ML20154C713
| ML20154C713 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Grand Gulf  |
| Issue date: | 10/01/1998 |
| From: | Murray B NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV) |
| To: | Eaton W ENTERGY OPERATIONS, INC. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9810070007 | |
| Download: ML20154C713 (27) | |
Text
. - -
e* ** " 8%
UNITED STATES y
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 5
l REGloN IV o
611 RYAN PLAZA DRIVE, SUITE 4G')
.g, ARLINGTON. TEXAS 760ll.80M October 1, 1998 William A. Eaton, Vice President Operations - Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Entergy Operations, Inc.
P.O. Box 756 Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150
SUBJECT:
GRAND GULF NUCLEAR STATION EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS UPDATE
Dear Mr. Eaton:
i This refers to the meeting conducted in the Region IV office on September 29,1998. This meeting was conducted to discuss the emergency preparedness program status and direction.
Specific topics covered included: implemented improvement items, planned improvement items, and future challenges, i
In accordance with Section 2.790 of the NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter will be placed in the NRC's Public Document Room.
Should you have any questions concerning this matter, we will be pleased to discuss them with you.
Sincerely, v4 Blaine Murray, Chief Plant Support Branch Division of Reactor Safety Docket No.:
50-416 License No.: NPF-29
Enclosures:
- 1. Attendance List
- 2. Licensee Presentation cc w/ enclosures:
Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer Entergy Operations, Inc.
P.O. Box 31995 Jackson, Mississippi 39286-1995 9810070007 981001 hDR ADOCK 05000416 PDR
l*-
j i
l 1
Entergy Operations, Inc. '
l l
Wise, Carter, Child & Caraway P.O. Box 651 -
i t.
' Jackson, Mississippi 39205 j
Winston & Strawn 1400 L Street, N.W. - 12th Floor Washington, D.C. 20005-3502 Sam Mabry, Director.
Division of Solid Waste Management Mississippi Department of Natural
. Resources y
P.O. Bev 10385 Jackson, M,ssissippi 39209 1
President Claibome County Board of Supervisors Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150 General Manager Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Entergy Operations, Inc.
P.O. Box 756 i
Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150 The Honorable Richard leyout)-
Attomey General Department of Justice.
~ State of Louisiana-P.O. Box 94005 Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70804-9005
. Office of the Govemor State of Mississippi Jackson, Mississippi 39201 Mike Moore, Attomey General Frank Spencer, Asst. Attomey General State of Mississippi
' P.O. Box 22947 Jackson, Mississippi 39225 Dr. F. E. Thompson, Jr.
l State Health Officer.
State Board of Health P.O. Box 1700
- Jackson, Mississippi 39205 i
i Entergy. Operations, Inc. -Robert W. Goff, Director State Liaison Officer l Division of Radiation Health.
Mississippi Departrnent of Health P.O. Box 1700 Jackson, Mississippi 39215-1700 Vice President Operations Support Entergy Operations, Inc.
P.O. Box 31995
~ Jackson, Mississippi 39286-1995 Director, Nuclear Safety and Regulatory Affairs Entergy Operations, Inc.
P.O. Box 756 i
Port Gibson, Mississ;ppi 39150 Vice President, Operations Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Entergy Operations, Inc.
P.O. Box 756
- Port Gibson, Mississippi 39150
4 Entergy Operations, Inc. DISTRIBUTION w/ coov of enclosures:
DCD (IE35)
Regional Administrator GG Resident inspector DRS Director DRS Deputy Director DRP Director DRS-PSB Branch Chief (DRP/A)
Project Engineer (DRP/A)
Branch Chief (DRP/TSS)
MIS System RIV File DOCUMENT NAME: R:\\_GG\\GGMSO929.GMG To receive copy of document, indicate in box: "c" = Copy without enclosures "E" = Copy with enclosures "N" = No copy RIV:PSB E
C:DRS\\PSB CP98S GMGood:nh (3 W BMurray V ATHoMill Cl h;O/98
\\9 /\\ /98
/
/98 \\
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
)
l:
t e,
- Entergy Operations, Inc. - DISTRIBUTION w/ coov of enclosures:
DCD (IE35) 1 Regional Administrator
- GG Resident inspector J
DRS Director j
DRS Deputy Director DRP Director DRS-PSB Branch Chief (DRP/A)
Project Engineer (DRP/A)
Branch Chief (DRP/TSS) 1 MIS System RIV File i
)
i I
i 4
t i
1 1
DOCUMENT NAME: R:\\_GG\\GGMSO929.GMG To receive copy of document, Indicate in box: 'C' = Copy without enclosures *E" = Copy with enclosures 'N' = No copy _
RIV:PSB E
C:DRS\\PSB DS8S GMGood:nh (nWer BMurray 0 ATHoMill 4 /SO/98
\\9 /\\ /98
/
/98\\
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY 0 0 0 "#'
l a
L w
ENCLOSURE 1 MEETING: GRAND GULF NUCLEAR STATION
SUBJECT:
Emergency Preparedness Activities and issues DATE: S_eptember 29.1998 ATTENDANCE LIST (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
NAME ORGANIZATION POSITION TITLE C,6 \\ K. (,ud M'RC Amen TT 9t.r h h nbek
~JL MnenA Gcds "
eau 63;d4e OkHwu~
MN %
H E L= ~ Pnn Ksaacd4 ffk Lcv G6ss b v, a s49;g i
Joseen 1. spfA Jt Rc_
r5rzm a cAep 0l>h3D6lllURYW h]00 SN b k A W
- C R H f> h kr.Sa((
Nd' ff/Z U M bikSx(v ~
,i
!~
l i
ENCLOSURE 2 I
I i
GRAXD GLLF NUCLEAR STATION EMERGENCY PREPAREDXESS i
PRESENTATION TO THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGION IV r
SEPTE MBER 29,1998 I
i i
i
.[
1 EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ISSUES IMPLE MENTED IMPROVE MENT ITE MS 1
- FRO M JUNE,1997 TO PRESENT PLAXNED IMPROVE MENT ITE MS i
- 4TH QUARTER,1998 Through 1999 FUTURE CHALLENGES i
l
[
i I
i I
4 IMPLEMENTED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS Weekly Training with Operations Crew
- Conducted in the Simulator i
- Includes Chemistry (Dose Assessment),
l Communicators and Emergency Preparedness
- Conducted During each Training Cycle EP Performance Indicators l
- All EOI Sites Use the Same Indicators
- Included as Part of Monthly Management Focus Meeting l
_-----------------------_---------_-------_j
M IMPLE MENTED IMPROVEMENT i
ITEMS Scenario Driven Table Top Drills
- Conducted in March for All Facilities l
i
- Plan to Implement on a Regular Basis in 1999
- Will Evaluate to Determine if Table Tops May Replace Some Classroom Training i
u IMPLE MENTED IMPROVE MENT ITE MS l
ERO Notification Drills i
- Increased Frequency (Monthly) l
- Unannounced and Some are Off Hours i
- Improved ERO Awareness i
- Improved Response Times 1
i
~
i IMPLE MENTED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS I
Personnel Rotation
- 1 Full Time Licensed SRO on EP Staff
- 1 Full Time. senior Health Physics Supervisor t
on EP Staff
- 1 Emergency Planner to SRO Certification Class
.i t
[
I
1 i
IMPLE MENTED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS 1
Exercise Weaknesses
- 82701 June,1997 l
Dose Assessment Activities Procedure Implementation
- 1997 Emergency Exercise Monitor and Replenish Supplies of Respiratory j
Protection Equipment Provide Protective Measures for Personnel in Security Island t
Properly Formulate PARS
PLANNED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS Enhanced ERO Training
- EP Day of the Week 2-3 Hours / Week in Each Facility j
Table Top Drills, Walk Through Discussion Groups, Site Mini Drills, Inter / Intra Facility Communication Drills i
Begin in October,1998 and Continue Until December. Then Check and Adjust.
l 1
l
- - r
I s
I PLANNED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS 1
Implement 4 Team Rotation 1
- Maintain 4 Strong Teams with Reserve (Fifth)
Team in Several Positions
- Enhance Overall Team Strength
- Effective October 12,1998 i
PLANNED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS f
Management Involvement in ERO Process
- Enhanced Facility Process Owner (FPO) f Involvement
- EP Staff Assigned to Specific Facility 1
- FPO Responsibilities j
Provide Guidance and Management for ERF 4
Assign Personnel to ERF r
Ensures Consistent ERF Operation L
Participates in ERF and Site Drill Critique i
Assigns Key ERO Position Leads
m PLANNED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS EP Self Assessment
- Intrusive Look Into EP Program, Corrective Action Process, Drill / Critique Process, and EP Training Effectiveness
- Team Includes Industry, EOI, and GGNS Personnel STP, Comanche Peak, PECO, RBS and W-3
- Conducted Week ofNovember 15,1998 Welcome NRC Involvement
~
i
i
?
F 4
PLANNED IMPROVEME3T ITEMS l
Severe Accident Management Procedures V & V Process Complete 1
- ERO Training To Be Conducted in October
- Operations Personnel Will Be Trained During j
November / December Training Cycle
- Demonstration During November Site Drill I
l
[
'I l
PLANNED IMPROVEMENT ITEMS Evaluation of EP Training Process
- Majority Currently Conducted in Classroom
- Will Evaluate Practical Activities During 4th Quarter EP Day of the Week
- Possible Replacement of Some Classroom Activities with Practical Training in ERFs.
j Initial Training; Classroom Oriented Continuing Training; ERF Practical 1
.l i
FLTURE CHALLENGES Emergency Response Organization Performance During Drills / Exercise
- Past Drills Lacked Effective Demonstration of Adequate Analysis of Simulated Emergency Conditions by Some Personnel
- Ineffective Communication Within and Among Emergency Response Facilities
~
2 I
i GGNS SEVERE ACCIDENT MANAGEMENT CONCEPT l
Two Step Approach
- When Adequate Core Cooling Not Assured Transfers Decision Making to ED
- Allows Control Room to Focus on Plant Operations
- Allows ERO to Coordinate Deliberate Actions that May Create Radiological Threats Containment Venting /RPV Venting l
Placing Restored Equipment in Operation i
i
GGNS EMERGENC3Y PREPAREDNESS b
Entergy n998 PERBO)RMANCE INDICAT(0)RS i
J
e
=== (3.Je r's)
Page i GGNS Portormance Monhoring
~.._7..__.,_,_.__
- _~.~
~ _. _.. - _ _. - - -
~
..~.._.7...
Eseorgemey 7 GoateJCreerte
'A*
7
.I.
~
v I.__...__
7
.. _._.,-_.i_
i-7 1
t J
i._
j Red 19981st Qtr.
I 1998 2nd Qar 1998 3rd Cir 1998 4th Or
- YTD,
- Values Geeen VWute Yeepe J
F M i A M ! J t
J ! A S
1 O +
N D
I t
4
}
r 8
"'*'Y' o2 u.".-a.'. %
-I
<95%-*92 5%
<92 5%*90%
<90%
! 95 2 % 94 8% 944% i 946%
94 8% l 950% 94 6% l 94 2% { 94 0%
{
l !
i
- WHITE l 2
$95%
i j
y.
,s y.
s
. 4
+
.4..
4 g
, 97 7% i 90 7% l 95 3% i _90 7% )
4
.. _ _ _ 7 -
j
_p.._
.,J _
}
93 0 % 930% i 930% ; 95 3 % 3 95 3% i j
}
1 g_
Noldcanon System
<94%>92%
I
<92%
[
j
$96%
<96%*94%
f 96 6% ! 99 3% l 99 5% j 100 0%, 100 0%. 99 5% { 99 5%
100%[
l i ; GREEN '1
Response
(
1 9
,N WI i, ___. -
A i.-
,_-.-__d..~-l_.~
[. _ _. 4 _.M -.. j - c.
I 96 6 %
r 100 0%,!.100 0% i 100 0% ( 100 0% ; 98 5%,! 100 0% l 100 0% i i
I l
q......,t...-
Regulamry Pw9weeme j
, g,
_ j 6.-
._4.
.... +.
.g-l j
-.a--
,e 4.-
l l
j
}--
s e
g Totalowardue QA e. or :
0 2
4
$4 0 { 0 - 0 ' NA ! O j 0 j 0 ! O i
- GREEN. 1 I
0 i
j FEMA assu'
__L
. - - - L_
_j.
. [..4.
i 4-t 1
I ERO PARTICIPATION t
i j
l
-..g.
4 4-
_ j __
__.7
..y __, p_.
? _...-. p.. p{
_.1 7
f
<98% *94%
- 95%>90%
<90%
f ND
% Attendance Dnus
- 98%
ND 100 %
ND ND 100 %
N3 100 %
ND I
?
GREEN 1
i I
{
I i
.1.._
l I'
1.,
.- p
_ _,..6545 ?
I 6555
- _ _ j
._4 9
. J_. _ yl _.
..p.
-+
Amendee Total 6545-4 i
1
-_..p.
.. j.
- j. _
._...-._7_
t i
i i
>98%
4
<98%=94%
>95%*90%
<90%
ND B3%
ND ND. ND 677%
ND 84 %
NO j
- RED i 4
% AttenaanceTabletops j a
L.
_-.~..q q - _... t -...,... _, 4445 l.
.A_
.-[_..._.
_. 4 _.
4... _ _4 -.
[
l 4&57 i
1 r._,l ADendeeTotal
-2._
.n r r
- m 4 -
..~
1 I
1 i
i j
l i
i
% AttendanceClassroom :
- 96%
<98%*94%
i
>954*9%
490 %
l ND l ND NO. ND ND 89%
93%
91 % l 50 %
I j j YELLOW 3
i i
f 1
i I
1 1
...,.._..4
. +.. _
'L u_..___.
_u
-..' 93/100.[. 31/34 i i
.p._
4_
_.t..
Attendee / Total i
(
, 81191
' 05
. _i..
4..-_
L.
+. _
~
l I'
i f.
+
i 1
L t
i i
1 0 f 5 2
I Lapsed ERO Quais 0
1 2
- 3 O
3 } 2 0 !
1 f2 RED 4
3 i
l i
l
(
i i
}
p_
_4
..i.
. j..
_p.
l 1
i 1
i i
_.i A
.. p 7
y.
L. -. q. -. __i
{,
i..L.
1 --
3...
.j 1
1 r
l I
t i
4
[
l
< super sars a up>
-*6 5-4
}
32 1
I ND 9
NO ' NO ND 4
i NO 8
, ND k WHITE 2
[
j 4
j l
+
. l - _.1 j
i y.
4 7
t I
I t'
t
- 2 O
O O
O O
1 l 0 1 0 '
0 i
3 CR Performance 0
1 l
2 6
GREEN 1
I s..,!
.l i
,i 4
l 3
a.
r e
i p
4 a
L Average Annunesator Value
! 2 11 l
1 i
Final Color WHITE 2
I I
l f'
i cntene i
vaiues values i
values values i
i i
g _
s - - _. 4
..--g.
~, -.
i.
s f
i L'.
,t s
s
+
t i
, i
[
1 2
3 4
l j
i f
i I
--..-y-.
..I TOTAL i
GREEN WHITE YELLOW RED l
l l
t
}
j l
q
. ___, 1 4
4 l
1
(
~,
i
+
9 4
i t
3 1
1 i
i I
1-1 1
i 4
j Green Criteria No Red Windows, No Yellow Windows and >=50% Green Windows i
(
White Criteria Annunciator Average <2.5 and <=1 Red Window Yellow Criteria Annunciator Average >=2.5 Red Criteria
>=25% Red Windows
e GGNS EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS SIREN AVAILABILITY 100.00 %
99.00 %
98.00k 97.00 %
96.00 %
95.00 %
94.00 %
93.00 %
N 92.00 %
91.00 %
90.00 %
OCT '97 NOV97 DEC 97 JAN 98 FEB 98 MAR 98 APR98 MAY 98 JUNE 98 JULY '98 AUG 98 SEPT 98
e O
Ei 8n am 8
O tsO Ch z
3 3
k A
wo,
>U '
zk MN e
2 5
w
.an e
e a
e l
e s
s s
s s
s s
s sss 8
s s
s s
s s
s a
a a
8s 9 e
/ n 8i 2a
/R 9
- dA ey tat r d e pv
$ e&
UeB
- yB
$ as
$ ew
$ E, SSE E N C
$ 8z P R E
Y P CN Y E R G O
$ 3o R TA E
L MU EG SE
$*K NR GG 0
$ e<
0
$ t, 0
$ 8a 0
$ts i
i 4
3 2
1 0
ti llllll l
l
GGNS EMERGENCY PREPARFl) NESS TABLETOP ATTENDANCE (12 month average) 100 %
f h
95%
i i
[
85% -
84 2 %
8.
1
?
80% -
l t
75%-
I i
i f
67.7 %
l
[
85 %
60 %
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY Jt)N JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC l
T i