ML20198G412
| ML20198G412 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Satsop |
| Issue date: | 05/07/1976 |
| From: | Maccary R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Deyoung R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| CON-WNP-1304 NUDOCS 8605290566 | |
| Download: ML20198G412 (3) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:l 1 s .
. 3'b OG 1 i I ;
1 1 I MAY 7 1976 [.
$ N Docket No.: 50-508, 509 MS No.: 27-112 ' "
R. C. DeYoung, Assistant Director for Light Water Reactors Division of Project Management WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM, DOCKET NOS: 50-508, 50-509 Plant name: Washington Nuclear Project No. 3 (WhT-3) & No. 5 (WhT-5) Docket Hunbers: 50-508, 509 Licensing Stage: PSAE Responsible Branch & Project Manager: LWR 3, A. Bournia Responsible SS Branch & Technical Reviewer: MEB, F. Cherny, P. Chen Requested Coupletion Date: 5-7-76 Description of Response: Supplement to Safety Evaluation Report Review Status: Complete Attached as the MEB input to this supple:nent is a response to the question raised in the ACRS letter of 4-16-76 regarding the design of the reactor vessel supports. The question relates to the generic concern which has been raised about theesffects of the transient asymetric differential pressure loads that act on the reactor internals and around the cxterior of the reactor vessel resulting fron a postulated pipe rupture at a reactor vessel nozzle safe end. Assurance must be provided that these loads are adequately accounted for in the design of the vessel supports. Since the UPFSS 3 & 5 plants are CESSAR reference plants, we have t.ssu:,cd that the applicant will adopt the solution to this generic probleri which has been comitted to by Combustion Engineering on the CESSAR docket. The CE comitment has been addressed in section 3.9.1.5 of the CESSAR SEE, and te noted this in our letter of 8-20-75 which transmitted the MEB input for SU'. sections 3.6 and 3.9.2.5. In addition, since that time, the ITPSS 3 & 5 applicant has addressed this subject in a letter to NRC dated 12-31-75. The applicant has provided in acceptable comenitment that the WPPSS 3 & 5 vessel. supports will be desirc.' with the feferenced loads taken into account. Since the applicant's letter does not refer specificall to CESSAR , we have referred only to the applicant's commitment in our attached input. orric a
- _ , ,
i
'va'a"'
- 8605290566 760507 PDR ADOCK 05000508 -- ' " - - '
cars > .. . g ,._ .., Forza ALC.)lt (Iter. 9 53) AECM 0240 1't u. a. oovanNusNT PR8NTINe oFFtCas 19,4 933.te3 L
l
. r \
d Also for clarification we note that the 4-16-76 ACRS letter ref erenced above ' f was transmitted to MEB by Mr. A. Bournia's letter of 4-19-76 to DSS Branch f Chiefs. Mr. Bournia's letter provided recommendations as to which DSS 1 branches might be involed in address.ing specific questions raised in the ACRS letter. The Mechanical Engineering Branch was listed for providing responses to paragraphs 2, 6, and 7 of the ACRS letter. We have determined that paragraph 2 should be' addressed by MEE. This input is attached. The Structural Engineering Branch will address paragraphs 6 and 7 in separate correspondence. . R. R. Maccary, Assistant Director for Bigineering Division of Systesm Safety cc: R. E. IIeineman, SS
- 0. Parr, PM J. P. Knight, SS A. Bournia, PM
!!. L. Bratraer, SS F. C. Cherny, SS P. Chen, SS -
Docket Files DSS: Rdg File DSS: MEB File DSS:MEB- DSS:MEB - - DSS:MEB DSS:AR4E MEB DSS:AD/E _.
'"*"'"'* lI.Branuner - JPKnight v- RRMaccary FCCherny:jk PYChen -
..... 5/6/76 5/6/76 . 5L6/ 76 5/ ./76 5/ /76 _
form AEC.3ta (Rev. 9 53) AECM 0240 # u. e. eovsammaar eninvene opricas sera.eas-see
n ?.- r> j; MECHANICAL ENGINEERING BRANCll N DIVISION OF SYSTEMS SAFETY WASHINGTON NUCLEAR PROJECT No. 3 and 5 SUPPLEMENT TO SAFETY EVALUATION REPORT 5.2.1 Design of Reactor Coolant Pressure Boundary Components The ACRS in their letter of April 16, 1976 to NRC Acting Chairman M. A. Rowden stated that a generic question has arisen concerning loads on the reactor vessel support structure for certain postulated loss-of-coolant accidents in pressurized water reactors. The letter further stated that the matter should be resolved for WNP-3 and WNP-5 in a manner satisfactory to the staff.
-By letter dated November 26, 1975 f rom O. D. Parr to J. J. Stein, we . requested the applicant to verify that the final design procedures would account for transient asymmetric pressure loads on the reactor vessel supports.
In a letter dated December 31, 1975, from M. O. Strand to B. C. Rusche, the applicant stated that it is their intent that the final design of the reactor vessel support system will take into account these asymmetric pressure loads in combination with appropriate LOCA and seismic loads. The applicant further stated that the results of these analyses and the final . design parameters for the sepports .will be incorporated in the Final Safety Analysis Report. We consider this to be an acceptable commitment, and, that accordingly, the design of the reactor vessel supports is acceptable for the construction permit stage of review.
*1
-t 5
JUN O 3 575 Docket Mos. *= W 508 aa W D M Olan D. Parr, Chief Light Water Roseters Project Breach 1-3, DEL FORTECOMINC MEETING WITR WASHINCTON F M LIC FO W E SUFFLY SYSTEM BGARDIEG GROUNDWATER DaATa&GE SYSTEN - UFFSS NUCLEAR PROJECTS NO. 3 AND WO. 5 TIME & DATE: 9:00 a.m. June 12, 1975 IACATION: Boom P-118 Bethesda, Maryland PURPOSE: To discuss revisions to the applicant's proposed grounduater drainage systea , desiSn that would mitiNate the consequences of a liquid raduasta tank failure. PARTICIPANTS: UFP&J (C. Sor m . D. Whitford) ERASCO (R. Yickare, A. Herm) l Nac - StarF (W. Bivias, T. Johnson, F. Stoddart, l C. Burke. I. Shit , P. O'Railly, D. Tibbitts)
. 4 Lbls W D. O'Bailly
[' t/ Patris Li$ht Water Enoctors Project Bransk 1-3 Divistoa of Ensetor 'i-ming l Jud (.i pV
.,,e., LWR 1-3 . .-
PD0'Reilly:an _ l 6/ /75 _ Form AEC 318 (Rev. 9 55) AECM 0240 W u. o. oovanmusme painvi=e opricas ser..s. .e t
l l
. p-4 ks Distribution:
Docket File F. Schroeder NRC PDR R. Tedesco L'd 1-3 File V. Stello NRR Reading (M. Groff) R. Maccary E. G. Case H. Denton B. C. Rusche V. Benaroya A. Giambusso G. Lainas R. S. Boyd J. Collins R. C. DeYoung D. Ross V. A. Moore T. Ippolito D. Skovholt J. Knight D. huller S. Pawlicki R. Denise L. Shao K. Coller B. Grimes R. W. Klecker W. Gamill M. Williams R. Ballard W. Butler P. Fine J. Stol:: T. Novak R. Clark M. Spangler D. Vassallo J. Kastner T. Speis ACRS (14) K. Kniel S. Varga A. Schwencer Project Manager - P. D. O'Reilly R. Purple EP Project Manager - J. Norris D. Ziemann Attorney, ELD P. Collins IE (3) G. Knighton SD (3) G. Dicker V. H. Wilson B. J. Youngblood Bethesda Receptionist W. H. Regan, Jr. W. Besaw R. Vollmer W. Bivins W. Houston T. Johnson G. Lear P. Stoddart C. Burke I. Sihweil P. O'Reilly D. Tibbitts ,
e i I UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION W ASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 Docket Nos. STN 50-508 JUN O 31975 and STN 50-509 Olan D. Parr, Chief, Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3, DRL FORTHCOMING MEETING WITH WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM REGARDING GROUNDWATER DRAINAGE SYSTEM - WPPSS NUCLEAR PROJECTS NO. 3 AND NO. 5 TIME & DATE: 9:00 a.m. June 12, 1975 LOCATION: Room P-ll8 Bethesda, Maryland PURPOSE: To discuss revisions to the applicant's proposed groundwater drainage system design that would mitigate the consequences of a liquid radwaste tank failure. PARTICIPANTS: WPPSS (G. Sorensen, D. Whitford) EBASCO (R. Vickers, A. Wern) NRC - STAFF (W. Bivins, T. Johnson, P. Stoddart, C. Burke I. Sihweil, P. O'Reilly, D. Tibbitts)
~% [
Patrick D. O'Reilly
, Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3 Division of Reactor Licensing goWT%
O 1m R 2 k
##76 198 i
b
t 2A , Docket Nos. -508 JAN. 0 61975 and 50-509 Olan D. Parr, Chief, Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3, L PORTHCOMING MiETiNG WITH WASHING 10N PUBLIC POWLR SUPPLY STSTEN - WPPSS NUCLEAR PR117ECTS NO. 3 AND NO. 5 Time and Date: 9:00 A. M. - January 9, 1975 I4 cation: Room P-110 Bethesda, Maryland
Purpose:
To discuss WPPSS' responses to staff's first round questions regarding mechanical engineering, accident analysis and radiological assessment.
Participants:
WASHING 10N PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEN (G. Sorensen, D. Lagrou) EBASCO (R. Vickers) COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC. (E. Guenther) USAEC - REGUAA1 DRY STAFF (P. Chen, P. Cherney, P. Kantor, E. Adensam, T. Murphy, V. Goll, M. Bolotsky, P. O'Reilly) Original Signed by Patrick D. O'Reilly Patrick D. O'Reilly Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3 Directorate of Licensing (,
. , ,,c L:LhR 1-3 o u .m . . , , PO'Reilly:pg
. . . . , 1/ /75 __
Forms AEC418 (Rev 9-93) ALCM 0240 W u. a. novsnmusme paintime opricas sere.ese-see
-%DCMMW pp.
~.
Y jtr $ .
?
W e ~, L Distribution: Docket Fil F. Schroeder AEC PDR- H. Denton
. Local'PDR R. Maccary LWR 1-3 Reading V. Stello t- ' LWR 1-3 File R. Tedesco V. Benaroya y L' Reading ,
E. G. Case C. Long
- A. Giambusso J. Kastner
- R. S. Boyd G. Lainas
- R._C. DeYoung D. Ross R. W. Klecker T. Ippolito M. Williams S. Pawlicki R. Denise J. Knight K. Goller L. Shao D. Maller ~B. Grines D. Skovholt W. Gammill V. Moore R. Ballard 9
W. Butler P. Fine D.' Vassallo T. Novak K.-Kniel M. Spangler ' A. Schwencer. A. Kenneke J. Stol: R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16) R. A. Clark S. Varga
, R. Ireland EP Project Manager - J. Norris R. Purple OGC h D. Ziemann R0 (3)
P. Collins RS (3) R. Vollmer V. Wilson ' W. Houston ' Receptionist, Bethesda G. Knighton G. Lear G. Dicker J. Peters B. J. Youngblood P. O'Reilly W. 11. Regan, Jr. D. Budge J. Greeves F. Kantor L. Phillips T. Johnson C. Stepp V. Goll T. Murphy R. Kornasiewicz
- C. Liang P. Stoddart J. Costello F. Cherney P. Chen '
E. Brooks R. Satterfield R. Priebe , F. Ashe M. Bolotsky G. Main: I. Sihweil R. Satterfield E. Adensam I
?
l p, , I DEC.171974 Docket Hos. ST)t 50-508 and diTN 50 509 Olan D. Parr, Chief Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3, L NOTICE OF MEETING WITH WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM REGARDING WPPSS NUCLEAR PROJECTS NO. 3 AND MO. S Time and Date: 9:00 A. M. - December 20, 1974 Location: Room P-130A Bethesda, Maryland
Purpose:
To discuss slope stability and the potential for landslides at the proposed site of WPPSS Nuclear Projects No. 3 and No. 5.
Participants:
WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM (G. Sorensen, D. Tillson D. Whitford) EBASCO SERVICES, INCORPORATED (R. Vickers, A. Wern) WOOOWARD-LUNDGREN ASSOCIATES, (A. Patwardhan, W. Hansen) USAEC - STAFF (D. Budge, J. Greeves, P. C'Reilly) i Originai Signed by Patrick D. O'Reilly Patrick D. O'Reilly Light Water Reactors l Project Branch 1-3 Directorate of Licensing l l l l l b a ric = * .. L: LWR._1 -3__
. ~ . . . - 10.'Reilly:pg
.... _12L/74 __
Foran AEC 518 (Rev. 9-53) AECM 0240 W u. s. sovsammes=, reentime orreesi sera.sas.see
,5
.4 Distribution:
Docket Fil F. Schroeder AEC PDR H. Denton Local PDR R. Maccary LWR 1-3 Reading
- V. Stello LWR 1-3 File R. Tedesco L Reading V. Benaroya E. G. Case C. Long A. Giambusso J. Kastner R. S. Boyd G. Lainas R. C. DeYoung D. Ross R. W. Klecker T. Ippolito D. Eisenhut S. Pawlicki R. Denise J. Knight K. Coller L. Shao D. Muller B. Grimes D. Skovholt W. Cammill V. Moore R. Ballard W. Butler P. Fine D. Vassallo T. Novak K. Kniel M. Spangler A. Schwencer A Kenneke J. Stolz R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16)
R. A. Clark S. Varga
, R. Ireland EP Proj ect Manager - J. Norris R. Purple OCC D. Ziemann R0 (3)
P. Collins RS (3) R. Vollmer V. Wilson W. flouston Receptionist, Bethesda G. Knighton G. Lear G. Dicker J. Peters B. J. Youngblood P. O'Reilly W.11. Regan, Jr. D. Budge J. Greeves F. Kantor E. Itawkins T. Johnson C. Stepp D. Bernreuter T. Murphy R. Kornasiewicz C. Liang P. Stoddart J. Costello F. Cherney P. Chen E. Brooks R. Satterfield C. Sullivan F. Ashe M. Bolotsky I. Sihweil
l i ., 4 ._.~n < -MP , *
- =e*(( ; L ga g 1 ^{
- :, k
;;p , ?Y
, g,
. .. < s,,
' 's g
.[ *
^
.y3y* N
-~ g
- 3i .p&,G. . Q,. /j$cilad"'
l ,
~ ". ~
< NOV. 2 41974 .;,
i 5 A [h. . $k?-f k+ n - NW Y ,
, .x!%cmwieg
. T ecTGMWL.'
6 i P WW Q
~
-% W::1%
m ,% 3 M m'~#64p re t. a' gp C'--n . jf.,Mijt t'm ' r 3 nwF > w eWM*b :"M W !*. \ M fM 41*Q . L .g m'me
't W;MGrgeatsasaus u i ex y,,q n,g,ts.q, n g ma w affF . . -
. .s . 1 . . u .
T. E. Ons > Plungsses) p of timed), '
- amt I met adeh aussed 5. I. h - M is tuait 3 Bass at k.
! : Phan's amies in Sun >== mamma, chaamme a.. et es - _ iuns to Amassus117 damamos issues af tausset a' , I the ammmazussian applisstisms Sur WIW utgange %_ uns. 1, 4, 3 ame~ filme by Emtengass stests samur ~ ser. Namn has f13a4 pottelmus to teessuuss in tote '
! the ameser projenes IIIs. I amt 4. ant the WOW Butser -
I - mes. 3 amt 5 -Ba amtttsmi1us thee
! I to h Ms M MM l , sur es seesty ama'ame ruusses at aggtessesses. .%
l
' w amp o m . 1 esmanims a list af assemeses. .. . + u._
. +
i i
,, _ _ . faww . ~ %. ..
- Es h m=====8 es contentions in Mr. Finn's '
tition .. _ f l 'en smeergume: (1) the noitase su'uB4 aSest ' 1 l ! - his hustmass Amtements gammedag capacier "- l in theos uggisms of the state dame plaats i usued be hommead; (2) the 's sembustles of ensup 43 - t asimuss ) is to suSe eut assey -- as a ame====**==* '
#gfM ass,ess,amm,a P-a,f s,asse_ net. '(5) ;
ee# #d
,,, , , , ,, m, ths'Asames ame aim an W,d" of W est in -
h M u ghougs empseestism&M SGMei f %TH . 94:n3 as gi > 3>. g y es ^': 998 m Gtsk g'ggi y,,,,, ,. .,N ,
~:%j ,. ; w !
y % n i: m :;a ggym+ g u ? ~ p vyn% wn w w - ': ,' .Q < W: l. i 's m N ; x r;, .e n = c, w
% , n.-
.+-em a mmme w.
n.pd .. I,,,4 ...*'t.ep %4
? 9 % e m +>
+sk _ c; t
= -
a s <
'(* 'b ,
, , y .
! . o ,. ,, wendwAwgp;' -
% oa
;>g q u y 5 4.g
- p. T p3 .,
.e '
e e .
+
r
. - - - - . _ . - . - - - - - . - . . - . . . - ~ - _ . . ~ . - - . _ . . . . - - _ - - - . . . - -
1 e
-s ,
NOV. 2 41974
\ [ , .,l ' '* *> -
),i . + y M* ;
i l - ! 3 . 5. <, e . i
,a
; '*;h -
i
. 4.u m i gy + * ' , _ '
*l 5 Y( 1 INg b- 4 6.~
p 3
- p. '
gg g .
-?
's pf '
)$ ' $ ;
. . .a nn.- . ,,
& 7 % g u em .
stycynTVp V4fMTWW g; :
$2M*W M i , i :
# Si Ag . / 1: [y
(! . Q:ahtm M , y- .
.3ast h I sg,; . '
r 3 m to3md eses,memessusa W ' 'D ssummmet e - l c tis 3ms. We aest W. Num . essWE egestGF M , e, m., ,as m q p.m y,p. . # , I
's es kends of te M ef Mh WWW (1) h is a to W MA 's q
( ! setense of the Ismen is assessary er esmatuses ,
. of en gesetemma psessejst. en tassai -
! As. Am Ms egdeemm. ,inm of N that it is required to objectively assess. fie expressed his.
deter::unation to obtain satisfactory r.esolution ..,,,4~ u ofithis conflict.
- x.7 . -
(1) h8gs en kuss esW e h h es e6 W assenate We et aussaar peer >h GWW is a.s.ms17 mesmee en ggssema's se hm l ' l the metashte sh 6 'l \ ce i Mr. Engen asked W. Piet to eldene a the esgo mi dayth of W1 assuammes that he uudd assider sh l l R. FAsmi :. ' [ amid that the MC shmed emntt es egen yeensma-o, j j;. e@ -n 7
; N; 4
=e=**.
e a a w t. w rg>+- v aan; h %..ar.s... s isa g J 4ak, gi41 g%
~ ' ' " .
~
y M g (S M h g g M ,.f I h'
!';hgPprocessi%p b : g W C-Q, I. h.
3new e , , .,f m ,
- . J yw esswassa. "
.fi p ! O es a m e 'ef't is poshese s e' L ~ :e ; !; os f 4:3l,,
t ,
> "3; ym : n .m.n a ax: we o.a ;
d$N ~.- g uu, , ~ - w,g . Patrick D.O'Rel% , ,, .
- M. , . _ p. ' _ __
NI[ l Jumpset meses(1-s ~v N,. - er massme m . i ~~atsP. -See page m'::,,,"11 7 ., ,
- t. . .a l
_ ,,. ,,, _ .m - * . . . . - . - . . , _ . . . . . - . i
e
}
4--
,,. % .J ,g NOV. 2 41974 i
i
- 3- .- . . .
u 1 i 1, - b $it1l*** H b Sg *
'- R -5 Cran::':MWs i ces 3: 4:M M " a1410!ky,9f',jy 4, . , .% Q g3yyb y g y .
f, ., y jf~ v3. jp?. .(P hif; ; ggygfg g p ; . Jggy yg 1 3ggm ,+ ~ 7 .
)$1f '
- M d M -
&uus:,;;;: L'iji,% >nn?pyy y y }gu[ f ylc)l_ [4 _3 f
g j'; 4pfor T%.& :s niMr. D..4F.
% X. Fim'WWWEZG9C3@Q&p lr.ir- g}4 egy6; %% % >;;jofjd, ;g ;_- g g_ y - G u n ,. o ,-
_ pO* M ' { v 4'?*d M** g p m 4,w.;.,p.4 eu r p.e s#e,. u,g
,m.x...,.
gy ,
, ,3. .
e h & vd[:? D W t*[rf,N*y-y^iO.>3 % w'
< a . m, Wr .ct, t s? 'E-m
.Y<- kh -s$ MN ,~-
-~_
y'.~. p o-Q 9 .. .- s c 4,, - , ..>g ,gsg g4gy
.g .
y 4 o I I i "i
, "L:L h
l ~- ,. i I I
- p. . _ . _. , m c.y m , , _
i m, % y ?.? m* '.: w eacu u w ^n ac* O c a c 3 / a a e # % . ,,md p[: w ng g rn.n.m,,. n,:c...mn :r;,.
. e...,ay,m.r.m r wwe w,.,p,. _ a w m' ,;, , n. ,
g pc3.. . ..m a u y'.
-{'Y$h pt} , , <=. YV ~ d f hD?)!*E
' ? f. ~?"
J., Yf/l, OMQ A55WWWMMZ$f[m Qib' fg *g y G gg g g y ' ~' A4'y ;;p *; . & y_,;f*}j M , ' l.
'. 4 k*
'fj$ < % %f QilA Vi k;$ Q gj $ qqyfjg > . fy r3; g 3 g .y. g
%,"! I.3 '.-
e-nfj, ; - gyg;)g f.] a nu.3 qq;
- ggp g g g g Q (g Qg g 7
,. 4
; ,q9= - > - m.
~ ' -'-
- w:yyts;7?MT<wgjg.4 ., ~
, gmkh
q f l P's 'e Z_) .
' rrecs o >
, Uf a ovanswe >
l
. . ,m, pave >
}
, Form ABC,}ng (Rev. 9 53) ABCM 0240 W u.e,sovsnuesent penevine oppieas .,,,,,,,,,,
.c. ,
-3
)
ENCIDSURE NO.1 ATTENDANCE LIST MEETING WI'III POTENTIAL INTERVENDR WPPSS NUCLEAR PRQJECTS NOS.1, 4, 3, AND 5 NOVIMBER 14, 1974 ParENTIAL INIT.RVENOR D. F. X. Finn
*C. Conde
*T. Sullivan AEC - REGULATORY STAFF T. H. Cox R.11. Q11p W.11. Regan, Jr.
P. D. O'Reilly
- Denotes part-time attendance
p .- 4 ) 0 ENCIDSURE NO. 2 LIST OF D00NENTS GIVEN 10 D. F. X. FINN AT NOVINBER 14, 1974 MEETING
- 1. Safety Review Schedules: WPPSS Nuclear Projects Nos.1 and 4 and Nos.
3 and 5.
- 2. Press Release of April 6,1973 on Public Participation in Licensing Process.
- 3. Federal Regulations: 10 CFR Parts 2, 20, 50, 51 and 100.
- 4. WASil-1238 - Environmental Survey of Transportation of Radioactive Materials To and From a Nuclear Power Plant.
~5. Fact Sheet on Conmercial High Level Radioactive Waste - June 21, 1973.
- 6. Licensing of Nuclear Power Reactors (Bulletin by 015, August,1974).
- 7. WASil-1250 - The Safety of Nuclear Power Reactors and Related Facilities.
- 8. 1973 Annual Report to Congress on Regulatory Activities.
- 9. Regulatory Guides: 1.17, 1.21, 1.42 and 4.2.
- 10. Atomic Power Safety - J. F. Hogerton (ITTIS)
- 11. Nuclear Power and the Environment (ITTIS)
a.
* 's '. % )
{ - Distributic,n: Docket File F. Schroeder AEC PDR H. Denton Local PDR R. Maccary L Reading V. Stello R. C. DeYoung R. Tedesco R. Denise V. Benaroya K. Goller C. Iong D. N11er J. Kastner D. Skovholt G. Iainas V. Moore D. Ross W. Butler T. Ippolito D. Vassallo S. Pawlicki
- 0. Parr J. Knight K. Kniel .
L. Shao A. Schwencer B. Grimes J. Stolz W. Gamill R. A. Clark R. Ballard R. Ireland P. Fine R. Purple T. Novak D. Ziemann M. Spangler P. Collins EP Project Manager - J. Norris R. Vollmer OGC W. Houston _ R0 (3) G. Knighton V. H. Wilson G. Dicker R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16) B.- J. Youngblood LWR 1-3 Reading W. H. Regan, Jr. LWR 1-3 File S. Varga F. Kantor R. W. Klecker E. Hawkins T. Johnson C. Stepp D. Bernreuter D. Budge T. Wrphy R. Kornasiewicz C. Liang P. Stoddart J. Costello F. Cherney P. Chen E. Brooks R. Satterfield C. Sullivan F. Ashe M. Bolotsky I. Sihweil G. Imar r - - -.~ , - - -,, --w--- ,, , - - . - - - . - , , . - . - - - _ _ - . - - - . - , , , . . - - --
/
e t + ,
. NOV 1 1 1974 DOCKET NOS: SDI- 50-508 G 50-509 PACILI1Y: WPPSS Nuclear Projects No. 3 ard No. 5 APPLICANT: Washington Public Power Supply System SGMRY OF MlWPASER 4,1974 M!PTING WTIN APPLICANT RBGARDING AUXILIARY N TT'? SYST!M On November 4,1974, repreentatives of WPPSS, Ebasco, and Combustion Pagineering net with the Regulatory staff in Bethesda. 1his neeting was held to discuss the staff's position en auxiliary feedwater system design.
A list of attendees is attachel. We stated our position on the desip,n of auxiliary feedwater systems. We believe that the auxiliary feedwater' system should be designed to provide a minieri of two independent and diverse, trains of feedwater supply. Each train aust be designed to perform the comphte systs function. The system should be designed to provide different pap drive mechanisms with diverse power supply sources fpr the pep drives, the valve operators, and control systems for each indivBdual subsystet. The pining arrangement should provide physical and functional independance between the subsystems. Such a design assures that the syste will withstand a f411ure of piping, caponent, power supply or control function in the redundant systems. Interconnecting piping may be provided between subsystems with normally closed valves in the line. These valves may be uanually operated from the control rom using the power diversity principle forxthe valve operators dnd actuation systems. 1he rationale for our position was discussed. We explained that we are requiring diversity in the pop drives and rewr sources to assure a high degree of reliability in the auxiliary'fre&".er system. Since the auxiliary fa=h=ter rystem may be used for nord w1 ir startup ani shutdown as well as for certain accident conditions,11 o r 4ect to more frequent challenge during the life of the plant. Ther d a , s . est be a reliable syst e. Also, setdies have indicated that the possibility of the loss of onsite power should not be considered unlikely. The possible loss of both offsite and onsite sources of AC power was dia:ussed. Lb F-A A "IW Wh/7 7 L t
e s The auxiliary feedwater system currently proposed for hT'PSS Nuclear Projects No. 3 'and No. 5 consists of two full-capacity, motor-driven pumps and AC controls. Ebasco described a syst a. modification being considered in order to meet our position. This modification would add a third full-capacity system which has a turbine-driven pump and DC controls. This systs would be operated manually when needed for feedwater supply. The amount of time i required for manual operation and startup of this systa was then di==W. This could be a disadvantage with such a design. i
- We gave the following example of acceptable auxiliary feedwater systas: one full-capacity systen with a turbine driven pump and DC controls plus a full-capacity system with motor
- 1ven s and AC controls. Ebasco remarked that the systm described in the was designed to minimize the location of high energy fluid piping in areas of the plant containing safety-related equipment. We stated that a system using a turbine-driven punp is not the only acceptable way to meet our position.
Patrick D. O'Reilly Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3 Directorate of Licensing
Enclosure:
Attendance List cc: Washington Public Power Supply Syst m Joseph B. Knotts, Jr. Richard Q. Ouigicy i o ,, . . L:L1R 1-3. _ so..... PD0'.Reilly:cis __ DATED. 11/ /74 Torm AEC-318 (Rev. 9 53) AECM 0240 W u. s. novsamment Painfame opricas ser4. ore-ise
e
\
ATENDANCE LIST NOVEMBER 4,1974 MEETING WIHi WPPSS Washington Public Power Supply Systen G. C. Sorensen G. G. Renfro Ebasco R. T. Vickers J. F. Killian 4 Combustion Engineering C. B. Brinkman R. L. Honigmann V. Adler* AEC - Regulatory Staff C. Y. Liang C. C. Iong F. Ashe P. D. O'Reilly P. Riehm , e
*Part-time attendance 1
r: (/ T. Distrilx2 tion: 1xxket Fil 11. Denton AEC PDR F. Schroeder Local PDR R. Maccary L Reading V. Stello R. C. DeYoung R. Tedesco R. Denise V. Benaroya K. Goller C. Iong D. Muller J. Kastner D. Skovholt G. Lainas V. hbore D. Ross W. Butler T. Ippolito D. Vassallo S. Pawlicki
- 0. Parr J. Knight K. Kniel L. Shao A. Schwencer B. Grimes J. Stolz W. Gamill R. A. Clark R. Ballard R. Ireland P. Fine R. Purple T. Novak D. Ziemann M. Spangler P. Collins EP Project Manager - J. Norris R. Vollmer OGC W. Houston R0 (3)
G. Knighton V. Wilson G. Dicker P. D. O'Reilly B. J. Youngblood R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16) W. H. Regan, Jr. LWR 1-3 Reading - S. Varga LWR 1-3 File R. W. Klecker G. Lear F. Kantor E. Hawkins T. Johnson C. Stepp D. Bernreuter D. Budge T. hbrphy R. Kornasiewicz C. Liang P. Stoddart J. Costello F. Cherney P. Chen E. Brooks R. Satterfield C. Sullivan F. Ashe M. Bolotsky I. Sihweil C. C. Long R. H. Culp P. Riehm H. M. Wilchins 9
o I NOV. 0 819N Docket Nos. STN 50 A-8 and STN 60-509 Olan D. Parr, Chief, Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3, L NOTICE OF MEETING WITH REPRESENTATIVES OF WASHINGTON STATE GEOLOGIST'S OFFICE - WPPSS NUCLEAR PROJECTS NO. 3 AND NO. 5 Time and Date: 9:00 a. m. - November 19, 1974 M cation: Washington State Department of Natural Resources State Office Complex Olympia, Washirgton
Purpose:
To discuss slope stability and landslides in the area near the proposed site of WPPSS Nuclear Projects No. 3 and No. 5.
Participants:
WASHINGTON STATL DEPARTMEhT OF NATURAL RESOURCES (J. Thorsen, W. Rau) AEC - REGULATORY STAFF (D. Budge, J. Greeves) ori:.ina; signed by Fairh;k D. 0'Reilly l Patrick D. O'Reilly l Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3 Directorate of Licensing l l I 1 I l l l L a"'*** L:LhR 1-3 - - - - -- - l PO'Reilly:pg ou~~~=* - -
=ar=> 11/-/74 Forma AEC. Sis (Rev. 9 S3) AECM 0240 W u. e. sovanmusNr pnantene orrics ser4.esa.ies
" ' 4
( (n-Distribution: .. Docket Fil F. Schroeder AEC PDR 11. Denton Local PDR R. Maccary LWR 1-3 Reading V. Stello LWR 1-3 File R. Tedesco L Reading V. Benaroya E. G. Case- C. Long A. Giambusso J. Kastner R. S. Boyd G. Lainas R. C. DeYoung D. Ross R. W. Klecker T. Ippolito D. Eisenhut S. Pawlicki R. Denise J. Knight K. Coller L. Shau D. Muller B. Grimes D. Skovholt W. Gammill V. Moore R. Ballard W. Butler P. Fine D. Vassallo T. Novak K. Knlel M. Spangler A. Schwencer A. Kenneke J. Stolz R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16) R. A. Clark S. Varga R. Ireland EP Project Manager - J. Norris R. Purple OGC D. Ziemann R0 (3) P. Collins RS (3) R. Vollmer V. Wilson W. Houston Receptionist, Bethesda G. Knighton G. Lear G. Dicker J. Peters B. J. Youngblood P. O'Reilly W. !!. Regan, Jr. D. Budge J. Greeves F. Kantor E. Hawkins T. Johnson C. Stepp D. Bernreuter T. Murphy R. Kornasiewicz C. Liang P. Stoddart J. Costello F. Cherney l P. Chen E. Brooks l R. Satterfield C. Sullivan F. Ashe M. Bolotsky I. Sihweil
9 i ( WV i 1974 Docket Nos. ' 50-460 50-513
. 50-50R 50-509 1
Olen D. Parr, Chief, Light Water Ranctors Project Branch 1-3, L NOTICE OF METIE hTlif D. FI?N, POITNTIAL IN'ITJtVINOR IN WPPSS MJCLFAR PRfUFCTS Nos.14 4 Ah7 3 F, 5 PROCEEDINGS Tire 5 thte: 2:00 p.m. - haaber 14, 1974 Incatirm: Roos 4211 44 '4cntgomery Street San Francisco, California Purpose
- Infomal discussion of issues of mutus) interest regarding the construction pemit applications for WPPSS Nuclear Projects Nos. 1, 4, 3 and 5.
Participants:
PETITI(Wfm (ii. F. X. Finn) USAEC - REGTLATORY STAFF (T. H. Cox, R. H. Q11p, P. D. O'Reilly, W. H. Regan, Jr., A. Schwencer) l Or!2inct Signed by l Patrick D. O'Reilly 1 Patrick D. O'Reilly Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3 Divoctorate of Licensing cc: see attached list l A.1 ! o c.c =
- L:LNR 1 - --
...e-.*
g ,Reilly l
=ar=
- 11/../74 Torm AEC.318 (Rev. 9 53) AECM 0240 W u. s. oovanmusm? Paintene orrics: is,4.sas.nes l
h hY W --
7 o. 1 Distribution: , Docket Fil F. Schroeder AEC PDR H. Denton Local PDR R. Maccary LWR l-3 Reading V. Stello LWR l-3 File R. Tedesco L Reading V. Benaroya E. G. Case C. Long A. Giambusso J. Kastner R. S. Boyd G. Lainas R. C. DeYoung D. Ross R. W. Klecker T. Ippolito D. Eisenhut S. Pawlicki R. Denise J. Knight K. Goller L. Shao D. Muller B. Grimes D. Skovholt W. Gammill V. Moore R. Ballard W. Butler P. Fine D. Vassallo T. Novak K. Kniel M. Spangler A. Schwencer A. Kenneke J. Stolz R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16) R. A. Clark S. Varga R. Ireland EP Project Manager - J. Norris R. Purple OGC D. Ziemann R0(3) P. Collins RS (3) R. Vollmer V. Wilson W. Houston P. O'Reilly G. Knighton T. Cox G. Dicker R. Culp B. J. Youngblood G. Lear W. H. Regan, Jr. J. Peters OIS I l (
Docket Nos.' 50-508 OCT 2 3 1974 and 50-509 Olan D. Parr, Chief, Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3, L PORTHC&fING MEETIE WI1H WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSDN - WPPSS WCLEAR PROJECTS m. 3 AND NO. 5 Date T, Time: October 29, 1974 9:00 a.m. Incation: Suite A-1, Sixteenth Floor, Triangle Towers, 4825 Cordell, Bethesda, Md. (local office of Combustion Engineering)
Purpose:
To discuss landslides and slope stability in the region near the WPPSS Nuclear Projects No. 3 and No. 5 site.
Participants:
WASHINQTW FUBLIC PPER STPPLY SYSTDI (G. Sorensen, D. Tillson, D. Whitford) ERASCO l (A. Wern, R. Vickers) i
- WO0tWMRD-IIPDGRDi l (A. Patwardhan)
USAEC - REGUIATGtY STAFF (D. Budge, J. Greevrs, R. Jackson, P. O'Reilly, C. Stepp) Origin 313177ed by Patrick D. O'Rellly l Patrick D. O'Reilly l Light Water Reactors l Project Branch 1-3 i Directorate of Licensing ec: see attached list arrie=
- 1 :Lh*t 1-3. - ...._ _
....... PD0'Reilly:cls _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
l
..t.* .10/. /74. _
Foran AEC.318 (Rev. 9 53) AECM 0240 W u. a. oovanmusst paintswa orricas ser4.sas.ese TV0W $,
Q P l l i Docket Nos.'. ' 50-50S and .. 50-509 m 23E4 Olen D. Parr, Chief, Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3, L FOR111COfIE MEETING WITil WASHINGitN PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYST24 - hTPSS NfCLFAR PROJFLTS NO. 3 AND NO. 5 Time S Date: 1:30 p.m. November 4,1974 location: Room P-126 Bethesda, MD
Purpose:
To discuss the proposed auxiliary feedwater system for hPPSS Nuclear Projects No. 3 and No. 5.
Participants:
WA9fIMTrrW PtmLIC POWER SLIPPIN SYSITNS (G. Sorensen, D. Whitford, F. Guyer, D. 14garou) ERGC0 (R. Vickers, L. Namer, II. Van Kapel) l OY8MISTI(N EEINEERING ! 3 . Guenther) USATC - REGLIIATORY STAFF (R. Tedesco, C. Long, T. Ippolito, C. Liang, F. Ashe, F. Rosa, P. O'Reilly) Original Signed by Patrick D. O'Reilly l Patrick D. O'Reilly Light Water Reactors Project Branch 1-3 Directorate of Licensing cc: see attached list kh a"'e =
- L: LWR.1 3 .
. .N... PD0'Reilly:cs on. 10/ /74 - . .
Form AEC.318 (Rev. 9 53) AICM 0240 W u. e. eovsRNMENT PRINTINe OPPaCEs1974 5289SG
/
i i Distribution: Docket Fil F. Schroeder AEC PDR H. Denton Local PDR R. Maccary LWR l-3 Reading V. Stello LWR l-3 File R. Tedesco L Reading V. Benaroya E. G. Case C. Long A. Giambusso J. Kastner. R. S. Boyd G. Lainas R. C. DeYoung D. Ross R. W. Klecker T. Ippolito D. Eisenhut 5. Pawlicki R. Denise J. Knight K. Goller L.~Shao D. Muller B. Grimes D. Skovholt W. Gammill V. Moore R. Ballard W. Butler P. Fine D. Vassallo T. Novak K. Kniel M. Spangler A. Schwencer A. Kenneke J. Stolz R. F. Fraley, ACRS (16) R. A. Clark S. Varga R. Ireland EP Project Manager - J. Norris R. Purple OGC D. Ziemann R0(3) P. Collins RS (3) R. Vollmer V. Wilson W. Houston Receptionist, Bethesda G. Knighton R. H. Culp G. Dicker H. M. Wilchins B. J. Youngblood F. Kantor W. H. Regan, Jr. E. Hawkins G. Lear D. Bernreuter J. Peters T. Johnson C. Liang T. Murphy F. Ashe R. Kornasiewicz F. Rosa P. Stoddart C. Stepp J. Costello C. Sullivan F. Cherney M. Bolotsky P. Chen I. Sihweil E. Brooks P. D. O'Reilly _}}