ML20196L113

Summary of 990330 Meeting with Util in Rockville,Md to Discuss Status of NRC Review of Bge License Renewal Application for Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant,Unit 1 & 2.List of Attendees & Meeting Slides Encl

ML20196L113
Person / Time
Site:	Calvert Cliffs
Issue date:	07/01/1999
From:	Dave Solorio NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
To:	NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
References
NUDOCS 9907120300
Download: ML20196L113 (24)

Text

u t l- ,

y, July 1,1999

~

LICENSEE: Baltimore Gas and Electric Company l

FACILITY: Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant, Unit Nos.1 and 2

SUMMARY

OF MARCH 30,1999 MEETING WITH BALTIMORE GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY (BGE) REGARDING LICENSE RENEWAL AC TlVITIES FOR CALVERT CLIFFS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, UNIT NOS.1 AND 2 On March 30,1999, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff held a public meeting with representatives of BGE at Rockville, Maryland, to discuss the status of the NRC's review of BGE's license renewal application (LRA) for the Calmt Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant Units 1, and 2.

During the meeting the staff summarized progress made on the BGE LRA review which included issuance of the safety evaluation report (SER) on March 21,1999, and the public meeting on the supplement to the environmental impact statement conducted on April 6,1999. Additionally, the staff summarized the re'sults from the recently issued scoping inspection report (NRC inspection report 99-02). BGE stated that they believed they met the rule regarding the Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) supplement and were concemed if the resolution of the open item regaroing the content of the FSAR supplement was tied to the implementation of 10 CFR 50.71(e) changes. The staff stated that recent developments related to 10 CFR 50.71(e) would only be used to inform the staff regarding the level of detail and content. BGE also raised a concem regarding the confirmatory item related to Generic Safety issue 190 outlined in the SER because BGE considered that they had met all requirements to address the issue.

Enclosure 1 to this meeting summary provides a list of the meeting attendees. Enclosure 2 provides a copy of slides that were used by the NRC staff and BGE to summarize the status of the review of BGE's license renewal application.

g David L. Solorio, Project Manager License Renewal and Standardization Branch Division of Regulatory improvement Programs Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-317 and 50-318

Enclosures:

1. List of Attendees - 1

2. Meeting Slides k . $'I /

cc w/ encis: See next page DISTRIBUTION:

/

See next page

{ol DOCUMENT NAME' G \RLSB\SOLORIO\ MARCH 30TH1999BGE&NRCMONTHLY MANAGEMENT MEETING

SUMMARY

.WPD OFFICE RLSB RLSB:D LA h _

NAME Iton DLSolor;o ClGrimes@

DATE ( /ep /99 4 /38r99 1/ I/99 i OFFICIAL RECORD COPY I 9907120300 990701 PDR ADOCK 05000317 P PDR 1 l

~

Baltimore Gas & Electric Company Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant cc: Unit Nos.1 and 2 President - Mr. Joseph H. Walter, Chief Engineer j

' Calvert County Board of Public Service Commission of {

I Commissioners Maryland I 175 Main Street Engineering Division Prince Frederick, MD 20678 6 St. Paul Centre Baltimore, MD 21202-6806 James P. Bennett, Esquire Counsel Kristen A. Burger, Esquire Baltimore Gas and Electric Company Maryland People's Counsel l P.O. Box 1475 ' 6 St. Paul Centre Baltimore, MD 21203' Suite 2102 Baltimore, MD 21202-1631 l Jay E. Silberg, Esquire l Shaw, Pittman, Potts, and Trowbridge Patricia T. Bimie, Esquire 2300 N Street, NW Co-Director Washington, DC 20037 Maryland Safe Energy Coalition P.O. Box 33111 Mr. Bruce S. Montgomery, Director Baltimore, MD 21218

. NRM' Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant Mr. Loren F. Donatelt 1650 Calvert Cliffs Parkway NRC Technical Trairdng Center Lusby, MD 20657-4702 5700 Brainerd Road Chattanooga, TN 37411-4017 Resident inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission David Lewis P.O. Box 287 Shaw, Pittman, Potts, and Trowbridge St. Leonard, MD 20685 2300 N Street, NW Washington, DC 20037 Mr. Richard I. McLean ,

Nuclear Programs Douglas J. Walters l Power Plant Research Program Nuclear Energy Institute i Maryland Dept. of Natural Resources 1776 i Street, N.W. l Tawes State Office Building, B3 Suite 400 Annapolis, MD 21401 Washington, DC 20006-3708 DJW@NEl.ORG Regional Administrator, Region I .

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Barth W. Doroshuk 1 475 Allendale Road Baltimore Gas and Electric Company I King of Prussia, PA 19406 Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant i 1650 Calvert Cliffs Parkway Mr. Charles H. Cruse, Vice President NEF ist Floor Nuclear Energy Division Lusby, Maryland 20657 Baltimore Gas and Elect.ic Company 1650 Calvert Cliffs Parkway National Whistleblower Center l Lusby, MD 20657-47027 3233 P Street, N.W.

Washington, DC 20007 l

l j

r NRC MANAGEMENT MEETING WITH BGE ENERGY CORPORATION ATTENDANCE LIST l MARCH 30,1999 4

NAME . ORGANIZATION JOE SEBROSKY NRC/RLSB RARRY ZALCMAN NRC/RGEB CYNTHIA SOCHOR NRC/RGEB STEVEN VIAS NRC/RLSD STEVE HOFFMAN NRC/RLSB THOMAS KENYON NRC/RGEB l P.T. KUO NRC/RLSB JIT VORA NRC/RES i SAM LEE NRC/RLSB MARIAN ZOBLER NRC/OGC CHUCK RAYBURN BGE/ LICENSE RENEWAL PROJECT ANNE COTTINGHAM WINSTON & STRAWN ROGER HUSTON LICENSING SUPPORT SERVICES DALE THATCHER NRC/DE PAUL SHEMANSKI NRC/DE JUAN PERALTA NRC/DIPM  ;

BOB PRATO NRC/RLSB I TONY PIETRANGELO NEl l JIM LONG EPRI  !

NEIL HAGGERTY BGE I DAVID LEWIS SHAW PITTMAN FRED POLASKI PECO ENERGY JOSEPFI HAGAN PECO ENERGY l CHARLIE CRUSE BGE HOA HOANG GENERAL ELECTRIC MIKE SCHOPPMAN FLORIDA POWER & UEHT CHARLES PIERCE SOUTHERN NUCLEAR LOUIS LONG SOUTHERN NUCLEAR DOUG WALTERS NEl GARRY YOUNG ENTERGY OPERATIONS RAYMOND BAKER SOUTHERN COMPANY l ALICE CARSON BECHTEL i CHARLES MEYER WESTINGHOUSE SIDNEY CRAWFORD CONSULTANT JOHN CARBY EPRI MICHAEL HENIG VIRGINIA POWER ROGER NEWTON WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER  !

STEVE HALE FPL i LYNN CONNOR DSA

(_ MELVIN FRANK NUSIS '

MIKE SELLMAN WISCONSIN ELECTRIC Enclosure 1 l

~

DEBBIE RAMSEY DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION BOB GILL DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION MIKE TUCKMAN DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION GREG ROBINSON DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION DAVE SOLORIO NRC/RLSB JACK STROSNIDER NRC/DE CHRIS GRIMES NRC/RLSB DAVID MATTHEWS NRC/ DRIP SIDNEY CRAWFORD SELF ROBIN MILLER DIRECTOR MSEC JAMES FIRTH NMSS/DWM DAVID BROOKS NMSS/DWM -

RAJ ANAND NRC/RLSB e

e I

k u

8 0

I a 8 e

MEETING SLIDES Enclosure 2 l

\

l 4

l

. ~

l s a a e s f w

e Gne o s me n a R n

e r ic n o r s g i

eh o o i vr o nn c s

i mI ya i

t i Dt P e a c r B

l t nc 9 9 r,nL e

i n

a ai l 9 o f, o l pp 1 t

c em ei l

n oAmp 0 3

io e

r vh it Ci z a

o h Dr ph d r

t Cl a c r

s,mc a r c a wI nd r n oi e y a pt r w

e Mh or Bt,S t

a e c n t t a a s Rel e Mlgu me& -

E R s d e i r

u i vR a G t d t

a n D i s

S a r

h C

=

f

1 2

w i

e v

e 9

9

/

g n

6 i R s u

/

4 t

e e

Ae s t S

t a S I

E m

c Ri i t

wf S

t i

l b

u I

fi v s u/

9 9 i e a r p

o ct t a 21 vD e

t s

a t n l yA S /R 3

o s e r l g u c a wd e e t a i n

t t

ai s n

i u nt e S m v s e e e g

m Ri e s mme n c nh a r n u yR ol r

i o c S

t E b i v u tt No i

f e S i a nP e S -

E -

P -

a m m

4

~ .

C dRn aN r o

w ge f 9 e d i nht & d 9

/

i py e 5 ve 9 ob x l u /

e u 9

/

c sd H d e

4 t

e e n n Rnt i 6

2

/

3 ht v o

r o

s h

c s

e m

An o d p n 2 e d

e e p o 0 g t

a a Rc i

u n e y i t

9 n

s s a L i s mgo ot pn s 9 m

e e R gl f s n po l

f n I g 9 o e s i

p md o f

t a o n p o i n

g yi t t u oi c yt h s gmg a ri a s e n n v

l t r noic a S n o

e p m )6 i

k g t

e o

n mic t n2 o0 o

r n/

g9 n

r on wdi e

m9 i t

o A pi 4EeRCca c/9 c i

m t c 9 i 5 e u e 9 GrE p R B s (S e

c Rs l

b1 a u/

p s

S s I Nc P 4 In I

n - - -

u

l a y t s

w r cR e o j eL nt r a t o r ,

e ol r P ge Rpu g r

a a e e e a n s

n ReR l c

uM e s Nt c c ura r,e _

it -

L ta le g ej o r

sS c aP f

f u n n ,

n ak i

l CiS t oNo i s

Muh

,s 9

9 9

1 s l eo r r aUi t b c i o 0 ei e m eD 3 l

vlpht m H h h c

a p o k tr c r a

CAtoC i DB aM M

g 2 n

i t E r aG f o

v l

eB s r

n ey o _

o d b t a C t

ee c R N _

g nla e w ee i d

S U

n m e nt t i n e

ht i

t e en sm e

i e

o t

t r

o e

ge ar um so c

ng R

p e

s u 0 n e s an t a1 M a mne yg swiC mi r e t

St 0 l 9 a9 w

e f ei v nn oe n e

o ec e ai r f r m R

e s

nl i r f e e n e

s e pw c i

i l

f i e Con et L

P i

v Rst si o i nS hi e sv P

N C

C t

c Ne r c mCCie a r RRb l

r e f eglpt i

e NN at x

j o p e t o roEnse i

r r b BpaDt O e e e t

$y :

1

~

i f l ] 7  ; 1 . ;

4. j , + ll

=

T'l< j 4 j;4_

~

. t ([, t . 1 .

. r  !  ? ;h

s 3

9 9

/ d e

p 9 l e g o e1 u n l e C R

c i

N -

d t v S nh e e e U e e a c ht h d o r c M t ma e t r

s c l o

p e

n u R r i oM l s _

u 0 d

do+bu t _

a1 e St 0 f h l 9 r r a9 e P c w e

n e fo sl u s R e

s mta/ e P s i s e n f

t i

s n

e c

d r t

RI n me ed e L P

L P e to s E e n l s

N C

C o a S p od u '

t COi vh e r a pi c h od R o n c W r n N NE s "

PI

• ee o l

E 1: [ .

f-  :

I h# ::# 4$  !

1 f i .

L

1. ' s.  !

[ [:

[ i .l[ a r 1l

\

d r

a s C f t 9f i r 9l o 9 9Cp 9 1

t e 9 1

h rR ,

c e 0 3

r vA h alar c r

MCL M a

)

1 5 3

3 t

s g 2

n 9 i n 3 e9 t e m d m12 /

M e 1 0

i t

e h/ y r s 3 c 3 r o

a i

i l

Rb d e smt a C l

pE ul ne t m R SPu d r N C

i mCSe enf r S U

i oREc I

h ce p o n

ht e

t cNSs nOC o r c o t t

r o A- -

C - - o p

e p e

• R s

u 0 e

t a1 St 0 e l 9 R c n

a9 w

e n

e 9 e r S R e

e k n s n

9 r o c e

9 h

d o .i t

i L

P 1 A W. a P N

C C f

e o

.l n C h l uc ar k

y u c d t t d o mdoo r en i l

aG o

mG a hO c u O S -

QC -

M e O O J

- ' ' ,' ! I t  ; l cf f; 6 .Y ll? hi k

,k 6o!

i i xi -

l

+ ~

7 ;.

pi  : '

Q  ; lf--

i f

I .h

~~

6 d

" n y a c s n _

a r o u m i t

c e g a c

a d

e t

i y ir t

nm C R

N S

U r

o wr e t o afo c nt c ht e

o v a

. t i

f i

nie t r

o w d e mug nn R

p e

e e r r mio s u 0 wg fn i t t t a1 i

vi s e n o mr opc o a i

t S t 0-l 9 a9 w

v be C i -

e eL i -

n e cpf i R

e R r s "g b eui sa r

e s

n e -

l m g n i c -

ae ct i n

e t mioa e mt l

ng l

c L

P P

N C

C i

n n I b i

n i

f r t con i i R e n eik t h o pd e c e E p C xd e e p S O " Eas TO

• e e

• 1 _

1 R ~ _)

l y; .

- L .

4 q N ':. {

~

" . i 'A .

(

4 M [ ; 3 '

^

~

}

. .. {

p l

L?I  :  ;  ; . [Y  ?' .

ll

n 7 o end e c a bet r nR l . i t

t r n o suh t a aA of i l l

i p Rl o o nuS pewe r Aste esF ps eh r t s s Srd o oh e i

sn aigf ,h F

e de r t t i

so n t noh t d e rf C yp ooes i

,at h oo R N

e e l i a uit bt nr or t S U

e pn" t

nt n an e a el uoi seob t f

,e . ht yd i

aseneot cor t h dtnm e oe t

t o

r t

e n vv ee i

nc hdt esel r

v cI t o

p e

f apy e r a o R s t d heTeas f

en s u 0 1 et e eh e t a1 l

a df eniute nd rTp St 0-l 9 ns a u g g )e t e e O a9 w

0. s qdi n( a sr . e i

f i

e e t 1 sa en n e

3 e t

n ef

's f svd a 7. h r sns sa t e R e

s n

ht a mt u pu5 b o r p0 nd od me ca e

c mf i

L oess at ei i

t P mrRa d l

l i P t

e t nph peaioF f mbey r ek d e N C

C n ,

Cr owc I teut ind ol a l

n s rodi toe0f t

nw i

a er n o)f cRsteio c dl p1 r

i err m nt ee e eAe e d ee i r b

p hSsl af avdthAfnal enf Sof l TF ( b en uoF cow i

O " rI d HL

^

~  :

E .

~

^

ij j6I

. 0 5 f ?* H t f tI ,

/

l

[ ,L yLI yti ;F l

l!

t 8 o c n e i

f s

P h e gac i

1 iPt e ar e 3 0N dl v sop s ,

9 Coou s t -

3 h e n 1

) Cisee r gs C

R

2. I Stop r i yl a S U

N yhl p e 3 Grdl a ht o

(

erd i oetenna a oa n t

t o

r m upnusgo R p

e t

e syeqtt c n s t

u 0 I sl l x e edim S a1 t 0-i yc a edf f n a r

l a

w y t i e a eug e n

e r f ereh t s ab oor l

R e

t o ant ut p i s

n e

c a senmnh cgi et i g

L P

P N

i nt mwi r n C m r e deian on C i

r nv t acor so". t f el gos epvt ri l iois r

ni s n f eppn co a o I

" r oaefamb C

f .J l

3 . .

} 4 {/ q1 1 } 3 t 4 4 j ' ,g rl_[p[} [ t! ! [; lc  ! ji[k l

9 t

sr c a

,t s 0 e ps s l

a e n t 9 -

f ee '

wr eumr ey l 1

e f

eb c o

ntue e t

ef r v ulaon st r

p)

Rt e u i

o) sn ed a 1 I l

1 C

R N

S qd -

3 U ee en 0 .t ymluw.e ht smr a3 enoe3 n

eoCym f

a oh r

n2

. t t

o r

o p

i ct t

Rae r

Siser3 v ,

R e

s u o L nNsI cnsemS t

t t ai o.

' e 1 e n re s ieis s e l 9 a9 ynt Em7 c e n sl ei

' w e

n e

Gle0.eperna nO nir cy R e

s Bp5 p n( Ge c a l

Et o L i

n e

c s gu d u egne P n

r i

nSar r

n svnouGamC i

t i

v cgBr P

N C

uR9 acl i i i

e qA5 eioht r sicf a h ef n c . pt s eh t o n eS0 RF5 peRwoo(C ar nf o

C -

e -

~

e

/ . } 1  ;;

.y o!f e f M} j ; g j ;lM f

ri> u

[ g; k.

o i

t n

e s m f

f e2 g1 r t

a a o s ny f c n

a a s r

u s

u d mM o e o t ni o

g s gis a t t

o e n g

i. i c r o

p c

y eu r un d n

a s

u o s ni t r a s ie t i a1 t o s-a s i

t ne e c

t 9 a9 w

nh omn9 e

n m og c a c

e i

t u d t

x a9 s n

ao m9 e

m c r ne 1 u c

u ih nt en m;f r

oy e p

u S ug s r a c c

s mio n m w eM p/

u mk r ci e eir l

t a oo e v ep t CwRr e SA S e e e

~

- j

l .. ' ;

E

~: $

g ':z ,4

,"3 i

f [ n!  !

/ ;jp)3 &2 l A

' [( ,

1 [ j. ;f3lt .

1 1

s

' 9 s 9 e 9 c 9 1 c "

d 9 u e s

mt e C

e9 c 1 6

s r R

N S

l e U n l i

r m i f l e p n p ht ai e o A o m mp t

t r I d c o t

r o

p d n e "

c R e

r l e e s s oA u 0 p s o mw t

a1 h St 0 l 9 f Ol c e e r r a9 s

g i

w e

e fo v n n w/t i e d y e R P i t ii ee r r e

s n

e s e vf i o "y i L

c d r e et n a c t P P

e to M Re ma N C

C s c tyd r o a i i

i f

r n c u

pi c feht l

b u aa o Ac od r P Sp C "

PI n e e e e

=

a.A 4 JN  ;

k k g } j,;n .

f

,} ! t  ; - ; L t [ [' -

'f {

. ~

2 1

n i

o t

s a

f i c

f l C l

e i l p N S

U R

u Cp ht e

d e t A t t

o r

o h r e a rl R p

e s

c ovl t u 0 a1 St 0-Sf w l 9 ae a9 w

e C Cn e R n

e e

s R ER i L

e c

n _

N Ge P P

N C

C Bs n _

e i

c _

L -

~

i

j . -

s c

' j s y s y; j 7 i *

'y

~. 4 d

. r

.~

^

, [ l, fl,  ; [ e.F f !.

~

_h{

i_

'l l 3

1 d

t e

l e

p m t n

s d o e t

e c d l

a e -

e m e n

o l

p C t e ta d i e t mRN o

l p S t t e

i d d l

e c b

y mt c o

l p

mr d

A t e

e C

R N

c a S u o fo l

d d p p U t

e l e t m c s m ht e

o d e t i i I d F s l s o e

l p V na i

s e c t e l t

e p

m o i g

n r

c e t

d E

n u

q e w t

r o

p h

i l

e a e R c mC o g H e

b P

u m n o

s n

R de l

i v

e s

u 0 c n / r o at t a1 ce R S r e t 0 i i t

o i

v t i S -

- e f i t

n i

t np l

s l 9 -

l d

t e

k c

o t i

y n

S l

a E

rd P

e r

h cmse eo r a9 w

e n

l fo et t

D g e Tc a

t i

m u n e o R d t r e se n s - r e b n o e e) P s r S u a p p

m n

gl np vr t

eA I

t n

n e

c e n e c O o

r imt t

e e o e l pR e i

L v i t

o a

c t

n a

p f

o e

i E

v n M-c cg I

f n

o m

o (n Ci t o e m

g P

P N

C O i l

p p

e c

c i

t c

o C

R i

l bi up n

i l

i g

n Ca Rrm a

n a

C A A N N Po c F Nof M C 8

- - - - S - I n -

R99 8 9

/

8 9

/

8 9

0 1

/

7-8 9

8 9

8 9

8 9

/

N1 0 1

/

4 0

1

/

5

/

8

/

7 7

/

7

/

9

/

7

/

7

/

8

/

7

/

9 8

2

/

9 3

- ~

1]

2 i .

- $

[

t f$.; 1 }

a,

F

' [ (

0 ,.N DISTRIBUTION:

Hard copy Docket File PUBLIC RLSB RF -

N. Dudley, ACRS - T2E26 EHylton E-mail: M. Evans i R. Zimmerman R. Bores W. Kane S. Stewart D. Matthews -

F. Bower S. Newberry B. Latta C. Grimes C. Carpenter B. Zaleman , D. Walters, NEl  ;

J. Strosnider l R. Wessman J E. Imbro W. Bateman J.' Calvo ,

4 H. Brammer

' T. Hiltz G. Holahan T. Collins C. Gratton B. Boger R. Correia R. Latta l

J. Moore J Rutberg R. Weisman M. Zobler M. Mayfield S. Bahadur N. Chokshi J. Vora l A. Murphy )

D. Martin - I W. McDowell l S. Droggitis RLSB Staff S.Bajwa A.Dromerick T.Kenyon K.Leigh R. Blough W. Cook  !

i 4

i

% ._= _ -__ _ - _ _ _ - - J