . -

. N. F: ...~.

PDR -

:* ' :., ,.s. :: -im - - -u c --

. P. . - . .. n DELL 85--534

.DR . . . .  ; > ., . ~i. .~s . . - . .-

,:.-.; .,..:..>:-- ..~ ;. 4,..-e.

., .. w - .. . . .

.. .. m .

2

. . - . ~.. ::

. .. c. . . . . .... . . .,;

i ..

SGPR q SGPR - -. < - -m 4 - .

. SGPR S. GP. R. . . ,.. . _.. . .

. s. 4

,'_ $.c.. 9 .:

' JDavidson/cw*LTen.. Eyc..k*: ' NParadiso*J. m..

. . GM.cCorkle

.. . ,... . . .. #.. .. ..,;p.. . .e w. . v,. :...

- --. ~

c,..- ... .. .

. . m _g . .P ..