ML20196J733

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.Forwards App D Documents.Apps C & D Documents Available in Pdr.App E Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)
ML20196J733
Person / Time
Site: Fermi DTE Energy icon.png
Issue date: 03/08/1988
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To: Bauman L
GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT
Shared Package
ML20196J737 List:
References
FOIA-87-871 NUDOCS 8803150035
Download: ML20196J733 (5)


Text

U.S. CLEAR RE ULATORY COM:CCSION aiac ago cep hi en si 9

\ '

... ~.,

  1. l ff 'U/; '

Fli ^* int TIFT l

!. R PONSE 40 FREEDOM OF ' I I *'

INFORMATION ACT (FOlA1 REQUEST M8

\e es.. /

/

cuxalt trywstt S. tosee= pei IS8g a

m sto.r.stui

~0 '

l1AbN PART I -RICORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATIO (See c^ecaed 6oses)

No agency recrrds wtect to the reawest have been located.

No add *tionel agency recorde evtect to Pe *eavest base been located AGency recorde At),ect to the roomt that are identfM e Apcendia _ -

e's already eveAete for pwtd.C rec +ct*on and copyeg c the NRC Pw.c Docvment Room.

1717 H Street. N W.. Wphegton DC

/ Agency records sAsct to the reavest that eso scentifM e Apc+rce _ _ ere bee n g mee eveAet4e foe pw.c eac+cton erd copyeg c the NRC Put*c Docwment Room.1717 M street. N W.. W sehegton, DC. e a foW under the F4 numte end tNwester name r -

The nonpropretary vow of the propose! si that vow speed to eccept e a to cAone con =e ution et* e memt** of my stem e no. to ng made avoiste for pubi.e repecten trd coveg at the NRC Pwtdec Docurrent Room.1717 M $.reet. N W . Wuhegtce DC . e a folder unde > the FOt A ncter sad esovestos eame Enclosed e Wormate on how vow may obtee occus to and the che>ges for cceveg records pieced e the NRC PwtAc Document Room 17t7 M $neet. N W . Washegion. DC.

Agency records Abspc1 to the re@.481 o's enclosed Arv eppl<st4 che*ge for Copes of the records prov4*4 and Der"Wnt procedwees are noted e the comments tecten seco,0. wb,oeno the reamt we b n , 4e-.d to enor., sese , egencvi.s, to, re- au d4ect rnpo,u to ,ov in - or NRc s ,apor.e io one ,mmt no ve, ecoce e e., tsien oa appen i.n*, daied PART 11 A-tNFORMATION WITMMELD FROM PUSUC DISCLOSURE Cetae Worma's>n e the 'eosesied records e tems etwn e id t om pwohe 04ciove pw<svent to t% FOI A eiewtes encreed e and for the rusone stated e Pe,t u. sec-l tee e. C. and D An, ro+n.d cu~ e e t*e docume-ts o, e n*.ca c.ni, se, e tw <eco,d t.ey weid e . c m -ce e,sasoie for pwtu esp.cten and copyeg c re Nac Pw.c Doev t Room irir M sveet N w . w e.h ngwn. DC. e e toioe. v,oe, the soi A u n mec and ..am, no-.

C~ ets i

l 8003150035 080300 PDR FOIA BAUMAN87-071 PDR i

^ l Nag c>ascion sec ,ssagoe, coa s me n.A l

,1 1

1 NRC FORM 4H er on o l

<t Or I

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE FotA NU M et o ss ~ " oaf t: N8 )$$8

, PART lt 8-f.PPLICABLE FOIA IXtMPTIOses Records subtect to the request that are descnbod m the enclosed Append *ces _ . ._ ere boeg eethheld m thee entrety or m part under FOI A Enemptons 6nd for the reasons set89rth beloor pursuant to 5 U S C. %2tbl and 10 CF R 9 Nel of NRC Regulatons.

t. The we4d eformation e proc 4y ctes>4 4 pursvent to ti,cwine Order 1274 ttx(MPTON 11 2 The ethheid eformoson r#ces solery to the -errel seasonnel evies and procedur es of NRC. tExtVPTON 2)
3. The wthheid aritormation a scocthcee v esempted tegen putdic dociosure by statute mecated itxtMPTION 31 Seston 141146 et the Atomac trergy Ac1 *+wch Poh4xts tte declosw ee of Restncted Data or f ormer*, Reevcted Data 142 U $ C. 2161-2106L Section 147 of the Atomic Energy Act which prohenta the dsclosw e of Unclaseded Sa'egweeds inforrretce M2 V $ C. 2167L e

4 The wthheid mformason e a trade secret or comtreece or feancel s% formation that a tomg wethheid for tN reasorwel nd<ared ttttMPTCN 46 The enformation a conadored to te conf 4ent$ bwsaness (propretary) eformetert The informeten a cor.soe'ed to te propretary eformaten ow swant to 10 CFR 2 PbdHIL The eformatson nos sole sited end rece ved an conf 4ence from a foref towrce Dweswant to lQ CFR 2 79CN642L

$ The vethheid aformeten coeests of etereaancy or et'eegency recceds that are not avedabie throwgh decovery dureg st$ation Decioewe e of predeteer# eMormaten would tend to ehtet the open an

-o~med edrect mowny eto they,*dwe.,d -- Tr frar*

preoeceens process

,e eenchange oar of the egenc, eof itx(M re ceas P res essente to the deleterets, process Where records are wthhee i' tionmagsegregat,ie f.ctv. po, ice. t-awse ihe re.eese of ene facts wow.d -

6 The utved Wormenon e ene-cod from pubic desoosu e becewse r es dectosw e e would resun e a oese, wenemanted mes.on os sersonal prmeev. :ExtMPTCN 6) r

7. The webeid c ormeten toneets of evestsetcry ruoros compaed for tan edorcement ow poses and a teeg *we.e for tN reesonisi edicated itxtvPTCN h 0.sciosure wow e d etersare wth se odortrent proceeene tecewie a cowe d reves the scoce, enmon end toews e eatorcement enorts and thws cowd e ponsstry salon them to tase ecten io sNeed potent
  • wrongdoing or a venaten of NRC reaw a rents f om eveeigators it)(VPTCN hAn Decicevre wou ns constavie ea wa near**d mes.cc of pe sons p%ecv atxtvPTcN 7tCu i The enformaten corests of norres of r@vowas and other Wormaten the d$ closure of wa .ch wowbd reveal $eatees of conf.oeate swecos attlVPTCN 710n PARY H C-DENYING OFFICIALS Purwent to 10 CFR 3 3 end or s 15 of the V 5 Nucieer Reg n end Ni as prouten or oeciowe e cart'ev to re put culatory eterest Commenen reawletons tre pesons responstine for a tNhas oen toen aetermrodn tnt ee adormeten wehe d e enret fece producwon er d oveen e Rwiesandmecords. owe e Aameet eten. sor 49 cones trat may te a:5eae4 to the tiei a e those cwir.e o cees orector centded tienom tcw Oscetens icooi es dryeg onces and the Ormor otNYING OFF6CIAL 3 , TITLE. 0F FiC1 RECORO$OtN10 APPtLLATE OFF4CIAL  !

. Y .

n -

Y D,N, d M, Y N  ;

I 1

i

\

i PART H D- APPE AL mlGMTS  !

The dental by each denyeg off.ce identfed m Part it C fnay be appeated to the Appenate Off.cel dentifed e that secton. Any such appeat must be in wnt.ng and must be made witNn 30 dan of rece*pt of this response. Appes's must be soaressed as approprote to the Enocutrve Drector for Operstona or to the Secreta.y of the Commenon. U S. Nwetear Reguletory Commission. Washington, DC 20%6, and shouu ctearty state on the envWope and in the letter that a e an " Appeal from en ina.al FDIA Dm e,ec Foais one iPea a c as, U.S. NUCLEAR REQULATORY COMMIS$40N FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION

l '

Re: FOIA- l APPENDIX RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG PDR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION .

J IU kkf Yp ,

[ hn (O yyh

! Ye4icrew. bss6 togyom 1- iM '_ite fym 1).90 +c 9n. 0. zuL  :

h65 ton tLOD73co10) iM97 LcNer fravn T.).BaKL to htt . [

bessuiet)o,gjoo c c I

i i

r P

[

l l

1 l

Re: foIA-l 3

APPENDIX J l RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE AB0VE REQUEST NUMBER  ;

l MUMBER OATE. DESCRIPTION I. lI30fn [dfer rm 2. 4tudk ho s . [Aum . t d, 39 o .

t i

I l

4 4

b I

I i

i t

i

)

l

4 RECORDS PART! ALLY WITHHEt.0, NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION _&EXp' ION I. TMO ficmo(rm $.M b'c to T . 6hm O 3 d Ab'pd',

M W ko % .Lo m , tuih a Jac.hn ut'.

b (r b wn9..Lae g. h h w bd p n W PWW e %xn% 6.

1 Umhtte ibuhJnh rG pm L.c.6 cone to Psc' totie Ll P2yd,doch 9 p93 ytmm cmwmm.jem tuaq % sat f caGd % 6. M>nr6 vet.

b kng withb)) wrud to bwfwh E,

-t

l i

i i

3 1

I I

. i 4 ,

CC $RNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT MIDWEST OFFICE 104 East Wisconsin Avenue l Appleton. Wisconsin 54911 (4 9 di 730 8533 December 22, 1987 l

l ERCEDOM OF INFCR "1 M 7 ACCDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RF.QUCF T ACJ RE

-ircetor

- FatA -QL STn-w l :ffice of Administration kl,t, 8d A3 - d./ -O

.S. Nuclear Regulatory Conmissien

'ashington, D.C. 20210

.O Wi!OM IT MAY CONCERN l

l 'ursuant r to the Freedom of Inf orr ation Act (F01A, 5 U.S.C. 552,) the Govornment Accountability Project (CAP) requests c0 pies of any and all agoney records and inf ormation, including but not limited to notes,

'ctters, memoranda, drafts, minutes, diaries, logs

. calenders, tapes, transcripts, s unea rle s , interview reports, procedures, instructions, ongineering analyses, drawings, f;1es, graphs, cha rts, maps, photographs, agrcements, handwritten notes, studies, data sheets, notebooks, books, tolcphone messages, computatier.s, voice recordings, computer runcifs, and cny other data compilations, interia and/or final reports, status reports, and any and all other records relevant to and/or generated in conr.ection etth a December 8, 1987 letter frem Themas E. Hurley, Director Office of

aclear Regulatory Commission to Ms. Garde and Mr. Condit in response to thoir Petition pursuant to 10 C.F.R. 2.206 dated May 7, 1987 on behalf of th Sofo Energy Coalition of Michigan and the sisters servants of the I mma cu l at <.-

HOort of Mary Cong. regarding the Fermi-2 facility which requests the NRC to institute a proceeding to modify suspend or revoke the license issued to Detroit Edison Company. 1) NRC take possession of all Safeteam files and rCview the allegations for all potential safety-related deficienies, make these concerns public. 2) NRC require all Safeteam allegations are processer by the utility in accordance with 10 CFR Part 50. Appendix B. 3) NRC requires 011 utility employees are fully informed about Safeteam before they make a choice between submitting information to the Safeteam or the NRC.

This request includes all agency records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b) l l

cnd the NRC Hanual, Appendix 0211 Parts 1. A.2 and A.3 (approved October l

8, 1980) whether they currently exist in the NRC offical, "working" I investigative or other, files, or at any other location, including private rosidences.

If any records as defined in 10 C.F.R. 9.3a(b) and the NRC Manual, supra, and covered by this request have been destroyed and/or removed af ter l this request, please provide all surrounding records, including but not '

limited to a list of all records which have been er are destroyed and/or '

rcmoved, a description of the action (s) taken relevant to, generated in com cetion with and/or issued in ordar to implement the action (s). l C f'"M i 7a a-m /N l

u W *%Y ff '  ;

a ,* '

I .

GAP requests that f ees be waived, because, "! r.fing the inf ornat:en can be considered as primarily benefitting the ytteral public, " 5 *.* . S . C .

j 552 (a) (4) (a). GAP is a ncn profit, non-; trtisan public ir. erest organization concerned with honest and open :cvernment. Thro:g.. public outreach, the Project promotes whistleblowers as agents of geTernment i cecountability. Through it Enviromental Wh:st'eblower Clinic. GAP of fers

essistance to local public interest and cit
re..s groups and i:tervenors 4

in the concern for safety at nuclear power g' ants. .

1 We are requesting this information as part cf an ongoing monitoring project

Of the NRC's efforts to protect public healt.* and safety at a:d near
nuclear processing plants and radioactive waste facilities.

For any documents or portions that you deny fue to a specific FCIA oxemption, please provide an index itemizing a..d describing t:e documents or portions of documents withheld. The index should provide e detailed justification of your grounds f or claiming ese.. exemption, ex;1aining why oach exemption is relevant to the document er ortion of the foeument withheld. This index is required under Vaue.in v. Rosen (I), 434 F.2d 820 (D.C. Cir. 1973), cert. denied, 415 U.S. 977 (.974).

We look forward to your response to this reg;est within ten ('0) working j days.

Sincerely, l

007 .r -@qq Linda Bataan FOIA Coordinator

, Midwest Office I

l I

l l

1 i

}

, , - ,