ML20155G481

Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents.App K Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5).App J Documents Available in PDR

ML20155G481
Person / Time
Issue date:	06/10/1988
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To:	Clint Jones AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
References
FOIA-88-92 NUDOCS 8806170325
Download: ML20155G481 (6)

Text

U.S. NUCLEAR CEGULATORY COMMISSION Nac poia aEFAt$' %W9te $s

, f [ l [ F01A-88-92 p.s :,,I'g ~ Et$PON$1 T vFt l l

! L i RESPONSE YO FREE OF l '^ ^' lN'IAL i

s / INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST JUN 101988 ee...

DOCati Nuv$le Sr W espacew MovtSTE R Mr. Charles Jones i PART 1.-RECORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATED ISee checaed bonest  !

No agency records subrect to the request have been located No additecal agency records subrect to the request have been located.

Agency records subrect to the request that are centifed m Append 4a are already avadatde for pun.c inspecten and copyeg m the NRC P@ic Docu"eet Room, yy 1717 H $trett. N W , Washegton. DC Agency records subrect to tee request Ost are 4ent; fed en Appenden __ _ are be,ng mace ava.lable for pubec eospecten and copyeg m the NRC Putn. Dxumeet Room,1717 H St'eet N W . Wasmegion. DC r a foner un der th.s FOIA numte a : reavester name Tre nonpropietary verson of the proc,osaHs) that you ag'eed to accept e a te'ep*one :ceversaton with a memter of my staM rs now bemg made avadatde for puc< especten and coymg at the NRC Putd.c Documeet Room,1717 H $treet N W Washmgton DC , e a folder under thes FOIA number and requester name Enclosed s eformaton on how you reay obtain access to and the u, ..ges for copying ecords placed m the NRC Pubiec Document Room.1717 H Street. N W., Wasteg'on, DC Agency records subect to the re@est are enclosed Any acecabie charge for copes e' the records proveed and paymer' procedu res are noted a the comments secton.

Records subject to the request have teen referred to another Federal agencyhest for wiew and direct resoor se to you in www of NRC's resnoese to the request. no furter acton a bemg taken on appeal e er dated PART 11 A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PU8 tlc DISCLOSURE Certam informaton e the requested ,ecords e be.ng withheid from pubiac d sclosure pu soant to the Fol A esemptor s descreed m and for the reasoes stated m Pai II. sec-tons 8. C. and D Any re+ eased portons of t** documents for whsch onty part of t% ecord is being et*heid are bemg reade avadabie for out*c especten and cccving m the NRC Pubiac Document Room.1717 H Sa'oet. N W . naseegton. DC m a foice' Wer this FOIA number and requester came.

Comments 1 i

l l

l l

l i

l l

I I

a A

5 t t 0.etCtCA r 50% 08 e' a%oescoacs

/

8806170325 880610 PDR FOIA JONES 88-92 PDR Nf;C FORM 464 er 94

FRsEOOu dF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE FOiA fwuMetRISL DATE: 0M FA47118- APfLICABLE FOI A EXEMPTIONS ._

Records subject to the request that are desenbed in the enclosed Appendices are being wrthheid in their entwety or in pa-t under FOIA Entmptions and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. SS2tbl and 10 CFR 9 5(a) of NRC Regulaton

1. The wthbeid informate e propody class,fied pursuant to Enocutive Order 12356 IEXEMPTION 1)

2. The wthhold wiformat>06 PWales soIWV to the eternal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. (EXEMPTION 2) 3 The wthbeid nformat>on e specshcaay esempted from public dsclosure by statwie irecated IEXEMPTION 31

$ection 141145 of the Atomic Energy Act which grohitzts the disclosure of Restncted Data oe Fonnerty Restrict.J Data i42 U S C. 21612165L Secton 147 of the Atonic Energy Act wNch probitzts the d sclosur e of Unclassded Safeguards infor vtson (42 U S C. 216h

4. The ethbend informaton e a trade secret or commercial or feancial informaton that es becg e. hhed for the reason's: edicated tex!VPTION 4)

The eformation es cor'sdered to be contcential buseess (propretary) enformation.

The informaton e considered to be propretary eformation pursvar t to 10 CFR 2Md)t1).

The information was subrnetted and received in conf 4ence from a foreign ser war .10 CFR 2MdH2) 5 The wthbed irdormaten consets of etFagency or intraagency records that are not evadable through d scovery dunng ht9stion. Doctoswre of predeceenal eformaton would tend to weitxt the open and fiar* enchange of ceas essental to the dehborstw process. Where records are *rthheed m thee entwory, the facts are mestncatdy etertwned v.ath the predeceonal eformaten There a#so are no reasonat#y.segregetde factwW portons tecause the resues of the facts would permet an Indirect inquery ero Ine prooece onal process of the agency. tf XEMPTION 5)

X

6. The wthbed mformation a esempted from public declosure becevue ets d scioswee would rssvit L. a dearty unwananted ewasion of personal pnvecy. (EXEMPTION 61

7. The ethhed w formation conersts of evest.gatory records cornoseu for law enforcement purpcses and es bemg withheed for the reanorqs) indicated. (E)(EMPTION h Disclosure would intF4ere with an enforcement procee6eg because 11 Could reveal the scope. difKten, and focus of enforcement efforts. and thus Could possitgy aepe them to take acten to she64 potentel w@ngrioeng or a votaten of NRC reouvements from evestigators IEXEMPTION 7t A))

Disc 6cevr e *ow6d constitute an unwonanted evason cf pe7sor,ai pnvecy (EXEMP AON 7tCl) r The information consets of names of indmdwals and other eformation the d sclosu e of wn.ch would reveal dentrues of contcentel sources (EXEMPTION 7101)

PART Il C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuant to 10 CFR 9 9 and 'or 915 of the U S Nuclear Regulatory Commsson regulatons, it has been determeed that t*e wilormaton *nhreid e enempt from producten or deciosure.

and that its producton or disclosae a contrwy to the put he eterest. The persons respons ble for the denial are those orfic+s cer toed teio* as r'enre g orfcais and the Orrector, D vision of Rules and Recores. C*fice of Admeetreten, for any deneis that may be appeased to the Esecutrve Director fcr Operatons 'Eco.

l DENYING OFFICIAL TIT LE r OF FICE RECORDS DEN:EO APPERATE 08FICIAL  ;

sscattany too William T. Russell Regional Administrator App. K X

l i

~

l PART H D- APPEAL RIGHTS The denial by each denying offcalidentifed in Part II.C may be appealed to the Appellate Off,cial identified in that secton. Any such appeal must be in wnting and must be made within 30 days of receipt of this response. Appeals must be addressed as appropriate to the Executive Director for Operations or to i

the Secretary of the Commesacn, U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555, and should Clearty state on the envelope and in the letter  !

shat it is an "Appeal trom an instial TOTA Decis.on."

uc som aos men 2'

'** U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION ,

4 Re: FOIA 88-92 APPEN0lX J RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FitES NUMBER DATE DE5CRIPTION

1. . 8/19/77 Letter, Schwencer to Consumers Power Company 7912180909 W. O. Parker

2. 6/8/78 Letter, Victor Stello to Consumers Power 8102100554 D. A. Bixel

3. 9/7/79 Letter, Eisenhut to Bixel 7910180237

4. 10/31/80 Letter, Eisenhut to David P. Hoffman 8012110303 5* 11/24/80 Darrell G. Eisenhut to All Power Reactor 8103040312 Licensees With Plants Licensed Prior to Jan 1, 1979

6. 2/20/81 Darrell G. Eisenhut to All Power Reactor 8103180264 Licensees With Plants Licensed Prior to Jan 1, 1979 l

7. 10/21/81 Letter, carrell Eisenhet t o C . N . Du nn 8111040460

8. 4/7/82 Gus C. Lainas to David Vandewalle, subject: 8204160274 Fire Protection Rule - 10 CFR 50.48(c)(5) - I Alternative of App R to 10 Safe CFRShutdown 50 - Section !!!.C.3

9. 4/20/82 Letter, H. R. Denton to S. A. Bernsen, 8205100003 Bechtel Power Corp

...,.. ... .. , ..,...3... . . . .

Re: F01A. 88 92 APPEN0lX I RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FitES NgMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

10. 7t2/:2 -

pecer :. u atts:n e Richard H. 'cil . er, 82080;052;

s:t i . ctits e-: e-

3. ;e t  ::::w.*:s

- s:..r. r  :: t-...ti.e 5%t:c - e: -

t .c J,or. v g a : re s n t Fer in s vsc;irve ic Achieve Celo Snutdcwm

11. 1/07/B3 L. S. Rubenstein to Roger J. Mattson, subject: Statement of Staff Position 8302010011 Re Source Range Flux

12. 3/18/83 Mee.orandum, L. S. Rubenstein to Roger 830 15045B J. Mattson, Revision To Statement of Staff Position Regarding Source Range Flux. Reactor Coolant Temperature. And Steam Cenerator Pressure Indication To Meet Appendix R l

13. a/22/83 Richard H. Voll cr to D.irrell r. Eisenhut. 830505027; sub;.ec t : Fire Protec t ion Requ irement s 1

l l

14. :l2;/83 william V. Jonnston to John A. Olshinski. 8305020091 subject:

Fire Protec t ion Modifications 15.

6/la/83 M=morandum. Richard M. Vollect to narrell 8307070052 Eisenhut, Surveillaner Testing Of Fire Pumps (Tasi Inter f ace Agreement s No. s 3-19 and 83-19A - TAC ;9720)

_ ~ , _. . . .~ - , ---

Re; FOIA. 88 92 APPENDIX .1 I 1

RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR Fitti NLpentR DATE DESCRIPTION

16. 7/1/83 Let ter anc snspec t ien r( pe r: . 50-255't)-12 63050906;;

'.' . C . S e i d l e t o W . C . J o n e n . Omana Public Power District. Notice of Vtoistion

17. 3/16/8.

Letter and inspect ion report. 50-267/83-2).

8:0al30223 no Notice of Violation f or Ft . St. Vrain

18. 11!!5/$;

James P. O'Reills to Victor Stello Jr.. 8412190351 subject: Recommended Fire Protection Policy and Protram Actions 19, 12/19/85 SECY-85-3068 Commissioners,Villiam subject: J. Dircks to The 8601160366 Staff Recommendations Re The implementation of App R to 10 CTR 50 l

l

-w- y 'T'

Re: F0!A-88-92 APPENDIX K RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD - Exemption 5

1. 11/2/83 Memo for Richard C. DeYoung from Thomas E. Murley, subject: "FirePrevention/ Protection (FPP) Inspection,"(2 pages)withattachments(6pages) 4 4

CIIARLES H. JONES .13024 HARTSDOURNE DRIVE e GERM ANTOWN. MARYLAND 2n871 (361) 972 nin7 February I,1988 ERT.EDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley M'((-91 Division Director Office of Administration, /h 2-// -[p Rules and Records U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Attention: FOIA

Dear Mr. Grimsley:

I wish to obtain several documents per t aining to 10CFR50 Appendix R inspections and enforcement. Accordingly, the following materials are requested under the Freedom of Information Act:

1. Copies of all Headq;ar ters and Regional inspection modules used to verify nuclear utility compliance with fire protection reg;1rements specified in 10CFR50, Appendix R, including drafts and revisions of those l

Inspection modules.

i

2. Internal correspondence between or among regional '

offices, and between regional offices and the NRC Headq;arters, concerning use of Appendix R inspection modules.

1

3. Commission papers and transcripts of Commission  !

meetings regarding Appendix R inspection modules and/or inspection results. i l

4. Commission papers and transcripts of Commission meetings referring to determination of enforcement actions and civil penalties resulting from fire protection inspections, including "closed" hearings such as that which occurred on or about June 8,1987.

5. Notices of violation resulting from Appendix R inspections for Vermont Yankee, Ft. Calhoun, Davis Besse, Fort St. Vrain, Salem, and Pilgrim.

o on w a e ea nr ia* w ^, -" ,' 2jojo

$_ r- * -

CHARI,ES H. JONES e 13821 HARTSHOURNE DRIVE e GERM ANTOWN. MARYLAND 20871 (301) 972 n197 j l

1

6. The Differing Professional Opinion (DPO) signed by l several NRC fire protection personnel concerning Appendix R guidance and all NRC memorondo, files, and notes pertaining to the review and disposition of the OPO.

I I understand that it may be necessary for me to pay for the staff research and materials involved with responding to this request. I appreciate your assistance.

Sincerely,

/ w Charles R. nes CRJ/ll P

E i

p i

i