IE Info Notice 82-02, Westinghouse Nbfd Relay Failures in Reactor Protection Sys at Certain Nuclear Power PlantsML20151H027 |
Person / Time |
---|
Issue date: |
01/27/1982 |
---|
From: |
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
---|
To: |
|
---|
References |
---|
IEIN-82-02, IEIN-82-2, NUDOCS 8107230046 |
Download: ML20151H027 (4) |
|
|
---|
Category:GENERIC LETTERS & IE LETTERS TO MULTIPLE PLANTS.
MONTHYEARML20151H0271982-01-27027 January 1982 IE Info Notice 82-02, Westinghouse Nbfd Relay Failures in Reactor Protection Sys at Certain Nuclear Power Plants ML20151H0201982-01-22022 January 1982 IE Info Notice 82-01, Auxiliary Feedwater (AFW) Pump Lockout Resulting from Westinghouse W-2 Switch Circuit Mod ML20151H0231981-12-23023 December 1981 IE Info Notice 81-39, EPA Cross Check Program - Low Level Radioiodine in Water Intercomparison Study ML20151H0191981-12-15015 December 1981 IE Info Notice 81-37, Unnecessary Radiation Exposure to Public & Workers During Events Involving Thickness & Level Measuring Devices ML20151H0151981-12-0303 December 1981 IE Info Notice 81-36, Replacement Diaphragms for Robertshaw Valve(Model No. VC-210) ML20151H0131981-11-16016 November 1981 IE Info Notice 81-34, Accidental Accuation of Prompt Public Notification Sys ML20151H0111981-11-0909 November 1981 IE Info Notice 81-33, Locking Devices Inadequately Installed on Msivs. W/O List of Recently Issued Info ML20151H0081981-09-28028 September 1981 IE Info Notice 81-30, Velan Swing Check Valves ML20151D7471981-09-0303 September 1981 IE Info Notice 81-28, Failure of Rockwell-Edward Msivs ML20151A6701980-12-18018 December 1980 IE Bulletin 80-17 Suppl 4, Failure of Control Rods to Insert During Scram at Bwr ML20150F8381980-11-26026 November 1980 IE Info Notice 80-29,Suppl 1, Broken Studs on Terry Turbine Steam Inlet Flange ML20125E3171980-01-0707 January 1980 Table C-1 to Be Included W/App C,Encl 4 of IE Bulletin 79-01B, Environ Qualification of Class IE Equipment 1982-01-27
[Table view]Some use of "" in your query was not closed by a matching "". Category:NRC INFORMATION NOTICE
MONTHYEARML20151H0271982-01-27027 January 1982 IE Info Notice 82-02, Westinghouse Nbfd Relay Failures in Reactor Protection Sys at Certain Nuclear Power Plants ML20151H0201982-01-22022 January 1982 IE Info Notice 82-01, Auxiliary Feedwater (AFW) Pump Lockout Resulting from Westinghouse W-2 Switch Circuit Mod ML20151H0231981-12-23023 December 1981 IE Info Notice 81-39, EPA Cross Check Program - Low Level Radioiodine in Water Intercomparison Study ML20151H0191981-12-15015 December 1981 IE Info Notice 81-37, Unnecessary Radiation Exposure to Public & Workers During Events Involving Thickness & Level Measuring Devices ML20151H0151981-12-0303 December 1981 IE Info Notice 81-36, Replacement Diaphragms for Robertshaw Valve(Model No. VC-210) ML20151H0131981-11-16016 November 1981 IE Info Notice 81-34, Accidental Accuation of Prompt Public Notification Sys ML20151H0111981-11-0909 November 1981 IE Info Notice 81-33, Locking Devices Inadequately Installed on Msivs. W/O List of Recently Issued Info ML20151H0081981-09-28028 September 1981 IE Info Notice 81-30, Velan Swing Check Valves ML20151D7471981-09-0303 September 1981 IE Info Notice 81-28, Failure of Rockwell-Edward Msivs ML20150F8381980-11-26026 November 1980 IE Info Notice 80-29,Suppl 1, Broken Studs on Terry Turbine Steam Inlet Flange 1982-01-27
[Table view]Some use of "" in your query was not closed by a matching "". Category:TEXT-INSPECTION & AUDIT & I&E CIRCULARS
MONTHYEARML20215G9881987-04-10010 April 1987 Notice of Nonconformance from Insp on 870223-27 & 0324 ML20206D8851987-04-0808 April 1987 Notice of Nonconformance from Insp on 870309-11 IR 05000354/19870101987-04-0707 April 1987 Insp Rept 50-354/87-10 on 870316-20.No Violations Noted. Major Areas inspected:post-accident Monitoring Sys Conformance W/Rev 2 to Reg Guide 1.97.Open Item Identified Re Identification of Category 2 Equipment ML20206M7981987-04-0707 April 1987 Insp Rept 50-312/86-41 on 861201-870212.Unresolved & Open Items Identified.Major Areas Inspected:Activities Supporting Restart & Ensuring Safe Operation of Plant After Restart, Including Stated Phases of Sys Review & Test Program ML20206D8361987-04-0707 April 1987 Insp Rept 99900271/87-01 on 870127-29.No Violations, Nonconformances or Unresolved Items Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Corrective Action Re Intermittent Failures & Review of Test Results on Three Failed Transmitters ML20215G9961987-04-0606 April 1987 Insp Rept 99900383/87-01 on 870223-27.Nonconformance Noted: Pressure Gauge Not Calibr for Over 0-30 Psig Range & 30 Psig Pressure Test of O-ring Seals Failed Pressure Drop Requirement ML20206F9681987-04-0303 April 1987 EN-87-029:on 870408,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $50,000 Will Be Issued.Action Based on Loss of Approx 141,000 Gallons of Water from Spent Fuel Pools Through Fuel Transfer Canal IR 05000327/19870051987-04-0303 April 1987 Insp Repts 50-327/87-05 & 50-328/87-05 on 870119-23.No Violations or Deviations Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Review & Evaluation of 13 Employee Concern Task Group Final Sequoyah Element Repts IR 05000327/19870061987-04-0303 April 1987 Design Calculation Review Insp Repts 50-327/87-06 & 50-328/87-06 on 870202-13.No Violations Noted.Major Areas Reviewed:Adequacy of Util Design Calculation Review Program & Extent Program Augments Design Baseline Re Restart ML20206E8121987-04-0101 April 1987 Insp Repts 50-445/86-26 & 50-446/86-22 on 860901-1031. Violations & Deviations Noted:Cable Pulling Ropes Left in Unit 1 Conduits & Cable Trays & Failure of Inspector to Write Memo Documenting Nonconforming Condition ML20206D9141987-04-0101 April 1987 Insp Rept 99901085/87-01 on 870309-11.Nonconformances Noted: Failure to Administer Exam by Level III Examiner or Designated Representative & 1986 Eye Exams for Listed Level II Examiners Missing IR 05000445/19860261987-04-0101 April 1987 Insp Repts 50-445/86-26 & 50-446/86-22 on 860901-1031. Violations & Deviations Noted:Cable Pulling Ropes Left in Unit 1 Conduits & Cable Trays & Failure of Inspector to Write Memo Documenting Nonconforming Condition IR 05000327/19860681987-03-31031 March 1987 Insp Repts 50-327/86-68 & 50-328/86-68 on 861201-12 & 870112-23.Violations Noted:Licensee Failed to Assure That Applicable ASME Code Requirements Included in Procurement of Specific safety-related Code Class Equipment ML20215E4831987-03-31031 March 1987 EN-87-026:on 870331,order Suspending Power Operation & Order to Show Cause Issued to Util Due to Discovery That Control Room Staff Have Been Sleeping During Various Shifts.Related Documents Encl ML20206D1901987-03-31031 March 1987 Insp Rept 99901088/87-01 on 870121.Major Areas Inspected: Corrective Action Taken Re 860917 Part 21 Rept Concerning Potential Problem in Pressure Transducers ML20205R4601987-03-30030 March 1987 Insp Rept 99900762/87-01 on 870203-04.No Noncompliances or Violations Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Allegations Re Use of Uncertified Welders & Possible Falsification of Welding Records.Two of Nine Allegations Substantiated IR 05000267/19870041987-03-27027 March 1987 Insp Rept 50-267/87-04 on 870126-30.No Violations Noted. Major Areas Inspected:Program to Maintain Qualification of Electrical Equipment Per 10CFR50.49.Potential Enforcement/ Unresolved Items & Open Items of Program Listed IR 05000277/19870061987-03-23023 March 1987 Fitness for Duty Program Insp Repts 50-277/87-06 & 50-278/87-06 on 870202-06.Observations Noted:Util Written Policies Do Not Address Features of Commission Policy Statement or EEI Guide & No Overall Audit Performed ML20205H3661987-03-23023 March 1987 EN-87-023:on 870326,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalties in Amount of $50,000 Will Be Issued to Licensee.Action Based on Failure to Obtain Prior NRC Approval of Criteria Change for Reactor Coolant Flow ML20205H2411987-03-23023 March 1987 EN-87-022:on 870326,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $12,500 Will Be Issued to Licensee.Action Based on Numerous Violations of NRC Requirements Re Overexposure to Workers ML20207S2811987-03-17017 March 1987 Notice of Violation from Insp on 870126-30 ML20207S2921987-03-17017 March 1987 Notice of Nonconformance from Insp on 870126-30 IR 05000275/19860331987-03-17017 March 1987 Insp Repts 50-275/86-33 & 50-323/86-31 on 861215-19. Deficiencies Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Implementation Program for Establishing & Maintaining Environ Qualification of Electrical Equipment Important to Safety ML20205D2131987-03-16016 March 1987 Insp Repts 50-445/86-22 & 50-446/86-20 on 860701-0831. Violations & Deviations Noted:Stainless Steel & Carbon Steel Stored in Outside Areas W/Improper Protective End Coverings & Records of Heat Treatment Not Available for Disc Inserts ML20207R5751987-03-13013 March 1987 EN-86-074A:on 870313,order Issued Imposing Civil Penalties in Amount of $3,000 to Univ of Utah,Based on Transportation, Health Physics,Safeguards & Operations Violations Noted in 860930 Enforcement Notification EN-86-074 ML20207R3341987-03-11011 March 1987 EN-87-019:on 870311,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalties in Amount of $50,000 Will Be Issued for Licenses.Action Based on Three Examples of Degraded Vital Area Barriers ML20207R3701987-03-0909 March 1987 EN-87-015:on 870312,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalties in Amount of $50,000 Will Be Issued for License.Action Based on Violation of Tech Spec Re ECCS Subsystems ML20207R4851987-03-0909 March 1987 EN-87-017:on 870312,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $25,000 Will Be Issued to Util Based on Failure to Provide Adequate Design Control to Ensure Emergency Feedwater Pump Operability ML20207S3331987-03-0606 March 1987 Insp Rept 99901079/87-01 on 870126-30.Violation Noted:Two Nuclear Purchase Orders Accepted & Fulfilled W/O 10CFR21 Program in Effect.Nonconformance Noted:Master Ammeter Had No Sticker to Identify Calibr Status ML20207R0301987-03-0303 March 1987 EN-87-014:on 870306,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $50,000 Issued to Licensee.Action Based on Failure to Establish & Maintain Operability of Nuclear Svc Water Sys IR 05000327/19860701987-03-0303 March 1987 Insp Repts 50-327/86-70 & 50-328/86-70 on 861208-12.No Programmatic Deficiencies W/Regard to Facility Maint of Environmentally Qualified Equipment Identified.Major Areas Inspected:Maint Program & Previous Insp Items ML20212F0181987-03-0202 March 1987 Notice of Violation from Insp on 870112-14 ML20212F0331987-02-27027 February 1987 Insp Rept 99901080/87-01 on 870112-14.Violation Noted: Failure to Adopt Procedure to Evaluate or Rept Defects Discovered in Motors Supplied to Customers Under Part 21 ML20212H0491987-02-26026 February 1987 EN-87-012:on 870303,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $75,000 Will Be Issued Based on Violations in Areas of Facility Design,Maint & Mods ML20212B1991987-02-26026 February 1987 EN-86-029A:on 870226,order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty in Amount of $50,000 Issued to Licensee Based on Licensee 860703 Response to 860501 Notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty.Section I Violation Did Occur IR 05000498/19860421987-02-20020 February 1987 Engineering Assurance Program Insp Repts 50-498/86-42 & 50-499/86-42 on 861215-19.Major Areas Inspected:Task 84-4, Separation & Fire Protection Criteria & Task 85-4, High Energy Line Break Analysis ML20211P4311987-02-19019 February 1987 EN-87-010:on 870224,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $25,000 Will Be Issued to Util Based on Multiple Violations Re Safeguards Info Protection Program ML20212E7581987-02-18018 February 1987 Insp Rept 99900507/86-01 on 861201-05.No Violations or Noncompliance Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Status of Previous Findings,Dedication of Commercial Grade Items Overview & 10CFR21 Evaluation & Reporting Review ML20211B8481987-02-13013 February 1987 Notice of Nonconformance from Insp on 870112-14 ML20211B9021987-02-13013 February 1987 Insp Rept 99900816/87-01 on 870112-14.Violation Noted:Mfg Did Not Specify Application of Part 21 Requirements on Listed Purchase Orders.Nonconformances Noted:Quality Sys Program Not Invoked on Listed Orders & Order Data Differed ML20211B8161987-02-13013 February 1987 Notice of Violation from Insp on 870112-14 ML20211B5511987-02-12012 February 1987 EN-85-084A:on 851213,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalties in Amount of $900,000 Will Be Issued to Licensee.Action Based on 850609 Failure of Auxiliary Feedwater Sys to Perform Intended Function ML20210U0531987-02-10010 February 1987 Insp Rept 99901067/86-01 on 861103-07.Nonconformance Noted: NDE Technician Certified W/O Attaining Passing Grade on Magnetic Particle Exam,Per Procedure QC-2.Data Sheets Encl IR 05000321/19860351987-02-0707 February 1987 Equipment Qualification Insp Repts 50-321/86-35 & 50-366/86-35 on 861103-07.Major Areas Inspected:Program for Establishing & Maintaining Qualification of Electric Equipment Per 10CFR50.49.Five Deficiencies Noted ML20210E9201987-02-0606 February 1987 Notice of Nonconformance from Insp on 861020-24 ML20210E9371987-02-0606 February 1987 Insp Rept 99900015/86-01 on 861020-29.Noncomformance Noted: Mechanical & Chemical Testing Svc Performed by Outside Lab W/O Advising Lab of 10CFR21 Requirements & Incorrect Audits of Vendors IR 05000508/19860121987-02-0606 February 1987 Insp Rept 50-508/86-12 on 860915-1215.No Violations Noted. Major Areas Inspected:Readiness Review Program Module C3-01, Earthwork & Followup on Insp Repts 50-508/86-10 & 50-508/86-11 ML20210A9591987-02-0505 February 1987 Notice of Nonconformance from Insp on 861202-05 ML20210B0011987-02-0404 February 1987 Insp Rept 99900835/86-01 on 861203-05.Nonconformances Noted:Controls Necessary to Ensure Charging Motors Purchased from Subvendors Conform to Drawings Not Established ML20210P9041987-02-0303 February 1987 EN-87-005:on 870209,notice of Violation & Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty in Amount of $50,000 Will Be Issued to Util Based on Ofc of Investigations Investigation Re Employment Termination of Technician 1987-04-08
[Table view]Some use of "" in your query was not closed by a matching "". |
Text
'~
' g
~*
. ,*. x SSINS: 6835 Accession No.:
t 8107230046 IN 82-02 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 0FFICE OF INSPECTION AND ENFORCEMENT WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555 January 27, 1982 IE INFORMATION NOTICE NO. 82-02: WESTINGHOUSENBFDRELAYFAILbRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS AT CERTAIN NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS Discussion:
Westinghouse has notified the NRC of a higher-than-expected failure rate of Westinghouse type NBFD relay coils in reactor protection systems at certain power reactor plants. Investigation into the cause for failure revealed that, at high ambient temperature conditions, relay coils could fail due to the inductive voltage spike generated by the deerergization of the relay coil.
It was also determined that the relay coil failures have been confined to nonnally energized relays used in the reactor protection systems where high ambient temperature conditions exist due to heat generated by the normally energized relays.
To date, no failures of NBFD relay coils have been reported in safeguard cabinets where these relays are normally in a deenergized state and temperature conditions are normal.
After reviewing the NBFD relay problem, Westinghouse issued technical bulletin NSD-TB-81-14 on December 7, 1981 to Westinghouse-designed power plants using BFD or NBFD relays in the reactor protection and saieguard systems. An extract of this bulletin is attached for your information and appropriate use. The bulletin provides interim test methods for verifying the operability of normally deenergized and energized NBFD relay applications and reconinends i replacement of NBFD relays manufactured prior to January 1,1981. The bulletin 1 also provides relay coil numbers as well as data codes to facilitate affected licensees' replacement efforts if required.
q
'This information notice is provided as an early notification of a potentially significant matter. It is expected that recipients will review the information for applicability to their f acilities. No specific action or response is required at this time. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please
, contact the Regional Administrator of the appropriate ;;RC Regional Office.
Attachments:
- 1. Extract of Westinghouse technical bulletin NSD-TB-81-14, dated 12/7/81
- 2. Recently issued IE Information Notices f/0 7.2.360 d J h* ' .
Attachment 1 IN 82-02 January 27, 1982 l Page 1 of 3 l l
EXTRACT OF WESTINGHOUSE TECHNICAL BULLETIN NSD-TB-81-14 Subject Number
, BFD (NBFD) RELAYS NSD-TB-81-14 System (s) Date REACTOR PROTECTION AND SAFEGUARDS SYSTEMS December 7,1981 Affected Plants 5.0.(s)
All those utilizing BFD or NBFD relays in the above systems. 385 References Sheet Of NSD-TB-79-5, 76-16, & 76-2. NRC IE BULLETIN 79-25 1 3 BACKGROUND This bulletin pertains to the modified Westinghouse BFD relays designated as NBFD with the style number 5072A49 (followed by the letter G and a two-digit number, depending on pole configuration) and with coil style number 1271C50G01.
The NBFD relay was first made available in December 1976. The purpose of this bulletin is to describe a Potential Substantial Safety Hazard attributable to the Westinghouse NBFD relay in certain applications.
Westinghouse has been notified of NBFD relay coil failures which have occurred in the reactor protection cabinets at certain sites. As a result, Westinghouse initiated an investigation to determine the failure mechanism involved. It was concluded that at high ambient temperature, relay coils could burn open due to an inductively induced voltage spike generated upon de-energization of the relay.
NBFD relay coil failures have been confined to the normally energized relays in the reactor protection rack where high ambient temperature conditions exist due to heat generated by the normally energized relays.
NBFD relays located in the safeguards cabinets are normally de-energized, and are energized to provide safeguards actuation. To date, no failures of NBFD relay coils have been reported in the safeguards cabinet. NBFD relays located in the safeguards cabinets are not subject to high temperature conditions due to the normally de-energized state. Also cyclic tests performed quarterly at the relay vendor show no abnormal coil failure.
Since an undetected open coil condition in the safeguards actuation circuitry (however remote) would prevent actuation of functions important to safety, it was reported by Westinghouse as a potential safety hazard for those plants which utilize these relays in the safeguards cabinet.
.g
-n P ,,, +
x Attachmen .
. IN 82-02 January 27, 1982 Page 2 of 3 EXTRACT OF WESTINGHOUSE TECHNICAL BULLETIN NSD-TB-81-14 (continued)
INTERIM RECOMMENDATIONS Westinghouse recommends the following interim measures for normally de-energized and nonnall'y energized N8FD relays.
(A) NORMALLY DE-ENERGIZED APPLICATIONS In normally de-energized applications, test for continuity of the relay
' coil and amend applicable test procedures to require a continuity test following every energized /de-energize cycle of the relay, including cycles required by periodic test procedures.
Westinghouse plants with provisions for-on-line test capability can utilize these ]rovisions to verify continuity of the NBFD relay coils. Those plants which do not] have on-line test capability should make use of portable test equipment to verify the continuity for each N8FD relay coil.
(a) Plants with on-line test capability:
Utilize established test procedures nonnally used during periodic on-line testing. These procedures which utilize the white test lamps provide indication of coil continuity.
(b) Plants without on-line test capability:
Utilize a volt-ohm meter to check resistance across the NBFD relay coil leads. If relays are connected in parallel, use the parallel resistance law to determine if any coil is open. If any parallel combination gives indication of an open coil, each individual coil must be checked to determine the failed coil.
(B) NORMALLY ENERGlZED APPLICATIONS Although open relay coils in normally energized applications result in the system (i.e. reactor trip) falling into a safe state tending to trip the reactor, Westinghouse reconnends the following: When the relay is energized (after a previous de-energization), visually verify that the armature has moved to the pulled-in position by observing the pushbuttons atop the contact assembly. The relay is energized if the pushbuttons protrude from the assembly by no more than 1/8 inch.**
- NOTE: Manual depression of pushbuttons should result in no inward mo,emer..
of the armature of an energized relay and may be used if desired in lieu M ,
visual verification.
- * * * *$**** a ---e +e me- eme e w w m w, ,. p ,, %. . , _ , , . .,, .
n
,\
- s. '
'6' .' Attachment 1 IN 82-02 January 27, 1982
' Page 3 of 3 EXTRACT OF WESTINGHOUSE TECHNICAL BULLETIN NSD-TB-81-14 (continued)
LONG TERM RECOMMENDATIONS Relays manufactured after January 1,1981 incorporate additiona'l (mylar) insulating material which has been confirmed by tests to resolve coil burnout by high voltage spikes generated when the relay coil current is interrupted.
It is recommended that the utility consider installing this improved coil during the next scheduled outage.
Relay coils with improved insulating material manufactured after January 1981 bear the style number 1271C50G01 and a date code, visible on the unmounted coil.
Those enils manufactured after October 28, 1981 bear the style number 1293C51G01 such that code date verification is unnecessary.
Contact your Westinghouse Nuclear Service Division representative...for additional information pertaining to replacement cofis.
To preclude excessive heating of the NBFD relay coil and degradation of coil in-sulation, Westinghouse reaffirms its recommendations for review of station battery charging procedures, such that the NBFD relay coils should not be l
subject to battery equalization voltages in excess of the coil rating. Caution should be exercised to ensure that charging voltage be limited to 140 VDC and that charging at 140 VDC be limited to 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> duration if the previous r chargingperiod[ occurred]...lessthan30 days [previously].
APPLICABILITY The information in this bulletin does not apply to Westinghouse plants using a l Solid State Protection System.
j L
a e enW'* *
- e 4 g 4 6 e tew FPe -N4 m e r-- - , , ,