ML20153C855
| ML20153C855 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Point Beach  |
| Issue date: | 09/22/1998 |
| From: | Baker E NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Sellman M WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER CO. |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9809240227 | |
| Download: ML20153C855 (9) | |
Text
,=.__
_-~ - -
September 22, 1998 Mr. Michael B. Sellman Chief Nuclear Officer Wisconsin Electric Power Company 231 West Michigan Stre Milwaukee,WI 53201
Dear Mr. Sellman:
This letter is in response to a request from Mr. Aldo Capristo of your staff for statistics on allegations received by the NRC concerning Point Beach. The attached tables provide a breakdown of the allegations concerning the site by source category, as well as comparison to allegations received at other operating sites for calendar years 1993,1994,1995,1996, 1997, and the first eight months of 1998.
If either you or Mr. Capristo have any questions conceming the data, you can reach me at (301)415-8529.
Sincerely, OfNMk Edward T. Baker, lil Agency Allegation Advisor Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attachments: As stated DISTRIBUTION:
File Center /Public EBaker CMohrwinkel FMiraglia EAdensam LGundrum MTschiltz, EDO D F.' ay
/
JGrant, Rll!
JHopkins, Rlli RDoombos, Rlli e,};:^-)e To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E= Copy with anachment/ enclosure N = No copy DOCUMENT NAME: p:\\ptbeach I
OFFICE NRR EBakerb DATE g/fygg
/ /Q8
/ /g8
/ /98
/ /98 OFFICIAL FILE COPY l
g h,p {'
9809240227 900922 PDR ADOCK 05000266 4
O ah $0hf
~
0 i
g 4
Mr. Michael B. Sellman Wisconsin Electric Power Company Ms. Sarah Jenkins cc:
Electric Division Public Service Commission of Wisconsin Mr. John H. O'Neill, Jr.
P.O. Box 7854 Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7854 2300 N Street, NW Washington, DC 20037-1128 Mr. Richard R. Grigg Aldo Capristo President and Chief Operating Officer Point Beach Nuclear Plant Wisconsin Electric Power Company Wisconsin Electric Power Company 231 West Michigan Street 6610 Nuclear Road Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53201 Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241
'Mr. Scott A. Patuiski Site Vice President Point Beach Nuclear Plant Wisconsin Electric Power Company 6610 Nuclear Road Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241 Mr. Ken Duveneck Town Chairman Town of Two Creeks 13017 State Highway 42 Mishicot, Wisconsin 54228 '
Chairman Public Service Commission of Wisconsin P.O. Box 7854 Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7854 Regional Administrator, Region lll U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 801 Warrenville Road Lisle, Illinois 60532-4351 Resident inspector's Office U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 6612 Nuclear Road Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241 f
Point Beach Nuclear Plant l-Units 1 and 2 i-August 1998 i-L
POINT BEACH ALLEGATIONS 1994 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE LICENSEE SPECIAL PRIVATE OTHER NEWS EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE IDENTIFIED INTEREST CITIZEN MEDIA GROUP RECEIVED 2
i H&l SUBSTANTIATED 1
1 OPEN 1995 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE LICENSEE SPECIAL PRIVATE OTHER NEWS EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE IDENTIFIED INTEREST CITIZEN MEDW GROUP RECEIVED 1
1 1
H&l 1
i SUBSTANTIATED 1
0 1
OPEN 1
1996 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE LICENSEE SPECIAL PRIVATE OTHER NEWS EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE IDENTIFIED INTEREST CITIZEN MEDIA
{
GROUP RECElVED 1
1 1
1 H&l 1
)
SUBSTANTMTED 0
1 1
0 OPEN 1997 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE LICENSEE SPECIAL PRIVATE OTHER NEWS EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE IDENTIFIED INTEREST CITIZEN MEDIA GROUP RECEIVED 1
1 5
1 1
1 H&l 1
1 SUBSTANTIATED 1
3 0
1 1
OPEN 1
1 1998 ANONYMOUS CONTRACTOR LICENSEE LICENSEE SPECIAL PRIVATE OTHER NEWS EMPLOYEE EMPLOYEE IDENTIFIED INTEREST CITIZEN MEDIA GROUP RECEIVED 4
1 j
H&f 1
1 SUBSTANTIATED 1
I OPEN 2
1 1
- =~
ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO LEAST CY98 - 8/31/98 9/22/98 a
She 1993h994h 995hS96l1997l1998 MILLSTONE 2 & 3 2 71 20 34:- 49 52! 26 ST LUCIE 4! 11i_ 16 22; 18 18 21i 46l 58 J DIABLO CANYON 12! 13 NINE MILE POINT 10' 7i III 12!
8 16 COOK 6! 10!
4i - 3:
6' 14 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 13! 22l 20 43! 20l 12 BYRON 3l 7i 4!
5! 11l 12 BROWNS FERRY 39i 1 51 13i 22l 19} 12 VERMONT YANKEE 3) 2}
5T 9l 4! 12 TURKEY POINT 13; 9: 12L 16l 19' 11 SAN ONOFRE 2 & 3 8! 16! 30l 31! 32i 10 INDIAN POINT 2 6;
11 6
6L 111 10 WOLF CREEK I
6: 12l 6,
13; 20; 10 BRUNSWICK 6 25i 11!
7i 8'
26 10 OUAD CITIES 5!
9 71 12 13i 9
DRESDEN 2 & 3 12 12l 12! 11 17 9
LASALLE 5
15!
7i 9
11 9
CLINTON 11 18l 8
19_
33 9
SUSOUEHANNA 8:
81 8 34: 24:
9 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR 8'
6! 14{ 18i 23[
9 SOUTH TEXAS 38 2 11 15i 23 Ill 8
COOPER I
3; 1 ( 11l 14h _18; 7
HARRIS i
2 4:
3 2
3 6
OCONEE f
II 4'
1l 8
2' 6
GRAND GULF i
3_
2 2,
9 4
6_
ARKANSAS i
4' 4'
7 2-7; 6
WATTS BAR
! 69 64, _. 50_
27 14; 6
COMANCHE PEAK 19 5
14' 18 13 6
SEQUOYAH i 31l 7{
19,__25 12:
5' FORT CALHOUN I
7, 4
4 4
10-5 HATCH 4;
8_
6 4; 17j 5
3 DIAN POINT 3 25: 14 11) 6 15:
5 N
POINT BEACH I
1' 3
3 4'
10 5
WATERFORD I
5' 3
16 21! 11 4
SEABROOK 4'
5 3
6 4
4 CRYSTAL RIVER i
5 3
6_
21i 20 4
RIVER BEND I 21i 12i 21! 17; 8'
4 CALVERT CLIFFS 6
7 8
7i 6-4 OAVIS-BESSE 10_
2 ill 5!
4 OYSTER CREEK 9
3 5
4' 10' 4
i CALLAWAY 5!
2i 5
78 4
3
.BRAIDWOOD 3
111 3
9 16;'
3 FITZPATRICK 8
3'
' 7:
5-5 3
PERRY 8
7i 2
10 9
3 PILGRIM i 19 9
8 5
2 3
PEACH BOTTOM 6'
8 3'
4!
5 3
PALO VERDE i 40 23 18' 22i 19 3
MCOUIRE i
8' 3'
E 3
3 LIMERICK l 16: 12j 4;
5{
9 2
BEAVER VALLEY 9_
7 73 5
7 2
1 VOGTLE 7; 11i Ill 6: 11 2
PALISADES 5!
6 8'
5 2-2' i
FAR. LEY 11 2!
3 6:
2; 2
CATAWBA 3
7, 21 5'
8 2
OUANE ARNOLD 2f 2'
3 l
3 2
THREE MILE ISLAND 4!
2; 1l Il 4:
1 l
P3AIRIE ISLAND di 2i 3
7l 5'
1 FERMI 9l 19' 8'
18' 8
1 MONTICELLO 2i 6
2 1
KEWAUNEE Il 1
Il_
1 I
GINNA 1!
1 1!
4l 1
SUMMER 2i 3
2i 9
2<
Page 1
-._ _ ___ _.~ - - - -
- _ _ _ _ _._._ _.. ~..,
1 ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO'LEAST CY98 8/31/98 9/33/98 l
- - e Site 11993l1994l1995l1999l199711998 l.
SURRY 5!
6:
3-4 3,
31 Il NORTH ANNA 1 21 2
8' i
l ROSINSON d-2!
3' il 2i t
1 1
l I
i i
l l
L.
i i
l c.
c s
l t
i
+
a Page 2 i,
s 7...,
-r,--.
a w
+ - - -
DISCRIMINATION ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED MOST TO LEAST CY98 8/31/98 9/22/98 i
4 Site l1993l1994l1996l1996l1997l1998 MJLL_ STONE 2 & 3 6
6_
to. 18 1 11 5
CLINTON I
2:
3l 6l 4
SUSOUEHANNA 2!
t 1
ti 2!
4 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3
5 7
10:
3' 3
l QUAD CITIES 1
2 3
2 DIABLO CANYON 1
2 1
5l 2
2 l
DUANE ARNOLD 1
1 i
2 SAN ONOFRE 2 & 3 4
4 3
6 6:
2 POINT BEACH 1
It 1
2i 2
HARRIS 1
i i
1 PALO VERDE 14 11 41 2-2:
1 1
OYSTER CREEK 1!
21 1
1 1
NINE MILE POINT 2'
1 4!
1 1
1 LASALLE 2:
1 4'
2:
1 INDIAN POINT 2 I
3!
1 i
1 GRAND GULF If i
1
{
1 COOPER 5!
t 2l 1
. COMANCHE PEAK 1r it 3
11 1
BRUNSWICK 6
li 1t 3'
5 1
BROWNS FERRY 4!
4 3
4' 4'
1 BEAVER VALLEY f
i 4!
li II 1
INDIAN POINT 3 3'
3 Si 1li 2!
1 VERMONT YANKEE I
i 2i i
1 MCGUIRE 4!
I i
1 ST LUCIE 2
3' 1
1!
1 TURKEY POINT 4'
i i
2:
1) 1 WASHINGTON NUCLEAR !
4 l
4' 21 4.
1 WATTS BAR l 18l 18 16 6
4 1
BYRON 1l 11 CALLAWAY 1!
11 li 1l 1;
.C_ALVERT CLIFFS li 3
3 VOOTLE.
4' 1!
FITZPATRICK i
2 ti i
li WATERFORD 2
I 5
7) 2 FERMI i
4' 3
3 4'
1!
. CRYSTAL RIVER i
2' 1~
4 3
I DAVIS-BESSE i
2l Il 1
1!
THREE MILE ISLAND j
l f
11 DRESDEN 2 & 3 -
t 3
li 2
2' BRAIDWOOD I
i 4
Il 2
4' COOK 3
1!
1 1!
2'
~UBINSON R
i 3
i i
PERRY j
2:
2:
It 3
3 PEACH BOTTOM i
1 2-1 1
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND ti PALISADES 1
1 1
1 RIVEN BEND 6
1 10' 6
1 OCONEE 1
It 1
SURRY 1
WOLF CREEK 1:
3 PILGRIM 2:
2 2'
2' ARKANSAS i
-l 1!
3l LIMERICK i
2 e
i 1
2 SEABROOK ii i
i l
SEQUOYAH 11 2
3 6:
2 L
SOUTH TEXAS 16' 7-Si 6'
3 l
HATCH 1
SUMMER j
1 FORT CALHOUN 2
21 1
1!
NORTH ANNA 1
If i
Il I
i i
Page 1 F
ALLEGATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YFAR RECEIVED 8/31/98 9/22/98 t
l Site l1993l1994l1995l1996l1997l1998 ARKANSAS 1
II 4'
2!
Si 1
l BEAVER VALL' /
1 3!
1 I
3; BRAIDWOOD 1
6!
2 3'
4!
2 BROWNS FE RY 14 8:
5 7i 4:
1 BRUNSWICK 10!
6 Si 5! 15l 1
l BYRON I
1 2;
3' 5;
2 i
CALLAWAY 3
3 3!
)
1 CALVERT CLIFFS 3
1 il 4I CATAWBA 11 -
3.
1 2!
3 l
CLINTON 4!
9' 5
8 15:
3 COMANCHE PEAK 71 3:
4:
5 6'
l COOK 2i 6'
2i 2'
6 COOPER 2!
Si 7!
7; 7
1 CRYSTAL RIVER 11 2i 4
12l 5l l
_ DAVIS BESSE 2:
4' 11 2!
I DIABLO CANYON II 81 8'
6; 8:
3 DRESDEN 7:
5' 6
5t 10:
1 l
DUANE ARNOLD 2:
1 li 2
- FARLEY I
l 1!
2l 2!
1 FERMI 5;
5'-
1!
8 2;
1 FIT 2 PATRICK 2;
3 i
i URT CALHOUN 1
2' 2'
2l 4:
2 GINNA l
il 2i li GRAND GULF _
1 2:'
3' 1!
1 HARRIS 1
1!
I II 2
HATCH 2:
3 2
2-10' 1
INDIAN POINT 2 2;
2:
3 4'
4 INDIAN POINT 3 10 4
2 1:
2' KEWAUNEE i
11 j
i 1,
i LASALLE t
2' 6'
5 2-4 1
LIMERICK 7j 4'
1!
4 2
1 M_CGUIRE It l'
li 1,
MILLSTONE 14' 4
5 13 7
1 MONTICELLO 2'
l i
1{
1 NINE MILE POINT Il 2!
3 1!
4 1
NORTH ANNA l
2:
i 2
2 1!
1 OCONEE i
2 2i Il 2
OYSTER CREEK i
2l 1!
3 I
2 PALISADES i_
li 2,
2 2
1:
PALO VERDE i
5:
9 8
9 8
PEACH BOTTOM i
li 2
11 2
l
_ PERRY I
2!
3 Il 3
1 PILGRIM 4
II ij II i
1 i
POINT BEACH 2:
2:
2 6
1 PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
11 i_
2; 2I 1
.OUAD CITIES 1:
5l 3;
4l 7j 1
RIVER BEND 111 6'
9' 4'
6' 1
ROBINSON 2!
1 i
1l 1}
SALEM / HOPE CREEK 3
11 7
12 >
5' 1
SAN ONOFRE 1
8 12 8
11!
$_EABROOK 1
Il Il 1!
SE_QUOYAH 7.
1!
8 11!
7 SOUTH TEXAS 16:
9 6
8 7'
1 ST LUCIE 1
2:
12' 26: 31 4
SUMMER 1
1 6
SURRY 4:
1 1
Il SUSOUEHANNA 3:
2 1
18' 11 1
THREE MILE ISLAND 11 11
)
i 2:
TURKEY POINT 7i 4
5' 5;
9 1
VER_MONT YANKEE 2
Il 2
1!
2:
3 VOGTLE 2!
4-3' Bi 3
1 WASHINGTON NHCLEAR -
4' 4'
7 6'
6 Page 1
.. - -.. - -. -..~. ~. -...,.... -. -..~,.
ALLEGATIONS SUBSTANTIATED IN YEAR RECEIVED 8/31/98 -
9/22/98 e
Site I1993l19Ml1995l19Ml199711gg WATERFORD 3
2-III 7,
2 1
WATTS SAR
- 33l 29! 16 11j 4=
1 WOLF CREEK 5!
7i ti 6'
9' 2,
i 1
f 1
Page 2
p OPEN ALLEOATIONS. MOST TO LEAST 8/31/98 9/22/98 l-Site l1996l1994l1997119981 Total MILLSTONE 2 & 3 11 2:
4 10, 17 DIABLO CANYON 11 1!
! 12 14 WATTS BAR 21 4'
3l 5!
14 1
, BRUNSWICK li 5;
6' 12 ST LUCIE t
1 1 11 12 SALEM / HOPE CREEK 1
2; 1
6; 10 COOK 11 2r 6:
9
, SAN ONOFRE 2 & 3 2!
l 7!
9 BROWNS FERRY 11 2'
5!
8 TURKEY POINT 1
71 8
DRESDEN 2 & 3 1
1 6'
8 PERRY -
2i 3-1 6
NINE MILE POINT 1
1 5
6
,CLINTON 2}
4!
6 SEQUOYAH 1
1l 4!
6 HATCH 1
41 5
COOPER 1
4' 5
GRAND GULF 5!
5 POINT BEACH 2-3 5
QUAD CITIES 1
1' 3
5 SOUTH TEXAS 1
4 5
BYRON Si 5
SUSQUEHANNA-5 5
WASHINGTON NUCLEAR li 4-5 INDIAN POINT 3 1
1!
2-4
, DAVIS-BESSE 1
3 4
SEABROOK i
1; 3
4 WOLF CREEK I
4' 4
CALVERT CLIFFS 3
3 CRYSTAL RIVER 3_
i 3
HARRIS 3
3 COMANCHE PEAK i
j 3
3 PILGRIM i
i 2;
11 3
}
3 3
LASALLE l
3 3
VERMON1 ANKEE 3
3 INDIAN POINT 2 1
2:
3 OC_ONEE 3;
3 OYSTER CREEK 1
1 1
3 VOGTLE 1
1 2
CATAWBA 1
1 2
PEACH BOTTOM 2:
2 PALO VERDE 2
2 PAllSADES i
1; il 2
MCOUIRE I
2, 2
DUANE ARNOLD 1
1l 2
~UMERICK li 1
FARLEY I
1 1
RIVER BEND 1
1 CALLAWAY 1
1 SUMMER 1
1 FITZPATRICK 1
1 FORT CALHOUN 1
1 BRAIDWOOD 1
1 BEAVER VALLEY 11 1
PRAIRIE ISLAND 1
I 1
u
[x Pa9e1