|
|---|
Category:INTERNAL OR EXTERNAL MEMORANDUM
MONTHYEARML20197H8581990-11-14014 November 1990
Summarizes ACRS 367th Meeting on 901108-10 Re SECY-90-353 Concerning Licensing Review Basis Document for C-E
ML20059L0071990-09-12012 September 1990
Notification of 901003 Meeting W/Abb C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Sys 80+ Seismic Envelope & Design
ML20246E2921989-08-17017 August 1989
Forwards Licensing Review Basis for CESSAR-DC.Document Establishes Schedule & Process for Design Certification Review of C-E Sys 80+
ML20245E8501989-08-0707 August 1989
Advises of Reassignments in Project Mgt Duties Due to Recent Reorganization of Standardization & Life Extension Project Directorate
ML20245H7651989-04-25025 April 1989
Requests Input Re Acceptability of C-E 890330 Design Certification Application for Sys 80+ Std Design
ML20246N3171989-02-23023 February 1989
Notification of 890313 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Results of Salem Project & Licensing of Future C-E Projects
ML20195K3481988-11-28028 November 1988
Notification of 881220 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Seismic Issues Involved in Containment Design for CESSAR-DC Sys 80e Re Soil/Structure Interaction Phase
ML20197D8161988-06-0202 June 1988
Notification of 880628 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Changes to CESSAR-DC,Sys 80+ QA Program
ML20154E8081988-05-12012 May 1988
Notification of 880601 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Changes to CESSAR-DC,Sys 80+ QA Program
ML20148C8221988-01-13013 January 1988
Notification of 880126 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss base-line PRA for Sys 80+ design,CESSAR-DC.Portions of Meeting Will Be Proprietary
ML20147C3881988-01-11011 January 1988
Notification of 880127 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss Steam Generator Vibration Issue for Sys 80 Design
ML20236W9231987-12-0303 December 1987
Requests That Encl Matl Re Sys 80 Should Be Added to File for Docket.Info Transmitted by C-E Via Telecopy on 871130, Per 871119 Telcon
ML20197A8741986-10-22022 October 1986
Notification of 861024 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss Submittal Re CESSAR
ML20136H6051985-08-16016 August 1985
Notification of 850821 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss Status of CESSAR Sser 3 & FDA-2 Amend
ML20140G8031985-06-13013 June 1985
Requests Set of Questions/Issues for Consideration as Discussion Topics at Upcoming ACRS C-E Subcommittee Meeting as Result of ACRS 302nd Meeting Re DHR Sys & Rapid Depressurization Capability
ML20054G5821982-06-15015 June 1982
Responds to 820512 Memo Re Control of Occupational Doses by Prevention of Transport & Buildup of Radioactive Crud,By Removal of Radionuclide Deposits & Minimization of Failure of Major Plant Components
ML20054G5871982-05-12012 May 1982
Discusses Inadequacy of Responses Re Prevention of Transport & Buildup of Radionuclide Concentrations within Primary Cooling Sys & Methods for Removal of Deposits If Preventive Measures Not Successful
ML20213E1231982-02-26026 February 1982
Notification of Assistant Director 820303 Meeting in Bethesda,Md to Resolve Outstanding Licensing Issues
1990-09-12
[Table view]
Category:MEMORANDUMS-CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20197H8581990-11-14014 November 1990
Summarizes ACRS 367th Meeting on 901108-10 Re SECY-90-353 Concerning Licensing Review Basis Document for C-E
ML20059L0071990-09-12012 September 1990
Notification of 901003 Meeting W/Abb C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Sys 80+ Seismic Envelope & Design
ML20246E2921989-08-17017 August 1989
Forwards Licensing Review Basis for CESSAR-DC.Document Establishes Schedule & Process for Design Certification Review of C-E Sys 80+
ML20245E8501989-08-0707 August 1989
Advises of Reassignments in Project Mgt Duties Due to Recent Reorganization of Standardization & Life Extension Project Directorate
ML20245H7651989-04-25025 April 1989
Requests Input Re Acceptability of C-E 890330 Design Certification Application for Sys 80+ Std Design
ML20246N3171989-02-23023 February 1989
Notification of 890313 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Results of Salem Project & Licensing of Future C-E Projects
ML20195K3481988-11-28028 November 1988
Notification of 881220 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Seismic Issues Involved in Containment Design for CESSAR-DC Sys 80e Re Soil/Structure Interaction Phase
ML20197D8161988-06-0202 June 1988
Notification of 880628 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Changes to CESSAR-DC,Sys 80+ QA Program
ML20154E8081988-05-12012 May 1988
Notification of 880601 Meeting w/C-E in Rockville,Md to Discuss Proposed Changes to CESSAR-DC,Sys 80+ QA Program
ML20148C8221988-01-13013 January 1988
Notification of 880126 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss base-line PRA for Sys 80+ design,CESSAR-DC.Portions of Meeting Will Be Proprietary
ML20147C3881988-01-11011 January 1988
Notification of 880127 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss Steam Generator Vibration Issue for Sys 80 Design
ML20236W9231987-12-0303 December 1987
Requests That Encl Matl Re Sys 80 Should Be Added to File for Docket.Info Transmitted by C-E Via Telecopy on 871130, Per 871119 Telcon
ML20197A8741986-10-22022 October 1986
Notification of 861024 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss Submittal Re CESSAR
ML20136H6051985-08-16016 August 1985
Notification of 850821 Meeting w/C-E in Bethesda,Md to Discuss Status of CESSAR Sser 3 & FDA-2 Amend
ML20140G8031985-06-13013 June 1985
Requests Set of Questions/Issues for Consideration as Discussion Topics at Upcoming ACRS C-E Subcommittee Meeting as Result of ACRS 302nd Meeting Re DHR Sys & Rapid Depressurization Capability
ML20054G5821982-06-15015 June 1982
Responds to 820512 Memo Re Control of Occupational Doses by Prevention of Transport & Buildup of Radioactive Crud,By Removal of Radionuclide Deposits & Minimization of Failure of Major Plant Components
ML20054G5871982-05-12012 May 1982
Discusses Inadequacy of Responses Re Prevention of Transport & Buildup of Radionuclide Concentrations within Primary Cooling Sys & Methods for Removal of Deposits If Preventive Measures Not Successful
ML20213E1231982-02-26026 February 1982
Notification of Assistant Director 820303 Meeting in Bethesda,Md to Resolve Outstanding Licensing Issues
1990-09-12
[Table view] |
Text
.
t r s
[>SRfCu UNITED ST ATES ACRSR-1409
[ *, f4 n, 1 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS
{-
o, g W ASHINGTON. D. C. 20$55
November 14, 1990 The Honorable Kenneth M. Carr Chanman U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555
Dear Chairman Carr:
SUBJECT:
SECY-90-353, L7'ENSING REVIEW BASIS DOCUMENT FOR THE COMBUSTION ENG1d1ERING, INC. SYSTEM 80+ EVOLUTIONARY F
LIGHT WATER REAC'I3R During the 367th meetino of the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards, November 8-10, 1990, we reviewed the staff's SECY 353, " Licensing Review Basis Document for the Combustion Engineer-ing, Inc. System 80+ Evolutionary Licht Water Reactor," dated October 12, 1990. Our Subcommittee on Advanced Pressurized Water Reactors also cor.sidered this matter during a subcommittee meeting on November 1, 1990. During this review, we had the benefit of discussions with representatives of the NRC staf f and of Asea Brown Boveri Combustion Engineering. We also had the benefit of the documents referenced.
The staff has recommended that the Licensing Review Basis (LRB)
- ef fort for the Combustion Engineering (CE) System 80+ design, which is well advanced, be continued to completion. There does not appear to be any substantive disagreement between the staff and CE on issues addressed in the LRB document.
The only approved LRB document was proposed by the General Electric Compa (GE) as a way of obtaining early agreemercc with the staf f on ma or process and technical issues for the review of its advanced boiling water reactor design certification application.
It was approved by the Director of NRR in a letter to Mr. R.
Artigas, GE, on August 7, 1987. This letter contains the qualifi-cation that the LRB represented the approach in "certain key areas" that GE was committed to follow " . . . until final Commission positions and staff requirements are de#ined and implemented." At that time, neither 10 CFR Part 52 nor Commission-approved staff
[ positions relating to the certification of advanced light water reactors such as SECY-90 -016 (referenced) were available. We note
, that 10 CFR Part 52 does not discuss the use of LRB documents as a part of the final design approval or certification process.
These regulatory requirements and others under development have preempted the need for and diminished the usefulness of an LPS document for the CE System 80+ design. We recommend that no further effort be devoted to the proposed LRB document for the CE System 80+ design.
W 2 '
T mn rm > , '
~.
e
- - - - - .___-.____._.m _
- v. i 9 :s . .
O
- w k ' ' q
'the Honorable Kenneth M. Carr 2 -November 14, 1990 Additional comments by ACRS members Ivan Catton, Paul G. Shevmon, and J. Ernest Wilkins, Jr., are presented below.
Sincerely, dk 2 Carivle Michelson Chai; man Additional Comments by A2RS Members Ivan Catton Paul G. Shewmon, and J. Ernest Wilkins. Jr.
We understand that this LRB document can be completed and issued with-relatively little additional effort. If so, we would prefer to see an orderly disposition of this LRB document in accordance-with the staf f recommendation in SECY-90-362 (referenced). We would agree with:our colleagues that the CE System 80+ LRB effort be terminated now if the Commission, the staff, and'the ACRS need to invest any significant additional effort.
References:
- 1. SECY-90-353, " Licensing Review Basis Document for the Combustion Engineering, Inc. System 80+ Evolutionary Light Water Reactor," dated October 12, 1990.-
- 2. SECY-90-362, "Staf f ' Comments on the Continuing Need for a License Review Basis Document for Each Passive Design," dated October 2.. 1990.
- 3. SECY-90-01c, " Evolutionary _ Light Water Reactor (LWR)
Certification Issues and their Relationship to current Regulatory Requirements," dated January 12, 1990.
- 4. Letter LD-90-005 dated January'22, 1990 from A. E. Scherer, Combustion Engineering, to R. Singh,
Subject:
System 80+
Licensing Review Basis Document.
- 5. Letter LD-90-060 dated August 28, 1990, from E. H. Kennedy, Combustion Engineering, to Thomas V.-Wambach, NRC,
Subject:
Licensing Review Basis for the System 80+ Standard Design.-