ML20154D928
| ML20154D928 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 08/31/1988 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC |
| To: | Belair R KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20154D931 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-87-794 NUDOCS 8809160172 | |
| Download: ML20154D928 (8) | |
Text
,
U S NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$10N w.*#a ssov ut svrie u
.. e "N, PCIA-87-794 o
.g 6.Sev.,$4,,ii y<
a RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF
.X!'**'
I l "'
\\,
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST g 3y g eu n a rr,. 4 a 5 %
e.,,
teovisite Robert R. Belait PART I -alCORDS RELI ASED OR 8 SOT LOCAft0 (See c^ec.ea bosest No.gency <eco,c..wbect to tm. roowe.t have beea loc.ted
. No.ddetomal.gency,eco,0..wbact to t,equest k.ve been loc.ted Agency,eco,os m.,bect to the,ne.t tb.t.*e u,eetf eo e Appenois J
.*e.ke.3,.. 4tde fo, pwt+c.,ucwton.ad copveg am the N m C Pwbhc Doewment monm, X
1717 H Street. N W., W Hmegton. DC N
Agency seco,0. htect to the,eows.1 t%st. e deatded e acosaes
.*e teeg mese...d.No 'o, pw.c escoctoe ed copyeg.n tN NaC Pwte Doewmeat c
X Room,1717 M Street. N W. W..*egion. DC. m. '*ow wade, th 80ia a mt.,.N,eo weiter n.**
w ts acee,o 1.,v.rse e tse e,opo.i e., vow.re.a io.ueci. e.eo one co,e,ute e.,,<., e m,.t n. no. toes we.....>. e, we c e e
m
.ad core 0.t the NmC Pwt*c Docwmeat acom.1717 H St set. 8 W. W.s^.egion. X. e. 'oue, w*ee, t*. FOi/ numbe,.ad 'oowe.,w ae*.
i Encteeed. iMo,m.te on how yow m., ret.e.ue to.a4 the ch. ge. 8, cocr g,.:.yo. p. cod in t*. Nec Pvt *c Doewment moom.1717 M St,eet. N W. Wuhettoe. DC i
0 e
1 A-,,=o, t io e..
i..e es i, u+i.c... cs..pe.., u e ne x o,....o,4e4.e. t.,-.
i,,x ow e.,e aow.n me c-t..-te coo.
.w.,eci io
,eove., u.e t.w
,ve,,0. to., ore, F.se,,.g.,e, e.i io. e...... ui -e to,ow i
x ia..e. o. NmC..
.e io r. e%eet. eo.w.v x
. e g t..e, oe.,,.,. e. o.,e. _ December _2A._1981 - (87-A-112 )
t PART 11 A-INFORM AtlON WifMMEL.D F9CM PUBLIC OISCLOSURE I
Cen n...,m...o re.
we.
o,o...e, r ow.. stAc.mm. ~e w io me no.
e.em.-. oom e.,..e, r.,.n e1.w.n P.u.--
ion...C..,.OA,,e.
3-e.eweoxw.t.... w. %
tb. NRC Pwtd.c Doewmeat Room 1717 M St nt N W. W..hegton DC. m. 'Nor ear ta. FOla nw.ezo,.. beeg -e
..e i.e. tee m.mo.oo...<. e., nu.c
.n=< tea.y u.v g a e
mte,.64 + owe 4
Comracet.
i i
f
)
i l
1 f
i l
r i
i i
)
9 l
t i
l 1
b i
S<
a' tag pag;tca p.vs.co. es nats as aga;a;s I
A dr 1%e 1
/
,/
}
BELAIR87 'M$f PDR i
i N R C F O R \\t 444..
6*
-,,w ea,
--,---m.
-,_-,___-,,,.ww--__w, 7-,
_~%g--,,
,y y
.y y
m.
5 j.
]
F:sepoeA of INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE tota Nv uttm st 87-794 CAtt PA=T 14 S. APPLICASLt FOIA talMPTIO8e8 MUU D 1 HP95
)
Records subrect to the request that are desenbod in the enclosed Append ces _ b I N
_ ere boeg withheld in their ent+rety or in part under FOIA
[sempteons and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S C. 562tbl and 10 CFR 9 54a1 of NRC Regulatons.
i 4
- 1. The wthre'd eformation e prope% classfed pweswent to lauwtw order 12356 ttutVPTcN 1) a
- 2. The wthhead eformoeon retetes soiepy to tre eternal personrel rwies and procedw es of smC. (ExtMpt@N 21 r
l a the -new em.on e weee,...,ted frorn oveAc e.iot,e py sieh,te in.ce,*.
in terr m 141146 of the Atomac treegy Act.h cm preheets the osciosv e of Restructed Date or For*edy Restncwd Date (42 U S C. It$121061 Secten r
d Secten 147 of the Atomic trergy Act.*=ch preherts t e doctoove of Unctetsdod Safegwares laforesten 442 U S C. 2167L h
L t
4 The wthhead s9ermetron e e trese secret & cornmercies or fearcel edumation that a boeg wt%Aou for the restorwsl eecated ItalMPTION 46 4
L The eformaten a comeeered to be cordioestet t>weeste (propretaryl eformation i
il I
i The saformetson e consesred to t>e propreter, e'orneten pw s..at to 10 Cf R 2 7soioult e
j j
two ee meten.
t,mm.s eaa exe,oa e coneence bom a 'we$n sowrce owreeet to to cia 2 7mes2i j
)
I s The win.4 ceo,wton cor e ewea.nc, e ciruaenc, exores trat we not...aeas throws
- e=o,*r, esce et,s.et.on ouiceve v 0,esweens etemeten
.owie teno w reeni m ocen va ters encarse e een aware to sne oweestw proceu wsore ruwee ce wthme o e then et ety, m ex3 ce ceitncet,%
1 eta,merc.e wen ngeoeceers enormeten in-e wee c, e ce rusogc%wereget.e ex1we patene twown the re = v the tute wowie perm. en j
x ca wt e.rv ew poowoons erwen e ine esenc itatwei i
I P
j s The wihm.4 c+ormaten a eireteo bom owtme ousosse twowu ts exioese *ci.,u rnen e e ou4, vn.crwes e,non e preorm penxv. itxtvrtcN 6>
l l
7 The etwasas e#ormation coneets o8 ewsteetor, recorse coressed tw te* e orceoat ovepows one e toeg wt**eu for N reenesi escowd iDtWPTCN ?)
s 1
l l
ocioe,,e wu ete4.e.wh en enNace ere praeosas tw.was a cowu rows the wope, e.,wten.,ene toeve,e eniaceroni evew ene inw cov i
peesco ee. tnem to tese wie = e saa poisai+ messoeg, e v.oiste e smC rew,emets
- m evec ews ititurics ti An
)
3 5
o.~e.~. co,.tw,.. w-er,-
r,es v,.- pe_,,niopics ? Cn 1
i j
tre riemeten careets e re-se e rose as ed etac e'ermeca N exioise v *.cm *wa re. e cet+= 8 coa'eetes soveca itxturicN 7en
[
l PAar u c-el%viano oniciat$
f
~
i pw.soeat to 10 CFR 9 9 and or 9 il se te U S Nweiser 8eewletorv Carer =esen reewletons. a mes teea eetermnes inet a reatmeten wthr u a earret bcra creeweten er encicwe.
i o
cowete e ou tme prioas reicn.t>e sw n oew re 4
re mi neIvw re xco.iosure e nam w ee owc *c eweeto*c. e emmnet eten. *w ri eeve thei ae, te accomes to ime fixww tweee onces esatsee too. n osaves e c+. ns N 0 wwr.
I a
oyeen e e
ovectw tw oocate seo.
i 6t%ti%G oncAL titta oHect atCo4os otN to APPtLLAf t oHrCiAL
{
Ass't General Counsel l
James A. Fitzgerald for Mjudications &
Aooendix L & M X
1 j
Opinions l
d 4
1 k
1 a
Pami H D-APPE AL mlGMi$
j The derwaJ by each denyeg Wtcial u$entJed m Part ll C may te opgested to the Accetate Off c41 identtted m that secton. Any such 435441 mu t te e i
n 4
- ting and must be made newi 3) den of rece ot of this response. Appea's must be a$$ressed as appropnate to the Esecutae Director for Operatons or to t*e Secretry of tee Comnesson. U S. Nwcker Regulatory Commoort. Was%eston. DC 00%5. and showid c'early state on the e%eiott a'M m t%e tetter taat t,s an ~ Acces: 'eceri en Irvt.at FOI A C+eson '
I
%ec sceu au een 2 U S. NUCLE AR REGULATORY COMMIS$10*v se FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION i
l
l l
t l
\\
l Re:
F0! A.87-794 APPENDIX J
RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPil0N 1
1 l
- 2) 4-14-87 Letter from Morris K. Udall Chairman.
Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, to j
Chairman Zech. NRC (1 page) with attached i
"Pre-Hearing Questions For The NRC" (2 pages)
Accession No. 8704240231 i
[
t f
i l
t i
l 1
Re:
F01 A-87-794 APPENDlX K
s 1
RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE POR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUM8th t
hy!$1R, DATE 0(SCRIPT 10N i
I l
4
- 1) Undated Handwritten notes of OGC Attorney on emergency planning rule comments (7 pages) a j
w b
I I
i J
l l
5 l
l 3
i I
l i
1 j
l l
l t
I l
4 1
1 t
I I
a i
2 l
j l
i i
)
4 i
i i
1
i Re:
FOI A-87-794 t
APPENDIX L
i RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD i
NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION j
1, 4/22/87 Memorandum fer Commissioners from John C. Bradburne, Director OCA, subject:
"Pre-Hearing Q's for Udall Emergency Planning Rule Change (1 page) - Release; r
I with 18-page attachment - Withhold. Exemption 5 l
l
)
i l
i i
i i
a i
4 l
i t
l i
l 1
I l
l l
1 l
4
)
i d
1 I
1 i
d I
f i
4 l
Re:
F01 A- 07-794 APPENDIX 1 RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION DOCUMENTS WITHHELD IN ENTTPiTY UNDER EXEMPTION 5 1)
Undated Evaluation of the Adequacy of Off-Site Draft FINAL RULE: Emergency Planning for Nuclear Power Plants at the Operating License Review Stage Where State and/or Local Governments Decline to Participate in Off-Site Emergency Planning (32 pages)
Attachment:
Regulatory Analysis (4 pages)
Attachment:
Environmental Assessment for Amendments to Emergency Planning (3 pages) 2)
Undated Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above (35 pages) (with handwritten annotations) 3)
Undated Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above (34 pages) (with handwritten annotations) 4)
10/28/87 Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above (36 pages) 5)
Undated Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above (35 pages) 6)
Undated Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above (33 pages) (with editorial corrections) 7)
Undated Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above (36 pages) ("line in/line out" version) 8)
9/25/87 Draft FINAL RULE: Same heading as 1) above 9/27/87 (with editorial comments) (29 pages) 9)
9/29/87 Draft FINAL SULE: Same heading as 1) above (35 pages) (with handwritten annotations)
- 10) 9/23/87 Draft memorandum to the Commissioners from William Parler, General Counsel.
Subject:
Emergency Planning Rule (36 pages) (with handwritten annotations)
- 11) 9/23/87 Draft memorandum: Same heading as 10) above (36 pages) (with handwritten annotations)
Attachment:
"Part 50 - Domestic Licensing of Production and Utilization Facilities" (with handwritten annota-tions (3 pages)
Re:
FOI A-87-794 APPENDIX M
i RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION
- 12) 9/17/87 Draft memorandum: Same heoding as 10) above (21 pages) (with editorial consents)
- 13) Memorandum for Martin Halsch, Deputy General Counsel, 000, from R.W. Houston, Acting Director, RES,
Subject:
Forwarding Comments of Proposed Emergency Planning Rulemaking Analysis (7 pages) (transmitted 8/31/87) 14) 8-13-87 First draft: Remarks of HRC General Counsel William C. Parler to Meeting of State Liaison Officers September 10, 1987 (13 pages)
- 15) 3-27-87 First draft: Testimony of Chairman Lando W.
Zech, Jr., United States Nuclear Regulatory i
Commission, Before the Subcommittee on Energy l
Research and Development of the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources April 22, 1987 (11 pages) j
- 16) 6-1-87 Draft questions and answers for Udall hearing I
(9 pages)
- 17) 4-30-87 Draft queswiens and answers for Breaux hearing (5 pages) i
Subject:
Draft Testimony (Udall and Ford Hearings)
(29 pages) 19) 4-1-87 Draf t testimor.y of Chairman Lando W.
Zech, Jr.,
United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Before the Senate Subcommittee on Energy Research and 1
Development of the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources April 22, 1987 (3 pages) 20) 4-23-87 Draft: Prehearing questions (Udall hearing 4/28)
(13 pages) 21) 3-24-87 Draft answers for Bevill hearing (17 pages) 22)
Undated Draft Questions and Answers, preparation for Congressional hearing, May 1987 (5 pages)
Re: F01A-87-794 APPENDIX M
RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD NUMBER DATE DESCRIPfl0N & EXEMPTION 23)
Undated Draft Short Statement of Chairman Zech, Emergency Preparedness Rule Change, at April 28, 1987 Udall Hearing (5 pages) 24) 4-22-87 Draft answers to pre-hearing questions (Udall)
(18 pages) 25) 7-17-87 Note for William C. Parler, General Counsel, f rom Peter Crane.
Subject:
Documents Related to Emergency Planning Rule (2 pages) 26) 9-30-87 Note for Comnissioners' Legal Assistanta, from Peter Crane,
Subject:
Advance Draft of SECY Paper on Emergency Planning Rule (1 page) 27)
Undated Draft letters to Congressmen responding to comments received on rule change (2 pages) 28) 6-12-87 Draft letters to Congressmen responding to 6-18-87 comments received on rule change (2 pages) f 29)
Undated Draft Regulatory Analysis section of Final Rule j
with handwritten annotations (4 pages) i 30)
Undated Draft Emergency Planning Federal Register notice inserts (7 pages) 1
- 31) Undated Draft Comment Summary on Proposed Rulemaking (6 pages)
J
- 71) Undated Note to Bill Parler, General Counsel, from Joe Scinto, First Deputy Assistant General Counsel (1 page, and attached note on Chronology of State and Local Comments on Emergency Planning Issues (2 pages) with Attachment 1 (7 pages); and Attachment (2 pages) (Ex. 5: Attorney Work Product) i l
- 33) 10/22/87 EP Comments: Draft "Outline of Comments" with handwritten annotations (3 pages)
- 34) Undated Draft responses to Congressional questions j
(Udall hearing 6/1/87) (4 pages) i i
r
~
-